ARTICLES
Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a
prospective study in the Netherlands
Pim van Lommel, Ruud van Wees, Vincent Meyers, Ingrid Elfferich
Summary
Introduction
Some people who have survived a life-threatening crisis
report an extraordinary experience. Near-death
experience (NDE) occurs with increasing frequency
because of improved survival rates resulting from
modern techniques of resuscitation. The content of
NDE and the effects on patients seem similar
worldwide, across all cultures and times. The subjective
nature and absence of a frame of reference for this
experience lead to individual, cultural, and religious
factors determining the vocabulary used to describe and
interpret the experience.1
Background Some people report a near-death experience
(NDE) after a life-threatening crisis. We aimed to establish
the cause of this experience and assess factors that
affected its frequency, depth, and content.
Methods In
a
prospective study, we included 344
consecutive cardiac patients who were successfully
resuscitated after cardiac arrest in ten Dutch hospitals. We
compared demographic, medical, pharmacological, and
psychological data between patients who reported NDE and
patients who did not (controls) after resuscitation. In a
longitudinal study of life changes after NDE, we compared
the groups 2 and 8 years later.
NDE are reported in many circumstances: cardiac
arrest in myocardial infarction (clinical death), shock in
postpartum loss of blood or in perioperative
complications,
septic
or
anaphylactic
shock,
Findings 62 patients (18%) reported NDE, of whom 41
(12%) described a core experience. Occurrence of the
experience was not associated with duration of cardiac
arrest or unconsciousness, medication, or fear of death
before cardiac arrest. Frequency of NDE was affected by
how we defined NDE, the prospective nature of the
research in older cardiac patients, age, surviving cardiac
arrest in first myocardial infarction, more than one
cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) during stay in
hospital, previous NDE, and memory problems after
prolonged CPR. Depth of the experience was affected by
sex, surviving CPR outside hospital, and fear before cardiac
arrest. Significantly more patients who had an NDE,
especially a deep experience, died within 30 days of CPR
(p<0·0001). The process of transformation after NDE took
several years, and differed from those of patients who
survived cardiac arrest without NDE.
electrocution, coma resulting from traumatic brain
damage, intracerebral haemorrhage or cerebral
infarction, attempted suicide, near-drowning or
asphyxia, and apnoea. Such experiences are also
reported by patients with serious but not immediately
life-threatening diseases, in those with serious
depression, or without clear cause in fully conscious
people. Similar experiences to near-death ones can
occur during the terminal phase of illness, and are called
deathbed visions. Identical experiences to NDE, so-
called fear-death experiences, are mainly reported after
situations in which death seemed unavoidable: serious
traffic accidents, mountaineering accidents, or isolation
such as with shipwreck.
Several theories on the origin of NDE have been
proposed. Some think the experience is caused by
physiological changes in the brain, such as brain cells
dying as a result of cerebral anoxia.2–4 Other theories
encompass a psychological reaction to approaching
death,5 or a combination of such reaction and anoxia.6
Such experiences could also be linked to a changing
state of consciousness (transcendence), in which
perception, cognitive functioning, emotion, and sense of
identity function independently from normal body-
linked waking consciousness.7 People who have had an
NDE are psychologically healthy, although some show
non-pathological signs of dissociation.7 Such people do
not differ from controls with respect to age, sex, ethnic
origin, religion, or degree of religious belief.1
Interpretation We do not know why so few cardiac patients
report NDE after CPR, although age plays a part. With a
purely physiological explanation such as cerebral anoxia for
the experience, most patients who have been clinically
dead should report one.
Lancet 2001; 358: 2039–45
See Commentary page 2010
Studies on NDE1,3,8,9 have been retrospective and very
selective with respect to patients. In retrospective
studies, 5–10 years can elapse between occurrence of the
experience and its investigation, which often prevents
accurate
assessment
of
physiological
and
pharmacological factors. In retrospective studies,
between 43%8 and 48%1 of adults and up to 85% of
children10 who had
a
life-threatening illness were
Division of Cardiology, Hospital Rijnstate, Arnhem, Netherlands
(P van Lommel MD); Tilburg, Netherlands (R van Wees PhD);
Nijmegen, Netherlands (V Meyers PhD); and Capelle a/d Ijssel,
Netherlands (I Elfferich PhD)
estimated to have had an NDE. A random investigation
of more than 2000 Germans showed 4·3% to have had
an NDE at a mean age of 22 years.11 Differences in
estimates of frequency and uncertainty as to causes of
this experience result from varying definitions of the
phenomenon, and from inadequate methods of
Correspondence to: Dr Pim van Lommel, Division of Cardiology,
Hospital Rijnstate, PO Box 9555, 6800 TA Arnhem, Netherlands
(e-mail: pimvanlommel@wanadoo.nl)
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
2039
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.
ARTICLES
research.12 Patients’ transformational processes after an
NDE are very similar1,3,13–16 and encompass life-changing
insight, heightened intuition, and disappearance of fear of
death. Assimilation and acceptance of these changes is
thought to take at least several years.15
We did a prospective study to calculate the frequency
of NDE in patients after cardiac arrest (an objective
critical medical situation), and establish factors that
affected the frequency, content, and depth of the
experience. We also did a longitudinal study to assess the
effect of time, memory, and suppression mechanisms on
the process of transformation after NDE, and to reaffirm
the content and allow further study of the experience. We
also proposed to reassess theories on the cause and
content of NDE.
We did standardised and taped interviews with
participants a mean of 2 years after CPR. Patients also
completed a life-change inventory.16 The questionnaire
addressed self-image, concern with others, materialism
and social issues, religious beliefs and spirituality, and
attitude towards death. Participants answered 34
questions with a five-point scale indicating whether and
to what degree they had changed. After 8 years,
surviving patients and their partners were interviewed
again with the life-change inventory, and also completed
a medical and psychological questionnaire for cardiac
patients (from the Dutch Heart Foundation), the
Utrecht coping list, the sense of coherence inquiry, and
a scale for depression. These extra questionnaires were
deemed necessary for qualitative analysis because of the
reduced number of respondents who survived to 8 years
follow-up. Our control group consisted of resuscitated
patients who had not reported an NDE. We matched
controls with patients who had had an NDE by age, sex,
and time interval between CPR and the second and
third interviews.
Methods
Patients
We included consecutive patients who were successfully
resuscitated in coronary care units in ten Dutch hospitals
during a research period varying between hospitals from
4 months to nearly 4 years (1988–92). The research
period varied because of the requirement that all
consecutive patients who had undergone successful
cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) were included. If
this standard was not met we ended research in that
hospital. All patients had been clinically dead, which we
established mainly by electrocardiogram records. All
patients gave written informed consent. We obtained
ethics committee approval.
Statistical analysis
We assessed causal factors for NDE with the Pearson ꢀ2
test for categorical and t test for ratio-scaled factors.
Factors affecting depth of NDE were analysed with the
Mann-Whitney test for categorical factors, and with
Spearman’s coefficient of rank correlation for ratio-
scaled factors. Links between NDE and altered scores
for questions from the life-change inventory were
assessed with the Mann-Whitney test. The sums of the
individual scores were used to compare the responses to
the life-change inventory in the second and third
interview. Because few causes or relations exist for
NDE, the null hypotheses are the absence of factors.
Hence, all tests were two-tailed with significance shown
by p values less than 0·05.
Procedures
We defined NDE as the reported memory of all
impressions during a special state of consciousness,
including specific elements such as out-of-body
experience, pleasant feelings, and seeing a tunnel, a light,
deceased relatives, or a life review. We defined clinical
death as
a
period of unconsciousness caused by
insufficient blood supply to the brain because of
inadequate blood circulation, breathing, or both. If, in
this situation, CPR is not started within 5–10 min,
irreparable damage is done to the brain and the patient
will die.
Results
Patients
We included 344 patients who had undergone 509
successful resuscitations. Mean age at resuscitation was
62·2 years (SD 12·2), and ranged from 26 to 92 years.
251 patients were men (73%) and 93 were women
(27%). Women were significantly older than men (66 vs
61 years, p=0·005).The ratio of men to women was
57/43 for those older than 70 years, whereas at younger
ages it was 80/20. 14 (4%) patients had had a previous
NDE. We interviewed 248 (74%) patients within 5 days
after CPR. Some demographic questions from the first
interview had too many values missing for reliable
statistical analysis, so data from the second interview
were used. Of the 74 patients whom we interviewed at
2-year follow-up, 42 (57%) had previously heard of
NDE, 53 (72%) were religious, 25 (34%) had left
education aged 12 years, and 49 (66%) had been
educated until aged at least 16 years.
296 (86%) of all 344 patients had had a first
myocardial infarction and 48 (14%) had undergone
more than one infarction. Nearly all patients with acute
myocardial infarction were treated with fentanyl, a
synthetic opiod antagonist; thalamonal, a combined
preparation of fentanyl with dehydrobenzperidol that
has an antipsychotic and sedative effect; or both. 45
(13%) patients also received sedative drugs such as
diazepam or oxazepam, and 38 (11%) were given strong
sedatives such as midazolam (for intubation), or
haloperidol for cerebral unrest during or after long-
lasting unconsciousness.
We did a short standardised interview with sufficiently
well patients within a few days of resuscitation. We
asked whether patients recollected the period of un-
consciousness, and what they recalled. Three researchers
coded the experiences according to the weighted core
experience index.1 In this scoring system, depth of NDE
is measured with weighted scores assigned to elements of
the content of the experience. Scores between 1 and 5
denote superficial NDE, but we included these events
because all patients underwent transformational changes
as well. Scores of 6 or more denote core experiences, and
scores of 10 or greater are deep experiences. We also
recorded date of cardiac arrest, date of interview, sex,
age, religion, standard of education reached, whether the
patient had previously experienced NDE, previously
heard of NDE, whether CPR took place inside or outside
hospital, previous myocardial infarction, and how many
times the patient had been resuscitated during their stay
in hospital. We estimated duration of circulatory arrest
and unconsciousness, and noted whether artificial
respiration by intubation took place. We also recorded
type and dose of drugs before, during, and after the crisis,
and assessed possible memory problems at interview after
lengthy or difficult resuscitation. We classed patients
resuscitated during electrophysiological stimulation
separately.
2040
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.
ARTICLES
artificial respiration without intubation, while heart
massage and defibrillation are also applied. When we
want to intubate the patient, he turns out to have
dentures in his mouth. I remove these upper dentures
and put them onto the ‘crash car’. Meanwhile, we
continue extensive CPR. After about an hour and a half
the patient has sufficient heart rhythm and blood
pressure, but he is still ventilated and intubated, and he
is still comatose. He is transferred to the intensive care
unit to continue the necessary artificial respiration. Only
after more than a week do I meet again with the patient,
who is by now back on the cardiac ward. I distribute his
medication. The moment he sees me he says: ‘Oh, that
nurse knows where my dentures are’. I am very
surprised. Then he elucidates: ‘Yes, you were there
when I was brought into hospital and you took my
dentures out of my mouth and put them onto that car, it
had all these bottles on it and there was this sliding
drawer underneath and there you put my teeth.’ I was
especially amazed because I remembered this happening
while the man was in deep coma and in the process of
CPR. When I asked further, it appeared the man had
seen himself lying in bed, that he had perceived from
above how nurses and doctors had been busy with CPR.
He was also able to describe correctly and in detail the
small room in which he had been resuscitated as well as
the appearance of those present like myself. At the time
that he observed the situation he had been very much
afraid that we would stop CPR and that he would die.
And it is true that we had been very negative about the
patient’s prognosis due to his very poor medical
condition when admitted. The patient tells me that he
desperately and unsuccessfully tried to make it clear to
us that he was still alive and that we should continue
CPR. He is deeply impressed by his experience and says
he is no longer afraid of death. 4 weeks later he left
hospital as a healthy man.”
WCEI score*
n
A No memory
0
1–5
6–9
10–14
15–19
282 (82%)
B Some recollection
C Moderately deep NDE
D Deep NDE
21 (6%)
18 (5%)
17 (5%)
6 (2%)
E Very deep NDE
WCEI=weighted core experience index. NDE=near-death experience. *A=no
NDE, B=superficial NDE, C/D/E=core NDE.
Table 1: Distribution of the 344 patients in five WCEI classes*
234 (68%) patients were successfully resuscitated
within hospital. 190 (81%) of these patients were
resuscitated within 2 min of circulatory arrest, and
unconsciousness lasted less than 5 min in 187 (80%). 30
patients were resuscitated during electrophysiological
stimulation; these patients all underwent less than 1 min
of circulatory arrest and less than 2 min of un-
consciousness. This group were only given 5 mg of
diazepam about 1 h before electrophysiological stim-
ulation.
101 (29%) patients survived CPR outside hospital,
and nine (3%) were resuscitated both within and outside
hospital. Of these 110 patients, 88 (80%) had more than
2 min of circulatory arrest, and 62 (56%) were
unconscious for more than 10 min. All people with brief
cardiac arrest and who were resuscitated outside
hospital were resuscitated in an ambulance. Only 12
(9%) patients survived a circulatory arrest that lasted
longer than 10 min. 36% (123) of all patients were
unconsciousness for longer than 60 min, 37 of these
patients needed artificial respiration through intubation.
Intubated patients received high doses of strong
sedatives and were interviewed later than other patients;
most were still in a weakened physical condition at the
time of first interview and 24 showed memory defects.
Significantly more younger than older patients survived
long-lasting unconsciousness following difficult CPR
(p=0·005).
Table
3
shows relations between demographic,
medical, pharmacological, and psychological factors and
the frequency and depth of NDE. No medical,
pharmacological, or psychological factor affected the
frequency of the experience. People younger than
60 years had NDE more often than older people
(p=0·012), and women, who were significantly older
than men, had more frequent deep experiences than
men (p=0·011) (table 3). Increased frequency of
experiences in patients who survived cardiac arrest in
first myocardial infarction, and deeper experiences in
patients who survived CPR outside hospital could have
resulted from differences in age. Both these groups of
patients were younger than other patients, though the
age differences were not significant (p=0·05 and 0·07,
respectively).
Lengthy CPR can sometimes induce loss of memory
and patients thus affected reported significantly fewer
NDEs than others (table 3). No relation was found
between frequency of NDE and the time between CPR
and the first interview (range 1–70 days). Mortality
during or shortly after stay in hospital in patients who
had an NDE was significantly higher than in patients
who did not report an NDE (13/62 patients [21%] vs
24/282 [9%], p=0·008), and this difference was even
Prospective findings
62 (18%) patients reported some recollection of the
time of clinical death (table 1). Of these patients, 21
(6% of total) had a superficial NDE and 41 (12%) had a
core experience. 23 of the core group (7% of total)
reported a deep or very deep NDE. Therefore, of 509
resuscitations, 12% resulted in NDE and 8% in core
experiences. Table 2 shows the frequencies of ten
elements of NDE.1 No patients reported distressing or
frightening NDE.
During the pilot phase in one of the hospitals, a
coronary-care-unit nurse reported a veridical out-of-
body experience of a resuscitated patient:
“During a night shift an ambulance brings in a 44-
year-old cyanotic, comatose man into the coronary care
unit. He had been found about an hour before in a
meadow by passers-by. After admission, he receives
Elements of NDE1
Frequency (n=62)
1 Awareness of being dead
2 Positive emotions
31 (50%)
35 (56%)
15 (24%)
19 (31%)
14 (23%)
14 (23%)
18 (29%)
20 (32%)
8 (13%)
3 Out of body experience
4 Moving through a tunnel
5 Communication with light
6 Observation of colours
7 Observation of a celestial landscape
8 Meeting with deceased persons
9 Life review
more marked in patients who reported
experience (10/23 [43%] vs 24/282 [9%], p<0·0001).
a
deep
Longitudinal findings
10 Presence of border
5 (8%)
At 2-year follow-up, 19 of the 62 patients with NDE had
died and six refused to be interviewed. Thus, we were
able to interview 37 patients for the second time. All
NDE=near-death experience. => more
Table 2: Frequency of ten elements of NDE
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
2041
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.
ARTICLES
Frequency of NDE
Depth
of NDE
(n=62)
LIfe-change inventory questionnaire
p
NDE
(n=62)
No NDE
(n=282)
p
Social attitude
Showing own feelings
Acceptance of others*
More loving, empathic*
Understanding others*
Involvement in family*
0·034
0·012
0·002
0·003
0·008
Categorical factors
Demographic
Women
Age* <60 years
Religion† (yes)
13 (21%)
32 (52%)
26 (70%)
80 (28%)
96 (34%)
27 (73% )
15 (43%)
NS 0·011
0·012 NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
Religious attitude
Education†‡ Elementary 10 (27%)
Medical
Intubation
Understand purpose of life*
Sense inner meaning of life*
Interest in spirituality*
0·020
0·028
0·035
6 (10%)
8 (13%)
31 (11%)
22 (8%)
NS
NS
NS
NS
Electrophysiological
stimulation
Attitude to death
Fear of death*
Belief in life after death*
0·009
0·007
First myocardial
infarction
CPR outside hospital§ 13 (21%)
60 (97%)
236 (84%)
0·013 NS
88 (32%)
40 (14%)
NS 0·027
0·011 NS
Others
Memory defect after
lengthy CPR
Death within 30 days
Pharmacological
Extra medication
Psychological
1 (2%)
Interest in meaning of life
Understanding oneself
Appreciation of ordinary things
0·020
0·019
0·0001
13 (21%)
17 (27%)
24 (9%)
0·008 0·017
NDE=near-death experience. 35 patients had NDE, 39 had not had NDE.
1 value missing for patients wih NDE in all categories; *2 values missing for
patients with NDE (ie, n=33).
70 (25%)
NS
NS
Fear before CPR†§
Previous NDE
Foreknowledge of NDE† 22 (60%)
4 (13%)
6 (10%)
2 (6%)
8 (3%)
20 (54%)
NS
0·035 NS
NS NS
0·045
Table 4: Significant differences in life-change inventory-scores16
of patients with and without NDE at 2-year follow-up
Ratio-scaled factors
Demographic
Age (mean [SD], years)* 58·8 (13·4)
Medical
Duration of cardiac
arrest (mean [SD], min)
Duration of
unconsciousness
(mean [SD], min)
Number of CPRs (SD)
NDE was linked to high scores in spiritual items such as
interest in the meaning of one’s own life, and social
items such as showing love and accepting others. The 13
patients who had superficial NDE underwent the same
specific transformational changes as those who had a
core experience.
8-year follow-up included 23 patients with an NDE
that had been affirmed at 2-year follow-up. 11 patients
had died and one could not be interviewed. Patients
could still recall their NDE almost exactly. Of the
patients without an NDE at 2-year follow-up, 20 had
died and four patients could not be interviewed (for
reasons such as dementia and long stay in hospital),
which left 15 patients without an NDE to take part in
the third interview.
63·5 (11·8) 0·006 NS
4·0 (5·2)
3·7 (3·9)
NS
NS
NS
66·1 (269·5) 118·3 (355·5) NS
2·1 (2·5)
1·4 (1·2)
0·029 NS
Data are number (%) unless otherwise indicated. CPR=cardiopulmonary
resuscitation. NS=not significant (p>0·05). *3 missing values. †n=74 (data
from 2nd interview, 35 NDE, 39 no NDE). ‡2 missing values. §10 missing
values.
Table 3: Factors affecting frequency and depth of near-death
experience (NDE)
patients were able to retell their experience almost
exactly. Of the 17 patients who had low scores in the
first interview (superficial NDE), seven had unchanged
low scores, and four probably had, in retrospect, an
NDE that consisted only of positive emotions (score 1).
Six patients had not in fact had an NDE after all, which
was probably because of our wide definition of NDE at
the first interview.
All patients, including those who did not have NDE,
had gone through a positive change and were more self-
assured, socially aware, and religious than before. Also,
Life-change inventory
questionnaire
2-year follow-up
NDE
(n=23) (n=15) (n=23) (n=15)
8-year follow-up
no NDE NDE
no NDE
Social attitude
We selected a control group, matched for age, sex,
and time since cardiac arrest, from the 282 patients who
had not had NDE. We contacted 75 of these patients to
obtain 37 survivors who agreed to be interviewed. Two
controls reported an NDE consisting only of positive
emotions, and two a core experience. The first interview
after CPR might have been too soon for these four
patients (1% of total) to remember their NDE, or to be
willing or able to describe the experience. We were
therefore able to interview 35 patients who had had an
affirmed NDE, and 39 patients who had not.
Showing own feelings
Acceptance of others
More loving, empathic
Understanding others
Involvement in family
42
42
52
36
47
16
16
25
8
78
78
68
73
78
58
41
50
75
58
33
Religious attitude
Understand purpose of life
Sense inner meaning of life
Interest in spirituality
52
52
15
33
25
–8
57
57
42
66
25
–41
Attitude to death
Fear of death
Belief in life after death
–47
36
–16
16
–63
42
–41
16
Only six of the 74 patients that we interviewed at
2 years said they were afraid before CPR (table 3). Four
of these six had deep NDE (p=0·045, table 3). Most
patients were not afraid before CPR, as the arrest
happened too suddenly and unexpectedly to allow time
for fear.
Significant differences in answers to 13 of the 34
items in the life-change inventory between people with
and without an NDE are shown in table 4. For instance,
people who had NDE had a significant increase in belief
in an afterlife and decrease in fear of death compared
with people who had not had this experience. Depth of
Others
Interest in meaning of life
Understanding oneself
Appreciation of ordinary things
52
58
78
33
8
41
89
63
84
66
58
50
NDE=near-death experience. The sums of all individual scores per item are
reported in the same 38 patients who had both follow-up interviews.
Participants responded in a five-point scale indicating whether and to what
degree they had changed: strongly increased (+2), somewhat increased (+1),
no change (0), somewhat decreased (–1), and strongly decreased (–2). Only in
the reported 13 (of 34) items in this table were significant differences found in
life-change scores in the interview after 2 years (table 4).
Table 5: Total sum of individual life-change inventory scores16
of patients at 2-year and 8-year follow-up
2042
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.
ARTICLES
people who did not have NDE had become more
emotionally affected, and in some, fear of death had
decreased more than at 2-year follow-up. Their interest
in spirituality had strongly decreased. Most patients who
did not have NDE did not believe in a life after death at
2-year or 8-year follow-up (table 5). People with NDE
had a much more complex coping process: they had
become more emotionally vulnerable and empathic, and
often there was evidence of increased intuitive feelings.
Most of this group did not show any fear of death and
strongly believed in an afterlife. Positive changes were
more apparent at 8 years than at 2 years of follow-up.
In a study of mortality in patients after resuscitation
outside hospital,18 chances of survival increased in
people younger than 60 years and in those undergoing
first myocardial infarction, which corresponds with our
findings. Older people have a smaller chance of cerebral
recovery after difficult and complicated resuscitation
after cardiac arrest. Younger patients have a better
chance of surviving a cardiac arrest, and thus, to
describe their experience. In a study of 11 patients after
CPR, the person that had an NDE was significantly
younger than other patients who did not have such an
experience.19 Greyson7 also noted a higher frequency of
NDE and significantly deeper experiences at younger
ages, as did Ring.1
Discussion
Our results show that medical factors cannot account
for occurrence of NDE; although all patients had been
clinically dead, most did not have NDE. Furthermore,
seriousness of the crisis was not related to occurrence or
depth of the experience. If purely physiological factors
resulting from cerebral anoxia caused NDE, most of our
patients should have had this experience. Patients’
medication was also unrelated to frequency of NDE.
Psychological factors are unlikely to be important as fear
was not associated with NDE.
The 18% frequency of NDE that we noted is lower
than reported in retrospective studies,1,8 which could be
because our prospective study design prevented self-
selection of patients. Our frequency of NDE is low
despite our wide definition of the experience. Only 12%
of patients had a core NDE, and this figure might be an
overestimate. When we analysed our results, we noted
that one hospital that participated in the study for nearly
4 years, and from which 137 patients were included,
reported a significantly (p=0·01) lower percentage of
NDE (8%), and significantly (p=0·05) fewer deep
experiences. Therefore, possibly some selection of
patients occurred in the other hospitals, which
sometimes only took part for a few months. In a
prospective study17 with the same design as ours, 6% of
Good short-term memory seems to be essential for
remembering NDE. Patients with memory defects after
prolonged resuscitation reported fewer experiences than
other patients in our study. Forgetting or repressing
such experiences in the first days after CPR was unlikely
to have occurred in the remaining patients, because no
relation was found between frequency of NDE and date
of first interview. However, at 2-year follow-up, two
patients remembered a core NDE and two an NDE that
consisted of only positive emotions that they had not
reported shortly after CPR, presumably because of
memory defects at that time. It is remarkable that people
could recall their NDE almost exactly after 2 and
8 years.
Unlike our results, an inverse correlation between
foreknowledge and frequency of NDE has been
shown.1,8 Our finding that women have deeper
experiences than men has been confirmed in two other
studies,1,7 although in one,7 only in those cases in which
women had an NDE resulting from disease.
The elements of NDE that we noted (table 2)
correspond with those in other studies based on Ring’s1
classification. Greyson20 constructed the NDE scale
differently to Ring,1 but both scoring systems are
strongly correlated (r=0·90). Yet, reliable comparisons
are nearly impossible between retrospective studies that
included selection of patients, unreliable medical
records, and used different criteria for NDE,12 and our
prospective study.
Our longitudinal follow-up research into trans-
formational processes after NDE confirms the
transformation described by many others.1–3,8,10,13–16,21
Several of these investigations included a control group
to enable study of differences in transformation,14 but in
our research, patients were interviewed three times
during 8 years, with a matched control group. Our
findings show that this process of change after NDE
tends to take several years to consolidate. Presumably,
besides possible internal psychological processes, one
reason for this has to do with society’s negative response
to NDE, which leads individuals to deny or suppress
their experience for fear of rejection or ridicule. Thus,
social conditioning causes NDE to be traumatic,
although in itself it is not a psychotraumatic experience.
As a result, the effects of the experience can be delayed
for years, and only gradually and with difficulty is an
NDE accepted and integrated. Furthermore, the
longlasting transformational effects of an experience that
lasts for only a few minutes of cardiac arrest is a
surprising and unexpected finding.
63 survivors of cardiac arrest reported
a
core
experience, and another 5% had memories with features
of an NDE (low score in our study); thus, with our wide
definition of the experience, 11% of these patients
reported an NDE. Therefore, true frequency of the
experience is likely to be about 10%, or 5% if based on
number of resuscitations rather than number of
resuscitated patients. Patients who survive several CPRs
in hospital have a significantly higher chance of NDE
(table 3).
We noted that the frequency of NDE was higher in
people younger than 60 years than in older people. In
other studies, mean age at NDE is lower than our
estimate (62·2 years) and the frequency of the
experience is higher. Morse10 saw 85% NDE in children,
Ring1 noted 48% NDE in people with a mean age of
37 years, and Sabom8 saw 43% NDE in people with a
mean age of 49 years; thus, age and the frequency of the
experience seem to be associated. Other retrospective
studies have noted a younger mean age for NDE:
32 years,9 29 years,6 and 22 years.11 Cardiac arrest was
the cause of the experience in most patients in Sabom’s8
study, whereas this was the case in only a low percentage
of patients in other work. We saw that people surviving
CPR outside hospital (who underwent deeper NDE
than other patients) tended to be younger, as were those
One limitation of our study is that our study group
were all Dutch cardiac patients, who were generally
older than groups in other studies. Therefore, our
frequency of NDE might not be representative of all
cases—eg, a higher frequency could be expected with
who survived cardiac arrest in
a
first myocardial
infarction (more frequent NDE), which indicates that
age was probably decisive in the significant relation
noted with those factors.
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
2043
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.
ARTICLES
younger samples, or rates might vary in other
populations. Also, the rates for NDE could differ in
people who survive near-death episodes that come about
by different causes, such as near drowning, near fatal car
crashes with cerebral trauma, and electrocution.
However, rigorous prospective studies would be almost
impossible in many such cases.
elements of NDE, such as out-of-body experiences
and other verifiable aspects. Finally, the theory
and background of transcendence should be included as
a part of an explanatory framework for these
experiences.
Contributors
Several theories have been proposed to explain NDE.
We did not show that psychological, neurophysiological,
or physiological factors caused these experiences after
cardiac arrest. Sabom22 mentions a young American
woman who had complications during brain surgery for
a cerebral aneurysm. The EEG of her cortex and
brainstem had become totally flat. After the operation,
which was eventually successful, this patient proved to
have had a very deep NDE, including an out-of-body
experience, with subsequently verified observations
during the period of the flat EEG.
Pim van Lommel coordinated the first interviews and was responsible
for collecting all demographic, medical, and pharmacological data.
Pim van Lommel, Ruud van Wees, and Vincent Meyers rated the
first interview. Ruud van Wees and Vincent Meyers coordinated the
second interviews. Ruud van Wees did statistical analysis of the first
and second interviews. Ingrid Elfferich did the third interviews and
analysed these results.
Acknowledgments
We thank nursing and medical staff of the hospitals involved in the
research; volunteers of the International Association of Near Death
Studies; IANDS-Netherlands; Merkawah Foundation for arranging
interviews, and typing the second and third interviews; Martin Meyers
for help with translation; and Kenneth Ring and Bruce Greyson for
review of the article.
And yet, neurophysiological processes must play some
part in NDE. Similar experiences can be induced
through electrical stimulation of the temporal lobe (and
hence of the hippocampus) during neurosurgery for
epilepsy,23
with
high
carbon
dioxide
levels
References
(hypercarbia),24 and in decreased cerebral perfusion
resulting in local cerebral hypoxia as in rapid
acceleration during training of fighter pilots,25 or as in
hyperventilation followed by valsalva manoeuvre.4
Ketamine-induced experiences resulting from blockage
of the NMDA receptor,26 and the role of endorphin,
serotonin, and enkephalin have also been mentioned,27
as have near-death-like experiences after the use of
LSD,28 psilocarpine, and mescaline.21 These induced
experiences can consist of unconsciousness, out-of-body
experiences, and perception of light or flashes of
recollection from the past. These recollections, however,
consist of fragmented and random memories unlike the
panoramic life-review that can occur in NDE. Further,
transformational processes with changing life-insight
and disappearance of fear of death are rarely reported
after induced experiences.
Thus, induced experiences are not identical to NDE,
and so, besides age, an unknown mechanism causes
NDE by stimulation of neurophysiological and
neurohumoral processes at a subcellular level in the
brain in only a few cases during a critical situation such
as clinical death. These processes might also determine
whether the experience reaches consciousness and can
be recollected.
1
Ring K. Life at death. A scientific investigation of the near-
death experience. New York: Coward McCann and Geoghenan,
1980.
2
Blackmore S. Dying to live: science and the near-death experience.
London: Grafton—an imprint of Harper Collins Publishers,
1993.
3
4
5
6
Morse M. Transformed by the light. New York: Villard Books,
1990.
Lempert T, Bauer M, Schmidt D. Syncope and near-death
experience. Lancet 1994; 344: 829–30.
Appelby L. Near-death experience: analogous to other stress
induced physiological phenomena. BMJ 1989; 298: 976–77.
Owens JE, Cook EW, Stevenson I. Features of “near-death
experience” in relation to whether or not patients were near death.
Lancet 1990; 336: 1175–77.
7
Greyson B. Dissociation in people who have near-death experiences:
out of their bodies or out of their minds? Lancet 2000; 355:
460–63.
8
9
Sabom MB. Recollections of death: a medical investigation. New
York: Harper and Row, 1982.
Greyson B. Varieties of near-death experience. Psychiatry 1993;
56: 390–99.
10 Morse M. Parting visions: a new scientific paradigm. In: Bailey LW,
Yates J, eds. The near-death experience: a reader. New York and
London: Routledge, 1996: 299–318.
11 Schmied I, Knoblaub H, Schnettler B. Todesnäheerfahrungen in
Ost- und Westdeutschland—eine empirische Untersuchung. In:
Knoblaub H, Soeffner HG, eds. Todesnähe: interdisziplinäre
Zugänge zu einem außergewöhnlichen Phänomen. Konstanz:
Universitätsverlag Konstanz, 1999: 217–50.
With lack of evidence for any other theories for NDE,
the thus far assumed, but never proven, concept that
consciousness and memories are localised in the brain
should be discussed. How could a clear consciousness
outside one’s body be experienced at the moment that
the brain no longer functions during a period of clinical
death with flat EEG?22 Also, in cardiac arrest the EEG
usually becomes flat in most cases within about 10s
from onset of syncope.29,30 Furthermore, blind people
have described veridical perception during out-of-body
experiences at the time of this experience.31 NDE pushes
at the limits of medical ideas about the range of human
consciousness and the mind-brain relation.
Another theory holds that NDE might be a changing
state of consciousness (transcendence), in which
identity, cognition, and emotion function independently
from the unconscious body, but retain the possibility of
non-sensory perception.7,8,22,28,31
Research should be concentrated on the effort to
explain scientifically the occurrence and content of
NDE. Research should be focused on certain specific
12 Greyson B. The incidence of near-death experiences. Med Psychiatry
1998; 1: 92–99.
13 Roberts G, Owen J. The near-death experience. Br J Psychiatry
1988; 153: 607–17.
14 Groth-Marnat G, Summers R. Altered beliefs, attitudes and
behaviors following near-death experiences. J Hum Psychol 1998;
38: 110–25.
15 Atwater PMH. Coming back to life: the after-effects of the
near-death experience. New York: Dodd, Mead and Company,
1988.
16 Ring K. Heading towards omega: in search of the meaning of
the near-death experience. New York: Quill William Morrow,
1984.
17 Parnia S, Waller DG, Yeates R, Fenwick P. A qualitative and
quantitative study of the incidence, features and aetiology of near
death experiences in cardiac arrest survivors. Resuscitation 2001;
48: 149–56.
18 Dickey W, Adgey AAJ. Mortality within hospital after resuscitation
from ventricular fibrillation outside hospital. Br Heart J 1992; 67:
334–38.
19 Schoenbeck SB, Hocutt GD. Near-death experiences in patients
undergoing cardio-pulmonary resuscitation. J Near-Death Studies
1991; 9: 211–18.
20 Greyson B. The near-death experience scale: construction, reliability
and validity. J Nervous Mental Dis 1982; 171: 369–75.
2044
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.
ARTICLES
21 Schröter-Kunhardt M. Nah—Todeserfahrungen aus psychiatrisch-
neurologischer Sicht. In: Knoblaub H, Soeffner HG, eds.
Todesnähe: interdisziplinäre Zugänge zu einem außergewöhnlichen
Phänomen. Konstanz: Universitätsverlag Konstanz, 1999: 65–99.
22 Sabom MB. Light and death: one doctors fascinating account of
near-death experiences. Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House,
1998: 37–52.
the role of glutamate and the NMDA-receptor. In: Bailey LW,
Yates J, eds. The near-death experience: a reader. New York and
London: Routledge, 1996: 265–82.
27 Greyson B. Biological aspects of near-death experiences. Perspect
Biol Med 1998; 42: 14–32.
28 Grof S, Halifax J. The human encounter with death. New York:
Dutton, 1977.
23 Penfield W. The excitable cortex in conscious man. Liverpool:
Liverpool University Press, 1958.
29 Clute HL, Levy WJ. Electroencephalographic changes during brief
cardiac arrest in humans. Anesthesiology 1990; 73: 821–25.
30 Aminoff MJ, Scheinman MM, Griffing JC, Herre JM. Electrocerebral
accompaniments of syncope associated with malignant ventricular
arrhythmias. Ann Intern Med 1988; 108: 791–96.
24 Meduna LT. Carbon dioxide therapy: a neuropsychological
treatment of nervous disorders. Springfield: Charles C Thomas,
1950.
25 Whinnery JE, Whinnery AM. Acceleration-induced loss of
consciousness. Arch Neurol 1990; 47: 764–76.
31 Ring K, Cooper S. Mindsight: near-death and out-of-body
experiences in the blind. Palo Alto: William James Center for
Consciousness Studies, 1999.
26 Jansen K. Neuroscience, ketamine and the near-death experience:
Clinical picture: Amiodarone-induced
pulmonary mass and cutaneous vasculitis
Christoph Scharf, Erwin N Oechslin, Franco Salomon, Wolfgang Kiowski
A 67-year-old man presented with haemoptysis and macular erythema on both legs.
He had longstanding congestive heart failure and was treated with quinapril,
digitalis, furosemide and phenprocoumon. He had been taking amiodarone for
4 years to treat unsustained bouts of ventricular tachycardia. An isolated pulmonary
mass of 5 cm in diameter with central necrosis was found in the right upper lobe
with extrinsic compression of the corresponding bronchus (figure, upper).
Transbronchial biopsies showed no abnormalities, the skin biopsy showed
lymphocytic vasculitis of the small capillaries. Antibody screening and urinalysis
were normal. On follow-up the mass decreased, new infiltrates appeared and the
TSH level increased to 37 mU/L (normal 0·1–4). The diagnosis of amiodarone-
induced pulmonary mass and cutaneous vasculitis was confirmed by complete
resolution of the infiltrates within 4 months after cessation of amiodarone therapy.
Department of Medicine, University Hospital, CH-8091 Zürich, Switzerland (Christoph Scharf MD;
Erwin N Oechslin MD; Franco Salomon MD, Wolfgang Kiowski MD)
THE LANCET • Vol 358 • December 15, 2001
2045
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.