ON THE COSMIC
RELATIONS
by Henry Holt
VOL. I
PBEPACE
Of course no one conld sanely undertake an exhaustive
treatmant of the subject indicated by the title of this book.
What I have attempted is an outline of the evolution of the
relations between the soul and the external universe and
a summary of the recognized relations that are still so immaturely evolved as to be little understood.
With the latest philosophy, I have assumed a germ of
consciousness in each particle of the star dust, recognizing
the consciousness when it becomes obvious in the recoil of
protoplasm from contact, and following the evolution up
through primitive life into the soul as we know it to-day.
I have made this sketch with a special view to showing that
the existence of an unknown universe is a corollary of the
evolution of knowledge. This has often been expressed in
a sentence, but not often systematically expounded and illustrated.
After this hasty sketch of the a priori indications of an
unknown universe, I have gone at once into the a posteriori
indications, giving an account of the mysterious relations
that have been carefully studied only for a generation, between
the human forces now termed telekinetic and the better
known modes of force; and also of the psychical relations
termed telepathic, following them up to those which some
consider spiritic.
That these phenomena are of great interest, and the study
of them of the very first importance, has been the belief of
some of the first minds of our time, including minds so
diverse as those of Mr. Gladstone and Professor James.
These things upon the borders of our Cosmic Relations
have been most notably studied by the Society for Psychical
Itesearch, and earliest perhaps among the motives for undertaking this book, was the desire to present, so far as I could
in the limits, and in such organic shape as I could, the most
important of the accounts of phenomena and comments upon
them scattered through the forty odd volumes so far published by that Society. My compilation has naturally accreted with itself considerable material from kindred sources,
including some from the observations of my friends and
myself; and I have ventured to accompany it with many
guesses and comments of my own as to causes and implications of the phenomena. Where all is so vague, there can be
no immodesly in any earnest student hazarding his guesses.
The only immodesty conspicuous in the connection is that
frequently shown by those who pooh-pooh the facts without
knowing anything about them.
Many of the facts presented are very nebulous, and the
guesses are naturally more nebulous still. This has led to
a great deal of deliberate repetition, of views from various
angles, — so much that I fear it will tax the patience of the
readers whose approval I most desire. I trust, however, that
they will bear with the repetitions better from knowing that,
although there is probably a full share of those which
resxdt from imperfection in the author's grasp, there are
many other which are of set purpose.
I beg farther indulgence for some inconsistencies. For
instance, in dealing with the most tremendous subjects that
tempt our intellects, at one moment one is conscious of their
immensity, and uses the habitual symbols for the feeling,
and at the next moment, in a different connection, the word
that he has just capitalized arises in some matter-of-fact
connection without any emotional content, and slips off the
pencil as free from emphasis as any other word. I let them
stay as they fell, and hope that their inconsistencies will not
bother the reader as much as they have bothered the proof
readers. Those good (and sometimes very bad) people have
also been greatly bothered by the extracts of heteromatic
writing : for I left them to be printed just as I found them,
and they are often superior to the rules of rhyme and reason,
let alone rhetoric and proof reading. Moreover, there are
folks who don't like being bound by rule : if there never had
been such, this book would not have been possible— or perhaps
any other.
In addition to the sins for which I have already sought
absolution, I have contradicted myself with a freedom perhaps not quite Emersonian, but also, alas! not quite with
Emersonian excuse; and perhaps the worst thing I have done,
but a thing which I suspect has been done by more than
one other author, even by as great a one as I have jnst
named, is letting stand two or three sentences written in
good faith, whose meaning is so elusive that, by the time of
revision, it has escaped even the author. It may come back,
though, when sought under different circumstances, even by
a different person.
To crown all the paradoxical treatment of a paradoxical
Bubject, there is matter on pages 373-4 and 395-6 that perhaps
ought to be in the preface, but it could not be understood
without a knowledge of much that precedes it.
I have not made so much apology without a vivid consciousness that qui s'excuse s'accuse. But is there not sufficient sanction in antique usage, for a preface being '' The
Author,s Apology''? And surely in these days of unrelenting book production, he has more need of apology than
ever before. I do not envy the man, or have much
hope for the work of the man, who can write on these vague
subjects without painfully mistrusting himself. But there
is at least one good reason for any aspirant setting out with
a good heart — though he may receive, and deserve, no attention, or even contemptuous attention, he is at least essaying
needed work: for our age takes too little interest in these
subjects, even if some ages have taken too much.
My obligations to many friends are great — to Mr. Dorr,
Professor Kellogg, and Professor Newbold they are beyond
expression. That two of them have sometimes talked all
night with me is but a faint indication. Professor Kellogg
has read some of the proof, and Professor Newbold the whole
of it So has Mr. Bartlett, the biographer of Foster. So
also have several other friends, some of them at almost as
great sacrifice of peace of mind as the proof readers.
I have also to express my thanks to the Society for Psychical Besearch for permitting the publication of some of the
matter in Professor Newbold's himds which is under their
control. It is given in Chapter XXXVI, and also in the
Baker case on page 859f .
Some paasagea have been printed in The Unpopular Review. As it is usual to acknowledge sach facts, partly perhaps to warn off readers, so alight a circumstance as my
being the editor ought not to prevent the acknowledgment
here.
H. H.
FjOBHOLT, Burlington, Vt.
September 26, 1914.
CONTENTS
BOOK I
COREELATED
KNOWLEDGE
I. Introduction
n. Skbtoh op Hukan Evolution— Body .
ni. Sebtoh op Human Evolution — Soul .
lY. Evolution op the Univebsb .
v. Thb Known Univebsb AND THB Unknown
YI. SoMB Ethical Aspects op Evolution .
Tkom
1
13
29
50
55
67
BOOK II
uncobbelated knowledge
YIL Intboduction
81
Pabt I
Telekinesis
Vni. MoLAB Telekinesis
91
IX.
X.
XI.
XII.
123
14S
167
181
MoLAB Telekinesis (Continued) — ,Dowsing
MoLECULAB Telekinesis
MoLAB Telepsychio Telekinesis .
.
.
MOLECULAB TbLEPSYCHIC TELEKINESIS .
.
Pabt II
Xm.
AUTOKINESIS
197
Part III
XIV. Psychokinesis
216
CofUents
Part IV
TELEP8Y0H08I8
XV. '.Introduction
XVI. Telepathy between Foster and the Author
XVII. Early Telepathic Sensitives .
.
.
XVIII.
Becent Telepathic Sensitives
.
.
XIX. Suggested Correlations of Telepathy .
XX. The Cosmic Soul
XXI. The Cosmic Soul and the Individual
Soul
XXII. Mind and Brain Again
....
XXIII. The Idea
XXIV. Possession in General
....
XXV. Possession in Heteromatic Writing
.
XXVI. Dramatic Possession.
Early Cases
.
XXVII. Preliminary Regarding the S. P. E.
Sittings
218
XXVIII.
XXIX.
XXX.
XXXI.
380
400
426
XXXII.
Mrs. Piper : Author's Experience .
.
Hodgson's First Piper Report, 1888-91 .
Mrs. Piper's English Sittings, 1889-90 .
Hodgson's Second Piper Report, 1892-5 —
George " Pelham "
XXXV.
XXXVI.
306
314
321
329
339
364
368
460
Hodgson's Second Piper Report (ConiiniLed) — Miscellaneous Sittings
. 479
XXXIII. Hodgson's Second Piper Report
tinned) — The Thaw Sittings
XXXIV.
221
228
240
276
294
(Con.
. 496
Hodgson's Second Piper Report {Cotir
c2iiJed)~H0DGS0N's Conclusions .
. 513
Professor Newbold's Report
.
.
Farther Newbold Notes ....
. 531
562
Contents
zi
PAOI
XXXVIL
XXXVIII.
Pbopessob Htslop's Report
Mb.
Piddington,s
Eepobt
Thompson
...
on Mbs,
XXXIX.
The
Thompbon-Fipeb-Joseph
Sebies
Mabblb
697
602
629
XL.
XLI.
XLII.
The Thompson-Myers Contbol
.
Hetebomatio Scbipt: Mbs. Holland
Hetebomatio Scbipt: Mbs. Vebball
. 637
. 647
. 672
XTJIL
The Pipeb-Hodgson in Amebica
. 685
XLIV.
The Pipeb-Hodgson in Amebica {Con-,
tinned)
The Hodgson Contbol in England
.
TfiB Isaac Thompson Sebies in 1906 .
Cboss-Cobbespondences
....
The Pipeb-Myebs and the Classics
.
The Pipeb-Junot Sittings
.
.
.
XLV.
XLVI.
XLVII.
XLVIII.
XLIX
BOOK
ATTEMPTS
L. Relations
.
713
737
749
761
774
785
III
AT CORRELATION
of the Medium's
WITH Otheb Dbeams
Dbeams
....
830
U.
LII.
The Making of a Medium
.
.
Final Quesses Regabding Possession
. 848
. 864
LIIL
Fbos and Cons of the Spibitistic Hypothesis
The Dream Life
Dbeams Indicating Subvival of Death
Final Summaby ......
LTV.
LV.
LVI.
870
881
914
931
ON
THE
COSMIC
RELATIONS
BOOK
CORRELATED
I
KNOWLEDGE
CHAPTER
I
INTRODUCTION
Thbrb is somethiiig more than resemblances of words to
make this age of wireless telegraphs, horseless carriages, and
tuneless mnsic, an age of lawless laws and creditless creeds.
When new things replace old ones, new conceptions mnst
follow; and during the transitions, men's convictions are
suspended. Accordingly the comparatively recent realization
that the Cosmos is governed by law, uniform, just, and merd*
less, has dethroned the god whom prayer influences to dis«
turb the order of Nature. With such a god, goes most that
such a god implies; and until we assimilate new conceptions
of the power behind the universe, we are getting along with
a short supply of faiths, and in some respects not getting
along at aU well. It may not be hard for instance to trace
the connection of the lawless laws and creditless creeds with
the tuneless music, or with any other art which has parted
with inspiration. The old views of our Cosmic Relations
being gone, these conditions cry out for new ones.
It is a commonplace, but a very true one, that we are apt
to attribute too much of mankind's well-being to recent discoveries. Telephones and wireless telegraphs are useful as
transmitters of words only if the words say something worth
saying; and there has not been said as much worth saying
since tiie invention of the telephone as there was during an
equal period before that invention. The wealth developed
by man's recently increased control of nature has put the
2
Introduction
[Bk. I
search for wealth in front of the searching of the spirit:
neither in production nor in appreciation have literature,
philosophy, or the arts, the place they had about the middle
of the nineteenth century, and science has been turning more
and more from the discovery of Nature's inspiring laws to
the production of wealth. The relation between man and
the universe outside him has been growing more mechanical
and less emotionaL True, the city dweller seeks Nature more
than he did, but it is for his body's sake rather than his soul's
sake, and he feels a responsive soul behind Nature less than
he did. The fervors, thrills, and longings of the philosopher
are gone with those of the devotee. With them have disappeared the inspirations of the poet and the artist. If they
come back, they must come under new forms: the old ones
are like worn-out garments. Of what the new ones may be
we are about to search for some hints.
Men have always had some sort of realization of the
ineffable mysteiy surrounding what they know. From the
savage's propitiation of the unknown Power behind eveiy
known thing, up to Spencer's predication of an Unknowable
beside which all we know shrinks toward nothingness, that
mystery has been the source of many of our best emotions,
and often of our dominant ones. For long periods and over
wide spaces, religion has been both an inspiration and a con*
trol. Although it was behind the cruelties of the Inquisition
and the asceticisms of the Thebaid, it was no less behind the
sculpture of Greece, the painting of the Benaissance, the
poetry of the Divina Commedia and the Paradise Lost, and
the music of the Twelfth Mass and the Stabat Mater. What
perhaps is more, it filled the ages in which lived makers of
other great works, who, while showing no consciousness that
they were affected by religion, even while contemning it,
unconsciously owed to it much of their inspiration. This is
realized by most of the. few living men who experienced and
hated the Puritan education that survived beyond the first
half of the last century. At ccdlege they may have hated to
go to chapel, especially when compelled to it before daylight
in winter, and in the shortened holiday of June afternoons;
they may have despised many of the dogmas taught, and
even many of the good teachers who were too stupid to see the
Ch. I]
Inspirations.
Puritanism.
Infidelity
8
new revolntioxifi rushing through thought; but despite all the
h&tred and contempt, some of them feel yet the thrill from
the old hymns sung in the slanting sunlight of the shortened
holidays, and realize that those thrills were akin to those which
made that an age of great music and great literature — greatness whose dwindling makes this age comparatively barren.
Yet the inspirations of Bossini and Verdi and Abt and
Lachner and our own Foster,, and those of Tennyson and
Emerson came from precisely the same universe that we have
before us now — nay, from a much narrower one; but the
interpretations of it were different, were generally accepted
and were embodied in a set of enthusiasms common to all men,
and therefore doubly inspiring to all men, even to the few
whose emotions affirmed when their intellects ignored or
denied.
The Calvinistic theology, with its outcrop of Puritanism,
had made Grod a tyrant to whom all joy in his creatures
was displeasing. This made morality consist in self Hsuppression. The master of my preparatory school, though educated
as a physician, counseled his boys against drinking water in
hot weather : so far did the conviction go that all our desires
inclined toward evil; even in fevers, water was not permitted;
and at Yale in my time, not only were the students forced
to go to chapel in the dark mornings and winter storms, but
an offer to cushion the benches of the chapel was rejected because it was feared the cushions would promote effeminacy.
At the same time, in 'defiance of all consistency regarding the
effeminacy, but most consistently regarding the asceticism,
athletics were not encouraged, partly, whether so realized or
not, because they gave pleasure.
But the reaction against those mcmstrous opinions, in
dethroning the monstrous god the opinions propitiated, dethroned the only god there was,jand, to the minds of many,
introduced a purely material umverse-— one without malevo,
lence but equally without benevolence— a Cosmos, it is true,
because orderly and governed by law, but with its emotional
elements ignored, and even its beauty dissected away in the
search for oiuses.
These arid views were of course possible only during the
passing of an intense emotional reaction. While the relations
of the Soul to God became abstractioiu too tennous to consider, the interactions between the Soul and the rest of the
Cosmos, were more distinctly recognized and investigated, and
it became generally realized that of those interactions, hap«
piness is, despite exceptions, the natural restdt: indeed, the
Cosmos has come to appear an apparatus for the production
of happiness, and, on tiie whole, despite many failures, a very
successful one. At least in our comer of it. Nature has been
at work longer than we can intelligently realize, in making
man ,'from the dust of the earth ', — ,in evolving responsive
matter from irresponsive, and in building up organisms of
responsive matter for no other apparent reason than that the
responses may produce happiness.
All sane action is undertaken for the sake of happiness.
Other reasons have been given, but they do not bear examination. Action may be sane, however, and yet mistaken, or
may even be deliberately counter to the happiness of the
actor, in which case, as in self-sacrifice for another's sake,
it will be intended for the happiness of someone other than
the actor — it may be even for the happiness of Ood, as in
the Juggernaut sacrifices no less than in the Boman incense
or the musical tributes of the rural New England melodeon
and choir. Or the action may be counter to the happiness
of someone else, in which case it will be for the happiness
of the actor, as in robbery; or of some third person, as in
removing a friend's enemy; or again even of God, as in
persecuting those who deny him.
Or, once more, the action may be against the immediate
happiness of the actor, but for his at4eastH3upposed ultimate
happiness, as in asceticism for the souFs sake; or it may be
against the immediate happiness of another, but for his supposed ultimate happiness, as in religious persecution. But
in whatever complexities the purpose of action may be disguised, itis, if sane, ultimately intended for happiness— of
somebody somewhere. Counter theories have been maintained, but they have been demonstrated fallacious, both in
logic and in practice.
The proposition that, so far as we can see, happiness is
the only known justification for the existence of either soul
or universe, has probably been the object of more attack
Cb. I]
Happiness, Duty, Cosmic Law
5
than any other proposition in philosophy. The opposition,
however, has been mainly against low definitions of the term
happiness, which the critics have made for themselves. But
that proposition is supported even by their suggestion that
Ood made both soul and imiyerse to amuse himself — that
his eyes might be delighted by human sacrifices, and his
palate by their flesh; or that his ears might be tickled by
melodeons, and his nose by incense — such was one idea of
Divine happiness entertained by some of those who made the
suggestion.
If happiness means the satisfaction of poor taste, or vanity,
or sensuality, or means even mere amusement, the proposition
is well founded. But where does happiness bulk larger — ,in
poor taste, or good taste; in vanity, or modesty; in excess,
or temperance; in selfishness, or in generosity; in laziness
or activity? If happiness is most effectively sought in good
work relieved by the recreation essential to its best eflSdency,
and directed to the greatest aggregate happiness — ,regarding
the happiness of the individual only as a component of that;
in love of the beautiful universe and of the arts we generate
from it; in love of beautiful bodies and beautiful souls, and
the beautiful moral law; and in grateful, hopeful, filial,
intimate reverence for the Power and Beneficence obvious
behind it all — ,if happiness comes mainly from these
things, who shall say that its production is not the main
result, and the best result, of all the legitimate activities we
know? And yet it is but a by-product of duty.
With this view — ,that the cosmic relations are normally
productive of happiness — ,has come the realization that the
substitution, in the control of the universe, of law for
anthropomorphic volitions, has not done away with morality;
and that discrediting the testimony on which, in our branch
of the race, the hopes of immortality had mainly rested, did
not destroy all bases for the hopes, especially as there began
to appear new bases, which even conquered the skepticism
of many investigators to whom the old ones appealed in vain.
These new mental attitudes have resulted from much dis«
cussion, but they are still so new that discussion can hardly
yet have become superfluous, and that any earnest writer may
hope to present some aspects worth noticing. In this hope
6
Iniroduetion
[BL I
I venture one more consideration of our Cosmic Bdations —
one by no means ezhanstiYe, even of our present knowledge,
but only of some salient features of it
Onr ', Cosmic Belations '' is a brief term for the interactions
between Soul and Uniyerse. For those interactions to be
successful — which means for them to be productive of happiness, the actions on one side must of course be in conformity
with the actions on the other. There are actions on both
sides not controlled by our wills — on one side, many of our
own thoughts and feelings; and on the other, most of the
processes of Nature. But we have always found the actions
we do not control, consistent with each other — ,in conformity
with Nature's laws, as we phrase it; and when the actions
we do control are also in such conformity, the actions we do
not control always co-operate with us, and insure our success;
when our actions are not in conformity, the other actions oppose us, and insure our failure. Conformity is what we call
morality.
With some of the reactions we are very familiar, some
we know vaguely, there may be others at which we merely
guess, and probably the vast majority we do not even guess
about. The changes in our bodies on which our mental and
physical well-being depends, are but very imperfectly known
to us, and many not known at all. The same is true of conditions in our environment. We can yet foresee but imperfectly the daily and seasonal changes of temperature and
moisture on which our health and fortunes so largely depend;
and we guess but faintly that there are around us changes
of magnetic and electrical tension which materially affect our
vigor and spirits, and yet which we recognize but slowly and
vaguely, and cannot anticipate, much less control. Such,
however, as already hinted, is the obvious consistency of the
universe, that there is every reason to believe that if we
deduce correct principles of conduct regarding what we know,
we will comport ourselves wisely regarding what we do not
know. The vast majority of wise people have even carried
this principle so far as to believe that if there is a life beyond
the one we are leading, the full use of this one is the best
possible preparation for that one. Some ascetics, however.
CIi. I] PhiloBophjf and Canduet
Saul and Unwerse
7
have advocated the subordination of this one to certain fancies
which they have entertained regarding that one.
To guard against such extremes, it is well to know the
general laws of the happiness-producing Cosmos: for they
indicate the right uses of less general knowledge. That is
the reason for traditionally applying the term The Guide of
Life to the general laws, embraced under the name Philosophy, and is why masters of special arts have always come
to learn from masters of philosophy, and why widespread
errors of philosophy have led to disastrous blunders in religion, statecraft, economics, criminology, physical science,
and invention — ,blunders all the way from attempting to
govern heterogeneous peoples by homogenedhs suffrage, and
attempting to cure laziness by fostering it, down to astrology
and perpetual motion.
As any treatment, however modest, of the widest generalities, must here and there touch the outlines of all we know,
to make some sort of consistent whole it must include many
things with which most readers are already familiar. But
that is an infirmity of nearly all exposition: often the best
that one can hope to reach, is putting old facts in new lights.
Our study, like all others, needs a classification of subjectmatter and a terminology, and our classification, like all
others, cannot escape being a little arbitrary, with some
overlapping at the lines of division.
As already intimated, we will consider the Cosmos as consisting ofthe soul and the universe external to it Yet some
wise people deny any such duality — ,part of them declaring
that there is nothing outside the mind, and others declaring
that mind is only a function of matter. Very well, we will
consider this later; at present, for the first class of persons,
let us divide the contents of the mind into what it does not
project as seemingly outside itself, and what it does; and
for the second class of persons, let us divide the functions
of matter into those taking place in the nervous system, and
those taking place outside* of it. As said before, no classification is faultless, but any one of these will do to work with,
8
Introduction
[Bk. I
and the three are nearly enough identical to permit the terms
of any one to apply to the others — at least closely enough
for our purposes. The terms in each case may well be covered by the old-fashioned words subjective and objective.
This is our first illustration of something that will come
before us often — and with which the reader is probably
already only too familiar — ,the absence in Nature of lines of
demarcation, and the frequent necessity of assuming them
for purposes of study. As with body and soul, so with animal
and vegetable, chemical and physical, and hosts of other
pairs of categories. Of most of the items under any pair,
we can say: This comes under one of the pair, and this
under the other; but there are some which we find it so
di£Scult to place that we are tempted to say : This comes under
both. Even to-day certain of the simplest organisms will
be found included in both zoological and botanical text-books.
Using our terms Soul and Universe, we place the body
outside of the soul. But inside the soul we recognize a
Something which says my body, my sensations, my thoughts,
my feelings, my soul. This something we know only as
making such remarks, and claiming such possessions ; but we
at least give it a name — Consciousness. But we call even it,
my consciousness. What calls it so? Another consciousness?
If so, that too must be ''mine,'' and so on oJ infinitum.
Thus consciousness, like everything else, is ultimately a
mystery beyond our faculties. Yet we include it with the
mass of sensations, thoughts, and feelings, under the conception which, pace the quarrels of the psychologists, we
call Soul.
Outside of the soul, too, are other souls, which, in relation
to it, we are to include not in Soul, but in Universe: for
as happiness is mainly produced by the interactions between
one soul and other souls, unless we did include objective soul
in universe, there would be but a sorry foundation for our
fundamental proposition that the interactions between soul
and universe are the cause of happiness.
To this proposition it may be objected (How hard it is
to make a proposition to which '' it may be objected ** never
applies 1) that the soul derives happiness from its own functions— from studying its own processes, contemplating its
CIl I]
Knowledge, Bxpmenee, Forecast
9
memories and imaginationB, and constructing its interpretations, theories, and schemes. True, but all these seem to have
their origin in reactions between Soul and Universe.
We will regard the universe as consisting of, first, the
portion known to us; second, the portion partly known, or
on the borderland between the known and the unknown;
and third, the portion unknown, which is presumably immeasurably the largest This classification, too, is like all
others, very vague at the dividing lines — so vague indeed
that we have to begin by admitting the first portion to be,
from one point of view, identical with the second; but we
will find another point of view.
What shall we understand by the known universe? It is
really a sequence of phenomena. Until lately it was believed,
and is still generally believed, that we can perceive, think, and
feel only through vibrations in the objective universe, including nerve matter, and we may as well proceed provisionally
on this belief until we reach the reasons that may point to
supplementing it. Supplementing belief seems, in this generation, to have been one of our most important functions.
Ejiowledge is the recognition of uniformities and differ*
ences in the aforesaid vibrations, and it is really knowledge,
only as it can prophesy uniformities and differences in new
vibrations.
The ability thus to prophesy depends of course upon uniformity and breadth of experience. Certainty varies as these
vary, and as ther, is no final experience — as the sun may
not rise to-morrow morning; as next winter may be hot,
and next simimer cold; as anything and everytl,ng may turn
out differently from what it always has; there is of course
no absolute certainty. Or looking at it from another angle:
if certainty means demonstration not open to any possible
doubt, absolute certainty is impossible to the human mind:
for, as has often been said, absolute certainty would need
infinite evidence, whose accumulation would require infinite
time. Meanwhile ,' absolute '' and ', infinite ** are words which
are merely confessions of ignorance, and therefore '' absolute
certainty', is not only unattainable, but unthinkable; and
over all this, some diseased minds have made a great pother.
10
Introduction
[Bk. I
But it is a far cry from such coiuiideratioBS, to the inference of the peseimists that as human knowledge is not
certain, it is useless. We have found practical certainty, in
the vast majority of instances, as reliable as absolute certainty
could have been; and our uncertain knowledge is not only the
best knowledge we have, but it is good enough. Our degree
of certainty that the sun will rise to-morrow morning, and
that things will go as they have gone, except as their totality
improves, has been a guide to all human effort, and a basis for
all human happiness. Though the disasters that have come
from mistakes have been many and serious, they have not
been enough to prevent life being generally worth while to
sane people not given to pessimism — if any sane people are.
There are those for whom the only certainty possible to men is
not enough. Their trouble, however, is not with their mental
food, but with their mental digestion. They need the help
of the alienist rather than the philosopher.
One often meets a general statement that the fact of evolution of our faculties and of our knowledge of the Cosmos up
to the present stages, demonstrates that the evolution of both
will continue, and that therefore there must be not only a universe, astronomical and microscopical, outside the one we
know, but also an unknown universe within the one we partly
know, and that this is as true of mind as it is of matter.
But I have never seen an attempt to make this abstract statement more realizable — ,more like the fruitful knowledge we
have of visible and tangible things, by a sketch of evolution
contrasting our universe with the universe of our primitive
ancestors, and drawing from the contrast the legitimate inferences regarding the wider capacities and wider universe
unknown to us, presumably infinitely vaster than those we
know, and presumably to be enjoyed by our descendants, and
possibly by ourselves in some other plane of being.
The mysteries of that unknown universe of mind and matter
have always been contemplated with awe, alike by the primitive savage and the most advanced saint and mystic, and
this awe has been the parent of most of the religious emotions.
But the developments in the universe of our daily experience
during the past century, have been so much greater than
ever before— have so increased our control over the powers
Ch. I] Cansctoumess of the Unknown* Plan of this Work 11
of Nature, and with it otur wealth, that never perhaps, certainly never since the lnxnrions days of Borne, have men's
thoughts been so diverted from the mysteries and emotions
which have marked the great religions ages. Those ages
have had their extremes, bnt onrs is in the opposite extreme,
and sadly needs to have a portion of its interests lifted from
Lombard Street and Wall Street, not to speak of the Savoy
and the Waldorf-Astoria.
Withont a large conscionsness of the nniverse beyond onr
knowledge, few men, if any, have done great things. The
consciousness may have been mingled with dark and cruel
superstitions, bnt it has been effective in spite of them. Even
poor Napoleon had it, and if his age had not been enough like
onrs to afford him but a niggard supply, he might not have
been the pitiable failure he was.
The task I have set myself is, first, to attempt (in Book I)
some such sketch of evolution as may impress, more than
abstract statements can, a living consciousness of the existence of the universe beyond our knowledge. For such a
sketch the facts are yet meager, and have to be pieced together
by not a little guesswork. Moreover, they largely relate to
primitive and uninteresting things, and I fear my sketch
will be dull, especially in the early stages, where its relation
to its object cannot be very obvious. Moreover, as it must
deal largely with commonplaces of knowledge, you may be
impatient unless I am fortunate enough to lead you constantly
to regard them as links in a chain of demonstration which,
when completed, may possibly repay your attention.
As soon as you find yourself bored, which I greatly fear
you will, it may still be worth while to turn to Chapter V.
There, after you skip what I fear may be some " fine writing '*
that I have been betrayed into, you will find the gist of everything between here and there; and in Chapter VIII you will
find the beginning of some things that may not have to depend on any powers of mine to make you ,' sit up and take
notice.''
Having done what I can to arouse an interest in the
Unknown, I shall proceed (in Book II) to give some account
of a mass of phenomena which of late have fitfully emerged
12
IfUroducUon
[Bk. I
from the TTnknown, and which although they aeem to have
always been more or less a part of man's reactions with the
Universe of both mind and matter, have been so small a part
that, while they raise questions of ihe highest importance, they
have been little explained — ,that is to say: little correlated
with the mass of verified and usable knowledge.
Incidentally, and especially in conclusion (in Book III),
I shall offer the leading guesses, and some of my own, as to
the possible correlations and implications of these uncorrelated
phenomena, and the answers they offer to the questions they
raise.
The last two books I trust will not tax the reader's patience
as severely as the first one.
We proceed now to the threatened sketch of evolution with
reference to its demonstration of a uniyerse beyond our
knowledge.
CHAPTEE
SKETCH OF HUMAN
II
EVOLUTION
The Body
FiBST for a rough snnrey of the apparatns through which
tiie Soul maintains its reactions with the Universe. As this
apparatns is eyolyed, its presumptive farther evolution involves
a farther evolution of its functions, which means an increase
of the reactions between Soul and Universe; and that means
an increase of happiness. At the outset, the survey of the
evolution of the apparatus may seem going over too familiar
ground, but it will contain some implications that are not
very familiar, and that are ancillary to our main purpose.
It will also help some more specific work later. Moreover
generally, probably always, the best way to study things and
their relations is to begin with their evolution.
Evolution began anterior to our knowledge, but it is now
going on in things so much like any one we may wish to
study, that we can generally get a fair notion of that thing's
evolution, through the similar evolutions going on around us.
For instance, from hints we get from other suns and systems,
and from the action of mechanical laws that we know, we
have made a history of the evolution of our solar system;
and although no man ever saw that evolution, our history
of it is probably more reliable than many histories of human
events that profess to be made from the reports of witnesses.
Similarly regarding the evolution of plants and animals and
intelligence : we have primitive protoplasm and many primitive organisms with us now, and by watching them, and seeds
and embryos which repeat their own ancestral evolution, we
have learned much of the past biological evolution of which
we are the summit.
As we know (in the sense of ', knowing*' already explained), the evolution of the human body took its start, if
18
14
Sketch of Human Evolution
[BL I
we wish to assume a start anywhere, an immeasurable time
ago, in a cell of protoplasm.
The most primitive individual creature that we know is
the amoeba. It is little more than a nucleated cell of
protoplasm, and yet it does queer things. But first let us
see if we can get behind it to a connection with inorganic
nature: for inorganic objects do queer things too.
Professor Holmes says {Evolution of Animal Intelligence,
p. 67) :
', There are various ways of imitating the movements of
Amoeba by drops of oil or other fluids subjected to changes
of surface tension. If a drop of mercury is placed in dilute
nitric acid and a piece of potassium bichromate placed near
it the drop of mercury will bulge out toward the bichromate
and may surround it. The bichromate as it diffuses against
tiie mercury causes a diminution of surface tension at the
region of contact. The stronger contraction of the rest of
the surface film forces the mercury to protrude at the weakest
point, producing an outpushing resembling the pseudopod''
[false tions
foot]
" of thetension
Anusba.account
It has inbeengreat
contended
in surface
measurethatforvariathe
movements of Amooba and other Bhizopods much as in inor*
ganic fluids. There is certainly a striking analogy between
the phenomena in the two cases, but the studies of Jennings
have shown that explanation of the phenomena is not quite
80 simple."
Elsewhere Professor Holmes tells us that a drop of water
will swallow a fine splinter of glass, and that a drop of
chloroform will also, if the splinter is covered with sheUac,
and will eject it after the shellac is dissolved and becomes
part of the drop. A drop of protoplasm with a nucleus, which
we call an amodba, will swallow pretty much anything it can
manage to flow around, and after treating it, so far as conditions permit, as the drop of chloroform treats the shellac, will eject what remains, as the chloroform does the
glass.
In view of such facts, one is almost tempted to ask whether
the desire to draw an arbitrary line between *' physical and
chemical processes,'' on the one hand; and on the other the
" super-physical agency • . . vital principle, or entelechy of
some sort,'' may not be simply the old theological prejudice,—
Ch. 11]
Ofiffin of Life.
Protozoa
16
and whether organic and inorganic are not simply two aspects
of the same thing.
To determine where, in the three performances above described, life begins, certainly will give material for debate to
those fond of the exercise. Perhaps the question can be
settled by the fact that yon and I can be pretty closely proved
to be descended from drops of protoplasm, and nobody yet
heard from can be nearly as closely proved to be descended
from drops of water or even drops of mercury or chloroform
or oil, though the chloroform is complex matter, and the oil is
organic matter.
Professor Holmto {op. cU.) is mj principal authority
for the statements immediately following:
In the material of amoebes and other low forms, various
chemical reagents inserted in the water they inhabit, awaken
reactions which lead to changes in form, sometimes enough
to produce motion of the organism, and lead it to or away
from the reagent It is thus difficult, if not impossible, in
the simpler creatures, to draw the line between chemical
reaction and animal motion, and even purposeful motion in
creatures a little higher stilL
So with the effects of gravity — some of these creatures
find their way to the bottom of the receptacle, and others
to the top. Chemical reactions, especially variations in the
amount of oxygen, combine with gravity in producing these
motions.
Light, too, is an agent; and when the spectrum has been
thrown on the water, there has been a marked clustering of
some creatures toward the red end. Often clusters form in
response to the conditions — for instance around a drop of
some reagent, sometimes to their destruction, though ofteher
to their betterment If an electric current is sent through a
mass of amoebee, it will move itself, or part of itself, toward
the cathode. All may go, or, if the current is very strong,
the point near the anode may contract and disintegrate.
Paramecia, worms and moUusks generally react to electricity negatively, and crustaceans positively.
Masses of amoebe elongate themselves toward favoring
', objects — ,throw out pseudopods — and attach themselves. We
envy the crab who, if he happens to lose a limb, develops a
16
Bieich of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
new one, bnt the crab may enyy the amoeba who makes his
limbs as he needs them— eztrades a pseudopod in the direction
where his reactions send him, and flows the rest of himself
np into the pseudopod. Then he will do it again, and so
travel.
Amoebae also get (make themselves?) top-heavy, and roll
over, and keep it up till they have traveled an appreciable
distance. Creatures a degree higher have more or less per«
manent cilia which they nse similarly, and by which ihey
regulate their motions. A grade farther on, these cilia become
a swimming apparatus — ,in later evolution, the tentacles of
the octopus; or the creatures may evolve, instead of cilia or
tentades, a curtain like that of the jelly-fish.
The cell of protoplasm has, in a sense, no interior organization: it gets all its nutriment and sensations (if it has any)
from its surface — from otiiside. But its descendants tend
to evolve into sacs or tubes, and the water flowing through
the opening of the sac or tube supplies some nutriment and
sensations tnside. This differentiation soon becomes marked,
the nutriment being taken up more and more from the
inside, and distributed through a system of minor tubes which
become evolved throughout the material composing the principal one.
In time, the central tube evolves a bulge which acts as a
stomach, a gland shows up alongside it, and that pestilent
organ a liver is introduced into the world, perhaps contemporaneously with original sin.
In time the lower end of the tube differentiates into various
sorts of intestines, and appendicitis becomes a fashionable
possibility. The upper end differentiates into a mouth, and
when the mouth becomes human, not only do its lips and
teeth become beautiful, but eating itself becomes a fine art,
and a well-managed dinner table becomes a great educational
and political influence.
The subsidiary apparatus for circulating the blood also
develops into a pumping engine and system of intakes —
arteries, and one of outlets— Teins, for the waste left after
the nutritive matter has parted with its force. This waste
is deposited in reservoirs from which it is discharged period-
CL II]
Digestive Organs, Ltmhs, Nerves
17
ically. Were it discharged constantly, as it is made, all refinement oflife, and present attractions of hnman beings for
each other, would be non-existent The circulatory and excretory system also does its share for the aesthetic, in supplying red lips and pink cheeks and the flushes of emotion,
and Cleopatra's ',bluest vein.''
Meantime is evolyed a parallel tube for gaseous food and
waste. It opens into the mouth, and below ramifies into
lungs, and, like the other tubes, in time makes its contribution
to intelligence and beauty: for it contains the apparatus for
the voices of Patti and Caruso, and an extension of it was
covered
by thatthesame
Cleopatra's
Pascal rested
fortunes
of the nose
world.upon whose dimensions
On the way up to all this, parts of the body surrounding
the original tube have differentiated, as already partly intimated, into the curtain of the jelly-fish, the radiates of the
star-fish, the feelers of the octopus, the fins and tail of the
vertebrate fish, the paddles of the amphibious lizard, the
wings and legs of the bird, the legs of the quadruped; and
at length the arms and legs from which are modeled those
of the Apollos and Venuses.
To receive the sensations which all these pieces of appa*
ratns pick up (including the aches announcing that they
need attention), and to direct their consequent activities,
there is gradudly evolved throughout the body a nervous
system. It begins at the surface, where it gets its sensations
from the external universe.
A very primitive nervous system is an afferent nerve near
the surface, bringing sensation to a ganglion, and from the
ganglion an efferent nerve going to some sort of contractile
tissue near the surface. The surfaces of some primitive
animals are covered with such rudimentary systems — ,the
earliest distinguishable ones being little more than ganglia
alone, which, in addition to producing contractions, in some
way influence the surface nutrition and, in time, the tem«
perature.
But by and by these rudimentary systems get integrated
into higher systems; two ganglia may be connected by a
nerve, or each connected with a third ganglion, and by the
18
Sketch of Human Evolutim
[BL I
intenrention of the third ganglion the afiEerent nerve to the
first ganglion may provoke an answer through the efferent
nerve from the second : so that a message that a surface spot
itches, is not offset by a mere message from the ganglion to
the spot to contract, but by a message through a different
ganglion to a beak or a daw or a hand, to scratch it.
Farther, two of such systems of three ganglia each, may
be connected through each third ganglion with a seventh.
And in this system, of seven, an afferent bringing a report
from any of the six, may start, by way of the seventh, an
afferent from any otiier of the six, or perhaps all of them.
There may be a scratch ordered from one, a cry from another,
a reflection on the cussedness of fleas from another, and so on.
Two such sets of seven ganglia may both, by connection
with a fifteenth ganglion, be incorporated into a set of fifteen,
and then there will probably be some philosophizing, perhaps
not only regarding the cussedness of fleas, but possibly regarding auniverse where fleas are possible, or even a god who
permits them.
These incorporations are not as systematic as described,
but take place in all conceivable fashions. Moreover they
need not be between ganglia connected by lines of nerves,
but in most cases they actually are between adjacent cells
connected in all sorts of ways by prolongations from globular
or oval centers. Masses of cells so connected by many varying
a£Sxes, make up still larger ganglia; and in the higher animals, the largest of these is the brain.
Meanwhile the nerves at the surface have multiplied until,
as any pin-prick will prove, they are as close together as
some of the early casuists supposed the angels were on the
needle's point
The ends of the afferent nerves all over the surface, including the sense organs, get intelligence from the external world,
and transmit it to the flrst point where something is done
about it— at least to the flrst point where the nerve carrying
intelligence in, meets, in a nerve-bunch or ganglion, a nerve
carrying orders out. This meeting may be in a ganglion on
the way to the brain, or in the brain itself.
In the first case, the return message goes to the musdes
near the affected spot, before the nerve fron, the spot affects
CSL n]
Bympathetie Nervous Syriem
19
tbe intelligence at all ; and the mtiBcle gives gome inyolnntary
jerk. Or poeeibly the afferent nerve current will pass on,
perhaps through snndiy ganglia, to the brain itself. In this
case, before any efferent message goes back, the situation may
be thought over — ,it may be concluded, for instance, that
scratching is more trouble than it's worth, and no orders are
issued, except sometimes a veiy imperative order to keep
still, if the itching, or the impulse to sneeze, or perhaps the
impulse to say something questionable, should be dangerously
strong.
Mingled with the laoework of afferent nerves to carry sensations from the surface of the body, but preponderantly
behind them, is the network of efferent nerves leading to the
muscles. Then, mainly well below the surface, both the
afferent nerves and the efferent nerves begin to join each
other, not only in ganglia, as stated, but also in ,' cables '*
going to other ganglia, the cables imiting into larger ones
until these last go to ibe backbone, and one of them passes
in on each side between each pair of vertebne, and there
unites with the principal cable of all, and passes up into
the brain.
A preparation of a human nervous system in the Jardin
des Plantes looks like a statue of lace: so here again, as in
every piece of apparatus or every function we have been considering, evolution has been toward beauty, even though hidden beauty.
This is a rough sketch of the apparatus for the soul's
voluntary reaction with the universe, whether the soul be a
mere capacity to react to touch, or a capacity to receive impressions and ideas, and issue directions and ideas, with the
power of a Bismarck or a Shakespere.
In addition to the apparatus for voluntary reaction, is
one in some respects more interesting still, and, as will become
plainer as we proceed, more related to our present task. In
fact the sketch of the nervous system already given, serves
our immediate purpose only as contributing to an understanding of the sketch we are about to give. In front of
the spinal column, and on its respective sides, are two other
cables which do not go to the brain, and into which enter
20
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
nerves from all the organs that act independently, or partly
independently, of the will — the heart, the lungs, the digestive
organs, even tibe sweat pores on the skin, which help to regulate the temperature of the body. These cables have several
ganglia which act like subsidiary brains in regulating the
actions of the connecting organs.
The two nervous systems may be — ,probably often have
been, respectively called voluntary and involuntary, though
they connect with each other so that, regarding respiration,
for instance, they are both voluntary and involuntary; and,
as in walking, playing music, or in some tricks of legerdemain,
the voluntary one may be trained into almost involuntary
action. Our wills control the first system, being limited only
by our powers and whatever unresponsiveness there may be
in the environment. With the other system (generally called
tiie sympathetic) our wills have little to do, except so far
as our knowledge and discretion affect the body's health.
If the conscious purposeful human soul controls the nerves
—or most of them, which center in the brain, what controls
the nerves centering in the sympathetic system, where the
human will does not enter? There are overwhelming reasons
for recognizing it as the same power that makes and vitalizes
the flowers and the sequoia, the unthinking monad and the
scarcely-more-thinking whale ; causes the sun to lift moisture
and to gild the clouds in which it floats; causes the air to
float them, and the shifting wind to send them back to earth
in storms and with lightnings — ,the same power that causes
the sun to burn, that rolls us away from him by night, that
swings the other planets around him, and all the planets of
other systems around their suns, and all (the word begins to
lose meaning here) the suns around each other ; and still the
same power that has evolved and sustains the mind of man
to learn these things — the power for which we may as well,
perhaps, use the old name Ood, with all its reverend associations, and despite all its besmirchings. The name can often
save a lot of circumlocution, and we need not confine it
to the anthropomorphic conceptions generally associated
with it
Our limitations being what they are, it is fortunate that
we do not have to take entire care of ourselves, and that so
CIl II]
The Power not Ourselves
21
much care of us is taken by that ,' Power not ourselves.''
If we had to take thought to pump our own hearts and
lungs, digest our food, secrete our bile, and perform the other
functions essential to keep us in condition, we would forget»
keep constantly ailing, or be letting something stop; and if
it were the heart, we should die. In fact, if we had to
attend to these functions from the beginning, we cannot
conceive of our growing up at all; we cannot even conceive
of our existence starting at all, if ''Gk>d'' had not started
it for us. ,' He '' sets the little apparatus going, and brings
it to maturity, but allowing us, as it goes on, to do for
ourselves as much as we can do well, and more.
Where and how did the apparatus start? Nobody knows.
Nobody knows where anything started — even a train of cars.
Did it start at the station, or in the factories, or in the ore
beds, or in the star dust, or. in the previous system smashed
into star dust, or in the star dust that made that system,
or where? In all our classifications, we have to assume a
starting-point with reference to the inquiry at hand. Whether
we begin man, as we have done, in primitive protoplasm,
or in the cell differentiated from the male parent, the will
and the power that assimilate and integrate and differentiate
him, are both his own and not his own. If the soul creates
the body (for which proposition Dr. William H. Thomson,
in his new book on Brain and Personality, makes the latest
argmnent and one of tbfi best), the soul must be both the
spark of life in the parent cell, and the power working outside
of the independent volition of that cell, even when matured.
There will be significant things to say about this later.
The Senses
So much in general for the apparatus through which the
reactions between soul and universe take place. Now let us
proceed to the more specific reactions. This will involve a
more specific consideration of some portions of the apparatus.
Here too we have to choose our starting-point Star dust may
be a little too primitive, though I confess that I, for one,
cannot conceive of anything physical or spiritual without
its start at least that early. But let us start with as primitive
a thing as we are familiar with.
2d
Sketch of Hwnan Evolution
[Bk. I
A bit of rock reacts to grayity. Ib there any dgn of soul
versus uniyerse there ? Hardly.
Non-magnetic ore reacts to magnetic ore. Any sign there?
Not yet probably.
A bit of protoplasm, or the sensitiye plant, expands to
heat, or contracts to cold. The puzzle begins: there is life
indeed, but expansion and contraction with heat and cold
are no evidence of life: inanimate things show that. But
when an animate thing does i, may it not mark a transition
toward consciousness?
The bit of protoplasm, or the sensitive plant, contracts to
touch, and restores itself; the puzzle thickens: a rubber ball
will do that, but tiie ball's contraction is only in proportion
to the degree of the pressure, while the protoplasm's or the
plant's contraction may be much greater or less than the
degree of pressure.
We have no doubt about that being a vital reaction — something that no inorganic thing will do; or if we find it done
by anything before called inorganic, we will, I suppose, at
once call that thing organic.
Such primitive responses, although there were, strictly
speaking, no nerves, were the first germs of nervous reaction.
As evolution went on, however, portions of the primitive homogeneous substance were more and more differentiated into
nerve, and nerve differentiated and integrated into brain.
Touch, as distinct from the special senses, is hardly differentiated atalL Very early in the scale of being, any portion
of the surface contracts when touched. Some portions are
more sensitive than other portions. QraduaUy from the surface with its one sense of touch, were differentiated, from the
more sensitive portions, organs of special sense: response to
contact with material objects being gradually refined into
response to objects so nearly immaterial as odors, as air
in vibration appealing to a gradually developed sense of
hearing, and as (we assume) ether in vibration appealing to
a gradually developed sense of sight.
light produces all sorts of changes in inorganic matter,
and organic matter is less stable thsn even inorganic. Light
has been impinging upon organic matter a long time: it is
inconceivable that no changes should result, and that sua-
Gh. II]
Evolniian of Sight
2d
oeptibiliiy to the touch of rays of light Bhonld not appear
Btronger in some spots than in others. (For the reasons,
read a hnndred or two pages of Spencer's First Principles.)
In the conrse of generations, perhaps as the result of chemical
changes, snch spots have become discolored by some sort of
pigment, and the dark color increases the amount of light
absorbed. Farther differentiations take place nntil we find
features that we deliberate about calling eyes; and a few
thousand generations farther on, we unhesitatingly call them
eyes.
The conception of the evolution of the senses thus becomes
easy, and the placing of its evidences in sequence in the laboratory, has been but a matter of detail. It has been easy to
find tiie points where primitive eyes, or pigment patches, which
would respond to white light, grow responsive to blue light —
or to red or orange or yellow or green or indigo or violet;
and similar points regarding response by other senses. If
receptacles of different colors are offered to mosquitoes, they
avoid the yellow ones. This has led some recent investigators
in mosquito regions to dress themselves and cover their shelters with yellow.
When pigment first appears, it is generally flat behind
the light-receiving tissues, and so can receive light from
but one direction; but later it and the receiving cells curve,
and so become capable of receiving light from more directions, and finally the curvature becomes, as in most seeing
animals, the lining of a globe.
The stained skin gradually develops into a crystal-clear
lens on the outer surface of a ball filled with clear jelly, and
on the back of its interior, the nerve, which first reported
only the difference between light and dark, becomes spread
out into the sensitive plate of a camera, and reports the
images thrown upon it through the lens, with all the colors
we know.
The evolution goes from a fixed rudimentary lens to a
developed lens — ,up to fixed eyes of many lenses, as in the
fly, or perhaps by a different route to the moving eye with
a single lens.
Eyes appear early in various parts of the body,— on ihe
back, belly, sides, legs, even the tdl ; and in special prolongs-
24
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
tioQB that can be moved in rarions directions, as if we had
qres in our hands.
In the human embryo, the first trace of the eye is a line
in the skin, which develops into a fold, and thence by slow
stages up to the eye as we know it; and in contemporary
animals we find eyes all the way from mere localized sensibility to light, up to the optical instrument in the head
of man.
Before leaving the eye, it may be worth while to quote,
with a comment or two, a remarkable account of its varieties,
by Dr. Edward A. Ayers (Harper,s Magazine, September,
1908) :
** The snake has no use for tears, nor the goose for parallel
vision. The spider can spin the warp and woof of his destiny
without gazinfiT at the stars, and the sand-burrowing eel would
soon starre with sensitive comee. Nature holds to her exoeptionless law that the talent unused by the sire shall be with*
held from the son. But simplicity has its compensations. If
the spider cannot bend his neckless head nor move his socketfixed eyes, he gets one for each point of the compass, whereby
he can keep one eye on his struggling menu fiy, and as many
as needed upon the straining halyards and guys of his gum
thread web. , And each eye is set high, like a lantern on a
hill, so its wide range of vision makes eye-rolling useless. But
he can only focus four or fiye inches, and can be easily fooled
with an imitation fiy. Why are his eyes so beautiful — ,for
many are like rubies set in gold — ,if the only creatures that
can see them well have no sense of beauty!
** The rock-clinging starfish with his penta rays jeweled with
eyes; and the wood-louse — called a millepede — ,with twentyeight eyes, set in rows of sevens, as if his ancestors had gathei,ed maternal impressions of navy-yard cannon-ball decorations; and the blood specialist leech, with ten little eyes
surrounding his mouth to guard against tainted food; and
the dozen-eyed silkworm witib eyes single to spinneret output
and market quotation each; and the caterpillar sticking his
nose into an octagon crowned yoke of eye-gems, whence no
salad leaf may escape his view.
''A goose's eyes are larger than his brain. Han's eyes are
the best all around yet evolved, though they can see less than
the owl's in the dark; less keenly than the eagle's afar; change
focus less quickly than the hawk's; cannot sweep clear the
cornea without briefly hiding the view; cannot focus as near
as the fish; nor glow back like the cat's in the dark; they
tih. II]
Senses of Tawh and Hearing
26
cannot see opposite points at one time like the chicken's, nor
staie all day long like the snake's; they cannot self-gaze like
the snail's, nor behold as small creatures as can the fly."
Yet they can do vastly more things than can the eyes of
any creature who surpasses ihem in some one capacity.
The matured eye is in itself a thing of beauty and moral
expression, and yet its functions have been evolved from
reporting mere mechanical contact, up to reporting everything
from the sun-studded night to ihe dotted plate under the
microscope — from the menace of the storm-cloud to the love
in eyes that answer.
While senses responding to light and sound have been de>
velopingy so of course has su8cq>tibility to contact with hard
bodies been developing into susceptibility to contact with soft
bodies. Very primitive organisms, without definite senseorgans beyond those for mere contact, have been seen to contract and expand at contact with fluid as well as with air,
light, sound.
As the eye has grown from mere reflex action from mechanical contact, to reporting Nature and art, so has the ear
from a mere sense of vibration, up to that of the songs of
the birds and loved voices and the other forms of what we
call music.
Organs of hearing have generally been differentiated from
the skin, but not always. In some animals far from the
surface, even inside a chitin shell, are strings which are
supposed to be organs of hearing, and which are evolved
from muscles. In such positions these chorodontal organs
could of course only be affected by vibrations heavy enough
through water to affect the solid body imbedding the organs,
but such organs have been found in a later stage associated
with tympanous membranes which could transmit vibrations
through the air.
The Greenland whale hears well through the water, but
does not appear to be affected by sounds through the air.*
Insects often can hear only sounds of a certain pitch and
quality — ,generally those made by the opposite sex, as by the
•K. Sajo, ScUnHfU American Supplemsni, April 18, 1900. (Appar*
ently quoted from " Prometheus'* 7. }
26
Sieich of Human Evolviion
[Bk. I
female moeqaito. So (Bounds, as well as sights and smella,
are emissaries of love.
But for that matter, so can wb hear only ''sonnds of a
certain pitch/' but about ten octaves in all, and probably only
of a certain 'Equality/' i.e., there are probably sounds of a
pitch we can hear, whose quality prevents our hearing them.
In insects, the ears, or what appear to be such, are pretty
much anywhere, but generally in the antenna, feet, and
abdomen.
Mark Twain's famous biological statement that clams will
lie perfectly still if you play dow music to them, is probably
not strictly accurate: for many organisms not so high have
visibly responded to sounds.
The same that is true of the organs responding to touch,
temperature, light, and vibrating air, is, mutatis mutandis,
true of the organs of taste and smell.
The antennae serve also as organs of smell. They, like
organs of taste, are naturally near the orifice receiving the
food.
But the reports of the senses are not restricted to the
organs specially differentiated for each. Lombroso {After
Death — Whatfj pp. 2, 3) gives the following case from his
own experience, and there are many others well attested.
'' A certain 0. S., daughter of one of the most active and
intelligent men of all Italy •••had lost the power of vision
with her eyes, as a comi)en8ation she saw with the same
degree of acuteness (7 in the scale of Jaeger) at the point
of the nose and the left lobe of the ear. In this way she read
a letter which had just oome to me from the post-office, although
I had blindfolded her eyes, and was able to distinguish the
fibres on a dynamometer. Ciorious, also, was the new mimicry
with which she reacted to the stimuli brought to bear on what
we will call improvised and transposed eyes. Por instance,
when I approached a finger to her ear or to her nose, or made
as if I were going to touch it, or, better still, when I caused
a ray of light to flash upon it from a distance with a lens,
were it only for the merest fraction of a second, she was
keenly sensitive to this and irritated by it. 'You want to
blind
me I is
' shemenaced.
cried, her Then
face making
sudden movement
like
me who
with ana instinctive
simulation
entirely new, as the phenomenon itself was new, she lifted
her forearm to protect the lobe of the ear and the point of
the noe, and remained thus for ten or twelve minutes.
Gh. II]
Trantferred Senses
S7
''Her §6X186 of smell was also transposed; for ammotiia or
asafetida, when thrust under her nose, did not excite the
slightest reaction, while, on the other hand, a substance possessing the merest trace of odor, if held under the chin, made
a viyid impression on it and excited a quite special simulation
/mimiea). Thus, if the odor was pleiUBUig, she smiled, winked
her eyes, and breathed more rapidly; if it was distasteful, she
quicUy put her hands up to that part of the chin that had
become ihe seat of the sensation and rapidly shook her head.
''Later the sense of smell became transferred to the back
mf the foot; and then, when any odor displeased her, she
would thrust her legs to right and to left, at the same time
writhing her whole body; when an odor pleased her, she would
remain motionless, smiling and breathing quickly."
He farther says (op. dt, 5-7) :
" As early
as 1808
the had
casesbeen
of eight
cataleptic
women
in whom
the Petetin
externalcited
senses
transferred
to
the epigastric region and into the fingers of the hand and the
toes of the feet (ElectriciiS Animale, Lyons, 1808).
"In 1840 Carmagnola, in the Oumuile delV Aeeademia di
Medicina, describes a case quite analogous to ours. It concerned a girl fourteen years old '\.. who had "true fits of
somnambuHsm during which she saw distinctly with the hand,
sdected ribbons, identified colors, and read even in the dark.''
"Despine tells us of a certain Estella of Neuch&tel, eleven
years old, who... was found to have suffered transposition of
the sense of hearing to various parts of the body, — ,the hand,
the elbow, the shoulder, and (during her lethargic crisis) the
epigastrium
**FTtmk(Praxeoe Medicte, Univ. Torino, 1821) publishes
an account of a person named Baerkmann in whom the sense
of hearing was transposed to the epigastrium,* the frontal bone,
or the occiput.''
The literature abounds in such cases, but I cited the first
I happened upon, and there are hosts of illustrations, as we
shall see later, of cosmic relations independent of any senses
yet known.
The implications of these, facts we will touch upon later.
The evolntion of the different sense organs received another
interesting suggestion and perhaps confirmation, from the
experience, reported in the Revue PhUoeophique in 1887 (and
by me got from the Proceedings of the Society for Psychical
Besearch), of a French sailor who came home from Madagascar with hysteria, sense-paralysis of the left side, but part
of his right side so sensitiye as to throw him into attacks
28
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
of hysteria. These abnormal conditions could be temporarily
relieved by hypnotism, and, despite some skepticism at the
time, appear to have been ultimately cured by the magnet.
The point in his case which is of interest here, however, is
that under hypnotization, the nerves of ordinary feeling appeared to act as nerves of special sense. When his ears were
closed, he would repeat words spoken close to his fingers,
and with his eyes bandaged, he would sort various colored
wools. All this might be accounted for by telepathy instead
of by interchange of nerve function, but how account for his
picking out all the blue wools in the dark?
It was once the fashion in dealing with somnambulic
patients to address the pit of the stomach instead of the
ears, apparently with reference to the sympathetic nervous
system. I don't know whether the fashion prevails yet
CHAPTEB
8KBT0H
OF HUMAN
m
EYOLUTION
(OmAfiMMd)
The Soul
(a) Baurcea
Ik proceeding to consider sonl, I use the term in the
popular sense, without any reference to the technical sense
over which the psychologists are constantly quarreling. I
take the word rather than mind, in order to cover the emo*
tions and the will, as well as the mere intelligence. Tet it
wOl often be natural to use the term mind interchangeably.
In considering the evolution of soul, we are met at the
outset by the question : Is there a primary something — a mindpotential, from which thought and emotion are evolved, just
as body is evolved from force and matter?
At first sight it seems easy to find the raw material of
soul in consciousness, and to assume a starting-point for what
we now know as mind, when the matter in an amoeba con*
tracts at a touch : for then there must be some sort of consdousness; but consciousness is not dynamic: so how can it
be the raw material of thought, not to speak of emotion and
will? It is merely aware of them, as it is of sensation.
Telesio ,' argued . . . from the human consciousness to the
feeling of [in ?] inorganic matter.'' Somewhere I have seen
Weismann credited with the question : , Why should we not
return to the idea of matter endowed with soul?'' It is
probably as old as the other great guesses. The present aspect
of it, however, could not have antedated the verification of the
old guess of evolution, and that verification cannot be set
before Darwin. Bergson says (Creative Evolution, p. 199) :
,An incidental process must have cut out matter and the
intellect, at the same time, from a stuff that contained both."
For myself, long before I knew the opinion as anybody's else,
30
Sheich of Human Evolniian
[Bk. I
I could not imagine mind existing in Shakespeie without its
germs existing in the star dust And long after I first realized
my incapacity to separate consciousness from the star dust, I
found (italics mine) in James's Psychology (I, 149) :
"If evolution is to work smoothly, consciousness in some
shape must have been present at the very origin of things.
Accordingly we find that the more clear-sighted evolutionary
philosophers are beginning to posit it there. Each atom of
the nebula, they suppose, must have had an aboriginal atom
of consciousness linked with it; and, just as the material atoms
have formed bodies and brains by massing themselves together,
so the mental atoms, by an analogous process of aggregation,
have fused into those larger consciousnesses which we know
in ourselves and suppose to exist in our fellow-animals. Some
such doctrine of atomistic hyhzoism as this is an indispensable
part of a thorough-going philosophy of evolution. According
to it there must be an infinite number of degrees of conscious*
ness, following the degrees of complication and aggregation
of the primordial mind-dust. To prove the separate existence
of these degrees of consciousness by indirect evidence, since
direct intuition of them is not to be had, becomes therefore
the first duty of psychological evolutionism.'*
Mind, then, would appear to be as much a general element
of the universe as Motion is, and not only to enter the body,
as already said, with each unit of matter, but also in more
complex forms — ,through our perceptive organs as raw sen«
sation, and in predigested shape from the memory of each
mind and other minds. All this psychic material from any
source, after it enters the organism is modified into a specific
stream of thoughts and feelings, which we call the mind or
soul, just as Motion (or Matter, if that is the more convenient
phrase) is modified into a specific stream of molecular changes
which we call the body. But however mind may enter the
system, in passing through it is modified into a more complex
form, as thread is modified into fabric as it passes through
the loom; but thought is no more made of brain-matter than
doth is made of loom matter.
But if mind-potential is inextricably associated with matter,
how can mind exist independently of matter — ,what becomes
of the idea of a soul surviving the body in which it was de*
Ql III] Forc, and MatUr Limited, Mind Unlimited
81
Tdoped? Miiid is not limited in pktoe or quantity, as appar*
ently matter is. With our present knowledge we cannot
imagine matter greater or less in amount than earlier or later
forms of the same matter. But we can imagine one little flash
of thought pervading the psychic imiverse.
If all mind inhered in the star dust from which our world
was eyolyed, no more mind was in the brain of Newton than
in any other brain of the same weight, yet from Newton's brain, mind spread over the world and over all succeeding time, while from the other brain it spread no farther than the owner's interlocutors, and no longer than his
life.
The fact seems to be that mind outgrows matter as soon as
perceptive organs are evolved — that it comes to be not merely
the presumed primitive mind-potential associated with matter,
but more in amount and complexity, and in some degree independent Soon the star dust mind-potential becomes a relatively insignificant portion of the developed soul, and if the
soul is to survive the body, apparently it can well afford to
let the congeries of atoms, or whatever you call them, that
have constituted the body, go their way to dissolution from
each other, and carry with them their negligible portion of
the original mind-potential.
It is a world-old speculation regarding immortaliiy, that
after-existence cannot be conceived without pre-existence. I
never saw any sense in the speculation, except as I have indicated regarding mind-potential in the star dust. But won't
that, up through the life of protoplasm to that of the immediate parent germ, do well enough for pre-existence? In light
of this very simple knowledge, we cannot conceive of the soul
at all without attributing to it a pre-existence, and I confess
that I cannot conceive it then, without going back not only to
the star dust, but to the hypothetical (if we are not hypothetical enough alreadjr) system where the hypothetical smash-up
furnished the hypothetical star dust ; and so back through evolution and dissolution ,' time without end.''
These ideas of course are somewhat vague and paradoxical.
But they are definiteness itself compared with some that we
will be led into. How often may I be indulged in repeating
the truism that our ideas of the universe beyond the little we
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
know must always be yague and paradoxical ? But it is only
by starting with such ideas and reshaping them as we go along,
that we come to know more.
The idea that there is cosmic mind-potential jnst as there
is cosmic matter and cosmic f orce, and that, like them, it
flows into TJB, helping to evolve ns, is fraught with some
very important implications, and may help us to some interesting conjectures regarding some mysteries which we
shall meet later. Meanwhile we will consider a few facts
which go to support the idea, and will later consider in its
light some of the salient phenomena of the evolution of soul,
and see if the idea is consistent with them.
The only alternative to the theory that the mind comes
from outside, is that it is evolved inside — ,that, in Cabanis'
celebrated phrase, the brain secretes thought, as the liver
secretes bile.
This famous analogy, however, is but a very partial one:
for bile is limited and sensizable (I don't know whether that
word is in the dictionaries, but ifs time it were), while
thought is neither. And at least the most valuable portion of thought enters the brain as thought, — ,thought
already evolved from sensation, and supplied by memory
or other minds, while bile does not enter the liver as bile.
True, while thought generally enters the brain as thought,
it sometimes, perhaps always, undergoes modification there;
but it is not modified into something other than thought,
as in the liver blood is modified into something other than
blood. Cabanis' analogy is not even good as an analogy: to
make it so, the brain would have to secrete thought from blood.
What it does with the blood is not to secrete or transform
thought, but merely to build itself up, and send away its
waste.
Those who hold the view that man is *, one and indivisible "
— ,that the stream of thought is not from outside, but is
secreted by the brain, only put the question a stage back,
not asking themselves what runs the brain — ,not considering
that the fact that man eats potatoes and exudes heat, belongs
in this connection. In holding their view, they are believers
in perpetual motion.
The entire being, body as well as mind, is but a fleeting
Ch. Ill]
The Stream of Coneciausnese
33
mass of physical yibratioiis and psychical experienceB, and
often has been well likened to a fountain: though it has
a definite shape, it consists but of particles changing constantly and with varying degrees of rapidity — ,those concerned
in respiration, for instance, probably changing fastest; those
in arterial and venous circulation, next ; and so on, in lessening degree, until we get to those constituting bone or toothenamel, which probably abide in the body from five to ten
years. At death so much of its energy as is in the form
of heat, rapidly rushes back into the cosmic reservoir, and
so much as is in the forms which we generalize as matter,
begins to return immediately but more slowly. Most manifestations ofthe psychic stream also cease to appear, but by
no means all. It persists not only in memories and influences,
but we shall see indications of it difficult to attribute to
either.
While force and matter seem to be limited— constant in
amount throughout the universe, and before and after their
service in an individuality are in service elsewhere, we have
a good deal of evidence, the best being very recent, that,
at worst, revolutionizes all our previous experience of the
reach of mind; and, at best, would indicate that even the
individual mind, not to speak of mind in general, has no
permanent limits in time or space.
One school of philosophers reason that as force and matter,
through all their variations, are both persistent and constant
in amount, so mind must be. Perhaps none of them ever
stated it exactly in this form: the proposition may be too
evidently ludicrous. But hosts of them have stated it in
hosts of other forms, rq,ardlees of the plain fact that mind
is increasing every day: not only are there new thoughts,
but what thoughts there are, are being disseminated indefi*
nitely.
An orator's mind pervades an audience, and next morning
through the papers pervades his city and country, and in a
few hours more, through the cables, pervades the civilized
world. So far as the orator said new things, or old things
in a new way, there is that much more mind in the world.
It is not, as would be the case with matter or force, a mere
substitution of a new form: for no mind to speak of has
M
Sketch of Human Evolution
[6k. I
disappeared : yirtually all that theie was before is still stored
up
in men's
memories
as we
shall see
later. and in libraries ; and perhaps elsewhere,
Moreover, when matter takes any one of its transitory and
limited forms, it arouses new ideas which are not transitory.
This is of itself no argument against Cabanis, assertion
that the brain secretes thought, but the men who produce
the mind-things that last, say they don't come that way.
Probably Cabanis himself, and each man who independently
reaches Cabanis' conclusion, would call his apparently im*
mortal and equally incorrect phrase, an inspiration — something breathed in from outside. This is, however, a denial
of his own proposition.
The theory that psychic phenomena are simply a result
of nervous function, beginning with it, running parallel with
ity and ending with it, is generally called parallelism, but
parallelism does not prove beginning or ending together : for
the soul could be entirely independent of the body, and yet
act in exact correspondence with nervous function, the two
being like instruments in the same orchestra. Nay, the body
could even condition the soul without the soul being evolved
from it, as a pipe conditions water running through it; or
a channel conditions a river.
Total parallelism is at best an assumption. M. Bergson is
credited with being the last Si George effectually to dispose
of it. Even on the assumption that all mind does run parallel
with brain changes during all the brain's life, as parts of mind
certainly do during parts of carnate life, it is no more proved
that they start together and end together, than the same is
proved of a railroad and river that somewhere keep each other
company. The question soon ends in paradox, as questions on
the borderland of knowledge always do: for the germ of the
mind was in parent and parent's parent, back at least to protoplasm, and probably to star dust and beyond.
Huxley suggested the name epiphenomenalism. But either
name might apply to the opposite theory, of animism, — ,that
the soul is independent of tiie body: for if that is true, it
is still true that during the limited period of the brain's
activity, there is some approach, though apparently an irreg*
Ch. ni]
Tarailelism
95
ular approach, to parallelism or epiphenomenaUsm between
its actions and those of the soul.
But we shall meet later, serious, though not necessarily
fatal, objections to believing that this approach is constant —
that all operations of what we call the individual mind are
even accompanied by transmutation of brain tissue.
Moreover, we shall meet reasons — ,very strong recent
reasons — ,for believing that soul and body, though very closely
identified during mortal life, may be so fundamentally independent ofeach other, that when the body stops work and
enters upon dissolution, the soul may ** leave the body '' and
continue to exist independently, and instead of suffering by
the disconnection, be merely relieved of certain trammels
and limitations, notably those of time and space and matter.
It looks a good deal as if the degree of parallelism may
vary inversely as the grade of the psychic process, because
(a) Low psychic processes like fear and anger use up force
and tissue at a tremendous rate. On the other hand high
processes — courage, joy, sympathy, even artistic production,
are stimulating and invigorating. It is true, however, that
even the advent of a poem is sometimes attended by birth*
throes. Lowell wrote the '' Commemoration Ode ', almost at
a one-night sitting, and he said that it '' took the virtue out
of ,' him fearfully. But undue deprivation of sleep did that,
and if he had had a night of fear or sorrow, probably ', the
virtue '' would have gone vastly worse.
(b) Take another case which long puzzled me, until I
found a provisional key. At a dinner well constituted socially
and gastronomically, the brain and the stomach each can
be doing its very best without at all interfering with the
other. We are taught that either, to do its best, needs all
the blood it can get, yet here both do their best at oncel
This makes it look more and more as if the higher sort of
psychical function (and is it too much to call that normal
psychital function?) involved very little transmutation of
brain matter — as if it were somehow largely independent
of brain function.
(c) But the main consideration is yet to come. A man
can dream the most tremendous dreams, provided only they
36
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
be happy ones, and awake in better trim than if he had not
dreamed at all — ,not only without the slightest indication of
fatigue or hunger, but stimulated and invigorated. This has
been noticed after some of the mediumistic phenomena that
would have been expected to be most exhausting.
Now doesn't aU this suggest strong probabilities that, as
said, parallelism or epiphenomenalism and all that sort of
thing, vary inversely as what we will call, until we know more,
the dignity of the psychosis — ,in other words, that there's
no parallelism at all, but merely propinquity only while the
streams that started at identity in the protoplasm have not
yet definitely branched into the physical and psychical, and
especially that after they branch, the psychical runs parallel
with the physical only in so far as the psychical does not
throw off branches of higher thought, and, especially, is not
concerned with what we must so far regard as somewhat
transcendental psychosis, as experienced in dreams and various extraordinary dream states — ,in short, that the dream states
are largely independent of the body — ,that even when we lose
strength in bad dreams and nightmares, it is because of the
physical conditions which give rise to the psychoses, and not
because of the psychoses themselves? But there are other
dreams of a happier and higher order, not traceable to physical
conditions, and apparently involving no waste, but rather
bringing recuperation.
Now here for a page or two back, I have been asserting
and denying both monism and dualism. The possibility —
the inevitability— of so doing, seems to piove both true rather
than both false. I have the very moderate grace to admit
all this to appear very much like nonsense. As just said, we
never get very far from everyday experience without reaching
the land of paradox: what is generally called philosophy is
mostly made up of it ; and at best consists of fumbling. This
present piece of fumbling, however, seems to suggest a recon«
ciliation in the greater including the less.
Now let us fumble a little more at the relations of soul
and body.
Get all the medianics and chemistry that are behind a
Ch. Ill] Differences hetwew Thoughts and Things
37
thought, and yon haven't got the thonght. A yiolinist's
brain, the nervea leading to his arms and fingerSy the muBclea
moving them, his violin and its bow, the vibrations in the
air, the vibrations in the ear, the transfer of them to the
hearer's brain, the changes in the brain : I've probably named
everything
even
named mechanical
the mnsic. that takes place, and yet I haven't
A big pile of rock, over it a lot of fog banks, behind both
the setting snn; vibrations eastward from the whole affair;
a poef s eyes receiving them and reporting them to his brain,
and changes in his brain resulting : thaf s all of the mechanical :the poem is no part of them. The chasm between the
instrament and the music, or the sunset and the poem, is
absolutely impassable — a chasm whose bottom never can be
reached for crossing.
Even if, as seems growing more and more reasonable to
fancy, the sunset is merely a vehicle for the expressions of
the cosmic mind, as a bludi or a smile are expressions of the
individual mind, the sunset is not the poem; or the violin,
the tune; any more than the blood in the maiden's cheek,
or the smile of her mouth, are the joy in the lover's heart
But here we are again on the edge of a swamp of paradox,
as we were when we followed the track of monism and dualism
to the limits of our circumscribed knowledge. But for variety, let us start from the same center on still a third track.
A lot of little lines and dots representing a poem, ether
waves from them into an eye, transfers and changes in a
brain. The same poem has reached its goal through an entirely different set of mechanical vehicles — ,another illustration
of the absolute separateness of thoughts and things.
As does the poet, so the composer of the music puts down
a lot of little prosy dots and lines, the violinist gets impressions from them into his mechanical eye and brain that
you wouldn't finger for something pretty, and passes them
along through his mechanical nerves and muscles to prosy
catgut and horsehair; and behold! the heavenly music, and
into many minds joy and inspiration I And yet some philosophers would have us believe that the tune and the poem
are so nearly of the nature of the signs on paper, and the
88
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
horsehair, and the catgut, and the brain, that when all these
are gone, the tune and poem are gone. We know better,
not as a speculation but as a fact Mind, then, I for one
cannot help regarding as distinct from Matter and Force — a
third fundamental element in the constitution of man.
This apparently disproportionate attention to the nature
of mind— specially its source in mind-potential, may be
jtistified in our later Btudy of some mysterious psychical
phenomena. Meanwhile let us see if the hypothesis that
mind comes from outside is supported by a brief survey
of its evolution.
(b) The Perceptions and the Intellect
Of course in sketching a few indications of the evolution
of the senses, I incidentally touched some of the germs
in the evolution of mind.
The first reaction of organic life to anything in the environment, would appear to be the first reaction between soul
and universe.
A primitive cell's experiences consist in expanding to heat
and contracting to cold or touch, and, most of the time, in
freedom from perceptible touch or change of temperature.
It has probably some consciousness of at least the active
conditions — the changes, and possibly 'Hate in life'' some
oecognition of them as having been experienced before. Without some sort of recognition of difference of condition, there
could not be the reflex action to touch, which we generally
r,ard as the most primitive response of organism to environment, or, as I have chosen to phrase it, of soul to universe.
Whether the response be what we would call conscious or
not, there is some recognition of changed conditions, or
there could be no response to them. There is Force, in the
contraction; there is Matter transmuted, as in every physical
change. These have come from outside to become parik of the
organism. We have seen that probably there also came with
them something else that brought about the reaction, and the
gradations are gradual and coherent from it to Newton's reactions to the fall of the apple, or Darwin's to biological
phenomena, or Spencer's to the phenomena of mind and
Ch. Ill]
SvoMion of P$rception$
89
aociety, or Bembrandf s to lights and shadows, or Beethoven's
to the bird's song and the thunder.
Professor Whitman in Animal Behavior said: ''The primary roots of instincts reach back to the constitutional properties of protoplasm."
Professor Holmes says (op. cit, 180f.) :
''Along whatever line organization reaches a certain degree
of development intelligence appears on the scene. . • . Intel igence isnot an entirely new power unrelated to the
other activities of organic life, but a process growing out
of'' [Thefunctions
present and
writerhaving
wouldthesaysame
accompanying]
organic
end as these"other
other
functions; it is, as Spencer has so well emphasized, but a
higher phase of those processes of adjustment and regulation
which make up the life of the animal."
The simplest knowledge is of a single fact, yet the first
consciousness, whether it appears in protoplasm or higher
in the scale of life, it seems necessary to think, is not absolutely simple, but must contain in itself some sense of difference from an immediately preceding state, and as soon as
this sense of difference appears, an idea is evolved. When,
for instance, a change of temperature passes, it is succeeded
by a condition similar to that which preceded it, and when
the experience takes place in a consciousness sufficiently
evolved to associate the two conditions, a second grade of
knowledge arises — consciousness of likeness.
The 63q)erience, say of heat, takes place in an organism
high enough to recognize the antecedent and subsequent conditions as similar. A general idea is evolved. Countless
generations later it gets a name — cold; or vice versa, if the
experience is of a fall of temperature, the earlier and later
experiences correspond to what we give the name of heat;
but the first conception of either cold or heat must be so
foggy that it would probably not be noticed at all among
the vastly clearer ideas of the vastly higher organism that
gives it a name.
The sun's heat is accompanied by light, and when a
creature is evolved with some notion of heat, that is inevitably
soon followed by an association with light; and a new idea is
bom. This too must be such a vague conception that it Would
40
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
not be thought of in our own more mature experience, unless
special attention were directed to it; but there it is in the
primitiye creature — a general idea, faint and rudimentary as
you please, but a general idea, as distinct from a specific
experience. Imagination and the laboratory can both follow
these little sensations and ideas.
Suppose a primitive nervous system, with two centers con«
nected, one experiencing the difference which we call rise of
temperature, the other experiencing the difference which we
call increase of light — some such sense of it as we feel with
our eyes shut: these senses of difference are associated by
the nerve-fiber connecting the two centers which feel them.
This makes possible some psychical change consequent upon
the simultaneous experience of light and heat, — ,there arises in
that being something that would not have arisen but for
association of heat and light — something different from the
single association of heat with heat or cold with cold, or
either with the other — something perhaps unnoticed the first
time it appears, but something that in the course of generations isgoing to lead the creature's evolved descendant, when
it wants heat, to seek light, and when it wants coolness, to
seek shade. This something, as has been said, is not a mere
sensation — it is a coupling of sensations, and that coupling
is the germ of a thought— of a concept that heat and light
are associated. From that it is but a step to another con*
cept — ,that heat and light are not always associated; and
many, but actual, steps to the concept that the change of
condition meaning heat, generally takes place when there
is a reddish or yellowish round light thing up above; and —
a step farther, that the change meaning heat does not take
place when the round light thing up above is whitish. But
all this involves the evolution and connection of several nerve
centers; and of several more to notice that the two balls
seldom appear in the sky at the same time.
Thousands, perhaps millions, of generations later, those
primitive concepts have grown into a generalization, and in
time words have been found for it,' which mean: fire bums.
It takes thousands of generations more for fire to imply the
combination of atoms of carbon with atoms of oxygen — and
indeed it means that to comparatively few people, even yet.
Ch. Ill]
Thought based on Likeness and Difference
41
The first word, whatever it was, which meant fire (whatever
that then meant) came into existence only by virtue of vastly
more nervous centers being evolved, and connected with the
first two which had already made possible some change consequent upon the simultaneous experience of light and heat.
Meanwhile, much earlier, and of preliminary necessity,
arises a discrimination between good-to-eat and not-goodto-eat, and in time is made a distinction between likely-to-eatme and not-likely-to-eat-me. The recognition of good-to-eat
as distinct from not-good-to-eat, probably waits for the
evolution of some sense of soft and hard, or even is preceded by it in the rejection of, say, a grain of sand as
contrasted with a thing soft enough to assimilate. But creatures are seen to feed long before any distinction is made.
To the earlier forms, all is grist that comes to the mill : they
let the water flow into the opening that is the precursor of
the smiling mouth, and let it bring what it will — *, they eats
'em skins and all '' ; assimilable matter is assimilated, and the
rest passes on.
But despite the complexity of high types, let us keep well
in mind that the elements of all thought are sensation, and
consciousness of likeness and difference. The combination
of these three elements, remembered in relation to various
phenomena, make up the mental life of a Newton or a
Spencer.
Thought, then, is simply the arrangement of items of
knowledge into classes, according to the test of likeness or
difference. The most primitive thoughts that we have dealt
with put the sensation of heat to-day into the class with
the like sensation of yesterday, and the sensation of cold into
a different class. So with the sensations of light and dark,
and those of resistance, associated with floating bodies and
the shore, and comparative non-resistance associated with the
water.
Let us farther illustrate the process of mind-building, from
thoughts of a higher order.
A straight line is the shortest distance between two points.
This is but a perception of unlikeness — all other lines between
two points are found to be unlike straight The shortest
42
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
one, wherever we find it, we dass with others likt it, and
call it straight.
A straight line is one whose direction never yaries. All
lines whose directions vary we find are different from straight.
We classify accordingly. lines which are not straight we
classify as zigzag or curved. We now recognize three kinds
by the differences of each from the others, and the lihenesses
of those in each gronp to each other.
Now for something more subtle: a line has direction, bnt
no dimensions. This is a recognition of differences. As
soon as we imagine breadth or thickness of a line, we recognize that we can divide such breadth or thickness, and still
preserve the line — ,that consequently breadth and thickness
are different from the line; and we can cut these different
things in two endlessly, and still retain something which is
different from the line: we cannot reach the line until we
imagine the something which differs from it all split away.
Let us take a little course of thought less abstract than
our recent mathematical one. First recognize that the whole
material of mental action consists of thoughts and things.
Each of these two sets, the mind groups because of their
likeness, and separates the two sets because of their unlike*
ness. Then follow down "things*' (as the simpler group)
by new recognitions of likeness and difference into animal,
vegetable, and mineral; then follow down animals, still by
recognitions of likeness and difference, into mammals, birds,
reptiles, fishes, and articulates; then mammals, still by
recognitions of likeness and difference, into any of the wellknown classifications, and you will recognize how the whole
vast department of thought called Natural History, has grown
up by recognition of likeness and difference, from (if you will
fix a provisional point) the early recognition by eater and
eaten of a difference between them.
Similarly, simply by classifications of likenesses and
differences, you can roughly trace the growth of any other
department of knowledge, or thought, or even emotion, from
mathematics or chemistry up to poetry or the most ethereal
charms of sex.
Take a fair approximation to all the material of language,
say Bogefs Thesaurus. You will find but classified lists of
CIl III]
Thought and Language
4S
words according to their likenesses, which face opposing lists
of differing words which are also classified according to their
likenesses. Now all these words represent thoughts and shades
of thought that have been CTolved by the discovery or evolu*
tion of newer and finer shades of likeness or difference.
And in fact, without going to all this trouble, you might,
perhaps, seize the gist of the whole matter by reflecting a
little on the fact that a definition, if a good one, is very apt
to state what a thing or a thought is, and then what it is not
Now by similarly rejecting one thing as unlike, and accepting another as like, the world has gradually built up all its
thinking. Some very good illlustrations are in Fiske's Cosmic
Philosophy.
Great efforts have been made, even by men among the
first to declare that ''there are no hard-and-fast lines in
Nature,',
to man
split and
off beast
mental evolution by a hard-and-fast
line
between
Thinkers have long found it comfortable to call a consciousnes ofsensation a percept, and the mental association
of two or more percepts, a concept Some affect to find the
hard and fast line in concepts, declaring that there is no concept that is not embodied in a word, and that as beasts have
no words, they can have no concepts. Some try to draw the
line at instincts.
All the time I care to spend over these discussions is to
state their existence, and to state that many beasts have
concepts and have words too, and to depend for readers upon
people that recognize that they have. The concepts of the
creatures below man are rudimentary, and so is their language. But if they do not possess both concepts and language,
such as they are, and with them arts and sciences and even
philosophies, such as they are, evolution covers less ground
and covers it in a more halting way, and is, on the whole,
a cheaper conception, than it appears to me. There are
minds fond of trying to discover where things start. Apparently wider minds go beyond any conception that they
started at all, and hold that any point for beginning their
treatment is, like all classifications, merely a question of convenience, and often a very difficult and profound one.
44
Bhetch of Human Evolution
[6k. I
(c) The Emotions and the WUl
The evolution of the emotions is inextricably contemporaneous with that of the perceptions and the intelligence,
and necessarily has been somewhat anticipated in what has
already been said.
For purposes of discussion, the best point to assume for
their start is probably, as with the thoughts, the first reaction.
As all mind is built up of simple recognitions of likeness
and difference, so all emotion is built up of likes and dislikes.
The complexities of both are merdy the complexities of their
objects.
Probably amoebfle hate being i)oked or chilled, as wiser
people do, only in greater degree. A time comes when the
sensation of contact with a smooth surface turns into the
very different sense of contact with a needle's point — ,where
mere sense of contact expands into sense of pain ; and a time
comes where sense of contact also expands into sense of
pleasure.
With the earliest sensations of touch or density or temperature or light, must come feelings of like or dislike: for,
as easily tested in the laboratory, very early creatures show
iheir preferences between heat and cold, and light and darkness, and even between different-colored lights. light and
heat and good-to-eat have a common quality which is felt
many generations before it gets the name agreeable, and the
Converse is true of dark and cold and inedible. In time,
to the good-to-eat class is added the quality sapid and other
details constituting ,ooe,-to-eat; and if the creature during
this ,Uhinking'* had language, he would be capable of a
remark quite up to the intellectual small-change of ball-rooms,
in : / float into pleasant bright warm places and find there soft
things good to eat.
These emotions of like and dislike, this sense of agreeable
and disagreeable, are the germs of confidence and fear, love
and hate, worship and exorcism, praying and cursing — of the
emotions of Job, Cleopatra, Paracelsus, and Hildebrand.
Just where, in the ascending scale of being, inclination,
disinclination, purpose, come in, cannot be determined. The
lowest creatures give evidence of hardly anything more than
Ch. Ill]
Likes and Dislikes
4S
such reactions as take place in inorganic matter. The worm
and the moequito, however, seem to have something like a
definite idea where they are goings and what they are going
for. Professor Holmes makes a veiy just remark to the
effect that though a contact reaction by an amoeba's pseudopod
differs very materially from one by the heels of a mule, the
two have an element in common. That element is self-determination, proverbially prominent in the mule, but only a
foreshadowing in the amoeba. But even there, it is interesting
in many ways. It is the germ of an independent soul. As
we have said, the bodjr's production and nutrition are largely
independent of any symptom of its volition — ,are largely dependent on '' God/' meaning by that venerable term at least
all the power we know which is not subject to animal volition
— even to the extent Kipling goes in " McAndrews's Hymn.''
But the contraction and restoration of the protoplasm, while
we call it involuntary, nevertheless has an element out of
proportion to any outside force, and with a germ of independence which later evolves into self-control or voluntary
action. It is individual — ,betokens an individuality, and lies
away back of Descartes' ', Cogito, ergo sum."
With like and dislike, comes in preference ; and with preference, will, purpose, and behavior. Distinct purpose seems to
oome in later than the amoebae and protozoa generally. The
restless wandering about of the earliest forms capable of real
activity serves to throw them in the way of whatever food
is within reach, but it is apparently unconscious.
Professor Holmes says, however (op. cit, pp. 64-65) :
, Instinct, memory, fear, and a certain degree of intelligence
are among the poychic endowments with which Binet credits
the protozoa. A good sample of his interpretation of protozoan
behavior is the following: ,The Bodo caudatus is a roracious
Flagellate possessed of extraordinary audacity; it combines in
troops to attack animalculs one hundred times as large as
itself, as the Colpods, for instance, which are veritable giants
when placed alongside of the Bodo. Like a horse attacked by
a pack of wolves, the Oolpod is soon rendered powerless;
twenty, thirty, forty Bodos throw themselves upon him, eviscerate and devour him completely (Stein).
'''All these facts are of primaiy importance and interest,
but it is plain that their inteipretation presents difficulties.
46
Sketch of Human Evolviion
[Bk. I
It may be asked whether the Bodos combine designedly in
groups of ten or twenty, understanding that they are more
powerful when united than when divided. But it is more
probable that voluntaiy combinations for purposes of attack
do not take place among these organisms; that would be to
grant them a high mental capacity. We may more readily
admit that the meeting of a number of Bodos happens by
chance; when one of them begins an attack upon a Colpod,
the other animalculsd lurking in the vicinity dash into the
combat to profit by a favorable opportunity.'
''More recent investigations have shown that the behavior
of protozoa gives no evidence of the high psychic development
assimied by Binet. There has been a strong tendency on the
part of certain investigators to explain the behavior of these
low forms as due in large measure to comparatively simple
physical and chemical factors. Others contend that the phe*
nomena are much more complex and at present defy analysis
into physical and chemical processes, while a few go further
and maintain that we must assume some super-physical agency,
a vital principle, or entelechy of some sort, to explain the
results."
Let us now look at some of the indications of the dawn
of other qualities, and I will venture on some suggestions
more serious than at first they may seem, of the lines of
evolution they point to.
As we search the examples which Professor Holmes has
collected, we seem to get within sight of the first prodigal,
the first conservative, the first radical, the first coquette, and
the first of many other types.
The first prodigal perhaps we find in Nereis, who loves
narrow places, and to whom sunlight is death. Yet give
him some nice little glass tubes in sunlight, and he will
crawl into them and stay there and die for it. Earwigs are
very similarly constituted : they don't thrive in light, and do
like crevices — so much that they will leave an open space
in shadow, and crawl under a glass plate, though it exposes
**
light.
full
to
them
And where does fear begin? In creatures who similarly
early avoid everything new? Are these the first conservatives?
Or are they the first of the skeptics? Probably both: it's not
inconceivable that long ago some amoeba split into parts,
one of which was the ancestor of lions and the other of
lambs. That is: it would not be inconceivable if the cross
CL III]
PnmUive Conduct
47
pairing on the way down did not make bo many remote beings,
ancestors of each present being.
Where does the monkey's (and our) imitatiyeness begin?
Soon after creatures show any reaction to light, some are
apt to follow, so far as they can, objects or shadows which
cross their range of vision.
Euglena viridis has a red eye spot, but not at the end that
goes first. It seeks soft light and follows it, but avoids strong
light. Many protozoa show the same reaction, and others its
reverse. Perhaps coquettishness starts in some of those which
(or who?) love the light but swim toward it backwards.
Higher organisms — larval lobsters for instance, do the same
thing. Fiddler crabs take it perhaps more coquettishly still —
sideways.
Among the amcebse we find a suggestion of the first drama.
Holmes says {op. cit, p. 69) :
*, Amoeba, like higher animals, may follow its food. Jennings
describes an Amoeba attempting to engulf a spherical cyst of
Euglena. As the Amoeba came in contact with it the cyst
rolled away; the Amoeba followed; the cyst continued to be
pushed ahead, now one way and now another, and the Amoeba
changed its course accordingly. After the cyst had been
roUed against an obstacle and the Amoeba was about to succeed in capturing it, a luge inf usorian appeared on the scene
and swept it away."
When we come to the question of the origin of Ethics,
we find the biologists constantly speaking of the ''be«
havior " of primitive organisms. The word implies standards
of conduct, and where there's a standard of conduct, there's
ethics, though the standard may be no higher than ', what is
usual"; and in that sense, the physicists and chemists and
geologists apply the word ,'behavior" to inanimate matter.
But is not ,, the usual thing '' also a standard — ,too much of
a standard, in high society?
The right search for happiness, and avoidance of unhappiness, are the fundamental causes of development; and the
wrong searches, of destruction. Ethics begin in self-preservation: that's a duty: and many steps up in insects, we see
the start of altruism, in helping the preservation of others —
48
Sketch of Human Evolution
[Bk. I
helping each other out of scrapes, and co-operation in
various enterprises.
Nobody can draw a line between the self-consenring reflexes of the most primitive creatures, and the poet's fine
frenzy or the policies of popes and emperors. The genealogy
of Napoleon has not been traced back to the myriad drops
of protoplasm which marked one stage of his evolution, and
still less has it to the transition from inorganic matter to
organic matter which probably was a stage in the evolution
of the protoplasm. But beginning with the drops of mercury
and chloroform that we considered in Chapter II, a set of
specimens from them to Napoleon could be arranged with
much more gradual differences than those in Marsh's line,
in the Tale Museum, of horses, from the little five-toe up
to Dexter, or in his famous ', infant class'' from monkey
to man. Of course with our present knowledge, there would
not be a strict hereditary line along the series, but the series
could be made to look as if there were; and as knowledge
advances, an actual line can be more and more approzimated
It may be interesting to dwell a moment on the evolution
most involving emotions and ethics — that of sex. It be*
gan, as it persists, in division of the personality. The cell
of amoeba gradually divides itself into two; and the latest
great romancer makes his hero, the morning after his union
with his beloved, ask himself : ,* Am I two ? " Through all
evolution, the mere physical reproduction has consisted of
the parent organism giving up part of itself; and when the
emotional stage becomes pronounced, the male and the female
begin to give up, not only their tissue, but their rest and
comfort, for each other and for the child. The evolution
of monogamy seems, in a rough way, to accompany the
evolution of beauty, intelligence, and character: among the
leaders in these respects, in the lower creatures, as well as
in mankind, monogamy is most frequently found; the most
noticeable instances being the birds generally, in their pairing
season, and the swans for life; and the lions till the cubs
are reared, and in some instances, it is believed, longer.
With the ants and the bees, the overgrown intelligence
Ch. Ill]
Monogamy a Test of Progress
49
aeems to have Bhut love out of the general experience, and
evolved polyandry with a vengeance.
With mankind, the prevalence of monogamy is the most
distinct test of progress, not only as a characteristic of na*
tions, but even of social sets. At the two extremes of life, *
among those debased by low nutrition and impoverished sen«
sation, and among those at the other extreme, debased by
excess of nutrition and sensation, monogamy languishes*
Where bodies are healthiest, sensations and habits nearest
normal, intelligence broadest, morals highest, and sensibilities
keenest and most catholic, love in its whole blessed range,
from parents to each other and to offspring, is deepest and
most enduring ; there monogamy has been the chief cause of
the peculiar evolution, and is itself most thoroughly evolved;
and the family, as the foundation for the development of the
individual and the state, is nearest intact. This development
simply means the enlargement of the Cosmic Belations.
Thus we have marked a few of the steps from the lowest
manifestations to the highest, of the soul which reacts with
the universe. Now let us tium our taper light upon a few
fragmentary aspects nearest related to our purpose, of the
universe.
CHAPTEB
IV
BYOLUTIOK OF THB UNIYEBSB
As comprehensiye a word as tiniyerse is sure to be used
in many senses. When I write here of the evolution of the
nniversey I do not mean the cosmogony — the process that
we generally assume to have begun when our bunch of
the star dust began gravitating toward centers, and which
has prepared the apparatus through which the Cause now
manifests the objective half of the phenomena appreciable
to-day. I mean the evolution of the soul's knowledge of
these phenomena. Here again classification is arbitrary. The
senses, intellect, and emotions all three respond to, and work
upon, vibrations 'flowing in from an outside something. In
this relation, it is really not the outside something, but the
vibrations flowing from it, that the soul works upon; and
in this sense, the sensations are the Universe; and it is this
mass of sensations (and the memory of them), that, for the
purposes of this treatise, I mean by the universe.
As a plain matter of fact, what have we in mind as
universe, when we speak of the interactions between the soul
and the universe? Obviously that portion of the totality of
things with which the soul interacts. Each soul then has
its own universe, which is plainly that soul's portion of a
greater universe; but souls of the same general development
have much in common, and, roughly speaking, the knowledge
of phenomena, and deductions from them, which are held
in common by civilized people, is what is generally meant
the term " The Universe.'*
by But
probably the soul reacts with more of the universe
than it is aware of. This, however, need not affect our
reasonings: they will, except by acknowledged inference, relate only to what we know, though it is obvious that if they
do that with fair success, they will probably be correct
regarding the uncertain fringe on the outer edge of what
we know.
50
Ch. IV]
Each Cansciauineas has its own Universe
61
I don't propose to go into the evolntion or the working
laws of the objectiye nniyerae. For those, read Spencer.
The '' nniyersal '' phenomena that have been discovered since
he wrote — the wider range of ware motion and radiation,
follow the " nniyersal '' laws that he indicated, and no genius
has shown ns any new ones since.
And I shall speculate very little regarding the nniyerse
in the sense of the totality of things. What I have read
of such speculations has been mainly nonsense made np of
words which are mere confessions of ignorance, and much
of this nonsense has come from misdirected efforts of abler
minds than mine. I only want to call attention to some
of the Cosmic Relations between nniyerse as we know it,
whateyer its laws, and soni as we know it.
Plainly, as already hinted, the objectiye nniyerse is not
the same to any two people — or any two organisms. Each
organism has its own. The amoeba has its, and Humboldt
has his, and we haye every reason to believe that outside
of the one that anybody has, or those that everybody has,
is still left more universe than our imaginations can in any
way compass. Its spaces range beyond our telescopes, and
even the qualities of the little space we thoughtlessly claim
to know, range far beyond our microscopes and our speculations.
The dimensions and other characteristics of each creature's
imiverse, are of course determined primarily by the sense
organs, and secondarily by the nervous structures which
register, accumulate, and compare the impressions received
by the organs. At one end of our living world is a universe
of only a few elements, or rather the difference between
degrees of one element, — of resistance and non-resistance,
OT of penetrability and impenetrability— of water that the
creature can float through, or of earth or log that it cannot :
or possibly the difference is one of heat and cold — ,water that
is warm, or water that is cold; or of light and dark — ,places
that have a glow, or places that have not. At the other end
are the universes of Newton, Humboldt, Helmholtz, Michelangelo, and Shakspere.
Each individual's universe is evolved with his mind, but
62
Evolution of the Universe
[Bk. I
don'ttheletmind
that and
makethe na,
with some
that
universe
are thephilosophers,
same. More ''believe''
than one
philosopher is deemed to have won a claim to undying fame
by demonstrating that there is a universe external to the mind.
Anybody can find a simpler demonstration than theirs, by
going toward an open door in the dark, with his arms stretched
out parallel to guard against it, and so moving that his arms
will pass on the respective sides of the door, and leave him to
strike it with his face.
Yet, despite such demonstrations, this external universe
seems to be losing its old contracted character of ''matter,"
and becoming simply another mind; but there is not much
question now, even among those given to that questioning of
obvious facts which they call philosophy, that it has an
existence outside of our minds.
We know it only by its phenomena, and they are constantly
in both our minds and the something external. A phenomenon
results only from an interaction between an object and a
perceiving subject We will find reason as we go on, for getting as clear an idea of this as we can. I will attempt a
simple demonstration.
A boy goes into the pantry after a pie. There something
gives him a sight-sensation of a round flat object, and an
odor-sensation of an agreeable something proceeding from
the object. If he pursues his investigation farther, he gets
sensations of touch, of sound, as he cuts or breaks the pie,
and then happily of taste. AH he knows of the pie is these
sensations. They constitute the complex phenomenon — ,pie.
They are, so far as concerns him (or us), the pie, and without
them, there would be, at least for him and us, no pie. Some
philosophers go so far as to say that there would be no pie
at all — that the pie exists only when, and as, somebody experiences these sensations. If they are right, the conclusion
is a saddening one for the boy: for if he went away leaving
half of the pie, there could be no half for him to come back
to. The truth is that while he is away, there do not remain
in the pantry any of the sensations which we call pie, but
something remains which, when he comes back, can again
arouse the sensations we agreed to call pie; and the happy
Ck lY]
Bealism and Idealism
53
fact that that something remainB, proves that there is a
nniyerse outside of the mind.
On the other hand, if a log of wood be shoved into the
room, but no boy, there are still in the room none of the
sensations which we agree to call pie. To arouse those sensations, the bit of the objective universe still there must be
visited by a bit of the subjective universe. The boy comes
in with that bit of the subjective universe eagerly acting in
his brain and on his salivary glands, and again are created
the sensations we call pie.
The bearing of this disquisition on pie (a subject for which
I have an Emersonian fondness) upon the wider questions of
our Cosmic Belations, will be more obvious as your patience
holds out
I shall never forget my feeling when the extreme idealistic
theory was first presented to me. As a boy I had just returned from my first trip to the Adirondacks. Probably
not three hundred people a year went into those mountains
then, and probably not three hundred lived in them. The
impressions left in my mind were nearly all of glorious
solitudes where I had been alone watching the runways of
the deer. The memory of those solitudes, and the hope of
being again amid them, were very precious to me. When
I first was indoctrinated with the theory that the external
universe has no existence except as seen by an intelligent
mind, I said to myself: As, then, no one sees those lakes
and mountains now, they no longer exist — they are not there.
The feeling was horrible. Even under the happy inspirations
the lakes and mountains had brought, there always had been
a heavy oppressive undertone of loneliness, which the recollection of them revived; and it had not been free from
some of the sense of terror of the supernatural fostered in
those superstitious days. But this suggestion that those
beautiful yet awful solitudes had disappeared when we disappeared, had in it something more eerie and terrible than
could come to a boy from the cry of loon or owl or panther,
or even from the silence and the loneliness that, in occasional moments of perverse imaginings, became more dreadful
still.
Against the unholy magic suggested by the doctrine, the
64
Evolution of th$ Universe
[Bk. I
boy's reason made little headway, and the philosophic difficulty did not take its place among clearly settled things
until; to the old man musing on the boy's perplexities, came
the suggestion of the pie, which, very wrongly, seems not
to have
occupieddid.
as large a space in the boy's horizon as
the
Adirondacks
CHAPTEB
THS EHOWN
V
UNIVERSE AND THE UNKNOWN
XJNITEB8B
Ths Adirondacks existed after I left them, and before I
saw them : so the whole universe visible to ns must have existed essentially the same as now, though different in some
details, before there was an eye to see it ; and it has been slowly,
slowly revealing itself to us as eyes have been evolved, and
seems to have been evolving eyes for that express purpose.
Let us imagine ourselves living in darkness relieved at
times by just enough suggestion of light to make the darkness
more visible, with no more sense of sound than an occasional
vibration somewhere in our interior economy; about the
same satisfaction from food and drink as has the patient
who is nourished by anointing his surface with an odorless
oil, and with no sensations beyond these, except a faint consciousness ofcontact with objects, and support from earth
or water. Such experiences constituted the universe of most
of our ancestors, and still constitute that of most of our
contemporaries.
Next assume a distinct sense of shadow between the rudimentary eye and the source of light. What an immense
resource this is— in seeking food and avoiding danger, not
to speak of variety of life and of pleasure, as compared with
the creature who has only the sense of touch I How immensely larger and more interesting is the universe of the
later creature! To get some realization of this, recall even
your own feeling at some time over the mere simple experience oflight after darkness, and yet you have so many
more complex feelings, that this one appears by contrast
insignificant.
Very early comes in a sense of different kinds of light —
of color. Think of the contrast between engravings and oilpaintings. Imagine the landscape of the moon-lit night
shifting to that of noon. But even in the senses of sight
65
66
The Known Universe and the Unknown
[Bk. I
alone, not to speak of other senfies, this is but the beginning.
With each sense evolved, a new nniverse is known.
And now, for contrast (for which, through all my tedious
exposition I have had a motive that will appear later), let us
jump to the universe of to-day as I see it at this moment.
As I look North, between the beautiful pillars of a Doric
summer-house, two immense pines, light green with dark
shadows, are in the panel at the left, soughing in the summer
breeze. A mass of lower foliage is this side of them, conspicuously agreat round laburnum, above and beyond which
a narrow sharp arbor-vitse shoots up, in lighter green against
the darker pines. Above all, blue sky with white douds. I
would like to have it all painted. At the right are two
more panels, of lawn and distant wood, with my distant neighbor's beautiful buildings with their peaked turrets, brownstone
against the green, and then in another panel, where I could
toss my pencil, rises a pretty little spruce, on whose spire a
pretty little bird has been chattering at me a pretty little song
nearly all the time I have been writing, and the pines have
soughed their accompaniment Then at the left of all I have
described, as I now look West, comes the massive square comer
pillar of the summer-house, and next it a fluted Doric column.
They shut out the left edge of the left pine ; and on their other
side opens a picture of absolutely different character, whose
limit is, instead of a hundred feet, some sixty miles. The
lower quarter of the panel is foreground — ,my hill sloping
rapidly in light green to where the men witti horses, bay
against the green, are turning the pretty cow-pond among
the trees into a swimming-hole for my young people — ,and
their mother and me; then, above in the perspective, a field
of buckwheat still green, then one of yellow stubble from
the oats just cut. In the perspective, these fields appear almost wooded with small locusts along some roads, and a few
great maples and pines; then my woods — so beautiful, the
rolling light green deciduous trees making the jagged pines
shooting up here and there in front and above, look almost
black. Beyond, over the woods, stretches the pearly surface of
Lake Ghamplain, with long faint blue lines of current At
the right, just above the trees, a low dark green island,
Cb. Y]
Protozoan and Human Universes Contrasted
67
with a white lighthoofle and keeper's home, reaches across
about a quarter of the picture. A little higher in the perspectiye, touching the left edge, is a smaller island. Beyond,
far off, comes the other side of the lake in what the foreshortening makes a virtually straight line across the picture ;
and above it rise in faint misty blue, fold upon fold, miles
upon miles until we come to rounded and peaked summits,
the Adirondacks. Above them, white clouds with bluish gray
shadows, the upper edges broken with the dark blue of a
dear sky. One more panel between the pillars, to the left,
is a beautiful variant of the one I have just described.
Where I turn South, there rise from the plain two of
those picturesque mountains of tilted strata that slope on one
dde and are precipitous on the other; and as I turn farther
to the East I come to the Oreen Mountains — ,first, the
beautiful reposeful gently-three-peaked Lincoln; next, the
unsurpassed gracefulness of the Couching Lion, not the
biggest mountain I know, but the one with the most uplift;
then after a few lower summits to (though fast becoming
shut-out by growing trees) Mansfield, with an outline that
seems really ingeniously bulky, sometimes looks bigger than
the Jungf rau, and yet in winter, in that strange green twilight
that now and then comes over the snow, makes one think
of fairies.
Now contrast these lovely things open to my eyes and ears,
with our ancestor's universe of darkness and silence. Then
suppose that he had varied the monotony of his existence by
splitting himself into a family, and contrast his experience
of it with mine if my little daughter should happen to get
off her pony and be chased down here by my six-foot boys.
To emphasize once more the emotional contrast (for all
of the contrasts, a reason will appear presently) : this beauti*
fnl universe, of which I have tried to give you some faint
notion, is mine — ,mine — ,mine, even the miles and miles of
mountains are as much mine to all significant intents, as if
I owned them in fee simple. Compare this joy with the
protozoon's right, title, and interest in his puddle. And then
with all he can do, compare my privilege of making roads to
all this loveliness, which was not accessible before, and leav*
ing my gate open to all who care to come.
58
The Known Universe and the Unknown
[Bk. I
Then think of the joy of doing, however badly, what amid
all this, I am trying to do with my pencil (among my joys
I prize that of not writing with a pen), which has nothing
in the primitive universe even to contrast with it
Then reflect that the scene before me is but a small part of
the universe open to-day — Niagara and the Orand Canyon
and the Yosemite and the wonderful Pacific coast, and the
Canadian Sockies, and the Alps, the Mediterranean, the
Himalayas — ,the whole wonderful world, and the ocean and
the night. Then the great architecture and sculpture and
pictures; beautiful men and women; the drama — spoken and
danced and sung; and Liszt's Preludes and the Pilgerchor
and Beethoven's last quartets. Then, on the more intellectual
side, the great books, long talks with great people, and with
others who, like not a few of the great ones, are better
than great.
Beflect that beyond the joy of contemplating our universe,
men have had the higher joy of creating no little of it— all
the art and thought and love. Nature supplied the material
and gave the hints, but the production was our own.
So I might go on for many pages more, describing the
universe of the modern man, and contrasting it with the
universe of the primitive animal; but perhaps I have taxed
your patience even more than my purpose requires.
And now for my purpose in trying to awaken some feeling
of the contrast It is to impress that, as our universe has been
a gradual revelation, up step by step from the protozoon's, ours
is presumably only a part of one as much beyond ours, as ours
is beyond the protozoon's. The amphioxus must have vague
feelings of something beyond what it can sense; and far
more certainly do we. As the early creatures must have in
their sight, faint presages of what we call color, or in their
hearing faint presages of what we call timbre, we certainly
have presages far wider. Are we not constantly feeling fore*
tastes of — we know not what, except that it seems high and
good?
There was certainly something prophetic, though not nee*
essarily prophetic of my personal experience, in the exaltation
brought me before sunrise this morning in the pearl-gray
Ch. Y]
Enjoyment of Nature.
Compeneation
59
sky holding one throbbing planet over dark Mount Mansfield
— there was something beyond my eyes, as surely as there
was beyond those of the tadpole in my pond.
After I saw this, I found ** something beyond ,' in another
sense, but still in the same sense. I could not sleep, and
80 I wrote what happened. The dawn, which is seldom
reported in words or pictures, is, other things even, more
interesting than the sunset — certainly more cheering, as coming light is more cheering than coming darkness. But there
is a difference in the other direction too, as the night is poetry,
and the daylight prose.
As I watch, above the mountains the gray turns to yellow;
the yellow to pink, the blue higher up growing more intense,
and the mountains growing blue with it; and then the blue
far up in the sky gradually comes down and absorbs the
lighter colors.
Across the wide valley below the deep blue mountains, the
black trees rise here and there above the mists. The mists
spread over the swamps and the lines of streams.
The cattle in the pastures begin lowing, and the dog barks,
as he herds them for their milking.
Now the mists have grown so that, beyond the low foothills,
they make, over the Winooski Siver, a gray line against the
great blue mountains. This side of the- foothills, in the
fields, the light greens and yellows of different crops begin
to show — all offset by gray in the pastures, and by the
nearer mists with the black trees jutting from them.
The sky over the mountains is very light now, but shades
fast into the dark blue of the ssenith. The planet has climbed
far up into that, and is still bright there.
The scene began to take on its everyday look before the
sun came. I did not wait for him, but went to bed.
3nt how richly I had been compensated for a restless
night, and even for the mischief it is going to raise in an
exacting day! And I must illustrate one of the truths for
the sake of which I am writing this book, by saying that
much as the slight infirmity which causes me restless nights
and early wakings, has eaten into working power — ,much even
as it may eat into the fag-end of old age, I have, in ways
similar to last night's, and in many widdy different ways.
60
The Known Universe and the Unknown
[Bk. I
beeii richly paid. He is a wise man who knows onerringly
what to call a misfortune.
But to return to our demonstration. In the first place,
the difference between the tadpole's sight and mine having
come by a slow evolution, is there any reason whatever to
believe that the evolution is finished at just the colors my
sight responds to now? There are plenty of existing eyes
otherwise normal that do not respond to all the colors to
which most eyes already do: even to-day some people see
only brown where others see red or green, and a daylight
landscape appears to them only much as an extra-bright
moonlight one. Still such defective eyes do respond better
than, probably within historic times, eyes in general did.
This point has had a very interesting but, as we shall see,
somewhat questionable treatment by Dr. Bucke {Cosmic Con*
sciousness: Philadelphia, 1901 and 1905). He first quotes on
p. 28, Max Miiller {Science of Thought, I, 229) :
, It is well known that the distinction of color is of late date;
that Xenophanes knew of three colors of the rainbow only —
purple, red, and yellow; that even Aristotle spoke of the tricolored rainbow; and that Democritus knew of no more than
four colors — ,black, white, red, and yellow.''
Then Dr. Bucke goes on to say:
, Geig,er {Contributions to the History of the Development of
the Human Race. Translated by David Asher, London, 1880|
p. 48) points out that it can be proved by examination of Iangu&ge tliat as late in the life of the race as the time of the primitive Aryans, perhaps not more than fifteen or twenty thousand
years ago, man was only conscious of, only perceived, one color.
That is to say, he did not distinguish any difference in tint between the blue sky, the green trees and grass, the brown or gray
earth, and the golden and purple clouds of sunrise and sunset.
8o Pictet (Lee Origines Indo-Europeennes, Paris, 1877, 11) finds
no names of colors in primitive Indo-European speech. And
Max Miiller {op. cit, U, 616) finds no Sanskrit root whose meaning has any reference to color."
Then Dr. Bucke continues, without specific references :
', At a later period, but still before the time of the oldest literary compositions now extant, the color sense was so far developed beyond this primitive condition that red and black were
Ch. Y]
Evolution of Sight
61
veoognised as distinct Still later, at the time when the bulk of
the Big Veda was composed, red, ydlow, and bla, were recognised as three separate shades, but these three included all color
that man at that age was capable of appreciating. Still later
white was added to the list and then green; but throughout tiie
Big Veda, the Zend Aresta, the Homeric poems, and the Bible
the color of the sky is not once mentioned, ther,ore, apparently,
was not recognized. For the omission can hardly be attributed
to accident; the ten thousand lines of the Big Veda are largely
occupied with descriptions of the sky; and all its features — sun,
moon, stars, clouds, lightning, sunrise, and sunset — are mentioned hundreds of times. So also the Zend Avesta, to the
writers of which light and fire, both terrestrial and heavenly,
are sacred objects, could hardly hare omitted by chance all
mention of the blue sky. In the Bible the sky and heaven are
mentioned more than four hundred and thirty times, and still
no mention is made of the color of the former. In no part of the
world is the blue of the sky more intense than in Greece and
Asia Minor, where the Homeric poems were composed. Is it
possible to conceive that a poet (or the poets) who saw this as
we see it now could write the forty-eight long books of the
Biad and Odyssey and never once either mention or refer to it!
But were it possible to believe that all the poets of the Big Veda»
Zend Avesta, Biad, Odyssey, and Bible could have omitted the
mention of the blue color of the sky by mere accident, etymology
would step in and assure us that four thousand years ago, or,
perhaps, three, blue was unknown, for at that time the subsequent names for blue were all merged in ,e names for black.
'' The English word blue and the Qerman hlau descend from
a word that meant black. The Chinese ht,-an, which now
means sky-blue, formerly meant black. The word nil, which now
in Persian and Arabic means blue, is derived from the name
Nile, that is, the hlaeh river, of which same word the Latin
Niger is a form.''
Homer certainly had a word for blue, though he may not
have applied it to the sky.
This last statement — ,that I ever got transformed into g —
makes me prick up my ears, but perhaps it would not if I
kniew more; and we need not let it fatally affect the whole
paragraph, or the statements (op. cit, 30, 31) :
** As the sensations red and black came into existence by the
division of an original unital color sensation, so in process of
time tliese divided. First red divided into red-yellow, then that
red into red-white. Black divided into black-green, then black
again into black-blue, and during the last twenty-five hundred
years these six (or rather these four — ,red, yellow, green, blue)
62
The Known Universe and fhe Unknown
[BL I
have split up into the enonnoTU number of shades of color which
are now recognised and named.
',The power of exciting vision of the red rays is several
thousand times as great as the energy of the violet, and there is
a regular and rapid decrease of energy as we pass down the
spectrum from red to violet It is plain that if there has been
such a thing as a growing perfection in the sense of vision in
virtue of which, from being insensible to color the eye became
gradually sensible of it, red would necessarily be the first color
perceived, then yeUow, then green, and so on to violet; and this
is exactly what both ancient literature and etymology tell us
took place."
But in the face of all this pretty demonstration and these
great authorities, stand the facts that the Egyptians used
color very well four or five thousand years before Christ, and
that the people in the Dordogne caves used it as much, prob«
ably, as twenty thousand years before. Moreover, recent
savages in a state presumably far behind that of the peoples
whose writings are quoted by Dr. Bucke and his authorities,
use many colors, and often with skill that puts civilized man
to his trumps. Among them, however, we should be slow to
put our wampum-making Indians : for they used the colored
beads which we gave them. But we found them with their
senses far enough evolved to appreciate those beads, as good
.William Penn knew to his profit.
Yet although Dr. Bucke may claim too much, what he
gives us is interesting and suggestive and in the general line
of evolution; and as we go on, we shall meet growing reason
to look for truth on both sides in most conflicts between
theories, and even between theories and facts.
It is an interesting question whether the eye as we
know it, is to be farther differentiated to report more colors,
or whether we must depend for farther knowledge of the
invisible ends of the spectrum, upon instruments of our
own devising. Somehow phenomena for which we have to
depend on instruments, do not seem as really parts of our
very own universe, as phenomena reported directly by our
senses. It seems more in accord with the beneficence so
prominent throughout previous evolution, that our senses
shall be expanded. Yet on the other hand, while that would
be more joy, it would not exercise our new and ineffably
Cai. Y]
SenseB sKll Evolving
68
▼aluable power of inyenting iiiBtnunents and hypotheses, and
finding laws for ourselves.
As with the eye, so with the ear. Is it going to stop
at ten octaves, when even some insects appear to hear higher
tones than we can, and the whale lower?
So with the other senses. All are of conrse, like sight and
hearing, the products of an evolution in response to the environment. Almost equally of course, then, they are yet but
small parts of a possible-— even probable development
In dreams, when separated from the activities of the body,
consciousness approaches such experience of new faculties—
the surmounting of time and space and gravitation; and we
cannot declare it impossible that consciousness separated altogether from the body should have such experiences, even to
a degree compared with which the difference between a
creature with one sense and a creature with six senses, is
trifling.
Men now living have seen striking evidence that such
development is going on. Some very competent observers
think they are now watching the most tremendous of all
evolutions yet known in the faculties themselves, of wbich
more later.
As with the faculties, so, as already intimated, with the
universe. As nearly all the universe we know is outside the
protozoon's, are not the indications virtually conclusive that,
outside of the one we know, there is more, bearing to ours
a ratio greater than ours bears to the protozoon's? What
reason have we to believe that all the universe revealable
to a possible sense of sight, is revealed to ours? We have
excellent reason to believe that it is not By photography and
the Boentgen apparatus, we can now find at the ends of the
spectrum, rays from which our eyes as yet get no direct
sensation whatever. Instruments show us longer and shorter,
and slower and quicker vibrations than those of which our
senses take direct cognizance. And even between the two
extremes that we do cognize, there seem to be gaps that we do
not This amounts to an almost mathematical reinforcement
of the demonstration already given — tiiat the sensizable universe, with its bounteous gifts to the intellect and the emo-
64
The Known Universe and the Unknown
[Bk. I
tions, with the numberless avenues for exploration that it
offers the adventurous soul, and with the numberless new
gifts it undoubtedly holds at the ends of those avenues, is,
after all, but a mere foretaste of a universe waiting for the
enjoyment of eyes evolved beyond ours, and containing intellectual and emotional exaltations that our blind gropings
even now touch without understanding.
Truths similar to those iUustrated regarding the visible
universe, must hold even more strongly regarding the audible
universe, because music is far the youngest of the arts: it
has no masterpiece two hundred years old, while all the other
arts have masterpieces over two thousand.
And yet are degrees between fragments so small in comparison with the probable wholes, worth considering? The
phraseology, however, assumes that the wholes are open to
human conception — a weakness haunting the phraseology of
philosophic speculation.
The evidence, then, seems conclusive from the evolution
of the recognized faculties, not to speak of the vague new
ones now the objects of so much research, that in proportion
to our senses, we know virtually as little of the universe around
us, as, in proportion to his senses, does the jelly-fish floating
in the dancing sunlit water among the yachts and the bathers,
and touching the loveliest of them with the same sensation
as if she were a floating log.
And yet the myriad particulars, objective and subjective,
which make our universe so different from the jelly-fish%
would probably, when compared with the whole universe (so
far as our minds can grasp the idea of a ,, whole '' universe)
show a ratio smaller than does the jelly-fish's universe when
compared with ours.
In a word, evolution has demonstrated the existence of a
Heaven, and instead of being up above us (which meant
something before Copernicus and Newton) it is all around
us and in us, only waiting for faculty to recognize it Nay,
we have been living in it all the time. If to the Heaven I
tried to describe from my summer-house and my east window,
could be added reunion with those I have lost, and gratification of divine curiosities just fast enough to prevent dulling
them, I, for one, don't want any better Heaven.
GIl V]
Senses Reveal bid Parts of BeaiUy
65
Or from another point of yiew, did human imagination
ever devise an entrance into Heayen, to be compared with
the experience of a person bom blind, suddenly restored to
sight in presence of a beautiful landscape, or better still, of
a beautiful and beloyed person? Yet experiences of the
same nature, but immeasurably greater, cannot be held impossible to a creature without a sense, or with only one,
or two, or fiye, or any number. Whatever the number, we
cannot conceive the impossibility of another sense being added
to the organism, or another field of response existing in the
objective universe.
But while the universe of the higher organism is a heaven
compared with the universe of the lower organism, it is not
generally appreciated as such: for in only exceptional cases
has it had the benefit of the immediate contrast between blindness and sight, or deafness and hearing.
However, each appearance has been only an appearance — a
quality : the , thing in itself , is unknown to us, and apparently must remain unknown to us, except so far as its
phenomena are revealed. Put yourself on Lake Champlain or
one of the few lakes to compare with it, or in the Yosemite,
or by the Orand Canyon, or at Zermatt, realize that the
immeasurable source of strong, beautiful, beneficent (is it too
much to say benevolent?) Power, is revealing itself in you in
the vibrations entering your eyes; regard the scene as simply
a lovely aspect of an infinite source of loveliness partially revealing itself to you, and probably to reveal to our descendants
immeasurably more of itself in ways that beggar our imagination; or go and listen to great music, and realize it as a
revelation, through the composer, of the same Power;
saturate your soul with such revelations, and then, that
you may appreciate them all the better, contrast them with
the gross and fantastic and often hideous pictures with
which, under the name of revelations, barbarous priests
have imposed the awful power of mystery on barbarous
peoples.
But the powers of mystery are lovely as well as awful.
The mists and mountains and dark shadows opposite me as
I write, are both. I do not read their meaning, as I read
the meaning of a' + ,,,, + ,S but they lift and expand
66
The Known Universe and the Unhnewn
[Bk. I
and deepen the 8onl as do no meanings that I can read; and
while they raise the most terrible questions, they answer
them with: ** Peacel Wait! Work! Earn (be rest that yon
All will be well!''
feelisinUsI
CHAPTEB
BOMS BTHIOAL
VI
ABPECTS OF EfVOLUTION
With snggestioa of the Beneficence which has been breeding from onr deaf and blind ancestors a progeny that enjoys
the nniverse open to us, comes the question: What need
of the ancestors' being deaf and blind? Perhaps an answer
whose consistency with the fact would not be its sole merit
would be : ** None of your business/'
But really it is no detraction from the Beneficence (or
any other name that yon may see fit to spell with a capital)
doing the evolution, that the evolution did not begin higher
up. We cannot conceive its doing so, any more than we can
really conceive a creation. Just at what point would our
wisdom have the evolution begin, and what reason have we to
believe that it cotdd begin in any other way than it did, or
that the inflow of the Cosmic Soul into us can be attained
in any other way than through just that evolution? The
Power does not seem to have been able to make the universe
perfect, and yet we assume the power to be unlimited — ,whatever that may mean, in spite of all the evidence indicating
that it is not Here comes in the inconsistency that we allege
between an all-wise, all«good, and all-powerful Qod, and the
existence of suffering. What do we know about ', all,'' except
all of some limited thing? The very phrase is part of that
nonsense- jabbering that we always fall into when we use words
greater than our actual conceptions. We merely assume such
a God, despite the facts that we cannot conceive one, and we
never saw any evidence of the existence of one.
We simply see the greatest power we know, but a power
we know to be imperfect, evolving the greatest universe we
know, but a universe we know to be imperfect We have
much reason to believe that we are to see more; but to juggle
with words that imply having seen all, or having seen what
we have not, is to babble idiocy.
67
68
Some Ethical Aspects of Evolution
[Bk. I
All ihis BUggested to Mill a deputy god of inferior powers-*
a queer suggestion for a man of his ability to entertain:
for the need of a deputy arises on, from the principals
limitations : so why not admit them at once, without lugging
in the deputy, or bothering ourselves to reconcile them with
the gratuitous pseud-ideas of an almighty and all-benevolent
cause and regulator of the universe? For our purposes, the
Cause is just powerful enough and just benevolent enough
to produce, so far, the tmiverse as we know it, no more and
no leas; and if we are not satisfied with that amount of
power and benevolence, after we have watched life long
enough to realize the good evolved from its evils, and to
catch glimpses of the possibilities of vastly greater future
good, we are pretty hard to please.
The real indications are of the obvious fact that our powers
of apprehension are not unlimited. We are even so stupid
that we are in the habit of saying that the universe is full
of imperfections and suffering and death, when it is no such
thing: it does contain imperfections, suffering, and death,
but anybody who says it is ''full of, them, simply has
diseased perceptions. The sad facts play a very minor part.
As I write this in my summer-house, the sheep are bleating
as they feed in the sunlight down the hill, sleek and happy.
All summer I've enjoyed watching them enjoy themselves.
During that time half a dozen have been killed by dogs.
There are scores of them left. Shall I say that their universe
is ''full of dogs and death? More of them have been
killed for my table. Am I proved capable of nothing but
ruthless murder?
Despite the misery in the universe, the joy is there, and
immensely preponderant; and we constantly see the misery
working out good.
This is a fact apt to be denied by the inexperienced and
unrefiecting, and realized only as life grows longer and
richer. Yet assertions of it abound in the utterances of
those whose thought is wisest and deepest. For proofs of
it, however, one is generally thrown back on his own ex*
perience: because such proofs are most frequent and con*
vincing in the things locked in each one's own breast. They
Ch. VI]
DdaUed Reach of Natural Law
69
are seldom known to the biographerB, and still more seldom
given b; the antobiographers — ,and when the fundamental
facts are known, their relations are seldom realized. Pions
souls — ,and many souls have been made pious by such experience— often delight in pouring out their convictions of
the beneficence of God in bringing good from evil, but
where their convictions rest on their actual experiences of
real life, and not on mere religious ecstasy, they are naturally slow to expose the experiences to the world, especially as the secrets of others are so often interwoven with
them.
Many must have wondered if it was not a duly to do
violence to their own feelings, and give the world the benefit
of such experience; but if, as an extreme instance, the premature death of someone useful and admirable and loved, has
been demonstrated in the course of many years to have
made possible for the survivors, shifts in the kaleidoscope of
life so good that the lost one would gladly have died to
effect them, to proclaim the particulars might not only expose
to the cold world the tenderest feelings of many survivors,
but might appear an underestimate of the life that is lost,
and a lack of affection for the memory. And yet there is
probably nobody of much experience and reflection, who does
not know of just such instances.
Moreover, in many such cases, the preponderance of good
rests on the assumption that the life is continued beyond: I
do not mean the easy general assumption that the lost one
has entered into a state of bliss beside which the agonies of
illness and death, and the sufferings of survivors, are as
nothing; but I mean a set of very obvious consequences which
would be rational in the extreme if there is a future existence
very much like this one to round them out, while without the
possibility of such consequences in an after Ufe, the present
life often seems like chaos.
And yet even that chaos can often be resolved by bravely
and candidly offsetting life's joys against its sorrows, finding
it as good as it generally is, and aflsuming the peace of
oblivion at the end.
That, however, is not the whole matter : for the educating
influence of suffering in life here, as we know it, is highly
70
Borne Eikical Aspects of Evolution
[BL I
▼alned by the best souls, and its recognition is so general as to
be almost a commonplace.
Yet when one realizes that the uniyerse is governed by
law, it is hard to realize a law comprehensive enough to
reach down into the details of each life, and make its reverses
what the character needs — ,to pick out among all the apparent
jumble of microbes and snakes and tigers and bad machines
and explosions, just the one and at just the time, that each
human being needs it to do him or his survivors good.
Equally hard is it to imagine a law which much oftener
sends the apparent ',accidents'' of happiness in the same
way. And yet some of the wisest of earth very strongly and
deliberately suspect — ,not a few of them hold as a belief
founded on frequent verification, that the Law and the Power
great enough to swing the stars, is also delicate enough to do
just those little things. It has often been found worth while
to search life and conscience closely for the evidences.
Among the things hard to realize a generation ago— and
much harder the generations ago when the litanies were composed, would have been the attitude now growing more general
toward one more hard subject We know now that among
the greatest humbugs ever imposed upon humanity by humanity, or inhumanity, has been the horror of death. As the views
inculcated by the priest for his revenue's sake are gradually
disappearing, we are gradually realizing that death is a muchmaligned institution, and that, except in its apparent incongruities with the useful and hopeful, it has, everything
considered, much to commend it. As evolution is making
life more normal, death becomes more normal — ,nearer a
mere long-awaited and welcome release from weariness and
ennui. Weariness and ennui are inevitable under limited
conditions: the wider the conditions, however, the longer it
takes to get tired of them; but the time must come. The
question tiieref ore is really : Why are our conditions limited ?
and our answer is: Whatever impressions like the worm's
impressions of scenery and music, we may get outside of
time, space, matter, motion, and force, while we are subject
to them, no mortal mind can really conceive of unlimited
conditions. It seems to follow, absurd as it may at first
Ch. VI]
LegiUmacy of BpeculaUan
71
appear, that no mortal mind can oonoeive of conditions nnder
which death must not in time be a blesBing. That now it
flo often comes prematurely as to seem, and probably to
be, a cnrse, is a corollary of imperfect e?olution. But if, in
our erring judgments, we must r,ard it as worse or better
than it is, what have we to gain by regarding it as worse?
There is a rapidly reviving impression that we don't know
much about it anyhow, aud that the little we do know is
the worst there is to know.
Part of the bad is the apparent fact that the universe
beyond our senses must remain unenjoyed by us if death
ends all. This tends to make the faith in such a universe
more tantalizing than inspiring; but as we proceed, we may
find some reasons why it should not be tantalizing.
* We have now been through such a summary as conditions
permit of the reactions between soul and universe covered by
our present knowledge — ,by our recognized faculties on one
side, and such phenomena as we have been able to correlate,
on tiie other.
But it is a plain corollary of evolution that there should
at times appear germs of faculty but faintly and rarely
apprehended, giving rise to phenomena new, strange, doubtfuL In this vague field lie many, perhaps most, of our future
possibilities, and it would be a very chary review of our
cosmic relations that should leave it out, or that even should
refrain from any inferences regarding the unknown that
our faint glimpses of it may legitimately suggest. It is
even true that as the old forms of belief regarding the cause
and fate of the universe and the soul, are nearly all gone,
the old fervors and the old despairs are nearly all gone too;
and with them seem gone nearly all great productive powers
of the spirit; and the world, with its great new mechanical
inventions, is absorbed as never before since Borne fell, in the
luxuries of material things.
The making of inferences regarding the unsensed universe,
notwithstanding their inevitable uncertainty and unverifiA,
bUity, has been, the vast majority think, of great benefit
to mankind : for the universe we do not know is presumably
far more important— possibly even to us in ways dimly sensed
72
Some Ethical A$pecU of Evolution
[BL I
— ,fhan the nniverBe we do know, and fhe vague borderland
between the known and the unlmown ia the field of much
of poetry and the other arts.
Every good strong emotion — and possibly every bad strong
emotion (which mnst be a misapplication or an excess of a
good one) brings the soul to the borders of the unknown-,
to the frame of mind where one is very apt to cry out:
'' God 1 '* and sometimes as apt to cry it out in oath as in
prayer. De Quincey speaks of literature as giving ', exercise
and expansion to your own latent capacity of sympathy with
the infinite, where every pulse and each separate influx is a
step upwards, a step ascending as upon a Jacob's ladder
from earth to mysterious altitudes above the earth.'' This
is at least equally the effect of great music, painting, sculpture, even architecture— of beauty in all its forms, most
perhaps of the great aspects of Nature, including humanity.
Certain it is that without an abiding consciousness that
the known mass of phenomena is not all, and that behind
them is a cause transcending our imaginations, life loses some
of its best emotions, the imagination grows arid, and the
moral impulses shrink. While what we know, and the increasing ofit, can more than occupy all our working powers,
they work all the better for an occasional dream of greater
and less troubled things.
When imaginations of the unknown world have most filled
the consciousness, mankind has done its greatest creative
work. For three thousand years, under both classical mythology and Christianity, the great outpourings of genius sprang
from a consciousness saturated with relationships assumed,
whether truly or falsely, to personal gods and immortal life.
That consciousness built the Qreek temples and the Gothic
cathedrals; it carved the Apollo Belvedere and painted the
Sistine Madonna; it wrote the Iliad and the Inferno and
the Paradise Lost; it composed the masses of Haydn and
Beethoven and the Stabat Mater; and it has done more to
shape the conduct of mankind than all the science, all the
codes, and all the armies: for though it has not shaped
the sciences, it has inspired the codes, and impelled most of
the armies.
These relations to the unknown have often been lost sight
Ch. YI]
Inspiring Interest in (he Unknown
73
of and ignored, but yet 8o generally and persistently have
they been felt that until lately they constituted most of the
atmosphere in which even the skeptic led his moral and
emotional life ; their fervors and their terrors made yirtually
all of man,s existence vibrant: whatever may have been his
speculations, ambitions, lusts, there was no escaping the conBciousness of the mysteries of the universe and the obligations
of the moral law, with all their power to terrify or inspire.
The robber baron built a church, the Sicilian brigand prayed
for the success of his expeditions, and even yet the ** criminal
rich,'' as well as the rich not criminal, give freely for re*
ligious uses. These emotions have probably been the greatest
of world-influences since men began to take the universe
serioualy. When, in the rhythmic course of Nature, great
waves of them have rolled up, they have generally come
nearly at the same time with great epochs of literature and
art. The struggles of the early church were followed by
the literary inspirations of St Augustine. Baphael and
Luther vrere bom the same year, and Michelangelo only
eight years before. The harrowing of the English Church
by Henry VIII was the precursor of Shakespere and his
companions; the Huguenot persecutions brought the age
of the great French dramatists and pulpit orators; the wars
of the Cavaliers and Puritans bred Milton, and presaged
the literature of Queen Anne; the great school of American
writers was bom of the struggle of the free spirit against
Puritanism; the Victorian age in Literature was the age of
conflict between Moses on the one hand, and Lyell, Darwin,
and Spencer on the other.
Be it noted in passing that, very often, these outbursts of
literary and artistic genius did not take place in the times
of greatest agitation, but a generation later. This, as I have
suggested before {Outlook for Nov. 24, 1906), may go a long
way to account for genius : it seems to be bom — ,not made by
its own experiences, but by fervors experienced by its progenitors.
During all these birth-throes of ihe spirit, whatever differences of opinion there were regarding the nature of Ood
and of immortality, both were believed in, and enough things
believed regarding both, to keep most of the world's active
74
Some Ethical Aspects of Evolution
[Bk. I
minds busy ; and to accompany the good results of such beliefs
with a terrible amount of bad ones, including some of the
worst tragedies in history. Conflicting assertions regarding
the supra-phenomenal unsheathed the sword of Islam, and
gave western Europe the most terrible wars and persecutions
in history; for hundreds of years such assertions turned
friend against friend, brother against brother, parent against
child. As a iypical instance so recently as John Fiske's youth
in the late fifties, in a small Connecticut city, his denial of
orthodox Christianity ostracised him from social intercourse.
But the reaction from all these extremes has been only less
deplorable than the extremes themselves. After so many
bad experiences from speculations regarding the unknown,
it was not a strange reaction to deny such speculations any
l,itimacy at all.
As knowledge widens, men depend more upon knowledge,
and tend to believe that absorption in the Beyond, where we
have no knowledge, is the deepest folly, because it is founding
our greatest interests in our ignorance. The systems of
belief reared regarding the Beyond have taxed so many of
the best powers of the race, and have so generally come to
nothing, that at last many of their most ardent admirers,
while insisting that their building has the highest value, have
come to admit that the value is not in what is built, but
in the act of building — ,just as it was generally held, a couple
of generations ago, that the highest value of education is
not in what is learned, but in the act of learning. To say
that there is not a grain of truth in these positions would
be fatuoufr— as fatuous perhaps as the claim that the preponderance oftruth is in them.
The best known expression of this attitude is of course
Lessing's preference of ''search for truth'' to truth itself.
No sane man really accepts this, yet it has been made famous
by the unquestionable poetry of its expression, and notorious
by the passion of mankind for the intellectual titillation given
by epigrams with a spice of truth and a sharper spice of
contradiction of what is known to be true. The acceptance
of such an epigram makes the vulgar feel wiser than the
acceptance of a. plain truth that everybody can see. Yet the
Ch. YI]
Beactions from mich Interuts
76
innate stupidity of the epigram in question is entirely in
keeping with the dinouement of the masterwork in which
it occurs. Despite all the poets have done for us, and no men
have done more, many of them have a terrible amount to
answer for.
But it is almost superfluous to reiterate that, wasted and
worse-than-wasted poetry and philosophy have been but a
small part of the negative effects of absorption in the Beyond.
Dogmatic statements regarding it have clashed; and quarrels
when neither side can be proved wrong are interminable, and
their passions illimitable.
In reaction against all this, a little after the middle of the
last century, arose a school led by perhaps the most powerful
mechanical intellect yet known — one the immensity of whose
processes touched poetry. This school declared : ', This universe, sofar as we know it, can all be expressed in mechanical
terms, and we have found the terms — or at least enough of
them to show that in time the rest may be found; we are
plainly on the track of principles that cover all we know,
or can know with our tools for knowing. Those tools will
never carry us beyond phenomena. Most of the wasted
strength of historic ages has been in speculating beyond phenomena, and most of their miseries have come from conflict
of opinions on alleged questions beyond phenomena. Now
as truth there is not attainable, agreement is impossible.
Let us stop all this waste and worry, and busy ourselves
with the correlation of phenomena by the mighty new engine
of truth we have just discovered after guessing at it for three
thousand years — in Evolution.'*
This reaction differed from those led by Copernicus and
Luther. That of Copernicus related primarily to the question
of the earth's place and man's place, at the center of the
universe. That led by Luther related mainly to the abuses
in the church. Neither revolution materially disturbed philosophic opinions regarding man's origin, daily duties, or destiny, or the universe beyond phenomena, and neither offered
an engine like evolution for the revision of opinions.
Since Luther's day the course of thought had vastly
widened, and yet it had been so dammed back in the churches,
in the schools, and even in social relations, that when the
76
BofM Ethical Aspects of SvoltUian
[Bk. I
dams were finally thrown down by Lyell, Darwin, Spencer,
Huxley, and their friends, the flood of aasociations on which
the old faiths depended, swept the faiths along with them,
and the absurdities, abuses, persecutions, and horrors which,
in the Christian and Moslem worlds, had attended speculation
regarding God and Immortality, were so intensely reacted
from, that for half a century some of the strongest minds
have regarded such speculation as subversiye of Philosophy,
Morals, and general well-being.
Nevertheless, the intellectual habits which had bred those
speculations were so deep-seated that most of our contemporary philosophers have inherited more of them than tiiey
realize, and affect to ignore Spencer even while they habitually
use his terms, and test all things by principles which, though
faintly appearing as guesses from the beginning of philosophy,
were first demonstrated as facts in mind, morals and society by
him : indeed so much of his work has got into the very air that
everybody, according to capacity, breathes in his principles,
often without realizing whence they came.
This ignorant, not to say ungrateful, attitude of many
contemporaries regarding Spencer, is partly due to the brain
evolved on the old philosophy being in many ways impermeable to the new. But it is also due, and perhaps in a greater
degree, to Spencer having poured out the child with the
bath; while insisting on the consciousness of the Beyond, and
not denying, though not asserting, the Hereafter, he rigidly
refrains from any speculation regarding the details of either;
and what little light he flashes toward both, is brief and cold
and dry. Though his daily walk and conversation were very
much informed by the esthetic side of Nature, his philosophy
was very little ; and as it offers none of the beautiful assumptions in which men have so long delighted, and deals very
little in poetry, except as its immensities are poetic, people
who cannot supply its poetical implications for themselves,
are apt to reject it as bare and arid. But now comes along
M. Bergson and covers the colossal structure with flowers — a
task for which the giant who reared it was not fitted. When
I said this to M. Bergson, he supplemented it with one of
Ch. VI]
Unhnoum and Unknowable
77
ixiimitable touches — ,,'I try to diow how flowers insvitably
of it/*
grow
It isoutthe proverbial fate of genius to have to make its own \
oonstituency; and while, in our day, that fate is not as heavy \
as it was in tiie days of Socrates and Ghnst, the work against \
habit and heredity is still hard and slow. It must be rhythmic
too, as Spencer was the first clearly to demonstrate. All these
things make it easy to understand how, in spite of the revolu*
tion wrought in philosophy by him, in spite of the contemporary spread of his doctrines over Europe, America, India, and
Japan, there has been a reaction since his death — ,a reaction
even among men who have for their main stock in trade, however unconsciously accumulated and assorted, the principles
that Spencer first clearly established, and even the terminology
that he mainly created.
While the principal cause of this superficial and ignorant
unconsciousness of Spencer's influence has undoubtedly been
his refusal to pander to the appetite for transcendental speculation, heyet provided the word Unknowable with a capital
n, which lifted it from a negation into an assertion, and
gave us a new word for something beyond the little contents
of our consciousness, to believe in and lift our emotions
toward.
But why doesn't the word Unknown answer the same purpose ? As a negation. Unknowable is nothing but a truism :
it cannot mean more than imknowable in the present state
of our knowledge, and that is a matter of course: for when
any item of the unknown becomes known, the state of our
knowledge is changed. And to assert that no matter how
many items become known, there will still remain an unknown
residuum, and therefore that there must ever be an Unknowable, isto make 1>ne of those assertions involving the
pseud-idea of " infinity,*' in -which the pre-Spencerian philosophy did its reasonings in circles, and which it is one of
the first principles of scientific philosophy to avoid. If,
again, the word means that the number of things not now
known is greater than can be learned while our race lasts,
it rises from a truism or a pseud-idea, into a guess, but
only a guess, even if one with which most men would agree.
78
Some Eihical Aspects of Evohitian
[Bk. I
But to assert that beyond our experience and knowledge
there is presumably an immensity of trutii and beauty and
happiness, beside which onr knowledge is as nothing, is only
to assert what we have almost as much reason to beliere
from our experience, as we have to beUeve the experience
itself. And we haye nearly the same reason to believe also
that we, or at least onr descendants, will have an increasing
share in that transcendent beatitude. Regarding our own
chances, some guesses will be ventured in later pages. I
say guesses : for when, as was the fashion with our ancestors,
such speculations assume the certainty that we now seldom
attribute to anything but hypothesis diecked by verification/
they have their dangers.
To the universe which transcends phenomena, the name
transcendent naturally has been applied. Of course more
nonsense has been talked about it than any other subject;
and in spite of the best intentions, I probably have talked
my share, and shall probably talk some more.
The term connotes two ideas (a) the unknown residuum of
cause, etc., behind phenomena; (i) the portion of the universe
whence we have as yet received no phenomena. Despite
Transcendentalism being a jaw-breaking term, it cut a great
figure on Boston Sundays a couple of generations ago ; but for
everyday use in our time. The Unknown might serve better.
The Spiritual World is of course another term for the
same thing, at least for its psychic side, if you wish to
draw a distinction which to me grows more and more shadowy
every day. When savages have had anything come to them
from their Unknown, even if it were but a bullet from a
musket, they have called it the work of spirits, and a large
portion of civilized mankind does not materially differ from
them to-day. That world, being Unknown, however, does
not quite justify Spencer in calling it Unknowable, Uiough
we may be justified in spelling both with capitals. And
our limited intellects are apt to get on high horses and
say that, in any event, it must be Unknowable in its totality,
just as if the word totality in the connection were an idea,
instead of a pseud-idea.
,
As to the universe which transcends our knowledge, the
Ch. YI]
No Magic Key9.
U9$s of 8p$culation
79
world's records abound in confident expectations of finding
, keys'' and ,'passwords'' that shall at a flash make all
the unknown, known; and no end of ''systems" of '' knowledge "of it have been bnilt, which were, of course, nothing
bnt card-honses with words on the cards. The only stable
knowledge has been built of classified phenomena; and the
only progress into the transcendent universe has been Btq>
by step. Thus only has some of the universe which was at
first all transcendent to our ancestors, become known to us,
and thus only, so far as we can see, will some of the universe
which is transcendent to us, become known to our d,
But speculation concerning the transcendent universe, when
honestly regarded as speculation, is justified by several considerations :
I. We never know when a speculation on the transcendent
universe is going to bring a valuable slice of it into our
IJniverse— into the Known (capitals have their uses). The
speculation of to-day points the way to the demonstration
of to-morrow — sometimes.
II. Characteristics pervade phenomena which may be held
to justify, though they may not strictly verify, some classes
of conclusions regarding their cause. For instance, the general
prevalence of beauty and happiness obvious to a healthy mind,
prove the cause beneficent, and therefore give much reason to
believe that it is benevolent. Such beliefs, however, must be
held and enforced only in proportion to their verifiability.
III. Some speculations beyond phenomena have verifiable
advantages — ,they unquestionably enlarge and intensify our
interests; and beyond possible waste of time, which they
share with all speculation and even all experiment, their only
disadvantages arise when they impose rules of conduct whose
advantages are unverifiable.
IV. What is more, we mast speculate, at least on the relations of the uncorrelated phenomena that are constantly
coming from the transcendental universe toward the universe
of knowledge — ,that constitute the borderland of knowledge.
But while science has been in the very act of demonstrating
the legitimacy of guarded speculation, many have said that
80
Some Ethical Aspects of Evolution
[BL I
science was kUling the imagiiiation. Others, however, insist
that science has been the healthiest stimulus of the imagination, not only in hypothesis, but even in poetry: certainly it
gave a new and very deep note to the poetry of Tennyson. But
equally certainly, it has diverted the imagination into new
channels, and these have not yet become so familiar — ,so much
a part of the general consciousness which responds to poetry,
as to inspire it habitually and powerfully. Poetry does not
come from, or appeal to, deep learning or high ingenuity,
but to the common emotions of mankind. True there is
poetry in the spectroscope showing us the composition of
the farthest visible star, there is poetry in the fact that what
we call that star may be only light that has reached us from
the star since it was burnt out and dead; but such facts,
although science is pouring them upon the poet in profusion,
are as yet so unfamiliar that he responds not so much by
feeling their emotional imjdications and turning them into
poetry, as by efforts to comprehend them.
Poetry does not go hand in hand with knowledge, but skips
all along the way, sometimes following in the paths which
knowledge has opened and smoothed, sometimes going ahead,
and throwing its vague lights into mysteries yet to be
explored.
BOOK
UNCORRELATED
CHAPTEB
II
KNOWLEDGE
Vn
INTRODUCTION
What do we mean when we say we know a fhing? That
we recollect enough of its qualities to be snre that when we
find an object possessing those we recollect, and no others
inconsistent with them, it will be the thing we know, or
one like it— one in the class of things with which our recol*
lections correlate it Far off at the edge of the woods I
see a moving object. I cannot make out another quality. I
simply correlate it with the class moving objects. Otherwise
II don't
knowI can
whatcorrelate
it is. It
the class
shadow,
and
see that
it emerges
with the from
smaller
of dark
moving objects. A little nearer, and I am able to correlate
it with the still smaller class of brown moving objects, but
I don't know how high the grass around it is, and don't know
whether to correlate it with cattle or deer or dogs. It begins
to run toward me, and its motion correlates it with dogs.
Its coming toward the house tends to correlate it with my
dogs. That, taken in connection with its color, narrows the
correlation down to collies: the color excludes it from the
class Scottish terriers to which my third dog belongs. But
among collies, I can't tell before it draws nearer whether
it is Laddie or his son Shep ; but as he runs up to me, his
very long hair and comparative lack of white, and large
head, and affection for me, correlate him with my recollections
of Laddie, and I **know" him. Now here are successively
the qualities visibility, motion, color, brown color, the additiond mass of visible qualities that go to make up dog,
the invisible one of tendency to come to my home, whidi
81
82
Introduction to Booh II
[Bk. 11
marks it as my dog, the specific colors which mark it as my
collie dog, and the long hair and preponderance of brown
and big head> which mark it as Laddie.
Dear old f eUow I He was literally old, and within a month
of my writing that passage, he fell miserably and incurably
ill, and we had to chloroform him> which is more than we
would do for each other under similar circumstances. Let
the passage stand as a monument, howeyer perishable, to
as loving and constant a friend as I erer had.
Now when I say I ''knew'' this dear dog, it is because
the whole mass of qualities enumerated were correlated with
my recollections of a corresponding mass of qualities which'
constituted Laddie. Had they not been, I should have had
to say, if asked : '' I don't know the dog." All the knowledge
up to that point would have been unoorrelated with the
knowledge essential to my knowing him.
Now when certain people are present, there are crackings
and tappings going on around the room. There is nothing
visible or discoverable to account for them ; so we can't safely
correlate them with mechanically caused noises. They are
too frequent to be correlated with the shrinkage of wood«work. Jones, who has heard similar noises before, correlates
them with certain qualities he has experienced before, and
says he ''knows" them — ,that they are noises caused by
spirits. I on the other hand having never heard anything of
the kind, and having nothing to correlate the noises with, don't
" know " what they are : to me it is imcorrelated knowledge.
And as, so far, Jones and the rest of us know precious
little, if anything, about "spirits," I suspect that in some
important respects it is really uncorrelated knowledge with
him. Similarly I see tables move in presence of certain
people who touch them very lightly or not at all : so I cannot
correlate the moving power with muscular force! Nor can
I correlate it with electricity: for electricity doesn't act
on wood; or with anything else I know. So for me, the
little knowledge I have of it is correlated with so little of
what I know about modes of force, that I can't say that I
" know " it. We say we know things, when what we know
about them is correlated with what cdse we know, and the
Ch. YII]
How Knowledge Takes Shape
83
wider and dofier the correlatioB, ihe better we know the
fhings.
Now as Jones thinks he knows all abont spirits, and that
what he knows about this force correlates itself with what
he knows about spirits, and that therefore the force comes
from spirits, there is no use in my telling him that it comes
from the medium because the medium is as tired as if he had
done the work with his muscles.
Because the noise takes place only when the medium is
present, I can only correlate it with human forces, though
with none I had known before. Jones prefers spirits.
Well, we have a good deal of such uncorrelated or halfcorrelated or miscorrelated knowledge— it makes the borderland between knowledge and conjecture, and consists largely
of both.
As to knowledge and possible knowledge, we are each in
the midst of two concentric spheres — ,not perfect ones, but
with irregular surfaces. Of course the spheres of no two
men are alike. Each lives in one consisting of what he knows,
or thinks he knows— of his sensed and correlated knowledge.
This shades into an including sphere made up of scraps
of uncorrelated knowledge but partly sensed, of intuitions
and impressions — some of them little more than emotions —
many of them, however, undoubtedly the germs of knowledge
yet to mature. Then, we have every reason to believe, beyond
this sphere must be a measureless infinity outside of not only
our sensed and partly-sensed knowledge, but of our intuitions
and emotions.
Most of the rest of our book will relate to the including
spjiere, and will consist largely of suggestions for correlating
its vague knowledge with that of the sphere of things we know.
The borders of the sphere of knowledge and the sphere
surrounding knowledge, overlap in both experience and feeling, or intuition, or whatever you see fit to call it When
some of our ancestors attained a general sense of light, they
must have had some vague impressions which have developed
into our sense of color; so when they got as far as a clear
general impression of sound, they must have had vague im«
pressions of what are to us pitch and timbre and even bar-
84
IntroducHon to Book II
[Bt II
mony and discord. Now we, in experiences that exercise
our present faculties to the full — ,before greiat aspects of
Nature, or great pictures, statuary, or music, are filled with
exaltations of ',we know not what,' beyond our distinct
sensations. Similarly in the laboratory, the workshop, the
study, the forum, even the market-place, something just beyond always invites us, and in overtaking it, we become
vaguely and tantalizingly conscious of yet more beyond.
This ',beyond'' presents itself partly in open questions
solvable by our present clearly-evolved faculties, and partly
through faculties but little evolved and little understood.
The groups of course merge into each other, as we have so
often had occasion to notice that subdivisions do. In the
$rst group are the phenomena whose genuineness nobody
doubts, but that are not yet correlated, like the Aurora
Borealis; or phenomena not yet actually witnessed, but clearly
ascertained, like the Pole before Peary, or Neptune when
Adams and Leverrier had told where it was, but no man had
seen it. At these questions explorers and scientific men in
general are working, with faculties lik, those of other men,
though often superior in degree.
In addition to this physical group of uncorrelated knowledge, there is a similarly uncorrelated psychical group of
phenomena considerably known and accepted, which includes
visions — sleeping and waking — somnambulism, and both the
foregoing under hypnotism and suggestion.
But beyond that group of phenomena well known but
poorly correlated, is a mass of phenomena newly and rarely
observed which are as yet so strange that they are generally
attributed to illusion or deceit. These phenomena are in
the borderland of faculty, as well as in the borderland of
knowledge. They depend upon human powers whose existence is but lately suspected, and still generally doubted, and
which, if they exist, are the very latest and rarest fruits
of evolution.
The fact that people vary enormously in their powers, is
obvious to all but the immense majority having inferior
powers. That great ability of any kind is rare, is probably
a corollary of evolution (though I have not yet happened
Difference in Men's SeneibUHies 85
CL Vn]
on any demonstration of anch a connection) : so it is to be
expected that new powers should be manifested by but few
people. That such is the case regarding certain powers to
be described later, has been used as an argument against
their genuineness. There may be other arguments against
it that are good, but this one, as far as it goes, is certainly
it.
farIntellectually
and emotionally men differ among themselves
more widely than any other genus of animals. I don't mean
merely the difference between ordinary men and Beethovens
and Shaksperes, who have faculties in high degree which
almost eyerybody has in perceptible degree, but I mean that
some men seem to possess faculties which most men seem
not to possess at all. One of these most marked differences
is in the premonitions of the unsensed universe. Even on
the emotional side, some men have virtually no such pre*
monitions, while they illumine the faces of others so that
you can often pick out such men on the street. Such premoniti ms are of course vague, and tend to become fanta6ti(,-—
''such stuff as dreams are made of,'' and in the efforts to
give them precision, many systems have been built; and
too often those not built in the laboratories, have fallen to
pieces with great destruction to the reasonable faiths that
were built in with unreasonable ones, and to the accompany*
ing systems of morality. In truth, so far, the laboratory,
the observatory, and their kindred have been the only places
of permanently successful effort to increase our knowledge
of the Beyond.
But in the laboratory and the study, feeling the Beyond
is greatly ''sicklied o'er with the pale cast of thought."
Yet not only is the recognition of its existence a commonplace
of healthy mental function, but emotional relations with it
often seem essential to a worthy and symmetrical personality.
It may well be questioned whetiier, even in the most commonplace and humble people who command our respect, this feel*
ing is not always very definite. Certainly the vast majority
of them, even many of them who scoff at the ordinary manifestations ofreligion, are religious in their way, having a
fidelity to such ideals as they have, that rises to the mystical.
There are indeed few human beings who are not some*
86
Introduction to Booh II
[Bk. II
where, somehow, sometime, exalted by this mystical communion. It may be in a Gothic cathedral or a Methodist
meeting-house, or in the chapel where the brigand prays for
snocess in his expedition; it may be before the Matterhom
or the Sistine Madonna; before McAndrews's engine or ,'a
weed's plain heart/' The person experiencing it may be a
Saint Francis or an Unde Tom; the occasions may be few
in a life-time, or they may include almost every conscious
moment; they may drive out of life almost every duty and
responsibility, or they may overcrowd it with them, and intensify and sanctify them all, the humblest as truly as the
greatest. But where, when, how, to whom, the feeling comes,
it comes some time to nearly all; and whatever its name, it
is a recognition of something beyond what we know, and
greater than we know.
And yet, while he who has not intensely felt his oneness
with all conscious being, has not felt the Best, the attempt
to live entirely in this feeling has on the whole been counter
to the best uses of Ufe — ,narrowing, enervating, and even
bestializing. While mysticism includes the roses of Saint
Elizabeth, it also includes the filth of Stylites, and the unnatural ecstasies of the celestial marriage.
But by no means all the persons who have had this mystic
sense have been vagabonds and parasites. Some of them have
left work of inestimable value, though of the value of much
of it there have been enormous differences of opinion.
James in his Varieties of Religious Experience, quotes with
approval from Dr. Buckets book which I have already cited.
It contains some interesting theories, and quite interesting
accounts of a couple of dozen people, from the prophet
Moses to Walt Whitman, who have attained the Cosmic Consciousness, which Dr. Bucke places as the third plane in
terrestrial experience, the first being mere consciousness of the
environment, which beasts share with us ; the second, the ordinary human subjective consciousness, the name of which in
our translation from German philosophy is very unfortunate—
*, self consciousness '' being well established as signifying awk*
ward feelings in society.
Dr. Bucke seems to think that Cosmic Consciousness — ,the
feeling of oneness with Nature— our forces, its forces; our
Oh. YII]
Cosmic ComciouMess
87
thoughts, ita thoughts; our life, its life, aniTenal and eternal; our coDflciousnefls, all cosscioxisnesa — ,is the endowment of
but a few favored beings, and that they generally get it at the
culminating time of life, between thirty-five and forty-five, by
some such knock-down experience as St. Paul's, and generally accompanied with an apparent blaze of glory, subjectiye
at least I suspect that more people are blest with it than he
supposes. He says himself that it is not necessarily accompanied with any extraordinary general capacities. I (pybody
writing of these things, ought to contribute what he can to
the sum of experience) — ,I cannot remember when I did not
have the rudiments of it before great scenery and great music,
and it culminated in me ten years before the usual period he
assigns. It came with the blaze of light, but the light was
from the natural sunset which, however, seemed that evening
not confined to the far-off clouds, but to pervade the whole
atmosphere and all other things, including me, and to be pervaded byenergy and mind and sympathy. Dr. Bucke says,
rightly, I think, that the influence lasts in its fullness but
minutes, seldom hours, but is never lost, and is sometimes
renewed and reinforced. But I wouldn't advise anybody
wishing to retain it vividly, to plunge into the competition of
American business ; and even into studies of practical affairs
,economics, politics, and the like : I suspect one has to keep
his eyes pretty wide open to be fairly conscious of any
Cosmic Belations that may inhere in such interests.
It is not during the comparativdy brief period covered by
human records, that most of the impressions that have been
in advance of knowledge during dl evolution, have been
overtaken by the understanding. With the exception of
some indication that the color sense has developed somewhat since Homer, our recognized senses and physical powers
generally seem about the same in number and quality that
they were at the earliest period we know of. Yet the progress of mankind as we generally know it, has been somewhat in the development of them. Everybody who sees much
of ordinary laborers, knows that the best class of mankind
has gone past the vast majority even in the ordinary senses of
sight and hearing.
88
Introduction to Bool II
[Bk. 11
But in the nineteenih oentoiy, especially late in it, began
to appear indications that, in a few exceptional indiyiduala,
evolution had brought the human organism to a point where
it exercises modea of force before little known, if at all;
manifests a complexity of personaliiy and relations to other
personalities, before unsuspected; and receives knowledge not
only through new channels, but of a new kind. Yet these
new faculties seem to belong in an old range beginning in
knowing good people from bad ,' by instinct," or knowing when
there's an unseen cat in the room, and now extending up to
seeing things without using eyes, hearing things without using
ears, and getting, in other ways we don't know, impressions of
the unsensed universe, including what appear to be innumerable
personalities. These impressions may come from the recollections (often unexpressed and even unconscious, so far as we
know) of other people, or from discamate intelligences, or in
some other way that we cannot conjecture much more than
a worm with only color pigments can conjecture the visions
of Turner.
In the presence of the latest of these phenomena, a man Js
like such a worm exposing his pigment-spot to the reflected
lights which make our visible universe ; or like an insect with
a rudimentary sense of hearing, fluttering in a hall where an
orchestra is playing. They must have some stirrings which
hold about the same place in their interests and sensations,
that our wonderings do before these matters of which our
senses give us such faint inklings, and among which our
curiosities do such clumsy fumblings.
In proceeding to the study of the borderland of knowledge,
and to some conjectures of what may lie beyond the border*
land, I shall attempt nothing but the study of phenomena, and
a few cautious inferences from them. I lack the inclination
and, I suspect, the capacity, to take a lot of words like
'* infinite,'* "eternal," "absolute," which are simply denials
of knowledge, or " omniscience," " omnipresence," " omnipotence," which are assertions of something the human mind
cannot grasp, and by keeping such words a long time in the
air, as jugglers do tiieir balls, construct a system of Philosophy. Previous to Spencer, and to some extent since, thinkers
have done bo much of this that, despite snggestions like Kanf s
of the cosmogony, most of their work simply doubled on itself
in circles, its predicates being merely its subjects in different
phraseology; and its conclusions, like its premises, pseud*
ideas with no possibilities of forecast in them.
And yet for three thousand years the imagination has been
the main instrument of philosophy, and curiosity beyond
phenomena its main motive — both to such an extent that
minds devoted to the subject have, both by habit and Buryiyal, been so shaped for such vaporings, that it is still rare
to find a mind inclined to philosophy which does not habitually seek those mists. And it is equally rare to find a mind
so open to the implications of evolution as to be guided
by them in all its speculations, and thus saved from clueless
wandering in the fog.
The more I read of philosophy and histories of philosophy,
the harder I find it to understand why men now trouble
themselves with the guesses that were made on the material
thinkers had before the recent knowledge of the physiology of
the senses, and the persistence of force, and its relations to
nerve function. Until those diseoveries, men certainly knew
nothing worth considering regarding the fundamental question
of the relations of mind and matter: so there could be no
enduring basis for psychological speculation, nor the elements
of a substantial organic body of doctrine to bear the name
Philosophy. There was nothing but a chaotic fiuttering mass
of contradictions, without a single established principle on
which to base a rule of conduct, much less any coherent
body of ethics founded on what is, for us, universal law.
Fr,,entary rules of conduct had been derived from experience, and embodied by men of genius in immortal phrases ;
and those rules had been in various degrees wrought into
sporadic and usually fleeting systems ; but the foundation for
any tmiversal and universally acknowledged systems of psy«
chology, philosophy, or ethics, was unknown.
I shall therefore not follow fashions still too current, by
encumbering what I have to say with many citations of
guesses that were made before our recent knowledge. Among
the good reasons why I don't cite them, is that I know, and
care to know, very little about them. Even many guesses
that were made so recently as just before the acctunnlation
and verification of facts by the Society for Psychical Be*
search, are often too antiquated for onr present purpose.
I shall try, therefore, to make my examination of the
subjects which tempt to the old-fashioned philosophy as
free from it as I can. But ttiat is no easy task : for everything
we know— -each science into which we have classified it, shades
off somewhere into the unknown, and much that we have to
deal with has hardly emerged from it The new questions
are tangled up with questions older than our records, but
which have had little scientific consideration until some thirty
years ago, and have not had as much since as their importance
may be found to justify. They have, however, to some extent, been named and classified, which is the b,inning of
science, and are, some of them at least, being slowly correlated with our present knowledge.
Certainties have a tendency to grow commonplace. Even
mountains and oceans satisfy for but a time : so the flights of
great and venturesome souls tend to the shifting skies of unverified beliefs. These are sometimes misleading, but often
inspiring, and it is one of the highest of intellectual delights
to watch them through history, gradually becoming brighter
and more definite ; and helping make them so is perhaps the
highest of intellectual functions.
BOOK II — PART I
TELEKINESIS
CHAPTER VIII
MOLAR TBLBEINSSIS
While the past half-century seems to have shown ns more
of onr Cosmic Relations, and to have widened them more,
than all preceding time since man was far enough eyolved
to write his history, most attention has been attracted by
the revolutionary discoveries affecting transportation of matter, and the communication of ordinary intelligence by
molecular forces of which we had long had some sort of con*
ception. Of late, however, much attention has been devoted
to new faculties and new means of communication.
Included with the phenomena out of which knowledge is
built, is the evolution of the senses which take cognizance
of those phenomena ; and during the last half -century much
attention has been drawn to indications of an evolution of
senses, or sensibilities, that take cognizance of phenomena
before unknown, and that may perhaps surpass in importance
(if comparisons can reasonably be made) any of the avenues
of knowledge previously known.
But in passing to the consideration of these matters, let
it be distinctly understood that we are to consider only phenomena, and not mere speculations on assumptions regarding the transcendent world, which have made the bulk of
'What has been called philosophy. I shall deal freely in provisional assumptions, but only regarding phenomena, and
I shall not use such words as infinite and eternal and unconditioned, inany other sense than as indicating directions,
regarding whose goals I shall not even knowingly make assumptions. Tocut it short : beyond this point, this book, so
far as it is not record of fact, is mainly candid guesswork
regarding fact.
Yet in being so, it admits no affiliation with the famous
masses of guesswork which announce themselves as established
truth.
On the borderland of our knowledge, we shall meet many
strange and startling statements, among which there is undoubtedly a substantial mass of fact, but just what that mass
is, we shall find hard to determine, and after we have done
our best to separate it, we shall find it equally hard to correlate it with our established knowledge. To the statements,
the winnowing, and the correlation, we will now apply ourselves. And let us do so with the hope that we may find some
new inspirations to lift us, if not back to our outworn creeds,
at least to all in them which promoted our higher interests,
and perhaps to more enlightened creeds promoting interests
higher still.
Early writings and traditions abound in accounts of magical
control of nature, mysterious visions, and spiritual communications and possessions, which may have been partly the
results of some rudimentary senses or susceptibilities akin
to those which, about the middle of the last century, were
manifested in America, and since have appeared sporadically
through Europe.
At first persons occupying the two extremes of mental habit
— theologians and scientists, alike generally scouted these
alleged phenomena as fraudulent, and refused even to investigate them. But the genuineness of some of them may now
be considered established in the scientific world, and that of
several others held fairly open to consideration.
The phenomena are both physical and psychical, though
with some mysterious connection between them: for most
persons, though not all, manifesting one group, have manifested the other.
The physical group is in the powers (I) to move material
objects by some extra-muscular force, and often without contact; (II) to pass matter through matter without disintegrating either mass; (III) to cause motion in the air without any
obvious agency. The aforesaid changes effected by the mysterious force or forces are molar. It is claimed that there are
powers to produce also the following which are molecular:
(IV) when near to certain objects — notably running water and
gold, and probably some others yet to be ascertained — to
establish inyoluntarily between the operator and the object,
some sort of current not yet named, but apparently akin to
magnetism, which not only makes the operator aware of the
nearness of the object, but causes in him nenrous and muscular reactions; (V) to produce sounds from tangible objects
and from the air, by some agency as yet unknown; (VI) similarly to produce lights; (VII) also changes of the air's temperature; (VIII) also eyaneacent unmaterial semblances of
material objects.
To the first of these powers is now generally applied the
name telekinesis. The tele, however, is not to be regarded in
the frequent sense of distant from, but merely as not in contact
with. And as the objects concerned in all of the eight categories are not in contact with the operator's body, we may
tentatively consider all the modes of force as telekinetic, though
as more is known about them, such of them as survive scrutiny
may receive separate names.
The first of these alleged modes of force I have seen in
action, and know to be genuine. There is plenty of honest
testimony to the rest; the only questions arise over the possibilities ofillusion. Tlie testimony to the fourth (,, dowsing ")
and fifth (sound) is strong enough to have convinced me.
That to the sixth (light) I consider in some cases very good,
but in most not yet convincing. For the rest, the testimony
does not seem to me convincing, perhaps because the allegations are so improbable, but the testimony is too strong to be
ignored.
The telekinetic forces ex vi termini act outside the body.
The following forces are alleged to have acted through the
will upon the body itself. I venture to suggest the name
autokinetic. They are said (I) to lift the body independently
of any known agency; (II) to resist the effects of heat; (III)
to produce stigmata and blisters. The testimony to the third
seems convincing, also that to one class of incidents of the
second; to the first, as to some sorts of telekinesis, it is not as
strong as the great improbability requires, and yet too strong
to be ignored.
There is anoiher new force of which we see evideiices in
the activities of the alleged spiritual mediums. I call it
psychokinesis. It will be described in due course.
The uncorrelated psychical phenomena we will consider in
Part III of this Book II.
I am fortunate in being able to begin an account of telekinesis from my own eiperience— one which, in boyhood, inaugurated an interest in these subjects that has endured
through a long life.
In the winter of 1856-7 or the spring of 1857, on a Sunday
afternoon, I was one of a dozen or so of the pupils of Oenerd
Russell's school in New Hayen who were loafing in one of
the recitation rooms, when one of them said to P---
"Ghost, show us the spirits !"
The boy addressed was a delicate-looking chap of medium
height, some sixteen or seventeen years old, whose gentle and
truthful nature had made him a faTorite with us all — ,to a
greater degree perhaps than any other boy in the schooL
The subject once opened, there was a quite general talk
about raps being heard about his bed, and similar stories.
It was news to me. I had previously supposed that his nickname of , Ghost '' was the result of his comparatively shadowy
appearance, but I was to learn better.
He objected to giving the exhibition because, he said, it
tired him so; but at last he was persuaded.
There were some music-stands in the room, probably two
or three, over which we did our fluting and fiddling. Certainly they contained no hidden batteries and connections.
Each consisted of a wooden slab some two inches thick, and
some fifteen by eighteen in width and length, resting on
the floor ; then from this a stick some two by three, rising to
the height required by the average player ; and on top of the
stick, an inclined piece about the size of the base, but much
thinner, serving as a desk for the music. The whole thing was
made, probably, of white pine, and unpainted.
P- stood before one of these stands, placing his fingers
and thumbs lightly on the desk, which sloped with the top
away from him. Soon, he said : "If there are any spirits present, will they please tip the stand?'' No response. After
several repetitions of the question, the stand tipped gently toward him. Now, as the desk sloped avay from him, its tipping
toward him by his muscular force was absolutely impossible.
After a time the stand would tip in response to all sorts of
questions, and spell words in response to letters as the
alphabet was repeated. Later knowledge leads me to believe
that these tippings were in response to P—'s unconscious
volition.
Soon P-,'s arms began to jerk convulsively, so that his
hands ceased their permanent contact with the stand, and
began to tap it with increasing frequency and strength. Soon
the stand ceased to fall back into its natural position of standing on the floor, but even in the intervals between the tappings, while his hands did not touch it, remained tipping
toward him, not rising and falling as his hands rose and
fell, but tipped permanently. The force produced this suspension without contact —literally was telekinesis.
The jerkings increased in frequency and violence to
a rapid tattoo of his fingers on the stand, the distances
away from it between the beats increasing to nearly or quite
a foot, and the stand steadily tipping more and more toward
him until, probably, the top had passed the center of gravity,
and yet it did not fall toward him or back toward its natural
position, but was virtually held in what all previous knowledge
would have declared an impossible position.
Then he said : "Try to pull it down" and the strongest
boy among us on one side of the base, and I, who was perhaps
the heaviest, on the other, tried to turn the base back to
the floor. We could not. We spread ourselves on the floor,
throwing our hands and the weight of our bodies over the
raised bottom of the stand, but we could only sway it a little,
while his hands continued playing their tattoo — both hands
irregularly, not sistematically relieving each other so as to
exercise a contintums pressure, but leaving the stand, at in*
tervals of perhaps a quarter of a second each, alternately with
and without contact with him. The contest between the muscular force of the strong boys at the base, and P-'s mysterious force at the desk, continued for a minute or two, until the
base of the structure was broken off or the nails drawn out, and
P- sank into a chair exhausted. The frail fellow had
put forth more force of some kind than the muscular force
of two boys, each of much more than his weight and many
times his muscular strength. We were out of breath and
tired too. I don't remember whether P- held the upper
part suspended in the air, or whether a mysterious circuit
with the earth was broken when we broke off the base.
Fatigue like P-'s is generally mentioned as following
experiences like his, and the other manifestations of telekinesis. There are a few instances, however, where apparently no fatigue is experienced.
I remember realizing at the time that his force could not
be electrical, as it acted through wood.
There was no cabinet, no subdued light, no machinery but
a commonplace piece of furniture familiar to all of us, no
money paid for the show, nothing but an honest and kindly
boy sacrificing himself for the entertainment of his mates.
The broken stand remained there as evidence that we had
not been hypnotized, and I seem to remember some inconvenience from being unable to use it before it was mended.
Now if I have not told those things exactly as they
occurred, I never told any other concatenation of as many
tilings exactly as they occurred. The fact of his putting
forth more of his mysterious force than we did of our mus*
cular force, is as indubitable as any fact in my experience.
The manifestation was so simple and coherent that not only
was room for error conspicuously lacking at the time, but
room for failure or distortion of memory has been conspicuously lacking since.
A decade ago, Fodmore would probably have urged against
this testimony that it has no confirmation; that the parties
were all boys ; that the only witness was convicted during his
youth of writing verses, and has since written fiction; that
the testimony is nearly sixty years after the event, and that
it was given when the witness was presumably in his dotage.
Begarding the last objection I am not entitled to an opinion,
and the others are all facts. The other witnesses of P-phenomena I have entirely lost sight of, and indeed forgotten
who they were, except the boy who helped me break the
stand. He was a Spanish-American, and went back to his own
people.
For anybody, however, who, in spite of all that, is rash
enough to accept the testimony, telekinesis is proved.
If I doubt that occurrence, I must doubt every other experience ever
I had. My certainty regarding those phenomena
cannot be increased. But if it coidd be, it of course would be
by the vast accumulation since then, of evidence of similar
phenomena.
There have been many ludicrous efforts to account for such 7,
things by mechanical means, and regarding my experience
with P-, I have been asked in many polite ways if I am
a fool. But all this was long ago: of late the evidence for
telekinesis is so strong as to have put an end to skepticism
in a large part of the educated world.
Manifestations of telekinesis have been known to come from
many persons, and whatever the supplementary tricks of
Eusapia Falladino — ,the ', medium '' most noted at present —
there seems no extravagance in assuming that this mode of
force is sometimes manifested by her, and is the foundation
of anything genuine in her performances.
Here is an account furnished by one of my sisters of an
occurrence somewhat similar to mine, witnessed by her :
"The remarkable 'table tipping' of which I have told you
occurred many years ago in the home of one of my school
friends. She had an older, invalid sister, a charming, magnetic woman, whose room was the center of all the life and
gaiety of the family. One day a number of us girls were
seated, as was our wont, around her bed — an old-fashioned
'four-poster' (for it was an old-fashioned home), when the
conversation drifted to 'spiritual rappings,' ghosts, etc. One
of our number (Miss A.), who had recently displayed remarkable powers in moving and tipping furniture, was challenged
to make a small but very heavy oval marble-topped table,
probably three or three-and-a-half feet in its long diameter,
move over to the bed and mount it. She accepted the challenge, while we all watched with laughing incredulity. She
simply rested the tips of the fingers of both hands on the
table, and in a short time it began to move, she following.
When it reached the foot of the bed it began at once slowly
to wriggle up the side— I can describe its motion in no better
way— until it lay on its side at the feet of the startled
invalid.
"On inquiring of Miss A. what her sensations were while
the tii,le was moving, we were told that she felt as if a
stream of cold water were running from her finger tips up
her arms, and she now felt quite exhausted.
"Not one of us could have lifted the table onto the bed,
using all the strength we possessed. She was soon after forbidden to make such experiments on account of the exhaustion
which followed."
The other witnesses of Miss A.'s phenomena are all
dead. But since that day so much well-authenticated evidence
of similar phenomena has accumulated, that one witness is
worth more now than a dozen were then.
I have been somewhat surprised at the number of private
persons free from all suspicion of deceit, and not working
for money, who have manifested such phenomena. While I
have been busy at this book, the conversation around the supper-table atthe Authors' Club has more than once turned on
experiences which have not yet been correlated with established knowledge, and probably half the men present have
related some.
The next case will be taken from the Proceedings of the
Society for Psychical Eesearch, but before giving it, it will
be weU to give some idea of that society and its publications,
citations from which will constitute a large part of the
remainder of this work.
Of course, like all other phenomena, these we are considering have their recurrent waves (Professor Newbold says
at intervals of about six centuries) of frequency and scarcity,
as required by the law of vibration, or ,'rhythm of motion''
as Spencer calls it; and probably the only new thing about
them is that the latest wave happened, as already stated,
to start up in the middle of the last century, and roll into
the ken of modem science. Under the present faith in facts,
there has been accumulated a vast array of those connected
with these subjects. But apparently unlike most other matters
of wide curiosity, until comparatively lately few systematic
attempts were made to "explain" them — to correlate them
with established knowledge.
About 1880, a group of friends connected with the Universities of Cambridge and Dublin, met for the investigation
of obscure phenomena. It will not be surprising if the
future regards the gathering of these friends as epoch-making.
In 1882 they founded the Society for Psychical Besearch.
The name Psychical was too narrow : for physical phenomena
have also been examined and reported upon. Up to that time,
so far as I know, neither class of phenomena uncorrelated
with existing science had received the attention of any organized body of workers. In October, 1882, the society issued
the first "Part" of its "Proceedings" to be hereafter alluded
to in these pages so frequently as to require the abbreviation
"Pr. S. P. B.," and later merely Pr. The first volume was
completed in December, 1883. The twenty-sixth volume was
completed in 1913.* The Society has also issued a " Journal "
exclusively for its members, of which the fifteenth volume was
completed in 1912.
The general intellectual culture concentrated in the Society
has seldom been equalled in any learned organization. The
reports almost without exception are models of reasoning and
diction. For their cultural effect alone most of them are .
well worth reading. The idea of vulgar and ignorant credulity,
in connection with the authors is ludicrous. Nor is it possible
to feel regarding the reports as a mass, the misgivings germane to the conclusions of purely literary persons regarding
practical affairs : for though Frederic Myers, for instance, held
a high position in literature; Henry Sidgwick held one equally
(* The S.P.R. was singularly fortunate In Its fonnden. They were
all remarkable persons. Among them, in addition to Professor (now
Sir William) Barrett of the University of Dublin, who called them
together, were Professor Henry Sidgwick of the University of Cambridge,
and Messrs. F. W. H. Myers and Bdmund Gurney, ex-fellows of Cambridge.
Soon after the start, the Cambridge group was increased by Mrs.
Sidgwick and Professor and Mrs. Yerrali, all of whom, especially the
ladies,
important
matter
to the value
Proceedings.
Mn. Verrall's
are quitecontributed
voluminous,
and their
scientific
is illuminated
by rare
literary charm
Closely psychologist.
associated withProfessor
those already
namedJames,
soon and
became
greatest
William
Dr. America's
Richard
Hodgson, who in many respects surpassed any of those named earlier,
yet he did,oot, like some of them, leave an important book as a monument, or, like others, attain fame in sciences outside of "Psychical Research." But in devotion to the cause, in acuteness of the intelligence
which he brought to it, especially in the detection of fraud ; and in
grasp of the indications of general principle scattered among its bewildering phenomena, he was perhafw first of all. James Mid that he
knew no handling of a large mass of elusive matter to surpus Hodgson's report in Pr. XIII. Hodffson began as the hardest-headed of the
skeptics, exposed more frauds than any other man, and eventually became an enthusiastic spiritist. The last dozen years or so of hu life
were spent in America as Secretary of the American Branch of the
8. P. R
Other officers and members have been Lord Rayleigh ; Professors
Bowditch, Cope, Crookes, Fullerton, L. P. Jacks, Langley, Lodce,
Gilbert Murray, Newbold, Newoomb, Pumpelly, Royoe ; Drs. W. T.
Harris, L. Emmett Holt, and Morton Prince ; and Messrs. Thomas Davidson, W. E. Gladstone, J. G. Plddington, Frank Podmore, and A.
R. Wallace.
Of the active members: Sidgwick, Podmore, Gumey, Myers, Hodgson, and James
gone sofrom
mysteries
which have
absorbed
much earth—
of theirperhaps
interest.into the deepest of the
Professors Lodge, Crookes, and Barrett, who were all of the early
group, and have contributed much to the Proceedings, still survive wiu
years and honors thick upon them. Sir Oliver Lodge, approaching the
subject with the usual scientific skepticism, bcScame a convmced
spintiit, and has written a volume on The Survival qfMan,)
high in the sciences of mind and society; Sir William
Crookes, Sir Oliver Lodge, and Sir William Barrett have
all received knighthood for their eminence in the physical
sciences, and the position in psychology of Professors James,
Boyce, and Morton Prince I almost feel like asking the
reader,s pardon for naming in an American book. That such
a society shonld have spent its time over trifling or unverified
stories woidd be ridicnlons to presume.
The twenty-six volumes of the society's Proceedings, and
its Journal, contain also pretty mudi everything of great consequence on the subject that has been reported elsewhere.
There is also a similar single volume of reports of a very
eminent American society that existed from 1885 to 1889,
and several volumes of reports of a later American society.
So much of these later American reports is duplicated or summarized inthe English reports, that I have not made a thorough study of them. In addition to these various reports, the
literature of the subject in English is already considerable,
though until the last fifth of the last century, with the exception of a few books on Mesmerism (or Hypnotism) and Somnambulism, and the usual quack mystical works, it was mainly
restricted to the general treatises on Psychology. The con«
tinental reports and literature are worth attention, though
until lately most continental investigators reported through
the S. P. B.
That large portion of the scientific world which has refused
to study the phenomena, of course scouts the questions altogether.
Professor Sidgwick, in his inaugural address as first President of the Society, said (Pr. I, 8) :
"It is a scandal that the dispute as to the reality of these
phenomena should still be going on, that so many competent
witnesses should have declared their belief in them, that so
many olhers should be profoundly interested in having the
question determined, and yet that the educated world, as a
body, should still be simply in the attitude of incredulity."
Probably no equal authority would find it worth while to
express himself to that effect now.
Throughout the early volumes of the Pr. S. P. B. a great ,
deal of attention was given to questions of intentional fraud,
and an enormous deal of it was unearthed. But gradually
enough unquestionable phenomena and reliable ''mediums"
were found to leave the society little time or temptation to
bother with others.
The day for extreme skepticism regarding the actuality
of most of the phenomena is now past. To doubt it is now,
as in the oft-quoted phrase of Schopenhauer regarding
telopsis, not skepticism, but ignorance. I shall not waste
much space in attempts to authenticate them. Men have been
very properly and profitably hung on the unsupported evidence
of children, the only additional requirement being confirmative
circumstances. Such circumstances, the existence of paralld
verified cases, the character of the witness, and consistency
of the general conditions, I shall try to regard in giving
unsupported evidence. Yet the principle illustrated is the
essential thing, and if it is so well supported as to deserve
illustrating at all, it might sometimes be better illustrated
for the general reader by even an impressive fictitious narrative, than by a squalid or malodorous fact.
It is often impossible within the limits to give a fair exposition of evidence on both sides. Persons caring for that
must go to originals. I will give only what appear to me
the points worth considering, with as fair an exhibition of
the tendency of evidence as the space and my capacities
permit
We now proceed to some other cases of telekinesis taken
from the Proceedings. I shall occasionally obtrude a query
or suggestion or explanation in square brackets with my
initials [thus: H. H.].
The first account is virtually identical with my experience
with P
and the music-stand. It is by Mr. George Allman
Armstrong, of 8, Leesonplace, Dublin, and Ardnacarrig,
Bandon . . . June 1, 1887. (Pr. VII, 158-9) :
''This manifestation ... required a great amount of concentrated will power, and when successful the results were startling,
and the apparent physical force developed really wonderful. . . •
The table slowly swayed from side to side like a pendulum,
stopped completely, and then, as if imbued with life, and quite
suddenly, rose completely off the floor to a height of a foot or
fourteen inches at least, and nearly always came down with
immense force, which ... on several occasions proved destructive
to itself, as ihe broken limbs of the table we used . . . could
testify. This table, I may add, was a round, rather heavy,
walnut one, with a central column, standing on three claw legs,
and it would have been impossible for us unaided to have developed the force (by muscular energy) required to produce this
manifestation. . . . On several occasions I have succeeded in
raising the table without contact, the latter rising to our
Angers held over it at a height of several inches, like the
Iffieper to a strong electro-magnet; in these instances the
table swayed slowly in mid-air for many seconds before
coming down with a crash. . . . Frequently . . . the table would
rise on one leg, in which position I willed it to remain,
the united efforts of the rest to press it down to its normal
position being utterly fruitless, and often resulting in a
fracture.'*
In Pr. S. P. B. and elsewhere are given scores, probably
hundreds, of authenticated accounts of phenomena similar
to those just described, and due to both non-professional and
professional mediums. There are two specially good ones
in Pr. IV, 29, and IX, 269.
The presumption for the genuineness of such phenomena
is of course greater where the mediums are persons least
likely to deceive, such as children, and my young friend
P
. There are many such cases. The two following
accounts are furnished by Professor Alexander of the University ofBio Janeiro (Pr. VII, 176f.) :
Ch. Vin]
The Davis Children
103
', At tea the dining-room table, round which were seated Mr.
Davis, Mrs. Davis, their five little daughters, Mrs. Z., and I,
swayed backward and forward, or rose at one end in sudden
emphatic movements.''
A very homogeneous party ! It will often be seen later that
these phenomena are generally better as the sitters are more
homogeneous.
Professor Alexander's account continues:
,'I requested C, who was seated two places from me, her
little sister D. being between us, to place her hand on the
back of my chair, which she did, touching it with apparent
lightness. The chair began at once to sway from side to side,
and continued to do so after I had taken my feet from tiie
ground. There was an application of great power. . . . All
this while C. sat immovable; and it was very manifest that
she made not the slightest effort. The next evening Mr. X.,
who is very muscular, took C.'s seat, while I retained my own;
and same
he then
tried"
muscular
H. H.] "to with
produce
the
effect
under[Byexactly
the force.
same conditions,
the
result that his chair slid back, while mine remained immovable. My weight, which I suppose has not changed to any
considerable d,ree since then, I find to be ISst." [182 lbs.
H. H.] " The high chair in which Amy, a child then thirteen
months old, was seated was moved backwards and forwards
about 10 or 12 inches, between the table and the wall, this
being done so abruptly that the chair was sometimes forced
partly under the table and threatened to fall backwards. The
child, instead of being alarmed, chuckled and laughed, though
we older people were sometimes rather anxious lest she should
be hurt. . . . On the right hand of the child was seated Mrs. Z.,
on the left A. The chair, while moving, . . . was not twisted
roimd as would be the case if it were drawn forward on one
side only by the foot of either of the neighbors. ... I have tried
moving the same chair myself, when seated beside Amy, and
find that, although I have rather more than the average strength
in my lower limbs, the push can be given only with considerable
difficulty, and has the effect of tiuming the chair half round."
In the following case (Pr. VII, 160f.) ibis force apparently
acted in the absence of a medium; but the last three paragraphs seem to indicate a medium after all.
The word medium is a handy one if it is not taken to mean
too much. Here of course it means only the medixmi — ,probably the generator — of an unknown force. Later it will mean
other things.
,'Our informant is a gentleman occupying a responsible
position; his name may be given to inquirers*
104
Molar Telehinesia
[BL II, Pt. I
''On Friday, September 234 I took my four pupils to a
circus, . . . leaving my two servants at home. . . . All but myself
returned at about 5:30, and found the two servants on the
doorstep, telling the boys not to go in by the area door . . . and
explaining that all the bells were ringing violently, no one
touching them, and they had been doing so almost ever since we
left. I left home, I think, at about 7 o'clock. At about 9 :30 . . .
the cook came over ... to say that we must come back, as there
were such dreadful knockings going on in the house. ...It
sounded like a mallet on a wooden floor, speaking loosely. The
laundryman came in soon after it began and was, I believe,
quite scared. ... A teacher in the board school was so scared by
tiie knocking that he would not stay in the house, but went
on the doorstep. . . . When I came back I found the same
state of things; the servants almost in hysterics, and the
bells ringing. The bells hang all in one row, just inside the
area door and opposite the kitchen door, nine of them. ... As
to the possibility of cats or rats doing it: this is a new house.
. • . We have never seen or heard the slightest trace of a rat, nor
have we ever to our knowledge had a strange cat in ; nor, indeed,
could one, as far as I know, get into the floor anywhere. . . . The
bell hanger entirely agreed with me that it would be an impossibility for any animal, or even animals, to ring them all
as they were rung. ... I ought to say that the wires of the bells
distinctly pulled — it was not only the bells or clappers moving;
indeed, in one or two cases they could be heard grating under
the floor. The bell-handles were not moved
'' Next day Mrs. K. took the boys to service, and when they
came back . . . the cook told her (and I believe she is perfectly
trustworthy, as far as truthfulness goes) that soon after they
left the bells had begun to ring; two of them, at least, and so
violently that at last she got the steps and got two of the beUs
ofF. . . . After that they heard the wires pulled in the floor, &c.
''Then they went upstairs to do the bedrooms, Mary (the
housemaid) clinging to her, as she did all the time, being
too scared to go about by herself. When they had got halfway up the 'knocking' began, just as on the previous occasion, and as I had heard it, in sets of two and three quickly
repeated raps, or, rather, blows. They ran downstairs directly,
in a fright. At last they summoned courage enough to go
up, and going into the bedroom where two of the boys sleep
they found the hairbrush belonging to one of them on the
floor by the fireplace, smashed in half
"I cannot help now connecting the occurrences with the
housemaid. ... I am, as I have said, perfectly certain that she
had nothing to do voluntarily with the bell ringing; indeed, . . .
it would be literally impossible for her to ring the bells as they
were rung, even apart from any necessity to conceal the method
of doing so.
Ch. YIII]
Daniel Dunglas Home
106
" If any further proof of her freedom from complicity were
needed, her state on the Saturday night would be enough.
...She was delirious all night... till 4 in the morning ;.«•
dearly asleep, though most of the time her eyes were wide open,
I suppose in the ordinary , sonmambulist ' state. She talked
incessantly all night, very much about the bells, &c., and in such
a way as to show she was completely alarmed and terrified at
it. ...The occurrences have taken place almost always, if not
always, when she has been in a state of nervous excitement; . • .
she had been upset in her nerves for some days previously."
The phenomena so far cited have had nothing to do with
professional mediums or persons who could have had any
possible motive to deceive. There are on record hundreds
of cases from similar agents, but to quote more would tend
toward monotony: so let us proceed to allegations of even
more remarkable manifestations, from persons so unusually
endowed as to make them notorious, and not only objects of
legitimate curiosity, but important in the relation their per*
sonal qualities bear to the qualities of the phenomena. Therefore I will give some account of the principal ones as we
meet them.
Perhaps the most numerous and remarkable exhibitions of
queer things during the present cycle of them in America
and Europe, were given by Daniel Dunglas Home.
He was born in Scotland in 1833, brought to America
when nine years old, lived for some time in Norwich, Conn.,
and is alleged to have exhibited in many places in America
and Europe pretty much everything of the marvelous that
has been exhibited by anybody. In addition to such phenomena as those already described, he is credited, or charged,
with telepathy, telopsis (clairvoyance), prophecy, seeing and ",
conversing with spirits, spirit possession, healing, and a habit
of getting himself married and adopted by rich women. He
also had a remarkable power of ingratiating himself with
important people, even being a favorite at the courts of France
and Bussia.
Many of the claims made for and by him seem so extravagant, and one side of his life, as hinted toward the end
of the last paragraph, is so open to suspicion, that persons
who directly know nothing of superusual phenomena, are
tempted to dismiss all connected with him as humbug.
Before I read his autobiography (Incidents in My Life)
I thought of him as a modem Gagliostro, but even Cagliostro,
like pretty much everybody else, has lately been whitewashed;
and after carefully reading Home's book, which quotes from
competent sitters many accounts ranging from skepticism to
enthusiasm, I am inclined to think that he was about as
honest as a half-educated, ansmic, neurotic, woman-hunted
sentimentalist is able to be, and this opinion is concurred in
by nearly all the most able investigators, although Bobert
Browning, for instance, who certainly was not one of them,
based ', Sludge the Medium ', on Home. As my own observation forces me to accept some of these wonders, I do not
find it easy to determine where to draw the line at the
others. Some accounts of Home's are so full of gush as
to seem on their face worthless; but they are supported by
others from calm lawyers and men of science, which testify
to things just as marvelous as those recounted by the gushers*
Here is a description of Home's personality from Stainton
Moses (Fr. IX, 295) of whom an account will be given a few
pages further on.
"Mr. D. D. Home is a strikinfir-looking man. His head is
a good one. He shaves his face with the exception of a
moustache, and his hair is bushy and curly. He gives me
the impression of an honesty good person, whose intellect is
not of a high order. ...He resolutely refuses to believe in
anything that he has not seen for himself. For instance*
he refuses to believe in the passage of matter through matter,
and when pressed concludes the argument by saying, 'I have
never seen it.' . . . He accepts the theory of the return in
rare instances of the departed, but believes with me that
most of the manifestations proceed from a low order of spirits
who hover near the earth sphere. He does not believe in Mrs.
Quppy's passage through matter, nor in her honesty. He
thinks that regular manifestations are not possible. Consequently, he disbelieves public mediums generally. ... He said
he was thankful to know that his mantle had fallen on me,
and urged me to prosecute the inquiry and defend the faith.
Altogether he made quite an Elijah and Elisha business of
my reception. He plays and sings very nicely, and recites
well. He wore several handsome diamonds, gifts from royal
and distinguished persons. He is a thoroughly good, honest,
weak, and very vain man, with but little intellect, and no ability
to ajgue or defend his faith."
There is a very interesting account of Home's personal
character in Jour. S. P. B., VI, 107.
Sir William Crookes says {Researches in the Phenomena
of Spiritualism, p. 99) :
"Mr. Home has frequently been searched before and after
the ssances, and he always offers to allow it. During the most
remarkable occurrences I have occasionally held both his hands,
and placed my feet on his feet. On no single occasion hare
I proposed a modification of arrangements for the purpose of
rendering trickery less possible, which he has not at once
assented to, and frequently he has himself drawn attention to
tests which might be tried.
"I speak chiefly of Mr. Home, as he is so much more powerful than most of the otiber mediums I have experimented with.
But with all I have taken such precautions as to place trickery
out of the list of possible explanations."
The best evidential accounts of Home's phenomena, though
there have been many others, are those by Sir William Crookes.
On page 85 he gives the following instances of telekinetic
molar effects produced by Home. But before I quote them,
let me say that Sir William does not attribute them to
"spirits.*' His "researches" were into what others called
" spiritualism," not what he did. He says :
P. 85 : " Tables, chairs, sof as, etc., have heea moved when the
medium has not been touching them. ...I have had several
repetitions of the experiment considered by the Committee
of the Dialectical Society to be conclusive, vie., the movement
of a heavy table in full light, the chairs turned with their
backs on the table, about a foot off, and each person kueeling
on his chair, with hands resting over ibe baclra of the chair,
bttf not touching the table. On one occasion this took place
when I was moving about so as to see how every one was
placed
P. 88: "On five separate occasions, a heavy dining-table
rose between a few inches and one and a half feet off the floor,
under special circumstances, which rendered trickery imx>08sible. On another occasion, a heavy table rose from the floor
in full light, while I was holding the medium's hands and
feet On another occasion, the table rose from ttxe floor, not
only when no person was touching it, but under conditions
which I had prearranged so as to assure unquestionable proof
of the fact."
P. 90: "A medium, walking into my dining-room, cannot,
while seated in one part of the room witih a number of persons
keenly watching him, by trickery make an accordion play in
my own hand when I hold it key downwards, or cause the same
accordion to float about the room playing all the time." [The
character of the playing will be described later. H. H.] '' He
cannot introduce machinery which will wave window-curtains
or pull up Venetian blinds eight feet off, tie a knot in a handkerchief and place it in a far comer of the room, sound notes
on a distant piano, cause a card-plate to float about the room,
raise a water-bottle and timabler from the table, make a coral
necklace rise on end, cause a fan to move about and fan the
company, or set in motion a pendulum when enclosed in a
glass case firmly cemented to the walL"
Here are the particulars about the necklace, etc. (Fr.
VI, 113.) Miss Bird writes:—
"I remember the circumstances stated in this stance. I
had noticed that the necklace worn by Mrs. William Crookes
looked green. I asked her why her beads were green. She
assured me they were her corals, and to convince me the necklace was passed into my hands. Instead of passing the necklace back I simply put it opposite me in the middle of the
table. Almost as soon as I had placed the necklace it rose
in a spiral shape. I called out eagerly to my brother, Dr.
Bird, to look at the extraordinary conduct of the threaded
corals, and whilst I was endeavoring to get his attention the
erect necklace quietly subsided in a coil on the table. I have
often recalled the incident, and although a skeptic by instinct,
this one strange experience has made it impossible for me to
doubt the, assertions of others whose judgment is clear and
whose uprightness is above suspicion.
'AuoB L. Bird."
To this Dr. Bird adds:—
"I recollect my sister calling out to me: ,Look, look, at
the necklace,' but at that moment my attention was directed
elsewhere, and I did not actually see the phenomenon in
question.
"George Bird."
(C.) [I preface this paragraph with Sir William Crookes's
initial, and shall frequently preface other paragraphs similarly,
to indicate where the principal narrator takes up an interrupted
theme. H. H.] ''At the moment this occurred I was writing
my notes and only caught sight of the necklace as it was settling down from its first movement. It made one or two slight
movements afterwards, and, as I state, it seemed to me as if
it had been moved from below. I mentioned this at the time
and was then told by Miss Bird and others that the necklace
had behaved as is now described by her. Not having seen it
myself, I did not alter the statement in my note-book."
Sir William published in the Quarterly Journal for Science
for July 1, 1871, an account of some experiments carefully and
frequently repeated in his laboratory, which demonstrated that
Home could greatly increase or decrease the weight of a body
by touching it He later describes an experiment in which
Home conveyed pressure not by touching the object moved,
but merely by touching water that was in contact with the
object, and later still without any contact whatever with anything related to the object moved, unless with the air and
the ether. A description of the apparatus is given, but is not
easy for the non-technical reader to understand. It can be
found by the few who would study it, in the Journal for
Science or in Mr. (as he was then) Crookes's book, the
Beaearches, already cited.
His dealings with his opponents, especially on pp. 46-8,
are almost as interesting — ,perhaps to the average reader
more interesting, than his accounts of his experiments.
He offered no explanation of the phenomena, simply attributed them to a mode of force previously unknown, which
he suggested should be termed Psychic, and called upon his
scientific brethren and all persons interested to assist in its
investigation.
The accounts, though they were subsequently confirmed
by Mr. Huggins, the astronomer royal, and Mr. E. W. Cox,
an eminent sergeant at law, were received with much de«
rision. The author was called a spiritualist; explanations
more improbable than the facts were offered by various persons, scientific and non-scientific; the author's farther papers
on tiie subject were rejected by the Boyal Society; sundry
proceedings were taken by members of the Society for which
the Society later passed a formal resolution of regret; and
the whole affair was one of the most discreditable in the
annals of science, except where science has been identified with
theology.
Sir William gave very full details of all the experiments
and their reception. He said {Researches, p. 40) :
"In the case of Mr. Home, the development of this force
varies enormously, not only from week to week, but from hour
to hour; on some occasions the force is imappreciable by my
tests for an hour or more, and then suddezdy reappears in
great strength. It is capable of acting at a distance from
Mr. Home (not infrequently as far as two or three feet)> but
is always strongest close to him."
(Op. cit., 10): ''It has but seldom happened that a result
obtained on one occasion could be subsequently confirmed and
tested with apparatus especially contrived for the purpose.
(Op, cit, 16-17): ''A committee of scientific men met Mr.
Home some months ago at St. Petersburg. They had one
meeting only, which was attended with negative results; and
on the strength of this they published a report highly unf avor*
able to Mr. Home. The explanation of this failure, which
is all they have accused him of, appears to me quite simple.
Whatever the nature of Mr. Home's power, it is very variable,
and at times entirely absent. It is obvious that the Russian
experiment was tried when the force was at a minimum. The
same thing has frequently happened within my own experience. A party of scientific men met Mr. Home at my house,
and the results were as negative as those at St. Petersburg.
Instead, however, of throwing up the inquiry, we patiently
repeated the trial a second and a third time, when we met
with results which were positive.
"To witness exhibitions of this force it is not necessary
to have access to known psychics. The force itself is probably possessed by all human beings, although the individuals
endowed with an extraordinary amount of it are doubtless
few. Within the last twelve months I have met in private
families five or six persons possessing a sufficiently vigorous
development to make me feel confident that similar results
might be produced through their means to those here recorded,
provided the experimentalist worked with more delicate apparatus, capable of indicating a fraction of a grain instead
of recording pounds and ounces only.
"Being firmly convinced that there could be no manifestation of one form of force without the corresponding expenditure of some other form of force, I for a long time searched
in vain for evidence of any force or power being used up in
the production of these results.
"Now, however, ... after witnessing the painful state of
nervous and bodil, prostration in which some of these exI>eriment8 have left Mr. Home — after seeing him lying in
an almost fainting condition on the floor, pale and speechless —
I could scarcely doubt that the evolution of psychic force is
accompanied by a corresponding drain on vital force." [The
reader will remember the similar cases already given. H.H.]
" I have ventured to give this new force the name of Psychic
Force, because of its manifest relationship to certain psychological conditions."
He farther quoted seyeral eminent men of science as
having reached by experiment conclusions similar to his own,
of whom one, M. Thury, Professor at the Academy of Geneva,
had, as early as 1855, proposed for the newly manifested force
the name edenic, because it acted in extemo — at a distance,
without contact.
Since then, however, the name telekinetic seems to have
been settled upon by common use, though it is far from a
fortunate name: for several forces already correlated are
telekinetic
At the dispersal of the library of my late friend Dr. Bichard
Hodgson, Secretary of the American Branch of the Society
for Psychical Besearch, there came into my possession a little
book now out of print, called "The Salem Seer. Beminiscences of Charles H. Foster, by George C. Bartlett" The
subject of this book was very well known from about 1865
to 1880. He traveled freely in America, England, and
Australia, received all comers, and had a business agent —
the author of the little book referred to.
Thirty years ago I should have hesitated to quote from
this book, because few of its accounts have the standard of
authenticity then considered essential. Of most of the events
Mr. Bartlett, the author, who was generally present, is the
only known witness, the other witnesses generally being newspaper reporters whose names are not given; but of course
the presumption is that they saw what they reported, so that
the testimony approaches very close to the standard two
mutually confirmatory witnesses, and some of it is highly
intelligent. Few of the witnesses were professed spiritualists,
and nearly all of them began by doubting. Mr. Bartlett also
quotes not a few who continued to doubt, and gives other
evidence of his own sincerity. His book was probably not
composed in awe of literary criticism, but is ingenuous to a
degree that encourages confidence — ,not the most " scientific ,
of evidence; but the skepticism regarding the phenomena
to-day ia rather regarding their alleged spiritistic source
than their genuineness.
In regard to Mr. Bartletfs testimony, moreover, it is to
be said that he is still living — at Tolland, Connecticut, where
he enjoys the confidence and respect of his neighbors, and
where, though he has about reached his threescore years and ten,
he is much given to playing tennis. We have exchanged several
letters, and he called upon me during a recent visit to New
York. I do not often meet a man who inspires me with as
much confidence in his sincerity. It does not detract from
the weight of his evidence that, notwithstanding the marvels
it contains, he does not accept the spiritistic solution.
But even assuming the accounts given and quoted by him
to be unreliable, they describe occurrences so much like many
later ones which have been abundantly verified, that they are
almost as safe to reason or guess from.
It is further to be said that the evidence now necessary
to make one of these stories worth attention, is small beside
what was necessary before the S. P. B. had accumulated such
overwhelming evidence of similar occurrences.
Now the burden of proof is rather on those who deny than on those who
assert. I find that those who deny are almost invariably
those who never saw the phenomena at all. So true is this,
that now when I find anybody vociferously denying the possibility of such things, and ask him if he ever saw any
manifestation of them from accredited agents, I expect a
negative answer, and am seldom disappointed. I have met
people who say: *'0h, Foster is entirely discredited,'' and
so far, not one of them had ever seen a manifestation of the
strange powers from him or anybody else.
Mr. Bartlett says that Foster spent a long time with
Bulwer, and was the original of '' Margrane ', in A Strange
Story.
Bartlett says {op. cit, 24, 38, 49) :
"Mediums who can easily become entranced, or be controlled
successfully by this mysterious influence, can as easily be controlled bytheir associates in this life. ... If their associations are
in the higher and better walks of life, their lives will average
well. On the contrary, if they are associated with the immoral,
they are easily led down the stream. It has been my observation
that when a man or woman has been controlled by these peculiar
influences, they are inclined to be weak, dissipated, and immoral. Th, are almost invariably kind-hearted, generous, and
childlike."
Those of sufficient importance to be investigated by the
S. P. B. have been very decent people, — perhaps partly from
being in such good company, and some of the heteromatie
writers of the yeiy highest character and attainments. Bart,
lett goes on :
"It has been said, 'Money flowed into his coffers like water,
and as freely flowed out, leaving nothing behind.' I wish to
state most emphatically that not a dollar did Mr. Foster squander in gambling. . . . While he had many faults, gambling was
not one of them. He did not even know the Ace of Spades from
the Queen of Hearts , [which is much more than can be said of
the researchers into Thought Transference — or of the present
writer on these profundities. HLH.].
Bartlett continues:
" Foster stood apart from all men. • . . While he was like others
he was also peculiarly unlike all others. He was extravagantly
dual He was not only Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, but he represented half-a-dozen different Jekylls and Hydes. . . . He was an
unbalanced genius, and at times, I should say, insane. He had
a heart so large indeed that it took in the world : tears for the
afflicted; money for the poor; the chords of his heart were
touched by every sigh. At other times, his heart shrunk up
until it disappeared. He would . . . with the petulance of a child
. . . abuse his best friends. He wore out many of his friends. . . .
He was not vicious, but absolutely uncontrollable. He would
go his own way, which way was often the wrong way. Like a
child he seemed to have no forethought. He seemed to live for
to-day, caring nothing for to-morrow. . . . He seemed impervious
to the opinions of others, and apparently yielded to every desire ;
but after all he did not abuse himself much, as he continued in
perfect health until the final breaking up.''
The sort of stock he came of is interestingly indicated by
Bartlett (op. cit., 44-5) :
"The next day we left for Salem. Mr. Foster's father was
a particularly kind and pleasing man, without guile, and in
his younger days followed the sea. We were sitting together
one morning . . . [when] he remarked that he had passed a
bad night... I inquired what was the matter? He replied
that Aunt Bessie had annoyed him and mother (his wife)
all night. I replied that I had heard Charles speak frequently
of Aunt Bessie, but I had supposed she had died some years
ago. 'Oh, yes,' he said, 'but she keeps coming back at night;
goes in and out of our room, pulls open the bureau drawers,
and fusses over her old things.' He continued, 'We have
asked her repeatedly to keep away, and not disturb us while
we were sleeping, but every little while she comes back and
makes a night of it.' Very innocently he said to me, ' Do you
not see spiritst' 'Why no,' I said, 'certainly not' He replied that he did, and that he supposed every one did. That
his family had ever since he could remember, and that he did
not suppose his family differed in that respect from other
families. I certainly think he was perfectly sincere, and that
he saw visions. His wife, Mrs. Foster, mother of GharleSt
told me she had talked wi, spirits aU her life, and that her
mother and father also conversed with them. She said when
Charles was a baby that she was too poor to hire a girl, and
having to do her own work her spirit friends often came to
her the
assistance,
and hear
that them
they had
Charlie's
cradle
by
hour. To
speakoften
of rocked
the other
life, and
of
their communications with those who had passed to the other
shore, made the intercourse between the two worlds seem as
real as between Europe and America.''
This is telekinesis with a vengeance. I incline to assume
that Mrs. Foster supplied the force. That assumption may
not appear so strange later, as it does now.
I had a stance with Foster in the early seventies, which
will be described later under Telepathy. At that stance there
were no phenomena of the mysterious force that had been exhibited before me by
P-, but there were other phenomena
even more remarkable, and I was impressed that Foster was
honest, and had powers beyond the recognized normal.
Of virtually all the strange kinds of phenomena that we
shall meet, there are many weU authenticated instances on
record. In selecting typical ones, I shall sometimes venture
to select Foster's, so far as they cover the ground, despite
his being a ''paid medium" (as, for that matter, is Mrs.
Piper), and despite his manifestations having transpired too
early to be passed upon by the S. P. B., or any other authoritative body. At the same time, I don't ask anybody to believe
everything in them : even regarding some of the very passages
I quote, my own judgment is certainly very much in reserve.
I shall take more illustrations from Foster than I otherwise
would, for the additional reason that the testimony regarding other leading "mediums" is easily accessible elsewhere,
while that regarding Foster is not; also because I know from
personal observation, if I know anything, that he showed to
me some of the powers as yet called supernormal; I wish
anybody disposed to scout my quoting a book perhaps purposely neglected by more competent vmters, might read it.
This is quoted by Bartlett (op. cit, p. 112) from Ashbumer'B Notes and Studies in the Philosophy of Animal
Magnetism and Spiritualism, in which are many references
to Foster. The phenomena took place without Foster being
in contact with the objects.
" The table was lifted into the air, and remained there for
some seconds. Then, it gently descended into the place it had
before occupied, with the difference that the top was turned
downwards, and rested on the carpet. . . . Some busts, as laige
as life, resting upon book-cupboards seren feet high, were taken
from their places. One was suddenly put upon Mrs. W. C/s lap;
others, on my obtaining a lights were found on the table."
The very simple molar phenomena already described are
among the first of a series which merge, as do all things
in nature, by insensible degrees into something very different
— ,in this case into psychical phenomena. The course of this
merging which I shall try to follow in the treatment (though
the topics are so mixed with each other that so doing
is not always possible) is molar-physical; molecular-physicid
— ,including materialization and levitation; molar-psychical,
including alleged communications by moving heavy objects; molecular-psychical, including alleged communications
through raps, lights, and sounds.
This will eventually bring us into the psychic universe,
where we will unroll a fresh chart
First a few more cases of molar telekinesis :
From Bartlett {op. cit., 112) :
"About 12 o'clock one summer night we met Oregon Wilson
and one or two friends on Broadway. Mr.. Wilson, as usual,
was in a lively frame of mind, and insisted upon our going
to his studio to look at some new curios. . . . This, however,
was only a pretext, as his real object was to induce Mr.
Foster to give some physical manifestations. ... He had often
tried to persuade Mr. Foster to give him and his friends
a dark stance; but Mr. Foster had always refused. We had
been in the studio a few moments only when Mr. Wilson
turned off the gas without giving any warning, and we were
in utter darkness. What occurred that night will not be forgotten by any of us, for it seemed for a few moments as
tiiough Ihe world had come to an end; that the building had
been blown up by dynamite, or that an earthquake was upon
us I It seemed as though everything in the studio would be
broken and ruined. Even I was frightened, for it seemed as
though there was danger of being hurt. We simultaneously
said, 'Wilson, light the gas/ and when the gas was lighted,
we found only a few things disarranged; and it is a mystery
to this day how to account for the hurluhrelu. Poor Foster
was faint. He could hardly stand, was pale as death, and
there was a cold perspiration on his forehead." [Compare
this with P-,'s and Miss A.'s exhaustion after their manifestation. We shall meet many similar experiences. H. H.]
. . . "I know positively that no amount of money would induce
Mr. Foster to sit in the dark for the purpose of producing
physical manifestations. He did not wish to stand the pressure,
and while we might say his reason was not afraid, his heart
was."
This matter of the light may be of much importance. I
do not recall another case where darkness has caused the
medium suffering, but on the other hand, all through the
literature of the subject there seems some incompatibility
between light and the phenomena. The incompatibility is
obvious where fraud is att,empted, but many experiences besides Foster's look as if there were some reason better than
fraud. Light is by no means always inimical: it was not
in my experience or my sister's, or in many, perhaps most,
of those connected with the supposedly honest ''mediums.''
Sir William Crookes says (op. cit, p. 85) :
"It is a well-ascertained fact that when the force is weak,
a bright light exerts an interfering action on some of the
phenomena. The power possessed by Mr. Home is sufficiently
strong to withstand this antagonistic influence; consequently,
he always objects to darkness at his seances. Indeed, except
on two occasions, when, for some particular experiments of
my own, light was excluded, everything which I have witnessed
with him has taken place in the light. I have had many
opportunities of testing the action of light of different sources
and colors, such as sunlight, diffused daylight, moonlight,
gas, lamp, and candle light, electric light from a vacuum
tube, homogeneous yellow light, etc. The interfering rays
appear to be those at the extreme end of the spectrum."
Bartlett gives another astounding account of telekinesis
{op. cit, 44) :
"The day before Mr. Foster left for his summer home in
Salem, Mass., he purchased two empty champagne baskets for
the purpose of packing therein his extra luggage. We were
both awakened that night ... there was a terrible commotion.
The champagne baskets commenced running around the room*
They flew up in the air, crashing against each other, ... and
in shorter time than it takes to relate it, all the chairs were
piled upon our bed. No harm was done, however."
The bell-ringing on page 104 and Foster's champagne
baskets and the racket in Wilson's studio remind one of the
alleged performances of the poltergeists (riotous ghosts) of
which the literature of the subject is full. An interesting
collection, with criticisms, is given by Mr. Podmore in Pr.
XII, 45ff.*
Poltergeists have been regarded with much skepticism, but
as the phenomena attributed to them are more and more
noticed to happen only when certain individuals (mediums?)
are present, the doings are likely to find a place under
recognized telekinetic phenomena. It may even be granted
that my friend P
was a ',polterer'' when he (or we?)
broke tiie music-stand, and Foster certainly was when he had
the rackets just recounted. In fact, telekinetic manifestations shade off from simple table-tippings to those alleged
wild riots of flying objects of all sorts. There is, however, a
pretty definite class of these latter occurring generally in the
presence of the uneducated, starting with the pranks of
children or servants, and upsetting the judgment and exciting
the imagination of superstitious and excitable people who
tell wondrous stories, and whose excitement reacts upon and
stimulates the original perpetrators.
(Note: And here let me introduce Mr. Podmore. He was among the most
active of the S. P. R., and from the first till his death in 1911 the skeptical critic. His prlDcipal works are Modern Bpiritualiim (1902) and
Ths Newer Spiriiualiem (1911), largely a repetition of the former. Bu,
despite their titles, the author was no spiritualist.
like Myers' great book, to be described later, these digest the Pr. S.
P. R., but not nearly so completely, and they go farther mto the early
phenomena kindred to those there recounted. He also published
Studies in I,ehical Research, Apparitions and ThougJU Trantferenee,
and Naturdtssaiion of the Supernatural, and contributed very voluminously tothe Pr. S. P. R. In the consistories where attempts have been
made to give the sanctity of spiritualism to our phenomena, he steadily
bore the part of devil's advocate, and he performed it with rare laborlousness, conscientiousness, and skill. Being human, he did not entirely
rise superior to bias. Up to his death, however, his skepticism was
gradually giving way, his last noteworthy expression, near the end of
The Newer
Spiritualism,'Mjag',
"If we reject,from
for the
the dead
present,
any
rate,
the explanation
... of communication
. . .atthere
remains only the agency which has been provisionally named telepathy." He puts tdekinesis and telepsychosis in the same boat, as the
work of alleged spirits, while in my opinion the indications that telekinesis has anything to do with spirits, except as all consciousness and
all force may be one, are not worth considering, while the indications
that some telepeychoses have to do with postcamate intelligence, are
well worth considering.)
The next medium from whom I shall draw some illustrations possessed, of all yet known, the greatest combination of
high gifts with high privil,,es of education, social opportunity,
and social endorsement. I refer to William Stainton Moses.
I go into considerable detail r,arding him, as he will appear
in our investigations more frequently and, on the whole, with
perhaps more importance, than either Foster or Home. And
yet by an irony of fate, the testimony to his manifestations is
perhaps less satisfactory than in the case of the others. He led
a very retired life and had few sitters, though they were of high
character. The accounts of his experiences are mainly in his
own note-books, and are so marvelous, but at the same time
so apparently honest, and so well vouched for, that one is
sometimes tempted to think: Perhaps he dreamt it And yet
his part in the Fr. S. F. B., whether for or against spiritism,
is too important to ignore. The following particulars are
condensed Itobol an account by F. W. H* Myers * :
(Note: *Myers was perhaps, up to his death in 1901, the most active contribator to the Pr. S. JP. R., and his aUeged spirit has been very active
since. He left a work which many reeard as monumental, called
Human Pisnanality andlU Jdurtrival nf Bodily Death, This work di£»ted the fourteen volumes of Proceedings which had then accumuted. Its interpretations are frankly spiritistic, and it is constructive
rather than critical: in fact, the author is often charged with having, in
matters of evidence, entirely subordinated the critical sense to his spiritistic convictions. He must at least have felt a temptation that I have
felt in the present work, and sometimes yielded to, to admit questionable evidence pretty freely 'vriien it accords with established evidence,
but keeping the reader fairly apprised of its nature, and letting him
Judge it for himself. Myers was no mean scholar and poet, and the
beautiful style of his magnum opui often breeds a concurrence that
its unassisted arguments might not always sustain.
This book is much the most thorough and elaborate of all the text
Writings from the S. P. R. evidence. It so arranges all the matter as
to build up a systematic argument for the survival of the personally.
Podmore*s works constitute a running commentary upon the Pr. S. P.
R., with extracts from the beginning through Vol. aXIV, which was
the
d before his death* Myen' book goes only through
Vol. XIV.)
Moees was bom in England in 1839, of an old Linoolnshire
family (not, as the name suggests, a Jewish one). His
father had been headmaster of a grammar school. The boy
was given to sleep-walking and writing essays — ,good ones for
a boy — ,in his sleep. Though fairly robust, he broke down
in health at Oxford, and left without graduating. During
some time of wandering he spent six months in a monastery
on Mount Athos. He regained his health, returned to Oxford,
took his degree, was ordained, and at twenty-four became a
curate on the Isle of Man. From ,63 to '70 he was a good
and self-sacrificing clergyman, beloved by his people, when
an attack of whooping cough interfered with his preaching,
which he relinquished permanently. He took a mastership
in University College School and held it for nearly twenty
years till his health broke down finally about 1889. He
died in 189S.
Myers says (Pr. IX, 250 et seq.) :
"The physical phenomena about to be described began in
1872, and continued with gradually lessening frequency until
1881. The automatic script began in 1878, and findly died out,
so far as we know, in 1883. During these later years Mr.
Moses was active in contributing to, and afterwards in editing, the weekly newspaper Light; and he took a leading part
in several spiritistic oiganizations. Of one of these — ,the London Spiritualist Alliance — ,he was president at the time of his
death. In 1882 he aided in the foundation of the Society for
Psychical Besearch; but he left that body in 1886, on account
of its attitude towards Spiritualism, which he regarded as
unduly criticaL It is worth remarking that although, as the
fact of his withdrawal shows, many members of the Society
held an intellectual position widely differing from that of
Mr. Moses, and although his own published records were of
a kind not easily credible, no suspicion as to his personal
probity and veracity was ever, so far as I know, either expressed
or entertained.
" Mr. Moses never married, and went very little into general
society. His personal appearance offered no indication of his
peculiar gift. He was of middle stature, strongly made, with
somewhat heavy features, and thick dark hair and beard. . • .
His expression of ooontenanoe was honest, manly, and resolute.
'' Dr. Johnson, of Bedford, writes to me:
''68, Higb''Ma
-street,
Bedf,ord.
rch 24th
1898.
"Dear Sir,— As the intimate friend and medical adviser
of the late Stainton Moses I have had ample opportunities of
thoroughly knowing his character and his mental state.
"He was a man even in temper, painstaking and methodi*
eal, of exceptional ability, and utterly free from any hallucination or anything to indicate other than a well-ordered
brain
"I have attended him in several very severe illnesses, but
never, in sickness or at other times, has his brain shown the
sL'ghtest cloudiness or suffered from any delusion.
"Wm. G. Johnson."
, University College School, Gower-stieet,"Ma
London,
0.
y 16thW.
, 1898
"Dear Sir, — . . • He always impressed me with
idea that
be was thoroughly earnest and conscientious, and Ithebelieve
that
perfect reliance can be placed on all his statements. — ,Yours
faithfully,
" F. W. Levander."
Myers says elsewhere (Pr. IX, 253) :
" I have heard him described as lacking in the grace of humility, and in that spirituality of tastes and character which
should seem appropriate to one living much in the commerce
of the ITnseen. But I have never heard anyone who had even
the slightest acquaintance with Mr. Moses impugn his sanity
or his sincerity, his veracity or his honor.
" With the even tenor of this straightforward and reputable
life was inwoven a chain of mysteries which, as I have before
said, in what way soever they be explained, make that life one
of the most extraordinary which our century has seen
"For almost all the sittings which he describes, and for
some which he does not describe, there is ... a second detailed, independent, contemporary record, by Mrs. Stanhope
Speer, and for many of the sittings a tjiird record, also
independent and contemporaneous, although very brief»
by Dr. Speer. For some few of them there is also a similar reconi by Mr. Percival, whose memory also confirms
the other accounts. Parts of Mr. Moses' own record, indeed,
are avowedly derived from the other sitters, since he depended
upon tiiem for information as to what went on when he was
in trance. But he has always, I think, made this distinction
dear in his notes.
" The evidence for all the incidents is practically the same;—*
the whole group of witnesses are as fully pledged, say to the
falling of pearls from the air as to the automatic script of the
trance-i,ienomena. I at least can see no via media which can
be plausibly taken. The permanent fraud of the whole group,
or the substantial accuracy of all the records, are ihe on,
hypotheses which seem to me capable of covering the facts.
"Some dozen other persons, who cannot plausibly be held
to be all in the fraud, witnessed the phenomena. It is true
that some of these witnesses are now dead or inaccessible.
But Serjeant Cox left a printed statement; Dr. Thomson, ci
Clifton, proved his belidE, by continued collaboration; Mr.
Percival, Mrs. Oarratt, Miss Collins, and Mrs. Honeywood
are still living, and cannot with, any plausibility be treated
as accomplices. Mr. Percival's evidence, in particular, is that
of an outside and occasional member of the group, who is
honorably known in academic and official life, and who would
have had everything to lose and nothing to gain by complicity
in such a fraud.
"...[Moses] was very reticent about exhibiting his powers,
and consequently almost the only records are his own and
those of his physician. Dr. Stanhope Speer, Mrs. Speer, and
their son, Mr. Charlton T. Speer, Associate of the Royal Academy of Music — ,all persons of undoubted capacity and probity
" Dr. Speer's cast of mind was thoroughly materialistic, and
it is remarkable that his interest in Mr. Moses' phenomena
was from first to last of a purely scientific, as contrasted with
an emotional or religious nature."
In another place, however, Myers says of Moses (Pr. YIII,
699):
"He lacked — and he readily and repeatedly admitted to me
that he lacked — all vestige of scientific, or even of legal, instinct.
The very words 'first-hand evidence,' 'contemporary record,'
'corroborative testimony,' were to him as a weariness to the
flesh. His attitude was that of the preacher who is already
so thoroughly persuaded in his own mind that he treats any
alleged fact which falls in with his views as the uncriticised
text for fresh exhortation. ... Having watched his conduct at
critical moments, I see much groimd for impugning his judgment, but no ground whatever for doubting that he has narrated
with absolute good faith the story of his experience."
(Pr.IX,258) : '' The phenomena here to be described, strange
• , . as they often seem, cannot be called meaningless. The alleged
operators are at pains throughout to describe what they regarded as the end, and what merely as the means to that end.
Their constantly avowed object was the promulgation through
Mr. Moses of certain religious and philosophical views; and
the physical manifestations are throughout described as design, merely as a proof of power, and a basis for the
authority claimed for the serious teachings."
In some of the molecular phenomena, especially those of
light, as will be seen later, the claims made for and by
Moses, surpass those made for or by Foster and Home. But
the molar telekinetic phenomena were not as prominent with
Moses as with the others, or as his molecular phenomena;
in fact he records his dislike , to violent physical manifestations.', More on this subject will appear later.
Detailed accounts of all classes are given by Myers in
Pr. IX and XI. I will give but a line to the molar in the
following scraps from Moses' note-books (quoted in Fr. XI,
34 and 266) :
"As soon as the gas was put out, a book from a closed
cupboard at the comer farthest from me, and immediately
behind Dr. Speer, was brought out and struck him on the
shoulder, and fell near Mrs. S. This is the first attempt to
bring an object from behind a sitter opposite to me. Usually
the power seems to be behind me. ...The objects come over
my head when brought into the room, and movements of
articles occur behind and near me. [Sounds occur] behind
and near me usually, though at times . . . far away.
" My records of stances during the latter half of the month
of August show over fifty instances in which objects from
different parts of the house were placed upon the table round
which we were sitting. They were invariably small, and were
generally thrown on the table."
The records of Stainton Moses in Pr. IX, 269-72 contain
accounts of his having, without any muscular action, brought
from unknown sources into his stance rooms, and there scattered, bits of coral, seed pearls, powdered musk, and some
aerial perfumes. This was done in dim light and sometimes
with the " cabinet " of the fake mediums. But the character
of Moses and of his witnesses makes it difiScult to believe the
phenomena fraudulent, and that they were not illusory is
proved, I tmderstand, by some of the articles being kept by
persons present.
Moses quotes Judge Edmunds in his book on Spiritualism,
as bearing witness to odors being brought into ''spiritual"
seances, without any visible mechanical agency.
Breezes are very frequently alleged to accompany other telekinetic phenomena.
CHAPTIB IX
MOLAR TELEKINESIS(continued)
Dawsing
Molar Telekinesis I venture tentatively to include
another strange mode of force that has long been known, but
manif estedy so far as I know, by none of the ', mediums '' of
other modes so far treated, and indeed by so few people as to
be little credited. It appears to have some telekinetic qualities.
To the modem mind, it may seem to find one pole in the
system of an occasional human being, and the other in one
of sundry inorganic substances, including especially running
water. The passing of the current between the two poles
is not always dependent on any intermediate conductor, any
more than when ordinary magnetism passes between two
separated pieces of iron, or telekinesis between a meditim
(using the word merely as medium of a force, not of any
alleged spiritual communication) and an untouched object
But these alleged manifestations are said to be sometimes
facilitated by a rod of wood or metal between the poles;
and indeed to be with some '' mediums'' sometimes possible
with that intermediary, and impossible without it.
Note here the fact that the recognized telekincftic force _
seems sometimes to have its non-human pole in wood, as in
P-' case, and wooden-table-tipping . generally f or in
mineral, as in Miss A.'s marble-topped table and olliers. We
shall later apparently find one in metal.
Where rods of wood have served as conductors, the force
has deflected them sometimes strongly enough to crack or
break tfatm. To the person participating, the flow of the
current has generally, but not always, been accompanied
by fatigue, as in other exercises of the tdekinetic power, and ,
frequently by nausea and other physical discomforts, apparently more than in
the other manifestations of the power.
,
Most readers have anticipated that the forgoing para198 into , scientific', shape the
graphs are an attempt to put
performances of the ,, dowsers " who for centuries have been
alleged to discoyer springs and metals underground.
My guess at the kinship of the phenomena with those of
teleldnesis is, however, as will be explained later, at variance
with the guesses of some of the theorists, but not with the
impressions of nearly, if not quite all, of the actors and most
of the observers; and I suspect that the discoveries reported
in the Fr. S. P. B. have niaterially affected the later guesses
of the theorists.
Now the above allegations, like nearly all allegations of
things unknown to general experience, have very properly
been flouted by the vast majority of laymen who have not witnessed the occurrences, and accounted for by some scientists
who have, on various hypotheses less probable than that the
phenomena really indicate something new. But that fashion
of accounting for things has been losing popularity since
'U, Edison, Bell, and Marconi. Dowsing, however, happens to
/I) . have been certified to by, among others, so eminent a physicist
as Professor (now Sir William) Barrett, after a very thorough
investigation, which he reported in Pr. XIII and XV, and
by other eminent men of science, among them Dr. Rossiter
Baymond, Secretary of the American Institute of Mining
Engineers, and several Fellows of the Boyal and Oeographical
Societies of England.
Professor Barrett says (Pr. XIII, 2f.) :
''At first sight few subjects appear to be so unworthy of
serious notice and so utterly beneath scientific investigation.
...Nevertheless, it is impossible to read the voluminous evidenc,. . . without coming to the conclusion . . . that the evidence
for the success of ' dowsing ' as a practical art is very strong —
and there seems to be an unexplained residuum when all possible
deductions have been made.
"In 1814, Dr. 0. Hutton, P. R S., after examining the
then accessible evidence ... and witnessing Lady Milbanke's
success with the rod, published a statement of his own belief in the practical value of the divining rod, though unable to explain its behavior. And recently, in 1883, Dr. R Raymond read a paper before the American Institute of Mining Engineers in which, after considerable investigation, the
conclusion is arrived at : ' That there is a residuum of scientific
value, after making all necessary deductions for exaggeration,
self-deception, and fraud...
"In like manner, it is impossible to study this subject
historically without being impressed by the number of Uiose
who have accepted as indisputable the practical value of the
rod, during the four centuries it has been in use. ...Among
them were some of the most learned writers and the most
painstaking investigators of their day, together with an array
of practical miners and well-sinkers, men who ought to have
known what they were talking about
"At the present day, as in the past, those who have had
the opportunity of examining most closely the practical use
of the Mowser's art' are not to be found among the scoffers.
The opinion expressed to me by many well-infonned and
critical observers who live in that region of the southwest of
England where the ' rod ' has been longest in use, ... is by no
means contemptuous or even unfavorable. ... With some, like
the late John Mullins, the number of failures seems to have been
very few ; with others, . . . far more frequent. This is what might
be expected if there be a peculiar instinct or faculty in certain
persons which is not common to alL Moreover, as an easy way
of earning a living without the trouble of any education, the
class of professional dowsers is sure to be recruited by a number
of rogues and charlatans. ... It will also be noticed that a ' dowaing faculty,' if such there be, is not confined to any particular
age, sex, or class of society. Thus in case No. 1," [as nimibered in Prof. Barrett's article. H.H.] ',the dowser was a
clergyman; in No. 2, a judge; in No. 8, a local manufacturer;
in Nos. 4, 13, 14, 18, and 19, a lady; in Nos. 5 and 9, a gardener; in No. 6, a deputy-lieutenant; in No. 8, a respected
member of the Society of Friends; in No. 12, a miller; in
No. 10, a little girl; in Nos. 11 and 16, a boy; in No. 20, a
French count, etc. ...In the lengthy list of those who have
employed him [Mullins] to find water, and have been led by
actual experience to have faith in the dowsing rod, will be
found nearly a score of distinguished noblemen, more than a
dozen owners of breweries and distilleries, or of paper and
doth mills and print works; town commissioners, and clergymen; and landlords and their agents by the dozen."
Professor Barrett's second paper says (Pr. XV, 136) :
"Upwards of 200 cases of water-finding by dowsers in
recent years have been investigated; in each case the independent evidence of disinterested persons ... was sought. Generally speaking, such evidence was obtained, the witnesses
allowing their names and addresses to be given. ... Omitting
a remarkably successful series of cases by an American dowser,
which Dr. Hodgson kindly investigated, 105 cases of British
professional dowsers were given in my former paper; of these
"
95 were successful and 10 were failures
"Pr. II also coontains confirmatory papers on the same subject by Professor W. J. Sollas and Messrs. Edward B. Pease
and E. Yanghan Jenkins. Mr. Jenkins collected in eighteen
months twenty-two well authenticated cases of successful
dowsing.
"In an article published in Light for August 4th, I&88, p.
849, it is stated that Professor Lochman, of the TTniversity of
Christiania, who is described as a distinguished phyaiologisty
recently read a paper on the divining rod before a scientific
society in Christiania, in which he stated that his skepticism
on this subject had lately been overcome by the discovery
"
that he himself could use the rod successfully
From a letter to Professor Barrett by Mr. H. W. Whitaker,
a well-known geologist, whom Professor Barrett calls ,'an
utter disbeliever in the dowsing-rod, or in any practical good
resulting from its use'* (Fr. XIII, 76) :
"John Mullins, . . • if allowed to follow the indication of
his rod, agreed, I understood, to receive no payment for sinking a well if a good supply of water were not obtained. When
one remembers the heavy outlay involved in making a wdl,
often through solid rock to a depth of 70 to 100 feet, or more,
this agreement is a forcible illustration of the faith Mullins
had in his divining rod
"I will now give some typical cases. The Hon. M. E. O.
Finch Hatton, M.P., writes thus of an experience with Mullins
(Fr. II, 101) :
" 23 Ennismore Oardens, S. W., February 29th, 1884.
"First he cut a forked twig from a living tree, and
held it between his hands, the center point downwards and
the two ends protruding between the fingers of each hand. He
then stooped forward and walked over the ground to be tried.
Suddenly he would stop and the central point would revolve
in a half-circle until it pointed the reverse way. This he
stated to be owing to the presence of a subterranean spring,
and further that by the strength of the movement he could
gage the approximate depth.
"My brother, Hon. Harold Finch Hatton, and I each took
hold of one of the ends, protruding as stated above, and held
tiiem fast while the phenomenon took place, to make sure that
it was not caused by a movement, voluntary or otherwise, of
the man's own hand or fingers. The tendency to twist itself,
on the twig's part, was so great that, on our holding firmly
on to the ends, the twig split and finally broke off. The same
thing oocuired when standing on a bridge over a running
stream.
"Stagnant water, he states, has no effect on the twig
''On our way to the kitchen garden Mullins discovered a
spring on the open lawn, whose existence was unknown to
me, it had been closed in so long, but was subsequently
attested by an old laborer on the place who remembered it
as a well, and had seen it bricked in many years before. On
reaching the kitchen garden I knew that a lead pipe, leading
water to a tap outside the wall, crossed the gravel path at
a certain spot. On crossing it the twig made no sign. I was
astonished at first, till I remembered what Mullins had said
about stagnant water, and that the tap was not running. I
sent to have it turned on, reconducted Mullins over the
ground, when the twig immediately indicated the spot.
" When Mullins had passed on, I carefully marked the exact
spot indicated by the twig. When he had left the garden, I
said, 'Now, Mullins, may we blindfold you and let you tryt'
He said, 'Oh yes, if you don't lead me into a pond or anything of that sort.' We promised. Several skeptical persons
were present who took care the blindfolding was tiioroughly
done.
"I then reconducted him, blindfold, to the marked spot by
a different route, leaving the tap running, with the result
that the stick indicated with madiematic exactness the same
spot At first he slightly overran it a foot or so, and then
felt round, as it were, and seemed to be led back into the
exact center of influence by the twig. All present considered
the trial entirely conclusive of two things : First, of the man's
perfect good faith. Secondly, that the effect produced on the
twig emanated from an agency outside of himself, and appeared due to the presence of running water.
"My brother, Mr. Harold Finch Hatton, is present as I
write, and confirms what I say. ...one of the Misses Wordsworth tried the twig, and was surprised to find that an influence
of a similar nature, though not so strong, was imparted to
it
. (Pr. Xirr, 89) : " The Lincolnshire Chronicle of June 8th,
1895, contains a long report of a visit of Mr. H. W. Mullins,
the son of John Mullins, to Oatley Abbey. The newspaper
report, which I have abridged, is as follows: —
"It was told to Mullins that his father asserted the seltzer
spring flowed under a hedge on the other side of the field, in
which we were then standing, and he was asked to indicate
the place. . . . He had gone about 100 yards when the twig
began to play, and digging his heel in the ground, he thus
marked the spot. Mr. Allen, who was present when Mullins, Sr.,
also located the spring, sent a man for a spade, and a stake
was dug up, which eight yean ago was driven in hy Mr. ADea
to mark the place. Mullins, Jr., had touched the spot exactly.' ',
Prom Mr. E. Vaughan Jenkins (Pr. II, 106) :
" October 7th, 1882.
"About thirty years ago I purchased a plot of land on a
hill slope two acres in extent whereon to erect a residence
of considerable value.
"The ' knowing ones '. . . did not consider there was the least
possible chance of water being obtained on the plot ol land any«
where. In this dilemma, the foreman of the masons, a native
of Devon or Cornwall — ,I forget which— exclaimed, ' Why don't
you try the divining rod} '. . .He said his little boy, eleven years
old, possessed the poower in a remarkable degree. . . . The lad, an
honest, innocent, and nice-looking little f ellow, ... placing the
ends of the rod between the thumb and forefinger of each handy
bending it slightly and holding it before him at a short distance
from the ground, started on his expedition, I and others following him and watching eveiy movement closely. After going up
and down, crossing and re-crossing the ground several times,
but never on the same lines, the lad stopped, and, to our
great surprise, we saw the rod exhibit signs of motion, the
fingers and diumbs being perfectly motionless. The motion
or trembling of the rod increasing, it slowly began to revolve,
then at an accelerated pace, fairly twisting itself to such an
extent that the lad, altiiough he tried his best to retain it»
was obliged to let it go, and it fled to some distance. . . . The next
day . . . tibe well-sinkers . . . had the gratification of striking on a
strong spring of pure and beautiful water coming in so fast as
to cause them to make a hurried exit. . . . The father stated that
when he was a boy he possessed the same power, but entirely
lost it at sixteen years of age. ... I was then, and I am now,
fully convinced ... of the full integrity of the whole transaction, no fee or reward being asked for or expected, and
I therefore cannot avoid entertaining the opinion that there must
be 'something in it,' that something being dependent upon
some peculiar magnetic or other condition of the human agent employed
Mr. John Wood thus wrote to Mr. Yaughan Jenkins
(Pr. XIII, 34) :
" Whitfield Estate 0£Sce, February 4th, 1890.
"
The next thing was for each of the company to try
with the rod, but not one of us had the ' faculty,' excepting my
little daughter May. Subsequently the rod indicated water
in several places, both in the hands of May and MuUins—
May finding it first sometimes and at other times Mullins.
• • • May is now thirteen years of age. She has proved successful
in numerous cases; four wells have been sunk where she said
there was water, and each one was a success
.
"
Here is the testimony of Dr. Hutton alluded to on page 134
regarding his experience with the diyining-rod as used by
Lady Milbanke (Pr. XIII, 42) :
"
Lady Milbanke showed the experiment several times
in different places. ... In the places where I had good reason
to know that no water was to be found the rod was always
quiescent, but in other places, where I knew there was water
below the surface, the rods turned slowly and rc,Bpolarly . . . till
the twigs twisted themselves off below the fingers, which were
considerably indented by so forcibly holding the rod between
them.
"All the company stood dose to Lady M., with all eyes
intensely fixed, on her hands and the rods to watch if any
particular motion might be made by the fingers, but in vain;
nothing of the kind was perceived, and all the company could
observe no cause or reason why the rods should move in the
manner they were seen to do''
The capacity of Bleton, the celebrated French dowser of
the eighteenth century, was discovered when he was a child*,
by his having ''la fiivre" when seated by a certain rock
tinder which later a spring was found, and there are many
similar cases (Pr. XIII, 272 ei seq.).
(Pr. XV, 265) : "The Chevalier de M. describes in detail
one of several tests he made, he brought Bleton to his own
house, arriving after dark; in passing through the village,
which Bleton had not visited before, Bleton suddenly stop,d
and said water was there; he followed it in the darkness and
arrived at a spot where he declared the spring existed; he
was right; it was, in fact, the source of the ,fountain of the
casde. , Other tests are also given: altogether a remarkable
and weighty testimony."
Dr. Thouvenal (Pr. XV, 263) says of Bleton :
"...
Sometimes, in order to try and deceive him, if his
senses were concerned, I placed fiJse marks as if to indicate a spring; sometimes after he had followed a spring across
several fields I moved the pegs some feet away without his
knowledge. Nevertheless, he was never led astray and always
rectified such errors. In fine, I tried all sorts of ways to
deceive him, and I can testify that in more than six hundred
triale I did not succeed in doing so one single time."
Here are a few of the many cases of dowsing for metals.
W. J. Brown, of M iddlehill House, Box, Wilts, a member of
the councils of several public bodies, says (Pr. XIII, 94) :
"Some friends and myself arranged to test Mullins's capacity for discoyering metaL In his absence we took ten stones
off the top of a wall, and, having placed them on the road we
deposited a sovereign under three of them. Mullins passed
his rod over the top of each stone, and without the slightest
hesitation told us at once under which stones the sovereigns
were. When he came to a stone under which there was no
sovereign, he at once said, 'Nothing here, master' but when
he got to the others, he remarked, * All right, master, thankee,'
turned the stone over and put the sovereign in his pocket.''
Mr. H. B. Napier, agent for Sir Gabriel Ooldney, thus
wrote Professor Barrett (Pr. XIII, 148) :
Chippenham, Wilts, May 11th, 1896.
"At Gloucester some years ago a sovereign was lost under
the board floor in the Finance Office. The members of the
Council did not themselves know exactly where to find it,
and sent for Mr. Tompkins, who indicated a particular spot
on the floor, and on a carpenter being sent for the sovereign
was found to be immediately beneath the spot
Mr. W. G. Hellier, of Wick St. Lawrence, near Westonsuper-Mare, Bailiff of the Merchant Venturers of Bristol,
states (Pr. XIII, 61) :
"Whilst the dowser was tracing this spring, walking backwards and forwards across the line of its course, I hid my
pocket compass in the long grass in his track, and, when he
came to it, the rod turned over, and he said, ' Thera is summat
here.' I am certain that he did not see the compass until
afterwards, when I showed it to him hidden."
Now for various opinions on the causes of these phenomena.
Thus Mr. SoUas, Fellow of St. John's College, Cambridge,
Professor of Gteology in the University of Dublin, says
(Pn II, 73) :
"I am confident, from what I observed, that the sole im,
mediate cause for the turning of the rod is to be found in
the muscular contraction of the hand of the operator.*,
Professor Barrett declared in his first paper (Pr. XIII,
253):
"Doubtless a tuheonacioui $uggestion, of some kind, evoked
in the momement
dowser's mind, the reflex action to which the
aotual
of the excites
rod is due.
"The recent discovery of a new type of obscure
radiation from certain bodies, such as uranium salts, and
also from numerous common bodies with whidi we are surrounded, renders it conceivable that a radiation, to which
opaque bodies are permeable, may be emitted by water and
metals, which unconsciously impresses some persons
"
Could not such a '' radiation '' affect the rod as well as
the person?
Dr. Lauder Brunton says (Pr. XIII, 8) :
"When we hear that a man is able to discover water at a
considerable distance below the ground on which he stands, we
are at first apt to scout the idea as ridiculous, while if we
were told that a caravan was crossing a desert, and that all at
once the thirsty camels started off quickly, and at a distance
of a mile or more water was found, we look upon the occurrence as natural. In the same way we regard as very remarkable the story of a man tracing criminals with a divining
rod, but it becomes quite ordinary if we put a bloodhound in
the man's place."
Probably it was also Dr. Bmnton who said {Ibid., 276) :
"I believe that the almost incredible acuteness of sight,
scent, and hearing, which are found universally in certain
classes of the lower animals, and are not uncommon in savage
races, are occiiaionally possessed by certain individuals amongst
civilized races. For instance: the presence of water-vapor
in the air over certain spots makes itself evident to everyone
as a visible fog in early morning. , Now I am acquainted with
a rheumatic patient who, on passing over such a spot during
the day, when no vapor is visible, feels pains in her joints.
Of course, such a condition of hyperesthesia is very rare indeed."
This doesn't account for the movement of the rod. Then
the writer takee a different tack:
"...
The moving of the rod in a diviner's fingers depends
simply upon the bodily condition of the diviner himself, just
as the rigidity of a pointer's tail when scenting game depends
entirely upon the excitement of the dog."
The dog's tail is directly in contact with his nervous system
—contains a part of it, in fact. The rod is not. Moreover,
the tail stands still, whereas the rod moves violently.
And here speaks that acute observer, great naturalist, and
saintly soul. Dr. Wallace, who wrote to Professor Barrett
as follows (Pr. XV, 217) :
"If the rod does move wholly by muscular action, it does
not at all affect the power of the dowser in finding water, —
but the fact should be proved. To me, the evidence you adduce
shows that it is not muscular action, and if this can be proved
it, of course, places the dowser in the ranks of a physical
'medium,' which I have always held him to be. If the two
facts you state are facts: (1) That the motion of the rod
cannot be intentionally produced (by any novice) without
visible muscular action of an eneigetic kind; and (2) that in
an outsider's hands, holding the rod for the first time, it will
often move if the dowser holds his wrists, and with no conscious, and little visible, muscular action on the experimenter's
part, — ,then it follows that the motion is not pfoduced by
muscular action at all, but is a physical phenomenon analogous
to hundreds of others occurring in the presence of ' mediums.'
"I think you should have said: 'The obvious explanation,
of course, is that the rod is moved by the hands of the operator,
acting consciously or unconsciously. There are, however,
many difficulties in the way of this view, and many facts
which seem directly opposed to it.' After which your various
statements would foUow naturally. Now, they seem to me
to be in the nature of a non sequiturt
"Of course, I am a confirmed lunatic in these matters, so
excuse the ravings of a lunatic, but sincere, friend.
" Alfred B. Wallaob."
Professor Barrett says (Pr. XV, 811) :
"The probability that an explanation is to be found in
some extension of our knowledge of human personality, something new to science, and something akin to what has been
termed clairvoyance, gains considerable weight from a critical
study of cognate phenomena."
But how about the rod?
The first step regarding the correlation of these phenomena
with familiar ones is to determine whether &e rod is really
moved independently of the conscious or unconscious volition
of the dowser. On this subject early testimony is conflicting,
but that recently accumulated seems to be overwhelming in
favor of the independence of the force.
True to the conditions of their craft, and very properly
so, most of the scientific men who have been very familiar
with the processes by which things become not what they
seem, or rather seem what they are not, have voted the
dowser's force to be involuntary muscular contraction, re*
sponse to clairvoyant vision, and several other things, some
of which are harder to accept than a new and as yet nncorrelated mode of force.
Professor Barrett says (Pr. XIII, 24) that the movement
of the rod is '' an automatic action that occurs under certain
conditions in certain individuals/' Perhaps his meaning
would have been expressed more precisely if he had said in
connection ioith '' certain individuals'': for he goes on to
produce a mass of evidence that the action is independent
of the will and of muscular control — ,is the influence upon
the rod of a current between the organism and the object
sought.
Here are two bits of evidence that, so far as they go, seem
to dispose of the case.
Testimony of Sir B. Welby Gregory (Pr. II, 99) :
"The lines of water indicated by Mullins had been marked
by pegs 60 yards or 70 yards apart, and just visible above the
grass. These lines Towers and his twig emphatically confirmed, and I proceeded to test him. I had the projecting
extremities of the prongs of the twig held tight by pincers, so
that there could be no voluntary action on Towers' part when
crossing the marked lines. Despite of this, the point of the
twig twisted itself upwards, till the bark was wrinkled and
almost split, while the strain and pressure upon the musdes
of the man's hands were most apparent."
The following from Mr. F. Bastable, 14, Foskelt Boad,
Fulham, appeared in the Carpenter and Builder of September 30th, 1892 :
(Pr.Alll,86) : ''We procured two pairs of smith's tongs
to see if the twigs did actually twist, and held them in
a tight grip, with one pair securing the tips and the other the
fork, but the contortions still went on between the points held."
The following seems a pretty strong piece of evidence,
especially considering its source.
Prom Mr. H. W. Whitaker, the well-known geologist, an
utter disbeliever in the dowsing-rod, or in any practical good
resulting from its use (Pr. XIII, 69) :
134
" The diviner, named Lawienoe, an old white-haized, benevolent-faced man... took ...a strong forked hazel twig, holding
an end of each fork in each hand, and keeping his elbows
tightly down to his side. I can only describe the antics of
that twig as a pitched battle between itself and himi It
twisted, it knocked about, it contracted and contorted the
muscles of his hands and arms, it wriggled, and fought, and
kicked, until it snapped in two — and then — ,what made it painful to watch until you got used to it, the old man reeled, and
clutched hold of anyone nearest to him for a few moments. It
evidently exhausts him very much, though afterwards I asked
him what effect it had on him, and he said it only made his
heart beat most violently for a short time. . . . He was asked
if he could mesmerize and he said, no. He held the wire over
Lady D.'s watch, and it wriggled just as it had done over
the water.',
If it is worth while to administer a farther quietus to a
subject already disposed of. Professor Barrett does it, with his
increased light in his second paper (Pr. XY, 277) :
"Other correspondents have also urged that muscular action,
whetiber conscious or unconscious, is an insufficient explanation
of the phenomena actually observed. In the Journal of the S.
P. B. for December, 1897, Mr. E. T. Bennett cites some of the
evidence I gave in the previous Beport in support of this
view. Mr. Bennett urges, with much cogency, that as Faraday's explanation of table-turning being due to involuntary
muscular action is now recognized as inadequate to cover all
the phenomena of this kind, so in like manner this explanation fails to cover bJI the cases of the twisting of the divining
rod, and hence some other cause, external to the dowser, is
probably at work."
This is followed by statements of various witnesses bearing
on the point, with fuller particulars and references than I
have space for. In fact the evidence is so overwhelming that
the only explanation of Professor Sollas and others having
stated a different opinion is that they did so before the eviIn view of what has preceded, does not the dowser's force
look much like merely one more form of magnetism? It
is like the known forms, in being:
I. A current between two poles.
II. Evolved from a preceding mode of force — that absorbed bythe human system from its usual sources of supply.
136
This is shown by the almost universal experience of fatigue
and similar results after the experience. The best statement
out of a vast number is that of Mr. Stears (Pr. XIII, 164) :
''My powers vary with health. If tired I lose the power;
provide the animal system with a fresh supply of food> and
back the power comes.''
III. In producing sensations like those from the electro*
magnetic current. The following accounts are but few out
of many.
Mullins stated to Mr. Plowman (Pr. XIII, 95) :
'' Whenever he is dowsing and gets over a stream of water
he feels a tingling sensation in his arms like a slight electric
shock, and the strength of this sensation enables him to guess
the approximate volume or depth of a spring."
Mr. Stone (Pr. XIII, 124) adds:
"The sensation I experience when over an underground
spring is very like what is felt when grasping the handles of
an electric machine, often seen at railway stations.''
Mr. Tompkins (Pr. XIII, 161) :
" I feel a water.
tingling
. . . when
I get
on to a ofrunning
stratum
. . . sensation
The moment
I cross
a stratum
water
I feel a sort of bracing sensation, which passes up my logs,
back, and shoulders, and down the arms to the twig; when I
get off the water course I feel the loss of this power, till £
cross the. water again."
IV. In being transmissible from one person to another,
by holding the wrists.
V. In reversibility of the poles: sometimes the twig turns
up, sometimes down. Sometimes it oscillates or twists.
VI. Apparently in that the need of good conduction appears to vary inversely as the strength of the current. I
say: "apparently" because the phenomena suggesting this
are confusing. The electric spark jumps unconnected intervals varying from a half inch between a child's finger and
a metal bracket, to those between the poles of a Buhmkorff
coil, and those between a cloud and the earth. Some dowsers
are able to work without any twig or steel spring, going entirely bysensations similar to those felt by others only when
holding a twig or spring. This looks veiy much as if the
twig or spring helped dose the circuit for a weak current, and
were superfluous for those who can generate a strong current
The dowsing magnetism seems to differ from the earlier
known magnetisms in the following particulars :
I. Having its only known origin in the human system.
II. Instead of being restricted, like the well-known forms,
to metal and nerve tissue as conductors: it seems to act on
water and possibly all known inorganic substances, and also
on some, perhaps all, of the tissues of the human body, and
presumably animal tissue in general, though all this may be
practically through the nerve tissue.
III. In apparently being directed by will, so far as will
may be an element in setting the current in motion, and in
determining the pole external to the human system. The
dowsers are generally not affected when they are not deliberately , "at work", and perhaps are able to fix one pole
of the current in any one of several substances they choose,
perhaps in any substance whatever; certainly in water
and metals, and are alleged to have traced a criminal in
France.
IV. In being apparently less reliable in the matter of
isolation. At least the evidence is perplexing — even contradictory. For particulars see Fr. XIII, 27, 31, 43, 58, 78,
186.
V. In being, in a new and more intimate way, an extension
of the control of mind over matter; and in giving one more
hint that perhaps the two are but different manifestations
of the same thing.
A connection with electricity is suggested by a statement
from Mr. A. B. Durfee, of Orand Bapids, Michigan (Pr.
XIII, 217) that Mr. Gyrus Fuller, a noted dowser of that
neighborhood a generation ago, told Mr. Durfee that whenever
he found a tree in a forest *' stricken by lightning, he was sure
to find a stream '' [undergroimd] ', leading very near to if
The exercise of tiie power is virtually alwajrs accompanied
by physiological experiences, not only, as already stated,
137
fatigue and the sensations prodnced by grasping tiie handles of
an electrical machine, but also, in some cases, nansea, palpitation, and ** fearful perspiration,''
Oddly, but suggestively, the electric (?) thrill frequently
goes to the solar plexus, in the near neighborhood of which
it produces nausea. This is stated in several instances. The
solar plexus seems to have some connection with telopsis
as will be substantiated later. Some telopsists even seem
to have a perception akin to sight through that region, and
(as already stated), some dowsers have clairvoyant experiences in connection with the zoomagnetic ( ?) manifestations.
Mr. J. F. Young, of Llanelly, a member of the S. P. K,
and a successful amateur dowser, thus wrote to Professor
Barreti; (Pr. XV, 360) :
"....I found that after 'setting' myself to use the rod,
Le., getting into an abstracted mental condition, lost to all
around, when, or just before, the rod turned, I could, — ,as it
were dairvoyantly, — €ee the underground springs and actually
appeared able to trace them out as I walked along. My friend,
Mr. Robertson, who, as you are aware, also uses the rod with
success as an amateur water-finder, tells me he also had a
similar experience, and we have since read that a 'diviner'
named Adams, a Somerset man, frequently asserted the same
thing."
On this Professor Barrett expatiates (Pr. XY, 366) :
"Now it is worthy of note that this inquiry has led us to
the conclusion that some dowsers exhibit symptoms of induced
catalepsy and experience singular sensations in the epigastrium
when the object sought for is transcendentally 'perceived' by
them. I have already pointed out in Part XII that the visceral
sensations of the dowser are probably emotional distuibances,
arising from a psychical state, and it is likely enough that a
similar explanation accoimts for the cataleptic subject believing he sees with his stomach, the sensation being there. But
tiiis explanation merely accounts for the secondary effects
observed; the induction of the psychical state still remains a
mystery."
All very well, but what accounts for the rod acting utterly
mdependently of the operator, as already abundantly indicated?
After all this wading through the slough, I incline to do
138
deliberately what Profeeaor Barrett tbs led toward doing
by force of circumBtaDceBy and frankly accept (" prOTisionally "
of course) both ioterpretatioiis — a new molecular force, and
telepsycbosis too, and a dozen others, if you pleaee. I am
by no means sure they are not fundamentally one, whatever
the differences in their manifeatations.
Hr. Barrett's conclusions so far as they are unfavorable
to a quasi-magnetic force, were probably reached before the
days of the trolley-car and the telephone; and certainly before
the days of the wireless telegraph. Probably in these days
of new modes of force, he would find a much more rational
explanation of the dowser's spasm and the rod's action
in a hypothetical mode of force which is, like electrici, and
magnetism, highly teleMnetic, independent of any conductor
(as is indeed the electric spark, in the laboratory or in the
clouds) and for which I have, as already intimated, ventured
to provisionally suggest the name zoomagnetism.
And here I am again reminded of the difficulty of drawing
distinctions in Nature. Perhaps all these mysterious powers
are but different aspects of the same thing; and as I grope
on I seem to get more definite and unified notions of what
that thing is. I will give them later.
The more I have read about these various modes of force,
the more surprised I am at the scant evidence of efforts
made to correlate them in the laboratory. I have not even
seen any indication of a test whether table-tippers have the
dowsing power or vies versa. Lines of investigatton opened
in this way might be very fruitful
The accounts of Foster, Home, Moses, and not a few
others seem to indicate a probability that the organism poaseasing any one of the aa-yet-mysterious powers we have been
describing is apt, thoOgh by no means sure, to possess soma
of the others. Of course to Uie ignorant all this spells fraud,
and to even the credulous, so many accomplishments in ona
an, none of which are possessed by average men, are a tax
I faith. But it should be carefully realized that the nearer
eee alleged powers may be found to be various manifeatationa
! a single power, the more the tax on faith will decrease.
s electricity, whether manifested as light, heat, or kinetic
Tce, has its own range of vibrations, so these half-dozen
The Pmdule Sxplorateur 139
new powers may be found to be assodaied in some other
single range of vibrations in the outer world, which interplay
with a corresponding capacity for nervous vibration that is
as yet developed in a few, and but few, human beings.
After I had written the forgoing passages. Professor Barrett's admirable little book on FsycUcal Besearch appeared,
and I found to my astonishment that in it he had returned
to, or perhaps merely more clearly expressed, his belief that
involimtary muscular action moves the rod. Moreover, I
found the
conviction
expressed
in Mrs.
Sidgwick's
presidentialsame
address in
Pr. XXII.
But what
moves
the muaclesf
Well I ,' Hiwr steh ich, ich hann nichi and,n." If it were
only a question of physics, of course I would not dare to hold
my opinion in face of Professor Barrett's. But it is a question
of physiology and psychology, and not only of them, but of the
interpretation of evidence and of ', common sense '' — ,whatever
that may mean. I'm not quite sure that I know, but I think
it relates to a pretty wide field wherein an ordinarily successful
man of affairs may Intimately be accorded as much weight
as a specialist in some particular department of knowledge.
Professor Barrett jumps to the dowsing-rod from the
pendule explorateur. This is a weight at the end of a cord
or chain held in the hand, and is generally believed to be
swung by unconscious and imperceptible muscular contractions
in the directions unconsciously willed by the person holding
it. This swinging in intelligent directions — such as toward
letters of the alphabet on a ring surrounding the pendulum-*
is attributed to muscular action, because it will not take
place when the pendulum is suspended from any rigid inanimate support. Then it cannot be willed into definite directions even by persons in whose hands it will swing in definite
directions.
But in these hands it cannot be wUled into definite directions either. From this it is argued that the muscular action
is involuntary. But I have not yet seen the demonstration
that the agency is muscular at all, though I find no insuperable difiiculty in the hypothesis.
But it is certainly a long jump from the possible muscular
contractions of the pendulum-holder which are so minute
140
Molar TeUhinesis
[Bk. II, R. I
that he and ilie spectators only infer them, to the marked
gyrations of the dowser's hands and arms. The queer Ihing
is that the dowsers themselves, professional and amateur,
nnanimonsly declare (so far as I recall) that their gyrations
are not inyolnntary efforts to move the rod, bnt voluntary
efforts to keep it quiet, while Professor Barrett, and some
other scientific onlookers, declare that the actors themselves
don't know their own minds and bodies, and that what they
deny regarding them is true; and what they assert, false.
I I don't know, though, that Professor Barrett's hypothesis
necessarily traverses the one virtually held by the dowsercf,
and seeming probable to me. He says the rod is moved by
involuntary muscular contraction. I guess that it is moved
by zoomagnetism. The truth may be (though the men
holding the rod deny it) that it is moved by involuntary
muscular contraction, and that the involuntary muscular
contraction is caused by zoomagnetism.
Whatever may be the originality of my opinion regarding
the force that moves the rod, I can at least contribute, vicari*
ously, to the history of the subject one item which seems to
have escaped attention. My young daughter says that Moses
at the rock of Horeb was evidently the original dowser.
Since this chapter was written, Journal S. P. B. CCXCIY
has appeared with a letter from Qermany announcing, in consequence ofsome remarkable successes with the dowsing rod,
the formation of a very eminent society to investigate it.
Breaks in the municipal water-pipes in Munich, and one in
a dyke at Tambach near Gotha, are alleged to have been located
by it
So far, the Germans ,' do not believe that the fundamental
principle of a solution to the problem lies in a supernormal
psychical gift of the dowser, but in the physical influence of
the soil acting on him."
The same number of the Journal contains a paper by Sir
William Barrett, in which he says that he has received a letter
from Professor Hyslop which
, illustrates the need of further investigation on the question
of the involuntary and unconscious muscular action which, I
have assumed in my papers, gives rise to the sudden twisting of
CIl IX]
Unconscious Muscular Action Doubtful
141
the dowsing rod. It is true» — as will be seen from my Report in
Proceedings, VoL XV, pp. 276, et seq,, and in subsequent papers
in the Journal, — that the hypothesis of unconscious muscular
action needs to be stretched to almost incredible limits in some
cases, and amongst dowsers themselves it is universally discredited. But what other hypothesis can take its placet ''
Jt had already been my lot to suggest one in the foregoing
pages. As I am not a physicist, I don't know how many laws
supposed to be established, it may run coimter to. Even if it
is correct it is sure to nm counter to some.
CHAPTEB
MOLECULAR
X
TELSEINESIS
Satinds
As already noted, the molar manifestations of telekinesis
are generally accompanied by molecular ones, especially of
*, raps '' more or less akin to crackings in seasoned furniture.
The source of these raps seems plainly molecular. There is
no apparent mechanical cause of them, and the objects, generally made of wood, from which they seem to proceed, give
no indication, like cracks from change of temperature, of
any change of structure caused by the source of the sound.
Moreover, we shall see later that similar phenomena take
place in the air itself.
We are reminded constantly of the absence of definite lines
of division in Nature. Allied with motions of the air started
by causes not aerial, which, so far as our present knowledge
goes, are essential to the transmission of sound, are alleged
motions in the air, of whose origin we as yet know nothing.
They accompany many sounds that seem to originate through
obvious manifestations of the telekinetic force, and so, it is
to be presumed, are a modification of it
I observed no raps when P
raised the music-stand,
though some of the other boys had heard raps around his
bed. I slept in a remote room.
The descriptions generaUy liken the raps, as said, to the
cracking of unseasoned wood, but there are varieties of sounds,
including one of a ticking in a letter. An account of this last
is given by Myers from the narrative of Mrs. Anna Davies
of IsHngton (Pr. VIII, 218) :
''One evening I paid a visit to Mrs. Brown, and she gave
me an Indian letter. ...I placed it on the chimney-piece in
our sitting-room, and sat down alone. I expected my brother
borne in an hour or two. The letter, of course, in no way
14S
Ch. X]
Ticking in a Letter.
Various Raps
143
interested me. In a minute or two I heard a ticking on
the chimney-piece, and it Btnick me that an old-fashioned
watch which my mother always had standing in her bedroom
must have been brovight downstairs. I went to the chimneypiece, but there was no wateh or dock there or elsewhere in
the room. The ticking, which was loud and sharp, seemed
te proceed from the letter itself. Greatly surprised, I removed
the letter and put it on a sideboard, and then in one or two
other places; but the ticking continued, proceeding undoubtedly from where the letter was each time. After an hour or
so of this I could bear the thing no longer, and went out and
sat in the hall to await my brother. When he came in I
simply took him into the sitting-room and asked him if he
heard anything. He said at once, ,I hear a watch or dodc
ticking.' There was no wateh or dock, as I have said, in the
room. He went to where the letter was and exclaimed, , Why,
the letter is ticking.'. .. My brother took the letter to Mrs.
J. W. either that night (it was very late) or next morning. On opening it, she found that her husband had sudden,
died of sunstroke, and the letter was written by some servant
or companion to inform her of his death."
In Home's case and many others, the presence of the
, spirits *' was generally announced by ** raps '* at the beginning of the stance; or, in common language, both those sets
of manifestations — ,teppings and raps, like steam from a
safety valve, showed that the telekinetic force was ready for
action.
Sir William Crookes {Researches, 86-7) thus describes
the varieties of raps. His account is supported by hosts of
witnesses to one or more:
,The popular name of , raps' conveys a very erroneous
impression of this class of phenomena. At different times,
during, my experimente, I have heard delicate ticks, as with
the point of a pin; a cascade of sharp sounds, as from an
induction-coil in full work; detonations in the air; sharp
metallic taps; a cracking like that heard when a frictionid
machine is at work; somids like scratching; the twittering as
of a bird, eto.
, These sounds are noticed with almost every medium, each
having a special peculiarity; they are more varied with Mr.
Home, but for power and certainty I have met with no one
who at all approached Miss Kate Fox. ... In the case of Miss
Fox it seems only necessary for her to place her hand on
any substance for loud thuds to be heard in it, like a triple
pulsation, sometimes loud enough to be heard several rooms
144
Molecular TeUhineris
[Bk. II, Pt I
off. In this manner I liave heard them in a Hying treeon a sheet of glass — on a stretched iron wire — on a stretched
membrane — a tambourine — on the roof of a cab — and on the
floor of a theater. Moreoyer, actual contact is not always
necessary; I have had these sounds proceeding from the floor,
walls, etc., when the medium's hands and feet were held,when she was standing on a chair — ,when she was suspended in
a swing from the ceiling — when she was enclosed in a wire
cage — ,and when she had fallen fainting on a sofa. I liave
heard them on a glass harmbnicon — I have felt them on my
own shoulder and under my own hands. I have heard them
on a sheet of paper, held between the fingers by a piece of
thread passed through one comer. With a full knowledge of
the numerous theories which have been started, chiefly in
America, to explain these sounds, I have tested them in every
way that I could devise, until there has been no escape from
the conviction that they were true objective occurrences not
produced by trickery or mechanical means."
When Sir William Crookes gives his testimony regarding
physical phenomena, there is not much more to be said.
But this foregoing statement regarding Miss Kate Fox needs
reconciliation with the fact that Mrs. Maggie Fox Elane made
'' exposures ,' of the frauds which she claimed all three sistexs
bad been guiliy of. The reconciliation may partly consist
in the fact that a great deal of money was made by public
exhibitions of these exposures. But while they were going
on, Mrs. Kate Fox Jencken wrote a letter printed in Light,
expressing great distress over her sister's conduct, and saying
of her and an associate who had long been a professional
"exposer'' of " spiritualism '* : "They are hard at work to
expose the whole thing if they can, but they certainly cannot."
She also says that she had seen her sister but once since
her return from England, and yet the issue of Light for
November 3, 1888, two weeks earlier than the date of Mrs.
Jencken's letter, said :
, We learn from America that Mrs. Jencken and Mrs. Kane,
two of the Fox Sisters, have started on an exposure tour.''
More particulars are given in the Jour, (not Pr.) 8. P. B.
for January, 1889, pp. 16f., and the S. P. B. seems to have
considered
the said
case about
settleditby Mrs. Jencken's letter, as no
more
has been
CIl X]
Baps Heard hy Barrett, Moses, Croohes, Etc.
145
Prom Professor Barrett (Pr. IV, 34) :
', Presently loud raps were given at this table beneath the
hands of the sitters, so loud, in fact, they quite startled me.
In character the sounds in general resembled the snapping
noises occasionally made by furniture when the joints open
under the heat of a room. But the sharpest and loudest
cracks can be well imitated in strength and character by
smartly striking a table with the edge of an ivory paper"
knife
The following occurred in the presence of Moses. The
initials are Dr. Speer's (Pr. IX, 319, Note) :
''Simday, July 20th. ... Knocks of the sharpest kind came
on the table and then on the floor. It was as if large glass
marbles had been thrown on the table, had bounded off on
the floor, and then rolled away. Till a light was struck it
was almost impossible not to believe that such had been the
case. . . . S. T. S.''
Sir William Crookes prepared an apparatus with a parchment diaphragm connected by a lever with a tracing registering apparatus. On the diaphragm he placed a few bits of
black lead. He got the medium (a non-professional lady
whose name he does not give) to place her hands over the
diaphragm, without contact. What followed he thus describes {Besearches, p. 39) :
',Presently percussive noises were heard on the parchment
resembling the dropping of grains of sand on its surface. At
each percussion a fragment of graphite which I had placed
on the membrane was seen to be projected upwards about l-50th
of an inch, and the end 0 of the lever moved slightly up and
down. Sometimes the sounds were as rapid as those from an
induction-coil, whilst at others they were more than a second
apart. Five or six tracings were taken, and in all cases a
movement of the end 0 of the lever was seen to have occurred
with each vibration of the membrane.''
This is from Bartlett {op. cit, 36) :
'' Thomas It Hazard writes :
"'One day as I was passing down Fifth Avenue I...
saw Foster and a stranger standing quietly by an iron railing.... Shortly after the stranger left, and Foster joined me
[and] . • • told me that the gentleman who had just left him
was an occasional visitant of his circles, who had a short
time before joined him on the avenue and said to him: "Mr.
146
MolecfOar TeUhineria
[Bk. II, Pt I
Foster, I wish you oould make raps somewhere else than
in your own room/' to which Foster replied that he could
have them come anywhexel The gentleman said, " I will give
you a dollar for each one you wUl make just here." .Whereupon Foster asked the skeptic to stand with him beside tiie
iron railing and count aloud all the raps as they were made.
Soon the ra,s came on the iron railingi and the gentleman
counted them until the number ten was reached, when a
pause ensued, and Foster asked if the raps should yet go on.
'* No/' said the gentleman ; ', I am satisfied/' suiting his action
to his word by handing Foster a ten dollar bill, which he
then showed to me/ "
Of course the skeptic will account for this on the obvious
hypothesis that Foster lied. I knew him, and I don't think
he did.
In Mr. Armstrong's case he said of the raps on a table
(Pr. VII, 168) :
''They resembled the sound of the sparks given off by the
prime conductor of a laxge Holtz electrical machine, ... and
the table always seemed supercharged with the ' force producing
fluid/ if I may be permitted to use the term, on every portion of
the table's surface, the chairs we sat on, and even on various
articles of furniture at considerable distance from us."
From Stainton Moses (Pr. IX, 280) :
, They have been heard ... in strange rooms ... in the countiy
. • . and even in the open air, under very curious circumstances.
...At SoutlMmd...a pier more than a mile in length, my
friend and I... were sitting at the extreme end... when raps
came ... on the rail in front of us. . • . They followed us all along
the pier, and were audible at a great distance, as indeed any
sound is if made on a long wooden raiL This was at, 4
o'clock in the afternoon. At 8 p. m. we went on to the pier
again. . . . The clear metallic rap was plainly audible . . . fifty
yards from me [and] ... to both of us when we were seventy
yards apart, and were apparently made in the space between us."
The sounds so far described, notwithstanding their variety,
have the common quality of proceeding from definite sources
appreciable by the senses. We now go on to a category of
sounds from no sensable sources.
Professor Alexander gives the following in connection with
the Davis children (Pr. VII, 180) :
''A peculiar whistling sound was heard by some — on one
occasion coming from behind the curtains drawn before the
Ch. X]
Ths Davis ChUdren'a Baps. Moses
147
▼erandah door, and on another, by Mrs. Z. in the garden path
leading down to the gate, where she had been seeing some
friends out. •••«./'
Little girls, and big ones too, do sometimes make ,'a
peculiar whistling sound/' But what comes from other mediums may suggest that this one was not of the usual kind.
Prof. A. continues:
''The sound which has sinoe developed to such an extent
was first heard by us on March 23d, 1873. At that time it
resembled the plucking of a string in mid-air. . . . We called it
the lyre sound, for want of a better name. ... A certain imitation of it could be made by slightly touching the wires of a piano
at the upper notes. ...I succeeded also in making some resemblance toit by drawing my finger over the wires of a musical
dock which hangs on the wall of the room adjoining. ... I supposed that the piano or dock must be used in some way to make
a sound which seemed to be in mid-air. This theory was soon
upset, for the sound came in rooms where there was no musical
instrument; even in my own bedroom, where sometimes the
sound has been so loud as to be distinctly audible through the
wall in an adjoining room. ...The soimd would traverse the
room and seem to die away in the distance, and suddenly burst
forth into great power over the table, which appeared In some
inexplicable way to be used as a sounding-board. The wood
of the table vibrated under our hands exactly as it would have
done had a violoncdlo been twanged while resting upon it. It
was no question of fancy or delusion. The sounds were at
times deafening, and alternated between those made by the
very small strings of a harp and such as would be caused
by the violent thrumming of a violoncello resting on the top
of a drum.... We never sat without them, and they formed
almost the staple phenomenon of the stance. With them, as
with other phenomena, great variety was caused by good or
bad conditions."
We are constantly reminded of the absence of definite lines
of division in Nature: even if the sounds above described,
and to be described hereafter, were carried by the air, their
source seems to have be,i some molecular action in the
atoms, as appears to be that of the ', raps " already described.
Stainton Moses suggests (Pr. XI, 49, 60) that some sounds
are independent of the ear:
'' May 30th. . . . The peculiarity of the stance was that when
I could hear the sound no one else could, and tnee versa.
148
Molecular Telehineria
[Bk. II, Ft. I
I heard by dairaudienoe and not by natural hearing, being
very deaf with my cold.... I described it long before it was
heard by the others, and heard it frequently whan they did not.
At the same time I was unconscious of sounds apparently made
on the table under my nose."
The sound referred to in the foregoing is the first among
tiiose indicated in the following from Fr. IX :
(IX,268): *'. ..The most perfect musical sounds are made
when I cannot hear them; and, as a general rule, to which the
exceptions are so rare as only to serve to establish the principle, the best and most successful manifestations occur when
the medium is deeply entranced."
(IX,279-80) : ". . . Of late they [the sounds] have changed, and
are usuaUy audible to me before they strike the ear of any other
person. How far this may be attributable to clairaudience, a
faculty lately developed in me, I cannot say positively."
(IX,342-3) : '' At one seance as many as seven different sounds
were going on at the same time in different parts of the room.
It would have been quite impossible for any one person to
',Mabu Spbsb."
have made them.
Moses' note-book says of certain sounds (Fr. IX, 281) :
**
They represented two instruments, the one of three,
the other of seven strings, and they were used in playing thus :-—
Certain notes were sounded upon the three strings, and these
were followed by a run made as if by running a finger-nail
rapidly over the strings of the other instrument. The result
was like what musical cognoscenti call * a free prelude ' ; what
I should describe as a series of notes, highly pitched, clear, and
liquid in Iheir melody, followed by a rapid run on an instrument
of lower pitch. I speak of instruments, but . . . there was in the
room — an ordinary dining-room — ,no musical instrument of any
kind whatever."
Dr. Speer says (Fr. IX, 281) :
,'The soimd ... during the space of fifteen months, almost
invariably presented itself at each sitting. ... A sound like that
of a stringed instrument, played, or rather plucked, in mid-air,
while there was no stringed instrument in the room. Every
attempt was subsequently made to ascertain through what substance the sound could be evolved. . . . The sounds were formed
independently of any material substance. , . . In process of time,
the manifestation became most extraordinary. It was almost
impossible (to an outsider it would have been absolutely impossible) not to believe that a large stringed instrument, e.g., a
violoncello, a guitar, a double bass, or a harp, was struck by
1
Ch. X]
Telehineiie Lights.
Colonel Taylor
149
poweif ul human fingers. ... On these occasions the sitters could
distinctly feel a strong vibration transmitted from the points
of, the fingers in contact with the table up to the shoulder-
joint. .•••••
',I confess myself entirely unable to give any idea of the
way in which these remarkable sounds are produced.
''
We have already, by almost insensible degrees, found ourselves in what I provisionally assume to be molecular action
of the telekinetic force, though the force has so far generally
been associated with Ihe molar action. We will now leave
that, and concern ourselves with some farther phenomena
that are purely molecular, until we meet the molar again
in discussing telekinetic phenomena associated with intelli,
gence, into which, by the way, we have already drifted some
distance, so inextricable from each other are the phenomena.
Lights
The molecular manifestations also include lights which sug*
gest not only the electric spark and the alleged magnetic aura,
but also often have characteristics peculiar to themselves. Un«
fortunately their case, like all manifestations of telekinesis,
is needlessly prejudiced by their being generally called ,, spirit
lights.'' The name of course tends to awaken in some credulity, and in others skepticism, both of which tend to obstruct
proper investigation. But probably every light from an unknown source that has appeared since mankind had a word
meaning ', spirit'' has been attributed to spirits. Whatever
such a word may mean etymologically, in actual use it is no
more or less than an a; to express a mode of force as yet xm*
correlated with the modes already familiar. So it was with
the lights of electricity, whether seen in the clouds or in the
'' artificial " spark.
lieutenant-Colonel Taylor, a frequent contributor to the
Pr. S. P. B., thus describes a '* spirit Ught" (Pr. XIX, 64) :
**,
This light seemed to me not to illuminate things
as much as a common light of equal brilliancy would do, but
perhaps a very feeble light, when looked at after the eye has
been some time in total darkness, may give an exaggerated
impression of brightness. I fdt no heat when the light was
in my hand, nor did I feel the touch of anything."
150
McUadar Telehinms
[Bk. II, Pt I
The following manifeBtation by Foster (Bartlett, op. eU.,
p. 78) suggests the lights and electric crackling from a
Bnhmkorff coil.
,' The lights were turned out without ooEisulting Mr. Foster.
Had he bea,ai consulted, he would probably not have given his
consent, being as timid and apparently as afraid of darkness
as a child. Two leayes of the dining-table were taken out,
intending to shore the table together, to make it somewhat
smaller. But the table would not shore. Who has not experienced this difficulty with their dining-table t In this
instance, however, I consider it fortunate that the leaves were
left out. Many surprising physical manifestations occurred*
so startling in their nature that I can hardly believe that they
occurred myself I In these aoooimts of Foster, I have" [heretofore? H. H.] ,'intentionally
avoided
mentioning
the physical
manifestations,
and have thought
it better
to confine
myself
entirely to mental phenomena. The raps, I think, might be
regarded as both mental and physical. Nimierous questions
were asked and answered by Mr. Foster, when suddenly, looking
through the aperture which the vacant leaves left in the table,
I perceived numerous small lights, like little balls of fire, in
size from a large pinhead to that of a pigeon egg. The entire
space of the lower part of the table was filled with these
electric sparks, and this to me was a wonderful phenomenon.
. • . [At each rap. H.H.] '' one of these sparks, or balls of
fire, darted against the side of the table or on the floor, producing the rapping, and disappeared. When" [There were
three
H. H.] from
',we could
see three
balls another,
of fire
separateraps.
themselves
the others,
run little
one after
strike, and disappear. ... K the rap was low, a little ball of
fire; just in proportion to the loudness of the rap was the
size of the ball used. A loud rap evidently required a large
ball of fire to explode. Having discovered this first, I called
the attention of tine others to the fact. This lasted for nearly
one hour."
You will remember Foster's champagne baskets flying
around the room (Bartlett, op. cii., 24). In that account it is
stated that '' what appeared to be electric sparks appeared in
many places in the room.''
Here is an account by Moses (Pr. IX, 273-4) :
**'
A number of cones of soft light similar to moon*
light appeared in succession, until a dozen or more had been
made. Th,y presented the appearance oi a nucleus of soft,
yellow light, surrounded by a soft haze. They sailed up from
a comer of the room and gradually died out. The most con-
CIl X]
Stainton Mose, LighU
151
apionous was diaped like a mitre and was 8 or 9 inelies in
height... We determined to extemporise a cabinet for the
purpose of developing them."
Why '' a cabinet '' ? One does not seem to huve been gen*
erally essential to the production of lights by Moses, and
does seem to have been generally essential to the production
of anything by mediums more open to suspicion.
, This was simply done by throwing open the door between
two rooms, and hanging in the doorway a curtain with a'
square aperture in the middle of it. On one side of the curtain a table was put for the sitters; on the other side I was
placed in an easy-chair, and was soon in a state of deep trance,
from which I never woke until the stance was concluded. What
then took place is described in the records of friends who
were present. Large globes of light., .sailed out of the
aperture and went into the room where the sitters were placed,
lliey Are described as of the same soft, pale hue, like moon*
light. They were sufficiently bright to illumine the lintel
and door-posts, and to cast a strong reflection into the room.
Within the gauty envelope was a bright point of concentrated
light, and the size varied considerab],. The cone shape predominated, but some were like a dumbbell, and others like a
mass of luminous vapor revolving round and falling over a
central nucleus of soft, yellow light. They seem to have been
carried in a materialized hand, a finger of which was shown
at request by placing it in front of the nucleus of light. Sound
each was soft drapery, the outline of which was usually
perfectly distinct."
Dr. Thomson of Clifton added the following (Pr. IX, 274) :
** The appearance of the light reminded me strongly of what
I have seen when an electric discharge is passed through an
exhausted tube, with the exception, of course, of the latter
being momentary, whereas in the present case the light continued more or less for nearly an hour. .••..."
Later Moses says (Pr. IX, 331) :
** I hadanbeen,
very anxious
try the
duration
of the light,
by phosphorized
is made
of such tolights
imitation
because
oil; but lights so made are of very brief duration. I believe
that a favorable trial would show that Mentor's" [another
''spirit'' whom we shall know better later. H.H.] ''Hgbi
would last seven or eight minutes."
Sir William Crookes says (Researches, 91) :
''These, being rather faint, generally require the room to
be darkened. I need scarcely remind my readers again that*
152
Molecular Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Pt. I
under these circumstanoesy I haye taken proper precautions to
avoid being imposed upon by phosphorized oil, or other means.
Moreover, many of these lights are such as I have tried to
imitate artificially, but cannot.
''Under the strictest test conditions, I have seen a solid
self-luminous
body, theabout
size the
and room,
nearly attheoneshape
i,urkey's
egg, float noiselesdy
time ofhi,ner
than
anyone present could reach standing on tiptoe, and then gently
descend to the floor. It was visible for more than ten minutes,
and before it faded away it struck the table three times with
a soimd like that of a hard, solid body. During this time the
medium was lying back, apparently insensible, in an easychair.
''I have seen luminous points of light darting about and
settling on the heads of different persons. ... I have seen sparks
of light rising from the table to the ceiling, and again falling
upon the table, striking it with an audible sound."
Compare Foster's audible lights, a couple of pages back.
There are many similar cases.
Professor Alexander says (Pr. YII, 183) :
,A beautiful, transparent, bluish light... was one evening seen by all, except Mr. Davis himself, playing on his left
shoulder. At my desire it moved to the right shoulder, but
seemed to have some difficulty in staying there. . . . The room
at the time was partially darkened, but not enough to hinder
us from ' plainly distinguishing the features of the persons
present."
Dr. Speer says (Pr. IX, 276-6) :
**
He told me to rub my hands so as to generate more
power, and very soon another large light • . . appeared.
''The way of renewing the light when it grew dim was by
making passes over it with the hand. . • . They . . . seemed to be
more easily and fully developed when I rubbed my hands together or on my coat."
This seems to correlate the lights definitely enough with
the other modes of force manifested by the medium. I assume that the force came from Moses tiirough Speer, though
that may be superfluous: aU people are supposed to have
some power to gather and transmit electricity, and Moses's
initiative may have been enough for the as yet mysterious
force. These lights, howevar, were unlike any electric lights
we know, except those in vacuum tubes.
Lights, like sounds, have been in evidence so much more
Ch. X]
Temperatures.
Matier through Matter
153
frequentij in connection with ostensible intelligence, that I
leave farther consideration of them to that branch of the
snbject, though we have already found the two inevitably
somewhat tangled together.
Temperatures
Shall we class as molar or molecular, the motion of air?
It is inseparably connected with phenomena of both heat and
cold, and therefore is both. As the reader will frequently meet
cases hereafter, I will not take the trouble to group them.
As a specimen, however, take the following from Sir
William Crookes's Researches, 86:
, These movements, and indeed I may say the same of eveiy
kind of phenomenon," [telekinetic and telepsychict H. H.]
''are generally preceded by a peculiar cold air, sometimes
amounting to a decided wind. I have had sheets of paper
blown about by it, and a thermometer lowered several degrees.
On some occasions...! have not detected any actual movement of the air, but the cold has been so intense that I could
only compare it to that felt when the hand has been within a
few inches of frozen mercury."
Similar allegations are made in connection with the manifestations ofmost, if not all, of the mediums.
Passing Matter Through Matter
Here are the alleged cases from Sir William Orookes (fiesearches, pp. 96-7) :
,,
I then went to the dining-room door, and telling the
two boys to go into the library and proceed with dieir lessons,
I dosed the door behind them, locked it, and (according to my
usual custom at stances) put the key in my pocket.
''We sat down. Miss Fox being on my right hand and tiie
other lady on my left, ...in total darkness, I holding Miss
Fox's two hands in one of mine the whole time. ...We all
heard the tilling of a beU, not stationary, but moving about
in all parts of tiie room, ...now touching me on the head,
and now tapping against the floor. After ringing about the
room in this manner for fully five minutes, it fell upon the
table close to my hands. ......
"I remarked Ihat it could not be my little hand-bell
which was ringing, for I left that in the library. (Shortly
before Miss Fox came I had occasion to refer to a book, whidb
164
Molecular TeUkineris
[Bk. II, Pi I
was lying on a comer of a book-ahelf . The bell was on the
book, and I put it on one side to get the book. That little
incident had impressed on my mind the fact of the bell being
in the library.) , The gas was burning brightly in the hall
outside the dining--room door, so that this could not be opened
without letting light into the room, even had there b, an
accomplice in the house with a duplicate key, which there
certainly was not.
''I struck a light. There, sure enough, was my own bell
lying on the table before me. I went straight into the library.
A glance showed that the bell was not where it ought to have
been. I said to my eldest boy, * Do you know where my little
bell isV ,Yes, papa,' he replied, 'there it is,' pointing to
where I had left it. He looked up as he said this, and then
continued, 'No — it's not there, but it was there a little time
ago.' 'How do you mean! — ,has anyone come in and taken
it) ' ' No,' said he, ' no one has been in; but I am sure it was
there, because when you sent us in here out of the dining-room
J.' (the youngest boy) 'began ringing it so that I could not
go on wi, my lessons, and I told him to stop.' J. corroborated
this, and said that, after ringing it, he put ,e bell down where
he had found it."
Sir William gives another where Home was the agent, in
Pr. VI.
This is from Stainton Moses (Pr. IX, 306, note) :
"April Bd. The medium was greatly convulsed, and suddenly alarge stone was rolled vidently across the table and
fell on Ur. Percival's knee. The stone had been brought from
Ae hall through a locked door, every hand at the table being
held during the process. Mr. Percival had been anxious to
have a proof of 'matter passing through matter,' and this
indeed was a solid one, as the stone was very large and
heavy.— M. 8." (Dr. [Mrs.!] Speer.)
Podmore gives another instance (Modem Spiritualism, 11,
69):
"Communicated to the Dialectical Society by Mr. Fusedale:
...The children and my wife would see the things they [the
" spirits." H.H.1 . . . took (in particular a brooch of my wiic,s)
,pear to pass through soUd substances, such as the waQ or the
doors."
If matter can pass through matter, the fundamental established axiom regarding it— ,that two bodies cannot occupy
the same space at the same time, is mistaken, and our notions
Ch. X]
MatmaliuiUan
156
regarding matter must be revised — we must face the question
if the molecules of one body can pass through the intermolecular spaces of another without either body losing its
shape. The X-rays suggest some sort of an answer. The
same is true with a yengeance, if there is a substantial f ounda*
tion for the reports of materialization, and perhaps our later
consideration of them may give us a due towards an explanation of the new aspects of the subject
Materialization
Home, Foster, Stainton Moses, and perhaps one or two
other agents in good standing, are alleged to have caused
momentary phenomena (no lasting ones are yet alleged to
have been produced) possessing one or more of the attributes
heretofore associated with matter — such as visibility, audi«
bility, odor, taste, temperature, texture, and resistance to
pressure; and there are several well-known agents of questionable standing who claim to have done the same, among
whom Eusapia Palladino is most prominent.
Probably the majority of investigators now accept what we
will provisionally call the other forms of telekinesis as fact,
and are trying to correlate them with our previous knowledge;
Materialization, on the other hand, they are still tiying to
account for by trickeiy and illusion. And yet what little
character Home had, seems to have been so sincere! And
Stainton Moses, had he been a fraud (which nothing told
about him seems to encourage), would hardly have been contented to defraud so small a circle; and as to poor Eusapia
Palladino, she is her own worst enemy, and that New York
report for many reasons cannot quite overbalance the earlier
reports.
One of the men who joined in it told me that lie did
so with a mental reservation, and I am credibly informed
that another confessed the same. The first one told me that
he passed his hands between the floor and the legs of a
table raised by Eusapia, and found the space absolutely free ;
also that the table could not have been lifted from above
by any known agency, unless telekinesis may be accounted
a known agency. From the evidence, I believe that whatever
166
MoUctdar TelekinMis
[Bk. II, Pi I
Eusapia's frauds, eome of her manif estatioiiB of telekinesiB
were genmne. This raises some presnmption that some of
her materializationB may have been too. I don't see, however,
that it makes much difference whether they were or not : the
evidence of her fraud does not fatally detract from the credibility of the witnesses in the other cases.
I am not at all prepared to deprecate the efforts to hunt
up tricks; at the same time, after the impossibilities that have
become the whole world's actualities during the last forty
years, there does seem about as much justification for working provisionally on the hypothesis that a respectably
vouched-for marvel is true, as upon the old one that it is
false.
It may eventually seem that the claims of materialization
may gain a little strength from the possibility that it may be
a corollary of telekinesis. The case for materialization, how*
ever, is different from that for the simpler forms of telekinesis. That is enough to convince anybody but the class
of skeptics who take nothing on testimony unless they have
experienced the like themselves, and are much more energetic
in denying the experience of others than in enlarging their
own. There are scores, probably hundreds, of mediums who
have given well attested cases of molar and molecular telekinesis, but there are hardly half a dozen whose cases of
materialization are worthy of any consideration. To begin
a few well supported instances with a very mild example:
From Bartlett {op. dt, p. 64) :
,'A gentleman, accompanied by two ladies dressed in deep
mourning, visited Mr. Foster. . . . The stance had only continued a short time when the elder lady said, * Sarah Jane,
behave yourself, and stop hunching me.' 'Why, mother, I
am not hunching you, I am hunched myself.' Hundreds have
testified tiiat while attending the stances th, have been
touched by a hand, on the forehead, on the shoiuder, or knee.
Was it imagination or a fact?"
If this phenomenon was genuine, Foster produced the distinguishing effect of matter — ,resistance — of which more later.
But this is the only case from Foster I recall, and Bartlett
overlooked it when he told me that all the materialization he
had seen (obviously from others) was fraudulent.
Ch. X]
Orookes an Mosei' Maierializationa
157
As we shall see later, materialized hands are quite generally alleged to accompany the lights in the Moses phenomena.
In the notes already quoted from Sir William Crookes,
some indications of ', materialization '' have incidentally appeared. Here are some more (Pr. VI, 106, et seq.) :
** Mr. A. S. Wallace then asked for * Home, Sweet Home.'
A few bars of this air were immediately sounded. He looked
tinder the table and said he saw a hand distinctly moving the
instrument '* [An accordion. H. H.] ** up and down, and playing on the kejrs. Mr. Home had one hand on the table and
was holding the top end of the accordion, whilst Mr. A. IL
Wallace saw this hand at the bottom end where, the keys were.
',We then heard a rustling noise on a heliotrope which was
growing in a flower-pot standing on the table between Mr.
Home and Mrs. Wm. Orookes. On looking round, Mrs. Wm.
Orookes saw what appeared to be a luminous cloud on the
plimt. (Mr. Home said it was a hand.) We then heard the
crackling as of a sprig being broken off, and then a message
—
came:
"'Four
Ellen.'
"Immediately the white luminous cloud was seen to travel
from the heliotrope to Mrs. Wm. C.,s hand, and a small sprig
of the plant was put into it. She had her hand then patted
by a delicate female hand. She could not see the hand itself,
but only a halo of luminous vapor over her hand."
"A hand was seen by some, and a luminous cloud by others,"
[Diddifferent
anybody people,
see Polonius's
whaleto t believers
Olouds look
different
to
especially
and very
disbdievers.
H. H.] "pulling the flowers about which were in a stand on
the table. A flower was then seen to be carried deUberatdy
and given to Mrs. Wm. Orookes."
The following is from Sir William Orookes' Researches,
pp. 92-3:
" The hands and fingers do not always appear to me to be
solid and life-like. Sometimes, indeed, they present more the
appearance of a nebulous cloud partly condensed into the
f orm, of a hand. This is not equally visible to all present.
For instance, a flower or other small object is seen to move;
one person present will see a luminous doud hovering over
it, another will detect a nebulous-looking hand, whilst others
will see nothing at all but the moving flower. I have more
than once seen, first an object move, then a luminous cloud
appear to form about it, and, lastly, the cloud condense into
shape and become a perfectly-formed hand. At this stage, the
hand is visible to all present. It is not always a mere form,
but sometimes spears perfectly life-like and graceful, the
168
Molecular Telddneais
[Bk. II, Pt. I
fingers moving and the flesh appAi<6>,il7 as human as that
of any in the room. At the wrist, or arm, it becomes haqr*
and fades off into a luminous cloud.
''To the touch, the hand sometimes appears icy cold and
dead; at other times, warm and life-like, grasping my own
with the firm pressure of an old friend.
''I have retained one of these hands in my own, firmly
resolved not to let it escape. There was no struggle or effort
made to get loose, but it gradually seemed to resolve itself
into vapor, and faded in that manner from my grasp.''
Dr. Speer says regarding Moses (Pr. IX, 275) :
''...... The medium was entranced, and the controlling q;>irit
informed me that he would endeavor to place the light in
the medium's hand. Failing in this, he said he would knock
on the table in front of me. Almost immediately a light
came and stood on the table close to me. 'You see; now
listen, I will knock.' Very slowly the light rose up, and struck
three distinct blows on the table. 'Now I will show you my
hand.' A large, very bright light then came up, and inside
of it appeared the materialized hand of the spirit. ... The
power having become exhausted, he eiiiorted me to wake the
medium."
Prom Moses.
(Pr. IX, 311-12) :
''Sunday Evening, May 18th, 1873. ... Scent was brought,
It was
not as before, but by a cool wind laden with the odor.
like otto [Sic for attar. H.n.] of roses, very powerful. As
it passed round the circle Dr. and Mrs. Speer and I saw a figure
carrying it apparently. I also saw a figure in the middle of the
table when the lyre soimd was heard there."
It seems to me that all these odors we are about amell more
of imagination than of anything else. We shall meet them
again.
(Pp.descend
309-10)from
: " Wednesday,
7th, and
1873.play
... the
We accordion.
all saw a
hand
the top of theMay
curtain
It was a large hand, and its reflection on the window-blind
was strong. After this a head showed in similar way. When
Mrs. Crookes was told to go into the room and occupy the
chair ... a form was materialized as far as the middle. It floated
near the folding doors, and advanced towards Mrs. Crookes, who
screamed, and it vanished.
" Mrs. Crookes, to whom I (F. W. H. Myers) have shown this
account, makes the following comments (Pr. IX, 310-11) :
".
Mr. Home then left me and stood between the two
rooms. The accordion was immediately taken from his hand
Ch. X] Moses and Cox on Homers MaieriaJizations
169
by a cloudy appearance, which booh seemed to candense into
a distinct human form, clothed in a fihny drapery, standing near Mr. Home between tb, two rooms. The accordion
began to play (I do not remember whether on this occasion
there was any recognized melody), and the figure gradually
advanced towards me till it almoet touched me, playing continuously. Itwas semi-transparenty and I could see ibe sitters
through it all the time. Mr. Home remained near the sliding
doors. As the figure approached I felt an intense cold, getting
stronger as it got nearer,'' JJ,, BhsJl meet much of this change
of temperature later. H. H.] ''and as it was giving me the
accordion I could not help screaming. The figure immediately
seemed to sink into the floor to the waist, leaving only the
head and shoiilders visible, still playing the accordion, which
was then about a foot off the floor. Mr. Home and my husband
came to me at once, and I have no dear recollection of what
then occurred, ezc,t that the accordion did not cease playing
immediately.
''Mr. Seijeant Cox was rather angry at my want of nerve,
and exclaimed : ' Mrs. Crookes, you have spoilt the finest manifestation we have ever had.' I have always regretted that my
want of presence of mind brought the phoiomena to so abrupt
a termination."
" Thursday, December lith. — Douglas House. Dr. and Mrs.
8. and I (M.) — The stance was short. I questioned Imperator "
[A " spirit " of whom we shall learn more hereafter. H.H.] " as
to a vision I had had on the previous night. He said that he
had appeared to me. He was somewhat different in appearance
to what had been described. I asked whether I should see
him again. He knocked out: 'Watch,' The clouds of light,
which had gathered as usual round me, lifted and went to
my right hand. They condensed gradually into a pillar, and
finally into a form, majestic, stately, and noble in piien. The
body was draped as with a toga, though that might simply
have been the spirit drapery. The right arm was extended
and pointed towards me. The face was the face of my vision,
though not so distinct. I asked that I might be touched, and
the figure slowly stepped towards me, but did not touch me.
Finally it faded away very gradually until it was dissipated in
luminous mist. Dr. and Mrs. 8. saw misty light, but nothing
more. I asked who it was, and 'Myself' was rapped, but in
Imperator's knocks."
Vastly more impressive than the child's " It's me/' but not
a whit more intelligent.
Imperator knew a language not evolved till a couple of
thousand years after his death. 8o they are learning in the
other world!
160
Molecular Telehinms
[Bk. II, Pi I
In the many cases of which a few are here given. Home
and Stainton Moses are, so far as I know, the only persons
(except Foster in the foregoing very mild case) who are said
to haye produced materializations without the conjunction
of cabinets, curtains, partial darkness, and other accessories
favorable to illusion. Eusapia Palladino's manifestations have
all been open to these objections, as well as to the one from
her frequent trickery. On the assumption, however, that
any materializations have been genuine, there is room for
some plausible guessing as to their relations to known modes
of force.
As has been seen, hands, limbs, faces, and entire human
figures seem to appear. Sometimes objects are moved by
apparently material hands. These hands are grasped by the
company. Sometimes they fed natural, sometimes cold and
clammy. All these phenomena are classed as ', materializations.,' Now what do we so far know of " materialization '*
— of " matter *, ? It has been followed down through atoms,
molecules, ions, until the latest view is that each portion
of it is an aggregate of units of force. All the phenomena
of matter that we know of, save resistance, we have long
known as manifestations of force in vibration-,heat waves,
light waves, sound waves, and the rest; and now resistance
seems to have been reduced, with the rest, to a mode of
force. Our conceptions are gradually changing from those
of two universes of, respectively, " matter ', and "mind,** to
a single universe of vibrations, all of it, of course, objective
to consciousness, as of old. Of the greater harmony of the
later conception with our latest knowledge, there seems little
question, but it is as revolutionary as was the conception of
evolution from inferior ancestors; and, while it is not as
repugnant to our habitual feelings as, at first, was the Darwinian conception, it will take some time to make the unified
universe of vibrations a permanent and consistent factor in
our thinking. But that it will in time become not only
that, but a welcome and fruitful one, seems highly possible.
Till lately we have supposed we knew two worlds — one
of mind, and one — which includes our own bodies— external
to mind. Each of these worlds has always been at bottom
Ch. X]
Speculations on Materialization
161
a mystery, and tbe relation between them a mystery. Each
produces phenomena in the other, and yet to imagine mind
and matter taming into each other, is very difficult, and
until lately has been impossible. But now it really does
seem as if the division between them might be but superficial
and often merely one of those provisional lines with which
our minds are constantly dividing, in the effort to conquer,
the essential unity of Nature.
In the chase that analysis and hypothesis have made after
the smallest particle of matter, they now seem to have chased
all the particles away, and found nothing really there but
psychical influences that awaken in us the psychical effects
which we call resistance, roughness, smoothness, form, color,
etc., etc., just as in our visions, sleeping or waking, we experience those same sensations, without the intervention of
any particle of ,'matter.'' If there is, then, after all, but
one source of sensation — ,mind acting on mind, '' materialization ,'is not impossible, and there is no longer any necessity
for reading libraries to find out that we don't know how
mind can act on body, or body on mind.
Now as, in our experience, mechanical energy, muscular
energy, nervous energy, heat, light, electrical power, and the
rest, are constantly transmuted into each other, is it not easily
conceivable that any one of them may be transmntable into
resistance to pressure? Nay, a step farther, is it improbable
that the telekinetic force may belong with the rest in a
mutually interchangeable group, which can produce on our
waking perceptions as well as in our dreams, all the effects
which, in certain combinations, we recognize as ', matter"?
On this hypothesis, the force manifested by or through the
materializers can (not inconsistently) be assumed to manifest
itself as ', matter,'' including such aggregates of force as we
are familiar with in the forms which usually perform certain
ftinctions — as hands which move things.
Another guess. The supply of force connected with any
one materializer is, of course, limited. Even the alleged
*, messages " through the meditmis assert that, and the accompanying phenomena illustrate it. When, on hypothesis, the
telekinetic mode is transmuted into the modes which, in certain
combinations and proportions, impress us as ', matter," that
163
Molecular T$lekiM8i9
[Bk. II, Pt I
impression can last no longer than the amount of force
available for the effect, holds out. Hence the force which
manifests itself as a hand grasped by the sitter, gradually
becomes ezhansted — that is, gradually changes, as all modes
of force do, into other modes — and the hand ** fades '' away.
Still another guess. The aggr,ate of modes of force—waves of light, heat, resistance, etc., which produce the impression of,say, a hand or a complete human form, with
its drapery if you please--of all those modes, only enough
may be present, at any moment, to produce a portion of the
phenomena usually impressing us as matter. The heat*mode
may be absent, and the " hand '' feels cold. The sight-mode
alone may be present, the resistance-mode lacking, and the
sitter's hand passes through the only partially ,' materialized **
hand, or the partially materialized human figure; or the spectator, trying to grasp the human figure that he sees, passes
through it
Somewhere about the middle sixties, I saw a play or two
at Wallack's, in which the visible elements, without the audible
and incompressible ones, were successfully introduced by
optical machinery. Moving figures apparently as *, real " as
the actual actors, were placed on the stage, and the actual
actors walked right through them.
The apparent hands or more complete figures which oppose
no resistance, nevertheless are said to move objects. Even
if they do, it is consistent with the hypothesis that, at such
moments, the resistance-mode of force is temporarily added
to the sight-mode.
We even appear to have the resistance-mode separated from
all the others— e.g., from visibility, etc. (Cf. Foster's case
ante.) I doubt if anybody can believe the account of the
attempt at independent writing by the pencil and the lath
on pages 176-7, and similar cases, without assuming an
invisible and an inaudible but resisting agent, or even personality, handling the two objects. This conception is something more than mere unthinking anthropomorphism.
Now a question, in regard to which perhaps the reader
will prefer to do his own guessing. If the alleged partial
and temporary manifestations of human figures do really
come through the thinking and feeling entities called Home,
Ch. X]
" SpiriU " Superfluous in Telekinesis 163
MocieS; and many others, whence come the complete and lifelong manifestationB of human beings that we know and are?
Was Garlyle stretching language yery far in calling ns all
spirits? ',Ghosts/' I believe, was his word. Do not onr
latest knowledge and best thinking result in the idesr— old
in many forms — ,that we are but expressions of a measureless
force which is ourselves and also behind ourselves? Would
any person given to the old phraseology be very fantastic in
calling us thoughts of the divine mind ?
Please notice that hitherto this exposition, so far as I have
been able to keep the threads distinct in spite of the in*
evitable tangle with '' spiritualism/' has referred simply to
a mode, or modes, of force, manifested, or alleged to be
manifested, like electricity and magnetism, in mechanical
action, and in the production of lights and sotmds; and,
unlike any modes of force previously known, in the pro*
duction, without the use of matter, of objects sometimes resisting pressure and sometimes showing other attributes of
matter. The word ''spirif and its derivatives have been
used a few times, generally in passages quoted, as, at the present stage of human intelligence, it is inevitable it should be
in the discussion of any phenomena not yet correlated with
familiar ones. So far, however, we have really simply encountered nothing more than new modes of force. As far
as concerns the merely kinetic side, the production of motion
in masses or molecules, it seems already as well correlated
with the other modes of force we know, as, say, the electromagnetic mode was a century ago : for :
(I) We know its source, which is the human organism:
for it is manifested only in the presence of specially endowed
human beings, and never, so far as we know, in their absence,
though Sir William Crookes thinks that probably all human
beings
however,Tn
inappreciable
I have hate~l{,
already sonie,
suggested
the possibility
of itsamounts,
existenceand
in
other animals. Much testimony indicates the possibility of
one person — ,possibly only a specially endowed one, collecting
the power from others. So with electricity.
(II) We know that it is a mode of chemical energy stored
up in food and air, and is extracted from them by human
164
Molecular Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Ft I
beings, just as muscular and some kinds of intellectual force
are.
(Ill) We know approximately, that it is quantitatively
transmuted from those possessing it: for their other modes
of force are depleted in apparent, though not yet closelytested, proportion to the manifestations of this one.
So far as we have got, then, there is nothing more superorauil or '' spiritual '' about the mode of force known as
telekinetic, than about any other; and we can expect to keep
on correlating it with the other modes, as we haye correlated
each of them with their fellows, and also to get practical
advantages from it as we have from them.
Magnetism is unquestionably telekinetic, and it might not
be a strain of language to call electricity so, and even heat
and light So the mere capacity to act without contact does
not necessarily entitle the new force more than any of the
others, to the name.
As magnetic aune seem at last to be established, and as the
new mode of force has also been associated with aurse and other
lights without heat, its association with magnetism seems
very close; and as it is, so far as we know, manifested only
by human beings, anthropo-magnetism might be a good name
for it; but as there is a strong probability that it may also
exist, as electricity does, in some, if not all, of the lower
animals, a more general name would perhaps be safer, and
I have already used zoomagnetism. I had written this word
several times before I knew that Dr. Id,beault had used it
in a widely different connection, now virtually obsolete. I
prefer to stick to it until mine too becomes obsolete, especially
as, whatever may be the defects of such a name, it is a step
toward embracing this new mode of force in the ''natural
and correlating it with the modes we know better.
But have we not merely got back to our old discarded
acquaintance Animal Magnetism, seeking to be restored to
credit under a new Greek first-name? No: this is an entirely
different character, and the different name may perhaps be
found to have uses that more than counterbalance the objections to its old associations.
The suspicion that the so-called telekinetic force may be
magnetic, not only suggests its correlation with the modes
Ch. X]
Possible Uses of Telekinesis
165
of force generally recognized nnder that name, but with
some other modes which are yet but faintly recognized, or
regarded as illusions or frauds.
These other modes would be partly explained if it should
be found that heat in contact with a living human body
possessing marked telekinetic power, can be converted into
telekinetic power and stored in the system. But to complete the explanation. Home's non-combustion of the handkerchief, recited some pages farther on, would also have to
be accotmted f or : so a more probable hypothesis would be that
zoomagnetism is repellent of heat, and can be conveyed to
v,table fiber generally, as we have abundant evidence that
it can to wood.
These questions will probably soon be settled in the laboratory. Iam surprised that they do not appear to have already
received more attention from such men as Sir William
Crookes and Sir William Barrett. They may have had it»
however, without the investigators being yet ready to report,
although the former has lately said, in effect, that for many
years he has been kept so busy witii the old modes of force
that he has had little time for the new ones.
Possible Uses of Telekinesis
If an electric eel were to make himself disagreeable to a
tadpole, the tadpole would probably not gain from the experience a very definite idea of the mode of force which
moves the Morse recording instrument, the telephone, the
trolley-car, the electric autos on land and water and in air,
and the *' wireless.'* The boys of whom I was one, who saw
the playing with the same force in the Tale laboratory in the
early sixties, had practically little more idea of its later uses
than the tadpole would have ; and indeed Oalvani, Volta, and
Ampere could not have had much more realization than we
boys had, of the possibilities lurking in the novel phenomena
which attracted their attention.
The new modes of force we have been considering may
have possibilities even more revolutionary than those of galvanism and electricity. It seems not unreasonable to presume
that so far as the occurrences grouped, perhaps unwarrantably,
under the name of telekinesis, surpass in interest the picking
166
MoUctdar TeUkinma
[Bk. II, Pt I
up of paper by glasB or amber rubbed with silk, or even the
modest laboratory performances which were all that was
known of electricity fifiy years ago, that far at least will
zoomagnetism eventually expand our reactions with the universe beyond the expansion given to them by electricity.
We may, even at the risk of ,'the dignity of letters/'
amuse ourselves with a few of the possibilities : young couples
could place the furniture in their new flats independently of
the servant problem; the mountains might not be made to
come to Mahomet, instead of Mahomefs being obliged to go
to them, but many smaller things could be brought, even
perhaps through obstacles that are now as impermeable by
matter as we onoe supposed them to be by light and electricity;
non-swimmers could (as we shall learn ( ?) in the next chapter) levitate themselves above water, though perhaps it would
be too bold a flight to imagine those going down to the sea in
ships lifting themselves and their ships over the shoals or of!
from the rocks, though persons threatened by runaway horses,
automobiles, or trolleys, or railroad trains could simply levitate themselves over the dangerous objects, if indeed there
should be need of encountering such objects: for levitation
might make most human transits, if they were no longer than
the limits imposed by food supply and digestive power, aerial
instead of terrestrial, though it is not yet time to sell out
aeroplane stock at a loss ; we might not, for lack of matches,
have to go smokeless with tobacco in our pockets, or fireless
with fuel on hand, though the indications of the new force
being mutable into heat are as yet scant: the evidence regarding its power, or some kindred power, to resist heat is,
however, more positive, as we shall soon see. If that power
becomes developed at the outset of conflagrations, a man
could render himself to some extent immune against injury
by fire, often long enough to escape danger, and perhaps
could even be his own fire extinguisher. As to light, in an
unanticipated and often dangerous darkness, the human system could supply its own.
These suggestions are of course as much jokes as prophecies,
but what would have seemed forty years ago, suggestions
of the electric light, the trolley-car, tiie telephone, and wireless
telegraphy ?
CHAPTEB
MOLAR
TBLEP8YCHIC
XI
TELBEINE8I8
Though I have tried to restrict myself to physical matters,
we have already found them inevitably tangled np with
,psychic ones. In fact I doubt if we know of one independently of the other — ,if their separation is anything more than
one of the provisional mental processes which we have so
often found classification to be. And yet tmtil the recent
strong indications that the incompres,ibility of matter is,
like its visibility and other sense impressions, but vibration,
the gulf between mind and matter was largely regarded as
impassable; but now it is very doubtful if the mind can
reidly make a coherent conception of any such impassable
gulf. Nevertheless from some points of view it seems impassable, and I have already spoken of it as such, and flatly
guessed the other way.
Here on the vague borderland of knowledge we get as
badly mixed up as if we were philosopl,rs; but then we
acknowledge it. And though the borderland moves outward,
those who enter it at any stage, always must get mixed up.
Some of them have made all the discoveries, nevertheless.
An impassable gulf between the physical and the psychical
had long been regarded as necessary to the possibility of an
immortal soul in a mortal body. It was held that without
that impassable gulf, the body must drag down the soul with
the body's death. It does not seem to have entered into anybody's mind that the vibrations constituting body might
in time even take on the qualities of soul, unless indeed there
was some such guess symbolized in the doctrine of the resurrection of the body. On re-reading the foregoing sentence
after some months, I find it, like many sentences more
nearly famous, rather deficient in clear meaning. Yet in
these gropings we must constantly encounter vague impressions, and it may be well to let some of them stand in the
167
168
Molar TeUpstfchic TeleUnesis
[Bk. II, Pi I
hope that here and there may be one which in time will turn
out a clue to something.
The telekinetic force we have been considering has a peculiarity that, so far as I know, was never until about the
middle of the last century, generally associated with the manifestation of any recognized mode of force. We have been
accustomed to intelligent reactions from human beings, sometimes through inanimate things obviously regulated by them;
but through telekinesis we are getting intelligent reactions
from inanimate things without the intelligence behind them
being clearly understood.
At first, the common inference was of course that the things
were moved by ** spirits,'' but many of the best investigators
incline to the opinion that tiie intelligence regulating the
movements was the intelligence initiating them — ,that the
medium, perhaps involuntarily, makes the intelligent reactions.
That may be true, but anybody who knows anything about
it (which but few people have taken the trouble to) knows
at least that if the only intelligence concerned is that of the
medium, the intelligence does not always act through the
muscles, or even the will.
Perhaps it is well to say before beginning on these things,
that I have no settled opinion regarding the source of this
ostensible intelligence. So far, my opinion has inclined much
more strongly to a ,, rationalistic " than toward a ** spiritistic "
interpretation. I don't think much of that pair of words,
however: for I don't see why ', spiritualism " is inevitably
not rational, though it has not yet been proved so, to my
satisfaction at least. Yet fairness compds me to admit
that I begin with a bias. For reasons that I cannot tell in
evidential detail, though I will later give an idea of their
general nature, I believe, as far as I believe anything imperfectly verified, that the soul survives the body; and therefore Imust of course consider telekinetic phenomena indicating intelligence, under the bias of that belief. I can say,
however, that so far, I do not regard them as demonstrating
the belief, or even strongly supporting it.
y Amid the tangled phenomena of telekinetics, we have already met some hints of intelligent manifestations. We will
Ch. XI] InMligence shown through ** Table,tipping *' 169
now proceed directly to them. We shall have occasion to go
over much of the ground we have been over before, though
with new crops on it
Intelligent " Tdble'tipping/' etc.
First as to some molar phenomena : P
,'s music-stand, it
will be remembered, tilted in answer to questions, and I
attributed it to P
,'s unconsciously releasing the telekinetie
force to answer his own questions.
Let us now return to the Davis children. From Professor
Alexander's account of those interesting young persons, part
of which was given on pages 103 and 147, 1 purposely withheld some passages, in order that I might present them here
to illustrate the manifestation of ostensible answering consciousnes . Hesays that the table's
** sudden emphatic movements . . . often meant, according to the
usual * yes ' or ' no ' signals [Usually one rap for No and three
for Yes. H.H.] approval or disapproval of assertions made in the
conversation.'',
It would have been interesting to note whether the table
represented the views of the mediums. Elsewhere he says
(Pr. VII, 176) :
''On one occasion, a light thiee-footed table was inverted;
and my hands, with those of Mr. Davis, Mrs. Davis, and the
two girls, were lightly placed on each of the feet. Care was
taken to see that no one did more than just touch the feet
of the table; and, under these conditions, it sprang: rapidly from
the floor into the lap of one of the sitters, and thence to the
floor again, repeating this manoeuvre for each of us in turn.
In the Thursday evening stances it was conunon for the table
to place itself in the necessary position on our sitting down
to it, either immediately before or after our hands had been
placed on its surface."
Here the table followed the natural inclinations of the
sitters.
Again the same apparent effect (Ibid., p. 177) :
** A favorite dog . . . was seated on a chair. ... I jokingly challenged the invisible influence so to move the chair that the
dog might be obliged to jump down. Nothing happened for a
minute or so, when the dog left the chair — apparently of its
170
Molar TeUp$ychic Telekinesis
[Bk. 11, Ft I
own aooord. Two or three secondB elapsed after it had sprung
to the ground; and then the chair tilted before us alL In the
same way a child's swing, hanging in a nook of the room, was
at my desire subjected to a slight but very visible oscillation.''
This, too, was all in Professor Alexander's mind.
From Moses's Researches in Spirituaiism. Quoted in Pr.
IX, 260-2 2
,Motion without contact, directed by eyident intelligence,
is seen markedly in the following instance: — ,I was calling on
a friend« and the conversation feu on the phenomena of Spirit*
ualism. A sitting was proposed* and nothing, or almost nothing,
oocurred. We were quite alone in the room, which was w,
lighted. We drew back from tiie table, intending to give up
the attempt. My friend asked why nothing occurred. The
table, untouched by us, rose and gently touched my throat and
chest three times. I was suffering from severe bronchial
symptoms, and was altogether below par. After this no rap
or movement could be elicited, and we were fain to accept the
explanation of our want of success."
Moses was not up to the work, and himself knew that the
source of his incapacity was in his bronchial tubes. The table
presumably echoed him.
In Chapter YIII it is stated that small objects from different parts of the house were '* generally thrown on the table **
when Moses and some friends sat The original farther
states that
''such of them, however, as would easily break, were placed
quietly, and our attention was drawn to them by a request
for light."
This apparently means that the stance was, as very usual,
in a partly darkened room, that the objects thrown on the
table themselves made noise enough to attract attention,
but that when the more breakable objects were brought, the
raps made the signal calling for the alphabet, and on its
being given spelt out: ''lighf Thus far there is nothing
not easily accounted for by the agency (presumably invol*
untary) of the mediums. The Davis children, granted the
force under their control, could have nnconsciously made
the table express their approval or disapproval. As one un«
consciously nods or shakes one's head, so a very simple de*
CL XI]
It B,flex from the Medium Buffieientf
171
Bvre, with hardly an intellectual element, could have brought
their light table into the laps of the sitters or in a position
for the circle. Similarly there need not have been more
than a very simple reflex of their desire to have Professor
Alexander's wishes carried out in the table tilting after the
dog left it, or the swaying of the swing which he asked for.
So too with sundry tables reported as keeping time to
music, or with almost any response made by the table
to a question or desire naturally entertained by the medium.
But as we pursue our way, it seems gradually to go outside
of these possible reflexes from the medium.
In the account of Sir William Crookes' bell on page 153
the original says that before the bell was heard, the table
spelt out: ''We are going to bring something to show our
power.'' Apparently there was no consciousness in the
medium of what was coming.
The same is true of Stainton Moses's big stone. The
original account states that its appearance was preceded by
a table message : '' We have brought stone. Wait."
On the face of it, these communications have much less
than the preceding ones, the appearance of being reflexes
from the medium.
Tables haye ascribed their motions to all sorts of angels
and devilB apparently expressing the conceptions in the mind
of the medium of the force.
Dr. Salveton's table (as reported in the AnnaU of Psychical
Science, January-March, 1910) said that it was moved by
''a deyil named Dormon," who agreed to show himself.
When asked why he did not come, the table said : '' Candles."
They were put out. Still he did not appear, and the tuble
when asked the reason, said : '' Oas," referring to a light in
the hall which came in through the transom. This was put
out Begarding the rest of the experience, Salveton says :
',We were all excited in the extreme, but the nervous state
of Barth,lemy G., C, and particularly that of Gabriel D.,
seemed to me to be abnormal. • . . I . . . put a further preliminary
question to the table. ... Is there any danger in Dormon coming?
Tes. What danger! Insanity. For all! No. For one onlyt
Tes. Which one? D. . . . Gabriel D., who had been thus named,
was in a highly-strung condition, and cried out: 'I don't caie.
172
No matter.
Molar TeUpsychic Telehineris
We must go on to the end
[BL 11, Pi I
I want to see what will
happen.'
'' I learned later that Eugene B. had formerly had a lunatic
in his family, who was a great ' table-turner/ and who asserted
that these unusual movements were the woric of the devil Dormon, and that he had often seen this devil, who had the
appearance of a tall, beardless young man of oorpse-like pallor
and draped in a shroud."
This of course points to the involuntary exercise on the
table of human force, either muscular or psycho-kinetic.
« I asked the table to tell Dormon '* [the « devil "1 « it was
ill-mannered of him not to be willing to show himself without
doing injury to one of us, that well-bred people did not act
thus ; that, in these circumstances, he had only to remain where
he was, etc. Without allowing me to finish my diatribe, the
table said to me, 'M — 1' as in the story of Cambronne at
Waterloo, and, suddenly, with a noise comparable to that of
a hard blow of a mallet on a big drum of extraordinary sonorousness, the window was opened wide, the curtains not being
moved at all; the heavy copper candlestick and the box cS
matches placed on the top of the trunk were thrown to the
ground, and the wick of the candle was half-extinguished by
touching the floor. . . . The table . . . began to turn, sometimes in
one direction and sometimes in another, at such a rate that we
could not follow it and the top slipped from under our fingers.
Then it began to dance a kind of waltz, and by degrees got
nearer to the trunk, in front of which, on the floor, there was
still the overturned box with the matches scattered about. When
it reached the trunk the table raised its feet, one after the
other, and let them fall with a rubbing motion, twice in each
direction. After a moment I noticed that each time the feet of
the table fell the head of a match exploded. I called out to my
comrades to press with all their might upon the table so as to
stop its movement; despite the combined weight of seven of us
leaning on the table, not merely with the tips of our fingers,
but with our open palms, we were not able to stop it. Then,
calling out to all of them to let go, and not to touch it, I took
hold of the center support of the table, turned it over in the air,
and put it down wi, the flat top downwards on the floor and
placed both my feet on it so that it was unable to move. . . . Only
the heads of the matches trodden on by the table had been rubbed
and bruised, without a single exception. . . . None of the matches
had been touched by the feet of the table anywhere but on the
head."
This is about the only account of ''pure devilishness ''
Ch. XI]
Dr. Salveton's Table
173
that I have met with. One of the sitters was in a highly
strung condition, and had just been threatened with insanity.
In support of the hypothesis that the table echoes the
medium, Dr. Salveton says:
'M have never observed any instance in which a sensible
answer was obtained which was absolutely unknown to all
the experimenters without exception. I have, on the contrary, only observed instances of replies known, supposed, or
foreseen in advance, before being formulated by the table, by
one of the experimenters, most frequently by the director of
the experiment, sometimes ako by another who appeared to
play only a subordinate part.
*, It was not long before we observed :—
,'1. That the sooner the table began to tremble after the
chain of hands had been formed around the top, the more
successful was the exi)eriment, and the more easily and accurately the replies were given. In other words, the stronger
and clearer the force, whether it was the sitters' force moving
the table as an echo to themselves, or was independent of
them.
,,2. That the replies through the table were always very
correct when they were previously known to one or other of
those joining hands in the circle.
,'8. That the replies were always confused or absurd when
the table was asked things unknown to all present.
, We formed the habit of leaving to the table itself the choice
of the experimenter who was to put the question, a choice
which it signified by leaning towards him.
''Every time that the choice fell upon me I noticed that
the reply that the table would make to each question came
into my mind before the table gave the answer, and that
every time that I did not clearly foresee the reply, the table
eilher did not answer or did not do so in an intelligible
manner.
" On several occasions we asked the table the ages of some
persons present (unknown to the questioner), the number of
coins an experimenter had in his purse, the number of matches
remaining in a partly emptied box, . . . and, for the most part,
[Italics mine. H.H.] the table replied correctly."
I suspect that the part where the table did not reply
correctly was where (as probably in the case of the matches
and the coins) nobody knew the fact — ,that the case was, in
one point, like that of the magician with my matchbox given
on page 280.
174
Molar Telepeychie Tdehineris
[BL II, Pt. I
I have yet to meet my first case of a snperosual report of
a fact not known to any human intelligenoe. Yet Salveton
tells of the table, in answer to an inquiry for an unknown
murderer, spelling out the name, occupation, and address.
The name, occupation, and address were found in the Paris
directory, but more than ten years having elapsed since the
crime, it was too late for any proceedings. But in this case,
a number of persons knew the name, occupation, and address,
and if they really were connected with the murderer, that
fact was known to at least the murderer himself.
Yet despite all this, Dr. Salveton says :
** A table has spelt out facts not known to any person present, but known to others. Its replies, however, were reported
'always veiy correct when they were previously known to
one or other of those joining hands in the circle ' and ' always
confused or absurd when the table was asked things unknown
to all present.'
,' 1 hold it to be established, though not fully demonstrated,
that the motive force of the table is quite unconnected with
any diabolical or supernatural intervention, and that this
force is connected with the scientifically studied phenomena
of hypnotism and catalepsy; by the formation of a circle of
hands by the experimenters, for a longer or shorter period,
this force seems to be discharged from their persons, just as
electricity is discharged from several cells coupled up to form
a battery, and by the application of this force the table can
be made to execute movements dictated by the will of all or
one imknown to themselves, or vaguely perceived by one of
them only, by a sort of collective, but very feeble, hypnotism."
The first cases I gave showed that no '' cells coupled " are
necessary.
Here is a more composite case from Bartlett (op. cit,
p. 117). It anticipates what will be told later of Foster's
reading from folded slips, and getting visions of the personalities towhom the names belonged.
From a Washington paper, name and date not given. Mr.
Bartlett, though plainly sincere, had not a historian's care
in his documentation. He telb me that every newspaper
account in his book which was cut out by him, is properly
attributed and dated, but that he used some clippings which
were sent him by others without the desirable memoranda,
Ch. XI] Foster,s Boclnng'Chair. Barrett's Amateur
175
and, especially in the confusion of travel, marking thoee often
escaped him.
"When the folded slip was placed on the table, three raps
indicated that the spirit corresponding to the name was present.
*Tes/ said Mr. Foster, *it is little
. She is your
consin, who loved you very dearly, and is very glad you came
here. She points to that rocking,air in the comer, behind
me, and says she will go and sit in it If she can, she will
make it rode.'
''At this point we of course looked at the chair, but so
many other 'signs and wonders' crowded upon us that in a
moment we had forgotten all about it, when suddenly the lad
looked up in amazement, and pointed to the distant rockingchair, winch surely enough was rocking away vigorously. When
the fact was noticed and acknowledged, raps came in all parts
of the room, and the sofa jumped out of place once more, as
if in confirmation of our acknowledgment."
Apparently the following is a strong case for the medium
being the source of the intelligence, and not some other mind
behind the manifestations. In Pr. IV, 34, Professor Barrett
gives an account of a stance with a lady (amateur) in Dublin,
which, although interesting for the usual physical manifestations, Iquote mainly for the sake of its conclusion. The
phenomena began with the usual raps,
** like the ticking of a hard point on the oilcloth which covev,
the floor of the room. ... In obedience to my request, the table
raised the two legs nearest to me completely off the ground,
some 8 or 10 inches, and thus suspended itself for a few moments.
Again a similar act was performed on the other side. Next
came a very unexpected occurrence. Whilst absolutely free
from tiie contact of every person the table wriggled itself
backward and forward, advancing towards the arm-chair in
which I sat, and ultimately completely imprisoning me in
my seat. ... It was followed by Mr. L. and Miss I., but they
were at no time touching it.
''Addressing the table, I now asked if knocks could be
given without the contact of the hand. . . . Three knocks quickly
cama The hands of both Mr. L. and Miss I. were now
held up, and whilst they partially withdrew from the table,
the knocks still came, not so vigorously, but still there they
were. This went on for some minutes, till they ceased to
be heard. A refresher was then given in the shape of a
few moments' contact with the hands. Once more the knocks
xetuzned, and continued some time after the hands were
176
Molar Telepsychic Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Pt I
r,noved." [Various * refreshers ' of the force will be met with
as we proceed. H. H.]
''There was always a remarkable intelligence and often a
jocosity about the sounds, and when a tune was played on the
piano the raps kept time to it Suddenly, only the tips of our
fingers being on the table, the heajy loo table at which we
were sitting made a series of vezy violent prancing movements
(which I could not imitate afterwards except by using both
hands and all my strength); the blows were so heavy that I
hurriedly stopped the performance, fearing for the safety of
the gas chandelier in the room below.
''It is true the character of the pious platitudes spelt out
by the table were just such as the medium herself (a Methodist)
would be likely to concoct."
Sir William Crookes says {Researches, p. 95) :
''During a seance with Mr. Home, a small lath, which I
have before mentioned, moved across the table to me, in the
light, and delivered a message to me by tapping my hand; I
repeating the alphabet, and the lath tapping me at the right
letters. The other end of the lath was resting on the table
some distance from Mr. Home's hands.
"The taps were so sharp and clear, and the lath was evi*
dently so well tmder control of the invisible power which was
governing its movements, that I said, 'Can the intelligence
governing the motion of this lath change the character of
the movements, and give me a telegraphic message through the
Morse alphabet by taps on my hand?' (I have every reason
to believe that the Morse code was quite unknown to any other
person present, and it was only imperfectly known to me.)
Immediately I said this, the character of the taps changed,
and the message was continued in the way I had requested.
The letters were given too rapidly for me to do more than
catch a word here and there, and consequently I lost the
message; but I heard sufficient to convince me that there
was a good Morse operator at the other end of the line, wherever that might be."
I don't see the impossibility of ', fhe good Morse operator
at the other end of the line'' being Sir William himself,
as were plainly Professor Barrett's Dublin Methodist lady,
and hundreds of others, including the father of the Davis
children, in a part of Professor Alexander's report.
From Crookes's Researches, p. 94 :
" A ' good failure often teaohes more than the most saocees*
ful experiment.' It took plaoe in the light, in my own room,
with only a few private friends and Mr. Home present. Sev-
Ch. XI]
Pencil and Lath.
Influence Covers MxUs
177
eral circumstances ... had shown that the power that eyen*
ing was strong. I therefore expressed a wish to witness the
actual production of a written message such as I had heard
described a short time before by a friend. Immediately an
alphabetic communication was made as follows: — ,'We will
tzy.' A pencil and some sheets of paper had been lying on
the center of the table; presently the pencil rose up on its
point, and after advancing by hesitating jerks to the paper
fell down. It then rose and again fell. A third time it tried,
but with no better result. After three unsuccessful attempts, a
small wooden lath, which was lying near upon the table, slid
towards the pencil, and rose a few inches from the table; the
pencil roee again, and propping itself against the lath, the two
together made an effort to mark the paper. It fell, and then
a joint effort was again made. After a third trial the lath
gave it up and moved back to its place, the pencil lay as it
fell across the paper, and an alphabetic message told us :— ' We
have tried to do as you asked, but our power is exhausted.' "
M. Edmond Duchatel narrates in The AnnaU of Psychical
Science, January-March, 1910, that he and a , psychometrist "
seated at a table, got it to rap out a message from a friend
three kilometres away whom he had asked to concentrate
his attention on the topic at the hour appointed for the sitting,
and that he got not only the message, but that he and his
companion both got a pain in the shoulder from which, unknown to them, the absent friend was suffering.
While the two persons were at the table, the distant third
person went to sleep (an experience almost unknown to him
in day-time) and was sleepy for hours after the stance closed.
He lost the pain in the shoulder when it was conveyed to
the sitters.
It seems as obvious as anything in these foggy regions
can be, that the message came to the ', psychometrist's ** subliminal consciousness (which will be explained later, see
index) and was echoed back to him by the table.
The case anticipates also our consideration of telepathy,
but in the vast complexity of these phenomena, clear dis*
entanglement and sequent arrangement are almost impossible.
It may be handy to have a word for telepathic communication with persons not present with the sitter — a wider tele*
pathy. Some of my Grecian friends suggest teloteropathy.
But this is anticipating.
Below are some of the occurrences and ''messages'' re*
178
Molar Tehpeychic Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Pt I
ported by Sir William Crookea to have taken place in the
presence of Home. They gave to the manifestations of molar
telekinesis a ', spiritual '' background. These are so generally
associated that it is not practicable to give a considerable idea
of telekinetic phenomena without bringing in the alleged
spiritual element. Most of this, perhaps all, exhibited in
connection with telekinesis, I am inclined, as in my friend
P
,'s case, to attribute to the volition, often unconscious,
of the operator.
(Pr. VI, 102): ''Answers were given by raps and notes
on the accordion. The alphabet being called for by five raps,
the following message was spelled out : ' It is a glorious truth.
It was the solace of my earth-life and the triumph over the
change called death. Robert Chambers.'"
(lb. 107) : '' Mr. Home then took the accordion in his right
hand in the usual manner, and placing his left on the table
it was held both by Miss Douglas and Mrs. Wm. Grookes.
The light was then put out, and the following message was
— Four Seasons. Winter first.' 'Spring— The Birth
spelt:
"'The
of the Flowers.' 'Birds in Summer.'
" The above messages were given whilst the piece was being
played. It would be impossible to give any idea of the beauty
of the music, or its expressive chanacter. During the part
typifying summer, we had a beautiful accompaniment, the
chirping and singing of the birds being heard along with the
accordion. During autumn" [Which the spirits seem to have
forgotten in the foregoing enumeration.] "we had 'The Last
Bose of Summer' played.
"Home said that the spirit playing was a stranger to him*
It was a high and very powerful one, and was a female who
had died young.
"Mrs. Wm. Crookes said: 'Is it my cousin M
f It has
flashed into my mind that it is she.'
"Answer by raps: 'Yes.'"
(lb. 114): "We soon had the message: — ,'We find we have
no more power.' The meeting then broke up."
On another occasion:
" Mr. Home then took it in his hand, where it played, and
delivered the following message by chords" [Presumably at
the mention of letters of the alphabet. H. H.] "in the usual
way:
"'Our joy and thankfulness to have been allowed to make
our presence manifest. We thank you for your patience and
we thank Ood for His love.' "
Ch. XI]
TeleHneiic 8h$U Carving?
179
(lb. 119): ,'We then saw the accordion expand and contract, and heard a tune played. Hre. Wm. Grookes and Mr.
Home saw a light on the lower part of the accordion, where
the keys were, and we then heard and saw the keys clicked
and depressed one after the other fairly and deliberately, as
if to show us that the power doing it, although invisible (or
nearly so) to us, had full control over the instrument.',
The following is probably the most incredible case of
intelligent molar telekinesis on record. In puzzling over it,
one may properly ask: If the telekinetic power can move
objects without contact, move them with discrimination and
force or delicacy, where is the limit to what it can do with
them? The case suggests that the field may be at least as
broad as human faculty. According to all we have gathered
before regarding the power, I, for one, don't know whether
to believe in the following alleged manifestation or not.
Where is one to draw the line ? The account at least indicates
a direction in which to keep one's eyes open, but unlike most
of what I quote from Moses, it rests on his unsupported
testimony.
From Stainton Moses' memorandum book (Pr. XI, 61-2) :
'' August 27th, 1875. . . . Some time since a cameo was cut
during a stance at Douglas House. . . . Last night the experiment
was repeated under very satisfactory circumstances. ... A long
message
rapped isoutanbyalleged
Catharine
frequent '*phenomena,
control " of
Moses. was
A control
spirit[A producing
including communications of any kind, through a medium.
H.H.]. She said they had brought a shell, and were going to
cut a cameo ; that I was in trance ' for the night,' and that I
was to be left alone ,11 morning, and not to be told of what was
done. A light was struck, and Dr. and Mrs. S. saw a shell in the
middle of the table. I was in deep trance. . . . Then Mentor came
and Imperator. [Two other controls whom I believe we have
met before, and shall often meet later. H.H.] After he left,
light was called for, and in the center of the table was a cameo
and a quantity of debris of shell. Noises had been heard as of
picking, and I saw a hand. The shell is more clearly cut than
the first, and shows a head, laurel-crowned. It is polished inside,
and shows plain marks of the graving tool. The stance lasted
about an hour.
" From Mr. Moses' letter to Mrs. Speer August Ist, 1876 :
''Mentor was the cunning workman who fashioned the
cameo. He is not content with his work, which he says was
bad, and that he can do much better. He actually carved it.
/
180
Molar Telepsychic Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Pi I
he says. And I see no reason to doubt it, seeing that I can
find no limit to spirit-power. If they are allowed to work in
their own way they can do almost ai,thing. It is only when
we compel them to work in lines prescribed by us that they
find any difficulty.,
I have deliberately transposed the chronological order of
these passages, because the one now first opens the subject
betterAssuming the authenticity of the story, it is not very easy
to fasten the performance on Moses's involuntary self. The
power that disintegrated the particles of shell presumably
came from him, an agent apparently being always required,
and the most remarkable feats being performed while the
agent is in trance, as Moses was on this occasion. But that
he supplied the direction of the power — the artistic capacity
— ,is not an hypothesis so easy to adopt: for I have met no
other intimation that he had any capacity in the representative arts. The case leaves less room for the medium and
more for the alleged control, than any other alleged telepsychic telekinesis I can recall.
And here at last we are face to face with the spiritistic
hypothesis, and with the only choice as yet apparent, between
accepting it or leaving the judgment in suspense — ,an art
in which apparently we shall have much practice as we proceed.
This astounding story is very properly '* the limit " of our
attention to molar telekinetic displays of intelligence.
CHAPTEB
MOLECULAR
Xn
TELEPSTCHIO TELEEINE8IB
So far as fhe tangled phenomena have pennitted daBsifica*
tion, we have now had illustrations of telekinetic phenomena
under the heads of the unconscious molar (Chapters YIII,
IX), the unconscious molecular (Chapter X), and the conscious molar (Chapter XI). Let us proceed to the conscious
molecular, though so intermixed are the phenomena and the
accounts of them that I have already partly anticipated that
division, and question my wisdom in having attempted any
division at alL
Intelligent Sounds
First, the changes in furniture, etc., which produce '' raps ',
expressing intelligence. To begin again with the most prob*
able, or least improbable, manifestations — ,those through the
young and innocent
Professor Alexander says of the Davis children (Pr. YII,
177):
''From the first outbreak of the phenomena rape were the
principal means used for announcing the supposed spirit presence. They came on the floor, on the table, and, more rarely,
on the walls, in signals which from the beginning were sharply
individualized for each separate influence, the same individu*
ality maintaining its characteristics throughout the sittings.
As before stated, they varied in loudness from hardly perceptible ticks up to resounding blows, such as might be struck
by a large wooden mallet. In the quality of some of these
sounds tibere were also marked and persistent distinctions.
...This individuality of the raps was early forced upon our
notice; and we learnt to recognize them when heard."
(lb. 179): ''The same blows came, but with even more
intensity; and they were finally requested by Mrs. Davis from
another room not to make so much noise, as they would wake
the children who were sleeping in other parts of the house.
The blows seemed to lir. Davis to shake the whole building.
"
Mr. Davis tapped out the alphabet from A to Z and
181
182
Molecular Telepsychic Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Ft. I
the numbers 1 to 0 in Morse signals. At each letter given the
same sound was exactly imitated, the raps coming again near
the elder girl on the floor at tiie other end of the room. The
imitation was, indeed, so perfect that Mr. Davis declared it
was his own * sending.' ''
Mr. Davis was an expert telegrapher, and it seems not
improbable that through sympathies which often accompany
zoomagnetic power, and which will be dealt with later, it
really was, unconsciously, his own ', sending,'' via the children, especially in view of the following paragraph (Cf.
Home's lath, in the last chapter) :
', Nevertheless, no message was given in Morse signals, the
reason a£Brmed being that, as the medium did not know telegraphy, they could not use her for that purpose. Now, Mr.
Davis was the only person present who knew anything at all
about Morse signals. . . . One only mistake was made at the
letter Q, which was, however, correctly given the second time.
All the other letters were smartly reproduced without the slightest hesitation. . . . Mr. X. found, when he tried alone, tibat,
although he knew telegraphy well, he could not kick out the
signals with his feet.
''I may say that, in spite of the many little proofs we had
obtained of the genuineness of our phenomena, my attitude
and that of Mr. Davis towards each repetition of the manifestations was always one of watchful suspicion. Protests were
often made by the influences at work; and it was affirmed
that we hindered their action by our persistent doubts."
This necessity for faith — for freedom from *' doubts" of
course suggests necessity of a willingness to be gulled, and
was generally so interpreted in the days when we were even
more ignorant than we are now. The topic will be discussed
more fully later.
Baps very generally come in answer to questions. In the
account (see in Chapter X) of Poster's percussive lights, the
original said, in place of the words I first put in brackets:
, When a question was asked, and the answer was no, which
was signified by one rap,'* and, in the other place " the answer
was yes," and the account, as I gave it, was followed by :
''We asked the raps to come as rapidly as possible, which
was done, dozens of them racing one after another, with
scarcely any intermission. Then we asked the raps to come
deliberately, then slow, which was immediately complied with.
Ch. XII]
Baps Respond to Auditof,s WiU
183
That night'B ezperienoe satisfied me forerer that there were
raps produced through an agenqy which h|is not yet been explaint latisf actorily.''
The raps produced in Mr. Armstrong's presence (page 146)
are said in the original account, to have come on his ,'expres ing awish/' and he farther says:
'* I could at will cause these sounds to cease or reappear, one,
two, three, or any number I demanded, and, stranger still, I
could induce a succession of knocks of various degrees of
intensity and so delivered as to 'knock out' with wonderful
accuracy any tune I asked for. I can now recall amongst
many such die airs of ' Not for Joe,' and ' The Blue-bells of
Scotland,' as especially well marked."
Apparently this manifestation of nerve force is sometimes
as involuntary as that in St. Vitus's dance, as illustrated in
the following from the Autobiography of a Journalist, by
W. J. Stillman, the well-known artist and author, who was
for a long time our Consul in Crete (I, 189-90) :
''We heard of a remarkable case in the circle of our own
acquaintance whidh had been kept from public knowledge as
far as possible by the aversion to publicity of the father of
the subject, my brother's chief foreman. She was a girl of
fourteen, of a timid and nervous organization, who had suffered great annoyance by the persistence of the rappings about
her wherever she might be; at first in her bedroom, but finally
to her great dismay in the class-rooms of die primary public
school of New York, in which she held the position of assistant
teacher. . . . The rappings caused such fright amongst the school
children that she was menaced with dismissal if they did not
cease. She implored the agency which was responsible for thesounds to leave her alone at school and do what seemed best
to them at home, and the rappings did actually cease at schooL",
An apparent instance of the well-known reactive effect
of prayer on the organism.
From Sir Wm. Crookes (Pr. VI, 121), after an account
of a s6ance with Home:
"Baps then said: — ,,We must go.' The raps then commenced loudly all over the room and got fainter and fainter
until they became inaudible."
(lb. 122): "Miss Douglas said: — ,'Dear spirits, how
pleiased you would have been had you lived to witness the
progress Spiritualism is now making.' Immediately a message was given in reply: — ,We are not dead!'
184
Molecular Telepsychic Telehinesis
[Bk. II, Pt. I
" I felt touched strongly on the knee by something feeling
like fingers. On putting
my hand down a sheet of paper was
put into it. I said:— 'Is anything written on itf 'Yes,'
It being too dark to see what was written, I asked that it might
be told me by raps, and on repeating the alphabet I got the
following: — ,*Rctojdourdaniel.' On striking a light &e following was seen neatly written.* — ,R, C. to J. D. Our
Daniel.' " [Alluding to Home.] '< Miss Douglas said the K. 0.
was Eobert Ohambers, whilst J. D. were the initials of her
own name."
In these almost incredible performances there were none
of the ', cabinets " and other paraphernalia used by Eusapia
Palladino and many others, and Sir William Grookes expresses great confidence in Home's sincerity, and in the gen*
uineness of the phenomena manifested through him.
Bartlett says {op. dtj 105) :
** 1 remember one evening calling with Foster upon Mrs. S.,
who had recently moved into unfurnished apartments. Mrs. S.
said ...' Please give us some physical manifestations. My
parlor is just the place, heavy blankets being over the windows,
to keep out the glare of the sun. One small wooden table
Foster,
Mr. for
. ' No,' replied
is
to sit in
him describing
it was
time how . unpleasant
same fumiture.'.
the only
at the
the dark. Mrs. S. persisted, 'Do, please, just this once.'
Finally Mr. Foster consented under these conditions: the
table was to be placed under the chandelier, we three should
take hold of hands around the table, matches should be placed
on the table, Mrs. S. agreeing to light the gas the moment Mr.
Foster so requested. We sat in silence a moment, when Mr.
Foster said the spirit of M.," [Ada Isaacs Menken, Mr. Bartall had
we saw
ILH.]said''whom
state.Foster
the
that he
was there.to Mr.
life,permission
in me
knownlett gives
spirit perfectly, and that she said if we would keep quiet she
would dance, and that the noise from the heels of her shoee
on the bare floor would give the tone and the character of the
dance. She did so. It was a success. Within a few moments
Foster said, ' Light the gas.' He was dripping with perspiration, which showed his peculiar nervous condition during
physical manifestations. . . . After a short rest, the medium recuperated, and we turned off the gas the second time. . . . M.
immediately returned and finished the dance. Whenever I
think of that night, I can distinctly hear the clitter-clatter of
the spirit dancer's shoes."
Of course if Foster had good control over raps and tickings, he could, voluntarily or involuntarily, give them the
Ch. XII]
Temperaiures.
Mose, Raps
186
rhythin of a dance. His doing so need not be deliberately
fraudulent: he may have, as he said, visualized a dancer.
Neither is it proved (a negative is hard to prove) that there
was not one.
Mr. Bartlett continues the same account:
" Mr. Foster then said the spirits told him they would cool
the room (it being a hot summer's night). Immediately waves
of wind rushed through the room, so cool that it seemed as
though they came direct from an icebeig.''
As already intimated, wind rushes and cooling of temperatures are frequently noticed in the accounts of these phenomena. They include some which eminent men of science declare
they have felt from a hole in Eusapia Palladino's head. That
seems about the simplest of her phenomena, with the least
chance for the cheating with which she seems to like to eke
out her real powers — ,if she has any — as I have no doubt she
has.
Here is a far different manifestation from Stainton Moses
XPr. IX, 290) :
,The room, which had been filled (especially round me)
with floating clouds of light, grew sudd,Jy dark, and absolute
stillness took the place of the previous loud knockings. It
would have been a strange scene for an ear- witness. The table,
isolated, with no human hand touching it, giving forth a series
of mysterious thuds of varying intensity, some of which might
have been made by a muffled sledge-hammer, all indicating
intelligence; an intelligence that showed itself by deliberation,
or eagerness, or stately solenmity, according to the nature of
the communication. Bound the table three persons sitting
with a hush of expectation, and faces (if they could have been
seen) of awe-stricken earnestness; a question put, and a loud
response, another, and a series, as though by a counsel cross*
examining a dumb witness. The room shrouded in total dark*
ness, except at one end, where shifting masses of luminous
vapor now and again gathered into a pillar which dimly outlined aform, and again dispersed and flitted round the head
of one of the sitters. No scene could be imagined more calculated to strike a novice with awe, none more solemn and
impressive for those who participated in it. The Witch of
Endor was not more surprised when her unholy incantation
evoked the shade of Samuel than I was when Imperator, in
answer to my solemn adjuration, professed himself to be a
departed spirit."
186
Molecuiar Telepsychic Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Ft. I
Here is in detail some of the conversation alluded to
above:
'' Question. Are these communications from spirits t— ,Answer. Yes. Q. Spirits of the departed? — ,A. Yes. Q. Are you
a spirit once incarnated? — ,A. Ye8....Q. Is the account given
of these manifestations by spirits true? — ,A. I don't ,ow.
Q. Is what you tell us true? — ,A. Yes (emphatically)....
Q. Did you write that message the other night?— A. No.
Q. Were you there when it was written? — A. No. Q. You
did not come because Dr. Speer offended you?— A. Yes. (Dr.
S. again apologized, and the apology was received with a series
of stately raps, suggestive of bows.)"
[A pretty strong indication of " the will to believe "I H. H.]
',Q. Then your absence let in an evil or lying spirit? — ,A.
Yes." [Again the medisBval superstition I It was afterward
denied by Moses's " spirit/' see p. 542 (Newbold sitting). H. H.]
''Q. Are we liable to that? — ,A. Yes. Q. Then you do leave
me? — ,A. No. Q. Not usually, you mean? — A. Yes. Q. Then
we must be guarded and cueful to sit with solemnity, and
follow guidance? — ,A. Yes. Q. You are good? — ,A. Yes. Q. I
solemnly charge and adjure you in the name of God that you
tell the truth. Are you a good spirit, once incarnated in the
flesh? — A. Yes. (Three of the loudest knocks I ever heard.
We all involuntarily drew in our breath, and a feeling of awe
stole over us.)"
We are now getting into very high society. This gentleman
Imperator we will return to again. But some other matters
had better be treated first, one of them being Sir William
Grookes's conclusions regarding the significance of raps (fiasearches, p. 95) :
'* Whilst I have observed many circumstances which appear
to show that the will and intdligence of the medium have
much to do with the phenomena, I have observed some circumstances which seem conclusively to point to the agency of
an outside intelligence, not belonging to any human being in
the room
''I have been with Miss Fox when she has been writing a
message automatically to one person present, whilst a message
to anodier person on another subject was being given alphabetically by means of 'raps,' and the whole time she was
conversing freely with a third person on a subject totally
different from either."
As we shall see later, Mrs. Piper wrote as one person, and
at the same time talked as another.
Ck. XII]
Mysterious Sounds and Voices
187
Other Bounds than raps are alleged to have manifested
intelligence. All sounds so manifesting are, like raps, repeated at request, a definite number of times, loud or faint,
and in different places; and by a prearranged code of signals,
give messages, and answer questions with varying accuracy.
Dr. Speer says of the musical sounds described on p; 148
(Pr. IX, 281) :
**
Certain evidences of intelligence having been ap«
parent in the manifestations, we ascertained that the sounds
were in truth evidences of the presence of individuals purporting tohave long since departed from earth-life. The intelligence was manifested first by answers to questions, which
were given in the same manner as the raps on a table, one,
two, three, five, etc. The peculiarity of the answers was that
the tone of the sounds corresponded in a most singular and
convincing manner with the nature of the response. In other
words, the passions of individuals, as exemplified on earth by
tones of speech, were here illustrated by the peculiar type and
tone of the musical sound."
Under Sounds we may as well include the unaccountable
" voices '' of which accounts began to appear in manuscripts
long before there was any printing. The reader will probably not care for more than a single veridical case. Stillman
gives a good one (op. cit, I, 200-1) :
''I saw one day a hunter who had come into the woods
with a motive in some degree like mine — impatience of the
restraints and burdens of civilization, and pure love of solitude.
He had become, not bestialized, like most of the men I saw,
but animalized — ,he had drifted back into the condition of his
dog, with his higher intellect inert. He had built himself a
cabin in the dep, of the woods, and there he lived in the most
complete isolation from human society he could attain
** He seemed to have no desire for companionship, but there
was nothing morose or misanthropic in his love of seclusion.
. . . He had heard of spiritism, and his own experience led
him to acceptance of its reality. In his solitary life, in the
unbroken silence which reigned around him, he heard mysterious voices, and only the year before he had heard one say that
he was wanted at home. He paid no attention to it, thinking
it only an illusion, but, after an interval, it was repeated so
distinctly that he packed his knapsack, took his dog, and went
out with the intention of going home., On the way he met a
messenger sent after him, who told him that his brother had
met with an accident which disabled him from all work, and
begged him to come to his assistance. The voice had come
188
Molecular TeUpsyi,ic TeleUnms
[Bk. II, Pi I
to him at the time of the aocident. As a rule, however, the
voices seemed vagarious and he attached no importance to
them, except as phenomena which interested him slightly."
Stillman also *, heard voices '' in the silence of the woods,
as many imaginative people do, bnt has not stated that any
of them were veridical.
Intelligent Lights
As raps and other sounds have communicated intelligence
from somewhere — ,perhaps merely reflecting it from the medium, so have lights.
Intelligence was manifested by Foster's lights, on pages 150
and 182.
Sir William Crookes says {Researchss, p. 91) :
', I have had questions answered by the flashing of a bright
face...'.
my luminous
of by
times in front
number ofcommunication
desired
light
given
an alphabetic
I havea had
flashes occurring before me in the air, whilst my hand was
moving about amongst them. I have seen a luminous cloud
floating upwards to a picture. Under the strictest test con*
ditions, I have more than once had a solid, self-luminous,
crystalline body placed in my hand by a hand which did not
belong to any person in the room. In the light I have seen a
luminous cloud hover over a heliotrope on a side table, break
a sprig ofl, and carry the sprig to a lady; and on some occasions Ihave seen a similar luminous cloud visibly condense
to the form of a hand and carry small objects about."
Here were intimations of materializations. Such are generally associated with light.
Moses says (Pr. IX, 275-6) :
** Since the commencement of the present year we have had
another kind of light altogether. ... It flashes with great rapidity, and answers questions by the usual code of signals. The
light usually hovers over my head, sometimes coming into the
circle, but more frequently floating in a distant comer of the
room. It is not apparentiy solid, nor does it seem to be surrounded with drapery."
Dr. Speer says (Pr. IX, 297) :
" December 81st, 1872. ... A column of light about seven feet
high was seen to move roimd the room, and about two feet to
the right of the column was a large glowing mass of light . . •
Ch. XII]
The Speers on Moses
189
During the time Imperator was entrancing the medium, and
conversing with us through him, we saw a large bright cross
of light behind the medium's head, rays surrounding it; after
this it culminated into a beautiful line of light of great brilliiancy, reaching several feet high and moving from side to side.
Behind this column of light on the floor was a bright cluster
of lights in oblong shape. These remained for more than half •
an-hour, and upon asking Imperator the meaning of the lights,
he said the pillar of light was himself; the bright light bdbind
him his attendant; and the numerous lights seen in the room
belonged to the band. The light around the medium's head
showed his great spiritual power. He also said in time we might
see him; ndght do so now were our spiritual vision clearer."
And here we are at last landed in the jumble of sounds,
lights, trances, materializations, alleged spiritual communications which, in addition to molar telekinetic phenomena,
rapfi, and Heaven knows what else, for a dozen years or
more, seem to have constituted the daily experience of Stainton Moses and those near to him.
So far I have tried to keep the threads distinct, but they
have now become too complicated.
Moses' phenomena are so well summed up in a letter from
Mr. Charlton Speer that, at the expense of some repetition,
I give it virtually entire (Pr. IX, 344-9) :
"3fy Dear Mr, Myers, — You have asked for some of my
personal recollections of stances with Mr. Stainton Moses, at
which I was present. ... It is important to note that at these
stances no less than ten different kinds of manifestations took
place with more or less frequency. On occasions when we
had fewer varieties we were usually told that the conditions
were not good. When they were favorable the manifestations
were more numerous, the raps more distinct, the lights brighter,
and the musical sounds clearer. The various occurrences may
be briefly enumerated as follows: —
''1. Great variety of raps, often given simultaneously, and
ranging in force from the rapping of a finger-nail to the tread
of a foot sufficiently heavy to shake the room.
** 2. Raps which answered questions coherently and with the
greatest distinctness; also gave messages, sometimes of con*
siderable length, through the medium of the alphabet. At these
times aU the raps ceased except the one identified with the
communicating spirit, and perfect quiet prevailed until the
message was delivered. We could nearly always tell at once
with which spirit we were talking, owing to the perfectly distinct individuality of each different rap.
190
Molecular TeUpsychic Telehinesis
[Bk. 11, Pt. I
',8. Lights were of two different kindB— objectiye and subjective. . . Dr. Speer and myself being of entirely unmediumistic temperaments, we were only able to see the objective
lights, but Mr. Stainton Moses, Mrs. Speer, and other occasional sitters frequently saw aiid described those which were
merely auhjective. Another curious point in relation to the
objective lights was that, however brightly they might shine,
they never — ,unlike an ordinary lamp— threw any radiance
around them or illuminated the smallest portion of the surrounding darkness — ,when it was dark — ,in the slightest degree.
,'4. Scents of various descriptions were always brought to
the circle — ,the most common being musk, verbena, new-mown
hay, and one unfamiliar odor which we were told was called
spirit-scent. Sometimes breezes heavy with perfume swept
round the circle, at other times quantities of liquid musk, &c.,
would be poured on the hands of the sitters and, by request, on
our handkerchiefs. At the dose of a stance scent was often
found to be oozing out of the medium's head, and the more it
was wiped away, the stronger and more plentiful it became.
''6. The musical sounds, which were many and of great
variety. . . . Having myself had a thorough musical education,
I was able to estimate, at its true value, the importance of
these particular manifestations. ... The musical soimds produced in the room in which there was no instrument,...
were about four in number. First, there were what we called
the , faiiy bells.' These resembled the tones produced by striking musical glasses with a small hammer. ...It was difficult
to judge where the sound of these 'fairy bells' came from,
but I often applied my ear to the top of the table, and the
music seemed to be somehow in the wood — ,not underneath
it; as on listening under the table, the music would appear to
be above. Next we had quite a different sound — ,that of a
stringed instrument more nearly akin to a violoncello than
anyt,g else. . . . It . . . might perhaps be produced by placing a
'cello on the top of a dnmi. . . . The third sound was an exact
imitation of an ordinary hand-bell, which would be rung sharply
by way of indicating the presence of the particular spirit with
whom it was associated. We naturally took care to ascertain
that there was no bell of any kind in the room. . . . Lastly, we
had a sound that it is exceedingly difficult to offer an adequate
description of. The best idea of it I can give is to ask you to
imagine tibe soft tone of a clarionet gradually increasing in
intensity until it rivaled the sound of a trumpet, then by degrees diminishing to the original subdued note of the clarionet,
until it eventually died away in a long-drawn-out melancholy
wail. This sound was ascribed to ' Odorif er.'. . . Like the two
previous sounds I have described, it was always associated with
one spirit.
" It is a noteworthy fact that in no case did the controlling
Ch. XII]
Mr. Charltan Speer on Moses
191
agencies produce more than single notes, or at best isolated
passages. This they accounted for as owing to the peculiarly
unmusical organization of the medium. . . . Over and over again
I thoroughly satisfied myself that there were no materials in the
room which could in any way assist in making any kind of
musical tones, and the darionet and trumpet sound was one
that I should be utterly at a loss to imitate in any way.
*'6. Direct writing was often given, sometimes on a sheet
of paper placed in the centre of the table and equidistant from
all the sitters; at other times one of us would place our hands
on a piece of paper previously dated and initialed, and usually
a message was found written upon it at the conclusion of the
stance. We always placed a pencil upon the paper, but sometimes we only provided a small piece of lead, the results being
the same in both cases.
"7. Movements of heavy bodies, such as tables and chairs,
were by no means infrequent. . . . The dining-table ... at which
we usually sat was an extremely weighty one, and was made
from solid Honduras mahogany, but at times it was moved
with much greater ease thim the combined efforts of all the
sitters could accomplish— and these combined efforts were powerless to prevent its moving in a certain direction, if the unseen
force willed it to. do so.
''8. The passage of matter through matter was sometimes
strikingly demonstrated by the bringing from other rooms of
various articles through dosed and bolted doors.
,'9. The direct spirit voice, as opposed to the voice of a
spirit speaking through the medium while in a state of trance,
we very seldom heard, and never with any clearness or distinctness. But occasionally it was attempted, and by listening
carefully we could distinguish one or two broken sentences
which were hissed out in a sort of husky whisper.
',10. The inspirational addresses given by various spirits
. . . though the voice proceeded from the medium it was always
immediately apparent that the personality addressing us was
not that of the medium. The voice was different, and the
ideas were not always in accordance with those held at the
time by the medium. ... Although many spirits exercised this
power of control, the voice which spoke was always different
!— and in the case of those spirits which controlled regularly,
we got to know perfectly well which intelligence was communicating bythe tone of voice and the method of enunciation.
"
Suddenly the medium — ,Mr. Stainton Moses, — ,who
was sitting exactly opposite me, exclaimed, 'There is a very
bright column of light behind you.' Soon afterwards he said
that the column of light had developed into a spirit-form. I
asked him if the face was familiar to him, and he replied in
the negative, at the same time describing the head and features.
When the stance was conduded I examined my sheet of paper.
192
Molecular Telepsychic Telekinesis
[Bk. II, Ft. I
which my hand had never left, and found written on it a message and signature. The name was that of a distinguished
musician. ... I purposely refrain from specifying him, as the
use of great names very frequently leads to results quite different from those intended. ... I asked Mr. Stainton Moses — ,without, of course, showing him the written message — ,whether he
thought he could recogni2e the spirit he saw behind my chair
if he saw a portrait of him. He said he thought he could, so
I gave him several albums containing likenesses of friends, dead
and alive, and also portraits of various celebrities. I remained
in another part of the room, and did not watch him, nor even
knew when he was looking at the right album. On coming to
the photograph of the composer in question, he at once said
without hesitation, , That is the face of the spirit I saw behind
you.' Then for the firet time I showed him the message and
signature.
(Signed)
''Oharlton T. Speeb."
November 5th, 1893.
" Ashley Villa, Ventnor,
"October SOth, 1893.
''I wish to state that I am a daughter of Mrs. Stanhope
Speer, and was present at many of tiie stances recorded in
Light by my mother, and, further, that the facts therein stated
are in my recollection, and are true, and that the phenomena
',Constance Bosaue Spkeb.''
actually took place.
I cannot see that it will do any harm at this late day, to
state thati somewhere that I cannot trace, I have got the
suggestion that the portrait was of Mendelssohn.
There is a circumstance connected with this letter worth
noting. Paragraph 5 regarding the musical sounds is entirely at variance with what Moses himself wrote in his
note-book over nineteen years before, on September 3 and 4,
1874 (Pr. XI, 64) :
*' The musical sounds have reached seven
*' 1. Orocyn. . . . The sounds are very pure, and express feeling
most wonderfully. They are most like a thick harp string.
*,2, Ohom makes the sound of an old Egyptian harp with
four strings. There is little similarity to a stringed sound.
" 3. 8a, makes a noise somewhat similar to Chom's, but the
lyre has only three strings. It is an old Egyptian instrument,
and the sound is like dropping water on a steel plate, a sort
of liquid sound, very intense. I am told it is very like the
sound of a harmonium reed.
',4. Roophal makes a soimd of a seven-stringed lyre, very
pretty rippling sound, but the strings do not seem to me to be
arranged in harmonial progression.
C9i. XII] Mosw' Telehineiic Orchestra
193
** 6. KabhUa makes a sound like a drum, yezy deep, a sort of
prolonged rolL
M 6.
makes a sound like the ringing of fine porcelain,
only that the ring is very much more pronounced. This is a
Tory intense sound.
,'7. The Welsh Harper makes a sound as of the highest
strings of a harp, shaip and ringing.
*'In addition there is a sound of a tambourine and a sort
of flapping sound like large wings. These can scarcely be
called musical in any sense, though they are but exaggerations
of oUiers in some way. The modus operandi is similar.''
These names were spelled out to Moses or his companions,
the notes answering at significant letters when the alphabet
was repeated. And what a lovely lot of names they are I If
Boophal had only been accompanied by Damphool, tiiey would
have been perfect, and what an orchestra to accompany
Imperator and his entourage I
But in face of the claim generally made by ''spirits,', as
will be more particularly indicated later, that they begin
receding from the possibilities of earthly communication immediately after death, and are out of its reach altogether
in a period somewhere stated at about six years, why should
the vast majority of the gentlemen above named proceed
from regions so remote in space and time — back to the very
infancy of music, when Europe has been supplying any
number of potentially musical ghosts during the last century when the art has been at its best?
There is not a single point of resemblance between the
accounts, unless Moses* ''ringing of fine porcelain'' (Why
" fine " ?) has some resemblance to Spear's bells. Dr. Speer
was a musician and Moses was not Did they sound so
amazingly different to the two men ? Did Speer never hear,
or in the nineteen years did he forget, the sounds Moses
reported; or did Moses never hear those Speer reported, or
did they come later in Moses' career, or did Moses imagine
the. whole thing, including his beautiful names? He does
not speak of them as a single experience, but they ''have
reached seven." Yet despite all this mix-up, there seems no
room to doubt — ,there are too many other witnesses — ,that
there were a variety of frequent superusual sounds, with indications ofintelligence behind them. Yet I confess myself
194
Molecular TeUpsyehic Telekinetis
[6k. II, Pt I
more nonpliused about ibe whole Moses matter than about
even Home's fiie performances: the testimony is so mnch
better and fuller regarding the latter.
Begarding the Moses phenomena, the Council of the
S. P. B. expressed itself as follows (Pr. IX, 353) :
, On tbe question whether the improbability of deception is
greater or less than the improbability that the events actually
occurred as recorded, the members of the Oouncil indiTidually
entertain diverse views, and they do not feel called upon to
oxproos any opinion collectively.
''If the human powers we are familiar with can produce
such phenomena as those that took place in the presence of
Moses, the methods certainly open new and important fields
of investigation, even if less new and less important than
would be opened by new powers."
As I hare said more than once, the time for the fraud
hypothesis in any respectably vouched-for phenomena, is
past To my mind the strongest argument in favor of the
honesty of the experiences — ,whether they were objective, or
co-operative hypnotic dreams, is in the portraits of Moses
(after death) and of the three Speers — Doctor, Mrs., and
Mr. Charlton, their son, given in Pr. IX. I was tempted
to reproduce them here for that argument's sake, but they
by themselves would be out of proportion with Ihe rest of
the book. Moses* face, taken after death, gives an impression
of strength and dignity which renders such weaknesses as
fraud absurd. The eyes being closed, impressions of sincerity do not directly enter into the conditions; but if ever
any three portraits meant honesty, those of the Speers do,
and, in the portraits of the elders especially, very much intelligence and everything that goes to make up goodness are
liberally manifested.
Often, as my mind dwells upon it, I come up to the impression that Moses imagined it all, as I think he imagined
the Imperator group and his various musicians (though not
the noises), and then I am brought up standing by the testimony of these good people, and so the only hypotheses open
to my mind regarding Moses, and Home too, are three :
I. That many wise and good people lied, and lied con-
Ch. XII]
Bypofheies regarding Masea
195
currently; and that Dr. and Mrs. Speer encouraged their
aon to lie. This I reject. It is less probable than eren
II. That there were numerous illnaiona — dreams, what yon
please, possibly nnder the influence of hypnotismy so far
identical with from a conple to half a dozen of these people,
and at many times, that whoever seyeral of the people give
accounts of any one experience there is no material difference
except in the nineteen-year-inter?al testimony over phenomena
so uncertain as the quality of musical tones. This hypothesis,
while I consider it more probable than the first, I consider
less probable than
III. That the events actually occurred in the normal experience of the witnesses, though possibly the meaning of
,, normal'' needs some sort of widening of which we have
not yet any clear inkling.
Now all I have said is that those three hypotheses are all
that are open to my mind. Perhaps that is not strictly correct for
: in any doubtful case, no matter how many hypotheses in the usuaJ sense are ** open,'' there is always the chance
that the correct one still lurks hidden behind.
I have said that I think III the most likely one open. That
is not saying that I accept it. Begarding the telekinesis of
P be shown
and thelater,
psychoses
of Foster,
of Mrs.'
will
to a certain
extent and
I knotv,
and Piper
anythingas
farther not inconsistent with what I know, I am inclined
to believe. Begarding Home and Moses and the other
mediums, I directly know nothing, and my readiness to
believe of course depends upon the concurrence of the testimony with that regarding mediums I do know. Begarding
those I have not met, this gives me, so far, basis for little more
than a suspended judgment, always qualified, however, by
the fact that I know so many things not yet correlated with
what everybody knows, and I recognize so fully that the
field of possible knowledge is so immense beside the field
of yet-recognized knowledge, that I am more ready than
most people to accept alleged new phenomena as actually
from the field of possible knowledge.
The intelligence conveyed by the raps, sounds, and lights
which we have so far dealt with — ,by merely telekinetic
means irrespective of impersonation or other utterance, vol-
196
MoUcular TOepsyAic TeleitfMra
[Bk. II, Pt I
nntary or in trance, through the organism of a medium, does
not seem to have amonnted to much with anybody but Stainton Moses, and the answer to the question whether it did
with him will be largely a matter of personal predilection.
He thought it amounted to a great deal.
We shall meet more about it later.
The methodistical inspirations of Professor Barrett's friend,
even the pious expressions through Home, and some through
Moses, do not seem to tend much to edification, at least my
edification ; in fact, almost all that has been receiyed through
raps and lights relates to the mere business of the manifestations, and despite an occasional bit of apparent independence, like the ,' We are not dead ** on page 183, there is yery
littie difiSculty in making it out an echo of the medium —
if one is disposed to.
Whatever the messages (?) through telekinetic phenomena,
they are so much surpassed by those through telepathy and
''possession,', that it seems hardly worth while to linger
over the telekinetic ones.
But before leaving this region of lights and sounds and
phantasmagoric effects, presumably the reader who has so
far followed ''this strange eventful history" may care to
know in a word how, after nU, it impresses me. The raps
and apparently the electric manifestations attending them and
some molar telekinetic phenomena are so closely allied with
plain telekinesis and the probable involuntary agency of the
medium, that I believe in their genuineness. But the rest
impresses me like a dream — as if half a dozen people, more or
less, had occasionally dreamed the same things. This impression may hardly seem worth putting down again, with the
conspicuousness of a chapter ending, as a final impression;
but perhaps as we go on, it may prove to be.
BOOK
II— PART
U
AUTOKINESIS
OHAPTEB
Xm
Thb manifestatioiis we haye already seen of the modes of
force grouped; perhaps too freely, under the name Telekinesis,
haye all been from the human body upon objects external
to it. Not only the molar movement, but the mysterions
changes of temperature, the sounds, lights, alleged materializations, the alleged passing of matter through matter, have
taken place only when a ', medium ', was present, and apparently in consequence of an energy manifested through him.
We now approach a series of new phenomena even less cor*
related with established knowledge, which are alleged to take
place in the body itself.
As usual, we approach the group through a phenomenon
that might almost equally well be included in the group
we are leaving. I refer to the alleged levitation of the
human body by a force which apparently is generated in the
body itself. I at first grouped this phenomenon with those of
molar telekinesis, but as the object acted upon is not external
to the body, I finally decided to place it with the new group,
along with the resistance of the body to heat, and the production of stigmata and blisters under the influence of suggestion. The healing power of suggestion might probably be
justly included also.
The evidence for some of the alleged resistance to heat, and
for the stigmata and blisters seems conclusive ; that for levitation is not as strong, but certainly is too strong to be
ignored.
This new group has not yet, 197
so far as I know, been even pro-
198
AvioMnens
[Bk. U, Ft. n
Tided with a name, in fact I don't know that the phenomena
have yet been grouped at all, and do not feel sure that I am
warranted in grouping them. Of course I do so tentatively.
For that matter all classification is tentative, and with the
process of knowledge is pretty sure to be upset, and names
to go with it.
As we must have a Qreek name to command any respect,
perhaps autokinesis will serve for the moment, and last at least
as long as the book will. But I sometimes wish we could string
out names from our own roots, as do the good Germans, even if
we seemed to model them as they appear to, on their dachshunds.
Levitation
When I first read of levitation, in Home's case, I was
tempted to give up farther attention to him and all his ways :
it was too much like a man lifting himself by his bootstraps.
A bird rises as a man walks, by transmuting molecular force
into mechanical force moving a mechanical apparatus against
a resisting medium. The same is true of perhaps all use
made by men of known molecular forces except magnetism,
and even the magnet could not lift itself without the aid of
a *' keeper " placed above it. But there does not seem to be
any theoretical impossibility of the generation, perhaps from
gravity itself, of a force counter to gravity, somewhat as
negative magnetism is counter to positive. And this sentence
is hardly written before along comes Mr. Farrows' alleged
discovery that (so far as I can understand it, from the only
account I have been able to see), he can directly concentrate
the Hertzian waves upon a body with the result of counteract*
ing the effect of gravitation. If then, the waves of zoomagnetism are convertible into Hertzian waves, " there you are 1 "
I want to caution the reader who may be skeptical regarding any one class of these phenomena, against applying here,
on the very far borderland of knowledge, the doctrine " falstis
in tmo falsus in omnibus** with the same confidence that
he would apply it in familiar fields. People who get in the
way of seeing and recording strange things are very apt,
without any bad intentions, gradually to get into the way
of seeing and recording too many. Their doing so, however,
Ch. XIII]
Levitation, Mosea
199
does not invalidate the genuine ones they gather in with
the rest; but it does throw upon the reader the difficxdt task
of discriminating, and in many situations, of keeping his
mind shut and at the same time quite ready to open.
But the evidence for levitation is at least worth reading,
especially as it does not all relate to but one person. Yet
there are probably not over half a dozen of whom it has been
aUeged in modem times. I can find space for only our old
friends.
Stainton Moses says (Pr. IX, 260) :
',My first personal experience of levitation was about five
months after my introduction to Spiritualism. Physical phenomena of a very powerful description had been developed
with gxeat rapidity. . . . One day (August dOth, 1872) ... I felt
my chair drawn back from the table and turned into the comer
near which I sat. It was so placed that my face was turned
away from the circle to the angle made by the two walls. In
this position the chair was raised from the floor to a distance
of, I should judge, twelve or fourteen inches. My feet touched
the top of the skirting-board, which would be about twelve
inches in height. The chair remained suspended for a few
moments."
So far this is only the ordinary levitation of furniture-,
the chair, which could have been done by ordinary telekinesis,
with Moses on top of it; but he continues:
''And I then felt myself going frcHn it, higher and higher,
with a very slow and easy movement....! remember a slight
difficulty in breathing, and a sensation of fullness in the cheat,
with a general feeling of being lighter than the atmosphere.
I was lowered down quite gently, and placed in the chair, which
had settled in it$ old poeitian
''This experiment was more or less successfully repeated
on nine other occasions. On the 2d September, 1872, I see
from my records that I was three times raised on to the table,
and twice levitated in the comer of the room. The first movement on to the table was very sudden — a sort of instantaneous
jerk. I was conscious of noUiing until I found myself on the
table — my chair being unmoved. .,. In the second attempt I
was placed on the table in a standing posture. In this case I
was conscious of the withdrawal of my chair and of being raised
to the level of the table, and then of being impelled forward so
as to stand upon it. ... In the third case I was thrown on to the
table, and from that position (m to an adjacent sofa. The move-
200
AvtohineHa
[Bk. H, Pi U
ment was instantaneous, aa in the first recorded case; and
though I was thrown to a considerable distance and with considerable force, I was in no way hurt
''These phenomena of levitation hare presented themselyes
on a few other occasions. ... I have discouraged them as
much as x)ossible, from a dislike to violent physical manifestations. Ihave little power to prevent a special kind of manifestation, and none whatever to evoke any that I may desire;
but I do, as far as I can, prevent the very uncomfortable
phenomena which at this period were so strongly developed.''
On December Srd, Dr. and Mrs. Speer both sign a note
(Pr. IX, 289) :
,Mr. M. was moved about and floated twice."
We can conceive a force in the body counteracting gravita«
tion, but it is not so easy to see how a force impelling the
body — ,as the rush of heat drives the rocket, should pervade
the chair or table too. Assuming the phenomena to be genuine, is it the same force impelling both, or is there one
force raising the body and another making the chair or table
stick to it ? In the fog of our present knowledge, all guesses
appear absurd.
Sir William Crookes says (op. cit, p. 89) :
** This
levitation
of human
beings The
has occurred
in my under
presence on four
occasions
in darkness.
test conditions
which they took place were quite satisfactory, so far as die
judgment was concerned; but ocular demonstration of such
a fact is so necessary to disturb our pre-formed opinions as
to
' the naturally
possibletheand
impossible,'
that I were
will confirmed
here only
mention
cases in which
deductions
of reason
by the sense of sight.
'' On one occasion I witnessed a chair, with a lady sitting
on it, rise several inches from the ground. On another occasion, to avoid the suspicion of this being in some way x>erformed
by heredif , ihe lady knelt on the chair in such a manner that
its four feet were visible to us. It then rose about three inches,
remained suspended for about ten seconds, and then slowly
descended. At anoti,er time two children, on separate occasions,
rose from the floor with their chairs, in full daylight, imder
(to me) most satisfactory conditions: for I was kneeling and
keeping close watch upon the feet of the chair, and observing
that no one might touch them."
Sir William does not tell us who were the agents in these
Gh. XIII]
LevHaium, Home
201
cases. If fhe persons themselves were not, the cases, like the
beginning of Moses, case on page 101, were hardly levitations
of human beings at all, in the nsual sense, but merely of
chairs on which human beings were sitting. But there is a
staggering number of vastly more improbable cases where
persons are alleged to have levitated themselves. Sir William
continues :
,'The most striking cases of levitation which I have witnessed hare been with Mr. Home. On three separate occasions
have I seen him raised completely from the floor of ike room.
Once sitting in an easy-chair, once kneeling on his chair/'
{These two cases are like the preceding two— levitations of
umiture. H. H.] " and once standing up. On eadi occasion
I had full opportunity of watching the occurrence as it was
taking place.
,' There are at least a hundred recorded instances of Mr.
Home's rising from the ground, in the presence of as many
separate persons, and I have heard from the lips of the three
witnesses to the most striking occurrence of this kind — ,the
Earl of Dunraven, Lord Lindsay, and Captain 0. Wynne—
their own most minute accounts of what took place. To reject
the recorded evidence on this subject is to reject all human
testimony whatever; for no fact in sacred or profane history
is supported by a stronger array of proofs."
In Pr. YI, 126, Sir William says of Home:
" He asked Mrs. Wm. Orookes to remove the chair from under
him, as it was not supporting him. He was then seen to be
flitting in the air, supported by nothing visible.
(P. 119) " Mr. Home dien wall, to the open space in the room
between Mrs. L's chair and the sideboard and stood there quite
upright and quiet He then said: 'I'm rising, I'm rising,'
when we all saw him rise from the ground slowly to a height
of about six inches, remain there for about ten seconds, and
then slowly descend. From my position I could not see his
feet, but I distinctly saw his head, projected against the oppo*
site wall, rise up, and Mr. Wm. Crookes, who was sitting near
where Mj. Home was, said that his feet were in the air. There
was no stool or other thing near which could have aided him.
Moreover, the movement was a smooth, continuous glide upwards. "
Sir William Crookes* notes (in Pr. VI) also give other
illustrations of levitation, both of the human body and inanimate objects. There is also the oft-quoted accotrnt of
Home's being floated out-of-doors through one window and
Atdohineaii
[Bk. II, Ft n
back through another. Variotis hypotheses, none of them
satisfactory, have been proposed to account for these phenomena on the theory of deception.
Here is a case regarding Foster which was reported before
the storm of modern criticism. It is from Ashburner, quoted
by Bartlett (op. cit, p. 110) ;
" In my duaker-Eammer, a room the Baron von Beichenbach
had taught me how to darken properly for experiments....
Suddenly a great alarm seised Mr. Foster; he grasped my, right
hand, and beseeched me not to quit my hold of him, for he
said there was no knowledge where the spirits might conrey
him. I held his hand, and he was floated in the air towardis
the ceiling. At one time, Mrs. W« 0. felt a substance on her
head, and, putting up her hands, discoyered a pair of boota
above her head.,
Resistance to Heat
The following cases seem to illustrate a mode of force
counteracting the effects of heat They would probably not
seem worth quoting, to a reader in whose belief telekinesis was
not firmly established. But that being granted, this form of
autokinesis no longer seems impossible, though don't ask me
if I believe in it: for I should answer: I don't know.
Several travelers give mutually confirmatory accounts of the
Fire-walk in Japan and Fiji.
Mrs. Joseph Lindon Smith (wife of the well-known Boston
artist, and daughter of the well-known New York publisher
Mr. George Haven Putnam) gives me permission to state that
she successfully went through it in Japan. How to account
for what my friend tells me, I don't know. The late Andrew
Lang had an interesting paper on the subject in Pr. XV, 2-15
from which the following extracts are made:
, Science is acquainted with no substance — alum or diluted
sulphuric acid, or the like — ,which will produce the result of
preventing cauterization." [This is contradicted below by Mr.
Lang himself, at least as concerns sensation. H. H.] ,'Sir
William Crookes, at least, is not familiar with any sudb
resources of science. His evidence as to fire-handling by D.
D. Home is familiar, and I understand that Mr. Podmore can
only explain it away by a hypothesis of a trick played in a
bad lights by means of an asbestos glove or some such trana-
Ch. Xin]
RBiistance to Heat.
Fire,Walking in Fiji
303
parent dodge (Studies in Peyehicdl Beseareh, pp. 68-59). Perhaps he adds a little ' hallucination ' on tiie part of the
spectators. But asbestos and hallucination are out of the
question in the cases which I am about to quote. Home was,
or feigned to be, iix a state of trance when he performed with
fire. The seeress of Lourdes, Bemadette, was also in religious
contemplation when she permitted the flame of a candle to
play tlurough her clasped fingers (which were unscathed) for
a timed quarter of an hour. Some Indian derotees, again, aver
that they 'meditate' on some divine being while passing over
the glowing embers, and the Nistinares of Bulgaria, who dance
in the fire, are described as being in a more or less abnormal
mental condition. But CTen this condition is absent in the
well-attested Raiatean and Fijian examples,'' [Not to speak
of Mrs. Smith, as above. H. H.1 'Mn which, also, no kind of
chemical preparation is employed. Finally, where savages are
concerned, the hardness of the skins of their feet is dwelt
upon. But, first, the sole of a boot would be scorched in the
circumstances, while their feet are not affected; next, the
savages' feet were not leathery .(so Dr. Hocken avers) ; thirdly,
one of the Europeans who waUced through the fire at Rarotonga
declares that the soles of his own feet are peculiarly tender.
Thus every known physical or conjectured psychical condition
of immunity fails to meet the case, and we are left wholly
without an ascertained, or a good conjectural, 'reason why'
."
for the phenomena.
Mr. Lang cites j(Pr. XV, 4) :
Te Utnu-ti, or Ffre-Walking Ceremony
(From the Journal of the Polynesian Society)
''In this
11, p. 105,
Miss Teuira
Henry
describes
this Journal,
ceremony Vol.
as practised
in Baiatea,
of the Society
Group. We have lately received from Colonel Gudgeon the
following account of his experiences. . . . Since the date of
the paper quoted, it has come to light that the Maoris of
New Zealand w,re equally acquainted with this ceremony,
which was performed by their ancestors. On reading Colonel
Gudgeon's account to some old chiefs of the Urewera tribe,
they expressed no surprise, and said that their ancestors could
also perform the ceremony, though it has long gone out of
practice. — Editors."
Colonel Gudgeon says:
''The tohunga (priest) and his tauira (pupil) walked each
to the oven, and then halting, the prophet spoke a few words*
and then struck the edge of the oven with the ti" [A native
Draetsna. H. H.] " branches. This was three times repeatedi
204
AidokineM
[Bk. U, Pi n
and then they walked slowly and deliberately over the two
fathoms of hot stones. When this was done, the tohunga came
to US) and his disciple handed his H branch to Mr. Goodwin, at
whose place the ceremony came off, and they went through the
ceremony. Then the iohunga said to Mr. Goodwin, ,I hand
my mana (power) oTor to you; lead your friends across. Now,
there were four Europeans — Dr. W. Craig, Dr. George Craig,
Mr. Goodwin, and myself — and I can only say that we stepped
out boldly. I got across unscathed, and only one of the party
was badly burned; and he, it is said, was spoken to, but, like
Lot's wife, looked behind him — ,a thing against all rules....
A man must have mana to do it; if he has not, it will be
too late when he is on the hot stone. ... Quite half-an-hour
afterwards someone remarked to the priest that the stones
would not be hot enough to cook the it. His only answer was
to throw his green branch on the oven, and in a quarter of
a minute it was blazing. As I have eaten a fair share of the
ti cooked in the oven, I am in a position to say that it was
hot enough to coc, it well
''I did not walk quickly across the oven, but witii deliberation, because I feared that I should tread on a sharp point of
the stones and fall. • . . All I really felt when the task was
accomplished was a tingling sensation not unlike slight electric shocks on the soles of my feet, and this continued for
seven hours or more. The reaUy funny thing is that, though
the stones were hot enough an hour afterwards to bum up
green branches of the ti, the very tender skin of my feet
was not even hardened by the fire." •
Mr. Lang comments (Pr. XY, 6) :
''On this report a few remarks may be offered. (1) No
preparation of any chemical, herbal, or other sort was applied
to the Europeans, at least (2) * The handing over the mana '
(or power) was practised by Home, sometimes successfully (it
is aUeged), as when Mr. S. C. Hall's scalp and white locks
were unharmed by a red-hot coal; sometimes unsuccessfully.
A clergyman of my acquaintance still bears the blister caused
when he accepted a red-hot coal from the hand of Home, as he
informs me by letter. (8) The ' walk ' was shorter than seems
common : only twelve feet, four paces. (4) A friend of Colonel
Gudgeon's was badly burnt, and the reason assigned was a
good folk-lore reason, since the days of Lot's wife, of Theocritus, and of Virgil: he looked behind. (6) The feeling as
if of ' slight electric shocks ' is worthy of notice. (6) Colonel
Gudgeon clearly believes that a man without mana had better
not try, and by mana, here, he probably means ' nerve,' as we
can hardly suppose, in spite of Home, that mana, in a supernormal sense, can be 'handed over' by one man to another."
Ch. XIII]
Fire-Walhing in Fiji
805
From an account of the Fiji Fire Ceremony. By Dr. T. M.
Hocken, F.L.S. (Pr. XV, 6) :
',A number of almost nude Fijians walk quickly and unharmed acT088...the payement of a huge native oventermed 'lovo' — ,in which shortly afterwards are cooked the
succulent, sugary roots and pith of the Cardyline temUnalis,
one of the cabbage trees, known to the Maoris as the ' ti/ and to
the Fijians as the 'maaawe/ This wonderful power of fiiewalking is now not only vezy rarely exercised, but, at least
as regards Fiji, is coined to a small clan or family....
They steadily descended the oven slope in single file, and
walked, as I think, leisurely, but as others of our party think,
quickly, across and around the stones, leaving the oven at the
point of entrance. The leader, who was longest in the oven,
was a second or two under half a minute therein. . . J gained
permission to examine one or two of the fire-walkers prior to
their descent into the oven. ...The pulse was unaffected, and
tibe skin, legs, and feet were free from sany apparent application. Iassured myself of this by touch, smell, and
taste, not hesitating to apply my tongue as a corroborative.
The foot-soles were comparatively soft and flexible — by no
means leathery and insensible. ... This careful examination
was repeated immediately after egress from the oven, and
with the same result.. ..No incantations or other religious
ceremonial were observed. Though these were fonnerly practised, they have gradually fallen into disuse since the introduction ofOhristianity.
,, I am absolutely certain as to the truth of the facts and
the bona fides of the actors. A feature is that, wherever this
power is found, it is possessed by but a limited few. I was
assured, too, that any person holding the hand of one of the fireWEdkers could himself pass through the oven unharmed
" Dr. Sementini of Naples found that frequent friction with
sulphurous acid rendered him insensible to red-hot iron; a
solution of alum did the same. A layer of powdered sugar
covered with soap made his tongue insensible to heat. In these
and similar instances, however, an explanation, though probably
not a very sufScient one, has been given, but in that forming
the subject of this paper no solution has been offered
, My next case occurs among a civilized race, the Japanese,
and is vouched for by Mr. Lalcadio Heam . . . and by Colonel
Andrew Haggard {The Field, May 20th, 1899, p. 7M). Colonel
Haggard saw the fire-walk done in Tokio, on April 9th, 1899. . . .
Ablutions in cold water were made by the performers, and
Colonel Haggard was told by one young lady tiiBt she had not
only done the fire-walk, but had been * able to sit for a long time,
in winter, immersed in ice-cold water, without feeling the cold
m the least'
£06
Autokinesis
[Bk. II, Ft, n
''In a prirate letter. Dr. Schiaehmanof hints at exUue
religieuse, as in the self-mutilationa of Derrishes and Fakirs.
Their peif ormances are extraordinary enough, hut there was no
religious ecstasy in the little Japanese boy of six, whom Colonel
Haggard saw pass through the fire, none in Colonel Gudgeon,
none Smith.
in the Fijians
Mrs.
H. H.] obeyed by Dr. Hocken.*' [And none in
Many other instances, ancient and modem, with reflections
upon them, are given by Mr. Lang. He idso discusses the
subject in his book on Modem Mythology.
I quote from Sir William Crookes (Pr. VI, 103f.). Note
date, Wednesday, March 9, 1871 :
** Mr. Home sank back in his chair wiA his eyes dosed and
remained still for a few minutes. He then rose up in a trance
and made signs for his eyes to be blindfolded. This was done.
He walked about the room in an undecided sort of manner,
came up to each of the sitters and made some remark to them.
He went to the candle on a side table (dose to the laige
table) and passed his fingers backwards and forwards throu,
the flame several times so dowly that they must have b,n
seyerely burnt under ordinary circumstances. He then hdd
bis fingers up, smiled and nodded as if pleased, took up a
fine cambric handkerchief bdonging to Miss Douglas, folded
it up on his right hand and went to the fire. Here he threw
off the bandage from his eyes and by means of the tongs lifted
a piece of red hot charcoal from the center and deposited it
on the folded cambric; bringing it across the room, he told
us to put out the cand7 to photograph
him in his exalted position* The plate showed no fakir and
no rope. The story was repeated in the press throughont
the civilized world, but on investigation, there proved to be
no more story than there was rope or iaidr on the sensitized
plate, or than there was sensitized plate. Before the investigation, however, the story was credited to collective hypnotism.
Elongation
Before closing this department of the subject, perhaps I
ought at least to allude to the alleged elongations of the bodies
of Home and Morse and Heme. I allude to them because, to
my mind, they tend to cast discredit on the other stories of
Home, and, by implication, on all the rest of the marvels
chronicled by the S. P. B. Therefore, in what professes to
be a general sketch of all those alleged phenomena, it would
not be fair to suppress the elongations. If I must hold an
opinion, it would incline to ascribe them to hallucination on
the part of the witnesses, as it does regarding Home's performances with hot coals, though I should not be surprised if
the world were yet to come into possession of a mode of
zoomagnetism resisting heat, if it has not one already illus*
trated in the Fire-walk.
With my impression regarding these alleged elongations, I
do not feel that my duty calls for more space than a reference
to the testimony from several witnesses, which is in Journal
S. P. B., IV, 123-6; X, 104f.
Stigmata and Blisters
Now by the way of this resistance to what usually affects
the
body, the
we come
another
direction
the them
body'swith
energies.
Whether
futureto will
associate
eitherof of
what
we now call telekinesis or autokinesis is of course doubtful.
But as I get the eels out of the pot, I keep those nearest
alike as well together as I can. If you don't see the point
of the metaphor, try to write a little on these subjects yourself.
From the bleeding spots on hands and feet symbolizing the
wounds made by the nails of the cross, asserted to have been
found on St. Francis of Assisi and other religious enthusiasts,
Ch. XIII]
Mentally Induced Stigmata and Blisters
211
kindred phenomena mn all the way down through the miracles
of Lonrdes, to sundry well attested recent phenomena, and
branch ofF into hypnotic therapeutics, and Faith Cnre and
Christian Science.
The scientific world paid little attention to these stories
before the case of Louise Lateau, of Belgium, who in 1868 began to exude blood from side, hands, feet, and forehead, every
Friday. There was an element of religious ecstasy in the
case. It is as well vouched for as most other phenomena
prominent in medical history. Myers gives the particulars
in Human Personality, 1, 492. There, and also in the Journal
(not Proceedings) S. P. B., Ill, 100 (where, as well as in
the Proceedings, many of his chapters first appeared) he
gives a dozen well authenticated cases somewhat resembling
the Lateau case, variously due to ordinary hypnotic suggestion, religious ecstasy, and other forms of self-hypnotism or
auto-suggestion.
Before going into them, however, let us anticipate Foster's
eadiibition in Chapter XVIII. He is there said to have shown
some names ''in letters formed of the living blood at that
moment coursing through the hand.''
It looks as if the phenomenon should be dassed with
Stigmata. But the following staggering statements from
Bartlett (op. cit, p. 23) look as if it was not even voluntary.
''It was in the early days of my acquaintance with lb.
Foster that a friend of mine, by the name of Adams, from
EvansviUe, Ind., called upon me. As he was leavin,r, Mr.
Foster told him that in all his experience he had never known
one individual to bring so many spirits; that he should suppose
the whole Adams family had appeared to him, the room being
literally packed with them, coming and going. About two
o'clock the next morning, Mr. Foster called to me (I was sleeping in the same room), saying: 'George, will you please light
the gasf I cannot sleep. The room is still filled with the
Adams family, and they seem to be writing their names all
over me.' And to my astonishment, a list of names of the
Adams family were displayed upon his body. I counted eleven
distinct names: one was written across his forehead, others on
his arms, and several on his back. It seemed to me then, and
stiU seems to me, as being almost miraculous. I can simply
term it unexplained, genuine phenomena, where trickery was
impossible."
21!,
Autolcines%8
[Bk. II, Ft II
Whether or not it was stigmata — a real phenomenon of the
strange involuntary self which also saw his visions, or whether
it was a trick to make more interesting the exhibition of his
real powers, why should he have played such a trick on
Bartlett?
You can produce the eflEects yourself by writing on your
skin with a blunt instrument (Fve seen it done with a
match) and then rubbing the spot. Whether Foster did it
that way, I doubt: for if so, sometimes he must have done
it through his coat sleeve, which I cannot; and at times the
writing showed gradually while the sitter looked at the
apparently undisturbed skin. Mr. Bartlett says:
<< As soon as Mr. Foster and I read that explanation, we tried
the experiment, but it was a failnre. . . . If the number of
names which appeared on his arm and hand in one week
had been caused by scratching matches on his flesh, I think
he would have been badly mutilated. I know of no explanation
of this ' blood-red writing on the arm.' ''
Myers considers the general subject in Fr. YII, 336-9,
whence I take the following:
,'Frofessor Beaunis and Dr. ErafiFt-Ebing have slowed the
pulse by hypnotic suggestion; and these savants, as well as
Professor Bernheim, M. Focachon, and others, have produced
redness and blisters by the same means. Drs. Mabille, Bamadier, Bourru, Burot, have produced localized hyperemia, epis*
taxis'' [nosebleed], ', ecchymosis " [a spot produced by extra vasated blood under the skin]. ''Dr. Forel and others have
restored arrested secretions at a precisely fixed hour. Dr.
ErafPt-Ebing has produced a rise of temperature at moments
fixed by himself, — ,a rise, for instance, from 87 deg. to 38.5
deg. C. Burot has lowered the temperature of a hand as much
as 10 deg. 0. by suggestion. He supposes that the mechanism
employed is the constriction of the brachial artery, beneath
the biceps. ' How can it be,' he asks, ' that when one merely
says to the subject, "your hand will become cold," the vasomotor nervous system answers by constricting the artery to
the degree necessary to achieve the result desired? C'eai ce
qui depasse notre imagination/'*
The following is an abstract of Dr. Levillain's account of
an experiment performed by Frofessor Charcot before a large
class at the SalpStri,re :
** On April 26th, 1890, a hysterical woman was deeply hypno-
Ch. XIII]
Mentally Induced Stigmata and Blisters
218
tized, and it was suggested to her that her right hand and
wrist would swell and become cyanosed. After she was woke
S8tc], this suggestion gradually realized itself, and in four
ays the right hand was in the condition of that of the
patients who had had spontaneous attacks. There was a
smooth surface, hardly any pitting on pressure, but much dullblue mottled swelling (which had obliged her to discontinue
wearing her rmgs), and anaasthesia. A bright red patch was
produced by touch.... M. Charcot re-hypnotized the patient,
and assured her that her hand was quite natural again, helping
his suggestion with a little massage. After a quarter of an hour
tiie anieethesia, venous color, and swelling were gone.
,'The subliminal consciousness" [We will consider this ez*
pression later. H. H.], ''it will be seen, was able to turn out
to order the most complicated novelty in the way of hysterical
freaks of circulation. Let us turn to an equally marked disturbance of the inflammatory type, the production, namely, of
suppurating blisters by the word of command. This phenomenon has a peculiar interest, since, from the accident of a
strong emotional association with the idea of stigmata on hands
and feet, this special organic effect has been anticipated by
the introverted broodings of a line of mystics, from S. Francis
of Assisi to Louise Lateau. A strange confirmation of ancient
l,,d! A singular testimony to the intensilgr of the meditations of that great saint who
Nel crude sasso intra Tevere ed amo
Da Cristo prese 1' ultimo sigillo,
Che le sue membra due anni portamo."
''The following experiment was performed by Dr. J. Bybalkin, in presence of his colleagues at the H6pital Marie, at
St. Petersburg. Dr. Eybalkin had previously experimented in
the same way with his subject.
"The subject ... was hypnotized at 8.30 a. m., and told:
'When you awake, you will be cold; you will go and warm
yourself at the stove, and you will bum your forearm on
the line which I have traced out. This will hurt you; a
redness will appear on your arm; it will swell; there will be
blisters.' On being awskened, the patient obeyed the suggestion. He even uttered a cry of pain at the moment when he
toudbed the door of the stove, — ,which had not been lighted.
" Some minutes later, a redness, without swelling, could be
seen at the place indicated, and the patient complained of
sharp pain on its being touched* A bandage was put on his
arm, and he went to bed, under our eyes.
" At the close of our visit, at 11.80, we observed a considerable swelHng, accompanied with redness and with a papulous
erythema at the place of the bum.
A mere touch anywhere
214
Antohinerii
[Bk. n, Pt U
within four centimeteis of the bum cauoed sovexe pain. The
surgeon. Dr. Pratine, placed a bandage on the forearm, which
extended up to the superior third of tibe arm.
''When the dressing was remoTed at 10 next morning we
saw at the place of the bum two blisters, one of the sixe of
a nut and the other of a pea, and a number of small blisters.
Around this tract the skin was red and senaitiye. Before the
eiqperiment this region had been annsthetic At 3 p. m. the
blisters met in one large blister. ... In the evening the blister,
which was full of a semi-transparent yellowish fluid, burst,
and a scab formed on the raw skin. A week later ordinary
sensibility returned to the scar, and after a fortnight there
was only a red mark in the place of the bum.''
Here is a case more suggestive in many wajs than those
already giyen> from Myers (op. cit., I, 493) :
''A girl of about eighteen, who complained to me one day
of a pain through her chest ... I magnetized ... as usual, and
told ... in a whisper :
'''Yon will have a red cross appear on the upper part of
your chest, only on every Friday, fn liie course g£ some time
the words Saficta above tibe cross, and Cruets underneath it will
appear also; at same time a little blood will come from the
cross.' In my vest pocket I had a cross of rock crystal. I
opened the top button of her dress and placed this cross on
the upper part of the manubrium, a point she could not see
unless by aid of a looking-glass, saying to her, ' This is the spot
where the cross will appear.' This was on a Tuesday...*
Next day Mrs. G. told me she had seen the girl now and again
put her left wrist over the top part of her chest, over the dress;
this was frequently repeated, as if she felt some tickling or
slight irritation about the part, but not otherwise noticed; she
seemed to carry her hand up now and then unconsciously.
When Friday came I said, after breakfast, 'Come, let me
magnetize you a little; you have not had a dose for several
days.' She was always willing to be magnetized, as she idways
expressed herself as feeling very much rested and comfortable
afterwards. In a few minutes she was in a de, sle,. I unbuttoned the top, part of her dress, and there, to my complete
and utter astonishment, was a pink cross, exactly over the
place where I had put the one d! crystal. It appeared every
Friday, and was invisible on all other days. This was seen by
Mr. and Mrs. O., and my old friend and colleague, Dr. B.
. • . About six weeks after the cross first appeared I had occa*
sion to take a trip to the Sandwich Islands. Before going
I magnetized the girl, told her that the cross would keep on
showing itself eveiy Friday for about four months. ... I also
asked Dr. B. and Mr. 0. to write me by every mail to Hono-
Ch. XIII]
Faith Cure.
Chrisiian Science
215
lulu, and tell me if the cross kept on appearing every Friday. . • •
While I was on the Sandwich Islands I reoeiTod two letters
from Mr. O. and one from Dr. B. by three different mails, each
telling that the cross kept on making its appearance as usual;
blood had been noticed once, and also part of the letter S abore
the cross, nothing more. I returned in a little less than three
months. The cross still made its appearance every Friday, and
did so for about a month more, but getting paler and paler until
it became invisible, as nearly as possible four months from the
time I left for the Sandwich Islands
''H. H. Biggs, K D.''
To this account Edmund Gumey adds in a note quoted
by Myers (op. cit, I, 493) :
, As to the first two of these cases [the one quoted above and
another], it is possible to suppose that the hypnotic suggestion
took effect indirectly, by causing the girls to rub a patch of the
right shape. The suggestion may have been received as a
command, and thei% would be nothing very surprising in a
anbject's automatically adopting the right means to fulfil a
previous hypnotic command. And even the third case might
be so accounted for, if the rubbing took place in sleep. At the
same time, it would be rash, I think, absolutely to reject the
l,TPothesis of the more direct effect''
In the sources I have quoted there are hosts of cases as
remarkable as those I have given.
Faith Cure, Christian Science
It would be superfluous to say much about these here : for
abundant literature is accessible. The votaries have got hold
of a truth; though many of them have got it by the taiL The
facts have been obscured by the fancies. Tet through religious
associations, some phases of truth can be got by many people
who otherwise, outside of commonplaces, could not get any
phases at all. This is true even of niordity. Many a mind
incapable of grasping the sanctions of Natural Law, not to
speak of subordinating inclinations for the sake of conformity
witii it, will perf onn no end of feats,— objective and subjective, and make no end of sacrifices, in conformity with a anpposed command from even a mythical law-giver.
My allotment of space for the subject is not small becanse I
consider its importance small, but, as already intimated, because of the abnndant discussion within everybody's readu
BOOK
II— PART
m
PSYCHOKINESIS
CHAtTEB
XIV
A RiiTHEB small allotment of space for a ** Part " is made
here in the interest of classification. Perhaps the future may
furnish more material for this division. Now assuming
Telekinesis to be established, perhaps we are as nearly ready
to consider what I shall call Psychokinesis as people were a
generation ago to consider Telekinesis. To introduce it here
is to anticipate the phenomena of mediumship, but, as I often
have occasion to remark, all these phenomena are so tangled
up that, in the present state of our knowledge, cross classification isoften inevitable.
We need a name, and I hope the one I suggest will do, for
a mode of force of which we shall meet many indications hereafter, and which Hodgson describes as follows. Although it
is incidentally implied eveiTwhere in the literature of mediumship, the passage I quote is the only direct allusion to it which
I know (Pr. XIII, 400) :
" The statements of the ' communicators ' as to what occurs on
the physical side may be put in brief general terms as follows.
We all have bodies composed of ' luminiferous ether ' inclosed in
our flesh and blood bodies. The relation of Mrs. Piper's etherial
body to the etherial world, in which the , communicators ' daim
to dwell, is such that a special store of peculiar energy is accumulated in connection with her organism, and this appears to them
as ' a light. ' . . . Several * communicators ' may be in contact with
this light at the same time. There are two chief * masses ' of it in
her case, one in connection with the head, the other in connection
with the right arm and hand. Latterly, that in connection with
the hand has been ' brighter * than that in connection with the
head. If the ' communicator ' gets into contact with the , light '
and thinks his thoughts, th, tend to be reproduced by movements in Mrs. Pipers organism. Very few can produce vocal
816
Ch. XIY]
Mediums Seem to Use a Mode of Force
217
effects, even when in contact with the * light ' of the head, but
practically all can produce writing movements when in contact
with the * light ' of the hand., Upon the amount and brightness
of this 'light/ cateris paribus, the communications depend.
When Mrs. Piper is in ill-health, the * light ' is feebler, and the
communications tend to be less coherent. It also gets used up
during a sitting, and when it gets dim there is a tendency to
incoherence even in otherwise clear communicators. In all cases,
coming into contact with this * light' tends to produce bewilderment, and if the contact is continued too long, or the ' light '
becomes very dim, the consciousness of the conununicator tends
J*
to lapse completely
But we have not the testimony of any living observer for the
manifestation of this force as a ', light/' though we have abundant testimony of its manifestation and fluctuation, in the
varying degrees of vigor in mediumistic phenomena. Naming
it, however, is of course a somewhat tentative step.
Hodgson farther says (Pr. XIII, 410) :
** What it is that gets used up during the trance I do not
definitely know, but that there is something that does get used
xxp, that represents directly or indirectly some peculiar form of
energy, that when this is abundant the commimications are
clearer, and that when, cateris paribus, it approaches ecdiaustion,
the communications become obscure and even absolutely incoherent, I have no doubf
BOOK
II— PART IV
TELEPSYCHOSIS
CHAPTEB
XV
INTRODUCTION
Of course these new manifestations of force that we have
jnst considered were generally attributed to ', spirits/' as
(pardon the frequent repetition) have been all new manifestations offorce; but the indications seem to be that the
inanimate objects hare been moyed, sometimes voluntarily,
sometimes involuntarily, in response to the more or less definite volitions of the persons exercising the force— that the
manifestations were psychical only in so far as they concerned
the psyche of the operator.
We now come to a group of phenomena that have nothing
to do with material objects external to the communicator, and
are physical only as concerns the communicator's organs of
expression.
The medium receives impressions apparently fr(mi other in*
telligences than his own, without the intervention of any
organs of communication with which we are familiar. These
impressions include facts that could have been communis
cated by word, and also visions, auditions, and other sensations.
They have apparently been derived from the minds of
persons present, persons distant, and Oitensibly persons no
longer in the body.
And right here we are met by a strange fact : discrete as
are telekinesis and telepsychosis, rare as are the persons
manifesting either, yet generally, not always, a person manifesting one, manifests the other. No hint of an explanation
of the apparent connection between them has, so far as I
know, yet appeared. All we 818
can yet do is to trace the tele-
C9l XY]
Omirdlly Known Imtances of Telepathy
219
kinetic power from its molar manif estatiosB up throtigh
significant raps, lights, etc., to where these disappear, and
direct mental impressions take their places.
Both classes of phenomena, telekinetic and telepsychic, were
manifested by Foster, Home, and Moses, but only the telepsychic set through seyeral important mediums whcmi we shall
consider later.
It is hard to account for the skepticism regarding telepathy
which prevailed till within a dozen years among investigators
who had long been familiar with it between the hypnotist
and his subject; and when the whole cultivated world knew
it between the conductor and his orchestra. The following
extract from the New York Evening Poet of April 8, 1912,
is worth quoting in the connection. An orchestra had been
practising under an average conductor for a concert which
Nikisch was to conduct
The writer says [italics mine] :
<< The men were tiied» having been rehearsing all the morning
and given a concert iu the afternoon. Yet at seven o'clock of
ihe same day Nikisch assembled them for another rehearsal,
iniey hoped he would make it short snd easy. He started off
with the fifth Tchaikovsky symphony. The rest may be related
in the player's own words, as chronicled in the London Mtuiedl
Timee of February, 1905:
, , Before we had been playing five minutes we were deeply
interested, and, later, whoi we oame to the big fortissimo, we
not only played like fiends, but we quite forgot we were tired.
For my own part, I simply boiled over with enthusiasm. I
could have jumped up and shouted — as a matter of fact, when
we reached the end of the first movement, we all did rise from
our seats and actually shouted because we could not help it.
The weird part pf it M woe that we plaifed thie symphony
througk,-with ecarceljf a word of correction from Nihteth-,
quite differently from our several previous performances of
the
same work'..
simiplyas loohed
at us, often We
scarcely
his hdton,
and weHeplayed
those possessed.
made moving
terrifie
ereseendos, sudden commas before some great chord, though
we had never done this before/ **
In this connection I am tempted to venture a speculation
which may be utterly valueless, but which may be found to
link in with later knowledge.
In the biography called T/haodore Thomas (Chicago,
1905), n, 26, the great conductor says that in the Ride
and tiie Fire-Music of The Walkiixe there ate passages whidi
220
Introduction
[Bk. 11, I*t IV
no yiolinist alone can play np to time, bnt which a dozen good
violinists playing together can. This I accounted for by
reasons which, for the present at least, are yagne, but are
not without analogues and supports— ,hat as the interchange
of ability and diffusion of intelligence appear to have no
fixed limits, and as the intelligence of a dozen men cannot
be identical, it would be possible for each telepathically to
receive a capacity in addition to his own from others attempting exactly identical things with himself, Certainly this is
not the only case where each of several working together can do
more than each can do separately. In the higher psychoses
there are strong indications that twelve times one are not
barely twelve, but nearer twelve times twelve. Instance the
telepsychic powers of the dream state, as we shall consider
them later.
This is all very well, and I don't altogether despair of its
being very true. Nevertheless Thomas says :
''The intervals which one man drops another will play, as
no two players will drop the same interval, and so the genend
effect is satisfactory.''
That, too, is all very well, if failure in a rapid passage
means to players of that grade only the dropping of notes.
But I know that, to at least one amateur, it means the playing
of occasional wrong notes, and I have reason to believe that
it means the same to all players. If that is so, they would
not all play the same wrong notes, but several of them would
play different and discordant notes at the same time, of
which, to the great leader, ''the general effect" could not
have been " satisfactory." Therefore I continue to hold my
theory that the dozen played together correctly when no one
of them could have done it alone. Musicians generally have
had something of the same experience in ensemble playing —
of doing with others what they could not do by themselves.
This all looks like telepaliiy, which is in part another name
for sympathy.
There was another illustration under the eyes of almost
everybody a generation ago :— ,Planchette often writes what is
not in the mind of the person using it, but is very distinctly
in the mind of some other person present
CHAPTEB
TELEPATHY
BETWEEN
XVI
FOSTER AND THE AUTHOR
One Sunday eyening in the early serenties, my wife and I
went, nnannonnced and unknown, to see Foster. We did
not give onr names, but merely asked at the door of his
boarding-house (near Washington Square) if he could see us.
That he knew anything about us before would be a ridiculous
supposition. He did not know my name, and if he had
there were then even fewer persons to whom it meant anything than there are now, and no portrait of me had ever
been published.
We were ushered into the second-story front room, an
ordinary ', sitting-room/' and Foster appeared. He was a
dark man of about thirty-fiYCy rather coarse and heavy, with
a liberal jowl and a fairly genial face, expressive rather of
interest in the things of this world than those of any less
material one. His eyes were dark and rather dreamy.
Neither in temperament nor physique was he of the , spirituality'' to be expected, according to our usual standards,
in one whose susceptibilities to the hidden world were
evolved beyond 'those of men generally. Becent experiences,
however, have tended to modify the old notions regarding the
spiritual.
His manner had nothing '' professional , about it, but was
easy, natural, and sincere. I expressed a desire for a sitting,
and he invited us to be seated. He sat by the ordinary parlor
table of that day, about two feet by four, on the side away
from the windows, and we on the other side, with our backs
to them. There was no machinery, no trance, no airs of
mystery, none of the " knockings " or " table-tippings " then
usually associated with ', spiritual communications '' — ,nothing
outside of ordinary conversation, except the remarkable substance of the conversation. He merely reported to us impressions that came into his 221
consciousness, and told us that
222 TeUpathy between Faster and the Afdhor [Bk. IL,FtIV
he thought they were put there by , Bpirits ', (the imiversal
and immemorial way of accounting for the unaccountable),
but that he had no objection to our accounting for them in
any way we pleased.
After the natural comments on the object of our visit
and the state of the weather, he remarked : ', Claude is here."
Claude was the name of a baby we had lost some seven
years before, and was of course the name most prominent
in our minds on going to see a ', spirit medium.'' That he
should have known that we ever had such a child, or anything
else about us, was virtually impossible. Apparently he got
it telepathically from our minds. Soon he began to declare
the presence of other personalities — ,friends we had lost, giving
us the names of perhaps a dozen in about the order of their
prominence in our minds.
We put questions mentally. The " spirits' " answers always
were germane to the questions, but were generally noncom*
mittal, and when otherwise, were wrong as often as right
When my father was declared present, I said: ',Ask him a
question I have in mind." Foster soon answered : *, He says
it is best for youS* My mental question was : ', Is my way
of life satisfactory to you ? "
Soon after graduation I had lost a college friend who was
perhaps the best endowed person of his age I have known,
and who left behind him some unpublished MSS. In time
Foster announced : ** Sextus is here." I said : ,* Please get
from him an answer to my mental question."
Foster said : '' Til tiy. Keep your mind on it as closely
as Ityouis can."
well to note here that while some mediums invite
concentration, others are confused by the sitter's letting
his mind dwell on anything: they want it kept as nearly
as possible a tabula rasa. We shall meet illustrations
later. Foster, on the contrary, said to me several times:
, Your mind is wandering. Concentrate it on the question ;
help me all you can." At last he popped out: *,He says,
* Publish every word of them.' " Now that is the very last
thing Sextus would have said: he was the most modest of
men, and the most apt to settle such a question the other
way, or depend on the judgment of his friends.
Ol XYI]
Piecing-out TeUpafhic Impresriana
2%S
Foster impreesed me as sincere, bnt I don't think that he
was able to draw an exact line between his ,'impiessions,'
from outside, as described to me, and his own inventions,
especially when he felt the impnlse, not unnatural or entirely
inexcusable, to show by pertinent answers that he had received correct impressions of questions in the mind of a sitter.
His spiritistic theory of the origin of his impressions had
started when it was the fashion to seek answers to questions
through table tippings, and when he found in himself the
sensibility to telepathic impressions, it was but a step almost
imperceptible to a person of his lack of training, to supply
coherent answers to questions, whether he was fully impressed
with such answers or not. I don't think he intended to
misrepresent, but simply did not distinguish. He probably
got the impression of the question, and himself supplied the
answer. This he did the more readily in the exultation of
having caught the difficult question.
As Foster got farther and farther away from our foremost
interests, which I assume most easily impressed his mind,
he began to write instead of talking, saying that perhaps the
', spirits" would guide his hand to write better than they
would communicate through speech. I think writing helped
him to concentrate. He wrote several scraps of paper which
are before me now. These are probably specimens of the
now widely known ,* automatic '' writing.
One impression indicated on one of these scraps is in
writing not clear, but pretty plainly seeming to be ', Voire
grandpire aux PrangoAa, Jean de Haeef* Now I did have a
grandpire FranQais, but never knew him, and he was about
the last person I would have thought of. Moreover, he was
more than two generations back, and his name was De Hass,
but it was not Jean, At the time, I did not know what it
was, and, of course, neither did Foster — there being nothing
in my mind to give him an impression. So when he wanted
a Christian name, he seems to have taken, voluntarily or
involuntarily, the one which is most frequent. This jumping
consciously or unconsciously to the most common names is
Tery general among sensitives.
Probably Foster knew no French, and I cannot find any
warrant for the locution grandpire Ofux Frangais instead cdF
224 Telepaihy between Foster and the Author [Bk. ll, Pi IV
the natural grandpire Frangais. It suiprised me at the tune,
and surprises me still. It is barely possible that at some
time I had got hold of some such false locution, and held
it subliminallj, and that Foster got it from my subliminal
consciousness.
To farther explain these unnecessarily long words for those
to whom they are new: they are an invention ''made in
Oermany/' though in England and America quite usually
attributed to Myers, but I never knew him to claim it.
His first mention of it that I can find (in Pr. YII for
1891-2) was five years later than when Du Prel's PhUoeophy of
Mysticism showed it to be common stock among ' - the inevitable Oermans.'' It seems to have started with Fechner.
Myers did more, however, than any one else to establish it
with English-speaking people as & working hypothesis.
The words are used to distinguish between conscious
thought and knowledge, and sub-conscious thought and knowledge. Why folks did not find these shorter and simpler
words good enough I have not been able to make out. The
preposition and the root limen, or more strictiy, limin, which
medns '' threshold,', is applied to a consciousness which seems
to exist under or away from the threshold of our daily
experience.
There is abundant evidence of there being within reach
of our memories more than we ordinarily realize — so much,
in fact, that some observers think that every experience —
and possibly eveiy ancestral experience — ,really survives in
the subliminal memory, and can be awakened under extraordinary conditions, such as hypnotism and dreams — ,and perhaps death. Some even go so far as to find reason to believe
that each subliminal consciousness is part of an infinite consciousnes inwhich our individual consciousnesses merge and
communicate with each other telepathically. As we proceed,
we shall find more to suggest such a theory, or rather to turn
Its name from a mere metaphor of localily into something
more significant.
The thing that struck me as most remarkable at Foster's
was that as he was telling me that his impressions often
came to him in visions, he exclaimed: ''I had a strange
one then I I saw a large oyster-shell over your head, and
Ch. XYI]
Impression Vimilmd
225
from it a pearl seemed to fall into your head.'' Now my
father, who had been dead fourteen years, having been one
of the founders of the Baltimore oyster industry, the pearl
coming to me from the oyster-shell was about as correct a
symbol for some of my important experiences as could
readily have been imagined. Foster knew no more about
this than about the revenues of the latest mandarin in China.
Foster gave many iUustrations — ,some to me and hosts to
others — that his sensitiveness was not restricted to another's
passing thoughts, but was apt to respond to anything in
character and experience, without any conscious initiative
from the other; and it was highly characteristic of the dreamlike action of the ', sensitive" mind that he should have
caught this fact in my history and made a vision of it, just
as people in general are constantly taking some triviid cir,
cumstance and expanding it into a dream.
Upon my asking him how he got such impressions, he
said substantially:
''All I know about it ia that they come into my mind,
and sometimes, like the oyster-,hell, seem to appear to my
eyes. I think they are communicated to me by spirits, buf
of course you,ll think what you please.''
I asked : '' Why, with your power of getting at secret things,
don't you learn the secrets of the stock-market, and make
yourself rich?" He answered: ''I feel that if I were to
use my strange powers to get anything but a comfortable
livelihood, they would be taken away." His biographer
records, however, that he did receive a great deal of money
in legitimate fees, and some in more or less legitimate bets
as to what he could do, but that he was not avaricious, often
declined to take a bet that he had won, and let his money
pass through his fingers like water.
For instance, Mr. Bartlett quotes (op. cit, p. 99) from the
New York Oraphic, October 24, 1874:
and''One
said: night a total stranger to Foster called at his rooms
'' ' Foster, I don't believe in your humbug. Now, you never
saw or heard of me, and I will bet you twenty dollars that you
can't tell my name. I do it to test you.'
" ' T-w-e-n-t-y d-o-l-l-a-r-s,' repeated Foster; 'twenty dollars
that I can't teU your name ? Well, sir (putting his hand to lua
226 Telepathy between Foster and the Author [6k. II, Ft IV
brow), the spirit of your brother Clement tells me that yoizr
name is Alexander B. Corcorane.'
''Mr. Corcorane was astonished, and took out his money to
pay the medium, who pushed it back with a laugh."
Of course he could have read both names from the yisitor'a
mind.
Foster did not tell me that he felt that his powers would
be taken away if he used them to obtain anything for which
he did not give an equivalent; but that was probably what
he meant. He was not a person of the high education that
seems necessary to enable most people to say very exactly
what they mean. In fact my recollection seems to be that
he was not very sure to say what he meant even grammatically.
The conclusions established in me by the interview were
that it could not be accounted for without the hypothesis
of thought-transference, as it was called then — ,telepathy, as
it is called now; and that there was nothing correct in it
which could not be accounted for by that hypothesis. He
told me nothing important or verifiable which I did not know
before, but the things he did tell me, he could not have
known without absorbing impressions from my mind or
from other incarnate minds or from the ', spirits.''
His impressions had all the clearness and all the vagueness
of dreams — ,from exact names to the (to him) meaningless
vision of the oyster shell and the pearl.
Myers has marked the difference between a mental impression and what might be called a sensory vision, like the pearl
oyster, by the two words telepathy and telesthesia. Though
perhaps he would confine telesthesia to a vision of an actual
thing or circumstance. Of course all such things merge
into each other as pretty much everything does into everything else— a fact to which I have called attention
probably often enough to tax your patience. The first two
or three times I did it merely as a matter of general scientific
interest ; but as I hftve progressed, I have been impelled to do
it more by fumbling against a vague suggestion of something;
and as I have groped along, this something seems to become
more definite and pervasive, until now it begins to look like
a clue running through the whole subject, and leading by a
new route to a better standpoint for looking through its vistas
Ch. XYI]
Telepathy Basis of Various Manifestations
227
than (so far as I know) has so far been realized. Perhaps we
shall reach it definitely in due course.
Foster's explanation of the '' spirits ', had been the general
explanation for the mysterious daring all previons history;
and at his time many scouted telepathy as a less probable
hypothesis. In fact telepathy was then scouted in favor of
fraud by many — ,probably most — of such people as are now
crying it up as against spiritism.
Although in those days Foster waa called a ''spiritual
medium/' so was everybody else who did anything unex*
plainable. Under the discriminations of to-day, Foster as
I saw him, would not be regarded as a spiritual medium at
all. He was, so far as I observed him, merely a telepathic
sensitive. He did not profess to me that his body was
used as a medium by another spirit. His own spirit was
in the possession of it all the while, and simply communi*
cated to ua what he thought other spirits told him. What
is to-day strictly meant by a spiritual medium is a person
whose spirit seems to relinquish the body for the use of
another spirit, who uses it to write and articidate, and by
so doing generally expresses an alleged personality entirely
distinct, perhaps in point of age and even of sex, from the
medium's waking self. But we are going to meet evidence
that Foster manifested these phenomena too. We shall find
reason to regard them as in some respects quite different from
what they seem.
Many years after I sat with Foster, I left a sitting with
Mrs. Piper more deeply, if possible, under the same impression of telepathy than I was when I left Foster. But
there were additional features in her case that have since
inclined me toward additional convictions. I will be more
specific after we have been over the phenomena.
CHAPTEB XVn
SOME EARLT TELEPATHIC SENSITIYBS
I HAVB introduced telepsychosis, as I introduced telekinesis,
by a personal experience because, as between my readers and
me, it is more direct tlian an experience from a third person.
But in the former case I began with the simplest sort of
illustration of the subject, while in the present case I have
subordinated simplicity to the other consideration.
Yet so many people have read of telepsychic experiences of
many kinds; in fact, so many people have known of, and
even experienced them, that any illustrations at all sometimes
seem almost superfluous. But the experiences are as yet so
little correlated with established knowledge that few people,
if any, profess to ,'understand'' them to any extent, and
therefore more illustrations may be worth while to stimulate
your guesses as well as to explain other guesses, including
my own.
Moreover, next to the question of survival of death, and
strongly bearing upon it, this subject of telepathy, or telesthesia, has turned out to be far the most important with which the
S. P. B. has had to deal. It seems to pervade nearly all
Buperusual psychic phenomena, and it is therefore well to
trace it from even earlier than the beginning of scientific
examination.
There have been many attempts to make the recent manifestations, beginning about the middle of the last century, of
a piece with manifestations going as far back as history.
There are at least two pretty clear differences. Most of the
early manifestations were associated with pathological conditions and religious ecstasy. The recent ones are generally free
from the first, and those as late as the contemporary S. P. B.
records, are free from the second. Indeed, while the comparatively illiterate spiritualism of the American outbreak had
religious associations, it had288few religious ecstasies.
The
Ch. XVII]
Swedehborg
229
manif estatioDB were generally normal, the earlier ones seem to
have been generally abnormal.
There seems then a good deal of warrant for assuming that
the recent phenomena come in the natural course of evolution,
while the earlier phenomena may have been precocious, and
therefore unsubstantial.
The reader who cares for a more complete and detailed
account than I have space for of these subjects previous to
the foundation of the S. P. B., will find the best I know in
Podmore's Modem Spiritualism (1902). But admirable as
it was at the time, in the light of later knowledge much of
it reads like the old disproofs of the possibility of a locomotive
moving over twenty miles an hour, or of more than one electric
light on a circuit
The earliest celebrated sensitive in the modem world was
Swedenborg. His case of course received little general attention before the movement of which one symptom was the
foundation of the S. P. B. Nevertheless, the case had attracted
the investigation and confidence of so great a man as Kant,
who vouches for it, expressing himself as follows in a letter
reprinted as Appendix II in his Dreams of a Ghostrseer (Qoerwitz's translation, London, 1900) :
''In the year 1769, towards the end of July, on Saturday,
at four o'dodc p.m., Swedenborg arrived at Qottenburg from
England, when Mr. William Castel invited him to his house,
together with a party of fifteen persons. About six o'clock
Swedenborg went out, and returned to the company quite pale
and alarmed. He said that a dangerous fire had just broken
out in Stockholm, in the Sodermahn (Gottenburg is about three
hundred miles from Stockholm), and that it was spreading very
fast. He was restless and went out often. He said that the
house of one of his friends, whom he named, was already in
ashes, and that his own was in danger. At eight o'clock, after
he had been out again, he joyfully exclaimed, ' Thank Ood, the
fire is extinguished the third door from my house.'... On
Monday evening, a messenger arrived at Qottenburg, who was
despatched by the Board of Trade during the time of the fire.
In the letters brought by him the fire was described precisely
in the manner stated by Swedenborg."
This may have been pure telepathy from the minds of
witnesses in Stockholm, or it may have been tdopsis (dair*
voyance) .
230
Some Early Telepathic Sensitives
[Bk. II, Pi lY
Kant also aaid on another subject (op. cit, pp. 17-18) :
<e,' said the husband, 'will you come, so
that I may be sure of your identity 9' The wife replied, as
g]ancing out of the open window she observed a pet white
fawn playing in the yard, 'I will come in the shape of that
white fawn.'
''Five years later, the wife died. The grief -stricken husband, hearing of the remarkable gifts of Foster, concluded he
would seek an interview. He was fortunate in finding Foster
alone. Questions were written, folded and placed on tiie table
in broad daylight, in the usual manner, but the result was disappointing. No response came. ' Strange,' said Foster, placing
the papers one after the other to his forehead, 'I feel no influence whatever. I fear that I am not in the proper condition
to-day to satisfy you.' Again Foster placed the slips to his
forehead without result, and then rather abstractedly leaned
bade in his chair. All at once, greatly to the astonishment of
his interviewer, Foster jumped up with unmistakable symptoms
of flurry and alarm in his countenance, at the same time brushing violently from his lap something nobody saw or felt but
himself. At last he said : ' I know I must be out of sorts, unstrung; for although many strange things are constantly happening, Inever had an experience that startled me so before.
It may seem very foolish to you, but as I had one of your slips
pressed to my forehead, suddenly looking up, I saw a beautiful
white fawn run across the floor towards me, and it jumped into
my lap the moment I started from my chair. I cannot account
for it— cannot understand it; I only know I saw just what I
have described.'
" His visitor said not a word, gave no clue to an explanation,
and did not subsequently visit Foster. As he said, he was
' afraid to do so.' "
There was no actual fawn. Foster did not see any material
thing teloptically, but got a suggestion from the husband's
store of memories, and expanded it into its vision, as we are
254
Recent Telepathic Sensitives
[Bk. II, Pt. IV
constantly expanding all sorts of notions into dreams. The
fawn was really less a construction of Foster's than my sheU
and pearl were; for the fawn had been in the husband's mind,
and the shell and pearl in combination, and especially with
the pearl falling into my head, never had been in mine.
My pearl and this fawn seem like catching dream-figments
from another mind; why not dream-images of persons in the
same way? Here is one more, but in it, as in many cases,
the percipient sees against the sitter's mind. What did he see ?
From the Troy Press, March 6, 1875. Bartlett {op. cit,
p. 108) :
''He made almost a mental photograph of one of my rela*
tives — an aunt who died fifteen years ago, and whose memory
has been especially dear to me. After he had given the shape
of her face, her apparent age, the color of her hair, and a sad,
thoughtful expression that especially characterized her face, I
added : ' She had brown eyes.' Mr. Foster instantly looked up,
as if into her face, and said: 'No; hazel eyes.' I afterwards
learned that he was right and I wrong about it."
The sitter's subliminal vision could hardly have been more
correct than his conscious one, and given Foster a correct
image. This of course suggests that Foster saw the aunt's
spirit rather than the nephew's recollection of her. And this
suggests in turn that in the preceding case the wife actually
did appear as the fawn, though the husband had not the faculty
to see her. But in that case would not Foster have seen her
jump into her husband's lap rather than his own?
Foster's '' spirits " were sometimes in the body. Mr. Bartlett writes (op. cit., p. 21) :
" I have a vivid recollection of a certain stance where . . . the
spirit was described as having bright red hair, freckled face,
short chin-whiskers, etc. The gentleman said, * You have given
the name correctly, and you have perfectly described my
brother, but he is alive and lives in Albany.' Mr. Foster replied, 'In these visions, I perceive the persons plainly, but I
cannot always tell whether the spirit be in the body, or out of
the body.' "
Telepathy from the sitter.
Here is a very significant circumstance, if it really is a cir*
cumstance, but I may be mistaken in my impression. Foster,
Ch. XVIII]
Ideas from Distant Persons
255
Mrs. Piper, and others frequently talked or wrote about living
persons, but although many of the dead persons they mentioned, themselves took the floor and talked or were reported
in propria persona, there is not a case that I can recall where
any living person has professed to speak through a medium.
Yet on seeing this Professor Newbold writes me :
*, If I am not mistaken Dr. Wiltse once was represented as
80 speaking through Mrs. Piper.''
Ideas from Persons Distant
The following was probably more apt to be teloteropathy
from the bo/s mind than advice from any " spirit,' (Bartlett, op, cit, p. 100) :
From the New York Oraphie, October 24, 1874.
" One day (and everybody knows the story in Philadelphia)
Alexander McClure, the old Greeley leader of Pennsylvania,
came into the Continental Hotel with Colonel John B. Forney.
Mr. McClure was very sad, for he had received news that his
son was drowned at sea.
'''What do you think about it, Foster!' asked Colonel
Forney.
"'Why, sir, the boy is not drowned at all,' replied Foster.
' He's alive and well, and youll have a letter from him in a day
or two, and then he will come home.'
"Two days afterwards McClure met Foster, and said, with
tears of gratitude : ' Why, Foster, you were right My boy is
all safe. I had a letter from hizn to-day.'"
This illustrates a very frequent experience — ,that the sensitive's susceptibility extends beyond the sitter and picks up
impressions from the minds of distant persons; and the cases
where sensitives have produced any verifiable thing not possibly existent in such minds, are rare. But if they were not
in such minds, they could not be verified. This, therefore,
is of course not necessarily fatal to Foster's own conviction
that the impressions were given him by " spirits."
A wife feels a blow received by a distant husband (Pr. 11,
128):
"Brantwood, Coniston, October 27th, 1883.
"I woke up with a start, feeling I had had a hard blow on
my mouth, and a distinct sense that I had been cut, and was
bleeding under my upper lip, and seized my pocket handkerchief, and held it ... to the part, as I sat up in bed, and after
256
Recent Telepathic Sensitives
[Bk. II, Pi lY
a few seconds, when 1 removed it» I was astonished not to see
any blood, and only then realized it was impossible anything
could have struck me there, as I lay fast asleep in bed, and so
I thought it was only a dream I— but I looked at my watch, and
saw it was 7, and finding Arthur (my husband) was not in the
room, I concluded (rightiy) that he must haye gone out on the
lake for an early sail
''I then fell asleep. At breakfast (half-past nine), Arthur
came in rather late, and I noticed he rather purposely sat
farther away from me than usual, and every now and then
put his pocket handkerchief furtively up to his lip. ...I said,
' Arthur, why are you doing that? ' and added a little anxiously,
' I know you've hurt yourself; but Fll tell you why afterwards.'
He said, 'Well, when I was sailing, a sudden squall came,
throwing the tiller suddenly roimd, and it struck me a bad
blow in the mouth, under the upper lip, and it has been bleeding a good deal and won't stop.' I then said, 'Have you any
idea what o'clock it was when it happened)' and he answered,
* It must have been about seven.'
" Joan R Severn."
Mr. Severn confirms the experience throughout.
Vague uneasiness leads a husband to his injured wife (Pr.
II, 126) :
" Cathedral Yard, Winchester, January 81st, 1884.
',
I am a working foreman of masons at Winchester
Cathedral. . . . More than thirty years ago ... in London . . •
I carried my food with me, and therefore had no call to leave
the work all day. On a certain day, however, I suddenly felt
an intense desire to go home, but as I had no business there
I tried to suppress it,— but it was not possible to do so. Every
minute the desire to go home increased. ... I got fidgety and
uneasy, and felt as if I must go, even at the risk of being
ridiculed by my wife
'*
The door was opened by my wife's sister . . . who lived
a few streets off. She looked surprised and said, 'Why, Skirving, how did you know? ' * Know what? ' I said. * Why, about
Mary Ann.' I said, * I don't know anything about Mary Ann '
(my wife). *Then what brought you home at present?' I
said, * I can hardly tell you. I seemed to want to come home.
But what is wrong? ' . . . She told me that my wife had been
run over by a cab . • . and she had called for me ever since,
but was now in fits, and had several in succession. I went
upstairs, and though very ill she recognized me, and stretched
forth her arms and took me round the neck and pulled my head
down into her bosom. The fits passed away directly, and my
presence seemed to tranquilize her, so that she got into sleep,
Ch. XVIII]
Visions from Distant Persons
257
and did welL Her sister told me that she had uttered the most
piteous cries for me to oome to her,
Visions from Persons Distant
Here is an experience more attractive than ihe average
in these studies. It is from Bey. P. H. Newnham of Maker,
Davenport, England, given in a paper by Myers in Pr. III.
At Oxford one night in 1854 Mr. Newnham went to bed
with a violent headache, to which he was subject Mr.
Newnham says (Pr. Ill, 6f.) :
'* I dreamed that I was stopping with the family of the lady
who subsequently became my wife. All the younger ones had
gone to bed, and I stopped chatting to the father and mother,
standing up by the fireplace. Presently I bade them good-night,
took my candle, and went off to bed. On arriving in the hall,
I perceived that my fianeSe had been detained downstairs, and
was only then near the top of the staircase. I rushed upstairs*
overtpok her on the top step, and passed my two arms around
her waist
"On this I woke, and a dock in the house struck ten almost
immediately afterwards.
" So strong was the impression of the dream that I wrote a
detailed account of it next morning to my fianeSe.
*' Crossing my letter, not in answer to it, I received a letter
from the lady in question: , Were you thinking about me, very
specially, last night, just about ten o'clock t For, as I was
going upstairs to bed, I distinctly heard your footsteps on the
stairs, and felt you put your arms round my waiBt.'"
Mrs. Newnham writes in confirmation.
Stillman says (op. dt, I, 184) :
'' On one occasion, when Mr. and Mrs. Brown were on a fishing trip into the wild parts of New York State, and, returning,
were on their way to the railway station, the wheel of their
wagon broke and they had to go to a blacksmith on the road
to have it repaired. She said to her husband that they would
lose the train, to which the voice replied that they would be
in time; for the train was late and they would arrive wiUi a
minute to spare, and in fact as they drew up at the station
the train came in sight and they had a minute to spare. . . •
Her husband implicitly and always followed the directions given
, ,
her through her demon
The S. P. B. Ciommittee rqKnrts (Pr. 11, 161) :
268
Recent Telepathic Sensitivee
[Bk. II, Ft. IV
'' The account was sent to us by the Ber. Canon Warburton,
The Close, Winchester.
','Somewhere about the year 1848 I went up from Oxford
to stay a day or two with my brother. ...I found a note on
the table apologizing for his absence, and saying that he had
gone to a dance. ... I dozed in an arm-chair, but started up
wide awake exactly at one, ejaculating *, By Jove, he's down ! "
and seeing him coming out of a drawing-room into a brighdy
illuminated landing, catching his foot in the edge of the top
stair, and falling headlong, just saving himself by his elbows
and hands. (The house was one which I had never seen, nor
did I know where it was.) Thinking very little of the matter
I fell a-doze again for half an hour, and was awakened by my
brother suddenly coming in and saying, ''Oh, there you are.
I have just had as narrow an escape of breaking my neck
as I ever had in my life. Coming out of the ball-room, I caught
my foot and tumbled full length down the" stairs."
* W. Warburton.
'' '
The general impression was of a narrow landing
brilliantly illuminated, and I remember verifying the correctness of this by questions at the time.
" * This is my sole experience of the kind.' "
Here are three accounts of apparently teloteropafhic veridical dreams given me by Professor Pumpelly, though all three
may have been teloptic, and the last one tdakoustic :
''Between forty and fifty years ago, while visiting my sister
in New York City, I came down to breakfast where I found
my brother-in-law reading the morning paper. Soon my sister
also came down and joined us at table. She said she had had
an awful dream; she had dreamed all night that she was standing in a church, where a continuous procession of men was filing
by her, carrying on litters something covered with sheets.
"Her husband resumed reading his paper and soon said:
'Why, Netty, here it says that they are removing the bodies
from the St. Mark's grraves.'
" Now, my sister's first child had been buried several years
before in the graveyard of St. Mark's church. My sister had
not seen the paper, and neither she nor her husband had heard
of any intention to disturb the graves."
" In the late winter of 1864-6, I was on my journey through
Siberia. In one of the first nights after leaving Irkutsk I
dreamed that I had arrived at my native village of Owego in
New York and had walked home from the station. As I came
up the driveway to the liouse I saw my mother and my father
standing at the door showing signs of great grief. I noticed
that my aunt, who lived with us and whcnn we all loved dearly.
Ch. XVIII]
Professor Pumpellifs Veridical Dreams
259
was not there. As soon as I waked I was so impressed by the
dream that I made a memorandimi, as I remember, in the form
of an inverted torch, with the date.
'' When I reached St Petersburg about three weeks later, I
found in my mail the first news I had had, for six months,
from home. I learned that the aimt I had missed in my
dream had died. I do not remember now the relation in time
between the dates of the death and the dream. It was close,
and my impression is that I thought, in reading the letter,
that there was coincidence."
''In 1906 we were living in Capri. One morning my wife
told me of dreaming that she found her sisters and her brother
Otis (who had died- several years before) in tears. When they
saw her, Otis said: 'We must tell Eliza.'
"That same day there came a cablegram saying that my
wife's favorite brother Horace was very iU, and within an hour
another cable saying he had died."
Here is an unreported case that came to me direct yesterday. The story will have to stand for what it may be
worth on my sole attestation. The parties are known to
me, but peculiar circumstances prevent confirmation by publishing their names.
On the first of January, 1912, a father was dying in one
city and a daughter twelve years old was lying ill with
pneumonia in another. Suddenly the child, with a rapt expression, raised herself to a sitting posture; her attendant
rushed in alarm to make her lie down, and the child exclaimed": Father was taking me in his arms ! " The father
died at about the time. Whether before or after cannot be
accurately determined.
There are on record many similar occurrences well attested.
Whether all visions are telepathic, including teloptic, is an
open question. Myers inclines to the opinion that they are
not — ,that sometimes the telergic effect includes a modification of space that makes the vision objective. Certainly such
modifications of space can be produced by mechanical means,
as in the theatrical exhibitions I have already described.
Whether they can be produced by telergy is a question. There
are on record hundreds of such visions well attested, from
those of simple objects deliberately transferred according to
260
Recent Telepathic SensUivee
[Bk. II, Ft lY
the early S. P. B. reports, to the complex ones spontaneouBly
received by Foster, Colville, and others.
The phenomena thus far given I have been content to
group nnder telepathy from the living, though some of them
are hard to account for in that way.
At the present time the great storehouse for these experiences isPhantasms of the Living, by Edmund Gumey,
Frederic W. H. Myers, and Frank Podmore, London, 1886.
This book is now out of print It is criticised in Podmore's
Apparitions and Thought Transference. There is a very good
article, with many cases, in Pr. V (Part XIV) by Gumey, completed byMyers after Gumey's death. There is also an important discussion by Mrs. Sidgwick on Phantasms of the
Dead, with some cases, in Pr. Ill (Part VIII), 69f. Others
are in Pr. VI (Part XV), by Myers, and in Part XVI by
Podmore and Myers, and in Pr. VIII (Part XXII) by Myers.
Space requires that generally the few accounts given here
should be much condensed. The increased vividness of details and frequent accompanying discussions and abundant
confirmations in the original statements would generally repay the reader for going to the sources cited. It may be
worth while to repeat that the volumes of the Pr. S. P. B.
generally consist of several parts, which can be had separately
from Messrs. W. B. Clarke & Co., of Boston.
Ideas Apparently from the Dead
A weakness in the assumption that any tdepathic intelligence or vision really comes from the dead is in the fact that
the circumstances are nearly always in the minds of survivors
near the scene of death, and may be teloteropathically conveyed to the percipient. It is a question, however, in many
cases, whether that hypothesis does not strain probability
more than the spiritistic hypothesis. That it does, seems more
frequently the conclusion of those who have read many of the
cases, than of those who know but few. But compare the
extracts from Professor Pumpelly a page or two back.
Stillman (op. dt., 1, 186-7) tells the following of a s&mce
where a child of seven, whose name is suppressed, acted as
medium. Stillman's questions were mental.
Ch. XVIII]
The Siillman Steamboat Case
261
''After sereral relatives had been named, I asked if our
brother Alfred was there, to which she instandy replied, ' There
is a gentleman sitting on the comer of the table by you who
says his name is Alfred.' , The opportunity then occurred to
me of asking a ' test question/ which was, * If Alfred is here,
will he tell me when he last saw Harvey t' The relevance of
this question will appear from the fact that they were together
on the steamer whose boiler burst on the Mississippi, killing
my brother and causing injury to the cousin such that he
committed suicide a month later. The reply was, ' He says he
does not remember.' At this I remarked guardedly to the
doctor [Another brother of Stillman, who was present. H. H.] :
* I asked Alfred when he last saw Harvey, and he replies that
he doesn't remember, but he must have seen him on board the
boat' To this she instantly replied, with an explosive laugh,
'He says that if he did it was aU blown out of him! '...It was
quite in accordance with the character of my brother to joke
on the most serious subjects — ,he was an inveterate joker.
"
All the facts were known to at least two persons present.
But where did the joke come from?
Here is a second Foster stigmata case, not given for the
stigmata, however. From Bartlett (op. cit., p. 12) :
"During the same sitting a word of three letters appeared
upon the back of Mr. Foster's hand — the letters were formed
by a red discoloration of the skin. The word was one which
was agreed upon by the gentleman and his wife before her
death, and it was to be used as a test by the one who should
die first. The word had never been mentioned to any person."
In this test, as in the fawn test, Foster was more successful
than, as we shall see, Mrs. Piper has been with some important
agreed post-mortem tests.
There are many habitual seers of waking visions, and hearers
of voices, and the heteromatists who write while awake are
closely allied with them. They are generally religious enthusiasts. St. Theresa, Joan of Arc, and the Seeress of Provost are
among the classical examples. A remarkable recent one is
Mme. Sophie Badford de Meissner, an American widow of a
Bussian diplomat. She has just published an account of her
experience in a little volume entitled There are no Dead. She
believes herself in constant communication by audible voices
with her husband and son and others who have died. The book
862
Recent Telepathic SensUivea
[Bk. II, Pt IV
abounds in the ortbodoz anthropomorphic conceptions, and yet
it falls in with what perhaps I may call the very reasonable
present-day idea of Heaven as a sublimated earth — scenery,
occupations, and alL As the old mixtures from the Apocalypse, Milton, Bunyan, etc., were belieyed in with religious
fervor, the replacing of them strongly suggests outside influence ;and that the experience is so general, makes the suggestion stronger still.
But Mme. de Meissner's heaven is by no means entirely secularized. Her controls often see Christ, and have frequent religious services, and the angels and archangels sing with them.
I give a few passages :
(Op. cit. Foreword.) "There is no attempt at anything in
the way of , test * cases, despite the fact that many such have
been shown me, though never in reply to a demand for the
same. Spontaneously things have been told me, either for my
own guidance, or for that of friends in sorrow and despair; and
spontaneously have I been informed of things that have afterward come to pass; but any attempt at forcing communications
in regard to future happenings has invariably been met by a well
deserved rebuke from those who are 'given charge' over all
us." cit,, 6.) " You all think so wrongly of the life here — it
of (Op.
differs so little from that in the world, except in that it is so
much more grand and full."
This is directly against her intense orthodoxy.
(Op. cit, 12.) " * There is no night here — what you call the
night is the best time of all, for then you are with us. As soon
as you are asleep your Spirit is here, and we sit and talk either
in the house or in beautiful gardens, or on the river's brink.' "
{Op. cit,, 23.) " (In reading a book of Professor Hyslop's, I
mentioned 'Rector's' name aloud, and he at once responds:)
"' Yes; I am here— do you want anything 1 '
"(I tell him of how E. F. had told me I would be able to help
others, and add that I cannot see just how that may be.)
''A. 'You will know in a few weeks. You will be much
stronger, and will see them soon. It will come by prayer and
fasting.' "
The Titanic went down April 14th. On the 17th Mme. de
Meissner thought she had communications from W. T. Stead.
On the morning of the 18th she thought she had communications from Major Butt It was not till the evening of the
CIl XVIU]
Mme. de Meissnwr's Cases
263
18th that news of the arriyal of the Carpathia gave her any
other assurance of their deaths that she remembered when
writing. But of course during the interval, the papers were
full of wireless messages that probably mentioned them. For
the particulars of all this, I shall have to refer you to the book.
On reading these accounts, the habitual student is apt to say
to himself : "This admirable lady is more gifted with emotional and imaginative power than with dry-as-dust judicial
habits. I wonder how many of these details are very natural
post facto imagination I Certainly her imagination sometimes
supplies pretty wide interpretationa of other incidents.''
I give the following as illustrating what will appear to many
a point weak enough to raise questions regarding the whole
experience — and it is not the only one. Yet if it is all imagination, itis at least a graceful bit, and there are many more
graceful things in the book. It will sometimes be a little hard,
though, for any but the very orthodox to sympathize with them.
Madame even goes so far as to have the mere pronouncing of
a sacred name break up very trying situations.
Here is the experience :
(Op. dt, 61-2.) '' October 9, 1902. (Beading in the Journal
do 8i. Petersbourg d three workmen who had been run over by
an express train in Austria, I hear these unhappy men beg me
to help them — ,they have no idea where they are, but are entirely
in the dark. Can see no way at all — ,they cannot pray, for they
never did that in their lives, and do not know how.)
"(' Ask God to help you.')
"A. 'Who is Qodf
" C Say : " Our Father Who art in Heaven,'* after me.')
,' (This they do; then I hear an exclamation, and the words:)
,'Now it is growing lighter, and we can see a little. Oh,
don't leave us, for we don't know at all where to go, or what
to do; but — there is a young man coming toward us, and it gets
'
lighter as he comes nearer
" (From my son) * Pray for these poor men — ,but I can take
them only a little way — yes, they can have work if they want it.'
" (Here they are shown a garden with flowers, and they say :)
"* No, we don't know anything about flowers — ,we only know
how to work on the rails.'
"(From my son) ' I cannot show them that, but there is one
here who can.'
, (From the men) * Ah, here comes someone who we see will
give us work. Yes, now we see the work we are to do; and we
G
264
Recent Tehpathic aensitivee [Bk. II, Ft IV
will not be alone, for there are some men farther down the road»
poor workmen like ourselves, and we can talk to them after a
while. Yes, now we are at work here, and we understand that
we must work as well as we oan in order to come to a lighter
and brighter place.' ''
Whatever impressions one may get from the book, there la
sure to be among them one that whether or not the experiences
are all pure auto-suggestions, they are a source of much happiness to the author and, apparently, many of her friends; and
the apparent fact that no harm comes from them suggests a
degree of genuineness. All such matter where deliberate deceit isout of the question, is worth studying : for even negative
results help fix the boundaries of the positive ; and that there
is an important positive of some sort, whether a vast addition
to our general Cosmic Belations, or only to our traditional
psychology, is an opinion that can now be contradicted only
by the ignorant
From Bartlett (op. cit, p. 62) :
"While I was connected with Mr. Foster I know of no one
stance which created such a sensation, and the reports of which
were so widely copied, as that given to Mr. 0. £. De Long, of
San Francisco, an extended account of which appeared in the
San Francisco Chronicle, of January 28, 1874,
"Mr. De Long was wholly unknown to Foster. They all sat
down to the table, and after Foster had smoked awhile at his
cigar, he said: 'I can only get one message to-night, and that
is for a person named Ida. Do either of you know who Ida isf '
"Mr. De Long looked at Foster with rather a startled look,
and said, 'Well, yes, I rather think I do. My wife's name is
"* Well,' said Foster, ' then this message is for her, and it is
Ida.'
important. But she will have to come here and receive it.'
" The next evening the same two, accompanied by Mrs. De
Long, were ushered into Foster's parlor. ... After Foster had
smoked for several minutes in silence, he suddenly said : ' The
same message comes to me. It is for Ida. This is the lady, is
it? ' he asked, as of the spirit. * Oh, you will write the message,
will you? Well, all right,' and with this he took up a pen and
dashed o£F the following:
my daughter
Ida —Madden
Ten years
,ago I for
entrusted
large
sum"Toof money
to Thomas
to invest
me in acertain
lands. After my death he failed to account for the investment
to my executors. The money was invested, and twelve hundred
and fifty acres of land were bought, and one-half of this land
now belongs to you. I paid Madden on account of my share
Ch. XYIII]
The ViMya/rc,Madden Investment
of the purchase $660.
266
He must be " made
* Yourto famake
ther, a settlement
" *
ViNBTARD.'
', Both Mr. and Mrs. De Long sat and heard this conmiunica*
tion read with astonished faces. Mrs. De Long . . . was terribly
frightened ... for she knew that Foster did not know who she
was, nor who her father might have been.
"2fr. De Long . . . next day called on Mr.
. [and]
unsettled. • business
asked Mr. Madden if there was not yet some Madden
between himself and the estate of the late Mr. Vineyard. Mr.
Madden thought for a moment, and then he said there was. . . .
When informed that Mrs. De Long had only just learned of
this investment of her father's, Mr. Madden expressed much
surprise. He said he supposed she and her husband and the
executors knew all about it, but were simply letting the matter
rest for the property to increase in value. Mr. Madden then
said that he was ready to make a settlement at any tima This
was readily assented to by Mr. De Long, and accordingly, on
Saturday last, Mr. Madden transferred a deed for 625 acres
of the land to Mrs. De Long.
, Meanwhile Foster is overrun with people anxious to interview their deceased parents, for the purpose of finding out if
the old folks are quite sure that their estates have been fully
and properly settled."
The dramatic features — ,the letter, etc., are not unlike the
dramatic features of ordinary dreams. All could have been
tdoteropathy from Mr. Madden's mind. But if so, as in
many similar instances, it must have been communicated involuntarily.
Visions Apparently from the Dead
The records contain perhaps more visions apparently from
the dead than mere communications of unknown verifiable
intelligence. This of course generated the idea that often the
personages are present in a ', spiritual '' body palpable enough
to affect the eye, but telesthesia would be enough.
In the general gossip regarding Foster, the feature that
decided me to go to him was my being told by Professor
Pumpelly that Foster had announced to him the death, too
recent to be reported by any means then known, of a friend
in China whom, from Foster's description, Professor Pumpelly at once recognized as Sir F. B. He also told me that
news of the death was received through ordinary channels in
due time after Foster had told him of it.
266
Recent Telepathic Sensitives
[Bk. II, Ft lY
This would be interpreted by skeptical experts as a case
of teloteropathy. They would say that plenty of people in
China knew of Sir F/s death, and Foster unconsciously tapped
their minds, being stimulated thereto by a previous tapping
of Professor Pumpelly's mind; in other words, Professor
Pumpell/s presence put Foster,s mind in sympathetic connection with minds holding knowledge of special interest to
Professor Pumpelly. The men who have given incomparably
more attention to the subject than have any others — ,Myers
and Hodgson — one of whom began his studies as a thorough
skeptic, would say that the spirit of Sir F. gave the impression for his friend to Foster. My impression, for which
reasons will appear as we proceed, is that some sort of psychic
record of all facts pervades the universe, and that Foster
caught up this one and others of interest to his sitters.*
(Pr. V, 408f.) From the Eev. G. M. Tandy, Vicar of
West- Ward, near Wigton, Cumberland.
<ending on artifices of great complexity — ,has made
known to us inferentially, yet not the less certainly, an obscure
physical entity which we style the cosmic ether; so also may
experiments on the propagation and interruptions of clairvoyant
or telepathic knowledge or memory conceivably reveal to us inferentially, but not the less certainly, an obscure piEqrchical entity which we can best describe to ourselves as an anima mundi
or cosmic record of all things."
Ch. XX] Myers Demands Hoiking Less* James
297
In Myerg's exposition of his theory of the Subliminal ConBdonsness in Pr. YII and in Human Personality (I, llf.) he
piles up the indications of superusual faculty until he gets
far beyond our usual conceptions of human powers, and where
apparently nothing short of the cosmic soul could be equal
to the results.
James runs up against the same notion all the while.
In Pr. XXIII, 4, he named as possibly accounting for the
medium's report of forgotten things:
''Access to some cosmic reservoir, where the memory of all
mundane facts is stored and grouped around personal centers
of association.',
Is ''personal center of association" a bad name for per*
sonality?
Here are some extracts from his A Pluralistic Universe:
(Page 299.) " For my own part I find in some of these abnormal or supernormal facts the strongest suggestions in favor
of a superior co-consciousness being possible. I doubt whether
we shall ever understand some of tiiem without using the veiy
letter of Fechner's conception of a great reservoir in which the
memories of earth's inhabitants are pooled and preserved, and
from which, when the threshold lowers or the valve opens, information ordinarily shut out leaks into the mind of exceptional
individuals among us."
Each individual mind seems to be a subdivision of that
reservoir, all subdivisions being subject to intercommunicatioxL
(Page 808.) " They have had their vision and they hnow —
that is enough — ,that we inhabit an invisible spiritual environment from which help comes, our soul being mysteriously one
with a larger soul whose instruments we are."
In his Psychology he says (I, 346) :
" I find the notion of some sort of an anima mundi thinking
in all of us to be a more promising hypothesis, in spite of all its
difficulties, than that of a lot of absolutely individual souls."
In Memmrs and Studies, James farther says :
/,My ownas dramatic
sense between
tends instinctively
to (Page
picture201.)
the situation
an interaction
slumbering
faculties in the automatist's mind and a cosmic environment
of other consciousness gI some sort which is able to work upon
them."
298
The Comic Boul
[BL II, Ft IV
(Page 204-6.) , There is a oontinuiun of oosmio oonsdoiisne6s» against which our indiriduality builds but accidental
fences, and into which our seyeral minds plunge as into a
mother-sea or reserroir.''
What follows seems to indicate that he really means that
rills from it plunge into us, which has long been my guess.
Throughout the passage it is consoling to the ordinary writer
to find himself among a gentle mixture of metaphors by
so great a man:
',Our 'normal' consciousness is circumscribed for adaptation to our external earthly environment, but the fence is weak
in spots, and fitful influences from beyond leak in, showing the
otherwise unverifiable common connection. Not only paychic
research, but metaphysical philosophy, and speculative biology
are led in their own ways to look with favor on some such
'panpsychic' view of the universe as this. Assuming this
common reservoir of consciousness to exist, this bank upon
which we all draw, and in which so many of earth's memories
must in some way be stored, or mediums would not get at them
as they do, the question is. What is its own structure! What
is its inner topography f
Podmore says {New. Spir., II, 162) that in his book on
Spiritism, the
"famous philosopher, Edward von Hartmann . . . explained the
physical phenomena as due to some force analogous to electricity
or magnetism emanating from the medium's body; but held that
the mental manifestations point to a transcendental origin.
He suggests, in short, that in thought-transference or clairvoy*
ance the mind of the seer is in connection with the Absolute, and
through the Absolute with other individual minds."
Podmore also quotes (New. 8pir., II, 172) Charles Bray
(On Force, iU Menial and Moral Correlates) :
, Our bodies are continually giving off thought rays, just as
they give off heat rays. These thought emanations, it must be
inferred, are not lost to the universe; and, indeed, 'many facta
now point to an atmosphere or reservoir of thought, the result
of cerebration, into which the thought and feeling generated by
the brain are continually passixig.' With this general thoughtreservoir the persons called spirit mediums may be presumed to
be in communication."
The conception is not restricted to "psychical researchers ''
in the special sense, but looms up in some form in Almost
Ch. XX]
BM-gson.
Paradoxes Fringe all Knowledge
299
all philoeophic writing. That we may be up to the latest
fashion, let ns take the following from Bergson {Creative
Evolution, 191, italics mine) :
''From this ocean of life in which we are immersed, we are
continually drawing something, and we feel that our being, or
at least the intellect that guides it, has been formed therein
by a kind of local concentration.*'
(Ih., 269.) ', On flows the current, running through human
generations, subdividing itself into individuals. ... Thus souls
are constantly beiag created which, nevertheless, in a certain
sense pre-existed. They are nothing else than the little rills
into which the great river of life divides itself."
When he writes of " life , dividing itself into individuals,
he probably would permit us to read '' mind *, or '' soul.,'
In such matters we are pretty far along when we get
hold of anything substantial enough to call an idea. But
the vague groping feeling, yet a strong feeling, of a reality
behind all these paradoxes and metaphors, is by no means
rare—a reality which is part of the advanced man's substitute for the Mumbo Jumbo god, which is the best that the
mass of mankind, even of ''civilized'' mankind, have so
far been able to place behind their universe.
All paradoxes? Of course they are. The whole fringe
of our knowledge is made of paradoxes.
All metaphors? Of course they are: so is nearly all our
language after it gets past material things and the primary
sensations and operations that they initiate.
Vague adumbrations of the general notion of course are
found as far back as Pantheism is, but in the shape I am
fumbling over, it could not antedate modem evolution, including the modern conceptions of force and matter. This
is probably why, in the indexes of the half-dozen histories
of philosophy I have at hand, I find the term World-Soul
in but two, and no closer equivalent than Pantheism in any
of the others, and in one or two (I don't care to look again
for the sake of exactness) not even that. The books all, of
course, contain various paragraphs about Pantheism.
Weber (History of Philosophy, translated by Thilly, p. 94f.)
has one on the World-Soul apropos of what Plato had to
say on the subject. The definite thing that can be dug out
800
The Cosmic Soul
[Bk. U, Pi IV
from his imaginatiTe and sometimes poetical conf usionfl is
that the cosmos has, in Weber's phrase:
, a soul> the mysterious Unk which unites the contrary prin*
ciples in the cosmos, and whose function it is to subordinate
the material world to the Idea, or to subject brutal necessity
to reason, to adapt it to the &ial purpose of the Creator. . . •
The soul of the world consists of Number, whidi subjects
chaotic matter to the laws of harmony and proportion.''
— ,whatever all that may mean — ,nothing that I can see, unless
the cart before the horse, while in the various modern notions
there does seem to loom up something behind the f og, something which is simply the facts which Plato had not.
Paulsen says (Introduction to PhUoaophy, Thill/s transla*
tion, 232ff.) :
'' Is all striving and willing, as it confronts us in the thou*
sand diverse forms of existence, finally combined into the unity
of one being and willt Does a unity of inner life, in whose
self -movement and self-realization all individual life and striving is included, correspond to tiie unity of the physical world
in universal reciprocal action!"
That last sentence has some correspondence with the question: Is Mind as much of a constituent of the universe as
matter and motion? I shall give reasons for thinking that
it is more of one, if there can be a difference in essentials.
(lb., 234.) ', Beality is not annihilated by becoming a thing
of the past. The past remains an eternal constituent of reality,
and the present moment does net comprise the whole of reality."
If Paulsen had had the recent evidence (much of which
we shall meet later) that everything past exists in memory
somewhere — say in the Cosmic Mind (The inheritance of aU
cestral experience is not big enough to fill the bill) that
/sts
statement would have had additional certainty and significance.
(Ih., 284.) ''May we now... say: What we see in our
own lives on the small scale, what we seem to recognize also
in the life of the earth, is true of the world at large t Are its
aim and being contained in a universal life, in an eternal
spiritual life, the fullness of which far surpasses our notions
of it, but of whose essence we get a glimpse in our own spiritual
natures?
''I believe that we may make such statements and that wa
Ch. XX]
Paulsen.
Science InadequaU
301
may add: There is no yiew which ezplaina ezisteotce moie
simply and dearly/'
Certainly none which so well fits the phenomena of telepathy and, we shall see later, of ', possession/'
in,, 2d5-6.) ''That this view is indeed more plausible
than any other is shown by the fact that all thinkers, witib the
exception of a few philosophiang physicistSy are remarkably
unanimous in regarding it as the final explanation of the
uniyerse. In the East as in the West, in ancient as well as in
modem times, the thoughts of the freest and prof oundest have
converged towards this point. • • • Wherever modem philosophy
finds its freest and boldest expression, it invariably returns to
this view. ... Existence is a unified spiritual life, the visible
part of which is the evolution of psychical life, and particularly
of earthly human life.
, During the ascendancy of speculative philosophy, this theory. ..was regarded as absolute truth.... It was called the
secret religion of the cultured classes, and its followers were
convince that it would gradually penetrate into such circles
as were as yet unable to grasp truth except in concrete images.
But it happened otherwise. As far as there can be any question
of a philosophical world-view among the cultured (most of them
get along without any), it is more apt to be found along the
lines of natural-scientific materialism or of an epistemological
skepticism. The physical view of things has dislodged the
poetical-speculative refiection. The notion of an inner universal life is, for the most part, wholly foreign to our natural
scientists. The idea of a world-soul . . . seems to them to be as
childish a dream as that of anthropomorphic gods. They do
not need the hypothesis, th, can explain the world by means
of atoms and physical forces, excepting, perhaps, that small
remainder, the states of consciousness in the brain of living
beings. Science... no longer allows itself to indulge in the
childidi play of such fantastical speculations. • . . And the educated classes, intimidated by the, self-assurance of natural
science, are ashamed to profess views that do not bear its
stamp.''
All of which casts some light upon the facts that within
a g,eration literature and art have drooped,, that the soul
of man has taken up its residence in his pocket, that gambling
has again become a current amusement in circles otherwise
respectable, and that the best thing the age could do with
the proudest of its typical creations — the Titanic — was to
send it to destruction for the chance of being able to
a trifling increment of speed.
802
The Cosmic Saul
[Bk. H, Pi 17
Heayen forfend, however, any attempt to cure such ills
by a revlyal of the old type of speculatiye philosophy I Dogmatism was a worse ill than any of them, and a priori
dogmatism is the worst of dogmatisms.
Let US see if we can focus the yaxions glints shown in the last
half dozen pages into something like a systematic statement.
Of course all our terms must be proyisional; in fact, with
our recent experience of the rapid eyolution of knowledge,
we are pretty near a recognition that all terms whateyer must
be proyisional. But let us go ahead with those we haye.
Of course we can get notions of these vague ideas only by
repetition of them from various points. I hope the repetition
will not overtax your patience.
Mind is as fundamental and pervasive a constituent of
the universe as Matter and Motion are. We cannot account
for mind as it is to-day without associating it with the atoms
from which we assume it to have started, though it is by no
means limited to them. IJnlike matter and motion, it is
not fixed in quantity; every moment its raw material is being
worked up into new thoughts, emotions, fancies — and psychic
personalities, if you please; and all these are added to the
previous sum, pervade innumerable individualities, and
through some phenomena which we have already seen and
others which we shall see later, now generally appear to be as
indestructible as matter and motion.
All this looks very much like good hard fact. Now for a
venture on the thin ice. A soul is made up of experiences,
thoughts, feelings. How, then, about the old and widespread
notion of the souls at death flowing back into the cosmic
soul ? This question is suggested, not only by the considerations just given, but also, of course, by the way things Suspiciously like departed psychic personalities have been showing
themselves through the sensitives and in ordinary dreams.
But though perhaps we flow back into this constantly
increasing aggregate of mind — ,the Cosmic Soul — ,it seems
mtich more obviously to flow into us — at times and in de*
grees that vary enormously, as we vary. Into the least
sensitive or receptive, it does not go perceptibly beyond
the ordinary psychoses of daily life; into others it seems to
Ch. XX]
Excluding Phetumena Admits Telepathy
303
penetrate in ways to which we hardly know how to assign
limits. Will it not presumably, as evolution goes on, flow
more and more into all of ns?
Now the human receptacles for mind seem to be, to use
our poor phrase, elastic; and the flow of mind depends on
many more conditions than we have any idea of. One of them,
as we all know, is the flow of blood. Another seems to be (to
express it as well as we can with our rough matter-made
metaphor-words) making a place for the inflow by excluding
ordinary matters of attention, as in hypnosis. There are
all degrees of this exclusion, from the hypnotic subject's concentrating his attention on a single object or yielding it exdusively to its hypnotizer, to Foster's voluntarily excluding
what does not concern his sitter and perhaps feeling a hypnotic influence from the concentration of attention he asks
from his sitter; on to, as we shall see later, Mrs. VerraU's
excluding everything she can when awake; to everybody's
excluding almost everything in sleep ; to Mrs. Piper's excluding
everything in trance. Under these conditions, to speak very
roughly and provisionally, there seems to be a cosmic inflow
in proportion to the space provided for it Foster gets an
occasional idea supemormaUy from the sitter and perhaps
even from discamate minds; Mrs. Yerrall gets a string of
them ; we nearly all get varying dreams, and some of us get
dreams beside which waking life is insignificant; and Mrs.
Piper appears to get the experiences of hundreds of souls
by the exclusion of her own and the reception of them.
There seems a close relation between hypnosis and cosmic
inflow. In fact, what is hypnosis but an inflow from one
unit of the cosmic mind to another — from the agent to the
subject? What else is telepathy? Our being too ignorant
to yake an answer does not prove the identity, but it does
leave the field open for exploration which may confirm the
identity.
But without the body, which seems as if it were devised
for the evolution of the individual soul, how do the alleged
departed souls remain individual? They profess to answer
by saying that they still have bodies, but better ones than
those we know. But we are anticipating.
Whether it all means spiritism or not, it certainly means
304
The Comic Saul
[Bk. II, Pt. lY
at least wider reach of mind than we knew before — some aa
yet faint reaction and apparent blending of each mind with
more of the mind pervading the aniverse.
In opening up this wider reach psychical research has done
a work of unsurpassed importance. The fruition of that
work we have but begun to enter upon. There seems reasonable hope that there is waiting something beside which all
that comes from our as yet rudimentary senses is insignificant
And now probably you see why I have harped so on the
impossibility of rigid classifications in Nature— on the fact
that those of science are necessarily arbitrary — ,why I have
tried in so many connections to impress the truth that> so far
as we can really conceive, all Nature is one. I have done it
to prepare the way to the conception that all Soul is one.
But, if in solitude at such places as the Qomergrat, or
Lake Champlain, or anywhere under the stars, you have
not already felt that conception, you will probably find my
efforts wasted, and they may be mere waste anyhow, except
aa they may possibly stimulate somebody else to better ones.
CHAPTER
XXI
THB GOSMIO SOUL AND THE INDIVIDUAL SOUL
But how about the bearing of this doctrine of the Cosmic
Soul on the question of our individuality?
Each of us sets a good deal of store by his individuality,
some of us rightly, but take away from one of us the stream
of vital energy that in one sense is not himself at all, but
flows from outside to outside through his sympathetic nervous
system, and also take away the stream of consciousness that
certainly in large part flows from outside into his afferent system and at least partly back to outside through his efferent
system — ,take away these streams which are not himself, and
how much individuality is left ?— ,The individuality of a corpse
that perceptibly begins to disappear within three ,ays.
The individuality, then, does in part come from outside.
Yet it is unquestionably largely determined in amount and
character by the body — ,the size, shape, and quality of the
brain and the blood-vessels supplying it, and, in less degree,
by the qualities of the heart and organs that affect the blood
supply. When the stream of mind-potential goes through a
man he is affected by just those things that his organism is
fitted to respond to. It is somewhat as if the brain cells and
their connections were a number of wireless telegraph receivers responding to such vibrations as they are keyed to.
The kinds of this responsiveness make up a man's individuality. The other persons who respond to nearly the same
kinds are congenial with him. Farther, like the telegraph
instrument, he not only receives, but he sends out — ,what he
has to say for TiiTnHAlf also determines his afiSnities.
The stream of thought that flows through us, then, is \
certainly not part of our individuality; and it certainly is \
part of our individuality. What it shall be for any one of
us is deten,iined more definitely than perhaps at any other
time, when (so far as there is a ', when " to the determination
306
Cosmic Soul and Individual Soul
[Bk. II, P& IV
of aoything) it is fixed which one of a niTriad of spermatozoa
is to become the tenant of a waiting ovum. That sperma*
tozoon seems to have its individual stream or streams of
outside power and mind-potential, while it is accreting to
itself pound after pound of matter, foot-pound after footpound of energy, and later, universe after universe of ideas.
Its body, its energies, its universes will be unlike those of
any other creature : it will be an individual.
One soon comes to have an individual share in determimng
what one's psychic stream shall consist of and whither it
shall flow. Whether it shall consist of the thoughts of
butcher, baker, or candlestick-maker, one has pretty much his
own way. So has he, but in less degree, as to whether it
shall be the thoughts of rich man, poor man, beggar-man, or
thief. In still less degree he determines whether it shall be
the thoughts of doctor, lawyer, priest, or engineer; still less
whether it shall be those of statesman, philosopher, artist, or
poet; and scarcely at all whether it shall be those of Shakspere, Newton, Humboldt, Lincoln, or Spencer. In one sense,
and in a very important sense, such men have relatively less
choice regarding their own individualities than have the rest
of mankind regarding theirs. The greater the individuality,
the less is it determined by itself.
But from another side: the greater the individuality, the
more is it determined by itself as it grows up. Lincoln had
to make Lincoln, but he could not help making Lincoln.
Not only can the man largely determine the contents of
his psychic stream, but he can also largely determine what
he shall do with it; and this not only, as already indicated,
in the broad general current of his life, but in the many
special things that are largely independent of the current.
But despite all this, the stream comes from outside him and
flows back to outside him, and is almost as independent of
him as if it ran through a hose, though he can use it in
the same ways — ,to water gardens in his mind, or to put out
mental conflagrations, or, like a sand-blast, to carve inscriptions and decorations. And while he uses his stream of
thought to affect both the world and his own mind, all the
while that stream of thought is not exclusively himself. And
it is himself I All those things are his work!
CIl XXI]
The Stream of Conscumsneis
307
When we think of a man as an individual it is because
we take thought of only part of him, and probably the least
significant part: we cannot form a passably thorough idea of
a man without saturating it through and through with the
idea of the Cosmic Inflow from out8ide-H)f God, if you
please.
" When me they fly» I am the wings."
Again I have been writing paradoxes, and I shall write
many more : that alarm bell always rings when we reach the
limits of our faculties.
Under ordinary circumstances the individual is conscious
of only the limited portion of the stream of mind which constitutes ''him'' — ,the ''him" of the moment; but in dream,
trance, hypnosis, and apparently articulo mortis, at least by
drowning, he seems conscious of a much larger proportion
of his own stream, sometimes apparently of all since the
first conscious experience. The stream, then, after it has
passed on is not lost, hopelessly sunken, or evaporated. Though
the man is not ordinarily conscious of the whole stream after
it has passed him, it seems to exist somewhere— somewhere
whence it can be brought The recovered thing is but a copy
of the stream, one presentation of the " Idea " of the man.
But at least the Idea is not lost The medium — ,telepathioally from somebodies' memories, or heteromatically from a
postcamate individuality — ,presents some sort of a rendering
of it at any moment — ,a rendering that is more than a stream
of memories — ,more like a thinking, feeling, responding man.
We have, I trust, reached some sort of a reconciliation
between the idea of a Cosmic Consciousness and an individual
consciousness, the interflow between them being most strongly
manifested in states of inspiration and dream. We have what
seem to be the facts, whether we can reconcile them or not.
The Transcendent Ego
The last guess is at variance with the guess that inspiration
and dream come from a transcendent ego— a subliminal self,
unless we adopt the Cosmic Mind as the transcendent eg<
the subliminal self.
I cannot find any transcendent ego in the ordinary
308
Cosmic Saul and Individual Soul
[BL 11, Pi lY
anything more in a man strictly as an individual independent
of cosmic inflow — than what has been evolved by the sensereactions between him, including his ancestors, on the one
side, and on the other, the environment, including what has
been put into him by that portion of the reactions constituting
his education. In the strict sense of ego or self, apparently
there cannot be more than that much, if that much.
And yet it is often said of almost any man : *, He surpassed
himself.'' This is of course a contradiction in terms — ,another
paradox on the borders of knowledge. Yet it relates to a
universally admitted phenomenon. Now what does the phrase
mean — ,what phrase that is not a contradiction in terms will
express it ? If there is any matter not yet verified, upon which
thinkers have agreed through all recorded time, it is that these
people who surpass themselves—orators, poets, artists, musicians, generals, even dancers and clowns — everybody who does
anything,
is occasionally
must be from
outside. '' inspired " — breathed into : and that
What makes a ', sensitive," or a genius, seems to be ability
beyond that of people in general, to evoke the contents of the
subliminal consciousness, whatever it may be — Cosmic Soul if
you please, into the supraliminal or vigilant or waking con«
sciousness. This is imagination — inspiration — ,', possession,''
though we may yet conclude that they may be also something
more.
The theory of inspiration is encouraged by the great ability
shown at times by men like Tolstoy whose intelligence and
reasoning powers are inferior — ,who are constantly ignoring or
even contradicting obvious facts; to whom two and two are as
apt to make five or seven, as four; and yet who, between times,
gush out streams of imagination that fertilize the ages.
The source of the inspiration has lately seemed to contain
all mind that is on our planet, or ever has been, and to
manifest it in all degrees, from the lightest thought, imagination, or emotion, up to those complexes of them all which
we recognize as human souls. As we go on we shall find
accumulating indications in this direction.
True, Foe made out that the general scheme of ,,The
Baven " was not inspiration, but a pure piece of mechanical
construction, and the finding of the refrain a piece of me-
CL XXI]
The Transcendent Ego
309
clianical inyesiigation ; but there are other things in the poem
that he would probably himself have called inspiration if he
had not been guardedly defending the contrary thesis; and he
is generally thought to have supported it merely for the saka
of making a sensation, which is more easily done by contradicting the truth than by supporting it The fact seems
to be, however, that the mechanical inspirations of a Poe —
or an Edison — are inspirations as truly as the different inspirations ofa Shakespere.
The idea of a transcendent ego seems to have come from
the idea of a transcendent universe. But the transcendent
universe is virtually demonstrable, while the transcendent
ego, as a purely individual quality independent of the cosmic
soul, seems far from demonstrable, and indeed counter to
the indications of evolution: for evolution apparently produces only the known ego resulting from interactions between
the known self and the known environment. Anything more
must apparently be an inflow from outside the known universe.
Those who hold for the individual subliminal are used to
seeing the physical man limited to his x pounds, and so
ihey assume a psychical man limited to his x capacities.
This X, however, they say = y + 2, y being what ttie man
does ordinarily, and z being what he can do only in inspiration or dream. Du Prel uses over and over again a comparison ot y + z to the visible universe. When the man is
awake y only is in evidence — ,this planet and the sun. When
he goes to sleep or goes into trance, or shows telepathic
powers, z appears — the stars, but they were there all the
while, only not in evidence. Yet, it seems well to repeat,
Du Prel seems to posit a limited y + z (== ,) faculties,
just as he posits x pounds for the body.
Now in view of such facts as that thoughts from single
brains are spreading into all the brains of the civilized world
every day, and that it has already become commonplace doctrine among all students that ''the subliminal self forgets
nothing/' isn't it a fundamental error to let the constant
familiarity with x pounds lead us to posit for each man a
limited x {,y + z) set of faculties, or, in more general
terms, to let the known fact that matter (motion) is limited,
310
Cosmic Soul and Individual 8oui [Bk. II, Pt IV
lead us more or less ooDBciotisIy to reason as if mind were
limited — ,to assume eyen, in &ce of the now incontrovertible
facts of the dream-stateh— the waking visions of Foster and
Stillman's friend, inspiration, ordinary dreams, trance, hypnosis, mediumship— that even the individnal's mind is limited ?
It may be a likely guess that that portion of it which has been
evolTed directly in connection with reactions between material
organism and material environment — ,the y mind, perhaps,
is limited; but how about the z mind of the dream state
as just particularized? Apparently it has not grown up in
the observed processes of evolution; before Mesmer it had
not attracted much attention beyond an occasional comment
by an occasional genius ; but all the while, with the evolution
of the y mind, that z mind has been spasmodically manifesting itself more and more, until in our time such a man as
Gladstone has pronounced its study the most important study
of the age, and the first psychologist of recent years probably
devoted more attention to it thim to any other department
of his subject The y mind has observably been evolved, and
we know, after a fashion, how. But let us amend that phraseology, and, provisionally at least, say that the capacity to
receim it has been evolved. This does not seem to contradict
any facts, and may be usefuL
The z mind, on the other hand, seems sprung upon us aU
of a sudden, or at least upon our modem observation, though
Joseph was an authority on it in Egypt, and there have been
others, in their way. But our modem students of psychological evolution have hardly paid any attention to it, and the
special students of it have hardly tackled it from the evolutionary standpoint Why P I hazard a guess. May it not
be that, unlike the y mind of everyday life, the z mind has
not, to any significant extent, been evolved in the individual,
that primarily it is as old as the universe, though it grows with
all mental action in the universe — that it is the Cosmic Soul ?
What appears to be the human evolution of the y mind is
mainly constantly increasing ascertainment of tmth already
existing in the cosmic mind— open by logical and ezperimentd
processes to human knowledge. The z mind, on the other
hand, may be the cosmic mind spasmodically flowing in without such process, but shaped into individuality by each con«
Ch. XXI]
The T Mind and the Z Mind
311
•titution, 88 each haj of the oce8n gets indiyidnality from the
shores.
Accordingly, if any portion, and not all, of the mind
sarvives bodily death, we would expect it to be the portion
we have designated by z, and later it may be fonnd interesting
to inquire if, of the survivals alleged through the mediums,
any preponderant portion is of the z mind-— of that part of
the personality least connected, or least obviously connected,
with the evolutionary reaction between body and environment ;and if ', evidential '' matter sought so signally in vain
is not after all part of the y mind, which is mainly an
apparatus for the conduct of earthly life, and which, tiieref ore, we could hardly expect to jSnd strong and dear beyond it
The phenomena suggest that the ordinary reactions between
the body and its environment evolve the commonplace selfpreserving faculties, and that exceptional circumstances which
we don't begin to understand— even heredity seems to have
little to do with them — produce sporadic persons specially open
to the exceptional forms of cosmic inflow — genius, mediumship, and the rest. Even the quite general form of dreaming
is by no means universal, and dreams of a high order seem to
CQme rarely even to good dreamers, while persons subject to
mediumistic visions are rarer than poets.
The discovery, if discovery it be, that the subliminal self
is the Cosmic Soul, may impress some readers as belonging
in the same class with the immortal discovery in Natund
History, made after so much investigation and reflection, that
a snark is a boojum. Argument against such an impression
would be wasted. The subliminal self is as much a part
of accepted knowledge as is the law of association of ideas,
and the Cosmic Soul is at least an intuition of most of the
minds whose intuitions havef been among the most important
of humanity's guiding lights. The conception that the subliminal self and the Cosmic Soul are the same, may yet be
demonstrated to a clearness that will place it among those
beacons.
(Let me not be misunderstood regarding the guidance of
intuitions. They point out promising directions, but not
always infallibly.)
312
Cosmic Soul and Individual Soul
[BL II, Ft IV
Of the transcendent ego, or subliminal self, then, as generally described, I see no evidence; but of it as the Cosmic
Soul, I see mudi evidence.
The capacity to receive the Cosmic Inflow and farther
evolve it seems to be in course of evolution, and it often looks
as if that capacity might, while we are yet in the body,
*enormously eiUarge our cosmic relations, through the dream
state ; and there is also enlargement for the old, old hope that
when we leave the body we may remain ourselves, and yet
become *'one with God/*
It looks, too, as if these possibilities might be the supreme
justification for the evolution of the universe. There may
be justification enough in birds and flowers, in the play of
lambs and children, in sex, in love, in the maternity around
which so much of Ihe world's worship has centered, in know*
ledge, in wisdom, even as they have been ordinarily understood; but a new significance, a new joy, a new glory over
and beyond them aU sometimes seems to have been lately
promised by that as yet dim conception of the Cosmic Soul.
Now in wandering around amidst these mists I here come
upon an idol whose exaggerated cult I hate, but there may
be something in its temperate cult. I mean the idol of
a priori knowledge — ,the notion that all knowledge is in the
mind, waiting to be dug out. Though man's mind may
not contain latent all knowledge, assuming a cosmic mind,
of course all knowledge is there, and the German professor
evolving his camel in his study, so far as he had any telepathic
communion with the cosmic mind, was right. But there is
no sign that all knowledge is in any human mind or accessible
by any human mind, even in the dream state. And unless it
is there, it can hardly be dug out by contemplation unchecked
by verification.
And now, having extracted whatever hope or consolation—
or amusement — ,we may have been able to derive from these
pages of guesswork, let us see if we can get them into a
paragraph.
There are unquestioned facts — abundance of them outside
so-called medixmiship— that demonstrate something in man
Ch. XXI]
I#
•
The True Mtfstickm and the False
313
beyond his surface faculties, to wliich the terms transcendent
ego and subliminal self hare been applied. But is that ego
merely of himself? Does it not seem to be rather each man's
share — that portion which the individual's conformation and
circumstances permit to pass into him — of that which transcends our conception, and of which we confess our incapacity
wholly to conceive, by such words as infinite and eternal, and
which we attempt to express by such metaphors as '' kinship
with the gods,*' or the better one of '* God in us '' ? If in
that later metaphor we must include universal motion, why
not universal milid?
Around this vague conception, more perhaps than anywhere
else, center the vague lights that we have on this whole subject.
I shall try to indicate them wherever we meet them, but all
my indications will necessarily be vague, and many of them
inevitably mistaken; and as I have revised my work I have
come to fear that my persistency in these attempts will sorely
try your patience. But I believe the attempts would be
much surer and less trying if the many men who have trod
these misty paths before, every one of whom seems to have
seen those lights, had tried more persistently to follow their
indications; and I believe that the ultimate solution will be
found among them.
I hope this chapter may have suggested some of the wider
notions of mind which recent experience demands. Tet it is
very largely analogy and imagination. I don't propose to
go to the stake for it, or send anybody else for denying it.
But, if yon please, it is not all analogy or imagination, but it
has a very visible claim to being hypothesis based on unquestionable facts. While we have been groping in the dark
it has been a dark where some pretiy definite things have kept
turning up in some very suggestive ways.
Speculation to account for facts, however mystic it may
be, is a very different matter from the mysticism which scorns
facts, and seeks truth only as visions and telepathic impressions from assumed mystic intelligences— often through the
mortification of the fiesh and vexations of the spirit, which
seldom find truth, and generally weaken the powers that seek it
CHAFTEB
XXn
MIND AND BRAIN AGAIN
Ik
Now let US go on tor gome facts in the general constitntion
of mind which support the preposterous jumble of propositions
in the last two chapters. Possibly as we proceed, they may
seem less preposterous, and we may even jSnd them supported,
if thafs not too big a word, by others.
Bnt let us keep safe in the realization that, until all are
verified, we must not assume them to be true, but equally
realizing that verified fancy is the chief source of progress.
These chapters are very repetitious. It has been said often,
but is not apt to be said too often, that the first essential of
good writing is knowing what you are writing about. Now
I am writing about certain facts, but as to the inferences from
them, I donH know: nobody knows: we are all guessing; but
somebody must do the guessing and the bad writing — ,bookfuls
of it— ,if our descendants are to know. The " common law *'
of our Cosmic Bdations is going to be in no small degree
developed, as much of the common law of our Civic Belations
has been developed, by *, text writers '' .correlating the cases.
The vague notions of a cosmic mind are dimmed by the
indications that mind is but a persistent individual secretion of brain; but the vague conceptions clear up again so
far as we are able to think of mind as independent of brain.
Some reasons for so thinking were given in Chapter m.
There are others that I did not give there, because I thought
that they would be less tedious here, where they could be considered in connection with telepathy.
We have seen some indications that mind may be not a
product of our mechanical part, but a redistribution, into
combinations ever growing Ugher, of a primordial element
like force and matter — ,an element inherent in each atom
of our structure, and also, like force and matter, constantly
flowing into us from the external universe, and constantly
going out This primordial element I have already, probably
814
Ch. XXII]
Mind Potential Vanes
315
following somebody whom I have forgotten, termed ''mindpotentiaL,' But I would now expand that term to cover
anything, from whatever it Ib that leads an amoeba to contract
when touched (while any inorganic thing that looks like
ity will not) up to whatever any psychic organism works over
into something else-,up to, say, the effects on the sensoria
of the sounds in Nature which Beethoven works into a great
piece of music, or the woodland colors and murmurs which
inspired '' Thanatopsis," or the charms of womanhood which
have bred an infinite variety of poems. Moreover, each
product of mind becomes mind-potential for farther products :
so under that term I would include even the impressions
made on the sitter or reader by an alleged personality expressed through a sensitive.
And there is not only more mind, but higher mind. Mindpotential, from its lowest to its highest forms, is constantly
worked into higher forms, new thoughts, feelings, impulses,
all sorts of mental and emotional products. If, then, there
is a cosmic soul, it would seem as already intimated to be
constantly growing by accretions from the souls developed on
the planets.
The material for furnishing copies of those individual
souls, or so much of them as is worth copying, seems to be
all there. Some specially gifted persons, more or less in the
dream state, and all of us in ordinary dreams, are able to
recover portions when even the memory of the originators
cannot. And the mind-product can be recovered not only
from each one's own memories, but from each other's memories, and apparently in much greater degree, independently of
the body, from some cosmic reservoir of all memories.
Mind's independence of the body, and its inflow to the
individual from outside is farther suggested by the following
group of considerations, some of which we have seen before
from a different point, or used before for a different purpose.
I. As we have seen, the matter and motion constituting
a man can be in only one place at one time, but his thoughts
and emotions can be in any number of places at any number
of times.
U. Mind, unlike matter and force, is free from limitation
816
Mind and Brain Again
[Bk. II, Pt lY
and measnrability. Motion disposes itself toward measoie*
ment in the most obliging manner : it sets part of itself oft in
the form of matter, which part we can measure readily ; it also
places some of the remaining and imponderable part of itself
at our disposition so that we can measure it by its effects
upon matter. Even when it is amusing itself in blowing down
forests, or tumbling seas, or splitting up the earth, or swing*
ing planets, we can still measure it, but only by its effects
upon matter.
We cannot similarly measure mind. We can reduce to
foot-pounds the power that rolls Neptune for a year; but we
would never think of reducing to foot-poimds the thoughts
of Bismarck that built the German Empire, or even those of
Moltke that moved the armies which took part in the building.
And yet, such is the continuity of the universe that strict
classification fails here as everywhere; the differences all
around are but differences of degree. Mind is measurable,
but thus far only in ways too insignificant to be worth taking
into account. We can already, to some extent, measure it by
its effect on matter, through the sphygmograph, for instance,
and we shall measure it more; but it is hard to foresee that
we shall measure it much. To measure mind as completely
as we measure force we would have to know even more recondite things than how many foot-pounds bring the flash
to the hero's eye, or the blush to the maiden's cheek. And
if we should ever think we had got the thing cornered, there
might escape from somebody one little thought that would set
all the men's eyes in the world flashing and all the maidens'
cheeks blushing, and would prove our measurements naught.
III. A given mental individuality varies from time to time
more than its physical companion, the brain. The healthy
powers of the body vary but little, but in inspiration and
dream (including somnambulism, trance, etc.), the powers
of the mind immensely surpass its ordinary powers. These
enormous differences take place in the same person, and so
suggest at least a partial independence of the brain. The
inference springing from these differences, so far as I know,
philosophers have, up to date, treated very queerly. On one
hand, they have ignored it; i,ey all, so far as I know, generaUy assume that the colossal powers a man shows only
Ch. XXII]
Mind Does Not Vary as Brain
317
occasionally are carried about with him all the time. A
more reasonable inference seems to be that they are not,
but they are temporary increases in the flow into him from
the Cosmic Soul. And on the other hand, of the philosophers
I know who ordinarily ignore this inference, most, if not all,
incidentally imply it in such passages as those already quoted
regarding the Cosmic SouL
IV. Minds differ more than brains do in amount, and at
least in mechanical structure. Just how much weight to
attach to this we don't know: for there may be differences
in molecular structure that, if we knew them, would account
for the differences in mind. Yet Dr. William Hanna Thomson assures me that so far as we know, the differences in brains,
when compared with the differences in minds, are as
nothing.
V. In addition to the enormous differences in amount between the psychical manifestations of different individuals or
of the same individual at different times, there seems to be
another line of cleavage which may indicate something important On one side of the line is the group of manifestations which are (a) under voluntary control, (b) shown by
all men, and (c) running closely parallel with manifestations
of physical force, as shown in increased flow of blood and
consumption of tissue, and subsequent fatigue corresponding
with the intensity and duration of the psychical manifestations. On the other side is a group of manifestations (a) not
under the control of the individual, (b) almost entirely
(except in dreams) outside the experience of ordinary individuals, and (c) not usually accompanied by any noticeable
expenditure of physical force. Witii certain qualifications,
which I will immediately specify, this second group includes
inspirations, visions waking and sleeping, nearly all — perhaps
all — ,veridical dreams, and nearly all — ,perhaps all — ,pleasant
ones, and all the phenomena of somnambulism, hypnotism,
and trance, and automatic writing and the other forms of
mediumship. For convenience* sake, all of these are generally
included under the phrase ,the dream state,'' even inspiration being often included with them. Inspiration is perhaps
the principal borderland where the two groups, like all groups
divided by human classification, shade into each other.
318
Mind and Bmn Again [Bk. II, Pi lY
Ordinary dreams belong with the second group — of psycho*
see apparentiy independent of physical function, in so far as
they are not to any extent under the control of the indiyidual,
are apparently not experienced by all men, and do not generally involve any appreciable waste of force and tissue. But
they are far from being unqualifiedly in the second group,
because they are appreciably under the control of some men
(Stevenson and van Eeden, for instance) and are experienced
by a very large portion of mankind. In short, they, like
inspiration, are on the borderland between ordinary pqrchic
processes, and those which seem to be largely in the tran*
scendent universe.
The classification of the two groups is rough and tentative,
partly because with our present knowledge we cannot be
very sure of our material — ,we cannot be sure we have exact
recollections of even our ,'best, dreams, and of many we
have hardly any recollections at all. But the classification
seems fairly to fit what material we have, and will be found
to make a farther fit with some wider classifications to be
attempted later. The differences are dear enough (and that
is the point I am after), and suggest inflows through different
channels— one from our worldly experiences, the others direct
from the cosmic mind.
As already noticed, ', the dream-state " evinces powers entirely surpassing those of the vigilant state — in the reception
of Ugher-developed mind-potential, the vivifying of fainter
memories, the solution of harder problems, the transcending
of time and space, the reception of telepathic impressions, the
veridical copies of personalities incarnate and (alleged) postcamate, etc., etc. All these capacities seem illimitable, and
again suggest inflows from an illimitable source.
The first of the groups of capacities — ,those of waking hours
that are common to all men, and subject to each man's control,
we more readily assume to be in some way peculiarly his —
originated in his brain from the reactions of his soul with
the universe — or even the secretion of his brain, than we can
assume the same of those exceptional capacities in the second
group which comparatively few men display, and no man to
any great extent contiols.
I think we shall find weight added to this suggestion as
OL XXII]
Dreams and Teuton Tissue
319
we go on to consider illnstratiye details of the manifestation
of the exceptional and more or less inyolnntary powers.
In marking the differences between the two gronps, one
qnalification is that although in the long ran some phenomena
of the dream-state do se,i somethii, of a physical tax,
and eyen characterize some forms of inyalidism, they occnr
more markedly with people in good health, and it is generaUy
when they present anything shocking or distressful that they
are attended by noticeable waste of force and tissue. Doubts
haye been thrown on this, the old ascetic idea of mortification
of the flesh has eyen been held out as essential to mediumship.
As a cause, this is not trae at all; and as a result, it is seldom
trae farther than the fatigue occasioned by telekinesis. The
cases of Foster, Colyille, Tuttle, Dayis, Mrs. Piper, Mrs.
Thompson are all the other way. Moses had rather def ectiye
health, and so had Home, but their cases make no larger proportion of the whole than would be those of the defectiyes
among people not mediumistic.
In psychosis apparently freed from physical parallelism,
we may include much of the experience, perhaps all the best
experience, of the medixmis. Foster showed no more fatigue
in his cheerful sitting with me than any other equally long
sitting at a table would naturally inyolye, though he did show
much from his more terrible experiences, as already narrated
in the extracts from Bartlett. And Mrs. Piper, when fayorably circumstanced and well taken care of, seems better for
her trances than without them. Golyille, we saw, emphatically testified the same thing, and the general testimony is to
the same effect
Of course this question of parallelism in the higher psychoses may be settled before long by experiment, though it is
not easy to get together the proper conditions of experiment.
Meanwhile the considerations expressed in the last few
pages seem to offer a strong hint that there may be some
modes of mental action without any physical correlate. Indeed haye we not long been familiar in the dream-state with
features that may perhaps be more easily accounted for by a
hyper-physical or metaphysical psychosis than on any otilier
theory yet in sight?
320
Mind and Brain Again
[Bk. U, Pi lY
This hypotheBis may throw some light on tdepathy and
receiye some from it. A fundamental difficulty with telepathy
is the assumed lack of a physical medium for transmission
of the assimied physical changes in the agenf s brain to the
brain of the recipient Possibly one is not needed, but if one
is, why are we not as much at liberty to assume an ether for
these assumed vibrations as we have been to assume an ether
for light or heat? But is it inconceivable that we may yet
find that in the phenomena involving telepathy we can drop
questions of ',energy'' and ,'neursd tremors,' altoge&er?
Apparently such a result will be inevitable if telepathy from
discarnate intelligences shall ever be accepted as part of
established science.
In this connection the following remarks by Myers are
well worth considering (Pr. YI, 320f.) :
" When we come to telergy, — ,to the power of propagating influences or phantasms at a distance [and, shall we add, of receiving them when awake or asleep t H.H.] — ,then the familiar parallelism between bodily and mental states assumes a quite
strained and hypothetical air. At first... we spoke of phantasms coincident with moments of death or crises, as though
a strong upheaval of the conscious being disengaged some infiuence which might be felt afar off. But as further cases
were gathered in it became dear that the * crisis ' which facilitated teleigic action was not necessarily a moment of conscious
excitement or strain. Quite otherwise; for it was found that
the * agent,' at the moment of the apparition, was often asleep,
or fainting, or even in a state of coma. Not the moment of
death alone, but also the hours of abeyance and exhaustion
which precede death, were found apt to generate these appearances. Nor is the moment of death itself, under ordinary
circumstances, a moment of impulse or exaltation. Far oftener
it is an imperceptible extinction of energies which have already
waned ahnost into nothingness.
''It would, then, be nearer the truth to say that teleigio
action varies inversely than that it varies directly, with die
observable activity of the nervous system or of the conscious
mind.'' [Of., my suggestion earlier regarding brain change
varying inversely as the grade of the psychic process. H. H.l
, And it follows that the presumption commonly urged against
the conscious mind's continuance after bodily decay loses much
of its force when we are considering this new-found form of
mental energy, — so much less manifestly dependent upon bodily
states."
CHAFTEBXXm
THE IDEA
But before ve go on to explore the deeper mTsteries, or, it
may be, the higher heights, perhaps we had better put into
our rucksacks another notion as old as philosophy, of which
not much use has been made lately, bnt which, like the Cosmic
Soul, is touched upon by pretty much everybody, and which
seems to gain new significance under the light of recent
developments.
We will perhaps best approach it indirectly. You and I
enter the Metropolitan Museum from Fifth Avenue. I try to
turn to the right, but you say: ,'Nol Lefs go on and see
the Parthenon.,' I go with you to the model of the restoration, and say : '' Why, this is much more the Parthenon than
the ruins on the Acropolis,'* and you answer: ,'Oh, if we
could only have seen the real onef I suggest: ,If you're
so much devoted to it, why don't you devote some of your
oppressive wealth to having it restored on the spot? Perhaps
the Greek government would be happy to have you." And
you, being of rather a romantic turn, object: ''But that
wouldn't be the Parthenon." I ask: "Why not? Couldn't
you leave all thafs there now, to keep up the associations ? "
You say : *' Perhaps, but the real architect couldn't superintend it." I answer : '' If that counts, there's hardly a cathedral in Europe that lofty souls like yours have any right to
gush over: for there's hardly one that was finished in the
Ufetime of the architect, or within that of anybody who ever
saw him. On the same principle, Beethoven's last quartets,
regarded by many connoisseurs as the greatest music in the
world, are not the real thing : for he never heard them played :
he composed them after he was deaf. And yet so far wrong
is your contention that the work is not complete unless its
creator supervises its production, that Beethoven's deafness
is r,arded by some as having Ittl
been a prerequisite of that great
322
The Idea
[Bk. II, Pt IV
muBic: it is donbted if his inspirations conld have been so
wonderf iQ if they had been interrupted by any external sounds.
Observe, too, please, in this connection, that, as there can be
an indefinite number of legitimate copies of the music, or
renderings of it, it seems reasonable tiiat there could be as
many legitimate Parthenons.'*
,, The architect's plan, then," you suggest, , must be the
real thing/'
,* In the hands of the workmen,'' I answer, ,* there were a
dozen copies of it, and possibly the original draft itself. Is
any one of them more ,the real thing' than the other? Or
would the first draft be more 'the real thing' than any
other? The 'real thing,' then, as you have probably anticipated, is 'the temple not built with hands' — the Idea in
the mind of the genius: the architect's plan, like the composer's notes or the poefs writing, is merely an expression
of it; and any one of the three can be read from the paper
and received by another mind, without marble, or musical
instrument, or speech."
Ideas are the nearest to permanent of human productions*
Buildings crumble, men die, all portraits of them vanish ; still
the Ideas of them seem indestructible. The Idea of St. Mark's
Campanile has just been expressed again after what some
would presume to call " the real thing " fell. The Iliad was
not in writing: it was merely given to the air by the poefs
voice, and yet it outlasts Greece and Borne; and many a little
poem survives, fresh and perfect, while the Pyramids crumble.
The streams of force and matter that built up the bodies of
generations pass on as their works decay, while the streams
of mind going through the same bodies build Ideas that do
not die. They live not only in the minds and records of succeeding generations, but as the pervasiveness of mind seems
unlimited, they seem also to survive in the Cosmos independently ofthe generations of men.
When, as in dreams and trances, we are not occupied with
the phenomena called the material world, copies of the Ideas
come in upon us from unlimited distances in time and space.
Sometimes the artist draws them, just as the architect's assistants do ; or as some artist, thousands of years after the architect is dead, extracts his Idea from the ruins or some other
Ch. XXIII]
Plato on The Idea
823
xnanifestation. William Blake, as he happens to be both seer
and artist, sees and reproduces any number of strange people
and things from ancient or distant environments; and with
such yraisemblance that it is hard, and probably unnecessary,
to believe that the originals never had ', material " form. And
in dreams we all of ns see similar things, both clearly and,
jumbled up. ', See *, is a limited and inaccurate term. Our
senses are of course mere machines for doing what some of us,
in some conditions, can do a great deal better without theuL
This generalization goes even so far as our muscles. Under
some circumstances, just as the telepsychic genius has no need
of senses, the telekinetic genius has no need of muscles. Thus
we get a glimpse of what seems to be a soul without the need of
a body. And yet we get no glimpse of any way in which that
soul could have been developed without a body. We do get
a glimpse, however, of its ultimately, after being developed,
getting along without a body; and in the apparent relations
of the individual soul with the cosmic soul, we get a glimpse
of how.
The foreshadowing of this set of notions in Plato is probably
the nearest distinct of those heretofore presented. As dug
out by Weber (I am through digging in Plato, for myself or
even for my readers), it relates to at least two distinct things
— one, abstract or generalized ideas — ,beauiy, strength, wisdom,
as distinguished from beautiful, strong, and wise persons;
the other nearly what I have tried to express: he says, for
instance (or Weber says for him, op. cit, 84) :
"The Ideas are the models or the originals, and the natural
beings or the individuals are the copies. ... They are the
thoughts of Ood, which no human intelligence can wholly reproduce, but which are none the less real, absolutely reaL''
But he goes on {op. cU., p. 84) :
, Now, every beautiful object, be it a man or a statue, an act
or an individual, is doomed to destruction and oblivion; hoauiif
in itself is imperishable."
v
Now I have tried to clarify an impression not merely that
generalities are indestructible (as they can be in a succession
of particulars even if the particulars be perishable in detail),
but that behind each particular thing is an individual Idea—
824
The Idea
[Bk. U, Pt lY
may I say a concrete Idea? — ,which ia indestnictible; and that
all ibdngs which appeal to the aenaes are merely copies of
the Idea which transcends the senses — ,that this is true even
of onr bodies, and that when they are gone the Idea sur*
vives.
Wdber says of this conception as expressed by Plato
(pp. 85-6) :
"To sum up: (1) The Ideas are real heinge; (2) the Ideas
are mare real than the objects of sense; (8) the Ideas are the
only true realities; the objects of sense possess a merely borrowed existence, a reality which they receiye from the Ideas.
The Ideas are the eternal patterns {fcapaMyfura) after which
tiie things of sense are made; the latter are ti, images {AduiXa\
the imitations, the imperfect copies («,ioi£,Mmi, fufi,eett). The
entire sensible world is nothing but a symbol, an allegory, or
a figure of speech. The meaning, the Idea expressed by the
thing, alone concerns the philosopher. His interest in the sensible world is like our interest in the portrait of a friend of
whose living presence we are deprired.
*' The world of sense is the copy of the world of Ideas; and
conversely the world of Ideas resembles its image. Parmenides,
182; Tim(BU$,4S/*
Not only do Ideas seem stored up somewhere independently
of human minds, but are there not indications that Ideas are
produced there — ,that there are possible sources of all the
ideas which reach us, even those of us who cannot express
them ? As one such, I know that, as I shall particularize later,
I have seen things in my dreams superior to any that human
art has yet accomplished, and so, I presume, have others.
Nay, we all know that each supreme work of art is a presenta*
iion of such an Idea, whether it came in an ordinary dream
or in a waking inspiration. But of those who have thus expressed any work, I have never met the recorded experience
{pace Foe's doubtful account of "The Haven '*) of one who
claims to have created it himself. On the contrary, they are all
eager to claim that they were , inspired ', by the muse or the
god or the daimone— whateyer anthropomorphic character
they may have given to the power not themselves. If asked
if they are proud of their work, fhey conrey as best thej can
the feeling that they are proud of being so constituted as to
be— of being selected to be — ,the mediums of their inspirations from their respectiye divinities.
Ch. XXni]
Inspif,ionj Subliminal Self, Cosmic Bovl
825
Now Dn Prel, MyeiB, and their school want to dethrone
those old diyinities, and depriye the artist of his claim to be
the agent of a higher power; and so have provided him with
their ,'subliminal self/' which throws out these splendid
things as a spring throws water — a consciousness of his own —
he does it himself after aU; but they haven't told us where
are the headwaters of the spring.
I suspect both sides are right, as they are in so many worldold battles. The artist is inspired by the god, and the god —
the cosmic soul — ,is his subliminal consciousness, as the cosmic
force is the motive power of his heart You may not understand how it is so (I certainly do not), but while you can
begin by thinking of the man and the cosmic power separately,
you can no more round out a conception of either without
including the other than you can round out a conception of
the voluntary nervous system through which man acts, without
including the involuntary nervous system through which the
cosmos supplies man the capacity to act In tiiis unity of
'diversity, independence with dependence, free will linked to
another will, , Behold 1 I show you a mystery.'' This is of
course as true as it was of Paul's. But how should it be
other than a mystery? These things are on the borderland
of our knowledge, where the best we can do is to fumble
in the dark, unless, as some of the wisest think, it were still
better to keep out of the dark altogether. But some others
of the wisest think that we can learn very valuable things there
-,perhaps strike an electric switch : so let us fumble a little
farther.
Every creation of man — ,from tool to temple — has behind
it an Idea — the man's Idea furnished him by the Ood. An
object of Nature expresses ''God's" Idea direct, not communicated through man. In a portrait, it is expressed in
another form by man, as the builder expresses the architect's
idea. But back of each object of art or Nature, there lies the
Idea. (See p. 487, 1. 8 from bottooL)
Now how about us? Some of us are pretty fine creations—
a few of us more beautiful, more august, than any works of
art. Was there an " Idea " — ,a " plan " — ,behind the creation
of each one of us? In what mind? Certainly not in the
326
The Idea
[Bk. II, Pt IV
mind of either parent: neither of them had a definite idea
of what one of us would be like, beyond a possible remote
composite of botiii of them : anything like a prophetic sketch
or '' plan " of one of us in their min, was out of the questioB.
But I hope I am not too wild in suggesting that somehow the
Idea of each one of us got into the universe — ,perhaps before
the spermatozoon entered the ovum, perhaps only as the in*
dividual was developed.
Is it unreasonable, then, to fancy that the Idea of each
of us was and is in the Cosmic Mind, and just as the Parthenon in stone is but one copy of the architect's Idea, so, from
the ', Idea '' of one of us in the Cosmic Mind is constructed
the copy we know in carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, hydrogen,
iron, and a few other elements? That copy resists pressure
and, varying a good deal in dimensions and details, sometimes
abides a hundred years. It assimilates food, wastes tissues,
sees, hears, thinks, feels, talks, and interchanges thoughts and
feelings, and is in all ways apparent to our waking senses.
Those Ideas have also been expressed in various other copies—
descriptions, photographs, paintings, statues — as well as in
our bodies and souls themselves.
Then outside of our ordinary waking senses, in vision,
dream, trance, still other copies are presented. These other
copies do not abide with us long, though they return, and they
do think, feel, talk, weep, laugh, interchange thoughts and
feeliDgs, resist pressure, and perform other physical functions,
certainly the most intense of them, though they may not have
been observed to perform all. Thus the expressions of an Idea
are both physical and psychical. Apparently the more important expression is the psychic — so important that even while
the two are together, from Homer down to Lincoln, the physical one sometimes appears to have been only ancillary —
evolved only that it might promote the evolution of the other.
The physical expression in time disappears before our eyes.
The Idea on its psychic side (assuming its existence and
reasoning from the Ideas of other things) seems somehow not
subject to death, and we often act on assumptions possibly
no wilder than that it may find farther expression after the
death of the copy we call the body.
As the Idea behind the San Marco Campanile was capable
CL XXin]
The Expression Goes, The Idea Abides < 327
of resarrection thotigh the brickB fdl, so, we have some faint
OTidence, abide the Ideas behind our visible frames, though
their atoms disint,ate ; and so, apparently much more probably, abide the Ideas oonstitating our psychic indiyidnalities.
They keep bobbing np it the most unexpected and inexhanstible ways from what has been called the subliminal soul,
and what some of ns prefer to call the cosmic soul. They
come np in ordinary dreams. and in all sorts of visions; come
up in copies which closely duplicate the familiar ', living ',
body and '' living ', soul, and have sometimes made communications later demonstrated to have been ''true,'' and
sometimes more important than anything in our waking life.
We know as a fact that these dream copies have apparently
been expressed over and over again, often very strikingly,
through many '' mediums,'' and there would be no little justification for calling gratuitous the efforts to make them out
anything less than copies. The dream copies as presented by
the mediums, are not always as complete or as convincing as
the copy our faculties have enabled us to know during ordinary
life, or as the copies in our own dreams. But there is a strong
presumption that the expressions through the mediums may
not be convincing because the method of expression is poor.
We know, too, that this later sort of expression is very recent,
and, like many faculties under evolution, unaccountably sporadic, and appears to be as yet in a stage very elementary
compared with a possible later one.
Now with these demonstrations, such as they are, to our
presumably elementary apprehension, such as it is, of the survival of the Idea, and of its various presentations, is it wildly
extravagant to suppose that the Idea really does survive death
in new expressions — new bodies even, to which the one with
which we are familiar may be merely preliminary and rudimentary ?
This is not sheer guesswork built up on a jumble of words
which in themselves are but professions of ignorance : it is a
tentative interpretation of fads, which we have got to interpret somehow, or resign the right and responsibility to use
our intellects. It may be all wrong, but doesn't it seem to
be in a direction where truth may ultimately appear more
clearly?
328
The Idea
[Bk. II, Pi lY
I haye deliberately put some chapters of guesswork regarding these psychic mysteries right in the midst of the
phenomena to which the guesses apply, instead of putting
them before all the phenomena as deductions for the phenomena to yerify; or after them all, as inductions which the
phenomena suggest. The inconsistency has been partly due
to the matter being so tangled up that it is hard to discuss
any without being led to discuss more, but partly because in
such uncertain studies it is 'well, after enough facts haye been
giyen to justify any guesses, to make the guesses as aids to the
mere exposition of the remaining facts, not to speak of their
interpretation.
We will now go on to the partly anticipated phenomena.
CHAPTEB
XXIV
P0SSBS8I0N(r) IN QBKERAL
Wb now come to the phenomena which bring the qnestion
of the Cosmic Inflow closer than do any others, and which,
of all the field we are exploring (and some would think of
all hmnan annals), are probably the most interesting and the
most puzzling. They are perhaps the only phenomena whose
claims to interpretation by the spiritistic hypothesis are admitted by the weight of authority to be worthy of consideration.
Nearly all such telepsychoses as have been recounted here
take place while the sensitive is in possession of his usual
faculties, and are described or expressed by the medium voluntarily. But there are telepsychoses which are expressed in*
voluntarily and unconsciously. Between these two classes of
expressions there is of course (as always between associated
groups) a transition group. In fact conformably with the in-1
structive gradualness of the transitions in Nature to which I \
have alluded so often, we find all degrees of such phenomena, ,
from the simplest telepathy to the inspiration which leads
almost everybody occasionally, without conscious efFort, to
,surpass himself; to that which sets ''the poefs eye in a
fine frenzy rolling''; to that which sets Mrs. Verrall, while
otherwise perfectly conscious, to writing intelligent things
she does not intend; to that which sets Stainton Moses and
Mrs. Piper similarly writing while their intelligence is otherwise engaged — ,perhaps in studying a profound treatise or
something else utterly at variance with the written topics ; to
that which makes Mrs. Holland occasionally write in trance,
and Mrs. Piper and Mrs. Thompson always ; and so by degrees
to the apparently complete '' Possession,'' where the medium's
soul appears to abandon the body and leave it at the service of
the hypoihetical souls who use it to express themselves.
When the medium's soul is thus apparoitly absent, the
vital processes still continue: they are carried on through
330
Pos8e8S%on(f) in Qenerdl
[Bk. H, Pt IV
the sympathetiG nerve and its oonnectioiib ; wliile the brain —
with all thought, feeling, and volimtary movement — ,is apparently abandoned by the original personality, and apparently
open to use of other personalities.
These individualities, in vocabulary, inflection, and, sometimes, gesture, appear as boys and girls, adults and old
people, men and women; Americans, Indians, English, French,
Hawaiians, Chinese; schoolboys, pedagogues, scholars, philosophers, prize-fighters, butchers, bakers, and candlestick-makers.
All talk through the medium with a dramatic verisimilitude
that, while perhaps never reaching the impressiveness or
humor of the great dramatists, seems, in varie, and faithfulness to nature, almost, if not quite, to surpass them all.
The ways of accounting for tiiese strange phenomena we
will consider incidentally in connection with the phenomena
themselves, and systematically after we have been over as
full accounts of them as space permits.
Many students believe that the sairdisani other souls are
simply dissociated personalities of the medium, but at least
for purposes of study, we must discriminate Possession from
Dissociation, and yet the difference between them, like so
many differences we have noted, is so gradual that it is hard
to tell where one ceases and the other begins. Perhaps the
best distinction is that where a person thinks and acts unlike
, thonself ,'' without claiming to be any other specific person
who has existed, we consider the new personality simply dissociated— ,we might almost say — differentiated from the old.
This is generally the result of accident or disease. But when
the new personality appears without any occasion from accident or disease, and claims to be somebody that has existed in
another body, and talks and acts, and especially shows exceptional knowledge, as if it had so existed, some commentators
say, often provisionally, that the new body is ', possessed '' by
the soul that formerly , possessed " the other body.
But this classification, like all others, is defective : for there
are many insane persons who believe themselves to be somebody else— some of them always, some only occasionally.
But they do not show enough of ,e foregoing requirements
to fool anybody, and have not noticeably displayed mediumistic
phenomena.
Ch. XXIY]
Acted Dreams.
Automatiem
831
On reading Ihe proofs, I see that it will probably be well,
without disturbing the preceding two paragraphs, to state here,
as a possible clue through the labyrinth we are approaching,
the conclusion I have reached (tentatively: that's as far as
it is yet time to go) that the phenomena of apparent possession result from the medium's identifying ,* thonself '' with,
and so acting out, characters that are telepathically presented
in dreams, possibly by the sitter, possibly by other incarnate
intelligence, possibly by postcamate intelligence, possibly by
any two of those things, or by all. This cryptic utterance
comes from so many considerations that to make it clearer by
giving them, especially with their illustrations, would be virtually to give the rest of the book: so we may as well resume
that process.
It seems a corollary from the law of evolution that there
should always be not only a few men vastly greater than the
rest, but also that when new and strange faculties appear, they
should appear only in a few people. Dreams we all have, somnambulism not so many have, and hypnotism and trance we
have long known occasionally; but telepathy and ',medium*
ship'' and ,'possession,'' all tiiree seem to be comparativdy
rare wonders of yesterday, though of course some scholars
think they have found evidence of them, as of everything
else, in remote antiquity.
We shall find in all these phenomena many traits in common* Unfortunately, it eeems impossible to give the phenomena names which do not imply opinions ; and this while
the weight of judgment appears to be that the time for
opinions is not yet come. A prominent alternate name for
''possession" is automatism, and Myers has so established
it that some objections to it seem worth considering.
Inanimate matter is generally moved by the immediate
application of outside force. When the force is stored up
within the matter, so that when it is released the matter
appears to be self-moving, the motion is called automatic.
Myers applies the term to all superusual' experience and
function in the broadest sense, covering all superusual sensation, waking and sleeping; but wh, he applied the term
automatic to the writfiig and speaking and gesticulating of
832
Pouemon(f) in Oenerdl
[Bk. II, Pt IV
the sensitiTeB; he supported the thesiB that those acts vere
not performed by the coDsdoasnesses of the mediums, bat
by consciousness outside ; while he called the phenomena automatic he strove with all his strength to prove them heteromatic, and produced in the reader's apprehension— mine, at
least— a good deal of wobbling.
To one who has groped much among these uncertainties
there can be no wonder that a man of even Myers's ability
sometimes fell into an inconsistent,, especially as he naturally
used the language as he found it And yet in this case it
seems a little strsnge that, with his facility in coining words,
he rested content with the old one.
His definition of automatism is {Human Penonaiity, I,
222):
" The products of inner vision or inner audition externalised
into quasi-percepts, — these form what I term iensory auton,
aiisfM. The messages conveyed by movements of limbs or
hand or tongue, initiated by an inner motor impulse beyond
the conscious will — ,these are what I term motor automatUmo.
And I claim that when all these are surveyed together their
essential analogy will be recognijsed hmeath much diversity of
form. They will be seen to be messages from the subliminal
to tbe supraliminal self; endeavors— conscious or unconscious
-—of submerged tracts of our personality to present to ordinary
waking thought fragments of a knowledge which no ordinaiy
waking thought could attain.''
Here he clearly restricts the whole business to the individual soul: no sign yet of his attributing any of it, as he
does later, to other intelligences acting through the organism
instead of its usual soul.
But he goes on (p. 223) to say tiiat:
''All human terrene faculty will be in this view simply a
selection from faculty existing in the metetherial world; such
part of that antecedent, even if not individualized, facidty as
may be expressible through each several human organism."
"Faculty existing in the metetherial world " seems a pretty
good expression for Cosmic Soul.
Furthermore, on page 218, under Hypnotism, he had said :
" There may be a truth — deeper than,we can at this moment
stay to discuss — ,in many subjective experiences of poets, philo-
CL XXIV]
Mym
on the Maethmal World
833
sophers, mystics, saints. And if their sense of inflowing and
indwelling life indeed be true; — if the subliminal uprushes
which renew and illumine them are fed in reality from some
metetherial environment; — ,then a similar influence may by
analogy eidst and be recognisable along the whole gamut of
psychophysical phenomena
*, The nascent life of each of us is perhaps a fresh draft,—
the continued life is an ever-yarying draft, — ,upon the cosmic
energy. In that enrironing energy — call it by what name we
will — ,we live and move and have our being; and it may well
be that certain dispositions of mind, certain phases of personality» may draw in for the moment from that energy a fuller
vitdizing stream.''
He closes the chapter with:
,,Let men realize that. ..their own spirits are co-operative
elements in the cosmic evolution, are part and parcel of the
ultimate vitalizing Power.''
Myers wrote these passages in speculation on the source
of the curative power of hypnotismy and they seem to indicate the conviction I have already expressed that hypnotism opens the soul to influxes from a cosmic reservoir of
knowledge and will, just as other agencies open the blood
and nerves to influxes from the cosmic store of matter and
force. This is a broader view than the exclusively individual
one of the subliminal self. Though not without vagueness and
paradox, it certainly seems pointed to by the facts ; it offers
an explanation where ''subliminal self" is but a name; and
is at least implied, even when terminologically ignored, by
almost every writer on the subject Our supraliminal souls
are individual, but they blend more or less with our subliminal
souls, which, as I fear I am wearying you by contending,
seem to be such inflows from a cosmic soul as our individual
make-ups permit.
We cannot draw a definite line between the supraliminal
and the subliminal, any more than we can between any other
related categories, and we are hardly to be charged with
inconsistency if, in treating of one aspect of soul, we omit,
or fail, to keep the other aspects equally in front. But does
it not seem probable that we will be on a more helpful way
to the truth if, in treating the subliminal aspect, we keep as
far as we can from confining it to the personal character-
334
Po8se88%on(f) in General
[BL II, Pi lY
ifltics, and keep prominent, as far as we can, the cosmic
characteristics? Tme it seems to be that strictly personal
characteristics determine the inflow of the cosmic element,
but as we look out through the channels open in the personality, we catch glimpses of that to which we can see no
limit in content or time, and to which we give the names that
only express our incapacity — infinite and eternal.
But although Myers so clearly went for his automatism
outside of the purposeful indiyidual, and into a cosmic inflow, later, as we shall have abundant occasion to see, he
absolutely leaves the cosmic inflow, and yet does not return
to the subliminal individual soul of his '' automatist,'' but
attributes the '' messages'' to individual souls which have
left the body, and this he does without any insistent recurrence to his implied suggestion that both are different aspects
of the same thing — the individual souls as parts of the cosmic
soul.
This all seems very inconsistent, and it is very inconsistent
unless the postcarnate souls and the automatisms soul are all
regarded as parts of the cosmic soul. But for ''subliminal
self* substitute "cosmic soul," or, more definitely, "cosmic
inflow,'' and we have a hypothesis consistent with itself so
far as one in these vague regions can be.
But I don't recall Myers ever being consistent enough to
perform that very simple feat of substitution; and if was
avoided with what seemed to me almost fatuous care by Da
Prel, an immediate forerunner in Fechner's doctrine of the
subliminal self, who, for all I know, may have invented the
name. Du Prel's motive, however, was plain enough: he
wrote in the days of the reaction against the old theologies,
begun by Darwin, Spencer, Huxley, and their fellow-laborers
on the Continent, and carried out on the Continent to such
extremes that Du Prel and many others would account for
a thing on any hypothesis, no matter how extravagant, rather
than on one involving an intelligent cause and regulator behind the phenomenal universe : apparently for fear that somebody might call it Ood. Man's was the highest intelligence
for which they would see any evidence, and they gave him a
"subliminal self" to account for any manifestations in or
through him which, a generation earlier, would have been
CL XXIY]
The Hypotheais of the Svblitnindl
385
called snperhiunan, and seem so to some of us in this genera*
tion.
Dn Prel was specially pnt to it to accotmt for the per*
Bonalities that oppose the self in dreams, and he fished
them out of his universal reservoir — ,,'the subliminal/' If
in a dream or trance an individuality leads you along some
ridgepole you never could have traversed alone, or solves some
problem beyond your powers, or even opposes you with some \I "ir
knock-down argument you never thought of, that other per«
sonality is simply your " divided self '* — according to Du Pre!
and his company; but according to some simpler souls, including mine, that other individuality is more nearly what
it appears to be — an independent inflow of the cosmic soul
into you. The modus operandi I don't attempt to explain,
but I'd rather attempt that than Du Prel's and Myers's job
of explaining the second personaUty as a divided part of the
first
Myers hung on to the hypothesis and the name for it, and
this he did after he had accepted the human personality's
survival of bodily death, and the cosmic soul; and he did so
much to popularize the individual subliminal hypothesis in
the English-speaking world, that he seemed to feel for it the
affection sometimes felt for an adopted child. If he had
risen so far beyond his partiality for his bantling just as it
was, as to persistently identify it with the cosmic inflow, he
would, if I mistake not, have avoided many inconsistencies
and have added materially to the unity of his work. Of
course in the present state of our knowledge this proposed
shape of the hypothesis would probably have run him into
other inconsistencies, as I am perfectly conscious that it is
running me; but I think it would still have left the balance
to the good, and have brought us a step nearer to correlating
the phenomena with established knowledge.
But in every one of the steps Myers certainly did go outside of the sensitive for his motive power. The operations
of the medium's brain, or hand, or tongue, or other members,
are apparently caused by an agency other than the consciousness which we ordinarily recognize as the specific human
being. That agency may be what is called the subliminal
consciousnesSi but the chief English-speaking apostle of the
336
Pos8m%M(f) in Oeneral [6k. 11, Ft IV
tenn, while lie bbjb it is that, defines thai into something
more. The agency may be some sort of a halfway cosmic
soul, as one individuality amusing itself by aping other individualities (not a very likely hypothesis) ; or it may be a
really cosmic soul acting in a genuine capacity not yet clearly
comprehensible— differentiating itself into each individual-—
thus becoming originator and sustainer of individual souls,
and, in some as yet mysterious way, identical with them.
Things seem to point this way, and Myers, apparently in
spite of himself, involuntarily kept admitting that they did.
I do not say that he was not justified in doing so, and
that the phenomena are really heteromatic, but if, like Myers,
I were fully confirmed in a belief in spiritism, I should say
so. Myers's inconsistency in using the word automatic when
he means heteromatic probably is due to his trying to ride two,
or rather three, horses. If all the phenomena are due to his
pet subliminal soul, and that is all shut up in the medium,
the proceedings are of course automatic. But once admit
telepathy, even from the sitter, not to speak of teloteropathy
from remote incarnate intelligences, and much less from discamate ones, and your automatism is gone. As the writings
profess to be heteromatic, and as the theory of the cosmic
inflow, which I tentatively accept, would make them heteromatic, Ishall call them heteromatic.
Between the holders of the hypothesis of the subliminal
self there is confusion and controversy. The spiritistic side,
led perhaps by Myers and adhered to by Hodgson, Lodge, and
others, claims that the medium's subliminal soul is a distinct
thing, and that there are other things equally distinct appearing as the souls of the '' possessors " of the medium, all of
which souls, they incidentally admit, may be inflows from
the cosmic soul.
The anti-spiritistic side, led perhaps by Podmore, admits
the subliminal soul, but as to the possessions being manifestations ofother souls, they are no sudi things, but mere processes
of the medium's subliminal soul — ,largely telepathic reflec*
tions from other incarnate souls. The dramatic quality of
these reflections, initiative, comment, repartee, discussion,
disagreement, even violent argument, expressions of satisfao-
Ch. XXIV]
Pei,pe aU Sides Carreet
837
tion and diflaatief action ranging all fbe way from joy to a
rage that smashes thing8---all this is left unaccounted
for.
.
There is a third gronp in the controyersy, led perhaps by I
James, which goes rery Uttle farther than to say: it is not '
yet time for an opinion.
And there is at least a fonrth position, thongh I hardly
see signs of its being occapied by a ''gronp/' which would
claim that there seem some gUmmerings of everybody being
right (as in most controyersies) in the direction of the
hypothesis, as yet very vague and paradoxical, that although
the individual soul is contained within the pretty definite
limits of its individuality, yet within those limits, it is a
portion — a sort of bay if you please, of the cosmic soul, and
is subject to occasional influxes or tides from the cosmic
soul in the shape of all sorts of inspirations (which turns the
fluid metaphor of a tide into a gaseous one), not only those
of music, poetry, hypothesis, eloquence, etc., but of all sorts
of. dreams and visions, normal or hypnotic, and '' possessions ',
of all degrees, from heteromatic writing up to entire apparent
substitution or at least predominance of a soul that, like the
minor inspirations or possessions, has drifted in from the
cosmic aggr,ate.
In writing this hypothesis I have been trammeled by the
inevitable behindhandedness of words in such connections,
and the most abstract words being, as we all know, metaphors
from material things. I am very conscious, too, that the
statement contains a luxuriant abundance of things already
said by others as well as myself, and I again crave your
patience for my repetitions. The conceptions are necessarily
too vague for definite statement once for all, and whether they
are anything more than mirages, and even if they are only
mirages, what they are can best be determined by approach*
ing them through all the avenues that may be found open.
Whether the ''possession'' is only apparent, or is partial,
or is complete, or is one at one tune and the others at other
times, is an open question. Apparently all three may occur
in the same sitting.
There is undoubtedly another soul than the medium's in-
838
Po$8€88ion(f) in Oenwal
[BL II, Pi IV
Tolved, but the method of its action upon him, perhaps we
ahall find, does not go so far as substitution for his souL
Mrs. Sidgvick very fully and ably argues this Yiew in
Pr. XV, but she pays so little attmtion to the dramatic
elements in the sittings — attributing them almost exclusively
to telepathy, even if from postcamate spirits, that the argu*
ment leaves my opinion in suspense, except so far as my
fumbling feeling about the Cosmic Soul sometimes seems
to render both telepathy and possession names for something
bigger.
Of course there may have been what we provisionally call
possession in many of the ph,iomena already given, especially
those under telepathy; but the indications of it are much
stronger in the set which we now approach — heteromatio
writing and dramatic impersonation. The ancients also associated the idea with dreams and the like, and we may yet
be brought back to a somewhat similar impression. I, for
one, have reached it already.
CHAPTEB
XXV
P08SB8SION(r) IK HETSROMATIO
WRITINa
On levisixig this chapter, I find it among the most imaatiafactory in the book, and my own work in it among its most
xmsatisfactory parts. Yet its relation to some of the least
unsatisfactory of later chapters, leads me to advise you, if
your patience is not yet exhausted, at least to skim through it.
Ever since there was writing, of course there has been
writing more or less *' inspired.'*
The capacity for it, as Dr. Crookes declares of the capacity
for telekinesis, seems to exist in some degree in eyerybody.
James says {Memories and Studies, pp. 199-200) :
, I have come to see in automatic writing one example of a
department of human activity as vast as it is enigmatic. Eveiy
sort of person is liable to it, or to something equivalent to it;
...our subconscious region seems, as a rule, to be dominated
either by a crazy ' will to makid-believe/ or by some curious ex*
temd force impelling us to personation. The first differenoe
between the psychical researcher and the inei,rt person is that
the former x,izes the commonness and typicality of the phenomenon here, while the latter, less informed, thinks it so rare
as to be unworthy of attention. I toish to go on record for the
commonness,
" The next thing I wish to go on record for is the presence,
in the midst of dl the humbug, of really supernormal hnouh,
/'
ledge.
Mahomet professed that the Eoran was entirely heteromatic from the Angel Gabriel.
Swedenborg was devoted mainly to science, and with great
success, until 1745, when he claimed that Ood appeared to
him and said: ,'I have chosen thee to imfold the spiritual
sense of the Holy Scripture. I will myself dictate to thee
what thou shalt write ', ; and surely from even the very un«
sympathetic point of view which I myself share, the writing
was a very extraordinary performance.
840
Po88e88ion(t) in Heteromatic Writing
[Bk. II, Pt IV
Blake, time and again, diaclaimed volantary authorship of
hia writings.
Accounts of several other heteromatic writers are given in
Miss Underhill's Mysticism and Psychology, pp. 78-80 :
" Madame Guyon states in her autobiography, that when she
was composing her works she would experience a sudden and
irresistible indination to take up her pen; though feeling wholly
incapable of literary composition, and not even knowing the
subject on which she would be impelled to write. If she resisted
this impulse it was at the cost of the most intense discomfort.
She woiild then begin to write with extraordinary swiftness;
j words, elaborate arguments, and appropriate quotations coming
; to her without reflection, and so quickly that one of her longest
I books was written in one and a half days.
"' In writing I saw that I was writing of things which I had
never seen: and during the time of this manifestation, I was
given light to perceive that I had in me treasures of knowledge
and understanding which I did not know that I possessed.'
*, Similar statements are made of St. Teresa, who declared that
in writing her books she was powerless to set down anything but
that which her Master put into her mind. So Bli,e said of
* Milton ' and ' Jerusalem,' * I have written the poems from im«
mediate dictation, twelve or sometimes twenty or thirty lines
at a time, without premeditation and even against my will. The
time it has taken in writing was thus rendered non-existent, and
an immense poem exists which seems to be the labor of a long
life, all produced without labor or study.'
*' There are, of course, extreme forms of that strange power
of automatic composition, in which words and characters arrive
and arrange themselves in defiance of their authors' will, of
which most poets and novelists possess a trace
"
As already indicated, apparent possession to the extent of
heteromatic writing was manifested in America bj, among
others, Tuttle, Davis, and Cdville. Foster never did it to
any extent.
Here is a case from Stillman, through a friend whom he
calls Miss A. {op. cit, 1, 190-1) :
"After having been for some time troubled by the rappings
she began to fed involuntary motions in her right hand whidi
increased to constantly recurring violent exercise of the muscles,
when it occurred to her from the character of the motions that
the hand wanted a pencil to write and she laid paper and a
pendl on the table. Her hand then took possession of the
pencil and began to scrawl aimlessly over the paper until, after
the interval of many days, the agency seemed to have sufficient
Ch. XXY] SiUlman's Miss A. SUUnton Mom
841
control over the nrascles to fonn legible letters. ... The hand
wrote legibly and neatly in r,ly to mental, i.e., unspoken qnes*
tions, she having no control of the muscles so long as the
' influence ' ., . chose to use it. She knew what was written only
when the writing was finished and she read it, as we did; and
the writing was . . . quite as regular and well formed when her
eyes were bandaged. ... As a further test of the involuntary
character of this we . • . tried her with . . . my brother talking with her from one side of the table, while she was writing
in reply to my mental questions on the other.
'*
Under these circumstances she wrote for us the replies in conversations with what purported to be the spirits
of three deceased relatives ... and the handwriting of the...
series of communications was a better imitation of their writing
than I, knowing it, could have produced. That of my sister*
in-law... my brother recognized ... as that of his wife, but
that of our brother was a perfect reproduction down to the
smallest accidents, and that which was given as the responses
of my cousin equally so, and executed with a rapidity of which
I was incapable — ,a large scrawling hand, that of our brother
being of a character entirely opposed, slowly and laboriously
formed, with occasional omissions of the last line of a final n
quite common in his writing. The girl had never known either
of these relatives.''
Stainton Moses was about the earliest of the heteromatic
writers who have come under modem scientific criticism.
The writing began in ISTS, nine jears before the foundation
of the S. P. S.9 so, though none of it is given before Vol. YIII,
chronologically it properly comes before that from others
given in earlier volumes.
In addition to the diary-like account of his stances, upon
which we have already drawn, he left twenty-four note*
books of automatic writing, which are treated by Myers in
Pr. VIII, IX, XL
He says (Pr. XI, 64) :
''These automatic messages were almost wholly written by
Mr. Moses's own hand while he was in a normal waking state.
The exceptions are of two kinds. (1) There is one long pa»>
sage . . . alleged by Mr. Moses to have been written by himself
while in a state of trance. (2) There are, here and there, a few
words alleged to be in ' direct writing ';— written, that is to say,
by invisible hands, but in Mr. Moses's presence
''Putting these exceptional instances aside, we find that the
writings generally take the form of a dialogiie, Mr. Moses
proposing a question in his ordinary thick, black handwriting.
An answer is then generally, though not always, given; written
842
Pmm%(m(t) in Heieromaiic Writing [BL II, Ft IV
also by Mr. HoieSy and with the same pen, but in some one
of Tarions scripts which differ more or less widely from his
own."
And elsewhere (Pr. IX, 267-8) :
"Am 9L general mle the same alleged spirits both manifested
themselves by raps, &c.» at Mr. Moses's sittings with his friends,
and also wrote through his hand when he was alone. In tibia,
as in other respects, Mr. Moses's two series of sittings — ,when
alone and in company — were concordant, and, so to say, complementary;—explanations being given by the writing of what
had happened at the stances. When ' direct writing ' was given
at the stances, the handwriting of each alleged spirit was the
same as that which the same spirit was in the habit of em*
ploying in the automatic script. The claim to individuality
was thus in all cases decisively made. [And on p. 384.]
Each series presupposes and refers to the other. The tranoeaddresses given at the stances are continued by the messages
written in privacy. The phenomena of the slances are predicted in the automatic script [This suggests that Moses's
agency, involuntary perhaps, may have been behind both.
H.H.] and similar phenomena sometimes occur to Mr. Moses
when alone.''
(Page 255.) ,The 'controls' themselves are of various
types; and there is one rare 'control' C Magns ')... whose
utterances seem to me shifty and exaggerated, in a way very
common in automatic script, and who does apparently endorse
a complete impostor. The utterances of other 'controls' for
ibe most part reflect Mr. Moses's own opinions on other
mediums, or are sometimes more severe. [Page 257.] [There
are] spirits who give such names as Bector, Doctor, Theophilus, and, above all, Imperator. . . . The names which they
assert to have been theirs in earth-Uf e . . . are for the most
part both more illustrious and more remote. ... Mr. Moses
himself ... justly felt that the assumption of great names is
likely to diminish rather than to increase the weight of the
communication. . « • For a long while one of his main stumblingblodu lay in these lofty and unprovable claims. TTltimately
he came to believe even in these identities, on the general
ground that teachers who had given him so mimy proofs, both
of their power and of their serious interest in his welfare, were
not likely to have deceived him on such a point. But he did
not count upon a similar belief in others, and he expressly
wished to avoid seeming to claim special authority for the
"
teachings on the ground of their alleged authorship
We shall find later that after Moses's death his alleged
spirit gave an entirely different set of names for the earthly
originals of these alleged personalities.
Ch. XXY]
Mo$etr Writing CantroU
843
Moses says (Pr. XI, 6S-7) :
,*
I soon found that writing flowed more easily when
I used a book that was, penneated with the psychic aura; just
as raps come more easily on a table that has been frequently
used for the purpose, and as phenomena occur most readily in
the medium's own room."
One argument for this point of yiew could be found in the
well-known effect upon violins of much playing. But Mr.
Bartlett tells me that Foster had no experience parallel to
that of Moses in this regard. Moses continues :
*'
At first the writing was very small and irregular,
and it was necessary for me to write slowly and cautiously, and to watch the hand, following the lines with my
,ye; otherwise the message soon became incoherent, and the
result was mere scribble. In a short time, howerer, I found
that I could dispense with these precautions. The writing,
while becoming more and more minute, became at the same
time Tery regular and beautifully formed. As a specimen of
caligraphy some of the pages are exceedingly beautiful. The
answers to my questions (written at the top of the page) were
paragraphed and arranged as if for the press, and the name of
God was always written in capitals, and slowly, and, as it
seemed, reverentially. The subject-matter was always of a pure
and elevated character. . . . Throughout the whole of these written communications, extending in unbroken continuity to the
year 1880 [From 1878. H.H.], there is no flippant message,
no attempt at jest, no vulgarity or incongruity, no false or
misleading statement.
, The earliest communications were all written in the minute
characters that I have described, and were uniform in style
and in the signature, 'Doctor, the Teacher.' ••• Whenever and
wherever he wrote, his handwriting was unchanged, showing,
indeed, less change than my own does during the last decade.
The tricks of stvle remained the same, and there was in short
• sustained individuality throughout his messages. He is to
me an entity, a personality, a being with his own idio,ri,crasies
and characteristics quite as dearly defined as the human beings
with whom I come in contact
, After a time, oommtmioations came from other sources,
and these were distinguish, each by its own handwriting, and
by its own peculiarities of style and expression. ... I coidd tell
at once who was writing by the mere characteristics of the
caligraphy.''
Myers, having seen all the heteromatic writing, tacitly
endorses Moses's statements regarding its visible qualities.
344
Po88es8%on(f) in Heteromatie Writing
[Bk. II, Ft IV
'' By degrees I found that many flpirits who were onable to
influence my hand themselyea sought the aid of a spirit
'Rector' [a gentleman whom we shall meet often. H.H.],
who was apparently ahle to write more freely and with less
strain on me; for writing by a spirit unaccustomed to the
work was often incoherent, and alwsys resulted in a serious
drain upon my vital powers. They did not know how easily
the reserve of force was exhausted, and I suffered proportionately/'
Apparently in Moses's case it taxed some source of physical
energy which ordinary writing does not; and yet there are
several automatic writers who give no indication of tax. Even
Mrs. Piper, with the arduous phenomena attending her
trances, can hardly be said to '' suffer," unless the trance is
unduly prolonged.
Moses continues (Pr. XI, 67) :
''I had, obviously, no right to print that which concerned
others. Some of the most striking and impressive communications have thus been excluded.
•"
This is one of the great disadvantages regarding the verification ofall alleged communications through mediums : the
most evidential are those too personal to print.
Moses goes on :
''At first... even... the thoughts were not my thoughts.
Very soon the messages assumed a character of which I had
no doubt whatever the thought was opposed to my own. [We
have met and shall meet more of this-,enough to have seriously
disturbed my original conviction that tiie phenomena are prin*
cipally due to the sitter — or writer. H.H.] But I cultivated
the power of occupying my mind with other things during the
time that the writing was going on, and was able to read an
abstruse book, and follow out a line of dose reasoning while
tibe message was written with unbroken regularity. Messages
so written extended over many pages, and in their course there
is no correction, no fault in composition, and often a sustained
vigor and beau, of style.
''
In several cases, information of which I was assuredly
ignorant, clear, precise, and definite in form, susceptible irit led onwaids by any -surer way.''
After a good deal of reading and pondering, I find the proportion ofMoses's self in all tiiese proceedings looming in my
apprehension larger and larger. The benefits he got from
them look to me like that portion— how large a portion I am
not saying — of the benefits of prayer whiph are independent
of external results, and consist in the benefit to character from
intense absorption in an inspiring subject.
Here is a very suggestive interview between Moses and
« Imperator " (Pr. S. P. B. IX, 256-6). " Our friends " (line
3) refers to Sector, Doctor, and Prudens. ', John King " was
a '' spirit " that used to " materialize " at these stances. '' The
more material spirits/' " Eabbila," *' deceiving spirits " — ,isn't
all this the terminology of a set of ideas now outworn, which
would readily have obtained lodgment in Moses's mind during
his youth, and which tends to mark the whole passage as an
involuntary creation of his own?
',Q.— Was anyone present at the last stance at Mrs. F.'st
I was mudh impressed. A. — ,Yes. I was not present myself
but our friends were there. We do not advise you to rest much
on that Q. — ,Whatt I thought it conclusive proof. A. — You
must use your own judgment. We do but warn you to be careful. Q.— ,Do you mean to say it was not genuine? A.j— We
only urge you to be waiy. The manifestation was suspicious
and is not to be depended on. Q. — ,I am surprised. Who
writes! A.— It is I,— ,tl: S: D. [Imperator, Servus Dei.
H.H.1 Q. — ,Then you will tell me. Am I to understand that the
manifestation was not of a materialized form? A. — ,We do not
feel it part of our work to save you from the use of your own
powers. You are warned. Erorcise your observing faculties.
Q. — ,But I am bewildered. A. — ,It is needful for you to woric
through such experience. We may not save you from it Only
be waiy. Q. — ,I have long wanted information about those
foAns and havA had grave doubts, but I have believed in
J. K [John King]. A. — It is not our plan to give you any
further information now. We only say that what was then
presented was dubious. Q. — But I am to write about it. Was
it a materialisation at all ? Is tiiere such a thing ? A.— You will
Imow all in due time, but that was not reliable. We urge you
to be careful. You are always careful, as you think. But be
wary as to generalizing too rapidly. There is in the manifestation of the lower spirits much decq>tion, nrar can you ever be
CL XXY]
Moses Compared with Mrs. Piper
347
sure that such is not being practifled. It is so in all the manifestations inwhich the more material spirits are concemecL
Q. — ,You do not tell me much* A. — We do not purpose to do so.
We only warn. It was not reliable. Q. — ,But I had my hand
in J. £.'8 and the other on the medium's body. There could
be no deception there. A. — On the medium's boot» but not on
his body, as Kabbila informs us. But we will go no further.
It is not our habit to go so far. Seek not further information.
It will not be given. We do not wish to communicate at length
now. You haye done all that you are capable of doing. Q. —
But I want to ask further. Axe my senses good for nothing,
or am I so easily deceired? A. — ,No, no. Neither. But you
know nothing of occult influence when deoeiying spirits are
present. The mixture of the true and false would make it
impossible for you to arrire at fact. Hence have we warned
you so urgently to beware of the introduction of such. They
are fatal to our work. Cease now*
«tI:8:D.
,' t B. [Rector.] ""
And the general style of expression and the signatures I It
all looks to me as if Moses had unconsciously dramatized the
whole things and imagining St Faul, as later indicated, for
the rdle of "Imperator , had so much impressed himself as to
give his language the coloring it bears throughout, and, as
we shall see later, even to impress Hodgson and Mrs.
Piper.
But most of the dramatizations of Mrs. Piper are a different matter. There are scores, probably hundreds, of them to
each one of Moses', and they are generally of people who are
known to have been real, and who are recognizable by their
friends. Imperator and his companions may have been real
too, but there is little in the nature of proof, and we shall
later meet something much like disproof. But there are good
reasons for giving some account of them.
Here is a characteristic bit of Moses's experiences from his
diary, quoted in Pr. IX, 71 :
, On an evening in the month of January, 1874, 1 repeatedly
said to Mrs. Speer, 'Who is Emily O— *-? Her name keeps
sounding in my ear.' Mrs. Speer replied that she did not know
anyone of that name. ' Yes/ I said very emphatically, * there
is someone of that name passed over to die world of spirit.' . . •
It became a regular thing for us to receive a message giving
su(, facts as an obituary notice would contain. We therefore
348
Po8se88ion(r)%nEeier(maiicWriHng
[Bk. II, Pt IV
looked for them, and we found an announcement of the death
of 'Emily, widow of the late Oaptain C— — C- — * On a
aubsequent erening in the following year • . . ahe returned again.
Dr. Speer and I had gone out for a walk in the afternoon . . . and
at our stance in the evening came 'Emily 0— — C
.* I
inquired what brought her, and her answer was rapped out on
the table. 'You passed my grave.'... At this time I never
went near a graveyard but I attracted some spirit, identified
afterwards as one whose body lay there. I said, ' No, that is
impossible; we have been near no graveyard,' and Dr. Speer
confirmed my impression. The communication, however, was
persistent, and we agreed that we would take the same walk
the next day. We did so, and at a certain place I had an
impulse to climb up and look over a wall . . . and my eye fell
at once on the grave of 'Emily O
C— ,' and on the
dates and particulars given to us, all exactly accurate."
As Moses intimates, it became a regular thing for him
to have such experiences; several are given. They seem
to mean that among the other superstitions with which his
mind was saturated was that of spirits haunting their graves.
But then how about that strange power to see through a
stone wall, or at least feel through one, which perhaps we are
all going to admit before long that some folks have, and
perhaps not ? In addition he seems to show here the subliminal
memory which, without the operator's knowledge, retains all
sorts of things that come out in the conditions where that doall and bear-all which we call the subliminal self has full swing.
This unlimited capacity even in the most ordinary man who
dreams, seems to point to something not really in the ordinary
man, but something greater, outside him, and occasionally
working through him. Is it the Cosmic Soul?
V Here is another instance of Moses's overlooking points
obviously open to criticism— of the faith that swalloweth all
things. I am not sure Saint Paul included that characteristic, and I do not assert that Moses's faith may not have
been justified. He says (Pr. XI, 74) :
" There stands ... a short letter written automatically by me
in a peculiar archaic handwriting, phrased in a quaint oldfashioned spelling. It is signed with the name of the spirit . . .
who was a man of mark. ... I have since obtained a letter in
his handwriting, an old yellow document, preserved on account
of the autograph. The handwriting in my book is a fair imita*
CL XXV]
The Blanche Abercromhy Case
349 «
tion of this, the signature is exacts and the piece of old-fashioned spelling occurs exactly as it does in my book. This, it
was said, was purposely done as a point of evidence."
And similarly (p. 81) :
,,
I have had repeated eases of signatures which are
veritable facsimiles of those used by the persons in life; such,
for example, are ,e signatures of Beethoven, Mozart, and of
"
8wedenborg
This would be more remarkable if the signatures were those
of private persons, which he would have been less apt to have
seen and forgotten having seen, but retained in his ,,subliminal memory.', Even the '' archaic handwriting phrased
in a quaint old-fashioned spelling " may be similarly accounted
for. I don't say it must be.
Here is Myers's presentation (from Pr. XI, 96) of the celebrated (ifa thing can be celebrated among a small part of
the public) ''Blanche Abercromby'' case which he calls
''chances
in some which
wbjb the
of order
all, from
series its
of
havemost
beenremarkable
needful in
to the
establish
veracity. The spirit in question is that of a lady known to
me, whom Mr. Moses had met, I believe, once only, and whom
I shall call Blanche Abercrooiby.
, This lady died on a Sunday afternoon, about twenty years
ago, at a country house about two hundred miles from London.
Her death, which was regarded as an event of public interest,
was at once telegraphed to London, and appeared in Monday's
Times; but, of course, on Sunday evening no one in London,
save the Press and perhaps the immediate family, was cog,
nizant of the fact It will be seen that on that evening, near
midnight, a communication, purporting to come directly from
her, was made to Mr. Moses at his secluded lodgings in the
north of London. The identity was some days later corrobo*
rated by a few lines purporting to come directly from her, and
to be in her handwriting. There is no reason to suppose that
Mr. Moses had even seen this handwriting. His one known
meeting with this lady and her husband had been at a stance—
not, of course, of his own
''On receiving these messages Mr. Moses seems to have
mentioned them to no one, and simply gummed down the pages
in his MS. book, marking the book outside 'Private Matter.'
The book when placed in my hands was still thus gummed
down, although Mrs. Speer was cognizant of the communication* Iopened the pages . • • and was surprised to find a brief
850
Po88e8sion(t)inneterofnaticWrHi$tg
[Bk. II, Pt lY
ktter wliich, though oontaining no definite facta, was entire!,
characteristio of the Blanche Abercromby whom I had known.
... I happened to know a flon of hen eufficienlly well to be able
to ask his aid — and ... he lent me a letter for comparison. The
strong resemblance was at once obviouSy but the A of the surname was made in the letter in a way quite different from that
adopted in the automatic script. The son then allowed me
to study a long series of letters. . • . From these it appeared that
during the last year of her life she had tekesa to writing the
A (as her husband had always done) in the way in which it
was written in the automatic script*,
Here is the equally celebrated Garfield case, but there does
not exist, so far as I am aware, a word of testimony regarding it outside of Moaes,a diary, quoted in Pr. XI, 102:
"80, St. Peter's Bedford.
"September 20th, 1881, 10 A.H. — ,This morning, on awakiog
at 6.54 A.M., I was aware of a spirit who desired to communicate. Itturned out to be Mentor, with him B. Franklin, [Epes]
Sargent, and others. They told me in effect, 'The President
is gone. We were with him to the last. He died suddenly,
and all our efforts to keep him were unavailing. We labored
haid, for his life was of incalculable Talue to our country. He
would have done more to rescue it from shame than anyone
now left.' [Notwithstanding tiie universal sympathy and
cordial recognition of the President's many virtues, this opinion
was by no means universal among the best-informed Americans
''in the body'' at the time, whatever may have been the
opinion in the ''spirit world." H.H.] I asked why it had
been deemed necessary to come to me with the news. It was
replied that a period of great activity in the spirit world was
now being renewed, and that my sympathies with him and
with his work, and their own knowledge of me, had inclined
them to bring the news.. ..The evening pnpeT,,,lohe and
Echo— rwhich I purchased at 4.80 p.m., gave me the first mundane information of the event. It is now stated that he died
at 10.60 P.M., and on the 19th (yesterday). That in English
time is 8.50 a.m. of this day, 20di, or two hours before I woke
and got the message."
Here is the famous steam-roller incident, the most striking
evidential piece of Moses's ostensibly heteromatic writing, and
there is much of the same kind. This is taken from his
diary (Pr. XI, 42) :
"February 20th, 1874. ...The Baron had previously magnetized me very strongly, and had rendered me more than usually
dairvoyant
He also recognised a spirit in the room, but
Ck XXY]
The 8Uam BoVer Case
861
thought it was the spirit of a liying person. After dinner,
when we got upstairs, I felt an uncontrollable inclination to
write, and I a,ed the Baron to lay his hand upon my arm.
It began to moTe very soon, and I fell into a deep trance. As
far as I can gather from the witnesses, the hand then wrote
out, 'I killed myself to-day.' This was preceded by a very
rude drawing P' which resraobled a horse fastened to a kind
of oar or truck,'' Mr. Perdval says in The Spiriiualiet of
March 27th], and then 'Under steam-roller. Baker-street,
medium passed,' [i,B., W. S. li., H.H.] was written. At the
same time I spoke in the trance and rose and apparently
motioned something away, saying, ' Blood ' several times. This
was repeated, and the spirit asloBd for prayer. Mrs. G. said a
few words of prayer, and I came out of the trance at last,
feeling yery unwdl. On the following day Dr. Speer and I
walked down to Baker-street and asked the policeman on duly
if any accident had occurred there. He told us that a man
had been killed by tiie steam-roller at 9 a.h
•"
Here is Mr. Percival's comment on the same incident
(Pr. XI, 76-78) :
, Neither he nor anyone present was aware that a man had
committed suicide there in the morning by throwing himself
under a steam-roller. A brief notice of the occurrence appeared
in the Pall Mall Oazetie in the evening, but none of the party
had seen that paper. ... It is worth remarking that on the front
of the steam-roller which was used in Baker-street a horse is
represented in brass, and this, perhaps, may serve to account
for its appearance in the medium's drawing, where we should
certainly not expect to find it"
Myers says (Pr. XI, 92) :
"Further information about this suicide was given by entry,
February 28, 1874. It is remaricable that , Miss X,' a frequent
contributor to the Pr., then a child, was prevented by a monition
(as she informs me) from entering the street where the traces
of this incident were still visible."
', February 28rd, 1874
''Q. — ,I very much wish to communicate with Imperator.
[A long pause.] A. — , Whatever communication you hold must
be brid,. You are unfit to commune now.' Q. — ,That spirit
who conmmnicated at Mrs. Gregory's. [The place of the
steam-roller communication. H.H.] A. — ,,He was what he
said. It surprises us much that he should have been able to
attach himself to you. It was owing to your being near the
place where he met his bodily death. Do not direct your mind
strongly to the subject lest he vex you.' Q. — ,What does he
want! Can I help himt
A. — ,'He was wretched and sought
852
PossesnonffJinHeierafnaiicWrUing
[Bk. II, Pi. lY
help in ignorance. Prayer will aid him.' Q. — ,WeU, now, how
oomes it that he woke at onoe, and Sunshine [an allusion to
somebody who had died earlier. H.H.] sleeps still t A. — ,'He
has not yet slept. It will be well if he gets,''repose
tl-S-Dwhich will
enable him to progress hereafter.
"'xTheophaus.'"
The following bit of Moses's heteromatic writing refers
to the same incident (Pr. XI, 92f.) :
« February 24th, 1874.
Q. — ,Is the spirit unharmed by such a ghastly mutila**
tion as that?... A. — The spirit body is not to be harmed by
injury to* the body of earth otherwise than by the shock. And
the very shock might stir it rudely into action, and excite it
rather than lull it into quiescence. You are not now in a condition which enables us to go far into the subject. You have
far from recovered your spiritual tone as yet. Q. — ,Then that
spirit haunted the place of its departure? A. — ,It is usually
so that a spirit which has so rudely been seyered from the body
would hover near even for a long time after. Q. — ,How did it
come to pitch on me? A. — You passed by, and being in a
highly sensitive condition the disturbed spirit would naturally
|>e attracted to your sphere, even as iron is attracted to a powerful magnet. Moreover, when he came near he would be enabled
to discern you by the aura which surrounds you and which
is visible to the spirit eye. Light and attraction would both
enable him to recognice a channel of communication which he
longed fdr. You have been told before that an aura surrounds
all material objects, and that aura in the case of a medium is
recognizable afar off by spirit eyes. ...All spirits know this,
though all do not [suspicious grammar for such a very heavy
intellectual swell. H.H.] profoundly understand it. ...Hence
it is that the highly developed are more open to attack from
the grosser spirits. Q. — ,Then to spirit eye, the aura declares
the character? A. — ,To the more developed and progressed
[He has just intimated tiiat the spirit in question was anything
and henc
does so, The
H.H.] itsphe
progress
'developed and
out conc
spiriet
the
ible in our
res.
ealment is not possed/'
carries its character impressed on the very atmosphere it
breathes. This is a law of our being. Q. — ,Very beautiful, but
Tery awful! A. — ,Nay, friend, not so: but a great saf,ruard,
seeing that we know we are open to the gaze and the knowledge
of all. It is well that it should be so. We pause."
To me all this sort of thing seems to speak as plainly
of the imagination of the Anglican dergyman, as Judge Ed-
Ch. XXY ] Beading of Closed Books by " SpiriU ''
353
munds' yiBions speak of the imagination of a man of matterof-fact mind who, presumably, as such men often do, loved
such reading as the Apocalypse and Milton and Bunyan, and
who fell into the rdle of ,'medium."
But admitting all that, how account for the testimony of
the Speers and half a dozen other good people to Moses's tel«
ekinetic performance — ,his lights and music and materializations, and the true things he told which he could not haye
learned by any means we are as yet familiar with ?
The Beading of Closed BooTcs hy "Spirits »»
If the following is correctiy told it indicates something
more than telepathy. It is an alleged interriew, with the
answers automatically written, between Moses and some
,'spirit'' whose name is not given (Pr. S. P. B., XI, 106) :
" Q. — Can you read! A. — ,No, friend, I cannot, but Zacfaary
Oray can, and Hector. I am not able to materialize myself, or
to command the elements. Q. — ,Are either of those spirits
here! A. — ,I will bring one by and by. I will send. . . . Bector
is here. Q. — ,I am told you can read. Is that so? Can you
read a book! A. — [Spirit handwriting changed.] — ,Yes, friend,
with difficulty. Q. — ,Will you write for me the last line of the
first book of the JSneidt A. — ,Wait. — Omnxbxis errantsm ierris
ei fluctibus €Bsias. [This was right] Q. — Quite so. But I
might have known it. Can you go to the book-case, take the
last book but one on the second shelf, and read me the last
paragraph of the ninety-fourth page? I have not seen it, and
do not even know its name. A. — , I will curtly prove by a short
historical narrative, that popeiy is a novelty, and has gradually
arisen or grrown up since the primitive and pure time of Christianity, not only since the apostolic age, but even since the
lamentable union of kirk and the state by Constantine.' [The
book on examination proved to be a queer one called Boget,s
Aniipopopriesiian, an attempt to liberate and purify Christian"
ity from Popery, Politikirhality, and Priestrtde, The extract
given above was accurate, but die word ' narrative ' substituted
for ' account.'] Q. — ,How came I to pitch upon so appropriate
a sentence! A. — ,I know not, my friend. It was by coincidence. The word was changed by error. I knew it when it
was done, but would not change. Q. — ,How do you readt You
wrote more slowly, and by fits and starts. A. — I wrote what
I remembered, and then I went for more. It is a special effort
to read, and useful only as a test. Your friend was right last
night; we can read, but only when conditions are very good.
354
Po88es9ion(t) in Heteromaiic Writing
[Bk. II, Pt IV
We will read onoe again, and write and then impieBs yon of
the bode: — ,'Pope is the last great writer of that school of
poetry, the poetry of the inteUect, or rather of the intellect
mingled with the fancy.' That is truly written. Go and take
the eleventh book on the same shelf. [I took a book called
Poetry, Bomance, and Rketoric.} It will open at the page for
you. Take it and read, and recognize our power, and the per*
mission which the great and good Qod gives us, to show you
of our power over matter. To Him be glory. Amen. [The
book opened at page 145, and there was the quotation perfectly
true. I had not seen the book before: certainly had no idea dE
its contents] [These books were in Dr. Spoor's library. —
F. W. H. M.] **
Here is the last veridical heteromatism quoted from Moses
in the Pr. S. P. B. It is in XI, 103. Mrs. Speer writes:
,Dr. Speer died February 9th, 1889, and shortly after his
death Mr. Moses received from him a remarkable proof of
identity, of. which he wrote me an account at the time
,'Mr. S. M. came one Sunday to dine with us. He looked
strange and remarked to me, , I have seen your husband again,
and ih sent you a message which I do not understand.' He
seemed troubled, and I saw he was unable to take any dinner.
Suddenly he took out his pocket-book and rapidly wrote something in one of the sheets, tore it out, and handed it to me,
saying, ' Can you make anything out of this f ' I saw a message
written 'Tell dearest
all's well.* The word omitted was
a pet name he often called me when alone. I think no one
had ever heard it, and I am quite sure Mr. Moses never had.
The name is too absurd to print, as pet names often are
"
Now to sum up Moses. The following case was not by
automatic writing, but by raps. I give it because of its
instructiveness regarding Moses's mental make-up. He says
(Pr. XI, 72) :
''Perhaps I may here mention a case in which I endeavored
to mislead a communicating spirit but without any success.
If there be truth in the allegations of the too-clever people that
constitute the Society for Psychical Besearch [Moses resigned
in 1886, disgusted because his associates would not swallow
everything that he would. H.H.] there should have been conveyed from my brain to that of the impersonal entity with
which I communicated the falsity I had fabricated. [This is
a sheer Mosesism, see below. H.H.] There came a spirit
who represented herself to be my grandmother. ... I then sisked
if she remembered me as a child. She did. I proceeded to
detail two imaginary incidents sudi as might occur in a child's
CL XXY]
Defects of the Btibliminal Theory
356
life. I did it so naturally that my friends were completely
deceived. ••• Not so, however, my ,Intelligent Operator at the
other end of the line.' She ref irsed altogether to assent to my
story. She stopped me by a simple remark that she remembered
nothing of the sort. ... I certainly rose from the table convinced
that I had been tidking to a person that desired to tell the
truth, and that was extremely careful to be exact in statement."
If the spirit was an echo of Moses's self, of course it would
not echo what Moses knew to be false (except so far as some
folks delight in what is false, which apparently Moses did
not). But assuming it to be an echo, the dramatic character of the responses would remain to be accounted for.
Yet even that would not seem difficult to anybody who has
successfully written dialogue. Such a person knows that, in
such a mind, thoughts readily take the shape of dialogue and
the dramatic tinge naturally resulting. But admitting that,
we still have to account for the fact that these dramatic
impersonations often appear in the automatic writing and
trance utterances of people who never show any dramatic
power in the ways we consider normal; and then of course the
difficulty, with difficulties generally, is pitchforked on to "the
subliminal self." This has been done until, to at least my
perhaps irreverent imagination, the strictly individual subliminal self is beginning to look like a joke. And yet the
readiness of so many intelligent people to attribute everything' superusual
it isanone
of manyof circumstances
are making
it loomto into
immensity
which perhaps that
we
have had some glimpse, but of which their imaginations do
not yet all seem to have caught the significance.
All this carries instruction regarding the queer intellect
of Mose9 — an intellect that could assume that the falsity
would be conveyed, but that the telepathy would stop at the
convenient point of not conveying the fact that it was a
falsity; and an intellect that could utterly ignore so obvious
a reflection from himself, and attribute the phenomena entirely to another intelligence. This last point, however, may
not be fairly open to criticism regarding the mind of a firm
believer: the criticism, if directed at all, should be directed
to the belief.
There is a degree of ingenuousness in the following sentence which, especially when associated with things that have
356
Possessionft) in Heterofnaiic Writing
[Bk. II, Pi lY
been noted before, indines me to quote it as an element to
be considered in estimating Moses's mind (Pr. IX, 291) :
,'So closed a most impzessiye stance; in which the opinion
of the intelligences themselves declared unmistakably [Italics
mine. n.H.] for the Theory of Departed Spirits. Though
this would not form any strong argument to conrince one who
had made up his mind in an opposite direction, still it must be
allowed to have its weight.',
The following passage, too, is so peculiar that the reader
may care to take it into consideration (Pr. IX, 291) :
"Taken in connection with other collateral evidence such as
the materialized spirit form» the strongly marked indiriduality
which pervades communications from each particular spirit, the
totally different nature of the knock in each case, and the fact
of certain tests being given, the balance of evidence must be
allowed to be strong.
',For instance, I see a materialised form which bears resemblance to a deceased friend (Step No. 1). I see that form
standing by during the progress of phenomena (Step No. 2).
A knock different from any other is given (Step No. 8). That
knock gives a communication which purports to come from the
person whose form I see near me (Step No. 4). Questioned,
that communicating intelligence asserts in the most solemn
manner that it is what it pretends to be, and persists in that
statement on being adjured (Step No. 6). On being further
pressed a test known only to myself is given to prove identity
(Step No. 6). That information is confirmed by other communicating intelligences, who knock with their own special
knock, and are apparently distinct individualities (Step No.
"
7)
"Step No. 6,'* I think, will be apt to strike the hardheaded reader as showing the same ingenuousness manifested
in the quotation before the last Moses continues:
"This forms a strong link [Does he mean chain? There are
seven elements. H.H.I of credence in favor of the Uieory
advanced by the intelligences themselves. On the other side
is the manifest fact that communications purporting to come
from our deceased friends are not always trustworthy, and that
they are generally marked by evidences of intellectufd weaknesses. It may be that the falsehoods are traceable to lying
spirits who personate spirits of good, and that the low order
(intellectually speaking) of the communications may be accounted for by the tortuous channel through which they come
and the medium through which th, have been filtered. But
,
CIl XXY]
DiffUuiUes Support Oenuineness
357
the explanation is not perfectly satisfactoir* And there is the
additional stumbling-block that it is prima facie extremely
unlikdy that the spirits of the noble, the learned, and the
pure ,ould be concerned in the production of physical and
intellectual phenomena which, when not silly, are frequently
mischieyous, and when distinctly true are not new, and being
new are not true."
It is now held by common consent that these communications, no matter if thoroughly genuine, are, in their nature,
difficult to make; and the reader as he goes on will find
growing reason to believe the same. Probably he may even
come to regard imperfection as a tag of genuineness.
And connected with this hypothetical difficulty of communication is another point not hypothetical at all. Plainly
it is not part of the cosmic order (or divine plan, if you
prefer) that at our present stage of evolution we should
know much of any possible future life, even if there is one.
There is more to say on these points later: at present it is
enough if we continue our examination with a realization
that it is a priori probable that communication between this
little universe of our experience and the presumably greater
one beyond, would be difficult, and not to any great degree
possible to our present faculties or consistent with our present duties. And yet it does seem possible that we have latterly attained a degree of evolution consistent with our having
something more than the say-so of prophets to assure us
that a future life exists and is happy.
If these are reasonable positions we need not take much
account of the fact that the communications are frequently
of the character Moses calls a ', stumbling-block.'' My reading, however, has not, that I remember, covered any appar*
ently genuine ones which were " mischievous " in any worse
sense than sportive, though there may have been such. When
I say " genuine *' of course I mean only honest — ,not deliberately fraudulent I do not mean the word to endorse a
spiritistic interpretation.
The notion of ,Mying spirits,'' in which Moses and many
others deal, is of course a part of the traditional theology,
but it hardly seems necessary, and will probably be found
peculiarly repulsive by those who regard evil as simply an
exaggeration or disproportion, which includes a lack of the
358
Po88e8Sum(f) in Heterofnaiic Writing
[Bk. II, Ft lY
good, which is incident to the imperfections of the piesent
life.
A control purporting to be Moses, later gave up 'Mying
spirits '' and a good d, more that was his. See Chapter
XXXV.
Moses goes on to say (Pr. IX, 292) :
'' The argument that God permits for the establishment of a
fading faith, manifestations such as these, would satisfactorily
dispose of all objections."
I should be a bit slow to accept this argument unless the
manifestations were clearer, but Myers tells us (Pr. IX,
293-4) :
',Mr. Moses came in a few months more to believe completely in the actual identity of the communicating intelligences. But this passage in his diary [i.e., the preceding, not
all of which have I quoted. H.H.] tends to show (what on
other testimony also I believe to have been the case) that he
was by no means anxious to believe in, or to defer to, the
claims of alleged 'spirit guides.' His previous Anglican convictions were very strong; and his intellectual habit of mind
inclined rather to the side of stubbornness than of pliancy."
When even Myers perpetrates such a phrase as ', intellectual
habit of mind" we can well allow anybody the margin for
inadvertences that I suggested should be allowed to Moses,
and that we all occasionally need.
We have to recognize, however, in his relations to his
superusual experiences, that in the last quarter of the nineteenth century he was, as Myers reminds us, an Anglican
clergyman, and that his experiences strongly appear to be
in writing colored by his type of mind. If we want any
farther illustrations of what that type was, they abound in the
next extract.
From a letter of Mr. Moses to Mrs. Speer, dated April,
1876 (Pr. XI, 63) :
''
I send you a package which you will see is * spiritual'
It contains a fragment of spirit-drapery sweetened by some
spirit musk. Magus is the operator, and I believe Mentor
with him. At any rate, those two have been at work. I think
that the musk smells more powerfully than usual. I Ibd a
long and very beautiful communication from Imperator yesterday (Easter Day) which I am minded to copy out and print.
Ch. XXV]
Letter, Mosee to Mrs. Speer
869
Easter Day aeema to be a favorite with them. I have had a
message on that day every year. The idea is the passage from
Death to Life symbolized by the Crucifixion and Resurrection,
and typifying the death of Self Denial, and Self Sacrifice leading to the Regeneration or Resurrection of the Spirit from dead
Matter to the higher life. It is well worked out» and very
strildng. There was also a communication written out about
the state of affairs in the spiritual world. You must read what
Imperator says. He does not speak hopefully, and wishes us
not to meet yet, though he evidently contemplates the resuming
of our circle hereafter. But by that time, he says, my physical
meditmiship will either be absolutely under control, so as to
be no longer fraught with danger, or will have ceased. The
latter seems to be implied, though he seems to hint that material
evidence will always be forthcoming. He is very decisive in
saying what he does, and says that we are none of us ever left
It gives me a very strong idea of prearranged plans and of
wise and powerful protection. He evidently looks far ahead;
his plans are now for the far future, and the mind U first pre*
pared. I am quite conscious of that.
"I shall probably hear more before we see each other. I
heard nothing of the Moravians this year.''
This refers to a poltergeist racket alleged to be raised
every Easter by the ghosts of people buried in a Moravian
churchyard near which Moses lived. Apparently he could
not be near a churchyard without stirring up a ghost. He
says so himself (Pr. XI, 71). He continues the present
theme:
''Nor was I conscious of any 'presence,' which looks like
a withdrawal from the objective. But Mentor's drapery and
musk are objective enough. ['The letter from which these
eactracts are taken ' (adds Mrs. Speer), ' still retains the scent
of the musk referred to at the commencement, as " sweetening
the spirit-drapeiy," altiiough it was written nearly seventeen
years ago. The drapeiy is lost, but the strong perfume of musk
remains fresh and pungent'] "
On May 2jiLi, 1880, occurred the last sitting which Mrs.
Speer has recorded. She concludes her records in Light
(October 21st, 1893) with the following words:
"I have now come to the end of the sJanoes at which any
notes were properly taken. Other meetings we have since had
occasionally, and at times Imperator spoke through Mr. S. M.
imtiArithin a few months of his decease. Raps were sometimes
heard and messages given. Musk and coral were dso brought
and scattered over , room at several different times. Half
360
Pos8es9ian( f) in Heieromatic Writing
[Bk. II, Pi lY
that took place could not be recorded* and often the addresaea
were imperfectly taken down. It is also impossible to give
any idea of the impression produced upon the circle by the
beauty and refinement of some of the manifestations, or by the
power and dignity of Imperator's influence and personality."
''Musk/' of all perfumes, for ', refinement 'M I confess
that the effect on me of Imperator's musk and other " properties/' and so much of his utterances as I have cared to
read, has been something like that of an ordinary service and
sermon in a very ''high" church. Whether such would be
the effect on others, I don't know; and whether such an
effect answers to one's spiritual needs is a personal matter.
At first one result, of the effect on me was an impulse to
relegate the whole thing to the limbo of buried superstitions.
But then I reflected that, though Moses's manifestations don't
happen to suit my tastes, a large portion of Mrs. Piper's,
outside of those from the Imperator group, do, and that
fact is to me an argument for their genuineness, though not
a proof of it. Why, then, shouldn't the manifestations
through Moses be suited to people of a different taste, of
whom there are a great many more than of my taste, and
some of whom, to judge by the portrait of Dr. and Mrs.
Speer, and of Moses too, are certainly in some respects a
great deal better people than I am?
If the order of nature really does permit communications
with intelligences beyond our ordinary observation, there appears no reason why those communications should not be conformed tothe tastes and capacities of the people participating
in them, and should not be credited to spirits possessing, in
the respective cases, congeniality with the mediums. People
who like musk go to heaven, I suppose, as well as those who
don't, and are just as apt to talk back to earth, and if Moses,
with all his virtues, happened not only to like musk, but also
to be a prig (I don't know well enough to say whether he was
or not), why should not his intimates in the other world like
musk, and be prigs too?
But Mrs. Piper was nothing of that kind, nor by a long
shot was Hodgson, unless Imperator and his gang corrupted
him toward the last of his life here, which, as will be ,n,
doesn't seem indicated by Hodgson's alleged post-mortem communications; and yet, as will also be seen, the Imperator group
Uoseff ''Spirit Teachings'* 861
CL XXV]
(or at least some manifestations doubtfully professing to be
they) swooped down on him and Mrs. Piper too.
Perhaps my distaste for all that sort of thing is abnormal.
If so, I am of course not entitled to pass judgment As the
earth is big enough for all of us, so presumably will heaven
be too, and the change in the twinkling of an eye probably
will not be of all of us to the same pattern; and so the indication ofthere being a variety of patterns ought not to be
taken as an argument that all the indications are fallacious.
Of what were the profundities which Imperator wrote
through Moses, Myers gave little idea. I don't find the
Spirit Teachings in which Moses chronicled them, a book
over which I care to spend much time. I did give an evening
to it, however, and found that it expresses the reactions
of the soul of an Anglican clergyman with itself or kindred
souls. For those who are fond of tracing the evolution of
ideas of questionable present value, from primitive peoples
down to the primitive-minded people to-day, the book may
have interest and, possibly, value. But it will not do much
for those who find the days microscopically short for keeping
up with live interests.
Here is a fair enough sample. Perhaps you can Sni where
the superhuman wisdom comes in: I can't. I can find a good
deal of old-fashioned anthropomorphism.
M. A. Ozon : Spirit Teachings, London, 1907, p. 16 :
, The other, the philosopher, hampered by no theories of what
ought to be, and what ,erefore must be— bound by no subservience tosectarian opinion, to the dogmas of a special school,
free from prejudice, receptive of truth, whatever that truth may
be, so it be proven — ,he seeks into the mysteries of Divine wisdom, and, searching, finds his happiness. He need have no fear
of exhausting the treasures, they are without end. His joy
throughout life shall be to gather ever richer stores of knowledge,
truer ideas of God. The union of those two— the philanthropist
and the philosopher — ,makes the perfect man. Those who unite
the two, progress further than spirits who progress alone.
"'His life/ you say. Is life etemalt
,Yes; we have every reason to believe so. Life is of two
stages — progressive and contemplative. We, who are still progressive, and who hope to progress for countless myriads of ages
(as you say), after the farthest point to which your finite mind
362
PossesHonff) in Eeteronuaie Writing
[BL 11, Pt IV
can reach, we know naught of the life of contemplation. But we
believe that far — ,far in the yaat hereafter — ,there will be a period
at which progressire souls will eyentuaUy arrive, when progresa
has brought tibem to the very dwelling-place of the Omnipotent*
and that there they will lay aside their former state, and bask
in the full light of Deity, in contemplation of all the secrets d
the universe. Of this we cannot tell you. It is too high. Soar
not to such vast heights. Life is unending, as you count it, but
you are concerned with the approach to its threshold, not with
the inner temple.
'' Of course* Do you know more of Ood than you did on
earth?
'* We know more of the operations of His love — ,more of the
operations of that beneficent Power which controls and guides
the worlds. We know of Him, but know Him not; nor shall
know, as you would seek to know, until we enter on the life of
contemplation. He is known to us only by His acts.''
At the close of Myers's second paper on Moses, in Pr. XI,
113, he said : ', At some future date, should my readers desire
it, I shall hope to record Bome more of the Moses phenomena,"
but he did not, although before his death he had nearly six
years to do it in.
So far, you may think the attention paid to Moses and
his friends unjustified. But they appear again in some very
puzzling ways.
Whoever or whatever the Imperator group may be, there is
this important point regarding them : they were contrary to
Moses's previous beliefs, and he fought and fought them until
at last they overthrew his previous beliefs. And yet, those
who fight the obvious implications of these strange experiencesy and the vastly more obvious implications of experiences
stranger still (some of which we shall learn later) say that
these opinions contrary to his own, came from the deepest
and best and wisest stratum of his own nature. So they say
that a similar overturning in a dream, of a terribly dangerous
opinion of my own, apparently by a discamate person most
interested in my welfare, was done by myself. My guess
that all these are enlightened and led by the Cosmic Inflow
may be absurd, any other guess may be absurd, but among
all possible absurdities, can any other be as absurd as that the
agency that
contradicts and overthrows a man's deepest convictions ishimself?
Ch. XXV]
Moses* Atmosphere OppressivB 363
To go from Moses to the other heteromatists spems like
going from a close room — an oriental dose room — ,into the
open air; and I say this despite a yeiy yivid recollection, not
altogether canny, of Mrs. Piper in trance : for I also remember the naturalness of her controls, contrasted with the stiltedness of those of Moses. To many of ns a future life in their
company would be a doubtful blessing; while with Mrs.
Yerrairs and Mrs. Holland's and Mrs. Piper's people, at
least before Imperator and his entourage appeared among
them, it would apparently retain whatever of attractiveness
life has here, with immunity from many of its ills.
CHAPTEB
DRAMATIC
XXVI
"POSSESSION "(f).
SARLT CASES
I Wb now leave for a time the heteromatic writing fonn of
apparent poBsession, and take up the dramatic form. We
have records of apparent possession from far back of the
Delphic priestess inspired or intoxicated by her subterranean
fumes, down to our own time, and through varieties of priests
and seers similarly affected by their favorite tipples or by
hypnosis or auto-suggestion — or spirits, if you see fit to look
at it in that way.
We will begin with a few cases in modem times previous
to the records of the S. P. B.
As I have often said, there are no abrupt transitions in
Nature.
Possession and telesthesia insensibly shade into each other.
Which was Foster's experiencing the pain in the following?
(Bartlett, op. cU., 146) :
From the Melbourne Argus:
" I took a slip of paper, and holding it in my hand on a card»
carefully concealed from other eyes ,an my own, wrote, ' Have
you seen
? ' giving the name of a cousin of mine. ... I folded
the paper and handed it towards him. As soon as he touched
it, and before it left my hand, he rejoined, , She says she haa
seen
, and what is more, he is here now. He is standing
behind your chair.' And after a moment's pause he added, * He
was killed.' I said, 'Yes. Howt' and was told to point privately to the letters of the alphabet on a card and the reply
would be rapped out. I pointed and raps came at the letters
DHOW — at which moment Mr. Foster, who could not have
seen what I was doing, put his hand suddenly on his side and
exclaimed, 'What a pain I He was killed by a falL, And I
have a vision of water — a fall in water,' the truth being that
my cousin hurt his side in plunging into the St. Oeorge,s
Baths, Liverpool, and was drowned before it was suspected that
in a prolonged dive."
he was doing more than indulging
864
Ch. XXVI] Foster's Apparent ''Possession" 366
Here we reach apparently full possession (Bartlett, op. cU.,
93):
From the Sacramento Record, December 8, 1873 :
"Foster at one time sei£ed A.'s hand, exclaiming, ' Qod bless
you, my dear boy, my son. I am thankful I at last may speak
to you. I want you to know I am your father, who loved you
in life and Iotcs you still. I am near to you; a thin veil alone
separates us. Good-by. I am your father, Abijah A
.'
,''Good heavens I' exclaimed A., ,that was my father's
name, his tone, his manner, his action.'
, * And,' said Foster, * it was a good influence; he was a man
of large veneration.' "
I said that the above indicated possession. But it is not
possession to the extent of complete expulsion of the original
consciousness, as in the trances of Home, Moses, and Mrs.
Piper.
And which is the following? (Bartlett, op. cit., 103) :
" [Letter to editor, written Nov. 80, 1874]
"New York Daily Oraphie: ... He told me he saw the spirit
of an old woman close to me, describing most perfectly my
grandmother, and repeating: 'Resodeda, Hesodeda is here; she
kisses her grandson.' Arising from his chair, Foster embraced
and kissed me in the same peculiar way as my grandmother did
when alive."
But here the possession seems complete (Bartlett, op. cit.,
140). From the Melbourne Daily Age:
,* Mr. Foster ... in answer to the question, What he died oft
suddenly interrupted, * Stay, this spirit will enter and possess
me,' and instantaneously his whole body was seized with quivering convulsions, the eyes were introverted, the face swelled,
and the mouth and hands were spasmodically agitated. Another
change, and there sat before me the counterpart of the figure
of my departed friend, stricken down with complete paralysis,
just as he was on his death-bed. The transformation was so
life-like, if I may use the expression, ,at I fancied I could
detect the very features and physiognomical changes that
passed across the visage of my dying friend. The kind of
paralysis was exactly represented, witib the palsied hand extended to me to shake, as in the case of the originaL Mr. Foster
recovered himself when I touched it, and he said in reply
to one of my companions that he had completely lost his own
identity during the fit, and felt like waves of water flowing all
over his body, from the crown downwards."
866 Dramatic'ToB8ess%on"(t). Early Cases [Bt II, Pt IV
Here is a still more remarkable case from Stillman (op. cii.,
I, 192). The medium was, I believe, the one in the heteromatic writing already taken from Stillman. The poeseadon
aeems to have been throughout free from tranoe.
,'I asked Harvey [the control, Stillman's cousin. H.H.] if
he had seen old Turner, the landscape painter, since his death,
which had taken place not very long before. The reply was
* Yes/ and I then asked what he was doing, the reply being a
pantomime of painting. I then asked if Harvey could bring
Turner there, to which the reply was, 'I do not know; I will
go and see,' upon which Miss A. said, ' This influence [Harv,s.
H.H.] is going away — it is gone'; and after a short pause
added, 'There is another influence coming, in that direction,'
pointing over her left shoulder. * I don't like it,' and she shuddered slightly, but presently sat up in her chair with a most
extraordinary personation of the old painter in manner, in the
look out from under the brow and the pose of the head. It
was as if the ghost of Turner, as I had seen him at Qriffiths's,
sat in the chair, and it made my flesh creep to the very tips
of my fingers, as if a spirit sat before me. Miss A. exclaimed,
* This influence has taken complete possession of me, as none
of the others did. I am obliged to do what it wants me to.'
I asked if Turner would write his name for me, to which she
replied by a sharp, decided negative sign. I then asked if he
would give me some advice about my painting, remembering
Turner's kindly invitation and manner when I saw him. This
proposition was met by the same decided n,ative, accompanied
by the fixed and sardonic stare which the girl had put on at
the coming of the new influence. This disconcerted me, and
I then explained to my brother what had been going on, as,
the questions being mental, he had no clue to the pantomime.
I said that as an influence which purported to be Turner was
present, and refused to answer any questions, I supposed there
was nothing more to be done.
" But Miss A. still sat unmoved and helpless, so we waited.
Presently she remarked that the influence wanted her to do
something she knew not what, only that she had to get up and
go across the room, which she did with the feeble step of an
old man. She crossed the room and took down from the wall
a colored French lithograph, and, coming to me, laid it on the
table before me, and by gesture called my attention to it. She
then went through the pantomime of stretching a sheet of
paper on a drawing-board, then that of sharpening a lead pencil,
following it up by tracing the outlines of the subject in the
lithograph. Then followed in similar pantomime the choosing
of a water-color pencil, noting careful], the necessary flneness
of the point, and then the washing-xn of a drawing, broadly.
]
CL XXVI]
The StiUman-TufT, Case
367
Miss A. seemed much amused by all this, but as she knew
nothing of drawing she understood nothing al it. Then with
the pencil and her pocket handkerchief she began taking out the
lights, ' rubbing-out,' as the technical term is. This seemed to
me so contrary to what I conceived to be the execution of
Turner that I interrupted with the question, ' Do you mean to
say that Turner rubbed out his lights?' to which she gave
the afSrmative sign. I asked further if in a drawing which I
then had in my mind, the well-known * Llanthony Abbey/ the
central passage of sunlight and shadow through rain was done
in that way, and she again gave the affirmative reply, emphatically. Iwas so firmly convinced to the contrary that I was
now persuaded that there was a simulation of personality, such
as was generally the case with the public mediums, and I
said to my brother, who had not heard any of my questions [He
says above that they were mental. H.H.], that this was another
humbug, and then repeated what had passed, sayitfg that Turner
could not have worked in that way.
"Six weeks later I sailed for England, and, on arriving in
London, I went at once to see Kuskin, and told him the whole
stoiy. He declared the contrariness manifested by the medium
to be entirely characteristic of Turner, and had the drawing
in question down for examination. We scrutinized it closely,
and both recognized beyond dispute that the drawing had been
executed in the way that Miss A. indicated. Ruskin advised
me to send an account of the affair to the Oamhill, which I did ;
but it was rejected, as might have been expected in the state
of public opinion at that time, and I can easily imagine
Thackeray putting it into the basket in a rage.
"I offer no interpretation of the facts which I have here
recorded, but I have no hesitation in saying that they completed and fixed my conviction of the existence of invisible and
independent intelligences to which the phenomena were due."
To me fhey seem the nearest I have come to a communication of something not known to any earthly intelligence, and
yet it may have been so known.
CHAPTEB
PRELIMINAIIY BBGARDIKG
XXVn
THB S. P. R. SITTINGS
It is again one of the classifications whose inevitable arbitrarines have
I
harped npon to illustrate the nnity of things,
that now places before ns as a separate category the sittings
of Mrs. Piper, Mrs. Thompson, and a few others. I prefer
to use the space mainly for the two named, as the best Their
manifestations were in trance, and thongh the voice no longer
takes party gestures still do in a remarkable degree.
Mrs. Piper's sittings for communications in response to
ordinary human interests, with scientific experiment only as
incidental, are reported in Pr. VI, VIII, XIII, XIV,
XVI, XXIII, and XXIV. Sittings with special view to cross,
correspondence — and very tedious sittings most of them are,
though productive in response to dose study — are reported in
XXII and XXIV. Cross-correspondences are two or more
', messages '' through different sensitives which are meaningless taken separately, but significant when taken together.
Such cases seem to prove a mind outside of the sensitive's.
More of Mrs. Piper's sittings are reported for the first time
in Chapters XXVIII and XXXVI of the present work.
Mrs. Thompson's sittings are reported in Pr. XVII and
XVIII.
The principal features that set the S. P. R sittings apart
from others are that they are
(a) better reported, sometimes stenographically, and always at least by competent and trained observers ticking notes,
or by the medium's own script;
(b) better guarded against fraud, though in the light of
the vast evidence accumulated during the last thirty years,
bothering with the idea of deliberate fraud, even in the primitively authenticated cases of Foster and Moses, seems silly;
(c) with the possible exception of my Chapters XXVIII
and XXXVI, infinitely better edited and commented upon.
Ch. XXVII]
Superior Biitm and Controls
869
Since 1882 these matters, previously neglected, have received
the closest attention of some of the best minds in both hemispheres;
{d) evoked by vastly better sitters — ,largely the editors
and commentators above referred to;
(0) emanating from vastly better alleged controls — ,whether
actual personalities or appropriate and suggestive memories in
the minds of survivors. Latterly they profess to be many of
the eminent sitters alluded to— of course after their deaths.
Among the recent alleged controls have been not only Moses
himself, Myers, and Hodgson, but also the equally high intel igences of"Oeorge Pelham,'' Oumey, and Sidgwick, who
had not been habitual sitters. There have been from these
controls and others, sittings which in number, variety, veri«
similitude, and dramatic quality are as much superior to other
sittings as illtmiination from the sim is superior to that from
the moon.
The mediums, as already indicated, vary very much in effectiveness, just as all machines for communication vary — their
capacity is evolved to different degrees of efficiency, just as
all faculties are, and the communications therefore, and for
other reasons, vary in deamess, consecutiveness, and intelligibility.
The d,ee of success seems to depend partly upon the
condition of the medium and the atmosphere, but much more
upon the character of the sitter. The mediumistic faculty
needs sympathy and co-operation. The sitter and the medium
are a pair striving for a result. If we are studying what is
done by pairs in racing, or tennis, or golf, or duet-music, or
telepathic communication, there is no use, except for expert
study, in spending time with pairs who do badly. From this
point of view, in the examination we are about to make, we
may as well confine our attention to what comes to good
sitters from good mediums. But there is also the point of
view of the man who ,* wants to see both sides,'' and I shall
try to meet his just requirements.
In the early days the need of sympathy was held symptomatic of fraud. The time for that is past
Perhaps as a result of the conditions, many of the communications fall below the intelligence of the alleged spirits
870
Praiminary an the 8. P. B. SUtings [Bk. n. Pi lY
while they were in the body; often they contradict what
would be expected of the spirits; and often they are sheer
nonsense. All this is no worse than might reasonably be
expected eyen if the communications were (or are) genuine.
Sir William Crookes says (Researches, pp. 84-5) :
" A third error is that the medium must select his own circle
of friends and associates at a seance; that these friends must
be thorough believers in the truth of whaterer doctrine the
medium enunciates; and that conditions are imposed on any
person present of an investigating turn of mind, which entirely
preclude accurate observation and facilitate trickery and deception. In reply to this I can state that... I have chosen
my own circle of friends, have introduced any hard-headed unbeliever whom I pleased, and have generally imposed my own
terms, which have been carefully chosen to prevent the possibility offraud."
Directly counter to this, Moses testifies (Pr. IX, 259) :
''We had ventured on one occasion, contrary to direction, to
add to our circle a strange member. Some trivial phenomena
occurred, but the usual controlling spirit did not appear. When
next we sat, he came; and probably none of us will easily forget
the sledge-hammer blows witii wluch he smote the table. The
noise was distinctly audible in the room below, and gave one
the idea that the table would be broken to pieces. In vain we
withdrew from the table, hoping to diminish the power. The
heavy blows increased in intensity, and the whole room shook
with their force. The direst penalties were threatened if we
again interfered with the development by bringing in new sitters. We have not ventured to do so again; and I do not think
we shall easily be persuaded to risk another similar objurgaBut later we read of several people joining the circle at
tion.''
different times in peace and quietness 1 1 Translation to the
spirit world ( ?) does not seem to make us angels of consistency
all at once, though perhaps in Moses's case, as in so many
others, time may have changed conditions.
When several good witnesses swear they saw something
remarkable done, the production of a thousand other good
witnesses who saw it faried in vain means little, and means
less in proportion to the supposed difficulty and rarity of the
act — unless they can prove their experience the only genuine
experienee, and the opposite experience the result of fraud
Ch. XXVII]
Beporta Usually Beri Passages
871
or mlsappreliension. The fraud question, however, in connection with most of the phenomena I have bothered with or
shall bother with, is simply out of date.
It follows, extreme as the statement will first appear, that
except so far as the negative sittings directly tend to explain
away the positive ones, they are negligible. Yet I wish to
present the negative side as strongly aa I can without boring
yon with repeated quotations of uninteresting and resultiess
matter. Bnt I wish to emphasize the fact that, although poor
sittings are probably less apt to be reported than effective ones,
they do appear in the reports pretty often — ,perhaps a tenth of
the total ; and this notwithstanding that successful sitters are
apt to return often, while unsuccessful ones are not.
I also wish to emphasize that in some cases the attempts
to ', explain away '' bear a very fair aspect of success, though
candor compels me to say that they often seem to me more
improbable than the flat-footed spiritistic hypothesis which
I began by scouting, and which I am not yet ready to accept
I wish, too, to be distinctly understood as admitting telepathy from the sitter wherever that will serve, and teloteropathy from other incarnate minds wherever there is room
for it.
And finally I wish to state that the tests perhaps most
ingeniously devised and generally regarded as most crucial,
of which we shall meet the details later — ,the reading after
death, through the medium, of sealed letters prepared by the
communicator before death, have failed in the two reported
cases, and that such reading does not, for any reason that I
can see, appear more difficult than other feats performed
by or through the medium. This, however, I take to be
mainly an argument against accounting for the phenomena by
telopsis.
This test was once regarded by a good many as final against
the survival of the author of the letter. It is certainly final
against his ability and inclination, if he survive, to communicate matter that from our point of view should be as
easy to him as other matter which he or the medium does
communicate, except in the vital point that the contents of
the letter can be proved not to be in the mind of any living
person, while of little or nothing else in the matter com-
372
Preliminary on ihe 8. P. B. Sittings [Bk. II, Pt IV
mimicated through the medium, can that be proyed. The
altematiyes then are: (I) If the writer can,t tell what he
did himself for the express purpose of telling it if he should
survive, he did not survive; (II) he did survive, as shown
by many other proofs, but there are insurmountable obstadea
to his giving the proof in question. Of this more later.
The circumstances under which the controls appear are
very yarious. We have had some indications of them already,
but they will grow much more distinct as we go on. In
many of the most important sittings there are ostensibly
gathered around the medium several *, personalities,'' of whom
generally one acts as spokesman, or writer, for the others,
though the others sometimes speak or write for themselyes.
Who shall be the spokesman seems to be determined by the
natural selection of some , person '' of superior experience or
intimacy with the medium. ', He " often professes to repeat
yerbatim, and it is not always possible to tell whether the
alleged communication is to be taken as direct or indirect.
Thus Mrs. Piper, for the earlier part of her mediumship,
was generally controlled by an alleged French physician calling himself Dr. Phinuit, who spoke for , everybody," but she
appeared gradually to come more readily under the immediate
control of any ,'personality'' who wished to conmiunicate,
though as Phinuit gradually disappeared, part of his place
was inherited by George Pelham and also by Rector, professedly one of the Imperator group with whom we haye
already become acquainted in connection with Stainton Moses;
and Imperator himself occasionally took a hand.
Mrs. Thompson is generally under the ostensible control
of her daughter Nelly, who died in infancy, but has been
growing up. ( ?)
Since the deaths of Gurney, Myers, and Hodgson, they have
ostensibly controlled very freely, the automatic writings of
Mrs. Verrall, Mrs. Holland, and Miss Bawson being almost
dominated by them.
The sittings, recorded but not printed by the S. P. E.,
are announced to be largely incoherent and insignificant
But not a few too intimate for publication are, for that yery
reason, more impressiye than anything that has been published. Eyen from those published, of course I can
Ck. XXVII]
Propaganda versus Exposition
373
give but fragments; and at best one who has read and reread thousands of pages of records of sittings and comments
thereupon can hardly pick out the few hundred pages most
worth boiling down for one who has read but little. The
difBculties of the task are greatly increased by the editors and
commentators having more generally had in mind their fellowstudents than the average uninitiated reader.
There are at least two obvious ways in which this material
can be presented. In Human Personality Mjers, who had but
half of the present accumulation to select from, strung his
on the thread of his theories, and used it in advocacy of them.
To do this, of course, he had to select here and there without
regard to chronological sequence.
I have preferred to attempt an outline by approximately
consecutive specimens from the Pr. S. P. B. and a few other
records. Myers's method has advantages for propagandism
which this has not; but this has enabled me to present what
perhaps I may call the Piper drama — ,the appearing, manifestations, and disappearing of her principal ', controls,'' Phinuit and G. P., and her relations with Myers and Hodgson
living and with their alleged personalities when they had
ceased to " live." Prom this chronological presentation, perhaps you can better decide whether, in the later manifestations,
those personalities were mere memories— or refrain from deciding.
My method of presentation has also left me absolutely untrammeled by any theory, except what has grown up during
the work itself. This condition has probably enabled me to
present both sides more fairly than I could otherwise have
done.
It is tantalizing to be able to give only such small scraps
of the reports : they must afford a very inadequate notion not
merely of the variety of the phenomena, but of the impressions
pro and con. The matter I had selected as desirable for conveying even the impression worth attempting here, was about
twice as much as I can give room.
It is of course desirable that interested readers should be
able to roam at will through the Pr. S. P. B., and even readers
who have not them within reach, can practically do so at
moderate expense. A full set up to 1912 would cost well over
874
Preliminary on the S. P. B. 8itHng$
[Bk. H, Pt. IV
a hundred dollars, but nearly all the ▼olxunes consist of sereral '' Parts/' and these can be bought separately in paper at
not over a dollar and a half each. The American agents aie
the W. B. Clarke Company of Boston. If you want fuller details of any topic than are given here, by naming to the agents
the Tolume and page cited, you will enable them to send you
the Part. My naming the Part as well as the volume and page
containing each citation, would be a nuisance to us both.
The sittings themselves soon become borous, but the treatment of them by the various editors is generally interesting,
and nearly all literature of a very high order. As I have reread and re-read it since making the first draft of this book, the
inadequacy and injustice to the whole subject of what I
can give here, has been doubly borne in upon me, and I should
be tempted to suppress it if it were possible otherwise to urge
readers to the sources from which I have drawn, if there were
any chance that even when so urged, those getting an inadequate notion here would seek the vastly better one there, and
if (the reason perhaps of least worth) it were not for features
on which I have dwelt when my predecessors have not In
case you may care for fuUer, and in many ways vastly better,
treatment of the sittings, let me recommend you, in the order
given (not necessarily that of merit, but approximately that of
interest to the lay reader) to the following papers from which
I have but briefly abstracted — ,Hodgson's report in Part (not
Volume) XXXIII ; James's in Part LVIII, and Piddington's
(on Mrs. Thompson) in Part XLVIL The editorial matter
in all these is very full, and of very high rank even as literature
alone. Perhaps merely as sittings, the Junot series (the last
which I abstract) in Part LXI are the most interesting of aU.
The editorial matter there is very good as far as it goes, but
to go very far would have been superfluous, as there were few
points not adequately treated by the editors of sittings previously published. Next in interest to most intelligent readers
— ,perhaps indeed greater than any other part to one who has
read the first two I have named, is Mrs. VerralFs admirable
account of her own and Mrs. Holland's automatic writing,
which fills all of Vol. XX. This too is of high value as
literature.
A little patient practice will be needed in reading the
Ch. XXVII]
Peculianties of Beparts
376
records, partly becatise they are reported in so many ways,
notes of sittings having been kept by varioiis people in varions
forms. I have found it impracticable to reduce them to nni«
formity. The words of the "controls'' uttered or written
by (or through?) the medium, in some cases are not set oft
by any sign. This is often unfortunate, especially where the
medium's utterances are jumbled up in the same paragraph
with those of the sitters in parenthesis, and of various commentators inbrackets.
Professor Newbold says (Pr. XIV, 8) :
" The reader will observe that ' yes ' and ' no ' are often written
when no questions are recorded. This is due to the fact that,
the writing being exceedingly illegible and coming very rapidly,
the sitter reads aloud with a slight interrogatory inflection at
any convenient resting point, as at the end of a sheet or at an
apparent pause in the sense. To this the writer responds with
' yes ' or ' no/ to show whether he is being correctly understood.
a these utterances are, as I believe them to be, entirely dissevered from the normal consciousness of Mrs. Piper, they as truly
reveal to us a new world of mind as the mieroecope reveals a
"
new world of matter.
Moreover, there are not infrequent grammatical errors that
divert the attention. I have thought best not to correct any
of them. Some may be misprints; some from inadequate
memoranda or stenographic reports; some from indistinctness
of heteromatic script; some may be due to the heteromatists
(though if any occurred in the script of the highly educated
ones, they were probably edited out) ; but I feel disposed to
take them as slips of the alleged communicators, even when
they professed to be such high and mighty personages as the
Imperator group. This is especially the case where those personages tried thee-ing and thou-ing, and slipped up on the
, number " of their pronouns and verbs. This of conrse tends
to make them ont as at least partly the products of the imagination of a medium unpractised in such language; and it
does not seem greatly to stretch consistency to assume that
they might be genuine personages, and their reported language
subjected to a coloring from the channel through which it
comes.
Editors have often found difficulty in separating the words
of different controls: they appear to interrupt each other.
376
Praiminary on the 8. P. B. Sittings [Bk. II, Pt. IV
and sometiines there seems to be a yeritable straggle among
ihem for possession of the medium. It is therefore not always
easy (or possible, for that matter) for even the practised
reader to get the meaning clearly. I have risked straining
the patience of such readers by continuing my own interpola*
tions intended to help the novice. I hope none of them will
appear too banaL They are, as hitherto, in square brackets
and followed by my initials, and should be discriminated from
other notes in square brackets by sitters or other editors.
I realize that these frequent interruptions are apt to become a nuisance to some readers whose sympathy I should
be very sorry to lose, — especially to those who are already
in the habit of reading sittings and interpreting for
themselves. But, to lay readers generally, for whom especially Iwrite, they are apt to be serviceable, even if at the
expense of some annoyance. I hope I have not made the
reports of sittings more tedious than they naturally are by
the attempted help I have interjected.
Like some other writings, accounts of sittings should be
taken in moderate instalments, especially if they are read seriously, in order that the mind may be keen for all the indications, for or against And after you get through, if you are
reasonable, as of course you are, you will find it a matter of
incontrovertible indications both ways.
Don't feel discouraged by the sitting given first: probably
it is given more in detail and with less editing into smoothness, than the later ones.
If you find yourself inclined to stop, don't before you
have tried skipping, and looked into the Junot sittings, which
are the last.
I have intentionally repeated a good many of my own
comments, and unintentionally not a few, but it hardly seems
worth while to fish them out, especially as the reasons sufficiently sound, I trust, for the deliberate repetitions, will
probably in some degree hold good — so far as they may be
good at all — ,for the accidental ones.
All the sittings published have, of course, had editors, and
remarks by the editors are of course frequently injected into
the reports. Sometimes when, in the course of a sitting, the
editor speaks in propria persona, and there seems danger of
Ch. XXVII]
''Evidential'' Teris
377
ambiguity, I prefix his initial to the paragraph. Keep thid
in mind, or you will occaaionally be puzzl,.
The controls say that not all of them can commnnicate
through any known medimn, and that some can commnnicate
through some mediums but not through others. Often one
of them who claims that he cannot communicate through the
medium then present, professes to make his communication to
another ,' spirit/, who deliyers it through the medium. Phi«
nuit, George Pelham, and Sector are the most frequent intermediaries.
I want to say at the outset that if we are to consider as
evidential of spiritism only facts not possibly known by any
incarnate intelligence, the sittings do not seem to me worth
taking into account Not only do the indications pro and con
too nearly offset each other; but, as has often been said, the
only accessible proof of a statement is in some incarnate mind,
and aU such proof must open up the suspicion of telepathy,
or at the worst teloteropathy.
Therefore I give the extracts from the records of sittings
not so much for their , evidential ', value as for whatever indication they may contain that the things said, no matter
whether facts or falsities, are said by substantially the per*
sonalities claiming to say them — ,for whatever they may show
of (a) the habits of mind and turns of expression of the
alleged communicator; (h) emotions, initiative, response beyond the reach of telepathy; and (c) growth in the alleged
communicator's character from the sittings of one year to
those of later years. The question is whether these are in
kind and degree sufficiently identical with the personalities
alleged. If they are, the facts or falsities communicated
seem to me of minor consequence. On the other hand, if
the personalities communicating the facts or falsities lack individuality and vraisemblance, they may all be summed up as
the medium and the sitter; and the facts or falsities summed
up as successful or unsuccessful telepsychoses from incarnate
minds.
What indications of personal identity the records contain,
cannot be fairly indicated in half a dozen sittings. Yet, outside of the Pr. S. P. B. and Myers's bulky volumes, they have
been very lightly treated by anybody. Podmore in his big and
378
Preliminary on the 8. P. R. Sittings [Bk. H, Pt. IV
important two-yolmne work, deTotee to them less than twenty
pages. I shall give them some hundreds — enough, I hope, to
give a fair outline of the Piper drama.
The impressions made upon me by the Tarions phenomena,
I have given pretty much as they occurred. They often contradict each other flatly, but, as will be seen, out of the mass
of confusion, some elements gradually preponderated and
shaped themselves into a theory which at last grew pretty firm
and distinct, but of course I hold it only tentatively. But after
the revolutions that have come within less than a century, how
many opinions will it do to hold in any other way ?
I for one find agreeable the change from the close overstimulated atmosphere of Moses into the often prosy paths
but natural human interests usually brought before us by
Mrs. Piper. Her controls generally profess to be ordinary
people seeking communication with friends they have left
behind. Whether she really gives that communication or
not, she gives an astonishing semblance of it, and with a
verisimilitude and vastness of detail that place her in a class
apart.
Mrs. Piper differs from many of the heteromatists in
that her writing is in trance. In the early part of her
career her vocal organs were used by several controls, each
with a special voice and enunciation, but that has gradually
disappeared, and for many years she has manifested only
by writing and gesture. No other heteromatisf s scripts, not
even Mrs. Verrall's, have been scrutinized by as many careful
and competent students as Mrs. Piper's, and perhaps none
have impressed people as strongly with the conviction that
they emanate from a life beyond ours.
In one sense they say very little, and reiterate that little
ad nauseam; but the little is said by so many ostensible personalities, and in such a number of different connections, as to
produce probably more dramatic variety, so far as mere variety
goes, than ever before was expressed tlurough a single human
being. But what is said contains nothing that could be
uttered only by a soul suddenly admitted to vast superhuman
knowledge, as the old theories assumed the postcamate soul
to be. An error in those theories, however, is no argument
against the present manifestations.
Ol XXVII]
Skipping Best for Some Readers
379
So far as regards fhe Pr. S. P. B., the cheap stage scenery
and inflated conversation borrowed from all sorts of mythologies, and attributed by most of the early ,' mediums " to the
life beyond earth, Mrs. Piper has little use for, although she
did descend a good way into both when, about midway in
her career, Stainton Moses, postcamate, turned up with his
grandiloquent friends Imperator ft Go. Mrs. Piper describes
little scenery, and her people, while uttering many incoherences, outside of Imperator ft Co., talk little coherent nonsense, and in their conyersations with the sitters are as
true to nature as anybody; and this is probably the strongest
support for the belief that the communications are from
actual personalities. .
But since the foregoing paragraph was in type Professor
Newbold has intrusted to me some records of sittings not reported inthe Pr. S. P. R, that call for modifications of this
statement They will be discussed in Chapter XXXVI.
I want finally to repeat again that the sittings tend soon
to become borons, but I hope that some readers who do not
care to study them may be repaid for skipping through them :
many quotations of interesting comment are scattered among
them, and a general knowledge of them is essential to understanding anytiiing that may be worth while, if there is anything worth while, in the speculations which follow them.
CHAPTEB
XXVin
MRS. PIPER : AUTHOR'S SXPERIENCB
As in Telekinesis and Telepathy, I began, for ihe reasons
there given, with my own experience; for the same reasons,
I run counter to chronology to present a sitting I had with
Mrs. Piper in 1894. It was a typical Piper stance of the
period. Although it was not printed in the Pr. S. P. B. because Iwas then too busy and procrastinating to revise the
copy which Hodgson sent me, it has some special points
worth noting, and in general can serve as a text for expounding many of the points of mediumism. One special
point is that it is one of the sittings when Mrs. Piper loth
spoke and wrote automatically — ,before she ceased the former,
and after she began the latter.
Mrs. Piper's psychic manifestations in an ordinary sitting
are much more complex than Foster's were, but so far as
I know, she has not, like him, given telekinetic ones. In
fact telekinesis appears for the time to be under a cloud. I
have read no account of it from an English medium since
Home and Moses, though Eusapia Palladino still has her
adherents, of whom I am one as far as the lion's skin goes,
but of late it seems to have been shrinking, and the fox's
to be expanding. This slowing up in telekinetic phenomena,
however, is probably nothing but an illustration of the law
of the rhythm of motion. But to return to Mrs. Piper and
Foster. While the impressions of both were obviously due
to some sensibility not yet evolved in people generally, Mrs.
Piper, while appearing a person much more susceptible to
spiritual impressions (whatever that may mean), in her own
personality had, in a sense, nothing to do with the matter.
Foster expressed himself, giving an account of what he saw
and felt, while she abolished herself, appearing to move her
own personality from her body, giving place to other apparent
personalities who expressed themselves through her vocal
Gh. XXyin]
Oefmn$nw.
ISodua Operandi
381
oigans, gestures, and writing. What they did, did not seem
to pass through her consciousness, and the apparent passage
of their consciousnesses through her oiganism involved some
disturbance in it. Mrs. Piper was in a trance, the passage
of the communicationB distorting her face, changing her
voice, and seeming to affect her whole being. Foster, on the
contrary, appeared as wide awake, intelligent, and cheerful
as people generally are in ordinary conversation. He remarked, after perhaps an hour or an hour and a half, that
he was feeling a little tired. Mrs. Piper, on coming out
of the trance after perhaps an hour, was somewhat exhausted.
This, however, was not the case some years later, as will
appear.
Mrs. Piper did not know who I was, unless Hodgson had
told her, and I am confident he had not There was a good
chance for her to read about me from his mind, as he knew
me well, but she read next to nothing that he knew!
Before we began, Hodgson placed some sheets of paper
and pencils on a small table within reach of Mrs. Piper,
and others on the mantel east of the table for his own
memoranda. Mrs. Piper and I sat facing each other on
the west side of the table. Hodgson moved to and fro
between the table and the mantel.
She did not hold my hand. Early in her career, as recorded in many places, she seems to have held her sitter's
hands through the whole stance, but gradually she came
not to touch the sitter at all. The change appears to have
come some time between '89 and '96. When that change
took place, ihe suggestions of '' muscle reading " in her case,
made by Mr. Podmore and others, were disposed of.
In the early reports are also several allusions to the stance
room being darkened. That, Itoo, had become outgrown
before my sitting, and with it, of course, the deductions of
fraud naturally drawn from it.
After we had been seated a minute or two, Mrs. Piper's
eyeballs rolled upward, her face became slightly convulsed,
and she began talking in a rough voice not her own. As
I remember, the voice at first affected me as if it were coming
from a statue, but I soon got used to it She was apparently
882
Mrs. Piper: Authai,s Experience
[Bk. II, Pi IV
"under the control '' of Phinnity an alleged French physician,
with whom readers of the Proceedings of the Society for
Psychical Research are well acquainted, and whom I will lat,
in,oduce more at length to others.
At times there seemed to be changes of control not noted
in the report. I attempt to note such, and have essayed a
few other incidental improvements. These notes aie sometimes interpolated in square brackets, with my initials, but
often in the separate paragraphs and in the larger type of
the author's usual part of the book.
Below are given Hodgson's notes of what was said, and
exact transcripts of what was written. The reader new
to the subject should know that alleged communications
through alleged mediums generally come with apparent diffi*
culty — a sort of stammering or feeling for words, and con*
siderable confusion. Literal reproductions, despite such inserted elucidations as may be practical, are not very smooth
reading. The confusion is attributed by some to the medium's
delays in ''fishing" for intimations from sitters; by others
to difficulties inherent in the case, especially witii inexperienced controls.
All these elements of confusion might suggest to one reading for the first time well annotated notes of a sitting, that
he is examining a photograph of chaos and old night As
I have already cautioned, patience is needed not only for
understanding the notes, but for estimating them as evidence.
Don't let the difficulty of the following sitting discourage
you regarding the later ones. They are apparently mudi
more freely '' edited," and are much easier reading.
BUting of April 8, 1894
Present, Bichard Hodgson, Henry Holt.
Notes by Hodgson.
" Phinuit speaking. [See Note 1, at end of sitting, p. 890.]
' Game all the way from spirit to see you. Want to tell you something about yourself. That gentleman [referring to Sitter] has
spirits around him all the time. He don't believe it, but he'e
medium/**
a Later
indications tend to verify this, but I have not tried
to increase them : I have been too busy, and have wanted to
keep a level head — as far as I can.
Ch. XXVIII]
Friends Troubles Reported
383
'* Sitter.—* Tou don't know me, do you? ' PL—* I have never
met you bef oie/ Q. P. [breaking in] — * Awful ecrape over here.
Want you to help me out. A. f assumed initial] is in a dangerous condition.' Ph. [explaining] * O. P. wants to speak to
you. He knows you.' "
0. P. is the "George Pelham', well known to readers
of the Pr. S. P. B., whom I will more fully introduce
to others later. When living he was a friend of mine as well
as of Hodgson, and of my friend indicated by the pseudo
initial A.
"8.
* An right.' *»
Here G. P. " assumed control '' of the medium — so Hodgson's notes say, but possibly **Phinuif reported for him.
I cannot remember now whether there was a change of voice.
**Q. P. — ,*rd like to know where Mabel is, and who the
dickens is that? Do you know what I meant' S. — ,, Mabel t
No.' G. P. — ,'A.'s in a critical state. He's not himself now.
He's terribly depressed.' S. — ,'Can you tell anything [more]
about A.? ' G. P.—' Friend of yours in body.' 8.—' Of Hodgson '? [This question and the following seem to have been mild
" tests ', I knew the man welL H.H.] G. P.—' Yes.' S.—
' Did I ever know him f ' G. P. — , Yes you knew him very welL
You're connected with him.' 8. — ,'Through whom?' G. P. —
'Do you know any B.?' [assumed initial. H.H.] 8.—
*Are A. and I connected through B.?' G. P.—* Write to R
and hell tell you all about it' " [See Note 2.]
It turned out later that A. actually was low in his mind,
and that B., whom nobody present Imew, was trying to get
him diverting occupation. This was found, too, to be a case
of cross-correspondence.
None of these circxmiBtances were known to anybody present, hut they were known to other minds '' in the body," and
hence the medium's utterance of them is open to the interpretation ofteloteropathy. Similar instances are not rare.
''G. P. [apparently: notes are uncertain] continued.
'Somebody wants to come in here. There's a lady with you
[natural, but probably I willed a change of subject. The
mediums generally respond promptly to such willing.] Go on
writing, it will help you.' [This may be taken to have referred
to some literary work on which I was engaged.] G. P. — * You're
going away. Don't go to sleep. WsIdb up and talk to me.
384
Mrs. Piper: Auihof,s Bxperience [Bk. H, Ft IV
An revoirl Fll see yon
tBepeated in two or three ways.]
Iter/''
Here Mrs. Piper's right hand began reaching and grasping,
and Hodgson put a pencil in it She wrote continnonsly in
a very large sprawling, irr,ular hand. Among other passages were those given below. The omitted ones are confused. My part of the dialogue was probably (it was nearly
eighteen years before this writing) put by Hodgson on each
sheet as the medium went to the next, and the whole revised
by me in the typewritten copy which he sent. Before going to
press I paragraph and punctuate a little, though at danger of
forcing intelligibility. The explanatory or suggestive comments of Hodgson or myself are in rectangular brackets,
mainly from notes made at the time.
At the risk of discouraging yon, and the certainty of presenting the material of the sittings in a disadvantageous form,
I have concluded to let it stand with all its obscurities and
eccentricities, edited only by comment The S. P. B. reports
are generally selections with the mold marks smoothed away,
but you may care for a specimen of the unmitigated thing, even
at the cost of extra hard reading.
, O. P. — * And how are you t O. P. G. P. [signature repeated]
I am not dead. How are you H.? [evidently referring to me»
whose initial Mrs. Piper did not know.] I am glad to see him.
Come and speak. Watson help those fingers. [Beferenoe to
Watson (unknown) suggests similarity of sound to Hodgson,Mediimi's fingers cramped.] Too bad about A. I am sorry for
him. I have however [been] a help to him.
I am here.
Oarlton [unknown] is a
. I see you H. [Sitterl,speak
tome.' S.— 'Can you hear well t' G. P.—' Not clearly H. Ill
get in stronger in a moment. AH O.K. H. we will be O.E.
in a moment. ... how is W
?' [A living acquaintance of
G. P. and myself, but seldom in my mind, certainly not then,
but whom G. P. in the flesh or spirit, would very naturally ask
about. He was not known to ,its. Piper or Hodgson. H.H.]
S.— ' First-rate, I think.' G. P.—' Good. Can't I help him don,
you think ! How are you getting on with your writing old man t
Can't I help youf"
Apparently referring to my literary work aforesaid. This
desire to help is constantly manifested by G. P., and is,
on the whole, more characteristic of those in the alleged
new life — certainly of G. P. — than in this life.
Ch. XXYIII]
Gf. P. Criticises Remote Conversation
386
"Q. P. — ,*I think he is going acroes water.* S. — ,'Do you
mean I ami ' G. P. — ' No F. J. [a common friend not in my
mind at the time] rundeciph.]/ S. — ,'Will you answer me a
question r Q. P.—' Yes I should be pleased/ S.—* Will you tell
me what you think of that talk last night t' [A controyersial
talk on philosophic subjects at the Century Club table, as I
remember, in which Hodgson and I had participated.] G. P.,* Nonsense.' [Possibly medium telepathically gave my own impression. The hand motioned to me not to speak, and the
written answers anticipated what I thought of saying.] G. P.
— * I know what you would ask, so will, yes I. Baby nonsense
or talk this is my well.' S. — * It made me tired.' G. P. — , So
it does me and it is rubbish. Rubbish don't bother your clear
brain about such trash... if it moves at ...thanks [probably
for assistance with pencil!] ... if it moves at all it will onJb,
talk baby talk . . . yes tell him he goes to B
[unrecognized
now] and hears nonsense.' H. — ,'Now tell him.' S. — ,'She
reads my mind like a book' [referring to medium]. G. P.,
' Not out of your mind old chap you mistake it concerns E. G.
and yours truly.'
« S.— [to Hodgson] ' Do you know who E. G. is!' [Writing
resumed.] G. P. — , Perf ecdy. Oh, yes, Edmund Qumey. He
was there and tried to get... (when was itt) the impression
where you dined where D.t' S. — ,,Dined! ' [Referring to
occasion of aforesaid talk.] G. P. — ,'Yes. Yes.' S. — 'You
think it was nonsense!' G. P. — ,'Exactly. Rightly named,
yes. This is what I am trying to tell you my good friend:
your clear brain ought to dear up such nonsense.' 8.—
[or possibly Hodgsrai] 'But you held the mind-stuff theory
yourself.' G. P. — ,'Well, mind stuff theory is all right when
put on a clear basis... no... but I want to keep you fellows
on the right track, you certainly understand me very well
considering you know me so little in my present state . . . yes . . •
very . . . perfectly oidy I find it a little difficult to express my
thoughts through this protoplasm. [Note 3.1 Exactly . . . yes . . »
evolution . . . yes . • •' S. — * What can you tell me about A. ! ' G.
P. — * All about him.' 8. — * Are you troubled about him f ' G. P.
,,* Not exactly troubled, yet I am afraid he has a mood of depres ion at the present time which is not entirely satisfactory,
think so, H. I... What about your work? are you clearing up
weather any maters [matters?] and how about cosmical weather.
[This was on G. P.'s mind especially in conection with Hodgson
who was present, but I don't know that he had ever discussed it
with me] . . . Philosophy.' [Topics I was working on.] 8. —
' Can you tell me my name 1 ' G. P. — ' Yes, I will surprise, I
will surprise you in a moment by telling you old chap just who
are.'"
youThia
illustrates >ooe of the moat perplexing and frequent
886
Mr8. P%p$r: Authar,s Experience [Bk. II, Pt lY
features of mediomistic oommunicationB. If the medium
was simply reading my mind, why shouldn, she promptly
read so dear and simple a thing as my own name, especially
as, on the telepathic hypothesis, she was reading much foggier
and more complex things? Her not doing so, and numberless similar cases, make very strongly against the telepathic
hypothesis. But on the spiritistic hypothesis, why should
my old friend delay giving my name, and end without giving
it at all? When at last it was given (see below) it was by
my ostensible remote cousin, who never saw me. Still the
•umame was his own.
', G. P. [continuing] — * I am also [ t] talking baby talk • . •
yes . . . what about the one and the many, the many and the one.
(Same true as regards '' cosmical weather." See above] . . . yes,
will here. ..do you believe in telepathy t A AUB [substituted letters, harking back to A.'s troubles.] Yes . • . and will be
the instigator, hear you mef Where is [undeoiph.], Verm [t]
yes . . • yes . • . tell me I must dear up these things H. I know.
Give me time and FU explain all, don't worry me, do you...
D ... e too bad.* ,
The writing here became very hurried and confused, apparently from the attempted intrusion of my young cousin,
Albert, who had lately been drowned, and who now seemed
to appear and want to communicate.
"G. P. [apparently to my cousin].—* Pll tdl him ... yes in
a moment, did you ... oh, I can't hear you [apparently a child
of mine breaks in here and is addressed by G. P.] weU dear,
come along ... Papa ... who is Boy [t] Bay yes... all. ..yes
• . . but
there tois stop
a child
here ' [I had
lost and
children,
the
medium
impersonating
them,
she leftandthewilled
subject. Note 41. G. P. — ' and a young Hall [effort, as appears
later, for Holt] who passed out of [the body?] by drowning
[My cousin. I never saw himi the yoimg man is, he died, as
you term it, by drowning, and nis name is Alfred' [wrong, but
corrected later.] S. — ,'What's his other namet' G. P. — ,'Am
telling. . you
can't. . you
what
. Hackett
. yes wait?
... all I Haccket
hear ... heG....[or
yes J.]
andAlfred...
he knew
him very well.' S. — * The name Alfred is a mistake.' G. P. —
' Not a mistake, not in the least Don't you recall Alfred? He
knew you years ago perfectly and John also, he was the one
who was with him."*
This looks like an echo of the prominence in the mind
of most Holts of the name of Sir John, the English chief
Ch. XXVIII] Sitter'g Drowned Cousin Manifested
387
justice in the seveiiteenth century, from whom not a few
of the Americans of the name claim to be descended, in spite
of the fact that he had no children.
**S. — ,'I don't know him/ Q, P. — ,'Ton do know him...
this... yes... it is so and right ask John unrecognizedl he
is... brother |[Albert had no brother John' [?[[ in earth...
fes . . . this is important. Henry ' [Sitter's Christian
name. G.
, never used it in life.] S. — ,'Are you sure Alfred is the
name?' G. P. — ,'I am not sure but I think it is very nearly
right as I hear it. HA...H O W I know, don't mind me.'
S. — ,'I am listening [Heading probably meant] attentively.'
G. P. — ' You don't quite believe me, that is that I am I Yes. yet
I am all that remains of yours truly G. P. H on Hom H o r t e
on [Farther efforts towards sitter's name.] (S. Hortoni) no
leave . . . H o n . . . I want . . . please don't worry him [apparently
alluding to cousin] he is in a dream keep quiet and let him see
where he is . . . yes . . . Ard [ ?] for him . . . yes I did . . . Alfred J
[or G ?] are you talking H • . . Haris . . . what . . . Hany [Sitter's
usual name with intimates, but G. P. never used it in life] . . •
keep clear if you can and TH help Hone.' [Apparently my
cousin shoves G. P. aside and takes control of the medium.]
A. — , Do speak speak to me now • . . not 11.' S. — * Yes you were
drowned.' A. — * You know me. Do, oh do tell my mother to
cheer up and don't worry •••she...yes.,. Holt [Correct at
last] . . . Yes.' "
Some people are so opposed to the spiritistic hypothesis,
or perhaps I should say to any hypothesis but fraud, that they
attribute to it this ,' feeling for '' names which is very frequent
among mediums. I can't see any indication that it may not
be a perfectly natural process, on the hypothesis of limited
power both to apprehend and to communicate in either
,' spirit " or medium, or of obstacles to both, which the means
are not fitted readily to overcome.
"G. P. [apparently] — , and you must speak to him, you heard
...you...' S. — ,* Where is lus mother t' A. [apparently]—
* In the South . . . yes . . .' [she had been there lately, but had
returned. I knew the first fact, and I think I knew the second.] S.— ,'Are you sure she's in the South?' A. — ,"Yes she
is there now.' [Note 6.] S. — ,'Does she live there?' A.—
' No, not her home/ [Correct.] ' Alfred now you must know,
do, oh do please. [See Note 6.] I ask of you it was the greatest sorrow to her . . . yes . . . [undeciph.] and Uncle Will [not
recognized. See below regarding identifying mother.] will
know.' S.— ' Uncle Will ? ' A.—' W not William not . . . No . . .
will know.' S. — ,*Will know?' A. — ,•Yes, please tell her for
888
Mrs. Piper: AvXhot,M Experience
[Bk. II, Pt lY
me.
[Several
ground*Writing
apparenfl7»
that
they luid
been pencils
handled rq'ected,
by other— on
persona.
resumed.]
Thanks ... don't let anybody touch those any more...no...
thanks.' S. — ,, Won't it be distressing if I tell his mother?'
A.-*' Tell her. But I shall be there before you are, and I will
help her to bear it. Albert was my name — brightly spelt [for
the first time] but she called me Al • . . yes and Allie.' "
The medium stopped writing, and Phinuit took control
again, speaking:
,'P. — ,'There's a great deal more thought here than's said.
Do you sleep pretty well? ,I did not.] You sit in chair
with arms, and write on bits of paper [True: on pad.]
I!gg8 are very good for you.' S. — ,'All of the egg! ' [I usea
tiie white at breakfast daily.] P. — ,'You take the white of it
▼ery nicely.' [Correct.] S. — , You are reading my mind. How
about fruit f P. — ,Trait's good.' [It was very bad for me,
though I persisted in it from mistaken advice. Phinuit appears
to have telepathically received my false impression.] S. —
* These are only vague generalities.' P. — * Well, that's specific
enough. Do you want me to tell you the color of your grandfather's cat's tail?' [Sitter asks about wines, mentioning
names. — ,Phinuit said he didn't know names of places. — Sitter
speaks of white wines, etc., and Bhine wines.] S. — , Not [good]
for me ? ' P. — * White wines good — acid. Sweet wines not good.
[Correct.] You taste oranges when you eat them. They come
up in your throat.'"
I ate them habitually at breakfast. This and the armchair and writing are wonderful bits of telepathy— or something else.
"S.— 'If I don't eat fruit, Pll get lithemia.' P.— 'Tiie
potatoes.' S. — ,'Disagreeing with ,e faculty.' P. — ,'Grated
potatoes beaten with milk. Something the matter with liver? '
S. — * Now No.' [Sitter had taken blue pill the night before.]
P. — , There's no disease in your liver.' " [Correct, Note 7].
0. P. seems to return.
"G. P. — , He seems to be very anxious H. [apparently referring
to Albert] and will say... Oh! Here comes a military man
with epaulets on his idioulders and had a bullet wound in his
head... too bad' [see below]. S. — ,'But Geoige people don't
wear epaulets on their Imees.' P. — ,'On knees? Who said
knees? ' S. — * You're getting tautological.' G. P. — , Not in the
least H. but I am as in a dream. Shall I be more philosophical?' 8.—'Oh no I But be like yourself .' G. P.— 'But you
seem not like yourself any more than I, I don't know why.
CL XXVIII]
Errors Mixed with Truths
389
Perhaps you can explain Why Why Why. Yee...ye8...hi8
son has been speaking now to me [apparently a repetition of
why recalled to Sitter's mind a similar habit of repeating
"Why? Why* Why?" in Sitter's living Httle son, and the impression went over telepathically into the medium, leading to
a confusion of my living son with the drowned cousin] . . . yes
he wants to have Helen know where he is. £1 liza... Ellen
[no such person recognized: not his mother's name.] . . .yes in
the body?' S.—* Where is she now?' G. P.—* In the South
I hear. Do speak.' S. — ,'What color was the military suit?'
Q. P.— 'It was Bed.'"
This is suggestive. I associate my cousin Albert, father
of the drowned boy, with visits in diildhood to my grandfather's, and one of the conspicuous recollections of those visits
is a young cousin in a much-too-big red military coat that
one of the elders used to wear at '' general trainin'.,' But
the bullet hole is a mystery. The '' grandpire aux Frangais ,*
in my Foster sitting is said to have been a general, but he was
not of that family, and I never looked him up.
*' O. P. — * Now you must speak I cannot keep him up and seem
my natural self, not for |T| him.. .there was [is?] a sister
Margaret . . . [No sister. H.H.] Al . . • I declare you must
speak . . . dazea . . . why ...Hou Hou Hor Hor Ho a.'
S. — , It would be unf ortimate to add an x, Qeorge.' G. P. — * No
sarcasm needed.' S. — ,'I don't mean it as sarcasm.' G. P. —
' Thanks. Thanks, no I should must confess I should not treat
you thus, not much, too bad, help the poor feUow will you H.
. . . you can indeed. Where am • • • yea trust me as you used . . •
did in years gone by. I look ... yes ... tell father I have ex•"*
plained all . . . will explain and it will be clear to . . • We
Possibly Albert had resumed ''control," though this may
have been a reference by G. P. to his own father, with
whom I had always been miore intimate than with G. P.
himself.
"G.P.— 'Where is H—s?' 8.— 'H— s?' G.P.— 'Yes.' [It
happened that the sitter had been thinking specially of H — s the
day before.] G. P. — * Tell him W. [H — s's deceased daughter] is
really not dead, and is with H. a great deal . . . yes . . . H. . . .'
8. — * What H. ? ' [For some reason, probably the indistinctness
of the writing, the name does not seem to have been clear at
the moment, though it was later recognized.] G. P. — ' In the
body . . . yes . . . yes • . . and you remember him or I do. Ask her
father and the message wiU [undeciph. — ,,'be taken" — see below.] Frank. [Possibly a dear friend of Sitter, wislung to
890
Mrs. Pip,r: Aulhaf,s Exp0ri0ne$
[Bk. 11, PL IV
oommimicate, bat too late for the medium's psychokinetic power.
[Note 8] . . . yes . . . what [undecipk] my thinking now ... be
taken . . . little mixed • • . who is Stead fPerhaps the well known
W. T. Stead, who was then risiting mediums] . . • no aU right • . .
do you know A. [undeciph.] ...yes theie it is...Albert H —
J H— A J H— I am going.*''
The writing ends abruptly, and the medium wakes.
I make no apology for having treated the apparent personalities atone moment as if they were simply human beings
in a new stage of existence, and at the next moment as if they
were dramatizations by the medium. The first method is
of course sometimes adopted provisionally as the most convenient, but both ways correspond to the alternating impressions of any sitter not die-stamped with the spiritist view
or its extreme opposite. When I was a score of years younger
(and wiser, as the younger think?), I should have been
more consistent — ,in the non-spiritistic way. Now, while I
believe in a future life, so far as it will do to use the word
', believe ', in the absence of complete verification (whatever
that may mean), I am still in doubt whether ''the spirits
of just men made perfect " or the spirits of any men at all,
speak through the mediums. At the moment I suspect they
impress the mediums telepathically to speak for them. This
seems as in ordinary dreams, only so much more intensely that
(as sometimes in my dreams) the dreamer feels identified with
itte '' agent,'' and Mrs. Piper speaks as the agent.
The following comments would have interrupted the memoranda of the sittings too much, had they been placed among
them.
Note 1. The amount of disQussion already bestowed upon
Dr. Phinuit, of whom we shall see much more, almost places
him, with Junius, not to speak of the Baconian Shakspere, among the great problematical characters of literature.
Through the dozen volumes of the S. P. R., from VI, where
he makes his first appearance, up to where he disappears,
nearly every commentator has a whack at him, and the
whacks soon get very amusing.
Half the whackers say he does not know French; the other
half prove that he does. Mrs. Sidgwick and Mr. Lang state
that he does not, and consider him an unmitigated scoundreL
CfL XXYIII]
Opinions Matters of Temperament
391
ITeifher of these commentators, by the way, was a ''good
sitter/' On the other hand, Mr. Bich, who was a good sitter,
found Phinuit at home in French; Sir Oliver Lodge, also a
good sitter, is fond of the old fellow; and I, who also am a
good sitter, think Phintiit, not only as I. talked with him,
but as I have read about everything in print regarding him,
one of the most natural and amusing characters I ever met,
and far from the least lovable.
Half the commentators say that he is an ignorant quack,
who never uses a scientific term; the other half say that
he has helped them and their friends, and given them efiS*
cacious prescriptions abounding in the technicalities of the
pharmacopeia.
The whole discussion is a very remarkable instance — ,remarkable even in the debatable regions of Psychical Research
—of how honest and intelligent people amid new and ques*
tionable experiences, do not see with their eyes or heat with
their ears, but do both with their temperaments. The evidence will increase as we proceed.
An objection is reasonably taken to Phinuifs uncertain
and unverifiable character. But that character is not nearly
as uncertain and unverifiable as some commentators make
out Wherever Mrs. Piper got the Phinuit of my sitting,
whether from her own invention or from me, or from himself,
she certaioly did not get from me his prescription of grated
potatoes as a cure for my ailments : all I had to give in that
line was objection by the very highest authorities to just
that food. Of all ways to account for him yet proposed,
far the least labored seems to be that she got him from
himself; but being the least labored does not necessarily prove
that way the nearest correct. Maybe it will yet be found
correct in the form that she got him from the cosmic consciousness, where perhaps he and she and you and I are
always to be found by such as have the finding power.
Note 2. The medium gets impressions of all sorts from
things and persons connected with the sitter or the control.
In this instance, I was ''connected with'' B, but only so
far as he had become a professor at Yale long after my
graduation : I did not know him personally. But my intimate
398
MfM. Piper: Aidhof,s Experience
[Bk. II, Ft lY
oonnection with A was not only direct, but through aeyeral
persons intimate with ns both and with G. P. Mere telepathy, certainly mere telepathy from my mind, would have
"spotted *, some one of these connections much more readily
thim the allied one with B, which was hardly a connection
at all. The simplest solution for the whole business, though
perhaps not the most *' scientific,'' or even rational, is that
the spirit of 0. P. was troubled about A, and habitually
thinking of me at the TJniyersity Club as a Yale man,
was reminded, on my turning up at the stance, of the solution
of A's troubles proposed by B, who was at Yale, and, it turned
out later, was trying to get A a place there, mA. O. P.
wanted me to help.
NoTB 3. "This protoplasm.'' 0. P. uses the expression
at other sittings, and I think iliat no other of Mrs. Piper,s
controls does. If she makes them herself, how does she keep
them so distinct? The sittings, however, abound in complaints from the controls that they find it hard to express
themselves through the "too solid flesh " of the mediums.
Note 4. Illustrations of the same experience (in shutting
off would-be communicators, by will) are frequent. I am
evidently far from alone in feeling a repugnance from having communications from loved and lost ones pass through
the body or even the dreams of a stranger. But those who
seek such commumoations may have better nervous organisms
than mine, and I do not wish to have my avoiding what pur*
ported to be such communications, indicative of any opinion
regarding their genuineness.
I experience no such repugnance regarding communications
in my own dreams, as will be abundantly demonstrated later:
for there the communication is not through an intermediary.
Note 5. This is one of the very frequent cases of the
medium going counter to the sitter,s knowledge, and goes
to controvert the telepathic theory. Among such cases are
many where the medium (or control) turns out to be rights
and the sitter wrong.
Note 6. This intense desire, so natural under the alleged
circumstanoes, to prove survival to their friends, will he
found characteristic of virtually all the controls. Those
Ch. XXYIII]
ConiroU Wish to Prove Survival
398
daimiTig to be persons familiar while on earth with the
methods of Psychical Besearch, strenuously and ingeniously
nse those metiiods for the purpose. We shall find, after
the deaths of Myers and Hodgson, that their alleged spirits,
like that of G. P., apparently bent all their powers toward
that end. With them it is generally alleged to be for the
promotion of science, but with the controls generally, as in
the case just given, it is of course for the comfort of survivors,
NoTS 7. As already intimated, there has been a great
deal of difference among the commentators as to Phinuit's
knowledge and capacity as a physician. His diagnosis of
me might have been telepathic from me, but his dietary
certainly was not He has made many diagnoses that certainly were not telepathic, and prescriptions as technical as
doctors generally make, with good results. Instances will
appear in later extracts.
Note 8. "Prank [possibly a dear friend,*' etc.]. I said
"possibly,*' and after " dear friend " I was tempted to add :
, or Mrs. Piper's personation of one.'' But why should Mrs.
Piper personate an individual she never heard of, and of
course cares nothing about, for the delectation of another
individual she never heard of and cares nothing about?
The answer, " Because the latter gives her ten dollars," doesn't
fit the case: she is amply demonstrated to be not that sort
of person. Perhaps James would say, in his pet phraseology :
Because she has a " will to communicate," which is another
way of saying: Because she wants to. But why should she
want to? And why, on the telepathic hypothesis, out of
the hundreds of persons who have affected my memories,
should she pick out this friend when I had not him specially
in mind, and when there were "on the other side" other
persons whose effect on me had been much greater? Or,
to put a stronger case, if she picked O. P. out of my mind,
why of all people who have left traces there should it be he?
The traces of him were not as strong as those of many other
men much younger than myself. Such questions have been
asked by innumerable sitters. The only answer worth con*
sidering that I have seen, and that may not be worth much,
is that when the sitter does not select the communicator.
894
Mft. Piper: Atahat,s Expmence
[Bk. 11, Ft IV
and Mrs. Piper does not, ihe only altenuLtive is that he
selects himself — ,thaty in this case, G. F, communicated because before he died he had determined and announced that
if there was any sunrival of death he was going to gire
evidence of it if he could; and "Frank/' if tiie occurrenoe
of the name had anything to do with my friend, sought to
communicate probably because he was of a peculiarly affeo*
tionate disposition — ,peculiarly apt to want to console tiiose
who had mourned him, and among his generally conservative
circle of friends I was the first one who had given him any
chance by turning up at a sitting. If at the time, amid the
confusion natural to both the sitter's mind and the writing,
I had attached all this significance to the name, probably
I should have tried to give him the chance; but probably I
would not have succeeded: for ''the light was going out,'*
as the controls generally express it. Many of them have
declared that to them a medium, when in condition to receive
communication, is surrounded by a light, and that as the
nervous s,isibility or capacity is consumed in the process
of communication, the light fades away. When I say : ''the
controls say" this, I am not expressing any opinion as to
what a control is. The reader, if he is built that way, may,
for all me, consider it a fraudulent impersonation by a sec*
ondary self of the medium, and made up of data telepathically
acquired. But the reader, by the time he gets through with
the facts, will find himself saddled with a pretty tough job.
A good many people, however, and some of them not very
highly endowed, have been equal to the job, or thought
they were.
The uninitiated reader who has struggled through the
incoherences of this sitting will probably be surprised and,
I fear, discouraged to learn that, judging by the published
records of other sittings, this is a fairly good one. I take
shame to myself for neglecting to write out my comments and
return the record to Hodgson. With his experience, he prob*
ably would have edited it into much more comprehensible
shape. I prefer to leave it with its imperfections.
If, instead of attributing the whole thing to telepathy,
I had then estimated the importance of the subject as I
Ch. XXVUI]
Change$ in AfdHaf,s TUws
895
do now, and had the leiaue I have uom, I should ha,e
returned it, e?en if I had realized that, after eighteen years,
my comments would be much better informed, and I would
have occasion to use the matter again in an exposition of
my own. But my attitude regarding spiritism — ,that it was
nothing but telepathy from the sitter, ha?ing been fixed in
my interview with Foster, and considerable reading and intimate associati(m with Hodgson and some other members
of the S. P. B. not having changed it; and finding, at the
time, in my stance with Mrs. Piper nothing but telepathy,
I felt no interest in farther personal investigation.
I went away from the sitting with the conviction : , She
gave me nothing which was not in my own mind : if s the
same old stoiy '' ; and I have not been near a medium since,
and do not care to go.
After this confession, my venturing to write upon the
subject may seem to others, as it often does to me, pre«
sumptuous. That view, however, would have silenced most
of the historians: for hardly any one of them, or even any
editor, witnesses the events or hears the debates that he generalizes upon; nor often does any philosopher discover or even
witness most of the facto that he correlates, nor (I hope I am
not wearjring you) any scientist most of the facto on which
he bases his discoveries.
There exist better books on this department of my subject
than I dare hope thia is going to be, but most of the
good ones appeal principally to stndento who have held
many sittings; and were b,, to support theses, while
I write for lay readers, and at least b,gan with the intention
of letting the theses regarding this part of my subject form
themselves as I should go along. Moreover, my long experience as a publisher has teught me that intermediaries are
needed between experto and lay readers. I have habitually
said to experto to whom I have suggested non-technical books :
''The right point of view must cover both knowledge and
ignorance; I can trust you for the knowledge, and I can
supply the ignorance.'' I am doing something of that here.
Nevertheless, if the persons who get and read an average
book, would get and read the forty volumes of the Proceedings
396
Un. Pip,sr: Afdhw,s Bsperienee
[Bk. 11, Pi lY
and Journal of tbe S. P. R, and would arrange from their
necessarily heterogeneoua contentB, fairly systematic presenta,
tions of the principal classes of phenomena, probably this book
would not have been written. I even doubt if it would have
been if there were any probability that as many persons as
may read it, would even read, in Part XXXIU (Vol. XIII),
Hodgson's treatment of the ground he covers. There are only
two reasons why I do not advise you, if your time is limited,
to drop this book where you are, and substitute that : Hodgson
does not cover the ground that I shall attempt to cover in
my chapters on the dream life, and in my final summary, and
in the passages preliminary to them; and, so far as I know,
no other writer on the general subject has been as persistently
haunted as I have by the conception of the Cosmic Soul.
And again, in a subject consisting so largely of speculation, and interpreted so largely by temperament, there is
a chance of almost any work, however humble, doing something that other works do not.
Behind all the apologia I have given, is the fact that I have
found the change from a disbelief in the survival of bodily
death, so fruitful, intellectually as well as emotionally, that I
am prompted to do what I can to share it with others. Nevertheless, my convictions do not rest on the phenomena of
mediumship, to which I do not yet confidentiy assign the
spiritistic hypothesis — at least as it is usually understood.
But when, about 1908, I had my long row of " Proceedings ''bound up, and began to read consecutively what, before,
I had merely dipped into spasmodically, the aspects of the
evidence underwent some change. Moreover, in the meantime Ihad received, in other ways, indications pointing more
strongly to survival of bodily death than to any explanation
I could frame or find (see Chapter LV). This of course
tended to change my point of view regarding the phenomena
shown by the ', mediums,'' but by no means reversed it
I gradually realized, however, that my conclusion that Mrs.
Piper gave me nothing which was not in my own mind, was
very superficial. The effect on me of reading the Proceedings isthat if we render unto telepathy all the things
which are telepathy's, there is still a great deal to be accounted for. Ascribe every verified statement in the reports,
CL XXYIII]
Experiences Outride Taepathy
397
if you will, to telepathy, and what are you going to do with
the immenae number of alleged personages through whom
the statements come, with their own consistent opinions
regarding the statements and other things, their initiatiyes,
discriminations, responses, retaliations?
Mrs. Piper gave me at least the following things which
were not in my own mind :
I. The impersonation of Fhinuit. Mrs. Piper didn't get
from me his humor or bumptiousness or medical skill or
philanthropy or dramatic qualities generally.
She may have got him from the first medium with whom
she sat (see Chapter XXIX), and it may have been a delib*
erate invention of that medium, expanded by her ; but not by
her supraliminal self: for that knows next to nothing of what
occurs in her trances; and her honesty regarding it is now
beyond all question. If she had developed and expanded
a fictitious dramatic impersonation, which she calls Phinnit,
she did it through her subliminal self — an activity to which
I find it more and more difficult to apply the term *, self,'' ex«
cept only so far as its nature and degree are determined by the
conformation of the self as a receiving and transmitting in«
strument But so far as the subliminal self is a motive power,
I grow less and less able to conceive it as anything but
a cosmic infiow, different from the cosmic inflow making
our ordinary (supraliminal) selves, in being a special influx depending upon some unusual circumstance — ,in Mrs.
Piper's case, presence of a sitter and the condition of trance.
In guessing the Cosmic Soul to contain in some mysterious way ,'the potency and power" of all the ideas,
impressions, memories, psychical activities in what we call
the universe, I of course guess it to contain all the groups
of them which we call personalities. Until lately, person*
alities have appeared to be ',real or imaginary": the real
ones appearing to be created by a spontaneous cosmic inflow
independent of any human volition, into a receptacle that
we know in each case as an independent human body; the
imaginary ones, so far as we have known until lately, are
created by a cosmic inflow eaughi and controlled more or less
deflnitely by a real personality-r-an author. We know some of
898
Mrs. Piper: Autkat,a Experience [Bk. 11, Pt lY
fliem as Colonel Esmond, Bedrjr Sharp, lago, Bosalind, and
the like, and entertain regarding them many of the opinions
and feelings that we entertain regarding real personalitieB.
Now supposing Phinnit nerer to hare existed in the flesh, are
he and his dass, of these imaginary personalities, or do they
belong to still a third dass— a cosmic inflow without a
, human body,'' and yet not ,created by a cosmic inflow
sought or controlled ... by a real personality "? If he did
once exist in the flesh, of course he is just such an individual
effect of the cosmic inflow as O. P. and my cousin and hosts
like them, and as you and I may yet be — ,in fact are already,
only we have so far been (or had to be) content to use only
our own bodies.
This is guess and speculation. Whether Fm ready to
swear to it as fact, as I do to the words uttered to me by
the Phinuit personality or impersonation I am guessing
about, is another matter.
II. Mrs. Piper did not get from me Phinuit's statement,
whether true or not, that I am a medium — a point on which
there was probably never an opinion, or even a curiosity, in
any mortal mind. Whence, then, could the assertion have been
telepaihed ? I am a very good dreamer, and she may have perceived some mediumistic quality in my makeup. There is
probably more than is realized, in everybody's.
III. She did not get from me Phinuit's question whether
I wanted him to tell me the length of my grandfather's caf s
tail.
lY. She did not get from me the dramatic verisimilitude
of O. P.'s comments and remarks. / didn't call her ,Hhis
protoplasm "; and she didn't call herself that by a long shot
Then somebody other than I must have invented those phrases
and all the other things she did not get from me. To say that
she did, is, as we shall have abundant evidence later, to say
that she is the greatest dramatist that ever lived. To say
that her subliminal self did, is but to beg the question. So
is it to say that a secondary self was Phinuit and a tertiaiy
self O. P., and so on down to the hundreds of her controls.
y. She did not get from me the facts about A and B,
yet she may have got them tdoteropathically from either or
both of those persons.
Ch. XXYIII]
Tehpathy Inadequate
399
VI. She did not get from me her 0. P. : for hers was
not merely the 0. P. I had known, but one who had growxL
She may have got from me some facts of his personality,
but where did she get his anxiety to prove his continued
existence, and to have me do something to better the state
of affairs with A and B?
YII. She may hare got from me the facts that my cousin
Albert was drowned and that his mother was (or had been)
in the South, but she did not get from me his poignant
anxiety to have me tell his mother that he had surrived the
drowning.
Among these seven points are germs which we will find
growing as we proceed to sittings of far more interest
CHAPTEB
XXIX
HODGSON'S FIRST PIPER REPORT, 1888-91
Mrs. Pipm,B Early Experiences
Froic my experiences with Mrs. Piper, let us now torn to
the records where, hut for reasons given, we would naturally
have begun.
Probably the first public mention of Mrs. Piper in any
organ seriously associated with science is in the Proceedings of
the American S.P.B. for July, 1886. On p. 95 is the statement:
, *' In two
persons
them being phenomena)
the Mrs. P. who
is mentioned in the
rei>ort(one
on of
mediumistic
an arm
was
made absolutely angsthetic, whilst retaining its muscular con«
tractility/'
And in the ,' report '' aforesaid (pp. 102-6) signed by no
less a person than James, it is stated :
"This lady can at will pass into a trance condition, in which
she is ' controled ' by a power purporting to be the spirit of a
French doctor, who senres as intermediary between the sitter and
the deceased friends. This is the ordinary type of trance-mediumship at the present day.
', I am persuaded of the medium's honesty, and of the genuine*
ness of her trance; and . . .1 now believe her to be in possession
of a power as yet unexplained.''
Now the hypnotic theory of telepsychosis that I advanced
earlier, if it is to fit Mrs. Piper, must be modified to this
extent. She is not readily thrown into the hypnotic trance
by anybody but herself. Neither is she susceptible to ordinary
thought-transference, when vigilant, like Mr. Outhrie's young
women, and she has an appreciable number of failures
in trance. James reports on all that in Pr. American S.P.B.,
102f ., and adds :
"So far as the evidence goes,400then, her medium-trance seems
r
Ch. XXIX]
Mrs. Piper,s Early Experiences 401
an isolated feature in her p,chology. This wotild of itself be
an important result if it could be established and generalized. "
The result seems to have since been *' established and generalized/' and she does not even exhibit telekinesis, which
was done by Foster, Home, and Moses.
The first important report published on Mrs. Piper is in
Ft. VI, by Myers, Lodge, and James, and covers sittings in
England from the latter part of November, 1889 till early in
February, 1890. But this does not deal with manifestations as
early as some reported in Pr. VIII by Hodgson, and covering
sittings from 1887 through 1891. In ma,ng my selections,
I will attempt to follow chronology as closely as practicable,
and accordingly will draw on Pr. VIII before Pr. VI.
The papers in the Proceedings being prepared by different
persons, widely differently circumstanced, even in different
continents (not excluding Asia), the order of their publication was by no means that of the occurrence of the events
they chronicled. Hence in our attempts at a chronological
order, which at best we can attain but very roughly, we will
have to skip to and fro among the volumes.
Hodgson prefaces his report with an interesting account of
Mrs. Piper's initiation into mediumahip (Pr. VIII, 46f.) :
i
, Mrs. Piper herself has given me what information she could.
In reply to inquiries in January, 1888, she informed me that her
husband's father and mother ... in 1884 . • . persuaded her to try
consultation with a medixmi who gave medical advice. She was
at that time suffering from a tumor. She visited Mr. J. B.
Codce, a blind medium, also a developer' of mediums. He
professed to be controlled by tt French physician whose name was
pronounced Finny. While there, she felt curious twitchings,
and thought she might become completely unconscious. On a
second visit to Mr. Oocke he placed his hands on her head, and
shortly after she became unconscious. As she was losing consciousness she was aware of a flood of light and saw strange
faces, and a hand moving before her. The ' flood of light ' she
had experienced once before, a few months previously; it immediately preceded a swoon, caused by a sudden blow on the side
of the head. When she lost consciousness on the occasion of her
second visit to Mr. Oocke, she was said to have been controlled
by an Indian girl who gave the name * Ohlorine,' and to have
given a remarkable test to a stranger who was present. She
402
Hodgson's First Piper Report [Bk. 11, PL IV
had ■evend more dttmgs with Mr. Oodke, and was again oon*
trolled, apparently on each oooasion by , Chlorine.' "
This name is evidently pitched npon on account of its
enphony and apparent femininity, by some consdonsness—
we canH tell whose, perhaps Mrs. Piper's subliminal (whatever that may mean) — ,unaware of the meaning of the word
(which I hardly need tell the reader nsnally refers to a
rather fetid gas), and especially of its etymological meaning —
light green.
Hodgson continnes :
, On her second visit to Mr. CoAe, he professed to be controlled byJohn Sebastian Bach. After this she tried sitting at
home with her relatives and friends. PhinuU (sic) * controlled '
first, andtrolled atsince
then r,ularly,
but she
was also
ostensibly
conoccasional
times by Mrs.
Siddons,
Bach,
Longfellow,
Commodore Vanderbilt, and Loretta PonchinL It was said that
* Mrs. Siddons ' recited a scene from Macbeth, Longfellow waa
said to have written some verses, and Loretta Ponchini (who
purported to be an Italian girl) to have made some drawings.
Th, verses and drawings have not been preserved
"Dr. Pbinuit only came at first to give medical advice. Ha
*trivial/
didn't care to come for other matters,' as he thought them * too
, Finally Sebastian Bach said they were going to concentrate
all their powers on Phinuit, and he ultimately became the chief
oontroL
, Mr. Piper says that there is no question but that it is the
same Phinuit or personality who controls Dr. Cocke, no matter
how their names are spelt."
The questions regarding him are different from those regarding most of the other controls : for, with the exception of
ibe Imperator group, they, in ordinary life, were generally
known, personally or historically, to the sitters; while Phinuit
has loomed upon the world as free from origins as Melchizedek, and some people think, despite his lack of priestly ways,
with as important a mission. But he has alleged a lot of
origins that, so far, cannot be traced. Even, however, if
they never can be, the fact would not prove that he never
existed.
He himself (I use the term simply for convenience, without
expressing any opinion, and shall do so freely regarding other
controls) says through Mrs. Piper (Pr. YIII, 60; Hodgson's
conxments are interspersed) :
Ch. XXIX]
PhinuiVB Aecawi* of Himself
403
','Phinuit is one of my names; Sdiville is my other name;
Dr. Jean Phinuit ScUville; they always called me Dr. Phinnit.'
He was unable to tell the year of his birth or the year of his
death, but by putting together sereral of his statements, it would
appear that be was bom about 1790 and died about 1860. He
was bom in Marseilles, went to school and studied medicine at a
college in Paris called * Merciana '(f) College, where he took his
degree when he was between twen,-fire and twenty-eight years
old. 'Merciana* Tou know the name ', Meershaum " f That
is the same name; I cannot spell it; sounds something like that.'
He also studied medicine at * Mats, in Germany.' At the age of
thirty-five he married Marie Latimer, who had a sister named
Josephine. 'Josephine was a sweetheart of mine first, but I
went back on her and married Marie after all.' Marie was
thirty years of age when he married her, and died when she was
about fifty. He had no children. P. : ' Do you know where the
Hospital of Ood is. Hospital de Dieu (H6tel Dieu)f ' Sitter:
' It is in Paris.' P. : ' Do you remember old Dyraputiat Dsrruputia [Dupuytrent] was the head of the hospital, and there is
a street named for lum.' He went to London and from London
to Belgium. * I went to Tory different places after my health
broke down.' "
On Dec. 26, 1889, Phinuit said to Sir Oliver Lodge through
Mrs, Piper (Pr. VI, 620) ;
"' I have been 80 to 85 years in spirit, I think. I died when I
was 70 of leprosy, very disagreeable. I had been to Australia
and Switzerland. My wife's name was Mary Latimer. I had a
sister Josephine (p. 495). John was my father's name. I
studied medicine at Mets» where I took my degree at 30 years
old, married at 35. Get someone to look all this up, and take
pains about it. Look up the town of
, also the Hotel Dieu
in Paris. I was bom in Marseilles, am a Southern French gentleman. Find out a woman named Oarey. Irish. Mother Irish,
father French. I had compassion on her in the hospital My
name is John Phinuit Schlevelle (or f Clavelle), but I was
always called Dr. Phinuit. Do you know Dr. Clinton Perry!
Find him at Dupuytren, and this woman at the Hotel Dieu.
There's a street named Dupuytren, a great street for doctors. . . •
.This is my business now, to conununicate with those in the body,
and make them believe our existence.' "
Hodgson comments regarding the statements he quoted, and
that just given. He says :
"Some discrepancies will be noticed between these statements
and those given in Pr.VI,5iM), and I understand that no trace of
'Jean Phinuit Schliville' has been discovered at the medical
schools where Phinuit claims to have studied and practised* or
404
Eodgsm's First Piper Report [Bk. EC, Pt IV
along other lines of inqoiiy suggested by the few fragments
which he offers of his life histoiy
, Concerning his inability to speak French, Phinnit's original
e3q>lanation to me was that he had liyed in Mets the latter part
of his life, and there were many Enc,ish there, so that he was
compelled to speak English and had forgotten his French. I
replied that this explanation was very surprising, and that a
much more plansible one would be that he was dbliged to use
the brain of the medium, and would therefore manifest no more
familiarity with French than she possessed. This — ,trite enough
,-suggestion appeared to Phinuit also more plausible, since a
few days later he offered it himself to another sitter as an explanation ofhis inability to sustain a oouTersation in French I "
There is a very simple answer to all this: he could speak
French, though Mrs. Piper could not See pages 414 and 420.
" Dr. C. W. F. [see Beport No. 28, Pr.Vin,98f. H.H.], requestioned Phinuit about the prominent medical men in Paris in
Phinuit's time. The names of Bouvier and Dupuytren were
given. Dr. F. tells me that he (Dr. C. W. F.) knew nothing
about Bouvier preyiously, but knew well about Dupuytren. The
doctors he had in mind at the time of his question ' were Velpeau, Bouillaud, Nelaton, Andral, and many others, all prominent forty or fifty years ago with extended reputations.' [If it
is all telepathy, why didn't Phinuit name one of them from Dr.
F.'s mindt n.H.] Taking the foregoing considerations together,
it appears to me that there is good reason for condudixig that
Phinuit is not a French doctor."
Or he must be a French doctor communicating under disadvantages.
Hodgson goes on to say something which tends very strongly
to
separate Phinuifs personality from Mrs. Piper's (Pr. VIII,
66-6)
:
" On one occasion, not long before a sitting (June 80th, 1888) ,
Mrs. Piper was startled by a very near sudden clap of thunder,
and Phinuit, on being afterwards questioned, appeared to have
no knowledge of the circumstance, and apparently tried to guess
at what had occurred. Similarly on questioning Phinuit at one
of my early sittings concerning the life of Mrs. Piper, he professed ignorance on the subject, but said that he would ' find out
things.' . . . Soon afterwards, however, Phinuit told me of incidmts in connection with Mrs. Piper which I think that Mrs.
Piper herself would never have mentioned to me. ... I have dso
met with several cases where Mrs. Piper [in the waking state!
H.H.] knew not a little of the sitter's ordinary environment,
CL XXIX] Hodgson's First Accovnt of Phinuit
405
names of friencbi, ftc, and yet this information was not giren
by Phinuit"
Hodgson says (Pr. VIII, 6) of one occasion when he per,
snaded Phinnit to stand up :
''Mrs. Piper stood up without changing the position of her
feet, at the same time throwing her head slightly back and her
chest forward, and thrusting the thumbs jauntily into what would
have been the armholes of b,r waistcoat had she worn after a moment, * I wrote an — ,he is writing it and I am
reading for you — an AB — TI — article A — Q — A against his W
— ,work in the AD — ,V— Advance. What the dickens is the Ad,
vancet * I said, ' It is a paper.' Then she continued, ' I thought
he was wrong, but — ,he was — aright, and I repent, he was ri,t
I want you to tell him for me. I am sorry. ... I want to right
all the wrong I did in the body.' I said to her, * Oan you see
himf ' ' Yes,' she replied. ' How does he look ? ' I asked. ' He
has grayish blue eyes, a beard, a rather prominent nose, a firm
mouth, a large forehead* and he brushed his hair up, so,' brushing my hair with her hand, to show the fashion of his. ' He is
of m,um build, rather talL He died of hemorrhage of the
kidneys.' . . . The description of Mr. West is photographic in its
truth. His appearance at our interview was entirely unheralded
by anything leading up to it.
'' Mr. M. J. Savage writes on June 26th, 1890 :—
, Mr. West . . . became editor of The Advance. While on that
paper he wrote a severe criticism on me, my doctrines, and my
work. My brother had not seen this criticism, and did not even
know about it.
"Neither of us knew the cause of his death. On writing to
the correctness of Mrs. Piper's
Advance,
The
was confirmed.
deathsitting,
his this
as toafter
statement
" Mr. W. H. Savage further writes July 6th, 1890 :—
',1. When Mrs. P. began speaking of Mr. West, she turned
with a surprised look, as at an unlocked for interruption, with
the remark, ' Ah I here is, etc.' [as above. H.H.]
"2. When I asked for a description she turned again in the
same direction and said, ' Hold up your head and let me look
at you.' Then she went on to describe as given in the statement.
, 8. She gave the date of death correctly, as well as cause.
'' 4. I did not know that West was dead.
"6. As my brother says, I had never heard of the attack on
my brother of which the interview speaks."
Bev. M.J. Savage. JanwryUih,!,, (Pr.Vin,105f.)
, On January 15th, 1889, the Bev. M. J. Savage had a sitting
with Mrs. Piper, in the course of which Rev. Robert West purported to communicate, stating that his body was buried at
Alton, m., and giving the text on his tombstone. Mr. Savage
was unaware of either of these facts at the time of the sitting*
He soon afterwards ascertained that Rev. Robert West's grave
was at Alton, 111., but he did not ascertain the text on the tombstone. He recently informed me of tl, circumstance, and I
416
Hodgson's First Pipor Report [Bk. II, Pt IV
have since obtained from Mr. J. A. Oondey, editor of the Daily
Telegraph, Alton, HI., a copy of the inscriptions on tibe tombstone. Irequested Mr. Savage tlien to furnish me with the
text which had been given to him through Mrs. Piper. Yesterday he found his notes made on the day of the sitting, and read
me the text, which agreed with that sent to me from Alton — ,via.,
* Fervent in spirit, serving the Lord.'
B. Hodqson.
, The above is correct
(Signed) M. J. Savagb.
" July 26th, 1890.*'
The following, if genuine (and there seems no more reason
to doubt it than any other Piper manifestation), looks more
like a case of '' possession '' than perhaps any other case of
hers I
Miss A. M.S.
(Pr.Vni,lllf.)
" Boston, February Uth, 1888.
'' At thewho
firsthad
sitting
tried to
get about
some information
regarding
a friend
thenI been
dead
three months.
I was
told by Dr. Phinuit . . . that I probably would not get anything
satisfactory for some time, and was advised to wait about eight
months. At the expiration of that time I sat again, and at the
third sitting from that time (I think my dates are correct) the
medium was controlled for a few minutes during the hour by
what purported to be the spirit of my friend who, however,
seemed to have such imperfect control that he could only speak
in a choked, whispering voice. At the next sitting he was
stronger, and now is able to take control and talk easily and
distinctly for perhaps half an hour. I have received the impression, from what has been told me through the medium, that for
some months after the death of my friend he did not sufficiently
understand the conditions of his new existence, or the conditions
under which he could return, to be able to reach me through any
"Boston, December 17th, 1888.
medium.''
''.
He used to be lame. ... He has often said to me, * You
know my lame leg; weQ, it is all well now.'... He tried very
hard [t.s., acting through the medium. H.H.] to raise himself
from the chair without succeeding at first 1 told him he had
better not try, as it might be too much for the medium. He insisted on trying, however, but commenced rubbing one leg, and
asked me if I could remember which leg was lame. [This
strsnge sort of ignorance is very characteristic of ,'controls."
H.H.] At last he raised himself, but instead of walking, as Dr.
P[hinuit] would do, he leaned heavily on me, and seemed to hop
or hitch along on one foot exactly as a person would do who
could use only one foot in walking. After he came back, he
dropped into the chair exhausted, and said that was the hardest
work he had done since coming bade, and that it was too much
Ch. XXIX]
MiS8 A. M. R/8 Lame Control
417
of the real life for him; he did not like it. . . . He says that his
spiritual body was not lame, but that he had to come back that
way so I would recognize him
"
'' BosTOK, June 23r(7, 1890.
*' At each sitting I have conyersed with two personalities, Dr.
P., the regular control, and the contr
ol which claims to be the
spirit of my friend H. . • . When my friend H. takes control of
die mediimi it seems to be quite a different personality, although
there is something in the voice or manner of speaking that is like
Dr. P. The voice, however, is not nearly so loud. When I
asked him once wl, this was, he told me tiiat Dr. P. was right
by him and that he could not stay a moment without his help.
In a great many little ways he is quite like what my friend us,
to be when living, so much so that I am afraid it would take a
great deal of explanation to make me believe tiiiat his identical
self had not something to do with it. • . . This, too, in spite of the
fact that he does not always know how to spell his own name
correctly, though I am happy to be able to state that he certainly knows what his name is. He says the longer he is away
the more he forgets about things in this life, though he does not
forget his friends. . . • He insists that he can see me in my room,
and often knows what I am doing. At one time he adked me
how I liked that little drab-colored book that I had been reading
with another person. There was a particular book which I had
been reading aloud with a friend, but it was covered with brown
paper, as I remember, and I had no idea what the cloth cover
was. On reaching home I took off the paper cover, and found
that it was a drab-colored cloth cover. I may have seen the
book when new, and before the paper cover was put on, but if I
did I had completely forgotten about it."
These subliminal memories are frequent. The mediums
often get them contrary to the supraliminal convictions of the
sitters. Do they get them from the sitter's mind, or have they
passed into the cosmic mind via postcarnate souls ?
This account concludes (Pr. VIII, 113-4) :
"When I talk with H. about the philosophy of spirit return,
he always seems more or less puzzled, and generally refers me to
Dr. P., saying that he knows more about such things. He hardly
knew at first what I meant by the mediiun, but says that he has
for the time being another organism, and that is about all he
knows. When he asked me why I did not come oftener to see
him, I explained to him, somewhat as I would to a child, that the
medium was not always at conunand, and that I had to pay
money for a sitting with her. He said, , I am an expensive
article, thent' I relied, 'Yes, you spirits are quite expensive
articles.' "
418
Hodg8on*8 First Piper Report [Bk. II, Pt IV
Mr.F.8.8. (Pr.Vin,ll».)
''(Question: Well, Sarah is Iier middle name. What is her
other? Could not answer.) [Phinuit says (H.H.)] ' She is different from your mother; has very original ways of thinking,
and ideas. She is yeiy positive; set as the hiUs; and doesn't
belieye in me. She is a crank, and so am I, but she will
have to be a good deal bigger than she is to scare me.'...
My aunt had given several sittings to [had several with? H.H.]
Mrs. P., but with no success; hence she had become somewhat
skeptical; hence the medium's words, 'She does not believe in
me.' Mrs. P. had no possible means of associating my aunt and
me, to my knowledge."
Mr. M.N.
(Pr.Vin,120f.)
" Briefly stated, the three cases of prophesying which I have
experienced with Mrs. Piper, and which have come true, are as
foUows :—
''
She told me that a death of a near relative of mine
would occur in about six weeks, from which I should realise
some pecuniary advantages. . . . My wife, to whom I was then engaged, went to see Mrs. Piper a few days afterwards, and she
told her (my wife) that my father would die in a few weeks.
'' About the middle of May my father died very suddenly in
London. ... Previous to this Mrs. Piper (as Dr. Phinuit) had
told me that she would endeavor to influence my father about
certain matters connected with his will before he died. Two
days after I received the cable announcing his death, my wife
and I went to see Mrs. Piper, and she [Phinuit] spoke of his
presence, and his sudden arrival in the spirit-world, and said
that he (Dr. Phinuit) had endeavored to persuade him in those
matters while my father was sick. Dr. Phinuit told me the
state of the will, and described the principal executor, and said
that he (the executor) would make a certain disposition in my
favor, subject to the consent of the two other executors, when I
got to London, Eng. Three weeks afterwards I arrived in London; found the principal executor to be the man Dr. Phinuit
had described. The will went materially as he had stated . . . and
my sister, who was chiefly at my father's bedside the last three
days of his life, told me that he had repeatedly complained of the
presence of an old man at the foot of his bed, who annoyed him
by discussing his private afiPairs.
" The second instance I would give you is as follows :—
" Dr. Phinuit stated that I would receive a professional offer
within two weeks by letter, to my present address, with the name
of the manager's firm on the left hand comer of the envelope,
and (as far as I could understand him) either from a man
named French, or else from a Frenchman. Within the time
stated the letter came, answering to the description of its appearance, and to this address, but the offer was from a Frenchman,
Ch. XXIX]
Mr. J. Rogers Rich
419
,' The third is as follows: —
,'Dr. Phinuit stated on one occasion that some relative was
suffering at that time from a sore or wounded thumb. We knew
of no one at the time. . . . Shortly after this conversation my aunt
stated that she had received a letter from cousins. . . . , Oh, bythe-bye . . . Jennie has . . . injured her thumb in some machine.'
. . . Dr. Phinuit cured me, or apparently did so, by a prescription
sent me by Mrs. Piper, of an internal trouble from which I had
suffered for eighteen months."
The following report (Pr. VIII, 126f.) by Mr. J. Rogers
Bich, made from contemporary notes of the sittings, is among
the best, and illustrates (by the converse) what has been remarked more than once — ,that scientific (and consequently
skeptical ?) people do not make the best sitters. This artist
made an admirable one.
*, I had always had a dislike for any , mediums ' or * spiritualists'of every kind, but on meeting this woman I was at once
attracted to her by the simple and sympathetic manner which,
she showed on greeting me, and I felt a delicacy about making
an appointment for a sitting, she seeming to me too gentle and
refined for a business of this sort. I was at once struck with the
peculiar light, or inward look, in her eyes. Her voice was full
and agreeable, but in every way a 'feminine ' voice, and there
was an entire absence of any masculinity in her manner, which
I had been expecting to find under the circumstances.
'' My first sitting with her was on September 6th, 1888. With
little trouble she went into the trance . . . and after a moment's
silence ... I was startled by the remarkable change in her voice
— an exclamation, a sort of grunt of satisfaction, as if the person
had reached his destination and gave vent to his pleasure thereat
by this sound, uttered in an unmistakably male voice, but rather
husky. I was at once addressed in French with, ' Bonjour, Monsieur, comment vous portez vous % * to which I gave answer in
the same language, with which I happen to be perfectly familiar.
My answer was responded to with a sort of inquiring grunt,
much like the French ' Heint '. . . Nearly all my interviews were
begun in the same manner. ... I was quite unwell with nervous
troubles. . . . The first thing told me was of a ' great light behind
me, a good sign,' &c. Then suddenly all my ills were very clearly
and distinctly explained and so thoroughly that I felt certain
tiiat Mrs. Piper herself would have hesitated to use such plain
language I Prescriptions were given to me for the purchase of
herbs, and the manner of preparing them. . . . My profession
(painting) was described, and my particular talents and mannerisms in design were mentioned. . . . My mother was clearly described! She was ' beside me, dressed as in her portrait (painted
420
Hodgson's First Piper Report [Bk. 11, Pt IV
a year or two before her death), and wearing a certain cameo
pin, the portrait of my father/
,
" Second Sitting on October 6th. — . . . The * Doctor ' told me
of my niece being frequently 'in my surroundings/ and that
she was then at my side. Up to this time I had not heard my
name mentioned, so I asked for it from my niece. The * Doctor '
was again puzzled and said, * What a fimny name — ,wait, I cannot go so fast ! ' Then my entire name was correctly spelt out
but entirely with the French alphabet, each separate letter being
clearly pronounced in that language. My niece had been bom,
lived most of her short life, and died in France. Then the
attempt to pronounce my name was amusing — finally calling me
'Thames Eowghearce Heach.' The 'Doctor' never called me
after that anything but ' BeacL' "
It is now time for a comment on Hodgson's expressions on
p. 404 regarding Phinuit's French. Between there and here
they have been traversed more than once, this time, I think,
pretty strongly : for the spelling of a name '' entirely with the
French alphabet, each separate letter being clearly pronounced
in that language,'' is a feat that few English-speaking
students could accomplish, because the matter is of little consequence, and generally neglected. I have been in France
some, and have translated two French books without incurring
critical censure that I am aware of, and yet that feat would
be far beyond me.
Mr. Bich's farther remarks on this subject at the close of
his account are the most important which it has evoked (Pr.
VIII, 131) :
"One day Mrs. Piper pointed to a plain gold ring on my
finger and said: ' O'est une alliance, how you call that? A wedding ring, n'est-ce past' This was true. Now if Mrs. Piper
had learned French at school here [which she did not or anywhere else. H.H.] she would most probably have called this ring
'un anneau de marriage,' and not have given it the technical
name ' alliance.' I several times carried on a short conversation
in French, making my observations in that language and receiving answers in the same, but which were always curt, and ended
with an expressed wish in broken English not ' to bodder about
French but to speak in English.' I made use, too, of certain
slang expressions which were apparently perfectly understood but
answered in English, though correctly."
But to return to Mr. Bich's earlier record (Pr. VIII,
1S8-9) :
Ch. XXIX]
Mr. BicVs Friend Newell
421
" November Sth. — , . . A friend's sister had met with a loss by
fire, and wished to see what could be done towards tracing the
incendiary. This lady had a habit of coloring or bleaching her
hair, of which she had sent a lock as a test. ,Dr. Phinuit' at
first refused to touch the hair, saying that it was 'dead and
devilish!' As I knew nothing whatever of the persons connected with the fire, I noted down the descriptions given, which
tallied perfectly with that of the parties suspected, as I afterwards learned. ... Breaking into tiie run of conversation, the
' Doctor ' of a sudden said, ' Hullo, here's Newell I ' (mentioning
the name of a friend who had died some months before).
* Newell ' is a substitute for the real name. I should add that
* Newell ' had frequently purported to communicate direcdy with
his mother through Mrs. Piper at previous sittings, but this was
the first time that any intimation of his presence was givea to
me. I was totally unprepared for this, and said, ' Who did you
say I ' The name was repeated with a strong foreign accent, and
in the familiar voice and tone of the 'Doctor.' Then there
seemed for a moment to be a mingling of voices as if in dispute,
followed by silence and heavy breathing of the medium. ML at
once I was astonished to hear, in an entirely different tone and
in the purest English accent, 'Well, of all persons under the
sun, Bogers Rich, what brought you here? Fm glad to see you,
old fellow? How is X and Y and Z, and all die boys at the
dubt' Some names were given which I knew of, but their
owners I had never met, and so reminded my friend ' Newell,'
who recalled that he followed me in college by some years and
that all his acquaintances were younger than I. I remarked an
odd movement of the medium while under this influence; she
apparently was twirling a mustache, a trick which my friend
formerly practised mudk"
Now if all this drama is telepathy, it certainly is not of the
"common or garden variety," and if " Newell " is a secondary
personality of Mrs. Piper, it is one of hundreds of instances of
that woman having secondary personalities who are men. I
have read accoxmts of a good many undoubted cases of secondary personality, and have yet to read one where the sex
was
little crossed.
absurd? Aren't these interpretations growing to look a
Mr. Bich now gets back to Phinuif s prescription (Pr. VIII,
129-30) :
" I had been following the treatment prescribed by the ' Doetor,' and had prepared at my home the herbs, etc., according to
his orders, as I thought. But I found that the medicine had not
the effect promised and so told him. The answer was that it was
422
Hodgson's First Piper Report
[Bk. II, Pt IV
xny fault for * iheiy were not properly prepared.' I assured him
that they were, whereat he said ,at * Uiat old nigger . . . had not
followed my directions, had used the wrong proportions, had forgotten to watch the cooking, and was a fool anyway! ' On inquiry Ifound this to be the fact, for she had understood me to
say a quart instead of a pint, and confessed to having forgotten
the mixture and allowed it to boil down but * thought it wouldn't
make any difference/
" A lock of hair belonging to a friend who is quite noted for
his amusing self-conceit was greeted with a laugh and recognized
as belonging to ' His Boyal Highness,' or the * Duke B,' calling
him by his real name and attaching the titles by way of
* chaff.'
,' Some prophecies were made to ' occur soon,' but I regret to
say that the 'Doctor's' idea of ,soonness' and mine differ
greatly — ,for they are not yet fulfilled.
"June 3rd, 1889. — ,My ninth sitting. This time I asked to
communicate with my friend ' Newell,' previously referred to in
my fourth sitting. The * Doctor ' said, ' I'll send for him,' and
kept on talking with me for a while. Then he said, 'Here's
Newell, and he wants to talk with you '' Beach," so I'll go about
my business whilst you are talking with him, and will come back
again later.' Then followed a confusion of words, but I clearly
heard the voice of the ' Doctor ' saying : ' Here, Newell, you come
by the hands while I go out by the feet,' which apparently being
accomplished in the proper manner, my name was called clearly
as 'Bogers, old fellow I' without a sign of accent [Bemember
that ''Phinuit" always pronounced it with an accent. H.H.]
and the same questions put as to how were the ' fellows at the
dub.' My hand was cordially shaken [by the medium. H.H.],
and I remarked the same movement of twisting the mustache,
which was kept up by Mrs. Piper during the interview. * Newell '
spoke of a ' pastel ' which I was drawing . . . and described the
pleasure he had in watching me do it. He told me of certain
private family affairs which I knew to be correct. Finally he
bade me good-by. Before going he spoke to me of his ' present
life,' and told me that he was writing a poem; that he was now
pursuing his literary studies with the greatest pleasure, &c, &c.
* But,' he said, ' was I not sick, and did I not suffer before I left
you all? Why, the leaving of the material body, Bogers, is terrible. It is like tearing limb from limb; but once free, how
happy one is.' When ' Newell ' left me there was the usual disturbance indie medium's condition, and then the resumption of
the familiar voice, accent and mannerisms of Dr. Phinuit."
The Doctor's remark: *,Here, Newell, you come by the
hands while I go out by the feet " has haunted me since I first
read it many years ago, and for several reasons.
Ch. XXIX]
Sympathetic Ganglia.
The Dog Orover
428
The hypnotists have found a peculiar sensibility in the pit
of the stomach, near the sympathetic ganglia. Their subjects
and some somnambulists appear to hear and see from there.
And there are suggestive accounts of its being the place of
entrance and exit of the soul or astral ( ?) body — suggestive
because it is near the umbilicus, where the foetus derives its
nutriment from the mother. Whatever that may amount to,
it seems absurd that the hands, and of all things the feet,
should be the avenues of spiritual entrance and exit; but in
the light of our inherited preconceptions, a good many things
uncovered by ', psychical research " have seemed absurd, and
yet some of them have, in time, become quite matters of
course. It has already ineffectually taken me nearly twenty
years to get over the feet and what they suggest They have
been one reason why I do not care to visit mediums. I don't
want any of the souls I love coming to me through a stranger's
body, especially the inferior members of such a body. Fhinuit,
however, does not appear to have been a very finical person,
and as a medical man he is presumably to be credited with
superiority to many of a layman's prejudices.
But with all my objections to the passage, isn't it as dramatic as Falstaff or Pistol ? I don't see how one can read it
without laughing at the idea that telepathy can be made to
cover the whole case. For myself, its dramatic quality so far
tends to overcome its coarseness and apparent absurdity, that,
commonplace as it is, it stands high among the phenomena
that weigh with me for the spiritistic hjrpothesis — and almost
equally high with those that weigh against it It would stand
higher still in the latter dass if it were not so magnificentiy
in keeping with delightful old Phinuit I'm sorry for any
reader of the Proceedings who does not enjoy him with the
two gentiemen I named before him.
Mr. Rich continues (Pr. VIII, 130) :
, Then I produced a dog's collar. After some handling of it
the * Doctor ' recognized it as belonging to a dog which I had
once owned. I asked 'If there were dogs where he was?'
' Thousands of them I ' and he said he would try to attract the
attention of my dog with this collar. In the midst of our conversation hesuddenly exclaimed, ' There 1 I think he knows you
are here, for I see [him] coming from away off I' He then de-
424
Hodgson's First Piper Report
[Bk. II, Pt IV
scribed my collie perfectly, and said, ' Ton call him, BeacV and
I gave my whistle by which I used to call him. , Here he comes!
Oh, how he jmnps I There he is now, jumping upon and around
you. So glad to see you I Boverl Boverl No — G-royer,
Oroverl That's his nameP The dog was once called Rover,
but his name was changed to Orover in 1884, in honor of the
election of Grover Cleveland."
This too is perhaps telepathy I Or are we on the brink of
finding that a woman's secondary selves are not only men, and
by the hundred, but sometimes dogs ? The only demonstration
necessary would be for Mrs. Piper to try to bark.
Mr. Rich continues (p. 130} :
, A child was constantly beside me and in my surroundings.
It was attracted to me and had much influence over me :' It is
aforblood
relation,
I denied
ever The
been answer
a fact
I never
had aa sister.'
sister and
never this
heardto have
of one.
came : ' I know that, you were never told of it. The birth was
premature, the child dead, bom some years before you were. Go
and ask your aunts to prove it.' On questioning an aunt who
had been always a member of our family, I learned that such had
been the case, and that by the time I came into the world the
affair had been forgotten and there had never been a reason for
informing me of the circumstances, proving that I in no way
had any intimation of it, and that this communication could
not be explained by thought-transference or the lik&"
Note that though Mr. Rich was a grown man, this sister,
bom several years before he was, appeared to Phinuit as a
child. Similar anomalies in regard to even stillborn children
appear several times in the reports. It is no explanation of
them to say that they are inconsistent with the spiritistic
hypothesis. We may yet find that they are not Either way,
they await explanation. Generally tiie controls appear as
having grown, and in long series of sittings (see Junot Series,
Chapter XLIX) as growing.
Mr. Rich remarks (p. 131) :
'' Although the ' prophecies ' of the ' Doctor ' were not fulfilled
at the time I understood him to mean as ' in the spring ' or ' in
the fall,' I have since found several of these things come true,
and in the season which he mentioned, but not that year in
which he led me to expect them to be realized."
Barring some comparatively insignificant matters, this
Ch. XXIX]
Chronology of Reports
425
doses the sittings previous to Mrs. Piper's departure for England late in 1889. We will now turn to her sittings there,
reported in Pr. VI, and then give a brief glance back to Pr.
YIII, where Hodgson gives those from her return in the spring
of 1890 through 1891.
CHAPTEB
XXX
MRS. PIPER'S SNGLI8H SITTINGS, 188M0
These were held under the supervision of Sir Oliver Lodge
and Dr. Walter Leaf , and the report of them has an introduction by Myers, and is followed by a statement of impressions
of Mrs. Piper by James. All these experts expressed perfect
confidence in the honesty of the medium, and that the phenomena were not explicable by any agency yet known to
science.
Sir Oliver Lodge says (Pr. VI, 446) :
"The details given of my family are just such as one might
imagine obtained by a perfect stranger surrounded by the whole
of one's relations in a group and able to converse freely but
hastily with one after the other; not knowing them and being
rather confused with their number and half-understood messages and personalities, and having a special eye to their physical weaknesses and defects. A person in a hurry thus trying to
tell a stranger as much about his friends as he could in this way
gather would seem to me to be likely to make much the same
kind of communication as was actually made to me."
With rather more confusion, one gets this impression constantly inreading the hundreds of pages of such reports, and
it reminds me, and probably many, of frequent similar impressions indreams, which naturally awakens the notion of
inflow of more or less confused material from the cosmic mind.
Touching Phinuit, Sir Oliver Lodge says (Pr. VI, 448f.) :
'* The name is useful as expressing compactly what is naturally
prominent to the feeling of any sitter, that he is not talking to
Mrs. Piper at aU. The manner, mode of thought, tone, trains of
idea, are all difiPerent. You are speaking no longer to a lady
but to a man, an old man, a medical man. All this cannot but
be vividly felt even by one who considered the impersonation a
consummate piece of acting.
'* Whether such a man as Dr. Phinuit ever existed I do not
know, nor from the evidential point of view do I greatly care. . . .
It can be objected, why if he was a French doctor has he so en480
Ch. XXX]
Sir Oliver Lodge on Phinvit
427
tirely forgotten his French? [But he has not See p. 420. H.H.]
... I am unable to meet this objection, by anything beyond the
obvious suggestion that Mrs. Piper's brain is the medium utilized> and that she is likewise ignorant. But one would think
that it would be a sufficiently patent objection to deter an impersonator from assuming a rdh of purely unnecessary difficulty.
, Admitting, however, that ' Dr. Phinuit ' is probably a mere
name for Mrs. Piper's secondary ccmsciousness, one cannot help
being struck by the singular correctness of his medical diagnoses. [Of course this, like everything else in the sittings, is denied by somebody. Cf. ante, H.H.] In fact the medical statements, coinciding as they do with truth just as well as those of
a regular physician, but given without any ordinary examination and sometimes without even seeing the patient, must be held
as part of the evidence establishing a strong prima facie case for
the existence of some abnormal means of acquiring information*
Not that it is to be supposed that he is more infallible than another. Ihave one definite case of distinct error in a diagnosis
''At times Dr. Phinuit does fish. Occasionally he guesses;
of his information
and sometimes he ekes out the scantiness
from the resources of a lively imagination. . . . The fishing process
is most marked when Mrs. Piper herself either is not feeling well
or is tired. . . . When he does not fish he simply draws upon his
memory and retails old facts which he has told before, occasionally with additions of his own which do not improve them. His
memory seems to be one of extraordinary tenacity and exactness
[more than any human memory. H.n.1, but not of infallibility;
and its lapses do introduce error [as to fishing, see p. 523. H.H.].
''He seems to be under some compulsion not to be silent.
Possibly the trance would cease if he did not exert himself. At
any rate he chatters on, and one has to discount a good deal of
conversation which is obviously, and sometimes confessedly, introduced as a stop-gap. ... It would be a great improvement if,
when he realizes that conditions are unfavorable, he would say
so and hold his peace. I have tried to impress this upon him,
with the effect that he is sometimes confidential, and says that he
is having a bad time; but after ell he probably knows his own
business best, because it has several times happened that after
half an hour of more or less worthless padding, a few minutes
of valuable lucidity have been attained.
" I have laid much stress upon this fishery hypothesis. . . • But
in thus laying stress I feel that I am producing an erroneous
and misleading impression of proportion. I have spoken of a
few minutes' lucidity to an intolerable deal of padding as an
occasional experience, but in the majority of the sittings held
in my presence the converse proportion better represents ,e
facts.*'
428
Mrs. Pipet,s English BHiings, 1880-90
[BL II, Ft lY
The amount of attention giyen eveiTwhere to Phinnit may
seem out of proportion, especially here, and also especially in
view of the fact that for several years, the old fellow has been
absent from mortal converse, and replaced by a great variety
of people ( ?) who speak, or rather write, for themselves. But
this attention to him is, on my part at least, largely because
he may help toward an explanation of those ', other people."
Here is an episode explaining a nickname that Fhinuit
habitually applied to Sir OUver (Pr. VI, 471f.) :
"Cousin married, and the gentleman passed out at sea, round
the sea. . . . Hullo, he's got funny buttons, big, bright. . . A uniform. He has been a commander, an officer, a leader; not military, but a commander. ... [A little further on Phinuit suddenly brings out the word Cap'n in connection with him, but, in
a curious and half puzzled way, applies it to me. It remained
my Phinuit nickname to the end, though quite inapplicable.]
Your mother has got a good picture of him taken a long time
ago, pretty good, old-fashioned, but not so bad of him. Yes,
pretty good. He looks like that now. He looks younger than
."
he did.
As in this vision, so it was in one of my own dreams which
I suspect was in several respects veridical; and in two other
dreams where I cannot trace any veridicity, the persons had
grown young. But in another which I fully believe to have
been veridical, the person had grown older in proportion to
the time since '' passing over/' but there was a peculiar reason
for such a manifestation : I fancy that my friend may have
wanted to appear to " grow old along with me.'*
You see I am now justifying Phinuif s report of my mediumship, but don't be alarmed. There is not much of it. Even
if more were possible, I have been too busy with other things,
and have a disinclination regarding it.
Phinuit asks (Pr. VI, 651) :
'''Do you remember the little one that passed out of the
body? ' E. C. L. [Sir O.'s sister. H.H.] : ' No, but I know there
was one.' * Well, he's here. . . . But you wouldn't know him now.
He's grown up.' E. C. L.: 'Then they do growf ' 'Certainly.
He's about 35, I should say. [The brotiier r,erred to, who died
aged five weeks, would have been 83.1 They all look about 35
here.'
But "how about such utterances as this to Mrs. Leaf (Pr.
Ch. XXX]
Controls Growing in Tears
429
Yly 694), and in the case of Mr. Bich's sister? Do they not
flatiiy contradict what has been said about growing up ?
" * There is a little child round you. The little body of a child.
It belonged to your aunt that is in the spirit, that passed out
years and years ago; you will have to ask your mother about it.
You will find that it is a little child that never lived in the body.'
B. M. L. : ' Whose child was that) ' * The child does not know
whose child she was. Don't you see, the child was too young.
I can't get it to talk to me. I see this little one; it belongs
either to an aunt or a cousin. Your mother will know about it.'
"[This is not known to be correct of the child of an aunt or
cousin. Mrs. Leaf had herself lost a baby, bom dead.]"
There are some things to suggest that if there are postcamate souls, they can appear as of any age in their experience— ,and so show their history since separation, to anyone
rejoining them.
One naturally speculates whether, if there is a future state,
those there keep growing old with all the disagreeables incident to so doing. Twice, in dreams, I remember very vividly,
the old had grown young. This recalls Peter Ibbetson's statement that he and his beloved kept themselves about twentyseven« There are reports that Peter Ibbetson is not all fancy,
but even if it were, such reports would be inevitable.
This whole question seems as much of a jumble as the question arising from the controls' frequent assertion that their
life is free from pain, while the medium is frequently acting
evidences of pain — ,usually that of their last illnesses. In sev-*
eral places the controls say this is done to prove identity.
Here is an account by Sir Oliver that makes strongly for
the telepathic hypothesis, but the last sentence is rather
against it (Pr. VI, 466-7) :
" You have a son in the body — a smart boy — clever, but not
very strong . . . but he has got worms badly. ..,* Ought he to go to
school? ' ' By no means. You ought to keep lum at home and
nurse him, and give him vermifuge. You will, won't yout
Worms are his chief trouble; they consume his food, his stomach
is filled with slime; he feels nausea; no ambition; rather irritable[All
.' ,perhaps
this aabout
eldest boy We
is painfully
true, worms
except
that it is
little myexaggerated.
had suspected
before, and perceiving the outside symptoms oorrecdy described
as above, we took the matter in hand seriously, and after acting
430 Mrs. Piper,s English Sittings, 1889-90 [Bk. II, Pt IV
for some days under medical advice we established the truth of
the above statement precisely.]''
And yet it is frequently said that Fhinuit could not
diagnose !
" ' Can you tell me what his favorite pursuit ist '
"[This I asked because he exhibits a remarkable and constant
hankering after architecture, spending all his spare time when
not feeling sick and headachy in drawing plans of houses and in
reading about buildings. The reply was utterly wide of the
markj
'''Pursuit? oh, takes an interest in natural things; is mu*
"
sical.'
We may
as well follow this boy through the sittings (Pr.
VI, 605f.) :
"Mrs. L.: 'Do you remember little V?' [The Lodges' sick
boy. H.H.] Dr. : ' I do remember.' O. L. : ' Where is he now ? '
Dr.: 'He is with Mary [i»e., his grandmother: true]. He is
better there, and we are going to take good care of him, that
nothing serious happens. You remember. See if we don't take
good care of him, in your life, not in ours. Our interest is very
great, very large, and we could do a great deal. And, Marie,
dear [Mrs. Lodge. H.H.], do not worry; be brave. ...Do not
send mm to school. Let him stay at home and rest well, and get
strong. . . . He will pull through, and come out all right. He has
got worms. Yes, he has got them still; but he will outgrow it,
and make a fine boy. Do not worry. I don't tell you that to
encourage you, but because it is true.' Mrs. L. : ' Are they little
or are they big worms t' Dr.: 'Large, not small, but large
worms; that is— ,they are not tapeworms. No.' [True.] Mrs.
L. : ' What should we give him 1 ' Dr. : 'You give him vermifuge
to take. Suggest some.' [N.B. — This is not the usual Fhinuit
method of prescription : it is quite exceptional.] O. L. : ' Mercury '? Dr. : ' No, too strong. Weaken him.' Mrs. L. : ' Santonin? Scammony? Quassia?' Dr. : ' Yes, scammony is good.
Give him that with quassia alternately.' O. L. : ' Both injected? '
Dr. : ' Yes, best thing in the lot. ... I tell you you have got a great
comfort in that boy.' Mrs. L.: 'Will he live to be a man?'
Dr. : ' Fretting ! It is all bosh, and you had better be asleep than
fretting about people. Do as I told you. He will come out
all right. That's what's the matter. Give him hot water to
drink. . . . You make the vermifuge I told you. . . . Take good
care of yourself, Marie, we'll take good care of him. Change
will do him good. There is others in your surroundings that
needs looking after just as much and more. [This grrammar was
not telepathed from the Lodges I H.H.] You need not worry
about any of them for the present. It is all right It will be
Ch. XXX]
Controls Do Beat near Home
431
all right. ...But God knows. What He told me to say, and
what He allows me to know, I know and no more. I can't help
getting mixed up sometimes; and it makes me mad. I'd like to
be all straight, not crooked. I do take care of you. When the
voice of Dr. Phinuit is no longer heard in the body, remember
you had a friend in me, and one who will always look after you,
no matter what one says about me. I go on. I fight, fight them
all; and th, will always do. . . . Get good for me to do. God
bless you all, and the b, wishes. Captain 1 Is there anything
else t I will speak to you again. Doctor 1 ' "
Sir Oliver thus speaks about something which the reports
had suggested to me before I had read up to his mention of it,
and which to me did not by any manner of means ', seem
absurd'' (Pr. XXIII, 138, a.d. 1909) :
'* One curious circumstance I feel constrained to mention —
though it will seem absurd — and that is that the controls seem
to do best in their own country. For instance, long ago [1889.
H.H.1, before any of us on this side of the Atlantic had seen
Mrs. i,iper, a control calling itself Gumey sent messages through
that medium while she was still in America; which messages,
when recorded on this side, were thought feeble and unworthy,
60 that the control was spoken of both by Prof. W. James and
by those in England as * the pseudo-Gumey.' When, however,
Mrs. Piper came over here the * Gumey ' messages became better, and could be described as quite fairly lifelike."
It was this Gumey control whom Sir Oliver Lodge reported
in Pr. VI as " Mr. E.,'* but revealed in a later paper in Pr.
XXIII as Edmund Gumey. The later report duplicates and
enlarges a contemporary report in which he suppressed several
matters that twenty years later he felt free to print. I quote
here from the later account, interrupting, and I fear confusing,
our chronological order, for the sake of getting in the comments which Sir Oliver made in 1909. He says (Pr. XXIII,
1411) :
''I learnt in this way more about the life and thoughts of
Edmund Gumey than I had known in his lifetime. [And Mrs.
Piper knew less. Then where did it come from? H.H.] My
acquaintance with him . . . began in the early seventies, when . . .
he . . . sat on the benches of University College, London, to listen
to my regular college lectures on Mechanics and Physics. ... He
was good enough to strike up a friendship with his youthfid
instructor, and I occasionally lunched with him, and once or
twice saw him in his rooms at Clarges Street.
',The talk gradually turned upon psychical matters. ... Mr.
432 Mrs. Pipet,s English SUHngs, 1889-90 [Bk. H, Pt IV
Gumoy was even then at work on systematic preparation for the
book, Phantasms of the Living, . . . Before long he introduced me
to his friend, F. W. H. ,ers, who, like Mr. Gumey, was patience itself in trying to inspire my snpeificial and dogmatic
materialism with an element of larger sense.
"A few years after all this the SP JEL was fonnded, but I was
not one of the original members. I joined, I suppose, after the
Liyerpool thought-transference experiments in 1883 and 1884
[see p. 245 f.]. I had migrated to LiTeri>ool in 1881, and remained
there till 1900. Professor Barrett I had of course known all
along as a physicist, and in the eighties we had some conversa*
tions on thought-transference in connection with the Liverpool
experiments, in some of which I took part, and on which I reported in the Pr.SJP JL,VoL2.
*' Until 1884 I was unconvinced of the possibility of telepathy;
and not till the end of 1889 did the evidence for survival of personality beyond bodily death make any serious impression upon
me. ...Edmund Gumey died in 1888, at a time when I waa
entirely absorbed in orthodox physical experiments and theory.
',The first mention of Gumey in my sittings occurred on
Saturday evening, December 21, 1889. ... (A photograph of my
late Demonstrator Mr. Clark was here handed in.) L.: 'Oan
you
is! ' burst
[Phinuit.][:
' Well I will
Edmund
will tell
help who
me. this
A vessel
in his stomach,
and try.
he passed
out
very suddenly. He was away, not at home. A clever fellow and
a great help. He fell. Edmund sends his love to you.' (A letter
from Edmund Gumey was handed in.) L.: 'Can you read
this t ' P. : ' Oh, I don't know. I can't read it word for word. I
can tell you what it is about. It has got Edmund's influence on
it. So had that picture. Had you kept it with Edmund's letter?' L. :' Well it had been in the same pocket.' P.: 'You must
not do that. You mix things up if you do that. No, I can't
read this letter. It is something about some books
'
'' [Here the personality seemed to change and to represent Edmund Gumey. He spoke so naturally that for a time I forgot
to take notes, but nothing evidential was said. , The notes go on
thus :— ,They are henceforward veiy imperfect, i.e,, fragmentaiy.]
'' G. : ' I am here, I etherially exist. I wrote to you about some
books for the Society. I have seen a little woman that's a medium, atrue medium. I have written to Myers using her hand.
I did do it, I, Edmund Gumey, I.' L.: 'Is this a medium here
now I ' G. : ' Yes, she's a medium. Very few you will get like Dr.
Phinuit. He is not all one would wish, but he is all right. You
are Lodge. I know you. Lodge we shall beat them yet. There
is no death, only a shadow and then Light. Experiment and
observation are indispensable. We have to use some method like
this to communicate
" ' Yes, God is in Nature, all Nature is God. We are a refleo-
Gh. XXX]
The Oumey Control
433
tion of God. Don't give up a good thing. The world will know,
and our Society will know, that there is no death. I didn't
know. I would have given anything to have had you come and
apeak to me, if you had passed away first, as I am speaking to
you now/ L.: 'Is it good to be where you are?' O.: 'Yes, it
is good, — ,the only good thing. Life in material world is beautiful. Marriage is beautiful, but this is far better.' L. : ' Is there
no marriage? ' O.: * No, no, Swedenborg was all wrong. Jesus
Christ was right; he knew. He was a reflection of God.' "
Evening of 25th Dec, 1889. (Pr.XXin,149f .)
,'(Phinuit now seemed to leave, and another control, speaking
in a more educated voice, took his place; the change taking
place with a little uncertainty and difficulty as to how to manage it, and a seeming colloquy between the departing and en«
tering controls, — ,Phinuit giving soito voce instructions. After
the change was over, the voice said) : ' Lodge, how are yout I
tell you Edmund Gumey is living, not dead. Edmund Gum,y,
that's me: you know me, don't youf ' L.: 'Yes, Gumey, delighted to see you again.' G. : ' Don't give it up Lodge. Cling
to it, it's the best thing you have. It's coarse in the beginning
but it can be ground down fine. Youll know best and correct ( t)
It can only come through a trance. You have to put her in a
trance. You've got to do it that way to make yourself known.'
[Foster required no trance, and many of the heteromatic writers
require no trance. H.H.] L.: 'Is it bad for the medium?'
G.: 'It's the only way Lodge; in one sense ifs bad, but in another it's good. It is her work. If I take possession of the
medium's body, and she goes out, then I can use her organism
to tell the world important truths. There is an infinite power
above us. Lodge believe it fully, infinite over all, most marvelous. One can tell a medium she's like a ball of light. You
look as dark and material as possible, but we find two or three
lights shining. It's like a series of rooms with candles at one
end. Must use analogy to express it. When you need a light
you use it, when you have finished you put it out. They are
like transparent windows to see through. Lodge, it's a puzzle.
It's a puzzle to us here in a way though we undentand it better
than you. I work at it hard. I do. I'd g,ve anything I possess
to find out. I don't care for material things now, our interest
is much greater. I am studying hard how to communicate; it's
not easy. But it's only a matter of a short time before I shall
be able to tell the world all sorts of things through one medium
or another. — ,Who's that? ' L. : ' It is my brother. He's taking
notes. . . . How is it they see their things? ' G.: ' I don't know,
there is something about articles worn by spirits which retains
their personidity ( ?) and a spirit controlling a medium is s«isitive to such. , nine cases out of ten they will recognize their
things; it doesn't come from your mind.' L.: 'Then it's not
434
Mrs. Pipet,s Bngliah Sittings, 1889m
[BL II, Pi lY
ordinaxy thought transferenoe.' G. : * No, it's Jiot thai Inyeat,
gate. You can verify with patience. From time to time you
will hear from me and I will advise youu I met a lady in America— a Mrs. Dorr ' [mother of Mr. George B. Dorr, whom we
shall meet later. H.H.]. [A lady well known to Mrs. Piper, but
I did not happen to know the name then. OJ*.!*.] L.: 'Dawt'
G. : ' No, Dorr, D o r r, a very nice lady; veiy intellectual spiritual and good. I had a long talk with her, and through her I
found the medium. She is a medium. These people are links
between the material and spirit worlds. ... Where's Myers!
Give him my love. I want to help him. Lodge, when I passed
out at first I didn't know who I was, nor where I was. I hunted
about for my friends and for my body. Soon however my sister
welcomed me. Three of them, all drowned. If I see Myers I
will talk to him. No spirit in the spirit world is more anxioua
to let friends know than I was. [Some private matter here.]
Don't mention this. Tell Myers if you like. Myers is my confidential friend. There is nothing I wouldn't luive him know.
Kate is my wife, my sister is Ellen, [abbreviated] Lodge keep
up your courage; there is a quantity to hope for yet. Hold it
up for a time. Don't be in a hurry. Get facts; no matter what
they call you, go on investigating. Test to fullest. Assure yourself, then publish. It will be all right in the end — no question
about it. It's true. • . .' L. : ' What sort of person is tiiis Dr.
Phinuitf ' [It is noteworthy that all the Controls treat Phinuit
as a genuine person of whom they have to speak circumspectly
when he is likely to be able to overhear what they are saying or
read what they are writing. Compare, for instance, statements
about him made by G. P. in the Hodgson Beport; footnote to
page 369, VoL 13.] In the present instance the Gumey Control
replied to my question thus :— *'Dr. Phinuit is a peculiar type of
man ; he goes about continually and is thrown in with everybody.
He is eccentric and quaint but good hearted. I wouldn't do the
things he does for anything. He lowers himself sometimes; it's
a great pity. He has very curious ideas about things and people,
he receives a great deal about people from themselves ( f). And
he gets expressions and phrases that one doesn't care for, vulgar
phrases he picks up by meeting uncanny people through the
medium. These things tickle him and he goes about repeating
them. He said to me the other day ', Mr. Gurnoy what you think
a gentleman said to me the other day: he said ' put that in your
pipe
smokeHe it,hasDr.'to "interview
He picksa great
up thisnumber
sort ofofthing
tiddeeandhim.
peopleandandit
has no easy berth of it. A high type of man couldn't do the
work he does. But he is a good-hearted old fellow. Good-bye
Lodge. Here's the Doctor coming.' L.: 'Good-bye Gumey.
Glad to have had a chat with you.'
'' (The Control here changes back again.) P.: 'This [ring]
belongs to your Aunt Your Uncle Jerry tdls me to ask. • • • By
Ch. XXX]
Aunt Isabel
Mare Qumey
435
the way, do you know Mr. Qurney's been here; did you hear
himl' L.: 'Yes, I've had a long talk with hinu'"
Evening of %UK Dec., 191,,. (Pr.XXinA54.)
, (Dr. Phinuit speaking and reporting in the first person.)
* I could ahnost come back and die over again to see you. You
tell Mary that her sister Isabel [See laterl still lives; tell her
she has done nobly; tell her William and 1 are together. That
•'
lazy gardener I
, (Then the voice and manner changed to that of the Oumey
control. G. : ' Don't give up a good thing. Lodge. . . • Who is
here I ' L. : ' This is my wife.' G. : ' How do you do, Mrs. Lodge
(shaking hands) {i.e,, the medium does. H.HJ. I remember
having tea with you once.' [It was true that Mr. Gumey had
G.:
done so.] L.: (Introducing) 'Mr. and Mrs. Thompson.'
* Yes, I remember you, I think. [They had once met] Good-by,
Lodge; don't divulge my secrets.' L.: 'No, all nght; goodby.'' [L.] .'
The point of this short episode is the sudden and natural stoppage of the conversation directly the control realises that
strangers are present. That and the introductions that followed
were all just as if the Gumey control were a person really
present."
Monday Evening, ML February, 1890. (Pr.XXin,155f .)
, Phinuit suddenly said, ' Here's Mr. Gumey.' (Thereupon
the control appeared to change, the impression somehow con*
veyed being very much as if Phinuit were leaving and another
coming in his place. The voice also became different and more
educated than before. No longer was I called ' Captain,' nor
were people's relations and personal affairs any more regarded
as objects of interest) . . . G. : ' It is wonderfully difficult to communicata All the time Fve been here I have only found two
mediums beside this one. More people might be mediums, but
many won't when they can.' L. : ' What constitutes a medium ? '
G. : ' Not too much spirituality and not too much animaHsm, not
tiie highest people and not the lowest. Sympathetic and not too
self-conscious, able to let their minds be given up to another-*
that sort of person— easily influenced. Many could, but their
pride and a sense of self comes in and spoils it' [Despite
Phinuit and Gumey, my conscience does not trouble me on the
point, if you will pardon my saying so. ,H.H.l L. : ' Gumey,
what about those table-tilting and physical tningst Is there
anything in themt' G.: 'Mostly fraud. The rest electricity.
[Apparently a queer remark for Gumey, but possibly not beyond
natural carelessness. Of course all modes of force are interchangeable. H.H.] A person's nerves are doing they don't
know what Th, are often not conscious when they move
things.' L.: 'It's like automatic writing then t' G.:' Something.
436 Mrs, Piper,s English Sittings, 1889-90 [BL II, Pt IV
Often the tilts and noises are made by them when under the
control of some other spirit, and then tibe message may be genuine. Trance things and automatic writing are good. Often
good. Other things sometimes, but mostly fraud.' L.: 'Can
things be moved without contact?' G.: 'No, all bosh.' [We
know better now; there are hosts of cases. See under Telekinesis. H.H.] L. : ' Then that Eglinton writing, with bits of
pencil untouched t ' G. : ' Trickery, Lodge. Not worth a thought.
Most of this I have gone into, and it's as false as that elf, &at
fiend, I might say. She bewitched me once. What's her name,
that woman who smoked! ' L. : ' Blavatsky ? ' G. : ' That's her
name. ...Who is this!' L.: 'It's my sister, a young girL'
G. : ' Oh; pleased to make your acquaintance. I didn't meet you
I think.' E. 0. L. : ' No, I never saw you.' G. : ' Glad to see you
now. . . . Phinuit will be coming bac, soon. He's a good old
man.
, He has
a hardallplace.
tiie hxmting
work he up
doestheir
for
anything.
Seeing
mannerI wouldn't
of peopledoand
friends, and often he has hard work to persuade them that th,
are reflJly wanted.' L.: 'Is he reliable?' G.: 'Not perfectly,
he is not a bit infallible. He mixes things terribly sometimes.
He does his best; he's a good old man but he does get confused,
and when he can't hear distinctly he fills it up himself. He does
invent things occasionally, he certainly does. Sometimes he has
▼ezy hard work.' L. : ' Are his medical prescriptions any goodf '
O.: 'Oh, he's a shrewd doctor. He ,ows his business thoroughly. He,can see into people [He certainly did into me.
H.H.], and is veiy keen on their complaints. Yes, he is good
in that way, very good.' L.: 'Can he see ahead at all? Can
anyone?' G.: 'I can't. I haven't gone into that I think
Phinuit can a little sometimes. He can do wonderful things;
he has studied these things a good deal; he can do many things
that I can, do. . . . But he is far from being infallible.' L. : ' The
Thompsons are waiting in next room. Shall I call them in?'
G. : ' The Thompsons ? Oh, I know, I met them at your house
once at dinner I think. No, I don't specially want to see them.
Well, Lodge, I must be going. Good-by.' (Here the medium
seemed to sleep a few moments, and then woke up again in the
Phinuit manner, putting out hand and feeling sitter's head.)
' Eh, what. Oh, yes. All right. [This was internal colloquy.]
Look here, Mr. Gumey has been here; he told me to express his
regret that he had not said good-by to Miss Lodge.' E. C. L. :
' Oh, it doesn't matter a bit' P. : ' Fm to tell him that, am I.
'
Very well
" [L.] Again it was the dramatic character of the sx>eaking
that was impressive— |-rather than the things said. ... I attach no
importance to what is said concerning physical phenomena: it
does not pretend to represent more than an individual opinion,
whoever the individual may be. . . . The casual refeTenoe of unknown phenomena, part to fraud, the rest to ' Electricity,' though
CL XXX]
Significance in Changes of Control
437
quite common with uneducated people, was especially unworthy
of Edmund Oumey, and not in the least the sort of thing he
would have said to me when alive. [Then it was not telepathy
from Sir Oliver, whatever it was. H.H.] . . . But the little friendly
speeches to my sister were quite appropriate to Mr. Gumey, and
so especially was the readiness to depart the instant he heard
that the Thompsons were waiting to come in. ...Not that he
had any objection to them; but, besides the dislike of keeping
anyone waiting, he had the natural unwillingness of the man of
sensitive temperament to be thrown with strangers needlessly.
" It will have been observed that several times in the record I
have emphasized the change of control. I have done so all the
more explicitly because now [1909. H.H.] it seems a comparatively extinct, or at any rate a less pronounced, feature. The
whole business of 'control' seemed more difficult then [1889.
H.H.], and it is possible that a personality really changes now
without our noticing the change so much. Then, however . . •
once I remember it occupied a minute or two, with a muttered
internal coUoquy going on, as if there were a tangle or a hitch
somewhere.
" The naturalness of the change in manner and memory was
very pronounced. ... A reader may think that this is due to the
peifection of conscious acting, while a sitter of any experience
will hardly think that. The fluctuation of memory is certainly
not artificial; it is a genuine change of personality — ,whatever
that may be . . . unmistakably analogous to multiple personality,
whether that be ever due to control by actual possession or
not
"February Srd, 1890 (as reported on p. 560, Vol. 6), I asked
for a certain person to come and control instead of only sending
messages, and was told that it was too difficult. I pleaded ' Mr.
Gumey does.' To which Phinuit replied, 'You are greedy.
Yes, Mr. Gumey does, but Mr. Gumey is a scientific man, who
has gone into these things. He comes and turns me out sometimes. It would be a very narrow place into which Mr. Gumey
couldn't get.' "
This closes the report which Sir Oliver made in 1909 (Pr.
XXIII ), giving more fully than he did in Pr. VI the contemporaneous report of the Gumey sittings that took place in
1889.
The appearances of the Gumey control in 1889 were largely
picked out and made consecutive, from sittings when other
controls also appeared. We will now revert from the account
of the Gumey control in Pr. XXIII, then twenty years old,
to the contemporary account in Pr. VI of the other controls
438
Mrs. Pipe/s EngltBh 8iUing$, 188M0
[Bk. H, Pt IV
who sometimes appeared at the same sittings when Gnrney
didy and sometimes at others. Here is a characteristic Phinuit touch (Pr. YI, 484) :
*, She remembers more than 70a do. What do 70a think alia
says to met She says, don't swear, doctor; she did» sure as you
Uve."
There is a Tery remarkable case of tdopsis, too long to give
here, in Pr. VI, 487-90.
BiHingU.
D«<:emfter S4ened to go
off.) P. : * Hullo, I didn't do that Jeny did that, to remind
you of him. Here, take it away — ,it goes springing off — ,it's
aUve.' Mrs. T.: 'What can we do for Theodora's headaches t'
P. : ' Nerves of stomach out of order. Have you got anything
of hers to give me?' O. L.: 'Go and get a lock of her hair.'
(Mr. T. went next door for that purpose.) P.: 'It was Uncle
Jeny, the one that had the fall. Ill bring you some more news
of him. Give me back his nine-shooter. (Meaning the watch.)
{Here hair was brought in, and O. L. and A. L. were ordered by
)r. P. to " dear out," which they did.] I don't care to talk
diseases before everybody. [Note 0.] Confound it, I saw
your influence before anyone else here. Didn't the Captain tell
you? You lost your purse, and if you had told me I could
have found it... Mighty mean trick about the puisel Lord!
done as quick as a fly. [Note P.] Who is the lady wears a
440
Mrs. Pipet,s Bngliih Sittings, 1889-90
[Bk. 11, Ft IV
cap in the spirit? She don't part her hair in the middle — she
Benda her love to you (Mrs. T.).' Mrs. T.: 'Perhaps it is my
mother.' P.: ,Well, I see more than a dozen ladies, but she
wears a laoe cap. There was some throat trouble in your mother.
(Indicating.) [Kote QJ] The mother of one of you is in the
body. I think it is the gentleman's. She is an angel — she is a
good woman — ,has some trouble with ankle — left one — it catches
her. She will be with you for some time.' [Note BJ] "
NOTEB
" 0. Mr. T.'s daughter's headaches well described, and some
Tery old-fashioned herb remedies suggested, with the recommendation tosee him (Dr. P.) again in six weeks if not cured.
'' P. Mr. T. was robbed of his purse in London dO years ago
— serious matter to him then.
" Q. Bemarkably correct description of Mrs. T.'s mother, who
always wore laoe cape and with ribbons to hide a lump on throat
— she parted her hair at side.
" B. Mr. T.'s mother, aged 81, living in Cheshire. The statement about pain in ankle was true; she had rheumatic pains in
left ankle at the time."
Sitiing 46. Christmas Day, 1889. (Pr.VI,512f.)
''Present: O. L. and Alfred Lodge.
''P.: 'How are you, Captain? Who have you got to see us
this timet ' O. L. : ' No one. We are having this to ourselves.'
P. : ' How's Mr. Thompson? He's all right, is he? I am pleased
he was here. How are you, Alfred? . . . Give me some things of
Aunt Anne's, and give me Uncle Jerry's watch again. . . . Aunt
Anne wants to know where her very dark brown doak is; if
Eleanor has it. A funny-looking thing; is that what you call
sealskin? She would like Ellen to have it. They want Eleanor
— ,EUenelly — ,Ellen to make a change in her surroundings, for
her good, at least until Alfred is settled. She is all mixed up
now. [True.] She should come into your surroundings, the
work will be good for her, it will take her out of herself. Give
her something to think about, it will be better for her physically
and every way. Your mother says so, Uncle Jerry says so.
Uncle John says so, your mother and father say so, and Aunt
Anne says so. There now, they are very anxious about it.' [All
these were no longer living, and Phinuit professed to speak for
them from the spirit world. H.H.] O. L. : ' But they must send
her name better.'
" [Note (Pr.VI,507).— [L.1. The welfare of my only sister,
Eleanor, commonly called X,ellie, much younger than the
brothers, and left in their charge is naturally a care to us, and
the advice given and subsequently iterated again and again by
Phinuit, as the one message which my mother was anxious to
send, is extremely natural Mrs. Piper had not seen, nor so far
Ch. XXX]
Lodge Family Controls
441
as I know heard of, my sister, who was in Staffordshire during
this first series; but at the second series of sittings she was
present on a short visit* The state of her health has for some
time made her place of abode and study a serious consideration.]
" P. : * Give me a pendL (Wrote on back of letter while holding it to forehead tiie word * Nellie ' distinctly.) There, that's
her name, and that's your Aunt Anne's writing; she wrote it. . . .
This was a Russian watch — the Emperor of Russia once had it.
[Enow nothing of this.] . . . Captain, your friends [in ,' spirit
world.',
very Let
anxious
about
Nelly.surroundings
They know for
she'sa
not been n.H.}
feehngarewelL
her be
in your
little while. It will do her good. If you can't see it now you
will see it in the future. • . . It's true, I tell you. They know
what they are talking about. ...Our poor little Alfred [her
brother. H.n.] can't see it as we can. He wants her in his
surroundings to be with him. Your mother says it's not wise,
not yet, anyhow. . . . She says distinctly, " She must be in Oliver's
surroundings for a while." [All this advice would be exceedingly important if it could be depended on. ...Her keeping
house for Alfred was one of the floating ideas.] To appreciate my advice is one thing, to remember me is another. Don't
forget me, my boy. Jerry says, *' Do you know Bob's got a long
skin — ,a skin like a snake's skin — upstairs, that Jerry got for
him? " If s one of the funniest things you ever saw. Ask him
to show it you. Oh, hear them talkingl Captain 1 '
, [L.] This episode of the skin is noteworthy. I cannot
imagine that I ever had any knowledge of it. Here is my Uncle
Robert's accoimt of it when I asked hun about it: * Yes, a crinkly
thin skin, a curious thing; I had it in a box, I remember it well.
Oh, as distinct as possible. Haven't seen it for years, but it
was in a box with his name cut in it; the same box with some
of his papers.'" [Teloteropathy from Uncle R.? H.H.]
Sitting 4:7, Evening of Christmas Day, 1889. (Pr.VI,516f.)
'' Present: O. J. L. and A. L. (taking notes).
"' Captain, do you know that as I came I met the medium
going out [i.e., his spirit met the medium's spirit! H.H.],
and she's crying. Why is that 9' [Why couldn't he know tdepathically, if telepathy accounts for all this? H.H.] O. L.:
* Well, the fact is she's separated from her children for a few
days, and she is feeling rather low about it.' P. : * How are you,
Alfred? I've your mother's influence strong. (Pause.) By
Oeorgel that's Aunt Anne's ring (feeling ring I had put on my
hand just before sitting), given over to you. [Aunt Anne
takes control? H.H.] Aiid OUy dear, that's one of the last
things I ever gave you. It was one of the last things I
said to you in the body wh,n I gave it you for Mary. I
said, ,For her, through you."' [This is precisely accurate.
The ring was her most valuable trinket, and it was given
442
Mrs. Pipef,s Bngliih BHHngn, 1889-90
[6k. n, Pt lY
in the way here stated not long before her death.] ...O. L.:
'Yes,
remember
'I tell ofyon
ImowI am
it.
I shall I nerer
forgetpeifecti,.'
it. Keep A.
i, inA.:memoiy
me,I for
not dead. Each spirit is not so dim ( t) that it cannot recollect
its belongings in the body. They attract ns if there has h&esa
anything special abont them. I tell yon, my boy, I can see it
just as plain as if I were in the body. It was the last thing I
gave yon, for her, through you, always in remembrance of me.
(Furdier conversation and advice, ending) Convince yourself,
,Regarding
spirits'to survival!
H.H.] and
do the
We are all liable
make mistakes;
but let
youothers
can see
for same.
yourself '
', P. : ' Give me that watcL [Trying to open
once
knife open
ms Here,
it. Take it out of its case. Jerry says he tookit.]
and made some little maika up heie with it, up here near the
handle, near the ring, some little cuts in the watch. Look at it
afterwards in a good light and you wiU see them.' [There is a
little engraved landscape in the place described, but some of the
skylines have been cut unnecessarily deep, I iJiink, apparendy
out of mischief or idleness. Certainly I knew nothing of this,
and had never before had the watch out of its case.— -O.J.L.] ,
Extract from letter [frtm Uncle Robert}. (Pr.VI,528.)
*, Great Geahies, Ilford, September 16th, 1890.
"As you wished me to send you notes of anything that strudc
me in the report of Mrs. Piper's sittings — ,here goes.... The
marks on the watch I do not think were made by him, as I
cannot remember his having a repeater until he lost his sight.
The term ' little shaver ' fits his method of expression to a T."
Sitting 49. December 2Bth, ISSd. (Pr.VI,62Qf.)
,Piesent: O. L., alone; afterwards M. L. also.
,
Then came Ifrs. Lodge, and Phinuit began to diagnose
her illness, which he did veiy exactly,, and to prescribe for her.
The prescription was wild carrot infusion and laudanum lotions,
with precise and minute instructions. The prescriptions have
done good. The complaint has been a long-standing one.**
In connection with this should be read the following (Pr.
VI, 546-7) :
, P. : ' Maiy, you come here; let those people dear out You
have been taking carrot' M. L.: 'Yes, you told me ta' P.:
* Yes, I know. Well, now you have taken plenty of that. Get
TJrsi. Do you Imow what that is? (No.) Well, it's
some Uvie cranberry.
mountain
Qet some of those leaves. You can get
the infusion, but leaves are better because pure. Let them steep
and take a wineglassftd before going to bed. Take it instead of
carrot for three weeks and then carrot again. (Medical details
gone into, accurate in general, but one statement which turned
out false. Prescribed also for third bay> vis., Sos. Huxum's
Clu XXX]
Phinu%r$ Prescriptuma
443
tinctaie of cinchona, Soz. French dialyzed iron, and 4oz. drug*
gists' simple syrup; a teaspoonful after fthaking in wineglass of
water, with a few drops of lemon juice or other acid.) He has
a pain here when he runs, blood poor, &o. [Details correct.]
Give him milk, lime water, and eggs.' (Further advice to M.
L., who having had the influenza badly, was in low spirits, with
attempts to cheer her.) ''
And yet more than one objector has said that Phinuit is
absolutely ignorant of medicine 1
Here is a strange, strange circumstance. It fits well enough
here to justify an episode. June 26, 1895, Phinuit says to
Professor Newbold, as per the unpublished Notes :
"Nothing special the matter with your liver, but it is inactive
sometimes and that throws the bile into the stomach. Do you
know what aloes aret Qet some rhubarb, aloes, and mandrake,
6/8 grain of aloes, 2/8 mandrake, and 1/8 of rhubarb compounded into a snudl pill and take one every night."
Now yean ago I was very seriously troubled by bile working
up into the stomach. A veiy great physician gave me Elixir
Euonymus, which acted like magic. I learned that it was a
cholagogue. A few months ago I said : , By the way, Doctor,
I may have to go to Euonymus again, but it has always
struck me as strange that when I was troubled by excess of
bile, you gave me a drug to make more. It did the trick,
however, and that's enough." I forget his answer: for I
was leaving somewhat hastily, having already used up more
time than either of us had to spare. Probably no more passed
than a laugh over the satisfactory result of the paradox. I
remember that he admitted it to be a paradox, and that I felt
that his facing it and doing his work in spite of it, was an
illustration of his greatness. Well, here is Phinuit doing pre-'
dmly the same thing! Now was Mrs. Piper, masquerading as
Phinuit, a really great doctor too? Or was Phinuit really
himself and a great doctor ? He was no doctor at all, according to several skeptical commentators — not in the opinion of
Sir Oliver Lodge, hovever, in whose family he ', practised,,'
and whose opinions are thought worthy of respect by the people
in England who confer knighthoods, and elect the presidents
of the A. A. S., not to speak of those everywhere who gratefully read his writings and profit by his investigations.
Do yon reaiiM that through Mrs. Piper, a woman of no
444
Mrs. Pipef,s English Sittings, 1889-90
[Bk. II, Pt IV
special education or capacity, except in her strange gift when
she was not herself, spoke a trained, judicious, resourceful, and
sttccessful physician? This physician used slang and swore.
So have a great many other good physicians. He was vain.
So are a great many other good physicians. He pieced out
his knowledge with conjecture. That's the habit, and even
the tradition, of the profession — it is necessary in many cases,
more than in any other profession in the main honest With
unvarying labor and patience, despite a little humorous irritability, this physician treated many people, as we have seen
and shall see more later, to their physical and emotional good,
and he misled no man to his hurt Was she that physician?
Did she get the knowledge, training, character, telepathically
from some other physician? Account for it in all ways yet
tried, is not the simplest and most rational just the plain
fact? Beside this explanation every other yet offered is
labored, sophisticated, and self-deceiving. This one, it is true,
is counter to nearly all human experience. So are a great
many things that people don't bend all their energies to make
seem different from what they appear. I am not arguing for
spiritism : I don't yet know whether to " believe " in it or not
I'm arguing only for common sense, as I see it, and honesty
towards one's self wherever the ways may lead. They may,
on the whole, lead away from spiritism, for all I know, but
they don't in this case.
But to return to the sitting (Pr. VI, 622) :
', P. : ' She has a picture of him. [Apparently Lady Lodge's
deceased brother. H.H.] They talked about having it copied.'
[Right] M. L.: 'What sort of picture?' P.: 'It's a painting of him.' M. L.: 'Who did itf P.: 'Wait a bit, PU
ask him. Oh, I see, you done it yourself. [Again, telepathy
would hardly give him bad grammar from Lady Lodge. H.H.]
[True, and he used to he pleased with it] He says so. It's a
good one. You're a good little girl, Mary. I say, do you know
who Isabella isf ' M. L.: 'Yes, yes.' P.: 'Oh, it is splendid;
you never saw her sad. Though she had her troubles, too.'
M. L. : ' She had, indeed.' P. : ' She is as beautiful as ever, and
as pure as the snow. She's a good creature.' [Isabella takes
possession. H.n.] ' I tdl you, you dear thing, to be as brave as
I was — always do the best you can ; do what your conscience tells
you. Take that advice from Isabella. Oh, what larks we had!
Ohl (Laughing all over.) Do you remember Clara! (Laugh-
Ch. XXX]
Lodge and Hionipion Families
445
ing again, and jigging about in chair.) FU sing for you. Why,
Mary dear, who ever thought to see you again like this, and
Oliver toot Oh, such fun I iWhat shall I do for you now I'm
here f ' M. L. : ' Sing us one of your songs.' I. : ' Shall I f Tou
used to sing and play some yourself. Your papa and I have
more fun thiui you could shake a stick at. Mary, how fat you
are! Where are your crimps t (Feeling hair.) You used to
crimp it. [True.] Oetting buy, eht Well, this is fun to see
you again. Oh, 1 do feel so happy. (Dr. P. chuckling.) She
whistled, and away she goes. I never saw such a merry girl as
that, never. How happy she is. Mary, it's about time you
brightened up.' [This extraordinary episode was very realistic,
and represented our memory of a brightslispositioned aunt by
marriage of my wife's.] "
Sitting 50, last of first series. December 26th, 1889.
(Pr.VI,623f.)
"Present : O. L. and Mr. and Mrs. Thompson ; later M. L. also,
".
(To Mrs. L.) : ' Aunt Izzie wants to talk to you. [See
previous sitting, * Isabella '; Aunt Izzie was her familiar name.]
[She takes possession. H.H.] 'Shall I sing to you? What
would you like? You have not been well lately. Are you glad
to hear of Aunt Izzie t I could almost come back and die over
again to see you. You tell Mary that her sister Isabel still lives ;
tell her she has done nobly; tell her William and I are together.
That lazy gardener ! ' [This message is exceedingly intelligible.
The Mary referred to is my wife's mother, recently widowed, and
left with a house and garden to manage in Staffordshire. ' Aunt
Izzie ' had been staying with her quite recently, at a time when
the gardener was troublesome.] (Then the voice and manner
chaxiged [to Gum,. H.H.]
'Don't give up a good thing.
.'
Lodge.
''Mr. T.: 'Can you tell me about my other sister?' P.;
'Sarah — ,no — ,Eliza-Maria — ,that's it. She's all right. We are
together and happy. That's Ted's sister and Ike's sister. She
and Ted and father are all together. She teaches entirely, and is
very religious. But she doesn't know you (Mrs. T.) in spectacles. (Took them off.) That's right; now I know you....
Cap'n, I'm going to leave you. Ood bless you and keep you in
His holy keeping. God bless you, Susie, &e, Marie, and Captain I Cap'n, I hiate to leave you, but I've got to go. Au revoir,
au revoir I Marie, I've got to go, but not for long; hope to see
you soon again. Cap'n, speak to me again. Good-by, good-by,
" of the First Series of Liverpool Sittings.
good-by.' End
Bitting 77. (First after interval) January Zlst, 1890.
(Pr.VI,581f.)
"Present: O. L., M. L., and, for first time, E. C. L.
" After recognitions and greetings, and saying that Myers had
446
Mrs. Piper,a English SUtings, 1889,
[Bk. II, Ft IV
told him to take cai6 of the medinia and not stay too lon,, he
[Phinuit H.H.] began sending messages about my sister, but
speedily became awaie of someone present and recognized her
with 'Hallo, by George, that's Ndly. . • . Come here, Sisa (to
NeUie). [Sir Oliver's sister. Phinuit sees her (!) for the first
time, and recognises her. Cf . pp. 440-1. ELH.] Yonr father [i.e,,
his *, spirit" n.H.] wants me to loc, at yon. Oh, you're not at
all right. You're wrong.' £. 0. L. : ' Oh, Fm pretty welL' P. :
' You feel pretty well, but you're nol You haven't a right circulation at all. You are what they call annmic,' Ac [Full medical details given at considerable length, all true, and prescriptions practically identical with what had been tried by London
and Malvern consulting physicians. Then advice given to stay
with me instead of elsewhere.] ,
Bitting 79. February Isi, 1890. (Pr.VI,686f.)
'' [Here M. L. entered with our second boy, who had begged to
see Dr. Phinuit, all the children being curious about the strange
voice. Phinuit immediately personated ATunt] A[nne.] . . .
A. A.: 'Mary, bring him here. You dear little fellow. Ood
bless you. That's what's his name. Oliver dear, have I lost my
memory! That's Bumey, Bury B, Bodie Brodie. Yes, Brodie.
[The name Bumey is, as it happens, a natural one to occur first
to A. A.] I remember you, my dear, when you were quite small
— flight hair — ,a chubby little thing. You don't remember Aunt
Anne 9 ' M. L. : ' No.' A. A. : ' He was the last, I think. Lef s
see, another older and another younger. Yes, three. One older
and one younger.' M. L. : ' Yes, there were three.' A. A. : ' But
this was my boy. Oliver, wasn't that l,e last? Seems to me
another one that I saw.' O. L.: 'Yes, three altogether.' A. A.:
' Another boy. Three boys. One named after your father ' (to
M. L.). M. L.: 'Yes.' A. A.: 'That was the last.' (Further
friendly remarks to Brodie about his lessons and so on. Some
from Phinuit speaking in his own person. Ending :) ' Glad to
see that fellow; done me good. [The grammar puzde again.
H.H.] Good-by, Brodie. That's a piece to make a man of. Let
him go. . . . That boy is a deep thinker. . . • Nell [Sir O.'s sister],
how's your heart? Smashed yet?' £. 0. ll: 'My what?'
P. : ' No, no, it's
has had his heart smashed. [Conventionally true.] . . . Nelly, have you got your medicine? ' £. 0. L.:
' No.' P. : ' She must take it (and so on, insisting on her taking
it, which she had not intended to do). Nell, how do you suppose
1 knew the name of the man owning the chain ? ' E. 0. L. : ' I
can't imagine.' P. : ' No, can you tell a body's name like that?'
E. C. L. : ' No.' P. : ' No, it will be a good test, to him and to the
world. Be a good girl. God watch over you, bless you, and all
good spirits guide and help you. FU see you again, I must go.
Au revoir/ "
Ch. XXX]
More of Thompson FamUy
447
Siiting SO. Fehruartf 2nd, 1B90. (PT.VI,689f.)
'eople come here. Gk)odby, Susie. Good-by, Ike. Good-by, Nelly. Now, aJl clear out
and let me talk to Marie. (Long conversation of a paternal
kind, with thoroughly sensible advice. Then O. L. returned.)
Captain, it's not good-by, it's au revoir, and you shall hear of me
when Pve gone away.' O. L. : ' How can I f ' P. : ' Oh, I will
tell some gentleman a message and he will write it for meu
You'll see.
**' Au revoir, au revoir/ Ac.'*
End of Second Series of Sittings at Liverpool.
and last of Phinuit and his Lodge friends; and my scraps,
though selected with great care and labor, must give a very
inadequate idea of their association. I strongly recommend
the interested reader to get Pr. Part (not Volume) XVIL
We now reach the sittings edited by Dr. Leaf (Pr. VI,
658-615).
Dr. Leaf speaks of Phinuifs ', complete ignorance of
French.'' This has already been disposed of. It is not
strange, however, that testimony of what occurs in these
foggy regions is contradictory : it is hard enough to get good
evidence in everyday affairs. Dr. Leaf also ascribes to Phinuit
rather more ,' fishing , than other commentators do, and gives
ingenious demonstrations of it, but yet says (Pr. VI, 561f.) :
" His supposed fishing was employed, if at all, only when the
supernormal power was for a time in abeyance; possibly it is
only an imagination of my own. But even with all risk of
being misunderstood, it seems essential that this side should be
put forward, if only to show that the investigators were fully
alive to all the various methods by which it might be possible
to take advantage of their credulity or carelessness. The more I
consider the whole of the evidence, the more I remain convinced
that it gives proof of a real supernormal power, subject, however, under conditions at which we can hardly even guess, to
periods of temi>orary eclipse
*' It is probable that here a certain amount of muscle-reading
was called into play as a guide to a right conclusion. The
medium usually sat with the hand of the sitter pressed to her
forehead. The attitude is a favorite one with so-called thoughtreading performers. [As already said, this was given up later,
as she appeared to grow in power. H.H.]| ... A very common
statement was that some relation of the sitter was lame in the
knee, or still more commonly that he had rheumatism there.
This was usually accompanied by a grasping of the knee, whidi
Ch. XXX]
Dr. Leafs Opinions
449
fluggeflts muscle-reading. In one case the suffering was followed
downwards and rightly located in the toe. At other times the
pain was said to be in the head — ,headaches or neuralgia. This
was equally accompanied by feeling over the sitter's head. Not
only are rheumatism and headaches two of the commonest of
complaints, and the most likebr to be guessed right, but the
knee and the head were the most accessible portions of the
sitter's frame, and those about which unconscious information
could best be given. ' SufFering from a cold,' too, was a favorite diagnosis. As the sittings took place in December and January, and the later ones during the height of the influenza epidemic, itis not to be wondered at that this was generally admitted to be correct
"I have now gone through all the possible explanations of
divination by ftsud which after a careful study of the whole of
the evidence I am able to suggest.. It will be found that th,
are far from covering the whole of the facts."
Now there was nothing of the kind in my sitting some
years later, or, I suspect, in any of the sittings after the exclusively writing period set in. The time has passed for this
sort of ingenuity, and commentators seldom trouble themselves with it now. I give it, however, " to be fair."
Here I think is a questionable saltus, unless the first sentence isrestricted to the incidents in hand (Pr. YI, 567) :
,Several instructive incidents point directly against any
knowledge derived from the spirits of the dead. For instance,
in Mrs. H. Leafs first sitting a question was put about ' Harry,'
whose messages Phinuit purported to be giving: 'Did he leave
a wife?' No answer was given to this at &e time, but in
accordance with Phinuif s frequent practice the supposed hint
was stored up for future use; and at Mrs. H. Leafs next sitting
she was told, 'Harry sends his love to his wife.' Now, as a
matter of fact Harry never was married. In Mrs. B.'s second
sitting and in Mrs. A.'8 account of her brother's suffering in
the arm, wrong facts were stated which corresponded to the
sitter's belief. This evidently indicates thought-transference, not
spiritual communication."
It seems to me, as perhaps illustrated in the first sentence
of the above quotation, that commentators generally have
erred in trying to restrict mediumistic phenomena to some one
of several causes — thought-transference, fishing, fraud, secondary personality, or that merely nominal omnium gcMierum,
the subliminal self, whereas there is a strong chance that almost every stonce shows them all, in the case of the honert
450
Mrs. Pipet,s English Sittings, 1889-90
[Bk. n, Pt IT
mediums, allowing a little for anconsdoiis fraud and fishing.
In this view, the whole thing readily comes under the hypothesis ofthe Cosmic Soul — of ideas and impressions of all sorts
floating about the universe — ,picked up in all sorts of ways
and in all sorts of combinations, and remodeled into all sorts
of new combinations. Phinuit as above gets the ideas Harry,
wife, and remolds them into ''Harry sends his love to
wife/' just as in the case I gave early, Foster got the
SeztuSy manuscripts, publish, and blurted out, ''He says:
' Publish every word of them,* " when Sextus, I know if I
know anything unverified, never said any such thing.
It is quite probable too that all the ideas Harry, Sextos,
manuscripts, publish came from the sitter's mind. Wherever
they came from, they were parts of the hypothetical Cosmic
Soul. Now in that hypothetical soul " Harry " may be anything from a mere name, to Colonel Esmond, or the Harry in
question, just as Parthenon may be a name, a memory, a charcoal sketch, a photograph, a painting, the original structure,
a restoration of it in picture or model, or the ruins still left
And the aforesaid " Hany '' may be a memory in a sitter's
mind, and so be reflected into Phinuit's, or hypothetically a
survival of the original soul once expressed in a visible Harry,
and as such have not only announced himself at the first sitting, and even (for "communications" often seem difficult,
and often are plainly open to misunderstanding) have started
Phinuit into his blunder at the second sitting, by trying to
send some message to the sitter which Phinuit, with the idea
wife already in his head, misunderstood. But even if we
don't grope after an explanation of the " subliminal self " but
merely cover our mysteries with that name, and if we insist
on drawing a line (which the hypothetical cosmic inflow can
save us the trouble of doing) between thought-transference
and spiritism, that some phenomena are due to the one does
not prevent otheri phenomena being due to the other. That
most of the inflows of the Cosmic Soul in dreams are incoherent nonsense, does not prevent others being coherent, up
to creations transcending the art of the waking world, and
even up to prophecy. Don't flnd fault with all this because it
is vague. What else can be our glimpses into the unknown
world of these phenomena, whether it is a post-mortem world
Ch. XXX]
Phinuit BeflecU Mrs. Piper
451
or not? Demand only that what we think we see, shall not be
inconsistent with what we feel dear about.
Dr. Leaf says (Pr. VI, 667) :
"On the whole, then, the effect which a careful study of all
the reports of the English sittings has left in xny mind is this:
That
Dr. Phinuit
is only
a nameandforacting
Mrs. the
Piper's
personality,
assuming
the name
part secondaiy
wilhi the
aptitude and consistency which is shown by secondary personalities in other known cases.''
But he does not express an opinion regarding her other
controls, or whether each one of them was a ', secondary ''
personality; or how many thousand secondary personalities,
and of how many sexes, a woman can have I In fact, up to
the stage of these sittings, these questions hardly came to the
surface, because nearly all of ttie alleged communicationa
were through Phinuit, other apparent communicators so
seldom taking control that the change of control was not often,
if eyer, specially noted in the reports — a grave omission which
I have ventured here and there to attempt to supply.
Dr. Leaf gives first (Pr. VI, 668-74) a very remarkable
case of telopsis in the sitting of Mr. J. T. Clarke at Professor
W. James's house at Ghocorua, New Hampshire. I have no
space for these remarkable sittings, but urge them on the
attention of the interested reader.
Bitting on December 2Bth, 1889. (Pr.VI,589.)
'' Present: Mrs. Herbert Leaf, and Walter Leaf reporting.
Mrs. B. Leaf was introduced as * Miss Thompson.'
"P.: *I see you. How are you, you lady? I say, OaptainI
Captain, come here.' [,Captain' is the name by whidi Dr.
Phinuit speaks of Professor Lodge.] W. L. : ' The captain is
not here.' P.: 'Oh, then, tha,s you, Walter I Where are we
now? Where be I?'"
I have taken the above for its next to last word, as throwing
some possible light on Phinuit ', Where be I?" is rank
Connecticut Yankee of the time before the New York and
New Haven Railroad was built. It is probably Massachusetts
Yankee too. Mrs. Piper does not use such language, but it
abounded in her ancestry and ', surroundings." Phinuif s use
of it is the extreme illustration of that strange blend of New
England and France which constitutes him. I cannot see,
however, that this disproves the previous incarnation of the
452
Mrs. F%p&f,$ English Sittings, 1889,
[Bk. 11, Pt IV
fellow. On the cosmic-BOtil hypothesifl, Fhmnif a portion of
it has often been in the same receptacle with Mrs. Piper'a.
It is not necessaiy to suppose that her ezdnsion was complete.
In fact, many considerations look as if any number of souls
—at least my i souls on p. 310 — ,might telepathically yirtoally
occupy the same body at the same time. Of course there ia
nothing *, scientific , about this guess : we are far beyond the
reach of science. Such guesses, howeyer, sometimes suggest
a direction in which it pays science to keep an eye open. But
to return to Phinuit as a possible guest of Mrs. Piper's mortal
frame, which I don't believe he was — ,more than telepathically.
Here is a piece of intense Phinuitism (Pr. YI, 695) :
''I don't think Harry ever knew him [Professor Verrallt
H.H.] ; he passed out before you got hitched.
, [Oorrect; Harry died August, 1887, and I was married the
following September. — ,B.M.L.] "
On p. 606 of Pr. YI, Professor Macalister, writing to Mr.
Myers, says:
,, Mrs. Piper is not anssihetic during the so-called tranoe, and
if you ask my private opinion it is that the whole thing is an
imposture and a poor one."
Now as Mrs. Piper has been proved '' anaesthetic during
the so-called trance " several times by authorities at least aa
high as Professor Macalister (James being one), some question arises as to the value of the second opinion he states, and
of the value of the opinions held on the whole subject by any
excessively scientific person without enough mediumistic
faculty, whatever that may be, to make a good sitter.
This somewhat strenuous observation calls for a word.
I have already spoken of the advantage of a sympathetic
attitude on the part of the sitter. There seems to be more in
this than merely the greater liability of the sympathetic to
be gulled, and I venture on a few suggestions of what the
"more '' may be.
People in general, including sitters, fall into two classes:
those of the intuitive, humanistic, and sympathetic make-up,
and those of the calculating scientific, skeptical make-up—
,'Platonists and Aristotelians.'' The first group, I need
bardly say, includes the poets and most of those gener-
Ch. XXX]
Platonists and ArisMelianB
453
ally called philosophers — Socrates, Plato, and Goethe. The
second group indndes Aristotle, Bacon, and Spencer, all of
whom the ,'high priori" philosophers hardly admit to be
philosophers at all.
Now the first group seems to include the dreamers and the
mediums. Socrates with his inner voice and his hours of
sleepless unconsciousness, was in all probability a medium ; and
Plato and Goethe were both great dreamers ; while regarding
Aristotle, Bacon, and Spencer I cannot recall at the moment
any assertion of remarkable dreams.
Now it is noticeable through the reports that scientific men,
especially those devoted to the inorganic sciences, get very
little out of the sittings, and are disposed to vote them all
humbug. Sir Oliver Lodge is a marked exception. Sir
William Crookes and Sir WUliam Barrett have devoted themselves mainly to the telekinetic phenomena.
I am as far as possible from intimating that either dass is
superior to the other. It would be interesting to debate
whether we owe more to Shakespere or to Spencer, although I
should hardly take Shakespere for the mediumistic type of
man, but rather (if you and God will forgive me), for tho
medium-mystic, and he is always in medio iuiissimus.
Assuming the generalizations in the preceding paragraphs
to be well founded, we might risk a much more uncertain one
— ,that as truth is generally indicated first to the intuitive type
of mind — ,Eant with the nebular hypothesis and Goethe with
the relations of the vertebrso to the dceleton and the leaves to
the plant — so the free appearance of the phenomena of mediumship to the intuitive type of person, and the scant appearance to the scientific type, have a certain correspondence with
Nature's general ways, and so far raise a presumption that
the phenomena are normal and deserve study. There may
even be in this some color for presumptions going farther.
I want, however, to guard against being supposed to rate
intuition higher than I do. Early in this book I enlarged on
the inevitability of intuitions beyond the reports of senses in
course of evolution, as probably all our senses still are. Yet
intuition proves nothing, but merely points ways for investigation—often misleading ways. Nevertheless a man cannot
speak of it with any respect without danger of being supposed
464
Mrs. Pxpef,$ EngUah aUtinga, 1889-90
[Bk. 11, Pt lY
to Tate it as high as did the Qerman professor with his cameL
Professor Bergson has suffered from this — ,to such an extent
that when, before his American lectureSy he told me he considered intuition inconduaiye without verification, I was a
little surprised ; and when I told Mr. Butgers Marshall what
he had said, I was thought to have misunderstood him.
It is not surprising, then, to be told that Professor Maoalister's sitting was "unsatisfactory,'' and it is an amusingly
incorrect one throughout The same is true of the next sitting, the sitter's account of which begins in the following auspicious maimer, but note well the last line. Mr. Barkworth
was plainly not the victim of any gullible sympathy.
Mr. T. Barkwcrih. Deeemher Zrd. (Pr.VI,606.)
, In commencing the stance I held the medium's hands, which
were icj cold and did not seem to gather warmth. PuIsq very
feeble, often quite imperceptible, and somewhat rapid. The
medium seemed to find my influence uncongenial; she complained more than once that I had done sometiiing to her, that
her head was bad, that she felt queer, had never felt so before,
Ac. She continually groaned as if in suffering. After lon,
waiting Mr. Myers took my place with much better results."
Professor G. H. Darwin (p. 627) naturally is " wholly unconvinced ofany remarkable powers or of thought-transference." Equally naturally, though conversely, the next sitting
with Miss Alice Johnson is not half bad. Yet Dr. Leaf finds
n,uch apparent fishing in it, but ends with (Pr. YI, 614) :
"Even on the most unfavorable view, therefore, it seems necessary to assume more than dumoe and skill in order to explain
this sitting."
The following of course falls in with the good cases. Unfortunately, for the excellent reasons given below, no details
are furnished.
Miss X. December 7ih. (Pr.VI,629.)
"Miss X. was introduced, veiled, to the medium in the tranoe
state, inunediatelbr after her airival at Mr. Myers' house. She
was at once recognized, and named. 'You are a medium; you
write when you don't want to. You have got Mr. E.'s influence
about you. [E. was Edmund Gumey. Miss X. was a crystalgaser, and very prominent in the SP.B. H.H.1 This is Miss
X that I told you about' She was subsequently addressed by
Ch. XXX]
Miss X.
Mr. Konstamm
455
her Christian name, one of similar sound being first used but
eorrected immediately.
, A large part of the statements made at this and the follow,
ing sittings were quite correct, but in nearly all cases of so
private and personal a nature that it is impossible to publish
them. [As so often in the best sittings. H.H«] . . . But these
sittings were perhaps the most successful and convincing of the
whole series
,,
"' You see flowers sometimes t ' (Asked, * What is my favorite
flower? There is a spirit who would kncw.O ,Pansies. No,
delicate pink roses. You have them about you, spiritually as
well as physically.' Miss X. has on a certain day in every month
a present of delicate pink roses. She frequently has hallucinatory visions of flowers."
The following is suggestive. Compare with it the various
remarks on the influence of the sitter.
Mr. E. M. Konstamm.
January 26ih. (Pr.VI,646.)
E. was
thatisheinclined
knew oneto Allen,
ellow,
but**......
lame.Mr.This
the told
sitter
refer a tosmart
Mr. fRider
Haggard's 'Allan Quatermain/ whose adventures he had just
been reading."
Commenting at the dose of this series of sittings, Sir
Oliver Lodge says (Pr. VI, 647-8) :
,,Is thought-transference from the sitter, of however free
and unconscious a kind, a complete and sufficient mode of
accounting for the facts t Mr. Leaf definitely takes the position that ... it is sufficient, and, considering the large amount of
labor he has spent on the documents, his opinion is entitled to
very great weight. For myself, I am not so convinced, but I cordiaUy admit the difficulty of any disproof of his position
•"
Here are a few extracts from Professor James's paper in
this same volume (Pr. VI, 651f.) :
" As for the explanation of her trance-phenomena, I have none
to offer. The pritnd facie theory, which is that of spirit-control,
is hard to reconcile with the extreme triviality of most of the
communications. What real spirit, at last able to revisit his
wife on this earth, but would find something better to say thui
that she had changed the place of his photographt And yet
that is the sort of remaric to which the spirits introduced by the
mysterious Phinuit are apt to confine themselves. I must admit,
however, that Phinuit has other moods. He has several times,
when my wife and myself were sitting together with him, sud*
denly started off on long lectures to us about our inward defects
and outward shortoomingSy which were very earnest, as well as
456 Mrs. Piper,a English Sittings, 1889, \B}l II, Pt TV
•obtUe moraDy and psychologically, and impiessiye in a higii
degree. These diacourses, though given in Phinuit's own penon,
were very different in style from his more usual talk, and probably superior to anything that the medium could produce in the
same line in her natural state.''
All of which exceptional facts may mean simply that in
this case the sitter had the exceptional intellect and character,
including the candor, modesty, and capacity of self-examination of William James. Possibly it was a case of a man showing himself to himself — of the fourth-dimensional trick of
turning a rubber ball inside out without destroying it— an
anticipation of the possible port-mortem privilege of each soul
as a member of the Cosmic Soul, of r,arding itself face to
face — or the further possibility of telepatfaically regarding
itself as reflected in another soul. This last possibility is, I
suppose, rank spiritism. I rather like it.
But whatever the facts mean, they do not necessarily mean
for one moment that the "control '' exercising this sympathy
and delivering the resulting lecture, was not a discarnate spirit
that had been incarnate in a voluble and profane but very
amiable old French physician, rather mixed in a good many
of his far-back memories, and in some of his properties much
influenced by Yankee contact James goes on to say of him
(p. 666) :
,,Phinuit himself, however, bears every appearance of being a
fictitious being. His French, so far as he has been able to display it to me, has been limited to a few phrases of salutation,
which may easily have had their rise in tiie medium's ' unconscious'memory; he has never been able to understand my
French [He understood Mr. Rich's, Chap. XXIX! H.H.]; and
the crumbs of information which he gives about his earthly career are, as you know, so few, vague, and unlikely sounding, as to
suggest the remancing of one whose stock of materials for in*
vention is excessively reduoed. He is, however, as he actually
shows himself, a definite human individual, wi, immense tact
and patience, and great desire to please and be regarded as in*
fallible. . . . The most remarkable thing about the Phinuit personality seems to me the extraordinary tenacity and minuteness
of his memory. The medium has been visited by many hundreds
of sitters, half of them, perhaps, being strangers who have come
but once. To each Phinuit gives an hourful of disconnected
fragments of talk about persons living, dead, or imaginary, and
evoats past, future, or unreal. What normal waking memory
could keep this chaotic mass of stuff together t Yet Phinuit
Ch. XXX]
Discussion hy James
457
does so; for the ehances seem to he, that if a sitter should go
back after years of interval, the medium, when once entranced,
would recall the minutest incidents of the earlier interview, and
he, by recapitulating much of what had then leen said. So
far as I can discover, Mrs. Piper's waking memory is not remarkable, and the whole constitution of her trance-memory is
something which I am at a loss to understand.''
Which naturally harks back to the theory that she, or
''he/' draws on a stock that fills the universe. And how
does that theory stand comparison with fhe theory that several
controls independent of Phinuit (and later Imperator and his
gang) speaking to each of '' many hundreds of sitters " and
keeping them all distinct, are all of them secondary, or
alternating, personalities of Mrs. Piper?
James says (p. 656f.) of the E. control:
"I confess that the human being in me was so much stronger
than the man of science that I was too disgusted with Phinuit's
tiresome twaddle even to note it down. When later the phenomenon developed into pretended direct speech from E. [Ourney. H.H.] himself I regretted this, for a complete record would
have been useful. I can now merely say that neither then, nor
at any other time, was there to my mind the slightest inner
verisimilitude in the personation. [Later, regarding the Hodgson control, his opinion was very different. See Chapters XLIII
and XLIV. H.n.] But the failure to produce a more plausible
E. speaks directly in favor of the non-participation of the
medium's eanseiaus mind in the performance. She could so
easily have coached herself to be more effective.
'* Her trance-talk about my own family shows the same innocen . . . Few things could have been easier, in Boston, than for
Mrs. Piper to collect facts about my own father's family for use
in my sittings with her. But although my father, my mother,
and a deceased brother were repeatedly announced as present,
nothing but their bare names ever came out, except a hearty
message of thanks from my father that I had 'published the
book.' I had published his Literary Remains; but when Phinuit
was asked ' what book t ' all he could do was to spell the letters
It, I, and say no more
"The aimt who purported to 'take control' directly was a
much better personation [than Phinuit. H.H.1, having a good
deal of the cheery strenuousness of speech of the original. She
spoke, by the way, on this occasion, <, the condition al health of
two members of the family in New York, of which we knew
nothing at the time, and which was afterwards corroborated by
letter. We have repeatedly heard from Mrs. Piper in trance
468
Mrs. Pipet,s English SiUings, 1889-90
[Bk. H, Ft IV
things of which we weie not at the moment aware. If the snpernonnal dement in the phenomenon be thonght-tranafeienoe it is
certainly not that of the sittez,e eonseious thought. It is rather
the reservoir of his potential knowledge which is tapped; and
not always thott, but the knowledge of some distant living person,
as in the incident last quoted It has sometimes even seemed to
me that too much intentness on the sitter's part to have Phinuit
say a certain thing acts as a hindrance. [Again the reverse of
Foster. H.M.]
, My mother-in-law, on her return from Eiirope, spent a morning vainly seeking for her bank-book. Mrs. Piper, on being
shortly afterwards asked where this book was, describe the place
so exactly that it was instantly found. I was told by her that the
spirit of a boy named Bobert F. was the companion of my lost
infant The F.'s were cousins of my wife living in a distant
city. On my return home I mentioned the incident to my wife,
saying, ' Your cousin did lose a baby, didn't she ? but Mrs. Piper
was wrong about its sex, name, and age.' I then learned that
Mrs. Piper had been quite right in all those particulars, and that
mine was the wrong impression. But, obviously, for the source
of revelations such as these, one need not go behind the sitter's
own storehouse of forgotten or unnoticed experiences [or the
world-soul's f H.H.]. Miss X.'a experiments in crystal-gazing
prove how strangely these survive. If thought-transference be
the clue to be followed in interpreting Mrs. Piper's trance-utter>
ances (and that, as far as my experience gCMBs, is what, far more
than any supramundane instillations, the phenomena seem on
their face to be) we must admit that the , transference ' need not
be of the conscious or even the unconscious thought of the sitter,
but must often be of the thought raaTy, 1892, at the age of
thirty- two. ... He was an Associate of our Society, his interest
in which was explicable rather by an intellectual openness and
fearlessness characteristic of him than by any tendency to believe in supernormal phenomena. . . . We had several long talks
together on philosophic subjects, and one very long discussion,
probably at least two years before his death, on t, possibility
of a 'future life.' In this he maintained that in accordance
with a fundamental philosophic theory which we both accepted,
a ' future life ' was not only incredible, but inconceivable; and I
maintained that it was at least conceivable. At the conclusion
of the discussion he admitted that a future life was conceivable,
but he did not accept its credibility, and vowed that if he should
die before I did, and found himself 'still existing,' he would
* make things lively ' in the effort to reveal the fact of his con*
tinned existence."
That his " spirit,'' or at the very least, recollections of him
which must have been in other minds than Hodgson's or Mrs.
Piper's, and which were telepathically obtained and dramatically combined by Mrs. Piper, shoidd have at length converted Hodgson to the spiritistic belief, is a strange outcome.
As a '' control " G. P. differs in some particulars from his
earthly self as known to me. He greeted me through Mrs.
Piper with a degree of jollity and bonhomie that I had never
seen in him on earth. The genial helpful creature ''going
about doing good " in aid of everybody's communication, Ihat
appears as his manifestations from another world ( ?), he may
have been at heart in this one; but if he was, it was under
a mask of shyness or reserve developed on a sensitiTe nature
by contact with a rough world. Yet he had an unusual d,ee
of candor, not to say self-assertion, which, though never
boisterous, was apt, at times, to become somewhat dogmatic.
I never thought of him as a happy man here, while utterances
attributed to him give a welcome impression that he is a happy
man there. This impression I think must hare had more
Ch. XXXI]
0. P/s First Appearance
465
effect on Hodgson's opinions regarding G. P.'s postcamate
existence than Hodgson has stated, or perhaps realized. I
think any friend of Q. P.'s must be somewhat affected by it,
even if unconsciously. This I find more the case regarding
him than I later found regarding the controls representing
Hodgson and Myers : for they were happier men here.
Hodgson goes on to say of 0. P. (Pr. XIII, 295-6) :
" On March Tth, 1888, he had a sitting with Mrs. Piper. . . .
I may add my own opinion that Mrs. Piper never knew until
recently that she had ever seen Q. P
" G. P.'s conclusion was, briefly, that the results of this sitting
did not establish any more than hypenosthesia on thcf part of
the mediimL
, I knew of G. P.'s death within a day or two of its occurrence,
and was present at several sittings with Mrs. Piper in the
course of the following few weeks, but no allusion was made to
G. P. On March 22nd, 1892, between four and five weeks after
G. P.'s death, I accompanied Mr. John Hart [not the real
name], who had been an old intimate friend of his, to a sitting."
That he did not appear till a month after his death is in
accord with the many indications and assertions that it takes
time for the newly emancipated soul to *, find itself " from a
dazed condition after death. If telepathy were all, Hodgson's
mind was probably fuller of G. P. at the first sitting after his
death than a month later. It often seems too as if the presence
of a close friend were necessary to help the control's early
utterance. This one did not speak at Hodgson's many sittings,
until the first sitting when his closer friend Hart was present.
After Phinuit had announced a ', George," an uncle of Mr.
Hart, he went on (Pr. XIII, 297f.) :
, There is another OeoTge who wants to speak to you. How
many Georges are there about you any way?
, [R. H.] The rest of the sitting, until almost the close, was
occupied by statements from G. P., Phinuit acting as inter*
mediary. George Pelham's real name was given in full, also
the names, both Christian and surname, of several of his most
intimate friends, including the name of the sitter. Moreover,
incidents were referred to which were unknown to the sitter or
myself. One of the pair of studs which J. H. was wearing was
given to Phinuit . . . ' (Who gave them to met) [Throughout
these sittings, the sitters' remarks are in parentheses. H.H.]
That's mine. I gave you that part of it. I sent that to you.
(Whent) Before I came here. Thafs mine. Mother gave you
4«6
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. 11, Pt IV
that (No.) Well, father then, father and mother together.
You got those after I passed out Mother took them. Qawe
them to father, and fatiier gave them to you. I want you to
keep them. I will them to you.' Mr. Hart notes: * The stude
were sent to me by Mr. Pelham as a remembranoe of his
''James and Mary [Mr. and Mrs.] Howard [Pseudonyma.
H.H.] were mentioned with strongly specific references, and in
connection with Mrs. Howard came the name Katharine. ' Tell
her, she'll know. I will solve the problems, Katharine.' Mr.
Hart notes: 'This had no special significance for me at the
time, though I was aware that Katharine, the daughter of Jim
Howard, was known to George, who used to live with the Howards. On the day following the sitting I gave Mr. Howard a
detailed accoimt of the sitting. These words, " I will solve the
problems, Katharine," impressed him more than anything else,
and at the close of my aocount he related that George, when he
had last stayed with them, had talked frequently with Katharine
(a girl of fifteen years of age) upon such subjects as Time,
Space, God, Eternity, and pointed out to her how unsatisfactory
llie commonly accepted solutions were. He added that some
time he would solve the problems, and let her know, using almost
the very words of the communication made at the sitting.' Mr.
Hart added that he was entirely unaware of these circumstances.
I was myself unaware of them, and was not at that time acquainted with the Howards
G. him.
P. : ' John,
if that
is you,
speak
ma Tell
to "see
He will
hardly
believe
me, tobelieve
that Jim
I amI want
here.
I want him to know where I am...O good fellow. All got
dark, then it grew light
"*Go up to my room. (Which roomt) Up to my room,
where I write. I'll come. Speak to rae, John. (What room!)
Study. (You said something about a desk just now.) I left
things all mixed up. [Remember: his deatibi was sudden. H.H.1
I wish you'ld go up and straighten them out for me. Lot *. • . The letters which you have written to my wife giving such
eztraordinaiy evidence of the intelligence exercised by Geoige in
som& incomprehensible manner over the actions of his friends
on earth have given food for constant reflection and wonder.
Preconceived notiona about the future state have zeoeived a
severe shock."'
On May 16th the following occurred (Pr. XIII, 314). Is
this play of conversation covered by telepathy or even by
memories "stored," etc.?
" [PhiQuit speaks on behalf of O. P.] ' Ask Hodgson whether
this is important to him or not. I am determined to [writing
again, transfer to you my thoughts, although it will have to be
done m this uncanny way. (Never mind. That's all right. We
understand, etc) Good. I will move heaven and earth to explain these matters to you, Hodgson. [Phinuit speaks.] [For
O. P. t H.H.1 You see I am not asleep. [Written.] I am wide
awake, and I assure you I am ever ready to help you and give
you things of importance in this work. [Phinuit speaks.] It
was like Ore, to him before he came here. I could not believe
this existence. [Written.] I am delighted to have this opportunity of coming here to this life, so as to be able to prove my
experiences and existence here. Dear old Hodgson, I wish I
eould have Imown you better in your life, but I understand you
now, and the philosophy of my being taken out and (Didn't yoo
I
472
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. II, Ft. IV
go too Boont) Not too soon, but it is my vocation to be aUe
to explain these things to you and the zest of my friends. [This
be (9 ) carried out for years. H.H., (Does it do you harmf)
And it is all nonsense about its doing me harm, for it surely
does no harm, and will help to enlighten the world. What tliink
you, Hodgson?, (I agree entirely. I think ifs the most important work m the world.) Oh» I am so glad your exalted
brains are not too pretentious to accept the retd tru, and philosophy of my coming and explaining to you these important
things. (Now, Qeorge, we mustn't keep the medium in trance
too long.) Do not worry about her, she is having a good time,
and I will do no harm. You know that too well. [Phinuit
Q)eak8.]
idiot, etc.) He says he's not an idiot. (Oh» I know he's not an
" [Written.] * I understand. You see I hear you. Now I
will proceed with my important conversation. Your material
universe is very exacting, and it requires great practice and perseverance todo all I want to say to you.' " [Cf. "this protoplasm "in my sitting. Chapter XiLVlJLl. H.H.]
November 22nd, 1892. (Pr.Xin,413.)
''Present: Mr. and Mrs. Howard, R. H. and Reporter.
*' After a short conversation with Phinuit, Q. P. wrote:
'* * Haloo, Hodgson, you know me. Haloo, Jim, old fellow, I
am not dead yet. I still live to see you. Do you remember how
we used to a, each other for books of certain kinds, about certain books, where they were, and you always knew just where to
find them. [This was characteristic. The sitting was held in
my library, where Qeorge and myself had • . . frequent occasion
to turn up references in one book or another. George, living,
had remarked several times on my accurate knowledge of loca*
tion of the books in my shelves. — J] Halloa, I know now
where I am. Jim, you dear old soul, how are yout ' "
November 28th, 1892. (Pr.Xni,414-6.)
''Present: Mr. and Mrs. Howard, and (part of the time)
their eldest daughter Katharine, R. H. and Reporter.
"'
Katharine, how is the violin! [She plays the violin.] ... To hear you playing it is horrible, horrible. . . .' , Mrs.
H.: 'But don't you see she likes her music because it is the
best she has.' O. P. : ' No, but that is what I used to say, that it
is horrible.' [George was always more or less annoyed by hearing Katharine practise when she was banning the violin as a
Utile child.— K.] "
The above, we are assured, is " telepathy 'M The following (Pr. Xlll, 416f.) may be?
" Mrs. Piper [on coming out of the trance. H.H.] : ' There is
the man with tne beard ' (whom she saw in the trance. H.H.].
Ch. XXXI]
Mrs. Piper in French, and Italian
473
Mrs. Piper then described what she thought was a dream. , I
saw a bright light and a face in it, a gentleman with a beard
on his face, and he had a very high forehead and he was writing/
B. n.: , Would you know it again if you saw it? ' Mrs. Piper:
* Oh, yes. I would know it, I think.' R H. : ' Well, try and
recall it.' [See note at end of sitting.]
'' [Medium says she feels queer and as if she could turn right
round and go into the trance again. Does not know what is the
matter with her. After saying this she becomes entranced again
very quickly at 0.22, and Phinuit appears, shouting.]
,, Ph. : ' You know you don't play that on me. George Pelham
is a very clever fellow, but I am going to tell you he passed by
me, and do you know what he did, he let her go without signaling to me at all; he did it by mistake; he told me afterwards,
and so I came back to tell you. . . . [To Katharine] Vous etes
bonne fiUe. C'est la petite de madame: bonne fille, bonne fille,
grande belle fille.' [I was struck by Phinuit's speaking French
all at once to Katharine, as she always speaks French with her
sisters, having lived so long in France. There was more French
than was here reported, as the stenographer does not know
French well, and had to get what we could remember from us
afterwards. Mr. Howard and I were much struck by the thoroughly French use of the word helLe. £[atharine is in no sense
of the word a beautiful girl as English people generally under*
stand the word belle, but she is conspicuously a tall, well-developed, well-made girl, of the sort to which belle in the French
sense would be applied. — ,K.]
"
How about the frequent claim that Phinuit knew no
French?
,' Mrs. Piper is apparently about to come out of trance when
another control takes possession for a few minutes, who is
thought by Mrs. Howard to be Elisa, and who whispers something in Italian to Mrs. Howard. [Mrs. Piper knew no Italian.
H.H.] Again Mrs. Piper is apparently about to come out of
trance when Phinuit returns for a moment to say au revoir,
[What follows is in substance the conversation between Elisa
and Mrs. Howard.]
', E. : ' Paidenza, pazienza, paaenza.' Mrs. H. : ' Si cara Elisa.'
E.: [Tries to give a message in Italian to her sister, but Mrs.
H. could only catch a few words.] Mrs. H. : ' Non comprendo
bene.' E. : ' Taceo, pazienza, pazienza. Dire tutto a Frederica
[name ofindicating
sister j| a the
rivederla.
Elisa
a rivederla.'
suffering
trouble that
caused
the death of[Signs
Madameof
Elisa.] Mrs. H. says in Italian * Don't suffer, EUsa.' E.: ' Pazienza a rivederla.'
"After Mrs. Piper comes out of trance she is shown a collection of thirty-two photographsy nine of them being of men, from
474
Hodgson's Bseond Pipsr Report [Bk. 11, PL IV
which she selects the pictore of the penon whom she saw when
coming ont of trance the fint time. The photogri,h that aho
first picked out was an excellent likeness of O. P. She afterwards picked out another photograph of hinu She stated that
she never knew the gentlonan whoi liTing.''
Within twenly-f our hours in this experiment, or some other,
as reported elsewhere, the dream recollection had faded away;
she could not recognize the photograph*
Now in face of such an occurrence as this (and it does not
stand alone), the talk about subliminal self, in the usual
sense, secondary personality and all that, simply '' won't do/'
We can talk about telopsis here; if we want to, but telopsis of
what ? Of that photograph ? Nonsense 1 And as strange as
anything else about it, is that there is nothing strange about
it In my own dreams I see any number of people I nerer
saw before, just as plainly as I see any number on the street,
and if photographs were handed me, as those were to Mrs.
Piper, immediately on awaking, I could identify them. Had
I seen fit to develop the mediumship Phinuit ascribes to me
(and Sir William Grookes, by implication ascribes to all of
us) , or had you seen fit to develop the mediumship probably
latent in you (instead of perhaps killing it by scientific
skepticism — ,an admirable thing in its place) — ,had we developed our mediumship so that we were giving sittings and
having friends at hand with pictures of the people we saw in
our dreams, we might be identifying controls too. This identification inothing
s
out of the ordinary course of nature, only
the wit to see that it is, has but just com,. If it is a step
toward accepting the spiritistic hypothesis, what is the harm?
Only it is well to remember that " fools rush in/*
As to the attempted solution that Mrs. Piper sees G. P.
as he exists in the memory of his friends, and picks out the
photograph of the man she sees: in the mind of an average
friend — ,mine, for instance, he doesn't exist with the definiteness of a photograph. If I had tried, when I sat with
Mrs. Piper, to describe him to an artist to enable him to draw
a portrait, I should have been wrong in so many particulars
that the portrait would not have been recognizable. I should
have given him a square forehead, and a photograph I have
looked at since, which I recognized as a very good one, has
Ch. XXXI]
0. P/s Intense Scene with Howard
476
a round forehead, and having seen that portrait within a
year, I couldn't say now whether the nose is straight or
filightly aquiline. I only feel sure that it was not pug. I
don't remember, either, whether his mouth was firm or
rounded, or his chin and jaw light or pronounced.
Yet at the sitting when Mrs. Piper saw him, the sitter may
haye been gifted with a much more pictorial memory than
mine; and with any sitter, Mrs. Piper may have just as
definite an idea as the sitter has, and that may be, like mine,
definite enough to recognize, but not to describe. But can
telepathy convey more than the agent can describe ? She may
have seen the man at all the sittings, as we see in dreams
people that we never knew or know we knew, or it may have
been the man himself who used her organism to speak
and write when it was asserted that he did. Each one of
us will have to fumble to his own conviction if he ever reaches
one. Mine is simply that she saw him in dreams, and the
sitters or his surviving personality impressed those dreams
upon her. One reason for that conviction is that despite the
occasional alleged going out of one control, and coming in
of another, generally the controls succeed and interrupt each
other without any intervals, as in dreams.
Hodgson continues (Pr. XIU, 321-2) :
"Itdramatic
was during
this sitting
[Dec. series
22, 1892]
that perhaps the
most
incident
of the whole
occurred.
"Mr. Howard : * Tell me something . . . that you and I alone
know. I ask you because several things I have asked you, you
have failed to get hold of.' G. P. : ' Why did you not ask me this
before? ' Mr. H. : * Because I did not have occasion to.' O. P. :
* What do you mean, Jim t ' Mr. H. : ' I mean, tell me something that you and I alone know, something in our past that you
and I alone know.' O. P. : ' Do you doubt me, dear old fellow? '
Mr. H. : ' I simply want something — ,you have failed to answer
certain questions that I have asked — ,now I want you to give me
the equivalent of the answers to those questions in your own
terms. . . .' G. P. : * You used to talk to me about
.'
''The writing which followed ... contains too much of the
personal element in G. P.'s life to be reproduced here. Several
statements were read by me, and assented to by Mr. Howard,
and then was written ' private ' and the hand gently pushed me
away. I retired to the other side of the room, and Mr. Howard
took my place close to the hand where he could read the writing.
He did not, of course, read it aloud, and it was too private for
476
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. II, Pt IV
my perusaL The hand, as it reached the end of each sheets tore
it off from the block-book, and thrust it wildly at Mr. Howaid*
and then continued writing. The circumstances narrated, Mr.
Howard informed me, contained precisely the kind of test for
which he had asked, and he said that he was * peif ectly satisfied,
perfectly/ After this incident there was some further oonyersation vriih references to the past that seemed specially natural aa
coming from O. P.
*'*
Jim, I am dull in this sphere about some things, but
you will forgive me, won't you 9 . • . but like as wh,i in t, body
sometimes we can't always recall everything in a moment, can
we, Jim, dear old fellow t...Ood bless you, Jim, and many
thanks. You often gave me courage when I used to get depressed. You know how you especifdly used to fire at me sometimes, but I understood it all, did I not, old fellow? ... and I
used to get tremendously down at the heel sometimes, but I am
all right now, and, Jim, you can never know how much I love
you and how much I delight in coming back and telling you all
this. . . . When I found I actually lived again I jumped for joy,
and my first thought was to find you and Mary. And, thank the
Infinite, here I am, old fellow, living and well
.'
*, Characteristic also of the living O. P. was the remark made
to me later, apparently with reference to the circumstances of
the private statements :
"* Thanks, Hodgson, for your kind help and reserved manners*
also patience in this difficult matter.' "
All this, I suppose, is mere telepathy or the subliminal self
of an average New England housewife !
Hodgson's comments apply equally well to the following:
December 19th, 1892. (Pr.Xin,433f.)
',Present: Mr. and Mrs. Howard, R. H., and Reporter.
',
Mrs. Howard gives a letter . . . sayiiig, * 1 want you to
see your father's letter, because there is something in it that
please you.'
will"G.
P. : ' This does not soimd as father would talk when I
was in the body. . . . He believes that I exist ' [calls for Hodgson,
complains of being muddled, and asks Hod,on to put his hand
,up there' («.6., probably against the forehead)].
ie.j the medium's forehead. This frequent claim by fhe
controls of bodily characteristics and functions (including
their giving, sometimes in pantomime, through the medium,
the symptoms of their last illnesses) is very incongruous with
their frequent claims of exemption from bodily infirmities,
and is one of the suggestions that after all the medium "does
it all " ; and as soon as one gets comfortably settled in tills, to
Ch. XXXI]
G. P. PhUosopkws
477
many, uncomfortable conyiction, along oomea something to
upaet it
0. P. continues (Pr. XTTT, 433-4) :
,'He was pained, but be is no longer pained, because he
feels that I exist.' Mrs. Howard: * That is right; I have read it'
G. P. : ' That brings me nearer to my father; now give him my
tenderest love and tell him that I am Teiy near him, and see him
almost eveiy day, if I could go by days, but I can't jud, of
that, because I have no idea of time; that is one thing I have
lost, Hodgson. . . . You of all others are the one that I want to
be absolutely certain of my identity. . . . Hodgson, I mean, and
Jim, I want you both to feel I am no secondaiy personality of
the medium's [struggling to get the last phrase out] . . . Now,
about my theory of spirit life independent of the material subthink, see, hear, know, and feel just as clearly as
stance. live,
I
when I was in the material life, but it is not so easy to explain it
to you as you would naturaUy suppose, especially when the
thoughts have to be expressed through substance materially. . . •
Nevertheless, I am bound to do just all I can for you to prove
to you that I (George Pelham) do absolutely exist, independently ofthe material body Irhich I once inhabited. . . . You see as
I was explaining to you about thought, and had not strength
materially nor time to finish, I will go on to ,at again and in a
little more detail, which will explain to you (as well as anything) how and what I am now, i,e., as a spiritual Ego.
Thought is, as I said before, in no wise dependent upon body,
but must necessarily, as you see, depend upon the body of another person or Ego in the material to express one's thought
fully after the annihilation of one's own material body. ... In
consequence of this you see that there must necessarily be more
or lees confliction between one's spiritual Ego or mind, and the
material mind or Ego of the one which you are obliged to use to
explain these difficult problems to you, my friends, in the
'
material
*' Questions asked for. R. H. asks what becomes of the meditun during trance. ' She passes out as your etherial goes out
when you sleep.' R. H. : , Well, do you see that there is a conflict, because the brain substance is, so to speak, saturated with
her tendencies of thought? ' G. P. : ' No, not that, but the solid
substance called brain, it is difficult to control it, simply because
it is material . . . her mind leaves the brain empty, as it were, and
I znyself or other spiritual mind or thought takes the empty
brain, and there is where and when the conldct arises.' "
People who knew G. P. have said to me : ', You know perfectly well that George was too inteUigent a fellow for his
spirit to talk the twaddle it is alleged to.'' Well, after more
478
Hodgson's Bscond Pipsr Bepart [Bk. 11, Ft lY
attention to the matter than they liave given, I conclude that
I don't know any such jiiing. The ezpreeaion "my tendeiest
loye '' at the beginning of the foregoing paragraph, etmck me
as one of those rare and happy coUocationB of a couple of
simple words that come only to people with a toach of geniuBy
and the next doaen lines and many lines tfaronghout his commnnications, are anything but twaddle. Often tiiongh the
sense persists, the expression weakens into saperflnities and
repetitions, bnt hardly worse than a good writer's first draft
sometimes shows, because of sleepiness or wandering; and it
would not be eztrayagant for a holder of the spiritistic hypothesis to claim that in such cases there is strong evidence to
justify
ascribing the '' twaddle " to difficulties in genuine communication.
CHAPTEB XXXn
H0DGU30N'S SECOND PIPER REPORT, 1899, {OmUnfuai
11. Miscellaneous Sittings
October, 1893. (Pr:Xin,480f.)
"Sitter: Mr. L. Vernon Briggs, Hanover, Mass.,
', . . . . . The medium was then given a handkerchief of a Honolulu hoy who had been shot in Boston — ,intentionally or unintentionally was not known. This boy had shown great affection
for a person present — ,following them [«tcj twice to Boston
from Honolulu as a stowaway. The medium showed great
suffering — ,placed her hand to her side, saying, ' It's my stomach
— Oh, my side. They put me out too quick.' Here the medium
seemed to suffer too much, and Dr. Phinuit was asked to take
control and Q)eak for the boy. [This makes a jumble with the
claim of freedom from bodily ills, and the other claim of repre*
senting them for evidential purposes. H.H.] Conversation continued through Dr. Phinuit. — ,'Is this you, Kalua?' [This
question was put by Mr. Briggs. — ,B.H.] * Yes, I did not kill
myself. He killed me. We were gambling — ,that was wrong.
He hid my purse imder the steps where I was killed.' [The
cellar was examined — ,five planks, one below another, were taken
up but no purse was found.] Kalua also said there was shrubbery near it. [There was no shrubbery in the cellar of this
house.]
',The boy seemed delighted to speek with his friend, and
finaDy took the hand and wrote, ,This is splendid — Oh, Dr.,
help me.' He asked questions, and tried to give the name of a
place in the Hawaiian Islands, which finally was made out. He
then tried to write his own language, apd did write some words
which were understood. For instance, he wrote Mei,' which
means 'wreaths' — and which he always made daily for his
friend.
" Dr. Phinuit said what he heard sounded like Italian*-and
that the boy was singing — ,which he was always doing in life.
He spoke again of his death, and said: 'The man had a hot
temper and disputed with me, and he shot me — he did not mean
to.' [Question] 'What became of the revolver!' [Answer]
* He uirew the revolver into the hot-box where the pepples are?
[Note. — ,This was true — ,the revolver was found in the furnace.]
479
480
Hodgson's Second Piper Report
[Bt H, Pt IV
[EnowQ to Mr. Briggs. By pepples was meant pebhUs, interpreted by the sitters as coaU. — iRH.]
" * Did you get my trunk! * * Yea/ * So glad you have ifr,
keep my things.' ' Did you get them, M.! ' ' Yes.'
''He was asked where his father was. And we could only
understand Hiram. — Phinuit could not get Hawaii for some
time — ,it was finally written Hawaiin Islands. We asked which
one — ,Phinuit said it was Tawai. This was interesting, aa the
island is spelled with a K, but pronounced with a T/'
Now, if you please, recall what has already been said
(p. 452f.) about scientific and sympathetic sitters, and look
forward to what Hodgson says on pages 520 and 526; and
then, in contrast with all the foregoing touches of personality
obtained by sympathetic sitters, compare the following by an
eminent man of science. Probably the reader free from the
skeptical habit has found in the records somewhat more
*' reminiscence of old affection ... to make the presence of a
beloved spirit seem real/'
April 2Sih, 1S92. (Pr.Xni,460f.)
"Sitter: Professor J. M. Peirce. R. H. taking notes.
**
In regard to the indefinable, unreasoned impression
made by the interview, — a point to which I am forced to attrib*
ute much importance in the case of some of my friends who
have visited Mrs. Piper, — ,I must say that I received none that
tends to strengthen the theory of a communication with the departed. No personal trait, no familiar and private sign, no
reminiscence of old affection, no characteristic phrase or mode
of feeling or thought, no quality of manner was there, to make
the presence of a beloved spirit seem real. I never for one instant felt myself to be speaking with anyone but Mrs. Piper, nor
do I perceive any change of voice or personality, beyond what
is ordinarily witnessed in skilled impersonation. ... Whatever
the explanation of the phenomena, I believe this process to go
on, — a struggle for knowledge to whose issue the sitter con*
tributes.
J. M. Peirgs.
"P.S. — Since writing the foregoing, I have gone over the
notes in detail, making a memorandum of successes and failures.
I am surprised to see how little is true. Nearly every approach
to truth is at once vitiated by erroneous additions or developments."
But here is another eminent scientific man whom I know
intimately, but who has the sympathies of a practising physician.
CIl XXXII]
8ci$ntific Sitters
481
Jfasf 6f , 1892. (Pr.Xin,462f.)
*, Sitters : Dr. and Mrs. L. E. H. New York.
'' [Dr. H. says:! The large number of little details brought
out about the family are extremely interesting, the most marked
being those relating to Walter, his death and his f rioids, and
to David, — many of the remarks made by both of these are
strictly characteristic. However, nothing appeared in the sitting which could be afterwards confirmed, which was not fully
known either to Mrs. H. or myself. [Otiberwise confirmation,
even of truth, might be impossible. H.n.] All the things here
brought out might be explained as simply mind-reading, but a
wonderful example of that.''
So I thought for some time after my sitting, but I thought
differently on knowing more and thinking more. This is
another illustration of the fallacious treatment of mere knowledge of facts as the main indication of personality.
Another eminent scientific sitter blest with a poetic imagination (Pr. XIII, 624-6) :
May 2fith, 1894.
*, Sitters : Professor and Mrs. N. S. Shaler, at the house of
Professor W. James. ... Account of the sitting given by Pro*
feasor Shaler ... in a letter to Professor James.
**
The statements made by Mrs. Piper, in my opinion,
entirely exclude the hypothesis that they were the resi:dts of conjectures, directed by die answers made by my wife
" While I am disposed to hold to the hypothesis that the performance isone that is founded on some kind of deceit, I must
confess that dose observation of the medium made on me the
impression that ,e is honest. Seeing her under any other conditions, should
I
not hesitate to trust my instinctive sense as to
the truthfulness of the woman.
"I venture also to note, though with some hesitancy, the fact
that the ghost of the ancient Frenchman who never existed, but
who purports to control Mrs. Piper, though he speaks with a
first-rate French accent, does not, so far as I can find, make the
characteristic blunders in the order of his English words which
we find in actual life. Whatever l,e medium is, I am convinced
that this ' influence ' is a preposterous scoundreL
"I think I did not put strongly enough the peculiar kind of
knowledge which the medium seems to have concerning my
wife's brother's aff airs. ... They had the real life quality. So,
too, the name of a man who was to have married my wife's
brother's daughter, but who died a month before the time fixed
for the wedding, was correctly given, both as regards surname
and Christian name, though the Christian name was not remembered by my wife or me. So, too, the fact that all trouble on
482
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. n, Pt. IV
account of the miflsing will was within a fortnig,ht after the
death of Mr. Page cleared away by the action of the children
waa unknown. The deceased is represented as still troubled,
though he purported to see just what was going on in his
f
family/'
Another eminent scientific man, though one also bleoed
with a poetical imagination (XIII, 482-3) :
''1524, Walnut Street, Philadblphu, Pa., January 2nth, 1894.
" Mt Dkah Jambs. — ,I have read, with care, since the receipt
of your note, the memoranda you and I made at my sitting with
Mrs. Piper.
'' If I had never seen you and heard your statements in regard
to Mrs. P., my afternoon sitting with her would have led me to
the conclusion that the whole thing was a fraud and a veiy
stupid one. Of course I do not thiz, this, because I am bound
to consider all the statements made, not merely the time spent
with me. As to this point I want to make myself clear, because
I should Hke on another occasion to repeat my sitting.
" On re-reading your notes I find absolutely nothing of value.
None of the incidents are correct, and none of the very vague
things hinted at are true, nor have they any kind or sort of
relation to my life, nor is there one name correctly given
" S. Weib Mitchell (M.D.).*'
With which contrast the following. This sitting will appeal
very differently to different temperaments. . To some it will
probably appear illusive gush, and they can skip. But skipping does not account for it. To others it will probably
appear the most important sitting on record. Whether one
scoffs or prays, it will at least be worth while to use a little
imagination — ,to see the entranced medium, with face generally as expressionless as if a statue were speaking, pouring
forth at one moment some brusquerie in the rough deep tones
of Phinuit ; at the next, in the same voice softened to gentleness, petting a child; then, perhaps, a return of the gruff
tones in some biting sarcasm to some interloping control;
then perhaps issuing from the same mouth, a child's voice
singing the little boat song — all going on amid the weeping
relatives who join in the song, with the sympathetic Hodgson
assisting the performance, and probably perplexed to know
whether he is in Heaven or in bedlam. I confess that I hare
such perplexity, with the doubt that James intimates somewhere, vheiher so important a section of the uniTerse— one
CL XXXII]
The Sutton Sittings
483
including so much and sach deep feeling, can be bedlam. And
yet look at the medisval church at intervals for nearly fifteen
centuries, and from the Nile to the Pillars of Hercules I
Bitting with Mrs. Piper at Arlington Heights, December Sth,
1893. (PrX[n,486f.)
" Present, Mrs. Howard, Rev. S. W. Sutton, and myself [Mrs.
Sutton. H.H.] Beport by Mrs. Sutton from notes taken by
Mrs. Howard during the sitting.
[Hodgson says (p. 484) :] '' Mrs. Sutton [the sitter. H.H.]
herself has had many remarkable psychical experiences, especially in seeing the ' figures ' of deceased persons, and in 1887
published a little book giving an account of some of these. It
was called Light on the Hidden Way, with an Introduction by
James Freeman Clarke.
,*
Phinuit said: '...A little child is coming to you*
This is the dearest lady I have met for a long time — the most
light I have seen while in Mrs. Piper's body. He reaches out
his hands as to a child, and says coaxingly: Come here, dear.
Don't be afraid. Come, darling, here is your mother. He describes the child and her ' lovely curls.' Where is papa ? Want
papa. [He takes from the table a silver medal.] I want this—
want to bite it. [She used to bite it.*] [The notes marked with
asterisks were added some four years siter the sitting. H.H.]
[Eeaches for a string of buttons.] Quick I I want to put them
in my mouth. [The buttons also. To bite the buttons was forbidden. He exactly imitated her arch manner.*] I will get
her to talk to you in a minute. ... A lady is here who passed
out of the body with tumor in the bowels. [My friend, Mrs. C,
died of ovarian tumor.*] She has the child — she is bringing her
to
takes Now
some she
keys.,
to me—
these
andme.
the [He
buttons.
will These
speak bring
to me.herWho
is Dodot
[Her name for her brother George/j Speak to me quickly. I
want you to call Dodo. Tell Dodo 1 am happy. Cry for me no
more. [Puts hand to throat.] No sore throat any more. [She
had
pain Can
and not
distress
of the
speakI
to me.
you see
me?throat
I amandnottongue.*]
dead, I amPapa,
Uving.
am happy with Grandma. [My mother had been dead many
years.*] Phinuit says: Here are two more. One, two, three
here, — one older and one younger than Kakie. [Correct.*]
That is a boy, the one that came first. [Both were boys.*] . . •
Was this little one's tongue very dryt She keeps showing me
her tongue. [Her tongue was paral,eed, and she suffered much
with it to the end.] Her name is EjBitharine. [Correct*] She
calls herself Eakie. She passed out last [Correct*] Tell
Dodo Eakie is in a spiritual body. Where is norsey? [I gave
him a little horse.] Big horsey> not this little one. [Probably
refers to a toy cart-horse she used to like.] Dear Papa, take
484
Hodgion's Second Piper Report [Bk. II, Pt lY
me wide. [To ride.] Do you miss your Kakief Do you see
Kakiet T& pretty white fioweis you put on me, I have here.
I took their little souls out and kept them with me. Phinuit
describes lilies of the valley, which were the flowers we placed
in her casket.
" Papa, want to go to wide horsey. [She plead this all through
her illness.] Every day I go to see horsey. I like that horsey.
I go to ride. I am with you every day. [We had just come
from Mr. Sutton's parents, where we drove frequency, and I
had seen Kakie with us. (This means that Mrs. Sutton had
seen the 'apparition' of Eakie. — ,R.H.) Margaret (her sister)
is still there, driving daily.] [I asked if she remembered anything after she was brought down stairs.] I was so hot, my
head was so hot. [Correct.*] [I asked if she knew who was
earing for her, if it was any comfort to her to have us with her.]
Oh, yes, — oh, yes. [I asked if she suffered in dying.] I saw l,e
light and followed it to this pretty lady. You will Iotb me
always? Tou will let me come to you at home. I will come to
you every day, and I will put my hand on you, when you go to
sleep. Do not cry for me, — ,that makes me sad. Eleanor. I
want Eleanor. [Her little sister. She called her mudi during
her last illness.*, I want my buttons. Bow, Bow, — ,my song,—
sing it now. I smg with you. [We sing, and a soft child voica
sings with ua] [i-e. Mrs. Piper's child-voice. HJQ.].
"lightly row, lightly row.
O'er the merry waves we go.
Smoothly glide, smoothly glide
With the ebbing tide.
, [Phinuit hushes
and Kakie finishes alone.]
"Let theus, winds
and waters be
Mingled with our melody.
Sing and float, sing and float.
In our little boat.
Papa sing. I hear your voice, but it is so heavy. [Papa and
Kakie sing. Phinuit exclaims: See her little curls flyl] [Her
curls were not long enough to fly at death, six weeks l>efore.*l
Kakie sings: Bye, bye, ba bye, bye, bye, O baby bye. Sing that
with me, papa. [Papa and Kakie sing. These two songs were
the ones she used to sing.] [She sang slight snatches of others
in life — ,not at the sitting.*] Where is Dinah? I want DindL
[Dinah was an old black rag-doll, not with us.] I want Bagie
[her name for her sister Margaret.] I want Bagie to bring me
my Dinah. I want to go to Bagie. I want Bagie. I see Bagie
all the time. Tell Dodo when you see him that I love him.
Dear Dodo. He used to march with me, — ,he put me way up.
tCorrect.*] Dodo did sing to me. That was a horrid bodty. I
ave a pretty body now. Tell Grandma I love her. I want her
to know I live. Grandma does know it, Marmie — Great — grandma, Marmie. [We called her Great Grandmother Marmie but
Ch. XXXII]
The Sutton Sittings
485
she always called her Orammie, Both Grandmother and Great
Grandmother were then living.*]
'I Here is Hattie. Speak to her. I am bo happy. [Button
string broke — ,Phinuit is distressed. We gather them up and
propose to re-string them.] Hattie says that is a pretty picture
there. [Hattie was the name of a dear friend who died seyeral
years ago. She was very fond of my copy of the Sistine Madonna, and in her last illness asked to have it hung over her
bed, where it remained till after she passed away. This did not
occur to me when Phinuit gave her words, nor for some weeks
after the sitting.] [It was plainly stored away somewhere aU
the time. In the cosmic soul! Such cases are frequent. H.H.]
I want the tic-tic. Take the buttons, and give me the pretty
tic-tic. Open the tic-tic. Mamma, do you love me sof Don't
cry for me. I want to see the mooley-cow, — where is the mooley*
cow? [R. H.: Did she so call it? A.: Yes.*] Take me to see
the mooley-cow. [She used to be taken almost daily to see the
cow.] Phinuit says : I cannot quite hear what it is she calls the
tic-tic. She calls it * the dock,' and holds it to her ear. [That
was what she called it] . . • She has the most beautiful, great,
dark violet dependent,
eyes.
, She is very full of life — ,very inbut veiy[Correct.*]
sweet in disposition.
'' [Kakie again.] I will put my hand on papa's head when he
goes to sleep. Want the babee. [Her characteristic pronunciation.*] Phinuit takes the doll and says: She wants it to cuddle
up to her, so. She wants to sing to it. Bye baby, bye bye.
God knew best, so do not worry. The little book. Kakie wants
tiie little book. * [She liked a linen picture book.*] . . . Phinuit
describes a gentleman with a beautiful face, greatly agitated,
also a very large gentleman with him — ,he was a great preacher
— Phillips — ,Phillips Brooks. He says : I want to say that when
I made mistakes in life, I hope you will do all in your power
to rectify them. [I asked if he did not believe in an after-life?]
Tes, but I did not believe in the possibility of communication
after death. . . . Here we see its full importance. [Mrs. Howard
notes : * 1 knew Phillips Brooks from the time I was a girl and
had more than one long talk with him.' It was known to myself
and also to Mrs. Howard, that the Bev. Phillips Brooks had
spoken disparagingly of attempts to obtain communications
from the * deceased ' through Mrs. Piper's trance. — ,R.H.]
" [There was also a long and painful effort with great agitation and anxiety to give an address asked for. This addiess is
not known by tiiose desiring to have it. To obtain it was the
object of the communication with the gentleman whose necktie
was placed in Mrs. Piper's hand. Nothing intelligible was obtained.*] "
If nobody knew this address, the failure is consonant with
the fact that in no sitting whose report I have eyer read, has
486
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. II, Ft IV
any communication been made of any new knowledge fliat
could not be obtained by the sweat of the mortal brow. The
mere fact of immortality, if it be a fact, may perhaps with the
aid of a little faith, be so imparted, aiid with it much that is
worth more than most other knowledge ; but I have not met
anything farther of importance. The cases of apparent prophecy are not yet frequent enough or clear enough to reason
from. In fact nothing seems to be but the dramatic yenaimilitude, the range of the controls' knowledge, their apparent growth, and the reasonableness of the conditions (so far as
they can explain them) under which they profess to be. Of
all this more anon.
A littiie more of the sort of thing tiiat must be infinitely
precious to some minds follows (Pr. XIII, 489) :
', After the writing, we thought the sitting over, and Mir.
Sutton had gone across the room, when Eakie's little Toice piped
up. Want papa — ,want papa. Dear papa. [Phinuit pats his
face.] Do you love me, papat Want babee. Sings, Bye, byepapa, sing — ,mama sing. Cuddles doll up in neck and sings.
[An exact imitation marvelously animated and real.*]
, It may be of interest to note that the day before the sitting,
Hr. Sutton had questioned whether it was right or desirable for
them to bring them back for our gratification. It did not occur
to him during the sitting, but iJonso said — ,'Do not think it
wrong to bring us back — ,we lore to come.'
,'The 'sitting' was as a whole very satisfactory. The con▼ersation did not follow the order of our conscious minds, and
had the moTcment and Tivacity of objective personalities.
"Ejlthaionb Paikb SuTTOir.''
A second sitting of the same people, Dec. 21st, was much
like the first. I cull a few touches. There's nothing to preTent anybody from skipping them.
Second eitiing with Mrs, Piper at Arlington Heights,
December 2l8t, 1898. (Pr.Xin,489f .)
', Present, Mrs. Howard and myself [Mrs. Sutton. H.H.].
Report by Mrs, Sutton from notes taken by Mrs. Howard during
the sitting.
**
Dr. Phinuit assumed control, ... recognized me cordially and said : Baby wants to see her mamma, come, dear. A
sweet child voice sang softly [the little boat song as befora
H.H.]
" [The child Toice again.] Kakie did see papa. Papa is
marching with Eleanor. Sings, ' March, march,' etc. [Eleanor
ClL XXXII]
The Sutton Sittings
487
18 a litde inYalid. Mr. Sutton carries her a great deal— of ten
sings, ' March/ etc. — had done so at this time.* j
'' I asked her to sing * Bye Bye ' with me, which she did precisely as when here. I could not repress the tears. Phinuit
said: You must not weep. When the little shroud is wet, the
child grieves.
"* Kakie ' says : Dear Mamma, do you lore me so t I love you
and I see you. I am happy here, I have so many little children
to play with and I love my Auntie. I like to be with you. I
play with Eleanor. [Living sister. H.H.I Does Eleanor see
met I play with her every day. I like tne little bed. I play
with it. [The lady with whom we stayed in Duzbury had lent
Eleanor a doll's bed, which she greatly enjoyed. Of course we
had not associated it with Xakie.] Where is Bagie? [Her
name for her sister Margaret]
''Phinuit said: Mary 0. wishes to speak to you. [See previ*
ous sitting. — ,RH.] She said: We will care for your babies.
We love them dearly. Hattie [a deceased friend*] is here.
She loves them too. ... I can see you and. know the darkness and
pexplezities, but it is the darkness just before the dawn. ... I see
you are nervous and impatient sometimes when the aching body
is tired out, — but control your nerves, can't you, dear? that is
all I want to change in you. I know you try, but it seems as if
you ought to rise above it. [This is not in the least like her.*]
, Phinuit said : There are many here anxious to speak to you.
Here is your father and your mother. They have been here a
long time, — ,your mother came first. [Correct.*] They are very
bright. They want to tell you to be patient. They see bright
days before you. [No. We have had much illness and tribulations manifold with smaller income than ever before.*]
"
The most scientific investigator, despite all the suspicious
emotional element, must at least admit Mrs. Sutton's candor.
'' Kakie wants her buttons. [I gave them to Phinuit.] She
wants them all, they are not all nere. [At the previous sitting
the string had brdcen and they scattered on the fioor. We
thought we found them all, but when Mrs. Piper's sweeping day
came,
rest were
[Howbuttons
is thishere.
for " evidence
H.H.]
Phinuitthe said:
Therefound.]
are eight
Sakie, let" fme
see
how many you have. [He counts twelve in French.] I exclaimedDo
: you have buttons there ? He replied : She had not
the button, but she has the idea of them, which is the reality.
[See Chapter XXTTI. H.H.]
'* [Kakie asks for her ball. I gave it to Phinuit, who tries to
find what she wants to do with it.] Bite it t Toss it t Roll it t
Throw it? [No, she wants a string. Mrs. H. gave him a string.
He tries to tie it around the ball.] [A little red wooden ball
with a hole through it. The ball had a string through it when
she used to play with it*] No, that is not right, through it.
488
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. n, Pt IV
There, there, be a good little girL Don't cry. Don't be impatient, you want your Tnamma to see how you can do it, so she will
know it is you, don't you, dear? Old man will do it for her.
[The " old man " was Mrs. Piper,
he? H.H.] [He put the
string through, held it up, and hit was
it with the finger, making
it
swing.] That is it, is it not, darling! Nioe little girl as ever
was. [While she was sick, it was her great delight to have me
hold the string, and let her hit the little led ball with her finger
or spoon. She made the motions as if doing it, after she became unconscious.]
, [Again I saw ner for a moment, (Le,, Mrs. Sutton herself
saw the 'apparition' of Kakia See introductory remarks to
her sittings. — ,R.H.) standing at tiie table, trying to reach a
spool of tangled red knitting isilk, and at ,e same moment
Phinuit reached for it, saying:] She wants that, she and Eleanor
used to play with. She calls it Eleanor's. She is delighted with
it— ,it brings her nearer her little sister. [All true, but I had
not connected it with Eleanor in my thought.] I gave Phinuit
a lock of Eleanor's hair. He felt it a moment and said: You
cut that close to the head — ,that was right I can see her perfectly— ,lovely little girl. [I had not told him whose hair it
was.] . . . How that p<>or child has suffered I [She is recorerins
from spinal meningitis and paralysis,] ,.
[He gives a correct diagnosis and advice that apparently was
good : for after them he continues. H.H.] : ,' I do not see her go
out of the body. . . . She must have great care, or she will go out
like that [snapping his fingers]. [She ... begins to... improve. . .*] [Phinuit returns to Kakie. H.H.] . . . She wants
Eleanor's hair. Phinuit makes the motion of drawing something
from it and giving it to her, saying : Now she has it. She can get
nearer her little sister with it. ... I gave him a bit of Mr. Sutton's
hair, vnthout saying whose it was. As he took it, he said laughing: That is papa's hair, — ,mighty little of it, was not he stingy
of it though t [When I cut it, Mr. Sutton warned me playfully
that he had not much to spare.] He wiU live to be a hundred.
You need not worry about that. [Mrs. S. has all of a woman's
solicitude fpr a perfectly healthy husband. — S.W.S.*]
" Phinuit exclaimed : I see you in such a pleasant home I AH
the surroundings so pleasant — ,lovely trees. Mr. Sutton will receive a'call' soon from a good parish, and will accept it....
[I named several places.] I think it ends in ton — ,Winchendon
sounds like it. ... Vestry, church parlors, etc. — a comfortable
support . . . it. will be a permanent settlement. . . . [We came to
Athol to a small struggling parish and small salary! No vestry,
or anything of the sort. . • • The permanence ol the settlement is
problematical.*]
"Phinuit turns his head, as if looking at a child beside me,
and says : Yes, I know ' Kakie wants,' but Kakie must be patient, others want to speak to mamma.
[She was very persistent
Ch. XXXII]
The Heywood Bittings
489
with * Kakie wants ' when here.] • . . You dear little girl, you
the
makesI saw
[Phinuit
mamma's
to get ofin lifting
want
a moment
and for
lap,shalL
my you
intoand
her lap,
movement
her distinctly lying in my arms, witii the sweet look of demure
contentment she used to have when I held her.] Phinuit said:
You have a child here who came long ago. He is a beautiful
spirit now, he does not get near enough for me to hear him,
but I can see him. And there is ano,er little one here, too,
they call ' baby/ not long here, it never lived on earth. Mary
0— - — has it. She does love that baby so, she and Hattie. Eliz*
abeth is here, too, they love you and will care for your babies.
{Elizabeth. Possibly an old lady I dearly loved, but I never
called her or heard her called Elizabeth.*]
,' Kakie wants the little bit of a book mamma read by her
bedside, with the pretty, bright things hanging from it— ,mamma
put it in her hands — ,the last thing she remembers. [This is
curious. It was a little prayer-book, with cross, anchor, and
other symbols, in silver, attached to ribbons for marking the
places. ... I read it . • . when she seemed unconscious, and after
her death I placed it in her hands to prevent the blood settling
in the nails. The last thing she remembered was my placing it
in her hands! What does this signify?] [Mrs. Piper held her
hands in just that position when she asked for it.*] ''
Here is a specimen of what investigators have to contend
with. That it can be got up deliberately on the spur of the
moment, or is apt to be intended, seems hardly supposable.
March Srd, 1894. (Pr.Xin,601-2.)
"Mr. Charles Heywood, Gardner, Mass. (Associate Am.SP.It.)
,'S. H. present part of the time.
''Mr. Heywood accompanied me for a sitting on March 1st,
1894. There was no speech but apparently strenuous attempts
at writing as by different persons. The oddities of spelling and
writing were probably Phinuifs. The following is the complete
record of the writing of March Ist.
''no light no light here [Spelt backwards and written forwards, on thgil, etc.].
"no liht liht [Spelt backwards and written forwards] no
[written correctly].
" no liht can't stay y yes no liht [Spelt backwards and written
forwards].
" can't stay [Spelt forwards and written backwards, %,e., yats
inae, beginning with the letter e and writing from right to
left], here [spelt backwards and written forwards, the h in
mirror-writing]. Phinuit [mirror-writing] followed by a stroke
with an r perhaps intended for Dr. on tighl [or ligM]. too
bad [spelt backwards and written forwards] bad dab oot. Dr.
Phinuit [spelt backwards and written forwards, and some of the
490
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. n, Pt. IV
letters mirror-wTitingl. Adieu [Spelt backwards and written
forwards]. No use Q. P. [followed by a scrawl sogsesting
/'
Adieu}
Extracie from Leitore from Mr. Hejfwood. (Pr.Xin,603f .)
Gardner, January 10th, 1895.
,
Phinuit made some remarkable prophecies at my last
sitting. The minor predictions, many of them, were fulfilled*
and I naturally expected a corresponding realization of the two
great predictions up to which the lesser led; but the Doctor evidently took too much for granted. The big things failed to
Gardnsr, February 10th, 1896.
occur.*'
**.
I send all which I can positiyely submit to strange
eyes, and I beg to assure you that what is omitted is of a character which exhibits starUing internal evidenoes of being com*
municated by the i)er8onality of my dead wife. . . . Phinuit's read*
ings from locks of hair, gloves, etc., pressed against Mrs. Piper,s
forehead, were exceUent so far as they related to the character
of the persons and their circumstances, but his predictions were
simply my own ideas of the probabilities, and in almost every
instance have failed. . . . Favorite expressions often used by he,
[his wife when living. H.H.] , i,e,, * Don't be stupid I ' ' Now yoa
are waking up I' 'Well, I should say I had!' 'Don't U*
'Well I guess 1' 'Dear,' and particularly 'Dear little boy,*
flowed from the pencil in such a familiar way that I felt tibe
influence of her personality very strongly. Some little traits
were shown in the impatient brushing away of loose articles
upon the table, and the pounding of tiie table with the fingers
when perplexed. When I saw that motion I exclaimed: 'Ah I
now I recognize you beyond a doubt 1' Little things like that
seemed to supply the missing links in the chain of identity."
From the Automatic Writing at Bitting of March Zrd, 1894.
(Pr.Xin,606f.)
"D.: 'Charlie, I am Dorothy [a pet name of my wife]
C-h-a-r-1-i-e, this is to you. Will tell you all soon. Wait for
him' [me, her.]
" G. P. : ' The lady is ' [through?] [This was a fragment intended for somebody who nad sat the previous day.] [Such interpolations are quite frequent. H.H.] Bead [a scrawl, perhaps
meant for 'Charlie/] [Daisy?] I am here [a scrawl, then
' strong.'] 0. H. : ' What is that"? ' G. P. : ' Strong. I am and
I saw her and in consequence right it for you.' Hodgson and
Heywood: 'Ha hal See how George spells "write"!' G. P.:
' Am I not right? [Presumably to D. P. B.] Well, do speak
'"
and I will help you. This was a mistake, if you please
The initials evidently refer to Mrs. Heywood, and are
Ch. XXXII]
The Eeywood Sittings
probably those of her maiden name.
below.
491
Thqr are spelled out
"0. H.: 'Is this Daisy f» D. P. B.: 'Yes, and I love you
and I want you to forgive me for not coming before. I tried so
hard to reach you, dear CSiarley, you know
* [Neither I nor
nay wife ever spelt my name * Oharley/ — C.H., '96] [Date of
note. Sittings were in '94. H.H.1 0. H.: 'Yes, I know, dear,
but now you have come to me.' I). P. B. : ' Oh, speak to me I
Hy cough is right all now [all right now.] Where is my picture, dear? Give it to me a minute.' [My wife had no cough.]
JI carry a photograph of my wife in my watch case. Taking
be watch from my pocket I placed it in the hand, which rested
upon it a few seconds, and then resumed as follows :] D. P. B. :
' Do you miss me now 9 I see you always.' C. H. : ' I can scarcely
believe this to be you, Daisy. Oan't you give me some proof 9'
" [Then followed an attempt to write a name. Probably ten
minutes were consumed in this eSort, but ,e seemed unable to
write the whole name. ...She finally spelt it phonetieally,
but I... failed to recognise what she was driving at, and
remained in utter ignorance until the next sitting, when she
was able to write the full name correctly, and imparted a
bit of information of which I was entirely ignorant She had
intended to tell me the matter, and about a month before her
death had started to do so, but something had turned the conversation....In attempting to explain the matter at her first
sitting, she referred me by name to a person who might readily
have given me the needed information, but I felt unwilling to
discuss the matter.]
"0. H. : 'I can't think what that means.' D. P. B. : ' Do,
dear. Give it [the watch] to me a minute. Oh, how this helps
me. I am still a little confused — ,fused — ,fused.' [If this frequent sort of thing is fraud, it is pretty ingenious fraud. But
how absolutely consistent it is with difficult communications
from some source I H.H.]
" [Then follows a reference of an extremely personal nature,
which afforded me a strong proof of personality. It was perfectly intelligible at the time, and it began with ' I tell you this,
but don't let that gentleman hear me,' — evidently referring to
Pelham, as Hodgson had left the room — sent out some time before by Phinuit. — Abridged from original transcript, — CH. '96.]
" D. P. B. : ' Don't feel strange with me, dear, for I love you
and always did.' C. H. : ' Can't you give me some further proof
of your identity?' D. P. B.: 'I will. ...Am I dreaming!
Where are you nowf O.H.: 'Right here, near you. I wish I
might see you.' D. P. B.: ' I will try to have you see me as I
am. Poor little boy — ,too bad — yes— do you reciJl — ,recall — can't
I help you when you go home. I say— don't you hear me ? '. . .
" [When I professed ignorance of some of the circumstances
492
Hodgson's Second Piper Report
[BL II, PL IV
the pencil rather impetaously wrote * Don't be stupid,' and tbea
' Don't be discouraged.']
', D. P. B. : ' A . . . is gone and I am glad of it. I am so happy
for that. Now talk to me, dear. l>on't you know the Simday
we went to the Point—' C. H.: 'Point! ' D. P. B.: * Yes [joyfully]. That is what I want to say: was it Sunday!
And I
remember it so welL P — oint Pines' [triumphanUy].
C. H.:
* Oh, the Point of Pines.' D. P. B. : * Yes.' O. H. :* And that ia
what you were trying to say, is it!' D. P. B.: 'Yes» all the
time. Do you remember the little place where we sat. I go
there often, yet I don't see you there.' 0. H. : ' Well, haven't
you seen me there sometimes!'
D. P. B. (joyously): 'Wdl, I
should say I had ! ' 0. H. : ' Oh, I recognize that expression I
I know now that you are Daioy.' D. P. B. : ' Well, / know I am
D.' — [a scrawl]. 0. H. : * Can you write your name! ' D. P. B. :
'Yes, ril give it to you — ,Bb-B-A-a.
[Here the hand seemed
angry at its inability to write, and covers the paper with dots.]
Over. I wrote it. I wrote it. Do read. It is over here, turn '
[hand fumbles among the loose sheets lying on the table covered
with writing]. C. H.: ' Can you give me your middle initial! '
D. P. B. : * X es, P. D. B. — do read — ,R — ,no more — ,A — that is
not ' [a scrawl]* C. H. : ' Will you give it me later! ' D. P. B. :
' Yes, before 1 go I will write it in full. Yes. Now let me
speak my mind. Do you go west!' C. H.: ,No. Didn't you
like me to go West! ' D. P. B.: ' Not a bit. You know how I
felt. Don't try to fool with me now. . . . You want me to B,eek
natural [ly] ' [which was exactly the wish framed in my mind].
C. H. : ' You feel well and happy, then ! ' D. P. B. : ' Don't I—
weU, I guess t [one of her favorite idioms]. All burden that
about.'
"[Then follows some advice upon a certain matter which
events have proven to be invaluable. Any other course than the
one advised would have been fatal to my welfare. — CH.,
•«4-
P. B.: 'Where are those pants!' C. H.: 'PanUf
D. P. B. : ' Yes — ,thoee light things. I did not like them — ,too
much like a negro.' C. H. : ' Negro, is that ! ' D. P. B. : ' Yes '
[joyfully and flourishingly].
"[During the summer of 1891, the year before the death of
my wife, I owned a pair of very light and very loud trousers,
which afforded endless amusement to my wife and myself....
We called them my coon pants! But reminiscences of that sort»
as may be imagined, were far from my mind during the
stance 1 .
" C. H. : * And you don't consider yourself dead ! ' D. P. B. : * I
don't think I am dead — ,not much I I want to trouble you a little
while longer. What about your hair! Yes, dear.' [The hand
dropped t,e pencil and came forward to my head and fingered my
hair.] C. H.: 'It's longer than it was when you were here.
Ch- XXXII]
Mrs. J. E. B. B.
493
That's the f aflhionable cut now.' D. P. B. : ' Looks well.' 0. H. :
' You like it, don't you f ' D. P. B. : * Yea.' 0. H. : ' Others do,
too.' D. P. B.: 'I don't care whether they do or not. I do.
Where is the cradle t ' 0. H.: ' Ifs in the baby,s room.' D. P.
B.i,,It's where I can't see it. I can't find it.' 0. H.: ,If you
go in there you can't fail to see it. . . . [suddenly recollecting]
Oh« I (now what you meant' D. P. B. [energetically] 'Now
you are just waking upl '
,* [ The hand, in the exuberance of its pleasure at my evidence
of intelligence, swept watch, note book, loose sheet and pencils
off the table on the floor. After th, were replaced the writing
continued.]
« D. P. B. : * Too bad.' 0. H.:* Oh, thafsaU right.' D.P.B.:
' I know, but see what I did Look here, do you remember the
cradle you never got! ' 0. H. : ' Yes, and that's a very good evidence that Daisy is here. I remember very well. And you remember that promised cradle.' D. P. B. : ' Yes, I am now. Well,
I **guess I do.'
0. H.: ,Will you be near me and help me in the
future!' D. P. B. : ' Yes, I wilL I promise. Ask him [G. P.t]
to help me.' Oeobob [}] : * Yes, I wiU. . . .' Enter Hodgson.
*' Hodgson : ' Oome, l)r. Phinuit, it is time to close the sitting.'
D. P. B.: ' Who are you! ' 0. H.: ' This is Mr. Hodgson, the
Secretary of the Society for Psychical Research.' D. P. B. : ' Do
you know my baby I He is a very nice boy. You go and see
him. He lodes like me.' 0. H. : ' Now remember your promise
to write your full name.' D. P. B.: 'Yes, D. P. B. [indistinctly.] Now D. P. B. [in startlingly distinct capitals] Daisy
—Park— Bradford. [The * Park ' scrawly ; the ' Bradford ' very
plainly written]. Da [scrawl] Par — [oh well, this — ,me!] Forgive me for my wrongs.' 0. H. : ' But there are no wrongs to
forgive.' D. P. B. : ' Mistakes.' [Then, as if seized by desire to
summarise rapidly the proofs of identity, the hand sci,awled in
coarse, hurried letters — ,, Point of Pines' — ,'the Seat' — ,* Don't
take A.... — no' — ,'My stomach is better — so is the babyH.
0. H. : ' You remember what we dreaded for the baby ? ' D. r.
B. : * Well, yes, but no fear of them now. I must go.' 0. H. :
'Oood-byl' D. P. B.: 'No, don't say good-bye.' [And with
this the sitting terminated.] "
April 4th, 1S94. (Pr.Xin,610f.)
', Sitter : Mrs. J. E. R. R (Associate AB.SP.R)
, Mrs. Piper became first controlled by Dr. Phinuit.
"[Spoken!
: That
lady's yourself
a medium.
You have
wonderful light, DUt
you doubt
sometimes.
... Doa very
you know
Robert who troubled your whole life? . . • Never will any more.
Yes, indeed, Robert was a great sorrow, and we are glad to reform him here
" Taken as a whole it would appear that the effort was made
494
Hodgson', Second Piper Report [Bk. II, PL ITT
by several of my nearest relatiyes to inform me of the death of
the bad influence of my life, and to let me know that th, knew
a story I had never told to any one of th&oL I do not know
wheUier R. E. W. is living or dead.
" Mrs. R. writes later: —
''Dear Dr. Hodgson,— Wbat do you think of thist I have
just received reply from England as to Dr. W., who you will
remember Qeorge, through Mrs. Piper, said was ' there.' Well,
he is alive, well, and stronger than ever. ... I for years have not
thought consciously of Dr. W. nor cared whether he lived or
died, nor have I borne him malice for the trouble, as ' Qeorge'
emphasized it, that his influence brought into my young life.
Why then so strange a re-awakeningt
Why so false a test? . • .
"J.E.R.B."
Which is offset by this (Pr. XIII, 613) :
"Oarnbgib Studios, March 2Brd [1895].
''Dear Dr. Hodgson, — ,When I had my sitting with Mrs.
Piper, perhaps you remember that Phinuit broke off suddenly to
say : ' There's a little child coming, it is still in the body, not
bom yet.' I asked if it was Dr. Moore's baby whose arrival I
was then anxiously awaiting. Phinuit said : * Yes, but he is not
coming to stay, — ,he is guaided by a great spirit.' The baby was
bom a couple of weeks later, and died suddenly this morning.
*' I have not the papers here but I think my recollection is
correct. I have remembered it several times since the child's
birth, but it seemed so healthy I thought it was aU a mistake.
It may seem worth while to note this without mentioning names.
—Cordially yours,
J. E. R. R.**
May 2Qth and 29th, 1894. (Pr.Xin,625f .)
" Sitter: Professor C. K Norton, of Harvard, at the house of
Professor W. James. . . . Professor Norton has made the following statement: —
**
First, that there was no question as to Mrs. Piper's
good faith, or as to her delusion in respect to the nature of the
influences to which she was subject when in the trance state.
[She herself had no opinion. H.H.]
"Her conditions seemed to me analogous to those of an ill
person dreaming a suggested dream, in which trains of dream
to which the dreamer has been accustomed are modified by the
special conditions of the moment.
"There was no evidence of acquaintance with any facts known
only to myself, or which were remote and obscure.
,'As to the origin of many of the phantasmagorias of her
trance dreams, t formed a very distinct opinion, but many experiments would be required to test its correctness, and these I
shall never make."
Ch. XXXII]
Bemarhible Telopses
495
If the following was simply Mrs. Piper's telopsis of a lady
with sore eyes, what was the reason for sending any ,* loye ''
and giving the husband's initial? (Fr. XIII, 528) :
"Dr. K ... on May 16th, 1896 . . . made the following statement in the course of a letter in r,ly to my [Hodgson's. H.H.]
inquiiy on another matter.
''
I received from Mrs. P. a few words of communicafrom someone
who I claimed
to be mywith
Uncle
. . . ' L.
Oiveis the
my
love tion
to L,
and tell her
see the trouble
her G.
eyes/
initial of my uncle's widow. ... I had but just returned from a
year's trip abroad, and I knew nothing about my Aunt L....
Later, when I reached my home, I found out that my aunt had
been for some little time under treatment for some trouble with
her eyes."
Ahout November SOth, 1895. (Pr.Xin,534-5.)
'' Sitter : Professor Herbert Nichols.
"The following account, undated, was forwarded to me [Hodgson] by Professor James, to whom it was sent.
" [Received by R H. December 2Wi, 1895.]
, Just before coming away I had a wonderful sitting with
Mrs, Piper. As you know, I have been a Laodicean toward her
heretofore. But that she is no fraud, and that she is the greatest
marvel I have ever met I am now wholly convinced. Think my
interview more wonderful than any I have ever heard reported
of her before.
'< Mamma and I one Christmas exchanged rings. Each had
engraved in his gift the first word of his favorite proverb. The
ring given me I lost many years ago. When Mamma died a
year ago, the ring I had given her was, at her request, taken
from her finger and sent to me. Now I asked Mrs. Piper ' What
was written in Mamma's ringt' and as I asked the question I
held the ring in my hand and had in mind only that ring. But
I had hardly got the words from my mouth till she slapped down
on the paper the word in the other ring/*
CHAPTEB
HODOSOITS
SECOND
XXXni
PIPER REPORT,
1892-5 (OfmUnMed)
III. The Thaw Sittings
The sittings of Dr. and Mrs. Thaw are mttch like those of
Mrs. Sutton. They had lost twin children, Margaret, aged
six months, a year before the sittings began, and Snth, fifteen
months old, three months before. Much of the baby talk
alleged to come from Snth was natural to her age at death.
Of course none of Margaret's could have been natural at six
months; and at the sittings much talk was ascribed to both
that would have been impossible to children at eighteen
months, their putative age at the time of the sittings. Moreover, in the report of the sitting of March 12th it is definitely
stated that the last one who died had only six words at the
time of death three or four months before. The increase of
vocabulary in that time seems to indicate a rate of development unknown in earthly conditions, or additions in Phinuifs,
or Mrs. Piper's, impersonations. Tet the impersonations are
too good and contain too much superusual knowledge to be
merely faked. The whole thing is a puzzle.
Dr. and Mrs. Thaw are both of the mediumistic temperament, if that term may be provisionally allowed, and the sittings are among the most successful on record. Mrs. Thaw
has told me of hearing the tappings about her bed which are
alluded to in the sittings.
Hodgson says (Pr. XIII, 636-7) :
''The record of one sitting... is omitted altogether, at the
request of the sitter, as being too intimately personal, and containing much very private matter concerning the deceased., [As
already suggested, perhaps unnecessarily often, this is inevitable,
and most regrrettably the case with the best evidence. H.H.] . . •
The records should be read in detail to be appreciated, as the
form in which the information is given is in most cases not less
important than Hie matter." 406
Ch. XXXIII]
The Thaw Babies
497
Unfortunately space imposes a most difficult choice between
the full presentation of a narrow yarietj of sittings or a
scanter presentation of a greater variety. I, of course, haye
tried to go in medio: no pun intended.
The notes in brackets are by Dr. Thaw, except where they
bear my initials.
I have peppered more than my usual proportion of comments through these sittings. I hope they will be less of a
nuisance than a help.
First Biiiing. February Uth, 1892. Present, Dr. and Mrs.
A. B. Thaw, and Mrs. Hohnes. (Pr.Xin,5d7f .)
**, on his
[1.1head.
A little
childalways
comesdidhere
gentleman.
hand
[Child
so.] to Light
golden Puts
hair.
Dr. T. has hair in pocket; stands ten feet away.]
]
t
c
e
.
l
e
y
t
{dCtorr bo
Child was very generally mistaken for boy.],
" Phinuit [in a child's voice, f or ' R ' [Ruth, the baby. H.H.] :
* Tell mamma not to trouble so. [Here, and at times later, there
seemed to be great physical distress and pain in abdomen, throat
and head.] It pains me so here. [Hands on abdomen.] [Correct Child had dysentery, with sore throat] My throat hurts.
The powder! Take it away. I don't like it Take it away.'
[Bismuth was given through entire illness of two wecdu, and
was always given with trouble.] "
Did the child's suffering continue, or would a child do this
and what follows for evidential purposes? It may be worth
while to repeat that ''spirits'' often declare that those in
their world are freed from their earthly pains, but they also
give indications of suffering pain as here. Some of them have
said they did it for evidential purposes.
" Phinuit : ' Curly golden hair.' [Hair was very curly.] Phinuit [for R.1 : ' I am not dead. I am not dead. I am not dead.'
Phinuit: ,My head aches sol [To Mrs. H.] Sis! Put your
hand on my head. Throat so bad! Hurt sol ' [Pause.] Phinuit [for R.]: 'I can't tell why mamma don't speak to met
Don't put it in the bottle. Take it away.' Phinuit: 'Little
girl! Long light hair. Eh— Eh—Etb— Ethie, Ethie, Ethie.
[Changing sound of E.] She's trying to tell me. Net-tie.
Ne-thie. iThis appears to be feeling for the name Ruthie. See
below. H.H.] Can't get it There's something the matter. This
little child hasn't learned to talk.' [Correct, except for a few
words which were mentioned at later sittings.] "
And yet she did talk very precociously, or Phinuit talked
for her, before and after this.
498
Hodgson's Second Piper Report
[Bk. II, Pt IV
'' [2.] Phinuitrfor B.] : 'Take me up in your annsl The
stars! Stars! When I saw the stars, then I knew I wouldn't
stay. [A good deal for a child of fifteen months to know. H.QL]
The book! I want the book. The book! I want mamma to
speak to me. I am trying to reach my mamma.' [Phinuit has
pains or distress here.] Phinuit : ' NeTer saw anyone so anziona
to come.
Trying to get through the veiL But can't do it.'
ISome
here.]
Phinuit |,or
Fvemycome
suchanda
bng waymumbling
to speak to
you, mamma.
They B.]
took: ' all
things
put them in the box. {|Correct/I I didn't like that. Oh, dear I
There's papa too.' Phmuit: ' This is dreadful. This little girl
will take me out with her. She's tearing me to pieces. [Great
pain apparently.] See the little curls! Ethiel Ethief Oh,
dear! Oh, dear! [More suffering.] What do I seel I don't
want Harry. [To Mrs. H.] [Pause.] Here come two! Bdhy
and little girL [Correct] She's gone to get baby.' Phinuit
[for B.] : ' She's here, too. And I'm not sony.' Phinuit: * Ellie
— ,Ethie. [We tell Phinuit that the first letter of the name is B.!
These children are crazy, trying to get to you. To reach through
the veil.* Phinuit [for B.] : ' I've been to you once. [About six
weeks after the death, Mrs. T. woke one night and heard a noise
like light rapping on the foot of the bed, which lasted for several
minutes. She told me about it in the morning.] Ill come again
often. Some time youll see me. See papa writing. Tell papa
to go home and think about it. [Eighteen months old child!
Thoy develop fast " there " I H.H1 Tell papa FU come to him,
too. I'll touch him.' Phinuit : ' Bet-tie. Bet,thie. [Phinuit is
given watch and chain that belonged to Dr. T.'s mother, who
died thirty years before.] Here comes a lady. Grandma ! She's
here, too, with children. Grandpa in tl, body. [Mrs. T.'s
father is living.] Never saw such a trouble to reach anybody.
[Another pause.] ...Oh, dear! In the body. Another one, to
be. Coming to stay with you. [See later in this sitting.] Fve
got something the matter with my teeth. [Baby was t,sthing
when she died.] . . . Take me in your arms, mamma. [Suddenly.!
And there's my picture! [Mrs. T. was painting a picture of
Buthie when she was taken ill.] It's good. It was the last
chance. I watched it every day. And you never did better.' [A
very precocious connoisseur ! H.H.] . . . Phinuit : , Who's mother!
Hear the little one call Grandma.' "
Grandma.
If she was still ', the little one/' in comparison with her
sister she had not been growing ; they were twins.
,' Phinuit [for B.] : ' Tell papa to think it over, and when alone
I'll come again.' [And neither at eighteen months could naturally have said this. H.H.] . • . Phinuit [impressively] : ' FriendSy
let me speak a word to you. Let me tell you there will be another that will stay. [Mrs. T. asks if there are any more.] One
CL XXXIII]
Some Older Friends
499
now. Only one.' Mrs. T.: (Will she stay?) Phinuit: 'She
will stay. One more ! [Mn. H. asks, ' Boy or girl f '] Phinuit :
* I'm a little boy. Three sisters! Two to stay and two to go,
but not to die I ' [Pause.] [Mrs. T. has since had two children,
both girls, bom one in October 1893, the other in September,
1895] . . .Phinuit [for B.] : ' Speak to me, mammal Speak to
me. I want to stay. Can't you think I'm here? TeU papa.
[Watch is given again.] Watch. Grandma's. Put Sis's hand
on my head. [Short pause.] ButhI Two Buthsl Two of
them. Mamma'iB grandma.'
[Correct.] . . . Phinuit [for B.] :
* Oreat grandma. My namesake
Do children of eighteen months know about great-grandparents and namesakes? Much of this is telepathy, but how
about the dramatic quality ?
"Phinuit [Loud]: 'Friend I HOW A— He's talking to me.
I hear him whisper. He's coming nearer.' [Phinuit here gtveB
a nidmame for a friend recently dead. Nickname not known to
anyone present. On inquiry his widow said it was the name
commonly used by his mother and sisters, all dead, but not used
by anyone living. A. B. Thaw.] [Compare with Mrs. Spoor's
case, p. 854. H.HJ
u FQ 1 TT
., ,
, [Giving name of friend.]
"(Mrs. T.: Does he know the babies!) Phinuit [speaking
softly and with feeling] : ' Quite well, quite welL' [True.] "
Second Sitting. February 27th, 1S92. (Pr.Xin,541f.)
*' [B. Hodgson and Miss B. have first part of sitting; those
present at last half are Dr. and Mrs. A. B. Thaw and Mrs.
Thaw's brother, Mr. A. Dow, who writes shorthand.]
**
Phinuit: * Come here, little girl, come here. TeOs me
to pat you on the head. [To Dr. T.] That's it She talks very
sweetly and very softly. She comes here and says that— Who is
B—Berthie— Bertie— B-E-A-B-T-A-I-C-E. [Living child Beatrice— ,her own pronunciation.] Buth, Buthie — ,Buthie here —
This little girl... she has brought another little girL Little
Marjory — Maijaret. You speak to papa too.' "
A good deal to ask of a six months' baby; and Phinuit
always insists that she's ,* the little one " as compared with her
twin Buth. He also often represents her as walking.
"'
Here comes a lady to you. You have got her picture
— a very large picture of her. [Correct of Dr. T.'s moliier.]
And she has come. She is attracted by the influence in the body.
I will awaken her in a minute. Don't hurry me, please. The
children don't like to be sent away. The little one is gone.
Little Buth is here with me, with little light curls all over
her
head. [To Dr. T.] She makes me pat your head But two will
600
Hodgson's Second Piper BepoH [Bk. U, Ft lY
stay. Little Betty is going to stay in the body with you. And
there is going to be one more that is going to stay. There
will be two with you and two of us l,re. I can't quite' —
''
[Broken.]
,[ToDr. T.] ' This is your mother. This is her watch. Sbe
aays, " Tell W
[Dr. T.'s father] that the baby is all right."
[Mother died in pren,ature childbirtn, but father was also dead at
the time of the sitting.] [Why didn't she meet him then, instead ofsending a message ? H.H.] [But Dr. Thaw's then liyins
brother was also named W
. See below. — ,ILH.] I don't
know what that means. . . .' (Dr. T. : Are you all happy there ?)
£. : ' I am very happy. Oh, if you will only believe ,ere is no
death I I live and love you. Don't let these little things worry
you. It grieves me. Will you cherish me in your memory as
you always did» and think of me as I amf Watching over you.
[To Mrs. T.] This dear little woman.
[Placing hands on heads
of Dr. and Mrs. T.] Who is L
1 I don't know. I only love
you. I wiU stay with you.' R. ,aby Ruth. H.H.] : ' Speak to
me. Tell Betty [living sister. H.H.] I love her., (Mrs. T.:
How does Margaret look?) Phinuit: 'The dear little thing—
dear
pat her,
andhim.
papa, Hewe can
love.'
used little
to takething.
me onThere,
his arm.
I see
takeM.:me ' He
no
more in the body, but in the spirit, if he wilL You have carried
me, you have seen me. You wiU see me again. Truly, truly,
truly]' (Mrs. T.: What can we do to see yout) 'Mamma,
dear I Mamma, dearl We'll be with you. Do nothing. Be
patient. When your pillow is wet, I cannot rest When you
are cheerful, I am happy. Don't ciy. — ,In the body. Dry away
those tears, and don't fret. That's all right.' "
As said at the outset regarding the vocabularies of the
children, this advicQ from a child of six months is of course
highly incongruous, and suggests either manufacture on the
part of Phinuit (whatever that may mean) or developmoits
much more rapid in the other life than in this one, — or dreams
with iheir mixture of true and false.
Third aitting. March 12ih, 1S92. (Pr.Xin,646f.)
, [Dr. and Mrs. Thaw. Mr. Alexander Dow writing shorthand.]
"
' Here's the baby. Oh ! I'm so fond of this little one.
She wants me to tell you she's not afraid of me any more. She
knows I talked to you in the body. You know what I mean!
I explained it to Ruthie.' (Mrs. T.: Little Ruthiel) Phinuit:The
'
little baby is Margaret. She is very delighted. She
wants a posie — give her some posies. [Mrs. T. had brought
some little flowers for the babies, at this time on the table in
paper.] Posie, posie, — give one posie. [Taking flowers and sep-
Ch. XXXIII]
The Thaw Babies Again
601
arating them.] Tliat's for the litde one.' (Mrs. T. : I brought
them for the little ones.) Phinuit : ' That's for the little one.
She wants some for the other one — just two or three. You don't
know how the little one can speak now. [But if she had been
growing so as to speak, how was she still ''the little one"?
Veiy possibly an entirely genuine dream. Perhaps pp. 428*9
may have some interest in this connection. H.H.] You know
she takes the spirit of these things — ,the spiritual thing — and the
spirit part is just as real to her as your life is to you.' M.:
'Come to me. Mamma.' (iAbs. T.: If I might see her!)
Phinuit: 'What a bright facel She has grayish blue eyes —
large, full and pretty. I call them blue, a grayish blue. What a
very bright and pretty little mouth she has I [Correct description of M.] She loves you both. Do you know, I can get moxe
from the children than I can from the old ones, because there is
such a strong tie between you. [Has often been noted. n.H.] . . •
She wants me to separate the posies and give some to the other
baby. I will give her so many [separating flowers], and that one
will have so many. Just the same for each little one.' R.,
'Pretty, pretty, pretty, pretty. Where's the little blue flowers!
Pretty, pretty, pretty.' Phinuit: ' Ohl That's a pretty baby—
Buth — ,Pretty, pretty, pretty. Do you love the babies ? ' (Dr. T. :
What do you think. Dr.?) Phinuit: 'She says that. Baby,
baby, babie. This little one says — ,Pretty, pretty, pretty, pretty,
pretty. BABY — Can you hear her speak? Do you hear her
speak? Bettie — ,Bettie — ,Bettie — she keeps calling Bettie. Give
me the little toy thing. I like that — ,it refreshes her. I never
saw two brighter children. You know they have no more pain
in the stomach.' (Dr. T. : Doctor, don't they ever suffer in the
spirit body?) Phinuit: 'No more pain — ,no pain.' (Dr. T.:
Do they grow up as we do here?) Phinuit: 'In just ihe same
number of years, but in this world there is no time. Life goes
on forever. That is, there is no death. I tell you, friends, just
as sure as you live in the body, I lived once in the body. I lived
in Germany and Paris and Marseilles. I know if those cranks
weren't so stupid they could find me. [Beferring to efforts on
the part of the S.P.R. to find out about him.] Well! I hear
Baby, calling baby, baby, baby.' [All these words — ,baby — ,pretty
— ,Bettie — ,were given with just the accent Ruth gave when she
was alive. Pretty was one of the first words, and she said it
constantly about anything she liked. These were the only words,
except Mamma and Papa and pussie.] "
Mrs. Thaw told me that the absolute resemblance between
these ejaculations and those of her child while living convinced her that they were made by the child's surviving spirit.
But here is the constantly recurring fact that the little one
seems to have got a suspiciously large vocabulary in the few
502
Hodgson's Second Pxp$r Report
[Bk. n, PL IV
montfas flhioe her death-H>iie perhaps as foil as Mn. Piper's.
And yet similar things constantly happen in dreams, and
some dreams contain truth.
"Phinuit: * Do yon know she takes your hand and pats it like
that
like bethat.
viU can
see see
her these
just
as sure[patting
as you Mrs.
live. T.'s
Thehand]
veil will
liftedYou
so you
two little ones when you are partially dreaming. It wiU not be
a dream. It will be reaL . . • [Pointing to Dr. and Mrs. T.'s
foreheads.] I see a great big light. What is that light? What
is that light heref [The mediumistic nature of the sitters t
H.H.] You, friends, are going to make a change in your life.
It is going to be the best change you can make. The baby
speaks to me. [Very precocious intelligence from a child!
Dream mixture again, but apparently yeridical and prophetic,
though possibly only telepathic! H.H.] It's in a different street
—a different place entirely. It's a pretty place. I see the
change. I see all the little details. I see it in detail, that I can't
describe. [AU correct]
'''Who IS that lady that is with yout No, the stout lady.
[Not stout.] She is very good to your little girL [The living
one. H.H.] • . . She has care of the little ones, and is cranky
sometimes,' (Mrs. T. : Do the babies remember her?) [She was
the nurse who had chaige of them all their lives.] Phinuit:
' The little ones, the babies in the spirit world, remember her
very well. * . . Who's M
J
? Your mother told me to tell
you.' [All correct. Aunt of Dr. T.] (Dr. T.: Is she happy
now?) Phinuit: ' She remembers you when you were a little
fellow. She was with you when your mother come out of the
body.' [Correct]'*
*' Come " — not *' went *' — ,is very dramatic, as coming from
Phinuit'
side Thaw.
; and the bad grammar was not telepathed from
Dr. and sMrs.
"'AH— WhoisEllie? Who is Nellie? The baby calls that
— she calls her Nellie. [Nurse spoken of b,ore.] Nellie!
That's a good memory for the little one, isnt it? Such pretty
light curls I All over her head. Just as perfect a little girl as
can be ! . . . You will see her in the new house. She wants me to
go there for you. She says there is going to be a better change
for you. It's going to be near the comer [correct of new house],
and you will go up to the upper room, up one flight front, and
in that' room you will see the babies come to you. This is a kind
of — ,what do you call it? A sitting place. You will get the
babies there. You stay there some twilight evening. They will
come to you. You will hear some patter, patter of the little
ones, and soon you will realize they are with you. I shouldn't
be surprised if you saw — , "
Ch. XXXIII] Phinuit Moralizes and Felicitates Himsaf 603
Mrs. Thaw tells me she often heard the '' patter, patter/'
but never saw.
"* How funny your mother wears her hairl [Smoothing hair
as Dr. T.'s mother always wore it.] Wears it so funny. 8he*8
the picture of modesty; she's the most modest looking woman
you ever sawl You know that what you call death in the body
is natural. You know that it is hard, particularly when those
you love pass over behind the veil. But they are far more happy
behind the veil than in the body. For it is God's will to take
them, as they have lived. We tell you of these things, because
it is right for you to know, and the instrument like the one I
have here [i.e., the medium. H.H.] is to use to explain what we
are in the spirit. But sometimes it is very hard to get the in*
fluences straight, and I tell you everything I can, and even then
it is hard for everyone. . . . Look on it right. Don't let it worry
you and affect your health. Little woman, keep straight. Don't
be too much exercised, and keep perfectly cool. You will get all
you want. It will be a help to you in the body. When you meet
a friend and you want them to know your experience, you can
explain it to them with perfect reason. Go on with your own
experience. If they do not wish to listen to you do not bother
theuL Your mother is guiding me every minute.' "
Few people could stand this free communication (if communication ibe)
t
or want it. Some people stop it, as already
indicated, by willing the medium to cease, which the medium
seems always to do readily.
*' ' But here's — ,weQ, wait a minute— Annie — ,Annie— no, Axma
Eliza. That's the name. Gomes. Anna Eliza. That's the
[Mrs. T.'sto dead
it. unknown
I hear
Eliza. and
Anna Eliza,
mother,
the
us ataunt.
it was
called Aunt
She was Eliza.
time that she had a first name Anna, • • • They tell me I am
smart enough to hear this all right. [Dt, T. offers suggestion.]
I don't want any of your help, Ellen. [To A. D.l What the
dickens is your name ? A-1 '— [Xaughs.] (Dr. T. : What is it ?)
Phinuit: 'I know. I know what it is.' [Laughs.] (Dr. T.:
Well, tell us what it is.) Phinuit: ' Oh, no. I know what it is
just the same.' (Dr. T.: Tell us.) Phinuit: 'Well, it's a
great long name, and it ends with e-r.' (Dr. T.: Good guess,
I)octorI) Phinuit: 'Oh, I am guessing, am It What a good
fellow I am to guess I [Spells.! Al-e-x-a-n-d-e-r. How do you
like that! You can call that what you like. You can give it a
name. [Is this telepathy, or is Phinuit one of the best dramatic
characters ever drawn ? If he is, who drew him f Apparently it
was not in Mrs. Piper's power to do it H.H.] Do you know, if
it hadn't been for your little girl I never should have found it
out. The little curly headed one. She tried to spell it for me
504
Hodgson's Second Piper Report
[Bk. II, Pt IV
but couldn't. [Children of eighteen months don't '' tiy to spell **
often in this world 1 H.H.] She told your sister [pointiDg to
Mrs. T.], and she asked tms lady — ,the lady the little one went
to find — [Dr. T.'s mother in first sitting], and she tells her, and
then she came and spelled it for me. Qraoe is with your little
ones, and she makes me put your hand up there so — and she
wants to be remembered to her papa in the body. [All tme.1
Who's L
? [Spelling diminutive.] Your mother just cidled
that to me. She comes closer — closer. She wants you to teD
I-d-a— it sounds like that— I-d-a. Oh I L
1' [Dr. T.'s
sister's usual name.] "
FouHh sitting. March ISth, 1892. (Pr.Xin,553f .)
, [Mr. Peridns sitting. Mr. A. Dow writing. Mrs. Thaw
in back part of roooL]
**
Phinuit to Mr. D. : * Aleck, you pay more attention to
me and stop your writing.' [He was taking notes. H.H.] . • .
(Mr. P.: \,at hour was I bom?) Phinuit [counting]: 'TTn,
deux, trois, quatre [up to ten]. Oh, you were bom at two o'clock
We begin at one, that's dark; then two.' [After some confusion,
not understanding whether night or day, decides at two at
night.] (Mr. P.: Father thought it was eleven.) Phinuit:
* Your mother tells me you were bom at two, and she was there
then and ought to know. If your father says you were bom at
eleven he miJces a mistake, that's all there is about it.' "
Here is a remarkably dramatic passage. I do not mean
melodramatic, but merdy lifelike — ,the sort of thing not easy
to invent
"
He says something about Bawldin — ,Baldwin. I don't
know how you pronounce it. You know who he is? Well, he
sends love to you, and says that you kind of misunderstood him,
and it was too bad. You can make it all right now. And he
says ' Tell Qeorge he is a good fellow, but he didn't understand
me; you must say so.' [Mr. P. and friend B. had misunderstanding for several months before B's death.] . . . There's someone calling who speaks in a whisper. George will tell yon
something. [This friend's name, Gfeorge Baldwin.] (Mr. P.:
Well,
Phinuit:
/Askafterwards.
Fred. He'sFred,
thereanwith
you;
tell himrU Fmlisten.)
all right.
[Verified
intimate
friend of O. B.] It was a cough that took me off, consumption,
for I passed out with it [True] and you fellows were good to
me, but you never quite understood me; you never did, quite.
I . . . taught in the school. . . . [G. B. taught in preparatory department of same schooL] . . .It's not long since I came here.
I'm so glad to see you. Look here! I want to talk to you. I
tell you there's only a veil between us. There's a good time for
you boys ... I don't see you come here for a long time. I hope
one of you will drop round and see me sometimes [f.e., through
Ch. XXXIII] Older Friends Again. Phinuit Prophesies 505
the medium. H.n.] I didn't think I was coming here — but
woke up. I choked at first, but Fm better now. You wouldn't
go to sleep if you had seen me when I first waked up. I didn't
think I was going to wake up like this. You haven't got all
your wits about you yet, and so you don't recognize your friends.
I'll be with you; 111 help you out in all your little difficulties.
Ill be with you. I mean well.' (Mr. P.: Will you tell me
about them? There's one that passed out after you did.) Phinuit : ' This one talks in a whisper to me. Good fellow, means
,ell. What a funny nose he has. He looks as if his nose
turned up a little. You know what I mean.' [Correct.] "
Could anything be more absurd than the supposition that
Mrs. Piper "got up" all this?
"
[Mrs. T. gives mother's glove again] . . . , She's nearer
to you [pointing to Mr. D., then to Mrs. T.] I can't make out
which one she's more with, but she's nearer one of you.' (Mrs.
T. : She's living with me now.) Phinuit : ' Oh, you live in one
home, but I see the other in another home, and she lives with
you [pointing to Mrs. TJ [Pointing to Mr. D.] She's very
fond of you.' (Mrs. T. : Yes, he's better than I am.) Phinuit :
'What nonsense, he isn't better than you, don't be jealous.'
(Mrs. T. : I'm not jealous.) Phinuit [rubbing Mrs. T.'s head] :
* No, and you are not going to begin m your old age, are yout
You be a good girl. Youll be all right il you don't read l,ng
down. . . .' (Mrs.
: What about
[Phinuit
immediately
makesT. motions
as of Father's
playing business?)
on piano keys.
Mrs.
T.'s father's invention, a typesetter, with keys like a piano.]
Phinuit : ' It has keys. Keys with letters on them. [Correct.]
{Mr. D. takes Mrs. T.'s place.] Oh, it's such a funny thing.
)id he invent them? Well, he's a great man. There's going
to be a spring addition that's going to be very useful, and after
a few months of dullness it will be all right. . . . He's going to
sell some of these things. . . . Add the spring part, and it will be
good. All this long pull and dull time was for the best. [Long
struggle to get the thing started.] . . . Qeorge Perkins. Do you
know how I got his name first. One of his friends whispered
me his name. Oeorge is a good fellow. Honest fellow. George
is true blue. Don't tell that to him; he might get conceited.'
(Mr. D.: I don't believe hell get conceited.) Phinuit: 'Well,
I'm only in fun.' [Mrs. T. takes Phinuit's hand] [i.e., the
medium's. H.H.] (Are we going to do any good in our work?)
Phinuit: 'You are going to make a change. Who's Emily?
You're going to change your life. 111 be there. [Mrs. T. found
on getting home that the Christian name of principal of the
school they were starting was Emma. This we had never heard
or seen, as the lady was not known personally to Mrs. T., and her
acceptance . . . was not received by us until after the sitting.] • . .
606
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. II, Pt IV
It's going to be splendid. It has to do with the mind. [Feeling
Mrs. T.'s eyes.] The physical being of those who can't see. To
benefit the blind, the ignorant. I don't mean the eyesight. [Dr.
and Mrs. T. starting free primary school and kindergarten.]
Margery will be there. Mamma, mamma, I love you. Don't
Ciy. Ruthie will be there.' (Mrs. T. to children: Do you sleep
there?) Ruthie: 'I sleep, I wake, I i,ay. I wake, I sleep, I
play.' (Mrs. T.: Won't they knock for me again?) R.: 'Ill
go on Bettie's bed and tap, tap, tap for you. Don't ciy. I live.
I am here. Tell mamma I am here. Pat papa for me. Posie —
posie — ,posie.' Phinuit: , Speak to me, friends, I'm getting
weak. Speak to me, I can't hear you.' (Mrs. T. : Oood-by, Dr.
Phinuit.) Phinuit [in a weak voice] : ' Speak louder, friends,
I'm going.' "
Sixth SitHng. May l(Hh, 1892. (Pr.Xni,564f.)
"Phinuit: * Florence [Mrs. Thaw. H.H.], I'm glad to see you.
(Well, we're glad to see you.) Good boy, doctor. . . . Sometimes
I come a long way to see you. Where's the tube ? [Reference to
phonograph.] ... I had a long talk with Alva. He wants me to
tell this to you and to Sabrina when I saw her. He caused her
a great deal of sorrow, and he's sony for it. [Sabrina is Mrs.
Dow. Alva was her first husband, deceased. The statements
made about him are true. — ,R.H.] Tell her about this, or youli
do him a great injustice. He's been in great suffering. You
can help him out of this. (What can we do?) Qet her to say
that inwardly and in her veiy soul she freely and frankly forgives him. Youll be the means of saving his souL I talked
with him.' [Further remarks about the great distress of Alva
and his desire to be forgiven, and to be helped in attaining a
higher state.]...
" (How is W
going to pass out?) * He's going to sleep,
and when he wakes he'll be in the spirit. Heart will stop. Kidneys out of order. He's out of order all over. Itll be one of
the greatest reliefs to all concerned.' [Note. — At the time of
sitting Dr. T. had no more reason to expect the death of W
than at any time for two or three years, W
being a chronic
invalid widi asthma. . . . W
died September 3rd, in sleep, of
heart failure, four months later. In the sitting of May 22nd
the time of death is put at ' six months, or a little less.'] "
See his appearance as control in twelfth sitting, page 610 of
this book. Sixth sitting continues :
"(Can you tell us about Dr. H
to-day?) [Pause.] 'Hallo,
doctor. I want to thank you for all the many kind things you've
done for me. The children are all right. There's not one of
them coming to me. What's that about the grave, the tombt
(I don't know.) Well, tell them not to worry about it. [Dr.
H.'s wife was for nearly a year much depressed by the fact that
Ch. XXXIII]
Phinuit Prophesies and Prescribes
507
H.'s body lay in vault awaiting burial.] He says something
about A
. [Spelling name of daughter.]
She coming out
all right, and I know it. She's going to stay in the body for
the present. [H.'s daughter A
was dangerously ill at that
time, but on our next visit was found to have passed the crisis.]
I'm glad to see you, my best friends. The first time I saw you,
you looked like great black spedcs to me. Now you look more
like yourselves. [Speaks of the spiritual activities there], ,'a
higher range of activities is carried on than in your universe.
Words cannot express how beautiful it is— ,like the dawn in the
body," etc., etc. [This long speech so characteristic of Dr. H.
that Dr. T., wishing to know whether he or Phinuit was speaking, said:] (Can you tell me anything about Dr. Phinuit?) I'm
talking to you myself, you rascal. I'm talking for him. (Well,
you're trying to make us think he's talking.) I'm simply telling
you what he says. I'm trying to imitate him.' "
Who made these dramatic touches, and the little ones which
follow, from the seventh sitting. May 19, 1892 (Pr. XIII,
570) ?
" [Dr. Phinuit listened to his own voice in phonograph, saying, Oh,
* you're a nice old fellow. You've got me on record.']
"[Phonograph says, * I'm going out.'] So I am going out.
Ha, na, that's good."
Eighth Sitting. May 20th, 1S92. (Pr.Xm,670f.)
" [Mr. L. Dow sitting,
"
(How about Medium? She has a cough) ' My Medium? She has a cough, has she? Well, you have her put a
half otmce of turpentine in a half a cup of boiling water, and
inhale it. (What for her trouble under the arm?) Oh, that's
poor blood. A tonic wiU scatter that. You give her two ounces
of tincture of cinchona; four ounces of French dialyzed iron
and four ounces simple syrup. Give her a teaspoonf ul one halfhour before meals.' "
And Phinuit knew no medicine I Was he Mrs. Piper P
Ninth BiUing. May 22nd, 1892. (Pr.XIII,572f .)
" Sitter, Miss Ellen Heffem, nurse of Mrs. Thaw's children.
"
She told me to get that. [,Object given which the
sitter supposed to be her mother's hair. It was, however, an
Agnus DeiJ] . . . [Miss Heffem brought several articles to the
sitting in a parcel. . . . The Agnus Dei . . . was wrapped in paper,
and she supposed that this particular packet contained her
mother's hair. . . ••— B.H., 1898.1 Put that in there* Put it in
there and wear it, [thrusting his finger down the neck of the
sitter] just as she told you to. [When sitter insisted that
Phinuit was wrong about this object ne tore off paper and showed
the Agnus Deu] [True. Mother had told sitter to wear it] "
608
Hodgson's Second Piper BepoH
Later, Dr. and Mrs. Thaw sitting.
[Bk. II, Pt. IV
AH the following dramatic business (Pr. XIII, 575-6)
strains the telepathic and divided personality theories hard :
"[Phinnit writes Harry twice, in mirror writing. (Harry ia
the name of one of Dr. Thaw's brothers. — ,R.H.) The hand
was then seized by another , itifluence/ and the following was
written, during the course of which Phinuit made occasional
remarks like these to the communicating intelligence; 'I told
you if you'd come with me I'd show you your friends, you old
idiot.'. ..' He's as stubborn as a mule.'. ..' Don't thump me,'
etc.] . . . [Phinuit then struggles to ' get his hand back.'] I got
it away. [To Mrs. T.] What are you worrying about! (I
want to go to you.) What! (To the babies sometimes.) Oh,
you wicked, wicked little thing, etc. [To Dr. Thaw. H.H.] Dr.,
can't you straighten her out better than that? You stop your
worrying. You've nothing to worry about. Go to sleep. ... (I
want to see them so much sometimes.) Oh, you act like a baby.
Come here, dearie, come along. Look at the little curly-headed
one. [To Dr. T.] Your moUier's got her. See her jump her.
[DandDiing.] Can't you see her, you stupid fools t (No.) You
can see her, can't you, Hodgson? (No.) Humph. [The reader
may be good enough to remember what was said earlier about
the mixing up of Phinuit's remarks and the children's. H.H.]
Tell mamma p-tee, p-sse, happy little Ruthie. Bring a posies.
That's a spirit posy. Don't worry mother. Dranma, she says.
Buth, dranma, don't worry papa, don't worry you [to Mrs. T.]
pt-tee, pt-tee. [Remember what Mrs. Thaw told me about these
ejaculations. H.B.] [Phinuit departs — ,heavy breathing.] Pttee.
Pttee. (Little baby. How do you do, baby?) Pt-tee. (Little
Margaret with you?) Pt-tee. [Points upwards and to one side
at picture with forefinger. Hand rises, finger points, trembles,
and hand sinks.] "
Of this scene Hodgson says (Pr. XIII, 385) :
',I was taking notes, sitting slightly to one side and partly
behind Mrs. Piper, while Dr. and Mrs. Thaw were sitting in
front of her, with their heads somewhat bowed. Phinuit apparently 'left,' and his place was taken by Ruthie, who began
whispering pttee pttee. The hand rose and turned somewhat
diagonally and extended the forefinger and pointed towards a
picture on the far side of the room. The Thaws did not see
this action until I drew their attention to it, when they looked
up, and followed the direction of the pointing. The hand then
trembled and sank. Dr. Thaw noted : ' During the last month
of Ruthie's life it was a regular morning custom to bring her to
the room in which this sitting was held-your bedroom — and she
would always point, as hand did in sitting, with one finger
Ch. XXXIII]
The Babies.
Pantomime at Picture
609
(unusual with a baby) and say ''pt-tee, pt-tee," just as in sitting. This little incident had not been in either sitter's conscious mind since baby's death, six months before. Mrs. Piper
had never been in that room until the actual time of sitting.
Many other pictures in the room, two of which Mrs. Piper's
hand could have pointed at more easily than the particular one
always noticed by the baby.' "
But to return to the ninth sitting :
*, [Phinuit returns.] Baby wanted to come. The old lady
stood up behind her so she wouldn't fall. Don't be so impatient, little one, wait a minute, darling. Thank mamma for the
I>08y. Bring the posy again another day. She has no pain-*
no teeth. I'm happy, happy. Don't cry any more. (And little
Margaret?) Little one can't talk so well. Little Margaret,
Margie, beautiful, they're just like flowers in blossom. (Why,
they were twins. Why can't she talk as well as the other?) She
doesn't talk so much. Her talk is different; she doesn't articulate quite so distinctly. I can understand it, but you wouldn't.
Little da da da dada."
One of the mutually ezdusive explanations so far suggested
is that Margaret lived here six months less than Buth.
" (Why did she put her finger up?) Pt-tee, Pt-tee. That's
wiiat she used to do in the body. Your mother says she had the
baby do that so that you'd know it's baby."
Tenth Sitting, May 23rd, 1892. (Pr.Xin,577f.)
'* [Present : Dr. and Mrs. Thaw. B. H. taking notes.]
" [Phinuit to Mrs. Thaw. H.H.1 * Well, little girl, you've got
over your worrying. I'll go and nnd some friends for you. (I
want to bring my little Betty in to you.) [Servant Nellie brings
in Beatrice, Mrs. T.'s little daughter.] Ha! Nice little girl,
come here. Here comes the baby. Two babies. Oive me
Buthie's play-toys. [Bosary.l See the baby. It's too heavy for
her. [Puts rosary round Mrs. T.'s head, between her and
Betty.f Seel That's little Margaret Dad, Dad, Dad. Ptee,
pssy, Nanna, Nanna. [Stroking B.'s hair.] Pttee, pttee, pttee.
[Phinuit leaves. Baby comes. Finger points toward picture.]
Pttee — ,pttee, etc. There, there, etc [Places B.'s hand on Mrs.
Piper's head, strokes B.'s hair, etc., pomts toward picture again,
'Pttee, ptt-ee.' Places hand on Dr. T.'s head and pats it.]
SMnuit returns. Mrs. T. is sending B. away.] Buthie wants
little one to stay. . . . Who's Elsine? [Struggles after name.]
That's W
, too. W
in the body.' (Who's speaking?)
Dr. H. : ' (George William . . . Andre Valliere says tell George I'm
all right. I have seen Whiskers.' [, AUred Howell's dog, then
dead.'— Dr. Thaw, 1896.] ',
610
Hodgson's Second Piper Report [Bk. 11, PL IV
I retain this partly because I want to see my dog Laddie
mentioned in Chapter YII> and his predecessor. Whiskers.
Eleventh Bitting. May 2%th, 18d2. {&. H. taking notes.]
(Pr.Xin,67M.)
After a sitting with ,e Thaws' nurse, which was as Irish
as that good woman herself
*,
There were indications of * change of control,' after
which there was a long silence while Mrs. Piper's hand pulled as
though at a mustache, mored her hair back from the forehead,
and felt my [Hodgson's. H.H.] face over. I said , Hallo, who's
there? Whafs the matter! Why don't you speak! ' Finally
the voice came, very different apparently from Phinuifa:
* That's the funniest — ,I didn't think I could get — ,it can't be
possible I've got here at last Weill Weill Well. You've
changed since I came here, tremendously. You don't know me,
do you? Fm Oeorge Pelham.' "
For some time sittings had been arranged with persons
unknown to 0. P., whom (at his then stage of developm,t?)
he would not have been apt to seek. Later apparently he tried
to be on hand to help everybody.
'' This incident occurred about a fortnight after the sitting
with G. P.'s father and mother. The series of stenographieaUy
reported sittings did not bepn till the following NovenJ>er. A
long conversation ensued, in which one or two obscurities in
recent sittings were referred to, but dealing chiefly with O. P.'s
experiences immediately after death, first impressions, anxiety
to speak with friends, etc. Nearly all this was spoken into the
phonograph, and scarcely any notes were taken. Unfortunately
we found later that the phonographic record gave us only a few
scattered words here and there. • . . When asl,ng O. P. to talk
into the phonograph, I said, , You know what a phonograph is? '
' Of course I do. Why, Hodgson, you must think Pve got very
unintelligent since I came over here.'"
Telepathy and divided personality !! !
Twelfth Bitting. [Over seven months since previous one. H.H.]
January l,th, 1898. (Pr.Xin,680f.)
, rpr. and Mrs. Thaw sitting. A. D. taking shorthand notes.!
"Phinuit : * That's Florrie. JYlirs. Thaw. H.H.] I'm so glad
to see you. How are you? Wnere's the doctor?' (Fm here.)
Phinuit: ,You're here toot I'm so glad to see you. ...Here,
speak to the baby. She has a gentleman with her. Who i,—
who is— I know tiiat gentleman just as well as can be. That is
the gentleman I told you was going to pass out
|